18 ms·
SoftBank’s Vision Fund Loses $17.7B on WeWork, Uber
- davedx 7y agoVision
- namdnay 7y agoMeh I like his vision: taking insane amounts of dirty Saudi money and giving it back to the people
- fedupp 7y agoThis is great news! Uber had a great idea but is run and mismanaged by the scum of humanity. Perhaps Sons investments would to better in the hands of ethical leaders. I'll never forget the day Uber deleted $300 I had earned right out of my driver account. I fought with them for a month and never got it back. The state and feds couldn't have cared less. This company has a license to steal. It's caught up with them. I look forward to the day the robot takes over and fires everyone.
- dannyw 7y ago> The drop in Uber’s share price was responsible for about $5.2 billion of Vision Fund’s losses in the period, while WeWork contributed $4.6 billion and another $7.5 billion came from the rest of the portfolio Losing even more on other portfolio businesses, like Oyo (the hotel chain) is going to hurt. I hope this gets rid of the "out-raise your competitors and spend ridiculous amounts of money on ridiculous money sinks" strategy forever.
- mtgx 7y ago> I hope this gets rid of the "out-raise your competitors and spend ridiculous amounts of money on ridiculous money sinks" strategy forever. Narrator: It didn't. As long as there is greed and speculation, people will continue to fall for schemes like these. People, especially here on HN, like to talk about how big of a ponzi scheme cryptocurrencies are, but they are just a reflection of other such systems in the offline world. They just happen in time-scales of weeks and months rather than years and decades.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago> I hope this gets rid of the "out-raise your competitors and spend ridiculous amounts of money on ridiculous money sinks" strategy forever. I don't think so. We live in a world now where incredible amounts of capital are chasing returns because of zero and negative interest rate policies. The only solution will be regulation. EDIT: The more interesting question (IMHO) is what happens when all of that capital has nowhere to go? Is there back pressure? How do accumulators of capital react to such forces?
- bergstromm466 7y agoYes completely agree. It's hard to get a firm grip on just how deeply unequitable society is today, and how little the big tech corps contribute in taxes. "JSavageOne 7 hours ago [–] Corporatocracy is probably the more accurate term, but the term neofeudalism isn't exactly a huge stretch. The only real difference today is that at least in theory a serf can become a lord, but the same power dynamic remains. When chattel slavery ended many of the freed slaves became sharecroppers, bound to the land by eternal debts that could never be repaid. Although they were no longer legally bound to their "masters", for many their lives were not really any better. Although in principle the monopolies and the government are separate institutions, we all know that the reality is that our politicians are bought out by the corporations, and the regulators are staffed by ex-employees of the very companies they are supposed to be regulating. We used to bust monopolies, but since the 70s or so the regulators have become very lax, and practically every industry has become more consolidated than it's ever been (finance, advertising, airlines, utilities, telecom, agriculture, healthcare, etc). What's interesting to me is that whenever Google/Facebook does something authoritarian that would seem to violate some principle of liberty we deem sacred (eg. censorship, violating freedom of speech), many if not most of the comments seem to rationalize the corporation's decision as exercising their own free speech. But when you're Reddit with 430M monthly active users, your userbase is the population equivalent of the world's 3rd largest country, and so you're effectively the equivalent of a nation-state. When you're Amazon with 750k employees, then your employees could fill up a city. Does the principle of democracy only apply to country's governments, or does it also extend to corporate monopolies?" [1] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23218895 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23218895
- 7y ago
- mbesto 7y ago> I hope this gets rid of the "out-raise your competitors and spend ridiculous amounts of money on ridiculous money sinks" strategy forever. Why? If you're a startup and a competitor does this and it leads to them losing value, isn't that a good thing for you? The only people who lose in this equation are the ones who accepted those risks. The market will eventually correct itself.
- vertex-four 7y agoThere's a piece of investment wisdom that says "the market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent" - or, applied here, Uber's going to take a while longer to die than your startup.
- mbesto 7y ago> or, applied here, Uber's going to take a while longer to die than your startup. So what? I'm so confused by this. This is exactly the point of "taking more money than you need". If Uber has a huge warchest of cash it means it can pivot as it pleases. Isn't this good investment advice then?
- vertex-four 7y agoIf Uber dies before making any money, and some other company would've made money but Uber killed it, then the investment in Uber was a bad investment (no return) and in addition prevented what might have been a good investment from working out. Or in words that matter to me as a consumer - Uber, an unsustainable company, killed an industry that will not immediately recover when Uber dies.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> The only people who lose in this equation are the ones who accepted those risks. And, more importantly, also the people who are collateral damage of this. I.e. the people in your or mine neighbourhood. The local restaurants, the local drivers, the local renters. All this money raised isn't just sitting there doing nothing, it's disrupting markets - the way a disruptor wielded by a Klingon or Romulan would disrupt your body. By the time the disruption ends, your body won't work. These markets won't work either.
- basch 7y ago20 Years Ago. They lose 70 BILLION dollars, and their next play is to throw money into something called Alibaba. 17.7 billion in 2020 dollars is nothing by comparison. $70B then is over $100B in today dollars. That is like saying "i hope that blackjack player learned to never double down", because they lost a hand.
- JumpCrisscross 7y agoUntil recently, Vision Fund proponents had been able to point to paper gains as signs of the fund’s performance. The fund is now underwater [1]. Given how personally leveraged Vision Fund’s employees are to the fund [2], I’m curious what morale is like there. [1] https://www.wsj.com/articles/softbank-posts-9-billion-loss-for-year-hit-by-poor-tech-investments-11589787762 https://www.wsj.com/articles/softbank-posts-9-billion-loss-f... [2] https://www.wsj.com/articles/softbank-to-lend-founder-and-employees-billions-to-invest-in-fund-11566051247 https://www.wsj.com/articles/softbank-to-lend-founder-and-em...
- boredgamer2 7y agoFrom [2], SoftBank lent billions for employees to invest. That's incredible and dubious! I've been offered to purchase stock of my employer at reduced prices if I hold it for X time, but never been offered a loan to do it.
- arebop 7y agoI've heard of this happening for executives and board members at various blue chip companies.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI remember reading that these loans are often forgiven when the stock doesn’t work out as expected. It’s just another way of paying more.
- TuringNYC 7y ago>> SoftBank lent billions for employees to invest. That's incredible and dubious! In some ways, this is great. It shows that fund executives' interests are aligned with the long-term returns of the fund. It shows they are there for the carry returns and not just the annual admin fees. It gives execs skin in the game.
- Traster 7y ago
- ckastner 7y agoNote that this was for the fiscal year that ended in March, so before most of Covid-19's impact. Can't imagine what FY2020 is going to look like.
- kolbe 7y agoUber is up about 20% from the end of March.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- puranjay 7y agoWhich is just baffling
- postingawayonhn 7y agoNot really. The whole market is up about 30% from its low. On top of that Uber Eats is obviously doing a lot of business right now.
- supertent 7y agoWhat's with GetYourGuide? Will they recover after COVID?
- VWWHFSfQ 7y agoIs SoftBank the worst investment firm of all time
- samstave 7y agoYou know, i would say no. I would actually like to thank softbank for taking the risks that it did, as it should be a very interesting business study to look at what, and how, they did what they did. They made collosal mistakes/mis-judgements, sure - but look at how much can be learned from what they have done. I would like to know even more about all the details of what they have done. I would like to see if i could learn - even for just the acedemic aspect of it - all the mistakes they made, their reasonings behind what decisions they made etc. Its a fascinating study, if you think about it. Look at the companies we are talking about they failed upon; uber, we-work and oyo are mentioned just in this HN thread. All of which are “household names” to silicon valley. Recall the articles about how OYO was “revolutionizing what we thought of hotels.... Man, that guy/company got mad press praise. So, i want to learn as much as i can about everything softbank did.
- gruturo 7y agoThat, and the name of the fund ended up being hilariously wrong. They have invested in things where a 10 year old could have pointed out obvious fallacies. Saudi investors must be really pissed off, they look like complete fools now (having just been parted with quite a bit of their money). If I were Masayoshi Son, I wouldn't step in a Saudi embassy for all the money in the world now. Oh well if they blow up it's actually capitalism working right for once. Too bad they own ARM, that's more or less the only thing of value that could be lost imho.
- disgruntledphd2 7y agoARM will just get sold to someone else. They own a bunch of Alibaba too, to be fair.
- Traster 7y agoI find it very difficult to see where ARM fits, it really should be an independent company. Since everyone who sees the most value in buying it shouldn't be allowed to. Can you imagine if Apple snapped it up? Or Qualcomm? Or even Intel?
- irjustin 7y agoTo be fair, so much of this is driven by market forces and Covid in general. Only WeWork was written down, the rest is the market absolutely tanking. I mean if you followed the index funds, you'd be posting ~20% losses right now. Earlier it was 30%. I definitely would not want to be those portfolio managers right now, but it's not all completely them... yet.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 7y agoIt's not really the stick market that's causing this, since few of Softbank's investments have IPOed yet. (The WeWork bubble, in particular, started deflating when they tried to list it.) The more immediate cause is that many of their companies are not profitable, which investors were willing to overlook because they were enticed by future profits. But now COVID is wreaking havoc on the whole economy, and these companies don't have any sort of path to profitability within a foreseeable timeframe.
- fastball 7y agoNope. This is for FY2019, which ended in March. COVID-19 is definitely not priced into this.
- colinmhayes 7y agoYes it is, March was the low point for the markets. They're up pretty big this quarter.
- eggsnbacon1 7y agoMight be true, but building a multibillion dollar investment strategy that falls apart during a market downturn is a very financial crisisy thing to do. Its easy to make money during a bull market, just toss money into an index fund. Uber and WeWork were both banking on increased travel and office presence. Seems like a dumb thing to do now that COVID has plowed everyone into remote work. It might have been a dumb thing to do even before. Crises tend to accelerate underlying societal changes. Remote work and online ordering were already at an all time high. The virus has pushed this increasing demand ahead a decade or more. Now I can even see my doctor from home, something unthinkable a few months ago. Travel is increasingly reserved for leisure. Uber might be okay but WeWork is on the wrong side of this. WeWork was a societal stepping-stone to remote work. We've blown past that checkpoint far sooner than expected
- as-j 7y agoI wonder how much good vs damage SoftBank has done to tech companies, or was it just te normal consequence of the end of the tech bubble? I don't mean Uber, WeWork and the high profile ones, but the less news worthy failures. What do I mean? SoftBank funded companies were told to grow at any cost, scale to become the market leader. A lot of companies weren't mature enough, or maybe not viable enough to do so and just burnt through cash and ended up with nothing as a result. I wonder how they would have done had they not had such a strong drive to grow at any cost?
- nsl73 7y agoI imagine if Uber hadn’t pushed so hard for growth most local markets would still be using their old taxi system.
- as-j 7y agoThat's why I excluded Uber and the like, the push was for the same strategy for all sorts of their smaller invesments. Edit: thinking companies like Wag, DoorDash, etc
- PaulWaldman 7y agoThe Vision fund is heavily invested in businesses that are negatively impacted by COVID-19. Are there any bright spots in the portfolio? Was diversification not possble?
- zacpross 7y agoWeWork seemed like a poor investment anyway. Pandemic or no pandemic, the economy was heading for a reset after 10 years of a good run. Why they expanded their building so quickly is beyond me, and it's left the whole business extremely open to a downturn. I've worked in a lot of the buildings in London and watched it explode since coming to the city. It started as a great idea and built on community, but it lost a lot of that with generic same same buildings. Money sinks. Something other spaces are doing far better, focusing on certain industries and startup communities.
- DavidHm 7y agoI work in the industry (yes, the whole debacle has been fairly entertaining). From what I've heard, Neumann was 100% convinced that the 16Bn financing round was a sure thing (and the rapid growth was how he positioned himself for it). I don't know whether he meant to ride off the sunset, or (as our ceo put it), rely on the fact that even if the business is unsustainable, tens of billions of cash means that you won't go bankrupt for a long time.
- zentiggr 7y agoSo where is the Vision Fund getting these billions, and why do they need them laundered (squandered?) so badly?
- roosterdawn 7y agoOil. You can probably connect the dots from there.
- mschuster91 7y agoSaudi-Arabian oil (read: blood) money. With Peak Oil around the corner (if it hasn't already hit thanks to corona), the Saudi dictatorship is in desperate need for a way to finance their lavish lifestyle and handouts, or it faces rebellion. The only thing buying the Saudi government peace at the moment from both religious salafi extremists on one end and a young Westernized population on the other hand is extremely generous handouts which in turn depend on an oil price around 80-90$ range IIRC. But cheap US/CA fracking and shale oil have been attacking that price level for quite some time which also is problematic for the Russian economy for similar reasons, so both SA and RU are hellbent on destroying the US/CA domestic oil industry (which is highly leveraged and debt financed), which complicates matters even more.
- jeffreyrogers 7y agoThere is no way peak oil (which I assume is peak oil demand, not supply) is going to happen anytime soon. Too much of the world has massive energy needs in order to develop (almost all of Africa, large parts of South America and Asia) and oil will be a huge part of the energy mix given its advantages. The current coronavirus situation might depress oil demand for a bit, but unless living standards get permanently stuck at low levels in the developing world oil demand is going to grow for the foreseeable future. Of course, how Saudia Arabia does depends on how long their reserves last, and many people believe they've overstated the amount of oil they have remaining.
- mschuster91 7y agoAfrica can satisfy lots of its energy needs with essentially free solar, plus Africa has lots of local oil, they don't need the Saudis. As for oil demand: many Western countries have by now recognized their toxic dependency on oil. Plastics are being fought against worldwide, electric mobility is more or less mainstream with Tesla and ICE phase-outs across Europe, business air travel will be mostly replaced with teleconferences...
- code4tee 7y agoThere’s tossing gasoline on a pile of cash and then there’s tossing gasoline on a pile of cash.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoAnd then there's tossing gasoline on a pile of cash made on selling gasoline.
- benjaminwootton 7y agoWeWork and Uber are two of the best “products” on the market. Thanks to SoftBank for their contribution I guess!
- whoisjuan 7y agoWas anyone (with remarkable or relevant VC experience) criticizing SoftBank Vision's fund approach before all this debacle? I remember a lot of articles praising it and basically claiming that their boldness and aggressiveness were going to create never seen returns / disrupt the VC industry forever.
- haram_masala 7y agoThis has downstream implications for global stability. Much of that money comes from Gulf states, including Saudi Arabia, who need investment returns to replace dwindling oil revenues. Revenues which prop up an extremely generous entitlements system that has kept the royal family in power.
- ChicagoDave 7y agoI'm just thinking about how many $500k to $1mm seeds could have helped founders get their ideas off the ground in lieu of these debacles. 17,700,000,000 17,700 at $1mm 35,400 at $500k That's a lot of ideas getting fuel and a lot of people being put to work. Even if you filter through for high quality ideas and teams, this is still a better use of those funds. WeWork was a bad idea from the start. Uber is a great idea without a functioning (profitable) business model. As an entrepreneur, this kind of news drives me batty.
- TremendousJudge 7y agoI don't understand how the Uber business model isn't profitable besides mismanagement. Taxi companies all over the world are profitable, and Uber doesn't even have to handle the regulation that they have
- doublesCs 7y agoHere in London Uber is MUCH cheaper than black cabs.
- cc439 7y agoThe reason Uber initially blew taxi companies out of the water is because taxis greatly limited their service to what was profitable and we're incredibly difficult to work with should you be outside one of their comfort zones. You could always count on Taxis near an airport or for an intra-downtown route but good luck getting a cab to pick you up at your house to take you to another suburban destination. It's not that they'd ignore your call because they sucked at customer service, it's that your call is only worth it to them if there's literally nothing else going on. Even then they might not show up if your request isn't going to end with them back in a profitable starting point for another ride.
- jkhdigital 7y agoExactly, this hits on an incredibly important point that gets constantly ignored in “disruptive” business models: if a particular market segment is “underserved” then it often means that there are poor cost economics in play. Sure, Uber can reduce those costs through algorithmic central routing and planning, but that only goes so far and some markets are just never going to be profitable to serve (at a given quality of service).
- socrates1998 7y agoThe more I read about WeWork, the more insane it is to me. I don't really blame the charlatans at WeWork, it's hard to blame people for taking money on a product. And they probably do think it's a good business plan. No, I blame the people giving them billions of dollars. These "investors" are complete idiots. It's shocking to me how little they understand about the companies they invest in. One look at WeWorks "business plan" and I knew it was all bullshit. It's just ridiculous that so many "smart investors" gave them money. Ugh, such a waste of money.
- KoftaBob 7y agoIt pains me to see such massive amounts of money wasted on a real estate ponzi scheme and a ride sharing company with a weak revenue model. If they're going to call themselves a "vision fund" that focuses on moonshots, and has the risk appetite to lose large sums of money doing that, at least invest in actual moonshots. Biotech, green energy, new forms of transportation like Hyperloop and improved supersonic jet designs. There are so many breakthroughs that need lots of funding and can be quite profitable if successful. I would love to see funds like SoftBank invest more in the SpaceX's of the world less in the WeWorks of the world.
- Invictus0 7y agoChange your perspective: this is not SoftBank losing money, this is the middle class gaining a free lunch. It's a massive redistribution of wealth from investors to consumers.
- qeternity 7y agoSome of this is also just hitting the undo button. Softbank had a murky habit of leading back to back rounds, so they were effectively dictating the market for their own investments. It’s like if you invest in my business at a $10 valuation, and then a year later you invest at a $30 valuation, and a year after that your accountants force you to carry it at the original $10 valuation. You’re undoing previous paper gains, but nothing really changed.
- antpls 7y agoSo, if $17.7B were lost on one side, it would be interesting to trace the money and see in which pockets most of the money went
- qeternity 7y agoValuations are not zero sum. On a cash flow basis, I think that’s pretty simple: consumers via subsidies. But on the mark to market side, if I invest $10 at $100 valuation and the company lists on a stock exchange where investors only value the company at $50, I’ve lost $5 and nobody has gained anything.
- jvln 7y agoI just finished reading https://www.billiondollarwhale.com/ https://www.billiondollarwhale.com/ book. The book tells a story how 11Billion USD were stolen. After seeing $17B losses I hardly can believe that a big chunk of it or most of it were not funnelled to support a lavish lifestyle of connected people.
- mrosett 7y agoWell yeah, take a look at how Adam Neumann is spending his billions...