21 ms·
A small restaurant owner on Google, DoorDash, and Grubhub
- 1024core 7y ago> Being that we are partners of DoorDash and GrubHub, Well, then stop partnering with them! If they continue to use your name, issue a C&D order!
- steveklabnik 7y ago> Well, then stop partnering with them! At the end of the article, they are saying they may do just that. It's also not clear to them that this will stop this particular issue. > If they continue to use your name, issue a C&D order! I don't own a restaurant, but I've worked in food service. If I were this guy, I wouldn't want to start a legal battle with a company that's much, much larger than I am.
- uoaei 7y agoSeems like a pretty clear-cut case of using branding that they don't own or have rights to, and that this is false advertising. But yes read the ToS to see if those terms are buried in there somewhere. Maybe the ad has "find food like that at Saddleback..." which would mean it's not technically false advertising if they take you to an aggregate/search page.
- djsumdog 7y ago> If they continue to use your name, issue a C&D order! Not to mention it's probably in the DoorDash/GrubHub agreement. That's probably how they get away with using that trademark. > Well, then stop partnering with them! Say you hate books-a-billion and you want to only sell at mom and pop bookstores. Good for you, but what if that kills 70% of your revenue? When talking about trying to make a living and pull in enough to stay afloat, these people often don't have the choice. You don't publish your ebook on Amazon Kindle and only on Barnes and Nobles Nook, you cut yourself out of a huge revenue stream.
- jdminhbg 7y ago> Say you hate books-a-billion and you want to only sell at mom and pop bookstores. Good for you, but what if that kills 70% of your revenue? Then it sounds like books-a-billion is providing a pretty valuable service to you.
- belltaco 7y ago>If they continue to use your name, issue a C&D order A waste of lawyer fees. Its legal.
- lonelappde 7y agoTrademark infringement us not legal. Google/Doordash are selling a different product and clearly labeling it as Saddleback.
- NoodleIncident 7y agoDon't companies buy google ads for when people search their direct competitors?
- sib 7y agoYes, but they are not representing the results as actually being the competitor.
- otterley 7y agoDoordash is selling Saddleback's food.
- gpm 7y agoChances are they're using the name within the terms of a license that was granted when this restaurant partnered with them.
- TuringNYC 7y agoIn some cases (not sure which companies) they do it w/o the permission of the restaurant and become a very frequent order-er who then hands off to the ultimate app-user. I read about this in the newspaper but could someone elaborate more on which companies do this?
- rmason 7y agoThe author is a friend and was the original marketing director for the hosting company LiquidWeb. He' a superb marketer and I suspect this article grew out of his frustrations dealing with this problem. I don't think the average restaurant owner who may not be very digitally savvy realizes how these companies piggyback on top of their brand. I predict that soon there will be a large class action lawsuit with thousands of restaurants going after the delivery services for these underhanded tactics.
- donmcronald 7y agoExactly, but I'm not sure about the class action lawsuit part. The contract probably forbids it and since it's B2B I bet those types of provisions stick. The most frustrating part is that these types of situations are tough to avoid and we're starting to see them everywhere. Ex: DoorDash has a huge marketing budget / money to burn when starting up, so the early adopters see great returns because someone else is paying for a bunch of advertising for them. They tell their friends and slowly the system grows to a critical mass where you're losing out if you're not on it. Then they abuse their market position and do stuff like this. You see it everywhere; Google, Amazon, Microsoft, app stores, adhesive terms of service, etc.. It's happening in the software development industry right now and no one's paying attention. Tons of services like SaaS Git, Saas CI, SaaS dev environments (Codespaces), templated SaaS deployment targets, etc.. The early adopters are seeing gains in efficiency, so they're out there advocating the use of all these subsidized services, but no one is considering what's going to happen in 5 years when the ownable workflow is neglected and the SaaS workflow is the only practical option.
- giovannibonetti 7y agoThere is a huge difference between SaaS and marketplaces. The latter is very prone to creating monopolies or oligopolies, but the former not so much. About the developer tools you mentioned, take for an example the CI service. It is relatively easy to switch to a new one. I have used Codeship and Circle CI in the past but have switched to Google Cloud Build since it ia cheaper for my use case with Docker containers.
- HaloZero 7y agoI don't think Google discourages this in any major capacity. I will say that Grubhub and DoorDash certainly have an ethical quandary. It certainly doesn't look good from a PR standpoint but I imagine it's a common practice. Not a case that Google does but for Apple's App store ad system. I've worked at Lyft and I know years ago the top ad for searching Lyft was Uber and vice versa in the app store. Both companies would pay for advertisements against the other. But it was cheaper to trade jabs than defend your search term.
- jeffbee 7y agoThere is no ethical dilemma here. They are simply choosing the unethical option.
- freeone3000 7y agoOn one hand, you can do the responsible thing and link the user to what they wanted. On the other hand, you could make money. This is an unsolvable ethical problem.
- sib 7y agoI still think that buying an ad against a competitor's brand in search (Uber buying an ad to show when user searches for Lyft and vice versa) is very different from the behavior shown in the article where the advertiser is literally using the restaurant's name in the ad itself to try to convince the user that the advertiser is the restaurant.
- arkitaip 7y agoArticle and entire domain returns 403.
- jxub 7y agoCan confirm (I'm in Europe, maybe it has to do with the regulations?)
- JGM_io 7y agoAlso in Europe and get a 403. Anybody have a pdf copy?
- zadki3l 7y agoHere you go: https://web.archive.org/web/20200515203018/https://www.saddlebackbbq.com/how-google-doordash-grubhub-conspire-screw-local-restaurants https://web.archive.org/web/20200515203018/https://www.saddl...
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoAnother thing I realized lately: I usually tip restaurants for curbside/pickup right now since I know their staff have been hit hard. But if we DoorDash, the tip goes to DoorDash, not the restaurant I want to support. I generally try to order either curbside or delivery through the restaurant's own site. I figure even if they use a third party then, they're using the one most advantageous to their business. I want my favorite restaurants to survive this pandemic, but I couldn't care less about these delivery startups.
- HaloZero 7y agoI've found that many of favorite businesses advertise using Caviar, at least here in SF. I wonder if they're offering better rates. This is purely anecdotal.
- cbhl 7y agoFor a while, I saw an option to tip the restaurant as a line item in UberEats. Not sure if it's everywhere yet. It was also a bit confusing that there were two different tips, with different UX (since there's still the existing option to also tip the driver).
- steveklabnik 7y agoOne issue with this approach is that the industry has lost consumer trust in this specifically. That is, DoorDash used to keep tips, then there was public outcry, then they said they would change, but then it looked like they actually didn't https://www.businessinsider.com/doordash-still-be-pocketing-tips-despite-pay-model-change-2019-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/doordash-still-be-pocketing-... (I know this is about it being for the driver, but the overall point still stands, I think.)
- NoodleIncident 7y agoYeah, the UberEats one even said they would match the tip to the restaurant when I used it
- 7y ago
- gaogao 7y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20200515173159/https://www.saddlebackbbq.com/how-google-doordash-grubhub-conspire-screw-local-restaurants https://web.archive.org/web/20200515173159/https://www.saddl...
- atarian 7y agoThis looks more like a huge oversight than a malicious decision. I can't think of a good reason why a company advertising deliveries for a specific restaurant would redirect to a listing of similar restaurants. As an end user that would really annoy me; it's not like I'm going to change my mind and order Applebee's instead. The only other explanation is that Applebee's is paying the delivery companies a fee to capture SEO acquired by them, which would be really scummy.
- d0m 7y agoI guess the idea is that once you try doordash, you'll want to stay there because you have more choices and better product. Doordash can control the whole experience as well as send you emails, push notifications, etc. to bring you back in.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago> "We believe online diners are becoming more promiscuous," Grubhub CEO Matt Maloney and CFO Adam DeWitt wrote in a shareholder letter, noting that Grubhub diners were once known to be extremely loyal, but new diners have often already sought out a competing online platform https://fortune.com/2019/10/28/promiscuous-grubhub-customers-just-helped-lower-the-companys-value-by-1-2-billion-in-minutes/ https://fortune.com/2019/10/28/promiscuous-grubhub-customers...
- shadowgovt 7y ago> As an end user that would really annoy me; it's not like I'm going to change my mind and order Applebee's instead Lots of people actually do. People like variety in their meals.
- colinmhayes 7y agoI worked for grubhub. They absolutely put up google ads to capture traffic and redirect it to restaurants that paid for advertising. The entire business is incredibly scummy and manipulative. Grubhub also bought the domains for most restaurants and created fake websites so consumers thought they were ordering directly from the restaurant.
- fmakunbound 7y agoWouldn't be a tech company unless it created another serfdom.
- tropdrop 7y ago> DoorDash uses our brand name “Saddleback BBQ” right in the advertisement. > Possibly the most maddening thing is that if a customer clicks on the link, it does NOT take them to a webpage to order from Saddleback BBQ. It takes the user to a general page to order BBQ from anyone that serves BBQ. At the top of the list? Applebees. This is a particularly egregious sleight of hand. It's a relatively easy click-through to write for DoorDash, and it would result in the customer getting exactly what they were looking for (instantly looking at Saddleback's menu options and probably ordering). But DoorDash isn't content with delivering what they promised! The customer must perform a secondary search within DoorDash just to find that same restaurant again, because Saddleback is nowhere within sight on the page they've actually landed on. It's sneaky because it seems like incompetence, but the reality is that they've absolutely done it on purpose so they can double-dip one customer and display ads to them from restaurants that paid more to DoorDash.
- majormajor 7y agoThis is confusing because it goes against everything the marketing folks in previous jobs were always pushing on our front end engineering and SEO efforts. I'm more suspicious of landing page incompetence then you. Our directives were always: If the user has showed intent for a specific thing, tailor the landing page towards that thing as much as possible, and get out of their way. Don't let them forget they already made up their mind. The DoorDash approach seems very backward. If I saw that landing page I'd be inclined to think "wow, these people don't actually have Saddleback, let me check somewhere else." I'm not gonna get Applebees after googling a different particular restaurant.
- kerkeslager 7y ago> Our directives were always: If the user has showed intent for a specific thing, tailor the landing page towards that thing as much as possible, and get out of their way. Don't let them forget they already made up their mind. That's if you're trying to sell them the thing they showed interest in. Door Dash et al aren't trying to sell you Saddleback Barbecue, they're trying to get you onto their platform so they can sell you to advertisers. What you're interested in is just a way for them to manipulate you onto their platform.
- JulianWasTaken 7y agoFully agree this kind of practice is disgusting on the part of the platform sites. And yet as someone who will never use each individual restaurant's website -- same as for retail, I just don't have the time except if one particular brand becomes an overwhelming part of my wallet spend -- it seems we have to be eying for a world where we do have aggregators making all these places available in one stop, but which aren't actively harming their individual pieces. At least for folks in the same boat I am.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI go out of my way to cut out as many middlemen as possible to ensure I receive the best service possible.
- shadowgovt 7y agoFrom the article: > The “Advertisement” is much larger than our own “order” button where someone can order directly from our website or get directions to our location. Doesn't this complaint ignore the fact that the first organic search result is Saddleback BBQ's own home page, complete with six deep links (including the "Ordering" link)? Text that directs user flow into Saddleback BBQ's page takes up about half the screen.
- devindotcom 7y agoSearch results differ widely between regions and users. FTA: "If a person in Lansing goes onto Google search..." No reason for companies to target users outside the Lansing metro area, no one in Boston is ordering BBQ from Michigan. If you're not in Lansing, you're probably not seeing the same results as the people this post refers to.
- shadowgovt 7y agoSure, but I'm not in Lansing (or anywhere near it). And both an incognito and logged-in search give me the same thing for the search query in the article. I'm not talking about the contents of the map sidebar; I'm talking about the big "Saddleback BBQ |" link in the main results and its children. While it's true I do not see the ad (probably because I'm outside the targeting area), even with the screenshots shown in the article, there are two order buttons on the page that deep-link to Saddleback and one ad link. Their complaint seems to be "The ad is more eye-catching than [ed: one of] our order links"... Yes, but it's also flagged as clearly an [AD].
- cbsmith 7y agoThe title is misleading. This is only one of the ways...
- dang 7y ago"Conspire to screw" breaks the HN guideline about titles, so I've edited it to make it less baity. It's a bit generic now though. If anyone suggests a better title, we can change it again. "Better" means more accurate and neutral, and preferably using representative language from the article.
- mfer 7y agoI tried the same thing in both Bing and Duckduckgo. In Bing there was no Grubhub and in Duckduckgo there was an ad in the sidebar that took me directly to the restaurants page on Grubhub (not a higher level page). Was just curious to compare across search engines.
- mharroun 7y agoI keep seeing things like this, people hating on the delivery companies. Customers moving to takeout and restaurants moving to self delivery. Its pushed me to have my quaranteen/layoff project be to create a competitor that supports only self delivery and takeout but has the order, management, aggragation functions, and crm of the competition for a low flat fee (plus cc fees).
- uoaei 7y agoI sincerely hope you can get that rolling. Power to the people! Edit: saw this in another part of HN, if you're at the right stage you may want to look into this: https://builders.mozilla.community/ https://builders.mozilla.community/
- Eridrus 7y agoNot to stop you from doing this because competition is good for businesses, but this exists. ChowNow is a commision-free piece of software anyone can buy for a flat monthly fee. Slice is a pizza-focussed app that charges a flat fee per delivery. I have no idea why they're so focussed on pizza rather than the general market, but do what you know, I guess.
- steveklabnik 7y agoFormer Slice user here. They're focused on pizza only because they started as a pizzeria in Staten Island. They know their vertical. Part of the mission is specifically to help pizzerias. I only stopped using them because I moved away from NYC.
- ryanwaggoner 7y agoThis is a classic case of aggregation theory: https://stratechery.com/concept/aggregation-theory/ https://stratechery.com/concept/aggregation-theory/ DoorDash, Grubhub, etc. are becoming the place that customers go to when looking for food. And if they own the customer relationship, then your restaurant is a commodity. This is basically how I live already. I sometimes want something specific from a specific restaurant, but more often than not, I just want something and I browse through Seamless until I see some food that looks good and order it. I don't really know or care where it's coming from as long as it's reasonably priced and has decent ratings. I know how heavy the fees are, so I tried for awhile to order from restaurants directly, but it's often horribly painful. You have to call on the phone, which is already a huge hit to user experience. Then you have issues with noise, accents, trying to accurately convey exactly what you want with any modifications, providing your credit card over the phone. It's just horrible and I always fall back to just using Seamless. I feel bad, but restaurants certainly don't seem like they're going out of their way to make the direct ordering experience as painless as possible. These restaurants don't have the money or expertise to develop great websites or apps, and I don't want an app on my phone for every restaurant anyway. Nor do I want a list of dozens of bookmarks for restaurants, without a way to discover new ones. Not that it matters, because I think we've seen pretty clearly that consumers as a whole are going to just go with whatever's easiest for them. And anyone who is going to build out the infrastructure that Doordash and Grubhub have so they can own the customer relationship due to a superior UX is going to extract as much value as they can as well, or they won't be able to keep up with the competition in terms of UX or ads. It feels like a fairly intractable problem without regulation, which I'm generally skeptical of. But maybe that's the answer here. I do wonder if Google and Apple could add "order online" functionality to their maps programs without too much trouble. Their interests might be more aligned with restaurants such that they could take 5-10% instead of 30%.
- thatfrenchguy 7y agoYou could also go out, and get the food from the restaurant itself, instead of having a low-wage worker do it for you.
- 7y ago
- flibble 7y agoThis sort of anti-marketplace sentiment is making mainstream media on the other side of the Atlantic. Today’s Sky News coverage https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vbt-l-RnQZo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vbt-l-RnQZo Disclaimer - I’m the bald guy.
- Jestar342 7y agoThis is happening in other industries, too. Google have recently launched a Hotels API where hotels, B&Bs, vacation rentals, etc can upload their prices and other data to Google, and Google will decide when to show that info to the user. So searching for "hotels in New York" will now be fronted by a giant Google widget that will capture your traffic and not a list of hotel websites.
- pb7 7y agoWhat's wrong with that? Hotels make money from people booking, not being on their website. If this helps people find what they're looking for and convert into a stay, that's great.
- Jestar342 7y agoThe user doesn't see their website. The content is loaded to google, google gets advert traffic, etc. etc. as well as the stuff outlined in the article. That's what is wrong with it.
- pb7 7y agoThere are thousands of hotels in New York. Nobody is going through thousands of links, unique websites, retyping the same dates and details into different forms. They’re going to the same top website that paid the most for SEO. The user doesn’t want to see their website. The user wants to see all the relevant details of all the options that match their criteria so they can hand over their cash to the best one, not the one that has put the most money into building a website. That is what modern search is. That is what Google is doing.
- uoaei 7y agoIf you don't like certain business practices, vote with your dollar! I refuse to use delivery apps because they skim ~10-20% off the top of my orders. I understand the utility of DoorDash -- there are a lot of customers who want the single interface and can't be bothered to search for a restaurant individually. But if you care at all about this sort of thing, with a simple search you can find the phone number of the restaurant you like and call them up. There will always be someone by the phone, this is how restaurants operated for 50+ years! The ordering process is, paradoxically, easier and less time-consuming than going through DoorDash. I find the app to be slow, with way too many menus and scrolling. Even the browser interface is kludgy because they insist on making huge buttons that take up a large part of the screen, so I can only consider like 4 options at a time on my screen. It's been easier for me just to get a PDF of the menu, read off the stuff I'd like, and go pick it up 20 minutes later. Bonus -- the restaurant gets 100% of your tips. In this era the rent-seeking behavior of these app companies really becomes apparent. It's not easier to do it through them -- they add no real value. Clearly they don't add value for the small restaurants either: they're shafting the small ones in favor of those who have a corporate structure and throw millions of dollars into ads. Stop feeding the ad platforms that use sneaky tricks to make the profits they promised to their investors. It's a self-perpetuating cycle if you keep letting them feed the VCs' expectations to the detriment of the people, the end users.
- hannasanarion 7y agoWhen you vote with your dollars, people with more dollars get more votes. Customers, drivers, and restaurateurs all hate doordash, but they have no choice because Doordash uses their oodles of VC bucks to squash competition and underhanded shady shit (like putting up menus without consent) to force restaurants to participate and hook them in.
- bhupy 7y agoWhat were restaurants doing for delivery before DoorDash et al came into the market? Why don't they do that now?
- 7y ago
- mangofizzy 7y agoIt is certainly not fair for restaurants to pay for ad fee when it is not ad for themselves, but I think calling it conspiracy is a little of stretch.
- oneiftwo 7y agoEverything remotely related to adware is just gross. It's hard to believe that after 10 years of this nothing has changed and the tricks are as dirty as ever. Totally unethical industry and I can't wait for the bubble to collapse.
- rochak 7y agoHow long have you been waiting? I think it is here to stay given how quickly it has become prevalent in real life as well as the web. We just can’t do anything as long as we are dependent on them for anything. It sickens me as well, but it can’t be avoided.
- pcmaffey 7y agoI've found the most effective way to place an order is to call directly. And I hate talking on the phone. It seems backwards, but I don't want to give aggregators my business or my data, and most local websites either suck or require I retype all my data. Calling is most analagous to just ordering at the counter.
- uoaei 7y agoYeah, the person on the other end of the line also wants the call to be over as soon as possible. There's no predilections of cordiality, you just say "pickup order", they say "OK", you list the things you want, they read it back to you, both hang up. It's awesome.
- jmondi 7y agoSometimes there is a language barrier when calling on the phone that is just not there when you order at the counter (without a mask). Ordering at the counter these days (wearing a mask) is actually very similar to ordering over the phone. It is much more difficult to hear what the other person is saying, and when you do hear it, you don't get the mouth movement to help you understand what is being said.
- projektfu 7y agoThey've also figured out how to scam the restaurant on that one. https://www.engadget.com/2019-08-06-grubhub-is-replacing-restaurant-phone-numbers-on-yelp.html https://www.engadget.com/2019-08-06-grubhub-is-replacing-res...
- acomjean 7y agoThat google "business name" sidebar has got to go. I volunteer at "somerville open studios" a once a year event where artists open their studios. Google has recently been showing the sidebar for "somerville studio" a photo studio. I get that google is confused and no amount of business registering seems to change that (we're a registered non-orofit, but don't have a physical space...) But they're showing the "Open time" and a bunch of sidebar info in the main feed (we're open at 7am.. but the event starts at noon). When that sidebar works its kind neat, but when it fails it fails spectacularly.
- genidoi 7y agoOn a more general level this kind of predatory behavior seems to the natural progression for internet conglomerates who specialize in connecting aggregate eyeballs / wallets to distributed vendors. It's not just delivery either, eBay, Amazon, AirBnb etc, they all absolutely squeeze vendors and there is no appeal process whatsoever if anything goes wrong with your account. I wish there was a better way. It's quite sad to see how the internet has these seemingly intrinsic highways to organizational psychopathy built into it.
- chillacy 7y agoOh this was happening pre-internet as well. Anonymous manufacturers get squeezed by brand labels, brand labels get squeezed by retail stores, franchise owners get squeezed by the franchise...
- ffritz 7y agoI’m getting a 403 when trying to access.
- someonehere 7y agoFor those saying they don’t want to tip through the app because DoorDash keeps the tip. Choose Other and put $0. Give the driver a cash tip. I have a friend who delivers for Whole Foods and he says it’s better that way because the payout on tips doesn’t get borked in the system or slip into the pockets of the delivery service. Yes I know we’re trying to avoid contact with items between people, but it could be easy to protect you and the delivery person with some hand sanitizer or wipes. Just my two cents.
- chrischen 7y agoNot only ads but these online ordering companies go as far as to setup fake websites under fake domains that make it look like an official website to unsuspecting restaurants that did not have websites. Previously, they would also take these fake websites and use them to claim the official website on the Google Places listing so they can show up at the top without much SEO. But often their fake websites would show up organically and appear as the real website, and then they’d take a 30% fee for “referring” the customer. I learned about this when I was trying to sell an online ordering platform so restaurants could setup their own websites with ordering. The problem was sales was slow and expensive, and small restaurants weren’t savvy enough to understand they’d need to spend a lump sum to setup their websites to fix the problem, or even how or why the problem existed.
- qppo 7y agoIsn't this fraud?
- AlexandrB 7y agoIt sure feels like it. I don't know whether it's legally fraud, but it feels very icky. I wonder how the product managers and engineers behind this justify it to themselves.
- nickff 7y agoDefinitely seems like customer deception, and potential misuse/theft of a trademark. I am generally skeptical of class-actions, but this seems like a legitimate subject for a (well-run) class-action lawsuit for the benefit of parties who were actually wronged.
- chrischen 7y agoSure, but these things don't really get enforced. I mean, one of my current competitors advertises their product as made in USA (which it is not), but only if you use their chat widget to talk to them (which most customers do) in a move I assume is to remove any paper trail. There is no real clear path except maybe ones that involve either bribing a politician or a lobbyist (which may be the same thing) to get this pursued.
- codazoda 7y ago> when you order delivery from one of the large delivery partners like GrubHub or DoorDash - not only do you pay a delivery fee, service fee, and a generous tip to the driver. But we restaurant owners also pay...these fees can range from 15% to 35% of your entire order. If these fees are too high, then why accept orders from these providers? If you don't get enough orders otherwise, then these services are providing value. If you do, then simply refuse to discount for these providers and handle the orders yourself. This post, and others like it, seem like they're asking consumers to avoid these services, but it seems like it would be much easier for restaraunts to refuse to participate.
- m-ee 7y agoThese services will go out of their way to place orders against the restaurants will if they choose not to accept them. Even going as far as having employees call in phone orders while posing as regular customers.
- forgotmylogin2 7y agoSo what? Then the restaurant doesn't have to pay a fee. If the problem is that the delivery services are charging high fees to restaurants, then terminating the relationship with the delivery service solves that problem. If the delivery service wants to make orders like a normal customer without any discounts, that's good for the restaurants.
- m-ee 7y agoRestaurants don't always have the capacity to make delivery orders and may not want to deal with the logistics of impatient drivers coming in and demanding their food in the middle of a dinner rush. In some cases they've set up fake websites and taken orders for restaurants that don't even offer takeout. Whatever their reasons for not wanting the business the OP's point was 'they can always opt out' which just isn't true.
- ryanwaggoner 7y agoNo, because by doing so, the delivery services are effectively injecting themselves into the middle of the relationship between the customer and the restaurant. Over time, most customers will launch the app when they're hungry in general or for a type of food, and if they don't see a specific restaurant there anymore but they do see competitors that have decent ratings, they'll just order from them.
- coliveira 7y agoWhenever you read "disrupting" industry X, the real way to read this is screwing local businesses involved in that industry. So, no surprises here.
- a3n 7y agoAnd disavowing responsibility for their workers.
- gabrielrdz 7y agoIt's so ironic that Google's original motto was "Don't be evil".
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bryanmgreen 7y agoPro Tip: For any company you really love that is smaller in size and not a global powerhouse, before you purchase, contact them and ask for their preferred purchasing platform. For most restaurants, just call to place an order.
- johnklos 7y ago1) We (technical people) need to stop being afraid to call companies evil. This isn't just an example of a company that does the profitable thing over the right thing - it's just an example of chosen behavior that almost always prioritizes profit over everything else. Once it's socially acceptable to call companies evil, people will start being less surprised by behavior like this, and they can start to make more informed decisions. Using Doordash, GrubHub and Google should ALWAYS be considered a calculated risk. The same can be said for Yelp, Facebook and others. "Do what we say, or suffer the consequences of our indifference once our game is played out on you." 2) Anyone who writes something like this might consider spell and grammar checking.
- strictnein 7y agoMore great "innovation" coming out of Silicon Valley. Congrats folks, you're really at the cutting edge of screwing over the little guy.
- strictnein 7y agoMore "innovation": https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/venessawong/grubhub-phone-order-call-fee-coronavirus https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/venessawong/grubhub-pho... > “If a customer calls to place a coffee order, we’re paying a $6.42 fee — for a coffee.”
- xphilter 7y agoI investigated a case similar to this a few years ago (as an attorney). The problem is that most of these restaurants already signed contracts with the tech company that gave away a lot, including rights like this. And because it’s B2B, it’s hard to play the “unsophisticated consumer” card.
- MattGaiser 7y agoReading this article, I realized that DoorDash and UberEats now own me as a customer. I have never been particularly picky about my restaurants. Chinese food is Chinese food. McDonalds vs Wendys is not something I have strong feelings about. Plenty of places have good ribs. Obviously there are places I will avoid due to bad experiences, but I am not highly opinionated as long as I find the food tasty. I am one of those people who would go to a different BBQ place if I found a cheaper one or a more interesting menu. Even when I don't want to cook, I don't search for a particular food item anymore and probably take the top DoorDash deal half the time. Even within that, I don't choose a restaurant anymore. I choose food and am generally satisfied with whoever DoorDash has to supply that food. That is a major shift for the food industry if even a small percentage of people are like myself as it means I must be won as a customer every single time I order and can easily have any restaurant in my quadrant of the city (rather than just going to the local one).
- hammock 7y agoWhat you describe is a valuable innovation on the part of the platforms, though. They allow you to search and order a specific menu item, without wading through a list of restaurants guessing what may or may not be on their menu.
- MattGaiser 7y agoOh certainly. The only thing I order now without a delivery app is pizza.
- ryanwaggoner 7y agoThat’s true, they’re definitely creating value, and probably increasing total delivery and takeout revenue industry-wide. But I suspect that they’re capturing even more value than they’re creating, with the bulk of the difference coming out of restaurants margins, which were razor thin to begin with.
- rockinghigh 7y agoI don't believe UberEats engaged in this practice of fake online presence of local restaurants. They also did not reduce payment to drivers when customers tip, unlike DoorDash.
- idid 7y agocached version: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:b4DOuGeTelQJ:https://www.saddlebackbbq.com/how-google-doordash-grubhub-conspire-screw-local-restaurants+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=uk https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:b4DOuG... (current link returns a 403)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lastofus 7y agoIf I wanted to start a grassroots local competitor for collecting delivery orders without screwing over restaurants, what would be the best way to handle payment processing? Using Stripe + manually sending money via ACH doesn't sound sustainable. Would AML/KYC laws start to apply for this sort of thing?
- MattGaiser 7y agoWhy couldn't you use Stripe? DoorDash does.
- dvduval 7y agoAn advertiser that advertises advertisers and monopolizes Google AdWords. I have the same thing in my industry where there are a couple of "directories" that sell advertising in my industry. They take the top couple of spots on Google AdWords. You click on their ad, and then you have a list of advertisements. This is a poor result for the end user. They have to click more times just to get to what they were looking for. Why can't Google just provide the best search results in the first place?
- TechBro8615 7y agoWhat’s amusing to me is that many of these techniques were well documented on Blackhat SEO forums circa 2010. These companies just normalized and scaled them.
- kmccauley 7y agoThere's nothing that Google does that's NOT evil.
- a3n 7y agoYes! More middlemen! /s As participating capitalists, shouldn't we be shunning any company that adds friction where there was none? This really brings to mind the mafia elbowing in for a cut of the operations, or the whole contract, and adding nothing but extortion and shoddy work.
- AlexandrB 7y agoStartup capitalism seems quite different from traditional capitalism. Instead of profitability, the main qualification for a successful startup seems to be a good story for investors. Then, with VC money in hand, traditional pricing signals can be distorted by subsidizing the service - sometimes for years. Whether the big business that results at the end of this process is viable, valuable, or even desirable to customers is impossible to tell until the subsidies run out and the startup has to try to make a profit. At that point no alternative may exist because smaller, independent competitors have been driven out of business by a series of VC-fuelled market distortions.
- agustif 7y agoHow hard would it be to make an open source framework for restaurants to be easy to setup/use instead of the alternatives?
- aloukissas 7y agoMost tech/VC folks: DoorDash, UberEats, GrubHut, etc are great for restaurants! Most restaurant owners: these guys are squeezing us of almost all profit margin with the argument "good luck doing any business without us" (platform fees are often 40% of the ticket, or more). Huge disconnect of realities.
- Jommi 7y agoHaven't really seen the former ever. Any links to those kinds of comments?
- aloukissas 7y agoFollow any investor on Twitter. Any negative comment that reads like "delivery startups are bad for the restaurants" turns into "yes, but look at all the revenue they're bringing". The more I talk with restaurant owners (almost daily), I'm convinced that a competitor that looks like Shopify (mostly fixed cost vs huge % of the check) will come in. And they may be many of them, perhaps local (not nation/global-wide like today).
- Jommi 7y agoAny links?
- ummonk 7y agoJust VC folks, not tech folks.
- Apofis 7y agoThis is just how Adwords works. Funny, Google seems to have removed ads for the BBQ keyword. Doordash was just putting up ads for any query that contained the word "BBQ".
- g_sch 7y agoI think the author's frustration here is warranted, but it's directed at the wrong part of DoorDash/GrubHub's product strategy. Advertising on competitor listings is a bread and butter marketing strategy that happens everywhere. If you're a BBQ restaurant owner, you want to advertise on your competitors' branded keywords because it's an obvious place to acquire new customers. The underhanded move on the part of food delivery platforms like GrubHub, DoorDash, Caviar, UberEats, etc., is that they increasingly are nudging their users to completely remove the restaurant brand from the loop. Open up one of the apps and notice a few things about the user experience they're pushing: - foregrounding "dishes" and "cuisines" rather than specific restaurants - hiding/burying the ability to just browse a list of restaurants, instead opting for themed or algorithmically generated collections of restaurants and dishes. I get the distinct sense that DoorDash, GrubHub, and the other delivery platforms want their users to think of the platform as the source of the food, rather than the restaurant. "Let's get some ribs delivered from GrubHub" rather than "Let's get some ribs delivered from Saddleback BBQ via GrubHub". This makes perfect sense for a company operating a two-sided marketplace - you ideally want to become indispensable to both sides. Restaurants need to realize that the marketing opportunities the platforms are offering will only provide them value as long as they're not entirely captured by the platform. And since restaurants have much lower brand recognition and far lower marketing budgets, it's going to be tough to fight back.
- bsenftner 7y agoIt amazes me the larger world is just figuring this out. Dark business patterns has been every delivery company's #1 business model from day one, regardless of what they have been saying. Their behavior has always included these types of dark patterns. Why anyone uses these loud frauds has always been beyond me. And that goes twice for the people tricked into being a gig worker for them.
- zwilliamson 7y agoIs there a way as an end user I can filter out all results driven by DoorDash, GrubHub and the likes on Google Search? Or perhaps would I be better off using DuckDuckGo? Seems like this might be neat browser extension to help people get search results that point you directly to a restaurant website. Perhaps following the ad blocker concept; restaurant middleman blocker.
- itsbenweeks 7y agoI wish it was just this. A friend of mine works in an upscale deli here in Boston. Their employer doesn't partner with DoorDash, yet GrubHub --interchanged because they both do this-- still lists them. What happens instead of a printed order from their system? They instruct the delivery person to place an order at the counter, wait for it, and then deliver it. All this seems fine, if DoorDash wants to hire people to proxy face-to-face interactions so they can up-charge 20% for a caprese sandwich on ciabatta bread, more power to them. I understand the value of it. But it gets squishy in places. What happens if an ordered and paid for item is out of stock? My friend's deli has excellent ciabatta and it sells out daily. DoorDash leaves this problem to the delivery-person, and delivery people can't cancel orders. Why can't delivery people on GrubHub cancel orders? For the same reason that Uber Drivers can't see their fare's destination until they get in the car. DoorDash doesn't want their delivery people to cherry-pick only the costliest orders with the choicest tips. That would leave a good portion of customers without food. So, the delivery people are left to call whoever ordered on their phone about this. If there's any confusion from the delivery person and their ability to convey the nuances of this problem --that GrubHub promised something they couldn't deliver-- then the delivery person is left to pay for orders that DoorDash users don't cancel. My friend has been given more than one upset delivery person's phone which has an angry GrubHub customer on the other end. So, while a DoorDash customer may have wanted to avoid a phone call, the customer is now hungrier and upset at somebody who would have been able to sell them their sandwich for 16% less and had actual knowledge about what kind of bread was still available because they wanted to avoid the phone call that they're now having. Usually not a big deal, but if you're already working a crowded deli-counter during the lunch rush; it certainly cements the uselessness of these platforms.
- ryanwaggoner 7y agoIt’s also a losing strategy long-term, because many of your existing customers will start just using GH to order, and eventually GH will own that relationship, not you. In the customer’s mind, “want food = Grubhub app”, not deli.
- cosmodisk 7y agoThe restaurants are equally to blame here. It didn't take long to realise that it's more profitable to deliver food to a broader audience than just serve 15 table each evening. Very few restaurants knew how or were willing to invest in marketing,internet reach and so on. Now a lot of them are no more than a nice thumbnail in these websites. I don't even know where those place are- all I know is somewhere within a few miles.. However, having written all this,the type of stuff mentioned in the article isn't doing any favours to anyone.
- imaadrashied 7y agoMight be a specific issue for this restaurant. Tried googling several restaurants in SF that are open at the moment and the link from google to the delivery company goes directly to a page for that restaurant, not a generic page for the type of food.
- chrisked 7y ago403. Can’t access in Europe.
- socrates1998 7y agoI avoid all of these app's and order directly from the restaurant themselves. 1) All of them add to the cost of the bill way more than I think is a good use of my money. 2) Driver's don't get paid very well. 3) Restaurants get screwed. Sure it might mean I have to go out and pick up the order instead of getting it directly delivered, but it's really not that big of a deal.
- HumblyTossed 7y agoI do curb side. I've read enough bad things about DoorDash, et al that I choose not to do business with them.
- Jommi 7y agoWhy would I tip before I order the food?
- ypeterholmes 7y agoSeems like this is a Google problem more than DoorDash or GrubHub, because it's google that allows people to advertise against your own business name. So that's the legal question- what part of your own name do you own on a third party platform? And what if that platform (google) has a monopoly on web searches?
- JGM_io 7y agoIs everybody getting an 403? Anyone has a copy of the article?
- pmorici 7y agoI was under the impression that it was against Google's ad rules to use the trademarks other than your own in your ads. Are they not applying their own rule consistently to these food delivery services? [0] https://support.google.com/google-ads/thread/8702273?hl=en https://support.google.com/google-ads/thread/8702273?hl=en
- WayToDoor 7y agoI'm getting a 403 Forbidden, here's a backup link that works : https://archive.is/sNLho https://archive.is/sNLho
- helen___keller 7y agoI can understand the author's frustration, but that's a doordash ad, not a Saddleback BBQ ad - it's unrelated to the advertising fee that the author pays to be on the platform from my understanding that fee is for appearing in searching on the platform. The ad on google is for the platform itself. Doordash paid google to pick out queries with words like "bbq" and redirect them to doordash queries for "bbq". That has nothing to do with saddleback BBQ -- except, that for some awful reason, the ad is placed in the sidebar full of saddleback BBQ information instead of the main search results. I'd say this is less conspiratorial and more evidence of incompetence. Still, I feel for the author.
- Quanttek 7y agoCached version: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&ei=dfO-XoeCPZHbsAfPvYmoAw&q=cache%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.saddlebackbbq.com%2Fhow-google-doordash-grubhub-conspire-screw-local-restaurants&oq=cache%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.saddlebackbbq.com%2Fhow-google-doordash-grubhub-conspire-screw-local-restaurants&gs_lcp=CgZwc3ktYWIQA1C1H1i1H2CBIWgAcAB4AIABaIgBaJIBAzAuMZgBAKABAaoBB2d3cy13aXo&sclient=psy-ab&ved=0ahUKEwjHkK3z0rbpAhWRLewKHc9eAjUQ4dUDCAs&uact=5 https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?client=firefox...
- jgurewitz 7y agoThis is a classic example of how affiliate marketing is generally bad for businesses. For a local restaurant it may seem appealing to only pay for demand generated, but your partners are better than you at intercepting your existing demand and charging for it. If you have a trademark on the brand you would be able to get Google to take down the advertisements. If businesses are looking to generate demand, paying on a CPM basis via FB for example is a better outcome.
- kelnos 7y ago> The problem is that if we cancel, does that mean they will actually stop stealing customers that are looking for our restaurant and directing them to our competitors? At least in this scenario, since there's no contract and no advertising agreement, Saddleback could sue them for trademark infringement if they keep advertising using the Saddleback name. Of course, lawsuits suck and cost time and money that I'm sure the owner doesn't have to spare.
- ljsmith93 7y agoAnd this is why I don't use any of these terrible services. Order direct with the business using THEIR phone number & pick it up.
- 205guy 7y agoHere's another example of dark patterns: "Grubhub is still charging some restaurants phone fees, even if you call directly" https://www.sfgate.com/food/article/Grubhub-is-still-charging-restaurants-phone-fees-15273491.php https://www.sfgate.com/food/article/Grubhub-is-still-chargin... Relevant excerpt: "Grubhub generates a phone number for each restaurant on its platform, which redirects you to the restaurant's own phone line when you call it. However, they are able to charge a fee for that redirection. In some cases, Grubhub collects a fee even when a call does not result in an order." "Grubhub phone numbers often appear higher in Google search results than the restaurant's own line, which can lead even customers who don't use the app to dial the redirect."
- corny 7y agoThis looks like the same thing Etsy has been doing since early this year. https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/26/21155193/etsy-advertising-program-angers-sellers-cut-of-sales https://www.theverge.com/2020/2/26/21155193/etsy-advertising... Ad landing pages feature prominent links to competitors' products at the top of the page.
- cs702 7y agoWow, the entire advertising chain here looks like a completely unnecessary TAX on restaurants and consumers: * A restaurant pays the advertising fee to DoorDash/GrubHub but the money is used to divert organic searches for the restaurant to DoorDash/GrubHub instead. The restaurant gets nothing for that advertising fee. In fact, it loses valuable organic traffic online. * A consumer searches for a restaurant, but the first result is for a paid link to DoorDash/GrubHub. The consumer gets connected to these middlemen instead of the restaurant as intended. The search engine and DoorDash/GrubHub charge their cut for inserting themselves into the transaction. The only term that in mind describes the act of extracting rents in exchange for providing no value or even subtracting value is... extortion.
- rossjudson 7y agoWhen I first started using food apps I thought they were great, and never really considered the flow of money. One day I ordered from a kebab place through an app, and went to pick it up myself. When I got there the owner asked me -- hey, why didn't you just call me? I replied that the app was really convenient, etc. He told me that the app was charging him 15% for my order, even though I was picking it up myself. So that was an eye-opening moment, and I haven't felt the slightest urge to use a food app since, if I have the option to get it myself or if the restaurant has their own delivery service.
- mahdix 7y agoI see this: Forbidden You don't have permission to access this resource. Additionally, a 403 Forbidden error was encountered while trying to use an ErrorDocument to handle the request.
- skny 7y agoThe post seems to misinterpret that Doordash + Grubhub are somehow in cahoots with Google to skim off of restauranteurs. What Doordash & Grubhub are doing is an extreme form of "growth hacking" that doesn't have any considerations for the collateral damage it creates - they should be held accountable for that. Google here is just the provider of a tool that they abuse, they need to work on ensuring that this form of abuse should not be possible. To deduce that there's a conspiracy between Google + Doordash is taking it a bit too far..
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bork1 7y agoas of ~15:45 PDT 5/15 searching saddleback bbq lansing on Google and DDG the links in the advertisements go to the restaurant's website, not GrubHub or DoorDash for me
- virtue3 7y agoI worked for a restaurant reservation company I don't feel like naming. Anytime the user had gone to the restaurants website, or used their website to make an online reservation, there was a significant reduction in our fee (like ~75%). That's because the user DID NOT use our network for discovery. Using advertising like that to drive to a generic page where you show competitors first is really underhanded. I get that you want your kickback from Applebee's but c'mon. A lot of this crap is just not fair to restaurants, and taking that HUGE of a cut from a restaurant AND gouging my ass in fees and then stiffing drivers in bullshit policies where my "tip" goes towards their minimum wage is horse shit (looking at you doordash).
- nabeards 7y agoI've never used DoorDash nor Uber Eats, and the one time I used Grubhub was a disaster. Don't use these services and you can help stop this insanity.
- Zetaphor 7y agoAnyone else find it peculiar that he keeps calling Lansing a small town? It's not only the capital city of the state, but it's generally divided in peoples minds into the four cardinal directions, so North Lansing, South Lansing, East, and South. This is important because each area is not only fairly large, but is also very different culturally from each other. In fact East Lansing (still Lansing!) is the home of Michigan State University. That's hardly what I'd call a small school in a small town. East Lansing is practically a city unto itself. Out of the 300 municipalities in the state of Michigan, Lansing is the 5'th largest by population. I understand he's trying to evoke a certain emotion, but to anyone who is even remotely familiar with the area it comes off as pandering and dishonest.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI live in a town of about 16k people. I don't think we have any of those delivery services. But those services tend to mostly be in the biggest metro areas. Lansing is relatively small from that perspective. So I figured that's why he framed it that way.
- DoreenMichele 7y agothe customer could have just gone to our website and ordered directly from our online ordering store and we would not be charged a commission to GrubHub or DoorDash. Is there anything we can do to start a counter movement to help restaurants figure out how to get people to more reliably type in the name of the restaurant they are interested in and order directly? (Or some other work around? I would love to start an app for my small town that lists "What's open now" for example.) I support gig work, but for various reasons I'm not a fan of services like DoorDash. I don't think such services are a good thing at all for anyone involved and I'm happy to support some means to give push back against such and try to find a way to help protect restaurant owners from these predatory business models.
- fulldecent2 7y agoMany business owners are frustrated by this. Suckers will call GrubHub and DoorDash to complain. When you call them you are entered into a workflow where you are talking to a human or robot that is trained to do the minimum for you to prevent you from suing them. They are doing unethical and/or illegal things so they are prepared for pissed off people and this is an expense on their business plan. Instead, just sue them. Even if you have to file by yourself, without hiring an attorney. Reading a sad blog post is fun. But reading "I just sued GrubHub because they are violating me -- I'm not sure what I'm doing, can anyone else relate or help?" is front page news in the 21st century.
- szaslan 7y agoThis is really frustrating to read and I know the importance of ordering direct when you can, but the hardest part for me was trying to find restaurants around me that actually offered direct online ordering. I helped build a site to try and solve that: https://foood.com/ https://foood.com/ It's mostly restaurants in the Chicago area right now but trying to grow as fast as possible everywhere
- fishingisfun 7y agoit doesnt help that many restaurants have terrible sites
- bvandewalle 7y agoI don't get those delivery companies (Doordash, Grubhub, etc). Even with a first-timer promotion, a meal would end up being close to 25% more expensive than ordering directly with the restaurant. I'm happy to order directly with a local restaurant on the phone, drive 10 minutes (especially now with no traffic) and get my food on my terms. I end up paying way less and the restaurant keeps the full dollar amount. It's a no-brainer win-win situation. I wish more people would order directly with restaurants.
- neop1x 7y agoSome fastfoods, with quick preparations and basic food can actually benefit from services like DoorDash. If they don't like technology, are not marketing specialists, live mostly offline, then it can bring them many new customers. So I think it's up to the restaurant to decide. Premium restaurants may have money and skills to have their website with their delivery ordering system and returning customers. It varies, I guess...
- ummonk 7y agoDoes the contract with DoorDash and Grubhub allow them to use the trade name? Regardless, if Saddleback BBQ does cancel, I would assume it would be very much illegal for DoorDash and Grubhub to advertise using that trade name.
- broknbottle 7y agoWhoa quite the surprise to see this posted on hacker news. I used to work with Travis for a few years. He was pretty much never in the office and if I did see him, he was usually hiding in the fish bowl. I also lived in Cherry Hill Downtown Lansing for three years about two blocks from Reo town. The food at Saddleback was decent but never knocked my socks off. Now crack chicken, east side fish fry, astros pizza and Olympic broil, those places had some food that brings back memories
- KoftaBob 7y agoAre there any food delivery services that aren't scummy? Would love to support those instead.
- gabagoo 7y agoWhy do these gig companies have to function like racketeers? I don't understand why everyone from Grubhub to Uber to Airbnb feels the need to "take a piece of the action" in the way they do. There are smarter profitability models, it's just so lazy.
- excalibur 7y ago> small town > small town > small town It's the state capital. It may not compare to the antics of stay-at-home protestors, but your insistence on describing the city this way when surrounded by so many ACTUAL small towns is still pretty embarrassing.
- giorgioz 7y agoThey can legally register a trademark (costs 500$ once and is done online). After trade-marking competitors can still bid for your trademark but they can't write the trademark words in the title or content of the ads. These two links explain how trademark vs ads works: https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6118?hl=en https://support.google.com/adspolicy/answer/6118?hl=en https://www.brandverity.com/blog/google-ads-trademark-rules-101 https://www.brandverity.com/blog/google-ads-trademark-rules-...
- x3blah 7y ago"They are redirecting those customers to their platform where they can purchase from a competitor or they can charge us a fee to provide food to that same customer. Whereas the customer could have just gone to our website and ordered directly from our online ordering store and we would not be charged a commission to GrubHub or DoorDash." Here he refers to Grubhub and DoorDash as "competitors" with the restaurant. Yet at the conclusion of the story he refers to them as "partners" with the restaurants who pay them. "DoorDash and GrubHub have a long history of screwing their partners." These companies are "middlemen". That description in fact fits a large number of "tech" companies. It is a common theme when we look at the "tech" industry. A few days ago food delivery, including Grubhub, was discussed on HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23169597 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23169597 One commenter argued that companies like Grubhub exist in "fake markets" that would not exist were it not for VC funding. Another argued that these markets are not fake because these companies have managed to be profitable and deliver returns to investors. Not sure what you all have experienced, in my experience with restaurants and delivery, the owners always seem to prefer customers who order directly from the restaurant, not via a middleman. However, I can sense that they feel compelled to sign up with the middlemen for fear of losing business. HN commenters seem to enjoy comparing first page search results on Google versus alternatives such as DDG. Try this one out. Search for your favourite restaurant. On Google, I see more middlemen than I see on DDG, including a result for "[restaurant-name].business.site" which I believe belongs to Google. I don't see that result on DDG. Imagine if the telephone book Yellow Pages listed multiple numbers for each business, some of them not belonging to the business but to middlemen who would "make calling easier". Even more, imagine it changed the order of the listings according to a "secret" methodology instead of presenting them in alphabetical order.
- princevegeta89 7y agoWow, this is unbelievably blatant. How can they even use the advertise the restaurant without their consent on Google? These ads almost look like spam to me like those old internet generic ads. Most people wouldn't click those, and even if they do, they would back off after all they see is a generic landing page which is not about the original restaurant they were looking for.
- mD5pPxMcS6fVWKE 7y agoHow much in a restaurant's cost is (food and its preparation) vs (rent, decor, service and marketing)? I bet less than a half. If they only had a kitchen, they would be totally ok with this arrangement.
- jessaustin 7y agoDoorDash and Grubhub might be the villains of this piece, but in general Google don't need any help to abuse the trademarks of small businesses. It's common (as in, I've seen this in multiple industries in small rural communities in my state) for AdWords advertisers to bid on their local competitors' actual business names, and thus appear above those businesses in searches for the exact names of those businesses. Then naive would-be customers are calling the wrong phone numbers and using the wrong driving directions. If they intended to drive to Alice's Donuts and end up at Bob's Donuts instead, they're obviously just going to buy something at Bob's. I think some younger Google users are aware of this phenomenon, but it's not a majority and above a certain age no one understands it. After all, on most phones the AdWords content is the only thing visible without scrolling. How many 70-year-olds can reliably scroll their phone, even if they know of the concept? I don't know how this practice has failed to inspire class-action lawsuits. Perhaps Google can argue that they don't intend to make billions of dollars in this obviously illegal way and it should really be AdWords customers who get sued for trademark infringement.
- masonic 7y agoWould there be any legal issue for a restaurant to banish external delivery runners? i.e. refuse to serve those using Doordash garb or luggage, those who don't show the same credit card used for purchase, etc?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- masonic 7y agoActual title is "How Google, Doordash, and GrubHub Conspire to Screw Local Restaurants".
- tacocataco 7y agoIf you don't tip cash, GrubHub takes back the hourly they pay the driver. Say you get $10 an hour delivering for GrubHub. You earn $10 in delivery fees and credit card tips in that hour. How much do you think the driver gets? It's $10. GrubHub gets to say "your whole tip goes to the driver!", But never says they claw back the drivers hourly making them free for GrubHub to employ. Tip cash, or literally don't tip at all. I never saw my credit card tips the whole year I worked for them.