15 ms·
2M chickens to be killed in US processing plants due to lack of employees
- vanniv 7y agoIt is unconscionable that our state governments are intentionally creating a famine.
- d1str0 7y agoWat
- vanniv 7y agoYou know that thing, where people die because the food runs out? That's called "famine" And just like Ireland was decimated intentionally by the potato famine, America is about to be destroyed intentionally by the coronavirus famine. Those who would have absolute rule never really change their methods.
- Lazare 7y agoThere is no famine. Nor is there going to be a famine. (Edit: In the US, which was the context of the news story, the comment, and my response.) We're discussing news of 2M chickens being killed and not processed into meat, which while unfortunate, is in the context of the over 20M+ other chickens eaten every day in the US. The sheer disconnect in scale between the news story at hand and your paranoid comments is mind boggling.
- FindMySocks 7y agoNah man, he's not referring to food. He's referring to that delicious crack. So moreish. Supplies are limited now though, so we're gonna have a crack famine the likes this world has never seen!
- bpodgursky 7y agoThere is absolutely going to be a famine: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/22/world/africa/coronavirus-hunger-crisis.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/22/world/africa/coronavirus-... It won't seriously hurt Americans (we have money, surplus, and net food production), but that doesn't mean it doesn't exist. The point isn't that this is a catastrophic amount of chicken right here, but that it's indicative of a general degradation of supply chains that will predominantly hurt the global poor, and lives will definitely be lost.
- mrb 7y agoAmericans eat 24M chickens per day. So 2M killed is only a fraction of the number eaten in a single day. However it's still deplorable that we can't find a way to not waste this amount of food.
- roebk 7y agoNot waste this amount of life
- downerending 7y agoIf it makes you feel any better, you may regard yourself complicit every time you leave a scrap of meat on your plate.
- mmsimanga 7y agoI struggle with leaving plate on my food and I also struggle with my weight. Growing up we weren't allowed to leave food on the plate. To this day I still feel guilty for leaving food on a plate and yet I am overweight. I know the answer is to dish out a little and get seconds if need be. Problem is I live with people who do more cooking than I do and because I am a fairly big guy they can't help but dish out massive quantities of food.
- BubRoss 7y agoStop eating sugar, watch 'sugar: the butter truth'. This isn't something that is happening -to- you, it is something you can control.
- downerending 7y ago+1 for delicious typo
- SamReidHughes 7y agoThink about it. "Wasting" food is identical to overproduction of food. That's slack in the system that prevents people from starving.
- msie 7y agoJust today I saw the news about famine in West Africa. Sigh...
- cmauniada 7y agoWe live in a bubble, I feel so out of touch with how people live in many of the other places in the world. Last October I visited Pakistan and what I saw there really made me think about the scale of globally inequality that’s just allowed to “exist”. Not just in food, but so many other places in our lives we take for granted.
- newyankee 7y agoPakistan is a lot of human created issues though. They have the most fertile land in the subcontinent along the indus river. However they have had absolutely no population control measures unlike India and Bangladesh which are almost at replacement level fertility. Throw in a backward society, mismanagement, lack of democracy and you get this. My point simply is that the hunger is not merely because of shortage of food.
- bzb3 7y agoFor some people, stating that poor countries might be remotely responsible for their own problems is a highly controversial stance.
- newyankee 7y agoYes and No, being from India myself i understand it is complicated. However western views are clouded. What the journalists and observers do not understand is that you cannot apply the same logic you applied to your own country and many good intentioned policies will turn out into tragedy of commons. This has been demonstrated time and again. This is why i have this unpopular opinion that what China did was simply unimaginable. Yes, they have their issues but a proper democracy where nothing moves (e.g. Sardar Sarovar dam on river Narmada was involved in litigation for over 50 years over increasing dam height which submerged some tribal villages, other side of the coin was it increased the irrigated land substantially ) compared to China where they executed more hydrological projects in 10-15 years than probably what the world did in entirety of 20th century. Surely some people were negatively impacted, but the outcome was net positive. We can argue about corruption, few people skimming the benefits but i think the Chinese society bargain with CCP is to ensure jobs, opportunities and development in exchange for no significant revolution. The misplaced idealism and token suggestions and projects that happen in Africa and India are useless. Only strong, difficult decisions that should've been taken decades ago would've made a difference. It is not possible to make everyone happy in one go.
- sandworm101 7y agoI don't get it. If they had enough employees, then these processing plants wouldn't kill 2M chickens? I think these birds were doomed. A more accurate title might be "Processors throw away 2M Pounds of chicken meat due to lack of employees."
- mongol 7y agoI think the word prematurely is missing
- Melting_Harps 7y ago> I think the word prematurely is missing If its a the processing plant that's kind of true, even if they could run them through the automated 'harvesting' system its probably really expensive to store until an undisclosed time for it to be processed and then sent to market. At a significant loss in Market price, I imagine. So its best to take the subsidy/insured loss and restart again. This is actually really fucking sad... I hope it encourages more people to focus on the World's broken food supply and its immense waste and do something about it. I hope we don't have to see the same thing that happened with toilet paper, and paper towels happen with our food before people get the message that we have to re-think our entire infrastructure. > Americans eat 24M chickens per day. So 2M killed is only a fraction of the number eaten in a single day. That's a horrible calculus, and quite frankly stereotypical of People so detached from their food system: have you taken into consideration the externalities of hatching, raising, and ultimately getting them to Market size? It's actually incredibly costly. And they were probably factory farmed, which makes it even worse given the cruel practices involved. On a positive note: Spring is finally here, and I saw a bunch of people's Community Garden's today.
- mike_d 7y ago> focus on the World's broken food supply and its immense waste That is an extremely hyperbolic statement. According to the United Nations [https://tinyurl.com/y9esnjez https://tinyurl.com/y9esnjez] fruits, vegetables, cereals, and roots account for 70% of all food waste. It is unfortunate that due to a global pandemic they had to be put down, but chickens are the most efficient form for preserving and delivering calories from grains to the table. Additionally, industrialized and developing nations waste food at the same rate - just in different stages of the logistics chain. No system is perfectly efficient, and while there are improvements to be made - it is pretty damn amazing that the majority of 7 billion people have a meal a day.
- sytelus 7y agoI don't remember who but someone (Naval?) had this quote that generations 100 years from now will think of us as utterly barbaric for eating animals. When I look around how we treat animals as if they were just sacs of meat, its amazingly heart wrenching. In Alaska I saw a casual 4th of July competitions where you throw dead fish and other person catches it. Sometime fish fall apart and all its guts spread out during these games while audience literally laugh at that scene. I wonder how people get so heartlessly cruel that not only they are killing animals for entertainment but also enjoy when their bodies fall apart? What is their internal justification system? A devout Christian explained to me that its their God given right to be superior to animals and God has instructed them to consume these animals. In a Chinese restaurant I had hard time explaining someone that fish is not really a plant. It seems minds can be programmed to shield away from any cruelty. Perhaps that's how people working in Nazi camps justified cruelty towards Jews: they aren't really living beings like rest of us, they are something else quite lower so no need to take all these to heart.
- dmitriid 7y agoI hate to break it to you, but in general our treatment of animals is way better than a 100 years ago. Animal shelters? Animal cruelty laws? Etc. That fish throwing contest? Oh, it's almost definitely older than 100 years (as are dog fights, dolphin slaughter, goose pulling, cock throwing and other wonderful traditions from around the world).
- 317070 7y agoThat is one side of the scale. The other side of the scale has the meat industry in it (which is absolutely not like 100 years ago). As someone who used to work in a slaughter house, I am not convinced that today is better. I can see our children looking back in a few generations and think of us as barbaric. I thought of it as barbaric and surreal when working there.
- dmitriid 7y agoThe scale? Yeah, the scale is much bigger. Conditions for animals? Not much different than 100 years ago [1]. And I'd argue they are better in many cases (and in many countries). [1] https://io9.gizmodo.com/utterly-disturbing-century-old-photos-of-meat-packing-1579470458 https://io9.gizmodo.com/utterly-disturbing-century-old-photo...
- mawuenash 7y agoI am disappointed, Does anybody can act to not waste all this food in this time?
- Melting_Harps 7y ago> I am disappointed, Does anybody can act to not waste all this food in this time? Yes: you! That's what it takes, if I'm honest. But if you're asking about startups, yes there is on based out of Texas and Colorado called Food Maven: https://foodmaven.com/ https://foodmaven.com/ Check out Roy Choi's PBS series Breaking bread, its all good, there they highlight how other places have tackled this issue in regards to environmental impact, local economic commerce, and food insecurity. It's really a rad series, and makes me glad Roy has gotten the success that he has! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jrV8WrqnyrM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jrV8WrqnyrM
- dvsfish 7y agothe true victims of covid-19....
- superpermutat0r 7y agoI think chickens are ground up with their feathers and ugly bits by falling from a treadmill. I guess one can't sell that as food but I'm pretty sure they can do something with it. Although, it's fine by me, meat is in its nature pretty wasteful, in addition to those 2M chickens there's probably more tons of soy protein wasted on chicken feed. Good thing that protein rich legumes do not need much processing.
- triyambakam 7y agoMy family and I are on day number 1153 of eating beans every day (and no animal products)
- koolhead17 7y agoAnd how was the experince? Some blog, could learn from it?
- triyambakam 7y agoThanks for asking! but unfortunately I haven't written anything up about it, but informally I can share that it's really benefited our health and even finances. Eating beans and rice every day and not eating out is very cheap. I buy most of our food in bulk online or from local farms - e.g. just got 50kg of chickpeas in the mail and 20kg of string beans from a farm. We also avoid eating oil for health reasons
- arcticbull 7y agoThe minimum daily intake of carbs for a human to remain healthy is zero. The minimum daily intake of oil is in fact, not zero, as oils are required for the basic functioning of a human.
- superpermutat0r 7y agoBut minimum daily intake of fiber, for humans to remain healthy, is not zero. Vegetables, especially if you eat them in amounts that sustain your weight, have enough omega essential fatty acids to last you a lifetime. Legumes do have fat in them. If you eat 2000kcal of red lentils, there's more than enough protein and fat content, almost meets your omega-3 essential fatty acid requirement. Nothing stops you from adding different fattier vegetables.
- irjustin 7y agoSadly this trend will continue. There will be a lot of wastage because our society and systems were built on higher levels of consumption, for better or for worse. There's momentum built in a system of scale and we're seeing what happens when the end consuming falls off the charts. Once society starts back up, we'll see the opposite where we'll be angry there are shortages of things we expect even though we're "back online".
- ryndbfsrw 7y agoSquint really hard with me... From an environmental point of view I think its encouraging there is so much headway we can collectively make by reducing waste than hoping new tech and infrastructure will allow the same level of consumption https://www.nrdc.org/resources/wasted-how-america-losing-40-percent-its-food-farm-fork-landfill https://www.nrdc.org/resources/wasted-how-america-losing-40-...
- koolhead17 7y agoHow much of deforestation their food would have resulted in?
- koheripbal 7y agoNone. Chicks eat very little and grain is already plentiful in the US.
- mesozoic 7y agoWord on the street is they would be able to kill them properly if the employees were there.
- peschu 7y agohmm anyone else get this: "Sorry, this content is not available in your region."
- sambf 7y agoYep. Although I'm now used to have location-restricted media content, I think that's the first time I can't read an article because of my location.
- RubenvanE 7y agoI got the same 403 message. Luckily outline.com was able to fetch the article: https://outline.com/yecexc https://outline.com/yecexc
- palae 7y agoTaking a critical look at one's own meat consumption can be enlightening, because it is something that we often take for granted. Do I eat meat because it is necessary for my health? If not, what are the reasons? How is the meat that I'm eating produced? How long do these animals live compared to their natural life span? What is the environmental cost of animal farming? Etc., Etc. I did not find convincing answers to these questions, so I stopped buying and eating meat.
- koheripbal 7y agoI eat hamburgers because they are delicious. I assume that the ethical, ecological, and societal impacts of that decision is somehow internalize in the price. I know I am wrong - but I hope that becomes true one day.
- notechback 7y agoSo you are aware that you are deluding yourself but don't take steps about it? :-)
- naruvimama 7y agoIt is our collective karma, to outsource cruelty to industrial animal farming. Even though I have become mostly vegetarian, it is quite tempting to buy meat for the convenience and the fact that sometimes it is much cheaper than fresh vegetables (at least in the west). Human progress and social evolution has somehow come with greater compassion for fellow beings. Will our coming generations value compassion in itself and will that affect the way we eat/farm. Will an advanced alien visitor be shocked by our animal farming or will will they hunt us down for meat. I guess we should expect either based on our own behaviour.
- sfj 7y agoI find the assumptions embedded in this argument very strange. It brings up a huge number of questions. Only a conscious being would feel pain, so what is consciousness? Does it come down and embed itself into creatures that are born? If so, if they weren't born, would that be necessarily better? What if consciousness, if it didn't have a body to enter into, appeared in a different universe from ours with its own, possibly worse, sufferings? Wouldn't it be better to give the animal a full, relatively pain free life than the possibility that it would suffer greater in some other universe in some other dimension? Or does consciousness originate on the spot, somehow born along with the creature? In that case it would be better to not be born at all? Or would it be better to have more consciousness in the universe, despite the suffering an individual might experience, rather than otherwise? Is consciousness a good in itself? Would a universe devoid of all conscious beings be the perfect good, lonely, desolate, without meaning. Or one full of them, with shared misery to go around? All in all, it's seems quite a murky topic to be throwing around judgement on people about.
- zhte415 7y agoI'd say set them free. But given the breeding of commercial chickens they'd simply not survive in the wild - not stop growing and after just days be unable to move, and easy prey. If you're fortunate enough to have land, use it, even a balcony or window sill can be put to good use. There are plenty of guides on YouTube, and for a window sill no need to spend money on herbs again. For food or for leisure (or both) - if you like flowers grow some flowers! And don't throw away potato skins, carrot tops, strings of beans, etc. Compost them, it really enriches the soil.
- enneff 7y agoReleasing them would be dooming them to a horrible death. They'd end up ripped apart by wild animals or otherwise injured and live in pain until they die.
- Viliam1234 7y ago> live in pain until they die. The ethically important part is that those would be different flavors of pain than the ones they would have experienced in factory farming normally.
- koheripbal 7y ago> They'd end up ripped apart by wild animals ...so exactly like the fate of literally every other wild animal on Earth.
- enneff 7y agoNot really. Wild animals mostly live in the environment they are adapted to. Most birds survive just fine out in the world. Chickens are not adapted to anything, but rather selected by us, and they certainly weren’t selected for toughness.
- zhte415 7y agoCertainly, it would. I raise chickens, but less than twenty, and mine are actual chickens that live for a while not factory ones. Decently sized coops, going for a walk once a day for a few hours (I suppose happy, they seem happy) and are quite good at seeing off the odd predator when they're out and about. You're correct, I put them in their chicken-wire yard at night for good reason. A neighbour has geese. Geese get freaked out very easily. If a stray dog comes by at 3am the entire street knows about it. I'm not from the farm. Interesting thing to learn is to let an egg rest a couple of days, no washing no refrigeration of course. Surprised me, wonderful variation in taste.
- ra 7y agoCan we not just put them in a field for a while?
- kwhitefoot 7y agoAll I got from that was: Sorry, this content is not available in your region.
- hkai 7y agoWhile people in developing countries will be suffering shortly because of lack of protein and malnutrition, I'm sure many in the West will celebrate this as a great step towards veganism.
- notechback 7y agoI doubt any vegans will celebrate unnecessary slaughter of 2M chickens. And animal protein consumes a lot of plant protein to make. If you want to feed people it's much more efficient to send over the soj and grain the chickens are fed, rather than the chicken meat.
- pcdoodle 7y agoWe need to lift this shelter in place order and hold these assholes accountable.
- Scapeghost 7y agoThis is just wrong. Anyone who justifies in any way this is evil. With practices like this, and other less murderous but still extremely wasteful shit like airlines burning thousands of gallons of fuel to keep their "slots" (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22511488 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22511488), I for one won't even mind if something decimates our so-called civilization.
- codeulike 7y agohttps://www.quora.com/How-many-chickens-are-killed-everyday https://www.quora.com/How-many-chickens-are-killed-everyday The U.S. consumes 9 billion chickens per year, so that’s 24 million chickens killed per day for food. So this article (about the 2m chickens) is about 9% of one days worth of chicken death in the usa, just for reference. (I agree with your point, industrialised meat production is nighmarish)