11 ms·
AMD reckons it can win the high-end GPU battle
- Iwan-Zotow 7y agoTheir software things (drivers, compilers, apis) are laughable.
- shaklee3 7y agoI would add libraries to that list (cuda equivalent).
- pixelpoet 7y agoOpenCL is all you need, and for the sake of a healthy (read: non-monopoly) GPU computing ecosystem you must insist on good OpenCL support! Having an additional CUDA backend is fine if you want, but AMD GPUs are often really strong in a level playing field, which is exactly what you want as a consumer. Basically no consumer ever benefitted from a monopoly, and GPU computing is very important. I've developed (as lead GPU dev in a 3-man team) two successful rendering applications with OpenCL on all 3 desktop platforms, it's not some kind of impossible task. More developers just have to stick their necks out and do it.
- shaklee3 7y agoIt's not, though. The blas and fft libraries are not only much slower (less efficient for the claimed peak of the cards), but they're missing features. For example, gemms don't work on complex half precision in any opencl library I've seen. Batched modes are missing for some types, etc. For basic operations, they're sufficient. But it's hard to get behind libraries that AMD doesn't really control. The ship has sailed on opencl for Nvidia. It's not going to happen, and it's not worth holding out hope. At this point, cuda has improved at a much faster rate, and the support is much higher. It's just not worth building a new scientific computing product around opencl, since it's as portable as cuda at this point if Nvidia doesn't support it.
- pixelpoet 7y agoIn principle there's nothing stopping people from developing similarly great libraries for OpenCL, which I would on the one hand expect to happen eventually, but on the other hand it's impossible to deny the existing achievements of Nvidia's software team. What I'm hoping is that people in a similar position to mine, where I could easily choose OpenCL since I was coding everything from scratch in basically C, choose OpenCL instead of CUDA. It's completely possible in many cases, and I'm not the world's greatest developer or anything; twice I chose OpenCL over CUDA and both turned out great. Particularly the JIT model is very useful. Judge for yourself: https://indigorenderer.com https://indigorenderer.com https://chaoticafractals.com https://chaoticafractals.com It's also very useful for cross-vendor GPU benchmarking, see https://www.indigorenderer.com/benchmark-results?filter=singlegpu https://www.indigorenderer.com/benchmark-results?filter=sing...
- pjmlp 7y agoOpenCL was never that portable to mobile devices anyway, even though they are at the other end of the high-end GPU spectrum. iOS never went beyond OpenCL 1.0, and eventually Apple moved into Metal. Android never supported OpenCL, as Google preferred to push their C99 based dialect, Renderscript.
- slavik81 7y agoThey've been hiring developers to work on ROCm, so it seems they're investing in improving that situation.
- fortran77 7y agoAgreed! I posted this link here because I thought it was laughable, too. We do GPGPU programming (signal processing) and there's really no choice but Nvidia. I'd love there to be some competition, but AMDs developer tools and support are nothing compared to Nvidia. Plus Nvidia architecture is more "general purpose" than AMDs is for general computation
- shmerl 7y agoI'd appreciate RDNA2 card for 2560x1440 too that's not crazily priced. Less power consumption and more performance would be useful.
- AmVess 7y agoThey aren't going to win anything until they fix their laughably bad drivers and keep them fixed. I have several Ryzens, but there's no way I'd go anywhere near their graphics cards.
- jdc 7y agoI'm running an RX 570 on Linux and it works fine for my purposes (work, Steam games & Blizzard games under wine).
- chao- 7y agoSame with a 580. Linux, many monitors, work, light gaming. Drivers are the first time I've ever not had issues with Linux graphics. Three years in I'm still waiting for the other shoe to drop. Where are the driver issues? I'm certain it was like a law of physics in Linux, but somehow, not this time, not for me?
- omegabravo 7y agoI have 2x 24" monitors on Ubuntu 18.04.03 with a Radeon RX 580 I can't watch a video on Youtube without substantial tearing on Firefox or Chrome. I've followed close to 20 guides and tried a number of drivers which all fail provide any benefit. Running glxgears will run at 7400FPS, with minor tearing. My monitors don't have FreeSync or whatever it's called since they're pretty old (over 10 years). Since most guides are as helpful as "type this into a console" - I haven't learnt anything while trying these fixes. edit: I tried to install the newest drivers (19.50), and they fail to install with build errors since I had to uninstall the old ones (19.20) I'm now running Polaris10? drivers by accident, and the tearing issue seems to have disappeared. I have no idea if these are less performant, but they are sufficient for my needs.
- atq2119 7y agoTearing issues tend to be problems of the application, compositor, or Xorg. Nothing the driver can do much about, unfortunately. Xorg in particular is pretty bad at tearing with multi-monitor setups.
- willis936 7y agoI’ll believe it when I see it. ATI has never made a good product and nothing has changed recently to turn them around.
- Damogran6 7y agoWhich would be lovely. High End GPU movement and pricing has been depressingly stagnant.
- bitL 7y agoLatest Ampere datacenter rumors are 70% speedup compared to V100, meaning 25TFlops in FP32, whereas AMD in theory could to 15Tflops and in practice only 8Tflops due to their software. They would have to improve speed 3x just to match NVidia's next generation GPUs; I am not sure upcoming Big Navi would be sufficient.
- trynumber9 7y agoIt's not comparable in efficiency but AMD is already shipping Vega II modules in the Mac Pro that claim "up to 28.3 FP32 TFLOPS". And regardless, the article is about 4K gaming. I don't doubt Nvidia will have some 7nm monster but there might be a time period before it launches where AMD briefly regains the crown.
- shaklee3 7y agoThat's not equivalent. That's a card with two ASICs on it, with each being 14TFLOPS. It's identical to the V100, but 2-3 years later.
- trynumber9 7y agoNvidia doesn't make any cards with two ASICs on it. There is no equivalent.
- PedroBatista 7y agoIt needs the help from Nvidia just like Intel helped them winning the CPU battle.
- unnouinceput 7y agoAnd when that day comes, I will buy it. But for now I will go with nVidia. Also I badly need same CUDA codebase/documentation on AMD part as well to make such a move. ML is such a breeze when you throw CUDA at it these days.
- joe_the_user 7y agoI am stiiiill mostly reading/researching but I'm pretty sure that CUDA is crucial and OpenCL just won't cut it for ML. That said, AMD had a CUDA clone/conversion system a while back. I'm not sure where that's gone. The ideal would be to leapfrog CUDA and present something more usable and straightforward, especially something where the memory and threading model is really clear. CUDA already seem pretty good but there's always room for improvement.
- melbourne_mat 7y agoAMD has something called HIP which is a portable version of CUDA (compiles to either nvidia or amd hardware). They made a tool called HIPPIFY which can auto translate CUDA source to HIP. Haven't used it myself so I can't comment on it's effectiveness.
- pixelpoet 7y agoAMD's rather old Radeon VII can really smash a 2080 Ti if you're doing relatively simple streaming computation, like say video processing. That 1TB/s HBM is no joke, and there's 16GB of it, at ~half the price of the 2080 Ti with 11GB. Nvidia's memory compression is very impressive and allows them to do better with a narrower memory bus in many situations (such as games), however if your data is not so compressible (often the case in GPGPU) this advantage disappears. Really all I care about is a good OpenCL driver implementation, especially OpenCL 2.2 support would be extremely attractive.
- llukas 7y agoDid you manage to achieve 1TB/s? https://www.sisoftware.co.uk/2019/08/01/amd-vega2-gpgpu/ https://www.sisoftware.co.uk/2019/08/01/amd-vega2-gpgpu/ BW test over there shows 627GB/s of actual BW.
- kiddico 7y agoNot saying that it can hit 1TB/s, but I wouldn't put too much trust in one benchmark. I got 704 GB/s on my machine[1] using their test. [1] https://imgur.com/a/tq3nEz5 https://imgur.com/a/tq3nEz5
- danieldk 7y agoAMD's rather old Radeon VII can really smash a 2080 Ti if you're doing relatively simple streaming computation, like say video processing. That 1TB/s HBM is no joke, and there's 16GB of it, at ~half the price of the 2080 Ti with 11GB. The Radeon VII is also pretty fast in training transformer networks. In some models that I trained, it was only ~25% slower than our Quadro RTX 5000s.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- spicyramen 7y agoI'm working in ML with NVIDIA, T4, v100, P100 GPUs, taking advantage of the integration with TensorFlow, specifically mixed precision, TensorCores and TensorRT, would like to see those levels of integration with AMD to start considering in our Infrastructure
- jamesblonde 7y agoThe big problem right now is that ROCm, AMD's equivalent to Cuda for deep learning, is not supported for the consumer Radeon Navi cards. I had hoped it would be supported in ROCm 3.0 when that was released - but there has been no official word, which is worrying. If AMD are to compete in the GPU/DeepLearning space, it will be because they have hardware that is competitive (not even as good as Nvidia), low cost, and doesn't have the same EULA licensing restrictions as Nvidia. Could you imagine taking your TensorFlow program on AWS and just running the same code on a AMD GPU, but costing 25% of a V100 (with 80% of the performance)? That is where they should be. And the "run unchanged TensorFlow program" is not actually a problem - ROCm has been upstreamed into TensorFlow. It is support for their own Navi GPUs that is the software problem right now!
- atq2119 7y agoI agree that the lack of (official) Navi support is just bad strategy on AMD's part, but I disagree with your numbers. Their goal needs to be performance parity or dominance, and then perhaps offer a slight discount. That's how they're succeeding with Zen on CPUs. Offering the kind of steep discount you write about is just bad business.
- jamesblonde 7y agoAt the high-end (V100), Nvidia are price gouging, so there is room for a profitable strategy here where AMD significantly undercut Nvidia. My reasoning comes from my belief that AMD will not reach performance parity in the next generation - for deep learning, at least. If the new Arcturus GPU is competitive with Nvidia's new Ampere chip, that would be great. But they won't sell if they are not significantly cheaper. But they won't be significantly cheaper (Arcturus will be the "Enterprise" GPU). However, Big Navi will be much cheaper and can be used in a data center for deep learning without the legal problems that using a 3080Ti would have. I see this as the same "war" between Enterprise hard-disks from 10-15 years ago. Google came out and built their infrastructure on cheap commodity disks. But Dell, HPE and other vendors would not let you use them - they said they were inferior, etc. Commodity GPUs could "democratize" deep learning - ordinary servers could just include a couple of GPUs as a cheap add-on.
- nyjah 7y agoAMD cards also work with hackintosh builds. Some of the cards work seamlessly, others take minor config, but much better than the nVidia support these days.
- amerine 7y agoAny recent hackintosh build guide recommendations?
- Kliment 7y agoNot used it, but this was posted on HN a few days ago https://infinitediaries.net/my-2020-hackintosh-hardware-spec/ https://infinitediaries.net/my-2020-hackintosh-hardware-spec...
- code_biologist 7y agoI recently built an AMD hackintosh and although I love it — this build guide is exactly what I'd do if I did it again.
- aspenmayer 7y agoClover guide https://midi1996.github.io/hackintosh-internet-install-gitbook/ https://midi1996.github.io/hackintosh-internet-install-gitbo... r/hackintosh guide https://hackintosh.gitbook.io/-r-hackintosh-vanilla-desktop-guide/ https://hackintosh.gitbook.io/-r-hackintosh-vanilla-desktop-... OpenCore (most recent) https://khronokernel-2.gitbook.io/opencore-vanilla-desktop-guide/ https://khronokernel-2.gitbook.io/opencore-vanilla-desktop-g...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- WWLink 7y agoThey do, but it's hard to get a replacement for my 1070ti. :( The rx580s are reasonably priced and have a good rep for being reliable! But compared to a 1070ti they are less capable. A vega 56/64 would be perfect, but they're hard to find new now. The 5700xts seem to be a disaster.
- tyingq 7y agoAs an outsider, it's encouraging that the debate seems mixed. That seems to point to the idea that real competition is afoot. A year or so ago, the discussion seemed much more clear that AMD wasn't in the game at all.
- fxtentacle 7y agoAMD is blocked by being not versatile enough. Their consumer cards support neither AI nor do they have good Linux drivers. Of course, the average gamer doesn't care, but developers do. And as the result, almost all the video games - their core sales driver - are not as thoroughly optimized and tested on AMD as they are on the (likely overpriced) NVIDIA cards that developers use in their own home rigs.
- _bxg1 7y agoI don't think there's much overlap between AI developers/Linux users and game developers. Of course the former market matters too, but I really doubt it has an effect on the gaming market.
- fxtentacle 7y agoSince some studios use Linux data processing pipelines or dabble with deep learning for procedural content generation, I don't see how they could buy anything except for NVIDIA for their staff at the moment.
- imtringued 7y agoI chose an AMD card specifically because of their great Linux drivers. Building a system on top of proprietary drivers is a non starter for me. Being heavily dependent on a vendor to support your platform has bitten me multiple times and it's especially frustrating when a proprietary software company uses something like electron but never ships a Linux release. Running these applications in wine is a complete pain in the ass and doesn't even work 90% of the time.
- new_realist 7y agoI’ve found amdgpu to be a terrible driver for high end displays; 8K doesn’t work, for example.
- t4h4 7y agoFYI, 8K/4K120 support was fixed with Linux 5.5 release.
- _bxg1 7y agoAMD cards don't yet have any raytracing support, right? I know it's a young technology, but they shouldn't be dragging their feet on it if they want to make a serious push for the top.
- pixelpoet 7y agoPlease see my comments at the bottom (lol) about implementing a commercial GPU renderer from scratch with OpenCL (i.e. Nvidia, AMD and Intel, on Win Mac and Linux). It's definitely possible to do it yourself in many cases, and while Nvidia have their amazing RTX technology now, for the sake of not having a GPU computing monopoly it's important to push for open standards support. There is DXR supporting multiple vendors, which is sort of one step forwards and two steps back (Windows-only)...
- alkonaut 7y agoI’d like a card that is a 2080 but instead used all the extra transistors compared to a 1080 for traditional rendering, not raytracing. Raytracing might be a thing in the future but now it’s just a gimmick that uses silicon that could have churned out more frames instead.
- QuixoticQuibit 7y agoThe RT hardware takes up a small fraction of die area based on some articles I read a year ago. Furthermore, RT isn’t a gimmick: it’s literally the holy grail of graphics. Ask yourself why AMD, Intel, and consoles are all moving to it this year.
- alkonaut 7y agoIt is the holy grail, but in current games it’s mostly a high cost effect that offers very little. In many games you pay a huge fps penalty for something you basically need circled in screenshots to notice. I don’t doubt it will be fantastic once it’s actually usable in the sense that people will choose to enable it. I fear next gen consoles, like current top end PCs, will have settings where you choose 4K/60fps/raytracing and you can enable two of them, or possibly just one. In priority order, raytracing is a distant third of those. I think they are all moving to it because they know they need to get there eventually, and they need consumers to pay for it all the way.
- sebow 7y agoThe "problem" with AMD GPUs was always the lack of software 'compute' libraries, poorly optimized drivers, etc. AMD could really gain a huge advantage(both in enterprise and in more consumer spheres, like gaming/media production) by opening up the development of drivers and software libraries to the interested folk. So far they have done this (arguably) very well on Linux(by comparison to nvidia),yet the ecosystem of nvidia is still very big by comparison. While it's true nvidia has invested hugely in their development ecosystem, AMD could gain some territory by integrating their software compute libraries(like RocM) in programming languages like C/C++/Python and libraries like Tensorflow,pytorch,etc. could gain them a huge advantage in multiple industries.(I personally would argue this should be done firstly for their very successful and potent CPUs) OpenCL has been truly great and it still a go-to when you talk about massive heterogenous systems, but they should abuse the fact that gaming cards could accelerate similar compute workloads.
- m0zg 7y agoI don't know where they make their money, but if the hope is to compete in compute, I'd suggest that they do not "play the game" at all in GPUs and instead put together something 7nm and TPU-like. If I were them, I'd be working on that right now. 1TFLOPs/W would be a good goal, 100TFLOPs in 100W, using bfloat 16. Sidestep the GPU bullshit entirely, print money in a niche instead.
- bobajeff 7y agoI wouldn't consider TPU/NPU/NNPUs a niche. It's inevitable at this point that you'll need machine learning accelerators just for running inferencing on edge devices. Even if done only on the cloud I can see more could providers investing in their own TPU-like hardware for their clusters.
- dep_b 7y agoAs a MacBook user having equally performing GPU’s from AMD is really great. Though raytracing demo’s impress me, in-game it’s often not so impressive. So if AMD’s there in two years or so the software caught up at roughly the same time.
- hellofunk 7y ago> If the rumor mill is to be believed, AMD’s incoming high-end graphics card could be a monster board bristling with 80 CUs (compute units) I thought modern GPUs had hundreds of cores, or is a compute unit something different?
- imtringued 7y agoImagine you have a fleet of 64 buses each filled with 64 passengers. Does that count as 64 individual vehicles or as 4096?
- smcl 7y agoWell "vehicle" in this case is unambiguous - there's no confusion between a passenger and a vehicle in the scenario you described. For many there's not such a clear distinction between "cores" and "compute units" so I can see where the confusion arises.
- dragontamer 7y agoEach compute unit handles 2560 hardware threads (64 per clock tick per compute unit). AMDs GCN architecture runs 4 threads over 4 clock ticks natively. I forget if it was vertical SIMD or horizontal SIMD or whatever the proper terminology was. But this 4 threads over 4 clock ticks avoids the register stall issue. (RDNA performs 1 thread per clock tick and schedules around the stalls) The other threads come from an SMT-like / hyperthread-like feature, allowing 10 hardware threads per slot. All together, a compute unit supports 16 way SIMD per vALU x 4 vALUs per CU x 4 threads over 4 clock ticks x 10 'hyperthread-like' = 2560 hardware threads (over 4 clock ticks) 16 SIMD x 4 clock ticks gives your 64 sized wavefronts / warps that the programmer works with. The majority of the 'threads' are for latency hiding: work the GPU can do while waiting for RAM to respond. (In contrast to a CPU, which will search ~200 instructions out of order for work while waiting on RAM)
- parsimo2010 7y agoEven if everything the article says is true, and the AMD software environment was also improved to compete with Nvidia, it's probably still not enough to beat Nvidia. The best they are claiming with Big Navi is 30% faster than a 2080 Ti. Sounds great, but they are comparing a card that won't be available for a year with a card that has been on the market for over a year already. Nvidia will have been working on faster stuff, and the best case for AMD is that they force Nvidia to release their next generation of products faster than they originally planned. This isn't the same case as Intel which had been struggling with their 10nm process and security issues, which meant their current chips actually slowed down and they didn't have any new answers ready when AMD came out with Zen 2. We have seen that Nvidia has an answer for everything that AMD has done so far (price drops and Super variants to make the Nvidia cards remain the best choice at every level), and likely has an answer for their next few steps. I think the best that AMD can hope for is to achieve parity, they certainly won't be dethroning Nvidia.
- t0mas88 7y agoI agree, the author makes a vague point about the 3080 not being released yet, but AMD also hasn't released their new chip yet. What I think will be great for consumers is AMD releasing a good competing offer in a similar timeframe as Nvidia releasing their next generation. That may limit the Nvidia price increases, because over the past few generations they have gone up a lot for their top offering. And even a year after release they're still high. That can't stay like that if the next gen mid range AMD has higher performance.
- ngcc_hk 7y agoCuda and ... it is not just hardware.
- new_realist 7y agoAMD can’t even get 8K displays to work under Linux.
- naveen99 7y agoTempted to try out the Mac Pro with 2x2 Vega2 pros / PlaidML. At $10k, you get 132gb Of hbm2 memory, 4x of a Nvidia v100. PlaidML got acquired by intel, but looks like amd support is still included. I wonder if I can convince our hpc people to buy some Mac Pro racs
- IronBacon 7y agoNot an AMD fault, but I'm bummed that the only model of RX 5700 with ITX form factor is available exclusively in Japan, cause a I would love to assemble a full AMD 5 liters PC (without selling a kidney for importing the GPU...) T__T I guess mini ITX is a niche market.
- wruza 7y agoAnother issues with AMD are power, cooling and deadlines. Our local term for Vega 56/64 is electro-chargrill, which is not far from true. Those who bought them report that PSU and tower-cooling costs are above normal. AMD can do that again, blow dust in their eyes and roll out a card that could melt your ssd and sound like a jet turbine. Also they are known for “soon” marketing, so that you wait for a year, postponing games that you could play right now with a decent nvidia card. I think they have their own vision of high-end, while frametime enthusiasts still struggle with making ryzen chips to not stutter three times a second. Measures include carefully choosing a motherboard, a memory kit, finding right timings, right cooling curves, etc. And still stock ring-bused 8700 beats easily any infinity-glued cpu in 0.1% low by a margin. Streamers love ryzen though, as it allows to stream from additional cores and microstutters are irrelevant on youtube.