15 ms·
I'm probably saying the complete obvious, but Apple can completely crush Google if they execute this angle properly. Google has no choice but to support ads. T
by Waterluvian 7y ago
I'm probably saying the complete obvious, but Apple can completely crush Google if they execute this angle properly.
Google has no choice but to support ads. They're an ad company. Apple has to keep hammering how bad the ad and privacy experiences are with Android. Make iOS an absolute delight to use in contrast.
I'd pay a premium for that. Android has done a great job making me want an iOS device again, these last ten years.
- hyperbovine 7y agoOf course they have a choice: charge money for the services they provide. Revolutionary concept, I know.
- ojame 7y agoWhat services are you thinking of? They charge for all the enterprise level stuff, and Google Cloud etc; but consumer facing every-day use services? I can't see how charging for search would work, charging for Android, they already charge for handsets but it's easier for Apple because of a closed ecosystem, I doubt they could charge for Chrome, so I'm a bit confused.
- Spooky23 7y agoThey could charge for search gold edition with fewer ads and more sophisticated operators, or buy companies like LexisNexis or other subscription options. Ads are an incredible cash cow and an amazing business, but there are all sorts of other ways to monetize that business.
- ogre_codes 7y agoCharge for search? For maps? Gmail? How's that going to work when you get it for free from everyone else? The entire reason Google's products are as big/ successful as they are is because they are free. If they started charging for Gmail, the rush to the exits would be instant. If Google started charging for Android OEMs would switch to AOSP, China, Amazon, and Microsoft would ensure a supply of free Android versions. Apple is able to charge people for their services more-or-less up-front. Google has to wrangle fickle OEMs.
- Spooky23 7y agoNot at all, they just bundle them. I’m a Google One customer... I came for the drive, but I’m stuck because of the nearly 15 years of GMail and the pain it would take to clean up!
- samstave 7y ago“Free” you keep using that word. I do not think that word means what you think it means. Convenient is the more apropos word.
- viraptor 7y agoThis is a false dichotomy. It's not free-for-all vs paid-for-all. Google charges for their services as well. Gsuite is "paid Gmail" among other things. GCP gives you access to extra APIs which are "paid google maps". They can move that balance where needed without causing a mass exodus.
- fastball 7y agoYou're comparing B2C with B2B offerings. The same concepts do not apply to the two categories.
- hyperbovine 7y agoI can't get maps or gmail for free from somewhere else. Maps is far and away the best in class, and I've got close to two decades worth of lock-in on their mail platform. And we haven't even mentioned the elephant in the room which is search. I'd pay them a seriously nontrivial amount of money each year if they bundled those services into a single privacy-aware offering. Way more than they're making off me from the ads I block and ignore.
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoI have never owned an ios device in my life and strongly avoid them but this makes drift slightly over considering one. If apple allowed easily sideloading apps I would consider moving over.
- jzvxkxbxjx 7y ago“ If apple allowed easily sideloading apps I would consider moving over.” This was the reason I was an android guy until my wife told me to just get a phone that works. And you know what? Not letting you side load is a feature. When you see it like that, you care a lot less about your phone, and just appreciate that it works and that you can trust it as your more intimate possessions .
- Polylactic_acid 7y agoWithout sideloading I can't use a 3rd party youtube app that has no ads, no tracking and allows downloads. I also can't use my pebble watch because the official app is unsupported and only community supported software exists. I also am restricted from some content that android users of the same app can view because apple prohibits adult content inside of apps. I see a phone as a tool to do what the user needs. Not the user doing what the phone will allow.
- nneonneo 7y agoI have a little "share" button on my iPhone that invokes Youtube-DL via Pythonista, so I can open any Youtube video and get a locally saved copy pretty much instantly. I can use VLC to stream YouTube videos without ads. There's a bunch of apps that let you load pretty much arbitrary code onto the platform - Pythonista and Scriptable are two of the top ones (Python and JS interpreters respectively), and with those you can do quite a lot. It's not the same experience - that I'll grant you - but if you're moderately a power user iOS gives you enough to work with.
- assadk 7y agoThat’s really smart! Could you share your script (as a Gist or something) I’d really like to use it.
- true_religion 7y agoNot really, dropping private data from the ad industry might make certain ads perform worse, but it will also remove information on why. In the end the ad dollars will still be spent, and Google and others will profit. The only potential harm to Google is that if advertisers go back to choosing publishers based on reputation alone, the need for Google as a middleman to lots of third parties is reduced so they will only earn the big bucks from their own properties.
- KaoruAoiShiho 7y agoI don't get it, where do you see ads in android? If anything I use android for the ad-less experience, youtube vanced etc.
- anarchodev 7y agoThis article is about a notification that appears on iOS devices letting you know when an app has been using your location information in the background. I haven't used Android in a while but I assume it doesn't have this. These data are often sold to advertisers, data aggregation companies, shared with police, etc. So that's the issue, more than ads being directly embedded in the apps of the phone.
- okr 7y agoSince upgrade to Android 10 i get for each app, that asks for location in the background the option to disable it and allow location access only, when i use the app.
- ncallaway 7y ago> I haven't used Android in a while but I assume it doesn't have this. I've started getting these notifications on my Android device. Each app that makes a location request in the background causes a notification that allows me to take away location access from the app, only allow location access when the app is in the foreground, or always allow location access.
- JoBrad 7y agoThis notification is slightly different: you still get a notification when an app asks for permission. But later on you get a notification telling you that the app has been using a given feature x times, and you have the choice of changing the permission again. For location, it also shows a map of each location gathered by the app.
- lostsock 7y ago
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoThere's probably more money to be made in Apple themselves becoming the middle man for location data, rather than charging a very small number of people who care a premium to prevent sale of said data. From an ethical standpoint, I see where you're coming from, but from a business acumen perspective, I can't see it being more profitable.
- Enginerrrd 7y agoI disagree. Treating customers badly is not a good long term business strategy. You can get away with it when customers don't know what you're doing, and you can absolutely get away with it by trading reputation for money for a long time when you have major market penetration or pseudo-monopoly, but eventually the public sours on the relationship. This trend has been seen in major retail stores. (Sears comes to mind as a good example) Compare and contrast to costco which works relentlessly to get their customers better deals, even at their own expense. They've seen massive growth where a ton of other retailers that focused on driving margins as high as they could get them (where costco literally hard caps margins internally) have seen major losses and then proceeded to blame those losses on online retailers. You can only abuse your customer for as long as you have a monopoly. For a closer analogy, look at how fit bit numbers dropped when google announced they were buying Fitbit. (https://www.cnbc.com/2019/11/17/people-getting-rid-of-fitbits-after-google.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/11/17/people-getting-rid-of-fitbit...)
- JMTQp8lwXL 7y agoWhat other privacy-minded phone are people going to run to, if Apple sells out? Google? Apple could absolutely be playing the long con here. Much like Google did with Chrome, allowing uBlock as a browser extension for nearly a decade. If Apple does struggle to grow profitability through services, or can't find it's next "iPhone", I would expect to see profits grow from some potentially unsavory options. They wouldn't be Apple's first option, for sure, but in a world where Apple's business plateaus, privacy is on the chopping block.
- surround 7y agoThere’s two things about iOS that bothers me, privacy wise: - Apple still makes money off of ads, creating a conflict of interest. By default, users have a unique tracking/advertising ID attached to their phone. - iOS is extremely restrictive, making certain privacy adjustments impossible.
- madeofpalk 7y ago> By default, users have a unique tracking/advertising ID attached to their phone. My understanding is that this tracking ID was a replacement for apps being able to obtain the devices serial number. The tracking ID is unique per developer (edit: not true, it is unique per device, so multiple devs can build a profile on you) and can be reset by the user at any time.
- KMnO4 7y agoI don’t believe the IDFA is unique per developer (assuming I’m understanding you correctly). I use analytics in my company’s app and I get my team to send me their IDFA by downloading a free app from the App Store. The IDFA in my analytics is the same IDFA in the 3rd party app.
- VintageCool 7y agoThere is an IDFA (ID for Advertisers) and an IDFV (ID for Vendors). The IDFV is unique per developer; the IDFA is unique per device. The device user can reset their IDFA at any time, and if the user disables ad tracking then the device returns 00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000000.
- banachtarski 7y agoYes but in practice, users never do, and when they do a reset, fingerprinting employed by most (all?) ad exchanges can make the association without issue.
- judge2020 7y ago
- otachack 7y agoSure, but Google/Android has added fine grain GPS permissions in Android 10+ so we have the option to say "just track when using app" instead of "no" or "all the time". The problem, now, is rolling it out due to fragmentation.
- jadbox 7y agoNot only do I like having the ability to limit GPS per app, but I can also disable background data and enforce 'energy saver mode' (aka make background tasks infrequent) on an individual app basis.
- chewz 7y agoWe can also easily mock GPS on Android and there are apps for that.
- nomel 7y agoGreat, you've covered 0.1% of the Android user base.
- jayd16 7y agoAre we talking about things we like, use and do, or are we in a pissing contest about who's team is winning?
- lorenzhs 7y agoWe're talking about privacy protections for all users, not just HN users. The change in iOS 13 doesn't allow you to do anything that wasn't possible before, the settings have existed for years. It "just" periodically asks if you really want to let that app access your location in the background all the time, showing you a map where it did so in the last few days. And according to the article, people are saying "no" a lot. Users will disallow tracking if prompted. The average user won't go out of their way to spoof location data, though.
- killface 7y agoUntil I can get a browser adblocker on a non-rooted, non-unlocked iphone, it's not a switch worth making. firefox mobile + ublock origin is the only way I find the mobile web tolerable.
- eulevik 7y agoHandblock on the App Store does a good job. Not as good as UBlock Origin, but pretty good.
- htfu 7y agoContent blocker extensions have been a thing on iOS for half a decade. Prior to that I'd just use a browser like iCab with built-in support for exactly the same type of filtering lists. So it's always been both possible and trivial.
- in3d 7y agoAnd Google can show a screen after each search encouraging people to contact Apple if they want it removed. Will you switch to Bing? They can do the same thing. Other websites can also bother iPhone users worse than ads do or make visitors pay for access on iOS but not on Android. Apple does not run the Internet.
- hamandcheese 7y agoiOS has roughly 50% market share in the US. Most rational companies are unwilling to alienate half of their users (and the more lucrative half at that).
- in3d 7y agoWhy "alienate"? Apple bothers me with their iCloud when I'm doing a bunch of unrelated things all the time but I'm not alienated. Google could show a sensible explanation (true or not) about how Apple's changes will cause their search quality to decline and could get users on their side. If Google went nuclear as an answer to losing 99% of their revenue from iPhones/iPads/macbooks and blocked their users completely, I would personally switch to Android right away. Google's search results and maps are much more important to me than a polished UI and a high-end screen.
- wnevets 7y ago"Google is terrible, also Google is our default search engine on safari" - Apple
- aabhay 7y agoGoogle pays very dearly for that, btw
- JohnTHaller 7y agoWhich is another way of saying Apple values money over users being protected from something terrible.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoThen again, I don't think defaulting to an inferior product is an obvious upside for the average user. I reckon the average user is more interested in a more robust search function when they're actually trying to get things done.
- lilyball 7y agoI think Apple values the user perception that Google is the best search engine. Note how they used Bing for Siri and Spotlight search (and they've been largely, if not entirely, replacing that with Siri Knowledge instead).
- ksec 7y agoNot only that, Google paid roughly $10/ user per year to Apple just to remain the default search engine on all Apple OS. That is roughly $10B per year into their Services revenue. All while Apple actively disarming tracking and Googles's revenue.
- JohnTHaller 7y agoWhen an Android app wants my location, I get prompted to Deny, Allow while using the app, or Always Allow.
- lorenzhs 7y agoWith iOS 13, Apple removed the "Always Allow" option from that prompt. If you really want to always allow location access, you'll have to go to the system settings and enable it. You'll also get the "App XYZ has used your location in the background 123 times in the last three days, do you want to continue allowing this?" prompt along with a map of where the app requested your location. According to the article, that really works.
- Nextgrid 7y agoMy concern is that they could let the opportunity pass if they keep being sloppy with the quality of their software. The quality & user experience of both macOS and iOS have been going downhill for years. The music app is a complete shit-show for example and is a significant downgrade from its former self a decade ago. The same can be said for many built-in apps and parts of the OS.
- NicoJuicy 7y agoI think you are generalizing your own perspective. Facts: 87% Android and 13% iOS
- Phylter 7y agoI'm an iOS user that moved from Android. I'll never go back to Android as my phone OS. With that said, Android has a lot to offer that makes it worthwhile. It just depends on what you're looking for. Thought the number of people that are privacy aware is growing it's still not what people care about most in an OS.
- agra 7y agoThe major carriers sell real time location data, and have repeatedly lied about ending the practice. Sandboxing apps can't solve that problem, only democracy can. https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/qvqgnd/sprint-stop-selling-location-data-tmobile-att-microbilt-zumigo https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/qvqgnd/sprint-stop-sellin... https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/nepxbz/i-gave-a-bounty-hunter-300-dollars-located-phone-MicroBilt-zumigo-tmobile https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/nepxbz/i-gave-a-bounty-hu...
- jeffparsons 7y agoFor some reason I still strongly prefer the look and feel of Android over iOS, but at this point my next phone will be an iPhone. Why? Because Google recently stepped up its notification spam in their official apps. They're using a mechanism that's supposed to exist to notify me of things _I_ want/need to know about urgently instead to advertise products and services to me that I have no interest in. It's tedious to track down all the places these are coming from and disable them. And I shouldn't have to. I paid a premium for a high-end flagship Google phone. As a phone user, I have to give the vendor power to do all kinds of things on my behalf and to me — in this case, the power to pull my focus, or even wake me up in the middle of the night. As a phone user, my bare minimum expectation is that this power will be respected. And yet Google has chosen to use this focus-pulling notification mechanism to serve me ads. Google does not respect even their paying users. It feels like somewhere deep in their corporate culture, their users barely even exist to them. I'm just a sub-pixel blip on a request rate dashboard, and if they can temporarily increase my "engagement" by slapping me in the face, then a slap in the face it is.
- aiiane 7y agoI'm not a fan of overdone notifications either. If it helps in the short term, long-pressing on a notification should give you easy access to the ability to disable it.
- remus 7y agoI think it was android 9 that added the ability to do this. Swipe the notification > settings wheel > disable notifications for that app (or you can just disable specific types of notifications if there's still things you want to see). It got easier again with android 10 with the options available directly from the notification itself (after a swipe).
- Mo3 7y agoI've recently switched from Android to iOS after a long time praising Android as the holy grail, for the exact same reasons mentioned by you and in this thread. It is an absolute delight to use and I couldn't be happier.
- jokowueu 7y agoWould a phone wide adblocker like blockada be more to your liking ?
- skc 7y agoThe thing that makes me chuckle gleefully when Apple does things like this is that I know that the people that make up Google as a company are massive fans of Apple products. Ouch.
- tiborsaas 7y ago> I'd pay a premium for that. You already are if you buy Apple products :)
- underwater 7y agoGoogle is an ad and data company, so they can't help but push ads and watch what you do. But on the flip side Apple is addicted to building their ecosystem. They will happily cripple the functionality of their devices to force you to buy their MacBook, AirPods, HomePod, Apple Watch, Apple TV, etc. I personally prefer companies who sell solid hardware and focus on their niche.
- leadingthenet 7y ago> Apple is addicted to building their ecosystem Which, on the flip side, is fantastic if you buy into their ecosystem.
- akudha 7y agoAgree. I don't like both companies and wish there were other options in the mobile space. But Apple definitely seems like a less shitty choice of the two
- prox 7y agoThere are other options. My next phone will either be a Librem 5 or a zerophone.
- lazyjones 7y agoGoogle could offer an identical feature while selling location data (transmitted by the OS) to customers themselves.
- 2wrist 7y agoAn interesting one, on a tangent, this morning on my work windows10 machine I had a Chrome notification telling me about the latest plurasight deal. First time this has happened for me, it is an interesting use of the notification system!
- amiga_500 7y ago> Make iOS an absolute delight to use in contrast. I cannot select the middle of a word. The audio jack is held in by friction.
- distances 7y ago> I'd pay a premium for that. Android has done a great job making me want an iOS device again, these last ten years. You greatly overestimate people's will to pay extra. I know my own experiences are also biased, but nobody I know would pay for iPhone themselves. Either they use company iPhone, or buy themselves an Android phone. Apple has completely outpriced themselves from the majority of the market. Doesn't matter if it's $500 or $1000, I'd say the usual cap is somewhere around $300 in Europe and much less elsewhere.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m an iOS user but Apple will never be the dominant phone vendor. The average selling price of an Android phone is $248. The cheapest iPhone is $475. Apple doesn’t have the stomach to compete on price and the vast majority of consumers aren’t going to pay Apple prices. If people cared about privacy, the majority of them wouldn’t be on Facebook. They know that FB tracks them and advertises based on the data they collect.
- heedlessly3 7y agoiPhone's user interface is way more visually appealing. You can also get an iPhone 8 on ebay for $200. So you can get the best of both worlds of price & UI.
- wobbly_bush 7y agoPerhaps in US, but in the majority of regions where low end Android phones are popular even used iPhones are way more expensive.
- jorvi 7y ago> I'd pay a premium for that. Not everyone has the money to do that, and privacy should not become another privilege that is solely meant for people of means.