21 ms·
Hard Problems in Cryptocurrency: Five Years Later
- carty76ers 7y agoI usually hate the cryptocurrency articles that get posted here, but I do like this one — a decent overview of technical challenges & possible solutions
- broodbucket 7y agoIt's such a shame that useful proof-of-work is so impractical. The amount of cycles spent mining for the sake of mining is pretty depressing.
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoEthereum proof of stake is coming and should fix that elegantly.
- all_blue_chucks 7y agoI hear it's powered by cold fusion and Half Life 3.
- away_throw 7y ago50% since they announced a third Half Life game.
- rsynnott 7y agoI feel like that’s been coming any day now since about 2014. And seems like a TERRIBLE idea, anyway. The rich get richer, built right into the system!
- spir 7y agoPhase 0 of Ethereum v2 arrives in Q1 2020. Coming since 2014 but finally arriving :) Proof of stake reduces the issuance of new ETH to pay for the cost of securing the network. It's cheaper than paying miners. And anybody can buy ETH to stake so it's more egalitarian than mining which requires economies of scale in hardware and electricity.
- tfha 7y agoDoesn't phase 0 exclude the ability to transfer money? The whole point of a "currency"???
- nullc 7y agoMy understanding is that Phase 0 features the ability to lock up eth and take it out of circulation. You might consider if perhaps the parties in control of that system have a different idea of its point than you do.
- meirdavis 7y agoCorrect. Phase 0 isn't useful by itself and phase 1 isn't that useful either. Phase 2 is when people can actually start using ETH2 instead of ETH1.
- celticninja 7y agoPoS would be more egalitarian if it was that way from the start, however as it is transitioning from PoW this means that anyone that bought in early, now has an opportunity to solidify their position. For new entrants to reach the same level of investment would be significantly higher. So the ETH rich get richer and it widens the gap.
- jdnenej 7y agoPoW is exactly the same. The rich can afford the most hardware and electicity. PoS just short circuits the burning power step. It's also the same as bank interest.
- rsynnott 7y agoWhen you put your money in a bank, it doesn’t just sit there. Deposits, while possibly not the most efficient way to do it, support useful economic activity. Proof of work is also terrible, obviously. Proof of stake seems like an awful thing to _aspire_ to, tho.
- Zamicol 7y agoThe minimum stake of 32 eth is probably going to require something like a laptop to run. Those with larger stakes are going to need to devote more computer resources to the network.
- gerikson 7y ago32 ETH is ~$4,800 at today's price of $151.07[1]. What's the expected "payout" for this stake? [1] CoinMarketCap used as source.
- DennisP 7y agoExpected payout depends on the total amount staked. With a large amount staked it's only a couple percent annually; with a small amount it's up to 18% annually. The idea is an equilibrium will be reached in the middle somewhere.
- gerikson 7y agoThat's an interesting formula.
- lawfulcactus 7y agoHow are participants prevented from simply splitting up their stakes?
- wyldfire 7y agoProof-of-stake has been in use in other non-Ethereum cryptocoins for a very long time [1] [2]. In Nano's case, there's no transaction fees paid to stakeholders (nor their delegated representatives). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peercoin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peercoin [2] https://en.bitcoinwiki.org/wiki/Nano https://en.bitcoinwiki.org/wiki/Nano
- _Kristijan_ 7y agoNano consensus mechanism is called Open Representative Voting (ORV). It has similar sides to proof-of-stake, but differs in important places. e.g. it is less a "stake" than a voting weight that the users themselves distribute to nodes of their choice (or their own). ORV's self-description at: https://docs.nano.org/glossary/#open-representative-voting-orv https://docs.nano.org/glossary/#open-representative-voting-o...
- wyldfire 7y ago> or their own Sure, it's an optionally-delegated-proof-of-stake. In practice, most do delegate their stake. But at the end of the day the "voting weight" that secures transactions is majority stake and not a proof of work.
- DennisP 7y agoThe rich get richer in proof of work, too. It's not like those giant mining rigs are free. It's also true in bank accounts; the more money deposited, the more interest you earn. At least in proof of stake everybody gets the same interest rate regardless of deposit size. Banks generally give better rates to larger accounts.
- qes 7y agoDecred set up it's mixed PoS/PoW so that there is an opportunity cost to staking - your funds are locked for a random amount of time up to several months. The staking rewards are also not enough to keep indefinitely staking. Your share of stake will continuously decrease, and, aside from ticket splitting, you would need to acquire more decred along the way to continue staking at the same level.
- hanniabu 7y agoEthereum wasn't launched until July 2015 so there's one inaccuracy. Also given you're on HN you should likely be aware that (a) timelines are difficult to estimate and often things take much longer than you thought, even more so with being the first to do something, (b) there's a lot of discussion and review for financial software, (c) it's much harder to change the carriage of a moving train
- ppf 7y ago(d) performing work on a moving train is a bug, not a feature.
- DarthGhandi 7y ago> is coming Yeah that was 5 years ago too if you don't remember. It's an incredibly difficult problem and anyone claiming to have actually solved it in a decentralised way that proof-of-work did is a charlatan. Given all the money slushing around in cryptocurrency looking for a problem to solve I'd argue it's an intractable issue that needs yet another breakthrough rather than marketing and bubble hype.
- jkhdigital 7y agoFrom 2015: http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/ http://www.truthcoin.info/blog/pow-cheapest/
- nootropicat 7y agoIncorrect. The supposed MR=MC law means that the entire economy is zero-sum and wealth creation is impossible. His reasoning also directly translates to real world physical security, as in, if you want to protect wealth worth $1000 from theft, according to him you have to spend $1000-epsilon, otherwise someone is going to outspend you and steal it. Fortunately, that's not how the world works. Visual illustration of the asymmetric security in action: https://www.pohjoiseen.fi/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/20839601684_2c10210f03_o-800x531.jpg https://www.pohjoiseen.fi/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/2083960...
- jotakami 7y agoFortunately, we get asymmetric security through laws and criminal punishment rather than machine gun bunkers. Also, MR=MC doesn’t imply that wealth is never created, it just means that it can’t be created purely through exchanging commodities.
- nootropicat 7y agoNothing special about commodity exchange. The difference between marginal revenue and marginal cost is marginal wealth creation (destruction if negative). A world in which MR=MC is in a global maximum and no improvement is possible - any state changes imposed externally can either lead to the same score ('wealth') or make it worse. In other words, he first assumes that no improvement is possible, and then indeed manages to show that, according to the assumptions, no improvement is possible.
- wyldfire 7y agoBesides proof-of-stake, there's also a coin that tries (tried?) a proof-of-work with greater public utility: Primecoin [1]. It creates Cunningham chains of prime numbers [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primecoin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primecoin [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cunningham_chain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cunningham_chain
- toastal 7y agoWasn't there also like CureCoin that unfolds proteins for medical application?
- haakon 7y agoYes, and there's also SolarCoin which rewards users for producing renewable energy. The problem is that these coins are centralised, so while they may be very useful for what they do, they don't solve the same problem as proof-of-work coins which aim to be decentralised.
- untoreh 7y agothere is also gridcoin but they are not useful pow. they are proof of stake where the stake is the amount of contribution towards boinc projects and the likes, and they are affected by the oracle problem
- swinglock 7y agoIs that useful for anything other than the Primecoin?
- tylersmith 7y ago"Useful PoW" is a dead end. Good PoW functions require properties that rule out real world useful problems.
- web007 7y agoI'm disappointed that PrimeCoin didn't really catch on. It's mathematically sound, relatively quantum safe, and produces useful output. Any improvements to factoring or finding prime chains would be genuine advances in the field, whether algorithm or hardware (ASIC) based.
- ganzuul 7y agoNeed to mention GridCoin because context. Uses BOINC for proof-of-work.
- nootropicat 7y agoWouldn't work, the security of PoW explicitly relies on waste. If the external value from mining is X and an attack costs Y, the net cost of the attack is X-Y=Z, so the real security is Z, the waste portion.
- koheripbal 7y agoNot necessarily waste, no. It just needs to be unpredictable. I think PrimeCoin was a great example of a PoW that had very small but non-zero value.
- sincerely 7y agoIn a space absolutely filled with hucksters and scam artists, vitalik is legit. Good read.
- snitko 7y agoVitalik and ETH are the definitions of scam and scammer. He's very good at obfuscating it by appearing very smart: read his articles and tweets, they always sound complex, but can be rewritten in much simpler terms. And ETH is the same: it obfuscates its uselessness and nonsense by being overly complex, every year employing new terms and coming up with tons of code that only increases the attack surface and complicates things even more.
- jkhdigital 7y ago> tons of code that only increases the attack surface Ethereum itself was the original sin in this respect. In Bitcoin, for the most part, the economic value at stake in a block is (1) the block reward, (2) the transaction fees, and (3) the amount transacted. (1) + (2) + (3) is therefore the maximum amount that can theoretically be "moved" if a block is invalidated through an adversarial fork, since someone else can claim the miner rewards and every transaction could possibly be double-spent. Anyone who wants to be assured of transaction immutability can, at the very least, calculate the total value that is at stake and wait until at least this much PoW has been layered on top of the transaction. Not so with smart contracts. A paper I read yesterday showed how smart contracts can be used to execute trustless, crowd-sourced DoS attacks on rival blockchains (https://eprint.iacr.org/2019/775.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2019/775.pdf). It's ridiculous. Once you open the Pandora's Box of smart contracts, you can throw your consensus guarantees out the window.
- lostmsu 7y ago> smart contracts can be used to execute trustless, crowd-sourced DoS attacks on rival blockchains And that's a good thing. We needed an established way to attack rival blockchains that use the same PoW mechanism. They are insecure by design of PoW, and until they are all torn down by attacks, unsuspecting people can loose a lot of money.
- hodder 7y agoThe biggest problem is actual uptake for real transactions, as opposed to speculation and black markets. The 2 biggest barriers to be solved are: -lack of trust/ease of use for the layman -volatility These problems may or may not sort themselves out with time.
- lalaland1125 7y agoThere is an even bigger problem: -a lack of reason to use cryptocurrencies when centralized alternatives perform much better for non-illegal usecases
- dorgo 7y agoCentralized alternatives work perfectly well until they fail (corruption, mismanagement, war, police state .. ). And when this happens there will be decentralized alternatives ready.
- donbindner 7y agoEven bigger than that is the treatment of dollar-denominated "value" of crypto as a capital gain. Tax adherence trumps volatility by far.
- wlesieutre 7y agoEven if I could use it for regular transactions, I’d still need a reason to want to. If the justification is “you don’t need to pay credit processing fees” then things would have to be priced cheaper. But I think you’d have to pay me more than the credit card fee to give up the ability to do chargebacks for a lot of online transactions. Maybe I’d use it for making donations where I’m not expecting anything back from a transaction that the other party could fail to deliver. They’re just not solving a problem that I have.
- matdehaast 7y agoCertain use cases are currently very difficult/too expensive on current payment rails (Card networks, ACH etc.). Whilst I am not bullish on using Crypto directly. I think a clearing layer that can be settled with crypto can create a very interesting space for real time value exchange. We are currently working in the space on Interledger.
- optimiz3 7y agoSome hubris in this post. Claims ASIC resistant PoW is "Solved as far as we can", with Ethash being the near end-all of hashing. Random-X is a significant step towards ASIC resistance, requiring near general purpose computation to perform efficiently (i.e. if you can build a better CPU than Intel/AMD/ARM, you've already won). https://github.com/tevador/RandomX/blob/master/doc/design.md https://github.com/tevador/RandomX/blob/master/doc/design.md (Random-X requires code JITting, large CPU caches, compliant floating point, SIMD, hardware AES, as well as large amounts of system RAM, and other things.) Innovation continues. If you stop having ideas, step aside.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoThis is what I really dislike about owning crypto long term as a store of value. It's a cat-and-mouse game with hardware and software development, and there's a lot of faith in maintainers to stay ahead of the threats.
- ses1984 7y ago>there's a lot of faith in maintainers to stay ahead of the threats. Isn't that true of basically all software?
- notahacker 7y agoNot all software purports to be a store of value
- ses1984 7y agoIt doesn't have to be a store of value to be critical to fortunes greater than bitcoin wallets, or even life and limb.
- hanniabu 7y agoBanking software and all the algorithms that power the global economy are vulnerable. Every 10 years or so there's a major crash because of dinne oversight and the result is "this will never happen again", yet it continues to happen again. At least here we can build an economy off an economic model instead of what we do now which is build an economic model off of the economy.
- jkhdigital 7y agoI literally spent the past week reading a couple dozen papers on cryptocurrency attacks, in service of a term paper which should hopefully turn into a master's thesis (and possibly more during my PhD campaign). I'm pretty damn pessimistic as a result. Smart contracts basically throw all of your consensus guarantees out the window because they can cause arbitrary exchanges of value in the application layer, which can be used to incentivize miners into all sorts of shenanigans. All of this research is producing a fascinating array of solutions in search of problems. Fun stuff to think about, but I suspect that the added complexity will only create a system that is just as prone to fraud and abuse as the existing centralized order.
- ddtaylor 7y ago> Smart contracts basically throw all of your consensus guarantees out the window because they can cause arbitrary exchanges of value in the application layer, which can be used to incentivize miners into all sorts of shenanigans. Do you have an example?
- jkhdigital 7y agoSo glad you asked: 1. https://eprint.iacr.org/2019/748.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2019/748.pdf 2. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.11605.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1810.11605.pdf 3. https://eprint.iacr.org/2019/775.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2019/775.pdf 4. https://users.encs.concordia.ca/~clark/papers/2019_wtsc_front.pdf https://users.encs.concordia.ca/~clark/papers/2019_wtsc_fron... 5. http://homepages.cs.ncl.ac.uk/patrick.mccorry/minerbribery.pdf http://homepages.cs.ncl.ac.uk/patrick.mccorry/minerbribery.p... This one isn't an attack per se, it is mostly an exploration of arbitrage bots in decentralized exchanges running on Ethereum smart contracts. However, they point out that miners can trivially capture the value of the arbitrage transactions by front-running, and that this "free money" is like a bonus block subsidy that falls outside of the PoW consensus models: 6. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.05234.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1904.05234.pdf This one actually operates through transaction fees only, so it doesn't depend on smart contract functionality. However, it is waaaaay more expensive (for the attacker) than the others: 7. https://www.cs.umd.edu/~jkatz/papers/whale-txs.pdf https://www.cs.umd.edu/~jkatz/papers/whale-txs.pdf
- snitko 7y agoWhether or not you're aligned with Bitcoin political values and goals, please don't be duped by Ethereum. It may appear as something useful, without the stigma of Bitcoin being black market money. However, you ONLY need black market money. Everything else that's ok with being regulated, does not need a blockchain. The hard problem that Bitcoin solved was "How do we create money that wouldn't collapse and lose value once outlawed". The proof-of-work solution cannot be replicated (for reasons I won't go into here, homework for you). And that's a good thing. Ethereum is a scam and has always been a scam from its inception. Multiple reasons for that: 1) Overly complex, obfuscating its lack of problem to solve by having lots of features and code 2) Constantly coming up with new terms and features and "new hot thing" to try and pump the price and keep the interest going. 3) No real world use case. Only promises and cryptokittes. 4) Literally controlled by one guy (see the now famous "Can you guys stop trading" quote). 5) Only produced scam ICOs with 99.99% of ICO projects practically stealing money from investors with no repercussions whatsoever. There are many more, but the thing to remember is - Bitcoin solves a real problem: it allows people to escape and bypass existing financial system and continue doing business, save and not be subject to policies outside of their control. It is black market money which governments hate and will try to outlaw in some way. That is the real pain Bitcoin solves for people: not agreeing to unjust laws peacefully and quietly exiting the system.
- seibelj 7y agoEthereum is a blockchain for general purpose computing. It’s not a scam, it delivered what it promised. MakerDAO, mentioned in the post, is a cool and useful project running on Ethereum. I agree with you about the core use case for Bitcoin currently being an escape from the government-forced financial system. It pierced the monopoly successfully. But the Ethereum screed is just lies at this point, Ethereum is one of the good ones.
- snitko 7y agoWhat has it delivered exactly? Where is it being used that's not itself a scam? MakerDAO - which seems to be some sort of token issuance thing - has no real world mechanism for enforcement. That is, if an autonomous decentralized organization issues a token, who's to make it pay you dividends or enforce your rights for whatever this token represents? This is the thing that ETH fanboys are completely delusional about. Securities only work because state regulators enforce the laws guaranteeing their value.
- Zamicol 7y ago"Cryptographic obfuscation" Wouldn't this be a subcategory of homomorphic encryption?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- busymom0 7y agoYour site's SSL cert has just expired at November 24, 2019 at 1:00:59 AM Eastern Standard Time Safari, Chrome give errors now.
- finchisko 7y agoHard problems in crypto... :) Auto cert renewal.
- dcsan 7y agois there a mirror somewhere? article seems interesting.
- input_sh 7y agohttp://archive.is/JTQSp http://archive.is/JTQSp
- fwxwi 7y agoState of browsers in 2019: asking your browser to bypass an SSL error is so hard that it's easier to ask for a mirror. btw, if you use Chrome and you see an SSL error, just type "thisisunsafe" and it will load the webpage. Try it here: https://expired.badssl.com/ https://expired.badssl.com/
- josu 7y agoIt is throwing an error for me too, but the certificate doesn't seem expired: >Issued by: Let's Encrypt Authority X3 >Expires: Thursday, 23January, 2020, 0:16:50 Central Standard Time
- beefield 7y agoFunny. Article discussing hard problems of crypto and ignoring the elephants in the room. There is still no actual and relevant use case for crypto outside illegal transactions and gambli^H^H^H^H^Hinvestment purposes. The second elephant is that it brings monetary policy back to medieval times. Third is that in practice the whole concept of credit and ots role in money creation is ignored.
- oraphalous 7y agoI'll just leave this here: https://www.wsj.com/articles/fed-adds-104-5-billion-to-financial-markets-11572355429 https://www.wsj.com/articles/fed-adds-104-5-billion-to-finan...
- platz 7y agoHow long ago did we almost have a hard fork? How long ago were the exchanges found to be manipulating prices fraudulently? As if crypto is immune to systemic issues. It's not a closed system after all, is it?
- newguy1234 7y agoOne legitimate use case for cryptocurrency is so you can transact with individuals who do not have bank accounts. Cryptocurrency allows anyone in the world to get a cryptocurrency "bank account" and that "bank account" allows the individual to transact freely in society. It is important for a free society.
- unityByFreedom 7y agoCash? Otherwise, for digital, who are we talking about, exactly? What country doesn't have banks? If you can't get a bank account it's unlikely your basic needs are going to be met by a stranger you've never met.
- lawn 7y agoThere are 1.7 billion adults in the world who are unbanked. 420 million of them have internet access. You can find them in countries all over the world. For example USA have 18 million and France have 3 million who don't have a bank account. It's not just poor people in countries without banks who have these problems. Even rich porn stars have had their bank accounts closed (for being porn stars) and people in the marijuana business too. Some more info here: https://whycryptocurrencies.com/for_the_unbanked.html https://whycryptocurrencies.com/for_the_unbanked.html
- elamje 7y agoCan some people from the crypto space give a quick tl;dr of what’s going on in the space that’s of note? Seems like I hardly hear about interesting stuff after the bubble burst (kind of at least). Are there any people using crypto to actually do work for clients and solve fiat currency based businesses problems? I am curious if the crypto start up space is mostly filled with crypto-to-crypto services or if there are many successful crypto-to-regular business cases. Edit: I’m interested in if there are many people making meaningful money from doing client work or building a business, mostly in the crypto space. There seems to be two camps: crypto idealists that don’t care about making money, and the crypto application people who might be a little idealist, but also want to make money here and now. This is more geared towards the latter.
- Heliosmaster 7y agoSecurity Tokens: https://coinsutra.com/security-tokens/ https://coinsutra.com/security-tokens/
- Geee 7y agoDecentralized finance (DeFi): https://defiprime.com https://defiprime.com
- spyder 7y agohttps://medium.com/@matteozago/50-examples-of-how-blockchains-are-taking-over-the-world-4276bf488a4b https://medium.com/@matteozago/50-examples-of-how-blockchain... https://www.ibm.com/blockchain/solutions https://www.ibm.com/blockchain/solutions
- Huycfhct 7y agoToken sale scams plus token sale scams. For references see above
- davidmurdoch 7y agoI build blockchain development tools at Truffle (a for-profit company). Most of our efforts are on Ethereum tooling, but not all, we are building some tools for enterprise blockchain tech as well as other public chains. I think most of us here believe we are building tools that will have had a role in the long-term future of (decentralized) finance. https://trufflesuite.com/ https://trufflesuite.com/
- Jd 7y agoThe original Hard Problems in Cryptocurrency was my favorite talk from Vitalik ever: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXRtJcNVfQE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXRtJcNVfQE
- cft 7y agofunny how his SSL certificate expired.
- troquerre 7y agoVitalik linked to our help article on Handshake's airdrop as an example of a proof of excellence alternative. It's ssl configuration was broken before but it's fixed now: https://help.namebase.io/article/4vchu01mec-handshake-airdrop-101 https://help.namebase.io/article/4vchu01mec-handshake-airdro...
- wildchild 7y agoHard problems of cryptocurrency is a scammers like Vitalik. He and financial criminals around him are big problems of crypto. Nasty to even read his bullshit since the day one he appeared in that space.
- regisg 7y agoIt's funny to write such a blog post without even mentioning Cardano...
- capableweb 7y agoIt's even more funny to leave a comment like this without even elaborating on the argument and not contributing to the overall discussion. Why would this blog post mention Cardano?
- flowless 7y agoBecause Cardano is what ETH might have been if done right. They did a tons of (actually scientific) research on the topics mentioned in this article but the author won't mention Cardano as it is his direct competition (even nicknamed Ethereum killer).
- exdsq 7y agoTo be fair, Vitalik didn't mention many research projects outside of Ethereum. I don't think he was intentionally ignoring Cardano, he just didn't need to reference them to make his points.
- capableweb 7y agoWhat does "actually scientific" and "real research" (mentioned by jki275) mean? I'm pretty sure most people doing research in the cryptocurrency space are trying to use the scientific method as much as they can.
- jki275 7y agoBecause IOHK is the only organization besides the Tezos foundation doing real research in the field of POS.
- regisg 7y agoYes, you're right. Sorry.
- Temasik 7y agohard problem in ethereum Only not on BitCoin SV node scales https://stn.satoshi.io/ https://stn.satoshi.io/
- Huycfhct 7y ago️ after year of this technology being around still this is the best article HN can upvote. Be a sceptic and a scientist
- arcticbull 7y agoNone of these are the actual hard problems in cryptocurrency and the fact this is the focus speaks volumes. The real hard problems are: 1. How do we stop using more power than Switzerland to process 4 transactions per second (lol) 2. How do we stop payments to international terrorists and rogue states. 3. How do we stop money laundering. 4. How do we stop price manipulation by fraudulent actors. 5. How do we allow people who lost access to their money by negligence, fraud, theft, act of god or otherwise, access to their money again. [bonus] how do we generate the right quantity of new cryptocurrency so that the pace of money growth matches that of economic and population growth so as not to disproportionately reward early comers just for “being early”? You know, the “currency” problems and not the “crypto” problems. These are the actual hard problems of cryptocurrency and until solved it will never, and I mean never, reach mass adoption, making the questions from the article totally irrelevant.
- ralfd 7y ago> How do we stop money laundering If that would be stopped, crypto would be pointless. We already have real (regulated) money. But with crypto you can online pay your drug dealer.
- arcticbull 7y agoFunny you can online pay your drug dealer in countries where drugs are legal, like pot in Canada. It’s almost like social solutions are the right way to solve social problems.
- mhluongo 7y agoYou don't think cryptocurrency is a social solution? To your implication- what's legal and what's right are orthogonal concerns. Individuals decide which to follow based on their own principles.
- arcticbull 7y agoNo, it’s a technological problem. The social solution is to make what you’re trying to do legal. And yeah you’re free to do whatever you want so long as you’re willing to pay the consequences such as fines and jail time.
- moralestapia 7y agoExpired SSL. Buterin's attention to detail is why I trust Ethereum so much.
- pron 7y agoAny progress on the problem of cryptocurrency being a vastly inferior solution to far easier ones, almost on every metric, in virtually every use-case?
- k5hp 7y agoThat moment when you click on the first paper referenced in the article, and the author is the professor of the lecture you currently should actually study for
- mindentropy 7y agoLol. What is the lecture you are studying for? Who is the author?
- k5hp 7y agohttps://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.10434.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1910.10434.pdf The author is Roger Wattenhofer. Currently taking his Computer Systems class at ETH.
- NoblePublius 7y agoTLDR: “ Great theoretical progress, pending more real-world evaluation, plz to buy more magic beans. “
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- onion-soup 7y agoOh shut up already with big block phobia. BSV proves that big blocks is the most rational way to scale. The small block mantra started by blockstream completely rotted the crypto space
- zhoujianfu 7y agoI agree, although I’d say BCH proved it first. :P
- onion-soup 7y agoBSV is a fork of BCH
- koheripbal 7y agoBig blocks will scale you one or two orders of magnitude. There are still 3-5 MORE orders of magnitude to go before you approach that of a standard Credit Card transaction processor.
- olivermarks 7y agoThe hardest problem of all is getting consensus to put in front of regulators whose legal frameworks are stuck in the early 90's. SEC Securities law is the 800 pound gorilla on the globe and the workarounds 'offshore' of the SEC (Malta EU framework etc) are pea shooters against this reality. I've been involved in a european utility token against a real asset (Beer) which is live but it has been very time consuming and difficult to navigate the regulatory maze.
- dnprock 7y agoI consider myself fairly knowledgable with cryptocurrency. I create and run a crypto project myself. I read this post and maybe understand 10% of it. This is probably the rate of things I read from Vitalik. Either Vitalik is extremely smart or he just doesn't know what he's talking about. Overall, his opinions are just confusing and distracting like the whole Ethereum ecosystem. A warning for those who think getting a degree is useless. At least, it will force you to think deep about some problems. I hope Vitalik will find his focus and really solve a concrete problem. For those who think I'm 10 times less smart than Vitalik. Here's my take on Ethereum and its prospect. https://bitflate.org/post/2019/11/16/ethereum-and-computer-language.html https://bitflate.org/post/2019/11/16/ethereum-and-computer-l...
- ddrdrck_ 7y agoVitalik is extremely smart, but even people that are 10 times less smart than Vitalik can create a crypto project ...
- dnprock 7y agoAssessing crypto problem is itself a problem. Vitalik maybe 10 times smarter than me. But his track record is poor. He hasn't really proposed a solution that is worthy contribution to crypto. I have solutions to some of the problems he lists. 10. Stable-value cryptoassets 13. Proof of excellence My solution is to add inflation into supply. A percentage point inflation, not tail emission. Inflation will discourage HODL behavior and stabilize token price. It's not perfectly stable. But it'll be more stable, more efficient than DAI and its financial engineering on top of Ethereum volatile price. That solves #10. For #13, with inflation, we don't have to worry about bag holders. Everyone has incentive to drive the system. Otherwise, their tokens will worth less over time. I designed a crypto that can help bootstrap inflation. My solutions are simpler. I think they'll work. https://bitflate.org/post/2019/04/14/bitflate-cryptocurrency-with-constant-inflation.html https://bitflate.org/post/2019/04/14/bitflate-cryptocurrency...
- woah 7y agoAt first glance, your coin looks like a copy and paste bitcoin clone with some tweaked parameters. If something like that was going to make a difference, I think we would have seen it happen in 2014 when a lot of copy and paste coins were being created. I was involved with Dogecoin back then. I advocated for inflation for the same reasons you want it. It has not led to Dogecoin having any great breakthrough in usage.
- baby 7y agoInterestingly, advances on currency stability are much more interesting than this post make it sound like: Libra backed 1:1 with a reserve, grincoin with its forever inflation model, and even tether with its controversial fractional reserve.