9 ms·
You Promised Me Mars Colonies but I Got Facebook
- samfisher83 7y agoI think the article points out the main reason. It is more profitable to build Facebook than put a man on mars.
- Irene 7y agoConnectivity-driven innovation is cheaper. Science is becoming harder and is getting less bang for its buck. We saw great progress in AI over the past few years but even this has taken far more effort and money than building social networks. Perhaps connectivity-driven innovation could help to speed up applied science innovation if power of the crowd is more efficiently utilized?
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoI don't agree that connectivity and applied science are two separate things. We don't get to netflix without applied sciences: encryption, compression, networking, neural networks. I don't know why the author said that. He has a degree in computer science
- randomsearch 7y agoMaybe that’s not true, in the long term? But certainly easier and more profitable in the short.
- skybrian 7y agoI doubt it would be any more profitable in the long run. A Mars colony would have extremely high barriers to trade. It's like a permanent trade embargo. Countries don't do well without trade. An entirely self-sufficient, technically advanced community hasn't been done, even on Earth. Antarctica would be much easier and cheaper in comparison.
- pfdietz 7y agoI don't understand why some people say they want to live on Mars. They'd be confined in small metal boxes, surrounded by things that would kill them in a moment. The cost of everything would be enormous, if it was available at all. If you want that experience, you can get it now on Earth in places we call "prisons".
- buboard 7y agoAnother reason: no imminent threat from the rival superpower. Though , the rise of china may change that
- bpodgursky 7y agoA lot of really stupid shit is going to happen in 2020, but if Starship makes it to orbit and Crew Dragon successfully launches astronauts, those are the only events anyone will remember in 100 years. (Come, on tell me with a straight face you remember anything else important that happened in 1903)
- option 7y agoDon’t want to sound as a fanboy, but IF (and this is a huge if) Elon succeeds on his mission to make humanity a multi-planentary species, he’ll be remembered as a greatest human who has ever lived for a very long time
- Aloha 7y agoI'm no Elon fan, and it's a really really big if, but - you're absolutely correct about that if he succeeds completely he'll go down in the same category as Edison or Napoleon.
- krapp 7y agoIf humanity ever does become a multi-planetary species, it will be because Elon contributed to a process that will still require decades, if not centuries, of effort beyond his death to achieve. He will not in any way be solely responsible, or deserving of that level of recognition, although I don't doubt that his fans will consider him as such anyway.
- Barrin92 7y agoI think it's great that there's a renewed discussion about the nature of productivity and growth and that people are starting to become aware that economic profit or consumer demand are not the same as progress on long term fundamental science and manufacturing. For way too long now we have all operated on the mainstream economic view that productivity growth is somehow like manna from the heavens and that we only need to let market forces play it out. I wholeheartedly recommend reading Dan Wang's piece on the issue: https://danwang.co/how-technology-grows/ https://danwang.co/how-technology-grows/
- shkkmo 7y agoWhat we need is progressively stricter tariffs paired with looser immigration laws. We need to force companies that want to efficiently compete for our consumer demand to in-source process knowledge and manufacturing.
- widowlark 7y agoThis is a novel take that I have not heard before. Thanks.
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoDunno if we is U.S. or someone else, but the U.S. could at least loosen up its immigration policy a little bit. We're literally putting Mexicans in fucking camps.
- tozeur 7y agoThe author works for a HPC company and is probably using this article for recruiting. I would’ve preferred the article to have more than a couple measly paragraphs on that subject, rather than he pander to the ‘futurists’
- eanzenberg 7y agoIt sounds like people are forgetting the world before Facebook. Isolated, repressed locations, limited flow of information from tiny amounts of sources. The Connected-Information Age seems to have brought on some great advances and has been self-sustaining from a profitable perspective. Sure, the worlds' governments could have spent billions / trillions building bases on Mars or even terraforming it. But for what purpose? And for how much misery would earth have to endure for all that effort?
- eanzenberg 7y agoAlso would like to add, sheer advances in compute and software lead by Facebook and others has enabled much cheaper space travel than what was possible in 1970's - 80's. This type of stuff is getting cheaper every day, so why be selfish because you "want to see it in your lifetime?" It'll happen. I don't care if it happens in 20 years, 200 years, or 2000 years.
- learc83 7y agoFacebook (and other web advertising companies) isn't leading most of the advances in computing power. Moore's law is much older than Facebook. And they certainly aren't developing the software that space agencies and companies are using. If anything they're likely diverting talent away from more beneficial work towards selling ads. There are maybe 2 projects on this list that could possibly be beneficial for space exploration, and they aren't groundbreaking. https://opensource.facebook.com/ https://opensource.facebook.com/
- helpPeople 7y agoOnly 4 more years until Elon Musk puts a $30,000 Tesla on Mars where solar power roofs cost the same as conventional. I believed it until about 3 years ago, when I realized spaceX is Elon's government subsidized advertisement for his other projects. Also the 30k car is never coming. And the roof price is loaded with astricks to be 'correct". We really need to wake up to the next gen marketing tactics.
- virgilp 7y agoI would argue that compared to status quo (ie either Russia, or Boeing &co) SpaceX saves the government a lot of money...
- smnrchrds 7y ago> the 30k car is never coming Never is a strong word. We may not get 30k electric cars in 5 years, but we will eventually. We may not get full autonomous vehicles in a decade, but we will certainly have it before the turn of the century.
- thatfrenchguy 7y agoYou mean when global warming will make most of the US a nightmare ? Great.
- muthdra 7y agoThat's not how marketing works. You don't try to make reusable interplanetary rockets just to sell cars. That would be the worst marketing tactic of all time.
- bitL 7y ago"You get what you measure" - talk to VCs that could finance your idea and then weep when you see what ideas do they actually select. Quick boring ROI + veiled scams are the way to go these days if you want to get external funding.
- rdlecler1 7y agoVCs have investors too. Want to change VC behavior? You need to change LP behavior. And if you think VCs are unoriginal with herd mentalities then LPs are 10x more so. If we want Mars colonies we need firms like Sequoia—-who effectively have the financial equivalent of tenure—-to step up, or it will come from billionaire entrepreneurs who have the risk tolerance and vision to think differently. Let’s hope all these tech unicorns are successful because it will be that generation that goes on to fund meaningful innovation, not University endowments or pension funds.
- buboard 7y agoI think the bigger lie is that you absolutely need VCs to finance your idea.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoWhat do you think is a better way to fund a manned mission to Mars? It's hard to argue with the progress that SpaceX has made - and that wouldn't exist without VC funding. Meanwhile NASA continues to operate at the whims of Congress. It's doing fine, but it's not looking for any moonshots like it was 50 years ago.
- dlp211 7y agoWhile agree they are at the whims of government, they literally have a moonshot in planning.
- OnlineGladiator 7y agoSure, but it's obviously going to fail to meet its deadline. It's politics completely disconnected from reality. Let's see how much Congress is willing to increase NASA's funding to actually make it a success, especially as they continue to miss deadlines. https://www.zdnet.com/article/another-nasa-moonshot-nope-you-cant-bs-your-way-to-space/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/another-nasa-moonshot-nope-you... > "If NASA is not currently capable of landing American astronauts on the moon in five years, we need to change the organization, not the mission." -Mike Pence I actually think this is a thinly veiled plan to defund NASA in the long run.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoThere's also a factor of iterativeness. I think everyone here will appreciate the value of designing something you can do step by step, with value at each step of the way. You don't have to go zero to 100 immediately. You can course correct. You can revise. You learn from 0-50 to do 51-100 better. Facebook can be built that way. Google too. SpaceX, maybe not so much. It's simply a harder and more expensive and riskier investment to do something that has so much startup cost before you start to get any value or pivotal learnings back.
- molteanu 7y agoI've told myself countless times lately, that it is simply not possible for young graduates to come to work knowing basically nothing, surfing fb and youtube all day long and then go buy cars and going to Greece as their very first vacation. Something, somewhere, just stinks badly. I've literally never seen a challenging and well run project in almost 10 years in this business. Always late, always overstaffed, always endless meetings and poorly trained people that nevertheless earn well above the median wage so the incentive to improve onself is almost zero and the attitude is "we're better than the rest of humanity. We deserve all, the rest deserves nothing." I did an Electrical Engineering faculty. I know how hard it is to do math and physics and all that. But since there's such an easy money to be made from slinging yet another website or a stupid mobile app with these dumbed down languages, the interest in the sciences and anything more complicated slowly wanishes. We'll pay the price eventually. Maybe not now, maybe not in 10 years, but eventually. We're too comfortable. "There existed no need on Caladan to build a physical paradise or a paradise of the mind — we could see the actuality all around us. And the price we paid was the price men have always paid for achieving a paradise in this life — we went soft, we lost our edge." - Dune (I'm from Eastern Europe)
- chrisseaton 7y ago> I've told myself countless times lately, that it is simply not possible for young graduates to come to work knowing basically nothing, surfing fb and youtube all day long and then go buy cars and going to Greece as their very first vacation. Something, somewhere, just stinks badly. What is this in reference to? Where do buying cars and holidays in Greece come into this article? Is there a stereotype of programmers holidaying in Greece?! And tech types mostly hate buying cars don’t they?
- molteanu 7y agoIn reference to all the money being invested in questionable places.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI think we’re missing some part of your train of thought here. But fundamentally tech graduates make a lot because the work they do makes a lot. You can’t argue the projects are both over staffed and pay too much at the same time! If there’s enough money coming into the company to pay that many people that much money then good for them? Looks like it is possible. Where should the money go instead? To the investors? That doesn’t sound better for ordinary people. But I don’t think they use it to go on holiday to Greece, and I’ve never heard anyone talk about normal tech graduates being involved in international tax evasion of all things - they don’t earn that much and I think most of it goes on rent in many places!
- scythe 7y agoWhy is it always space? Space technology requires lots of energy and our society is currently in the middle of realizing that our current way of getting energy is going to kill us. Of course we're not making large-scale investments in energy-intensive exploration. I wish EDS maglev, fusion power or quantum computing generated so much excitement, to say nothing of grid batteries, magnetocaloric heat pumps, or electric impedance tomography. I guess QC has done well lately.
- adventured 7y ago> Why is it always space? For the same reason it's always flying cars, despite how comically inefficient such vehicles are. The masses have an extaordinarily simplistic notion of what futuristic or advanced technology is or should look like. There are only a few well-trodden idols linked to what the future is supposed to look like. Hollywood has told them so; they've been told for many decades that it most certainly involves a space thing and or flying thing. Cracking the human genome was a thousand times more interesting and important than flying cars could ever be and yet the masses can't let go of flying cars as somehow representative of magic futureness. It's nothing more than cultural brainwashing, equivalent to being projected on by media & advertising for decades that smoking cigarettes is cool (and that worked just the same, people bought into it fully). They do what they're told. They believe what they're sold.
- krapp 7y ago>They do what they're told. They believe what they're sold. But you don't. You're not one of the tomatoes, you're a real person, huh?
- balt_s 7y ago> Why is it always space? Two words: Star Trek
- Animats 7y agoWhy is it always space? Good question. The best off-earth real estate in this solar system is worse than the worst on-earth real estate. It's easier to build colonies in Antarctica or underwater on the continental shelf than on Mars. Mars is small, cold, and nearly airless. We're not short of low-value real estate, after all.
- buboard 7y agoAnd he doesn't even touch on the inefficiency of public research spending which has ballooned since 2000 with disappointing returns
- rhizome 7y agoMars colonies don't come from the private sector, Elon and Jeff notwithstanding. The problem is that public science has been starved of funding for decades through tax cuts. If the author would take off his (it's always a he) blinkers of technocracy he might see that profitability is not the only measure of "why." Some things are not profitable, yet are still worth doing. Andrew Yang-lite doesn't account for this at all (see "blinkers" above), which is pretty much par for the course for the "Facebook is the be-all end-all" attitude. To paraphrase JFK, we pay taxes for public benefit not because it is cheap, but because it is expensive.
- georgeburdell 7y ago>Mars colonies don't come from the private sector, Elon and Jeff notwithstanding Exploration has a long history of rich benefactors and private interests. Monarchs, Dutch East India Corporation, etc., are closer to Musk and Bezos than a modern democratic state >The problem is that public science has been starved of funding for decades through tax cuts. This graph suggests otherwise? In current dollar terms, R&D spending is double what it was in the 1970s. https://www.aaas.org/sites/default/files/2019-06/DefNon.png https://www.aaas.org/sites/default/files/2019-06/DefNon.png
- rhizome 7y agoI am skeptical of the success rate of rich benefactors for a technology with only a century of practice, vs. boats that have been used for thousands of years. >In current dollar terms, R&D spending is double what it was in the 1970s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_NASA#/media/File:NASA-Budget-Federal.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_NASA#/media/File:NAS... And there are more budgets to be involved than just these two.
- taway16 7y agoI have talked to VCs who told they love to fund "deep tech", but when they realize that basic research is binary result, they get surprised, and say it's too risky. And sometimes the VCs who evaluate this are people who are young enough to never lived on their own during a recession.
- trixie_ 7y agoNASA hasn’t been actively trying to drive down the cost of space. If the had it would of unlocked space for all of us decades ago. It took SpaceX investing their own profits into building a reusable booster. And now they’re doing the same for the entire vehicle with Starship. NASA does pay SpaceX for flights to the IIS, but most of that money goes into building Dragons and the rockets to support them. What if NASA actually invested in truly low maintenance fully reusable vehicles decades ago? You might actually have Mars colonies today. But what do we have? Continued investment in SLS when the writing has been on the wall for years now.
- p_l 7y agoNASA projects are endangered by politicians. The difference is that SpaceX funded reusability on their own, instead of depending on fickle funding from Congress that killed the original STS (leaving us with the one that flew and costed as much as Apollo per launch). And sometimes it wasn't Congress zit was president - like Nixon deciding to kill nuclear space propulsion for no known reason. The cutthroat politics of inter-OKB competition in Soviet Union Post Korolev's death sometimes appear milder than the indecision left after Kennedy in actually funding NASA.
- merpnderp 7y agoNixon killing nuclear space propulsion for no known reason? You mean the Orion project and thousands of nuclear bombs in space? I’d say keeping space nuclear weapons free in the face off with the Soviet Union counts as a known reason.
- p_l 7y agoThe nuclear propulsion project was unrelated to Orion. And yes, the reason is unknown, because in giving his Executive Order there was no reason attached. It was nuclear thermal engines, similar were being developed in Soviet Union in fact. IT was even tested for safety in case of crashing on Earth (and could run on earth, though the target was using it in space).
- pfdietz 7y ago
- philipkglass 7y agoThis raises some interesting questions about why the-future-seen-from-1970 included so many developments that failed to materialize. Unfortunately, I think it provides mostly wrong or irrelevant answers. One thing that made the 20th century so amazing was the discovery of scientific phenomena that were easily translated to industrially and commercially relevant technologies. We're still mining the rich vein of technological possibilities opened up by quantum mechanics. The major features of the field were well established before World War II. There has been nothing so technologically fruitful discovered since. It's possible that amazing scientific breakthroughs in cosmology or particle physics will be made this century, yet fail to have anything like the technological impact of quantum effect devices, if the time/length/mass/energy scales are not amenable to building products and factories usable on Earth. The other big headwind since 1970 has been the price of fuels. In every year of the 21st century, inflation adjusted global crude oil prices have remained above where they were in 1970. The one modern bright spot [1], the shale revolution, has spectacularly failed to make its investors prosper [2]. Nor is its continuance assured enough for airlines and aircraft manufacturers to decide that the time has come again for faster rather than thriftier passenger service. Airframes last a long time. Want faster-than-Concorde passenger air service for the 21st century? You need new vehicles and a stable, low priced [3] energy source for them to consume. [1] For oil and gas prices. Not for the climate. [2] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/shale-pioneer-fracking-unmitigated-disaster-230000670.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/shale-pioneer-fracking-unmiti... [3] Including climate externalities. I wouldn't bet on those remaining unpriced over the airframe's life either.
- petre 7y agoThe future acording to Ford Perfect: just the same old stuff in faster cars and smellier air. Douglas Adams was a visionary, as many writers before him. That's why we need literature and human sciences - because we lose focus otherwise.
- adwn 7y agoAlmost all "visionaries" are wrong, and it's impossible to tell in advance which ones aren't. > That's why we need literature and human sciences - because we lose focus otherwise. Non sequitur: neither part of that sentence follows from the rest of your post.
- dade_ 7y agoI watch what NTT Research is up to, and frankly, how many startups even know anything about how to fabricate a superconductor, let alone have the facilities to create them? They have the tools to make websites and little computers with sensors made in Shenzhen, so that is what they make. https://www.ntt-review.jp/archive/ntttechnical.php?contents=ntr201910fa4.html https://www.ntt-review.jp/archive/ntttechnical.php?contents=...
- Razengan 7y ago> “Why We Can’t Solve Big Problems” I think it may partly be because most of human civilization is still basically slave labor. You indenture some people and you tell them what to build. People don't care about problems they're not supposed to take care of. It's a detriment to them if they do. This kind of makes it tricky to take on tasks like say, space elevators or arcologies or extraterrestrial colonies. You need expertise and constant collaboration from so many different domains it's hard for a single organization to have enough musclepower and brainpower for, even with contractors. Then there's the tribalism. Governments may have the resources to take on global/space-scale projects but they generally try to hinder other governments, even within the same nation.
- balaam 7y agoI agree with this. A basic income program could have an unexpected dividend of a new innovation boom.
- sabujp 7y agoForget mars colonies, i just want robots that can do household chores that don't cost more than a vacuum cleaner (and i think roombas are overpriced), where's Rosie?! That's hard, let's build the 10000th chat app instead, e.g. why did this cost $120 million https://qz.com/1194939/the-us-government-just-gave-someone-a-120-million-robotic-arm-to-use-for-a-year/ https://qz.com/1194939/the-us-government-just-gave-someone-a... ? Can't we do better now with 3d printing? I dunno, i think we're getting there : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6xqTcLXXC8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6xqTcLXXC8
- randomsearch 7y agoThought: is the migration of manufacturing away from western countries part of the problem? Lots of innovation in software in the US or UK, but less in manufacturing - perhaps because the skills aren’t there?
- ben_w 7y agoIs there really a lack of innovation in manufacturing? 3D printers (hyped though they are) are improving rapidly. Nanoscale stuff (not just graphene and chips, but also those) are seeing a lot of progress. I’m not in hardware though, so I can’t tell if that’s part of a trend or not.
- randomsearch 7y agoOh, sorry, I mean - as in innovation in hardware products rather than the manufacturing process itself.
- widowlark 7y agoProbably some of the issue, yes. I will say this is chiefly a company-side problem. Lot's of companies still have manufacturing jobs in the US, but they are typically high-skill manufacturing, like Boeing or Tesla.
- breck 7y agoThe problem is Intellectual Monopoly laws. Imagine you have 8 billion processors but you only provide 8 million of them with disk access. Very few people have access to the information necessary to build innovative products. Instead of waiting for BillG to solve the energy crisis and healthcare delivery and new kinds of toilets for everybody, let's abolish Intellectual Monopoly laws and unleash the power of all 8 billion processors on solving these hard problems. #intellectualfreedom #scihub
- nscalf 7y agoWhat is tough about this problem is how hard it is to communicate. We all know something is wrong, even if we don't really realize it. Like the article says, we've been promised all of these incredible things by the advancements we've seen, but we have gotten very few fundamental improvements. I live in the US, so I'm going to speak from that point of view. We work more than every, are poorer than any time in recent memory, have a broken healthcare system, we're seeing decreases in life expectancy, epidemic levels of suicide, etc. and all of this at a time when the market is at ridiculous highs. There are very few people talking about this in highly coherent ways, one is Eric Weinstein on his podcast The Portal, which focuses on this. What we have seen in the past 50 years is that physics has hit a wall in delivering meaningful real world improvements for people's lives, biology has largely done the same, and chemistry pushes forward at a snails pace in the form of pharmaceuticals. The saving grace that makes everyone feel as though we're progressing is technology, which seems to have hit the same wall in recent years since most of the easy problems to solve with computer science have been solved. In the soft sciences, economics has some deeply troubling problems down to the fundamentals, our politics/government/public policy is damaged and decaying at the root, academia has exploded in cost with little payoff for most, and has entrenched itself as a inescapable shadow that looms over young people for the rest of their life, all while cannibalizing those who speak out against it. Many great advancements are threatening to become meaningful, but many more have been doing that for decades. It really seems like we are running out of easy problems to solve, and the systems that we have in place are remarkably bad at solving hard problems, while being remarkably good at concentrating wealth I often think of the first few lines of a poem by Allen Ginsberg: "I saw the best minds of my generation destroyed by madness, starving hysterical naked, dragging themselves through the negro streets at dawn looking for an angry fix, angelheaded hipsters burning for the ancient heavenly connection to the starry dynamo in the machinery of night, who poverty and tatters and hollow-eyed and high sat up smoking in the supernatural darkness of cold-water flats floating across the tops of cities contemplating jazz..." I'm seeing the best minds of my generation destroyed trying to sell ad space, starved of connection, posting selfies looking for a hollow fix.
- numair 7y agoAll of these articles and ways of thinking always miss the bigger, more fundamental shift in human society — we now know there is literally no place we can access in any meaningful amount of time where the “grass is greener” than the places we’ve already been. This is profound, semi-depressing, and enlightening at the same time. Rather than seeking something new somewhere else, our new obsession is in improving what we’ve got, where we are right now. I know a lot of you are going to make hand-wavy claims about space mining and things like that, but our population curve seems to indicate a very minimal benefit to all of that. If anything, the fastest-growing environmental concern seems to be space and sky pollution. Starry-eyed young engineers have been sold on the idea of interstellar space travel, when the reality of the commercial application of their work is that it’s more likely to lead to an over-proliferation of satellites and help rich people get to places faster via space plane. The final argument someone’s inevitably going to make is, survival of the race. Yeah, okay. You might want to self-reflect on our existence as deeply terrestrial beings that are intrinsically connected to the Earth. Even if you spend all of your day hidden in a bedroom, you can’t escape your bond with this planet. Instead of trying to find a mistress in the form of another moon/planet, we need to spend more time working on the marriage. I think space technologies are fun, and that rich people obsessed with suicide missions to other planets should be able to do what they want, but let’s not kid ourselves on the moral superiority of these sorts of things. There is no shame, and no inferiority, in working to optimize our Earth-bound existence.
- guelo 7y agoI try to imagine humanity a thousand years from now, still bound to the same increasingly inhospitable planet, paying for the sins of our generations but nowhere to escape to. With probably an abandoned Mars or moon colony. Just nothing to explore. Even the boundaries of natural science would be mostly understood by that point. It would be so depressing. Our only salvation would be if we still have enough resources remaining for computers to run virtual worlds for us to explore. Basically video games, that's our best hope.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- munherty 7y agoTo provide an edgy answer, we live in a rather peaceful time... We haven't had a good old fashioned War to accelerate our technological advancements. As humans were rather adept at finding new and creative ways to kill each other and then ultimately repurposing it for good later on...
- undefined3840 7y agoI’m surprised this article is so upvoted. 1. The author took this nearly word for word from Thiel/Eric Weinstein, who have both discussed this point extensively, most recently on Weinstein’s podcast. 2. The author is using this click bait headline to discuss his own industry/company, and this looks like some content marketing piece.
- ElFitz 7y agoPlus, the clickbait headline is merely a copycat of one Thiel's own words, except it was with flying cars and Twitter
- chr1 7y agoIt is a marketing piece. I liked the article because it did not go on complaining how we wasted our time on building useless things like facebook, but suggested possible reason why innovation in engineering things is slower than in engineering programs. And also suggested possible solution.
- idoh 7y agoAgreed. It's actually a worse version of the Thiel/Weinstein framing, because the author posits the divide between "connection driven" and "applied science" innovation, which is a less useful distinction than the "bits" v "atoms" distinction. The "bits" v "atoms" distinction is better because software as a whole has seen dramatic innovation that is not confined to "networks". Feels like a marketing piece for the author's company TBH.
- kristopolous 7y agoI'm writing a book on future thought tentatively titled The Soul of Tomorrow A futurist's construction kit A field manual for how to think about and create "future stuff", stepwise advances for a continuous world. I'm about 25,000 words in. It's currently being developed on github. If this really interests anybody, I'd really love to talk to them about things. The chapters are starting to come together, but honestly this is 15 years of thinking and currently only 15 days of writing (November novel writing) I intend to eventually get this to a publishable academic state with careful citations. I've even taken a week off work to travel around to libraries and do research for it. I'm looking at how visions of possible futures operate, how they change, get communicated, materialize, and often collapse. I've developed a number of frameworks that I'm currently trying to validate and falsify by looking at many classes of future from things like biblical second coming theology to socialist theory to technological dreams to even white nationalism. I'm trying to figure out how the dreams of a different tomorrow operate at fundamental levels. Please reach out and contact me if you want to talk about this. I'm really passionate about this study. My email address is in my bio. If you replace the domain of Yahoo with Gmail I'll probably see it quicker.
- mch82 7y agoHave you checked out Shell’s scenario writing? They used to publish some very good how-to guides for futures research. I didn’t see as much how-to content the last time I visited the website. https://www.shell.com/energy-and-innovation/the-energy-future/scenarios.html https://www.shell.com/energy-and-innovation/the-energy-futur... Syd Meade is also an interesting person to study for a book about envisioning the future. He designed a number of cars and is famous for Blade Runner. I talked with him & his key insight was that he always drew a car in a world. A car needs a world (context) in order to make sense of its design. http://sydmead.com/ http://sydmead.com/
- tomaszs 7y agoI hope tech will be used to hack universe not people eventually
- api 7y agoFacebook is addictive. There's nothing addictive on Mars. If we discover space crack then we will have a real space program.
- skybrian 7y agoSeems like we don't get Mars colonies and supersonic jets for good economic reasons? These are luxuries at best. It's a nostalgic idea of progress only tenuously related to actual progress. More relevant questions might be why the cost of housing hasn't improved and why we haven't cured cancer yet.
- pfdietz 7y agoCancer's a really tough problem, and we're only now getting the mass of detailed information about its biology (in all its forms) that allows targeted therapies.
- masonic 7y agoWe don't have a market for commercial supersonic jets (given present technology) because they are an environment-clobbering indulgence even worse than private jets. And its consumers would no longer be as comfortably private with their consumption being sprayed all over IG and the like.
- rileymat2 7y agoAm I the only one who feels weird reading this article on LinkedIn?
- vkaku 7y agoRemember: Back to the Future?
- m0zg 7y agoIn a way, FB is more useful than Mars colonies could ever hope to be. How the hell do you even survive on a planet without a magnetic field to repel cosmic radiation? A few kamikaze will go, but it's lunacy to expect some kind of massive and growing settlement there. It'll likely be an extremely expensive counterpart of the ISS or an arctic research station. You aren't ever going to get it to more than a few hundred people. Inspiring? Hell yeah. But beyond that also pointless.
- widowlark 7y agoThere's a certain irony in Buzz Aldrin complaining that he didn't get Mars Colonies and simultaneously hating on Elon Musk for not being the US Government.
- innagadadavida 7y agoThere has been no progress on the quality of life front expected from technology advances either. Advent of dish washers, washing machines etc, made our life simpler. But even now, these are not “end-to-end” solutions - someone has to load and unload these machines and maintain them. These problems are not as complex as the ones mentioned in the article. However, nothing has changed for the last 50-60 years. Solving these do not involve any political changes or other forms of complex coordination. We’ve talked about personal robots, but nothing exists that can solve these problems.
- DennisP 7y agoI'll just mention there are a bunch of privately-funded fusion reactor projects, including TAE, General Fusion, Commonwealth, Tokamak Energy, LPP, Helion (funded in part by YCombinator), and others. There are also lots of companies working on molten salt reactors. In theory that's easier than fusion, but governments are more prickly about letting you work on fission.
- pfdietz 7y agoTAE: it was explained to them 20 years ago why their idea didn't work, even theoretically. General Fusion: acoustic compression was shown to be unworkable, so they pivoted to a slower scheme with a central conductor down the middle of the chamber. Good luck getting that conductor to survive 100T magnetic fields and orders of magnitude higher neutron loading than in conventional reactor concepts. Commonwealth and TE: overall volumetric power density of their concepts will be very poor compared to fission reactors, even if every other problem is avoided. LPP: there is a serious disconnect between accomplishment and hype. Also, pulsed approaches with very short bursts of fusion output make wall engineering much harder, and it's already very hard in continuous fusion reactor concepts. The only one I cannot immediately dismiss is Helion, although that may be because I know less about them. The goal of direct conversion is admirable if they want to have a chance of being cheaper than fission, but the demands on that seem formidable. The high current, high voltage, billion reps over the lifetime of the reactor switching requirements seem extreme.
- DennisP 7y agoI'm not trying to claim that these particular projects will succeed. I'm just saying that some VCs are in fact funding the sort of high-risk breakthrough physical technologies that the article claims are not being funded. But a nitpick on LPP: wall engineering isn't really an issue for them since they're attempting boron fusion. Like Helion they're also planning direct conversion, since the output is a pulsed beam of charged particles. I once asked Lerner why they don't start with D-T and he had an argument that their concept actually works better with boron (don't remember why).
- 7y ago
- brainfarts 7y agoHumans are notoriously terrible at predicting how technology with develop over decades. It’s humorous to look at what people a hundred years ago thought technology would be like. [1]https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wired.com/2014/05/victorian-postcards-predict-future/amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.wired.com/2014/05/victorian...
- jglathe 7y agoWell. Complexity kills. This is true on so many levels. Whatever was promised by futurists or science, is most of the time a marketing blurb. But it almost always adds complexity. Maybe it is a good idea to avoid easy gains. You get born, you have to learn the ropes and use your skills. You always build on the knowleadge of others. But you have to learn it first. That's something other than reciting.
- sk84life6 7y agoFacebook promised social networking but I got privacy violating CIA spy machine. Big thanks to all social networking companies like Facebook, Google and Twitter to keep NSA and CIA always in people's pocket! All HN fanboys time to put some serious thumbs down now
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lazylizard 7y agoI dunno why ppl keep saying all we got is facebook. We got vxlan, 100gbe, SSDs,nvme SSDs,and soon non-volatile memory, GPUs, dpdk, segment routing, containers, config management, nosql, json, bittorrent, blockchain, eliptical curve crypto, totp, letsencrypt/acme, raft consensus..and more!
- truncate 7y agoI somewhat agree. Facebook may not appeal much to people interested in let say space exploration or self-driving cars, but amount of engineering lessons learned by deploying a software at that scale is still invaluable. We are so much better at distributed systems, machine learning than we were, and that knowledge can be applied to other problems (and it is).
- gruez 7y ago>[...] nosql, json, [...] Those are not like the others.