24 ms·
The FCC Has Fined Robocallers $208M, Collected $6,790
- brenden2 7y agoHonestly I'm surprised they've managed to collect that much. Good job guys.
- nobodyandproud 7y agoThis is a market-based problem rather than a policy problem: The problem is the low cost of making calls. Make calls cost money and the problem will naturally go away.
- alyandon 7y agoTelcos are not incentivized to do much about this problem because they get paid by the scammers to complete their calls. As long as telcos continue to make money from these fraudulent calls, the problem will continue to exist. I'm not even sure that raising the floor cost of making calls would help because scammers only have to swindle a single person out of thousands of dollars to offset the costs. :(
- nobodyandproud 7y agoMaybe. It would be interesting to know the average dollar raked in per call.
- Aloha 7y agoIt depends on rate center - remember those free conference services - they often used rate centers which were rural so they had a higher termination charge, which meant that the service was profitable. While I'm having trouble finding hard rates - with the big carriers, I know its not a ton of money now in any case - low enough that I dont think the financial incentive is a relevant course of action, it just subsidizes the trunking infrastructure needed to support the calls. See Call Pumping: https://www.fcc.gov/general/traffic-pumping https://www.fcc.gov/general/traffic-pumping
- nobodyandproud 7y agoNo. I mean the average dollar amount scammed per call. I assume most calls are not successful, but over a thousand calls how much can a scammer expect to make?
- brenden2 7y agoIndeed. Same with messaging, email, etc.
- vkou 7y agoNo, this is a problem where the necessary resources used to punish white collar crime are not being allocated. If there was a known Florida-based drug dealer that was bringing in $120,000,000 of drugs/year, there'd be dozens of cops working around the clock to bring him in. A Florida-based robo-caller, fined $120,000,000, who isn't paying a penny? Nobody cares. I understand lack of enforcement against some robocall firm incorporated on Mars, or somewhere else beyond the reach of law enforcement. I don't understand the lack of enforcement against ones based in the US. Jail them, take their homes and cars, put their kids up in foster care.
- briandear 7y agoTo be fair $120 million in drugs and $120 million in uncollected fines are apples and oranges. The drug money is financing murdering drug cartels that have brought Mexico to their knees. Robocalls are kind of not on the same level as funding human-trafficking, murderous cartels.
- rebuilder 7y agoAre you sure it's not organized crime running the robocsll schemes?
- stjohnswarts 7y agoNo one is saying that it's as bad as murdering, but it should be a minimum of at least 1 year in prison for everyone involved.
- nobodyandproud 7y agoIf you read the article, you’ll see that often the ones running these scams can’t pay the full amount. You don’t need a lot of money to spam calls. It wasn’t always this way, and getting random BS calls almost never happened back then.
- vkou 7y agoThat's fine. We have a solution for people who don't have the full amount of a fine. We take every penny that they do have. Since the guy hasn't paid a cent, and is not living under a bridge, panhandling with a "Homeless veteran, please give me money for food" sign, I'm pretty sure that this is a problem with enforcement. > You don’t need a lot of money to spam calls. No, but you do get a lot of money from the people buying ad time from you.
- phkahler 7y agoI think the problem is that it's possible to spoof called ID. The fraud starts before you answer the phone. Caller ID used to be an extra charge. The telcos needed it not to be mandatory. But now my land line is going away because it's become nothing but an annoyance. They could have prevented that but... but...
- nobodyandproud 7y agoThat is part of the problem, but it costs almost nothing to spam calls. So even if you track someone down, what will you do if they are dirt poor?
- stjohnswarts 7y agoA few years in jail will help adjust their attitude.
- sieabahlpark 7y agoThey would prefer not having to maintain their infrastructure as a utility for landlines. They would much prefer you just kept using your wireless phone where the margins are much higher.
- nobodyandproud 7y agoAlready three down-votes, but not a single explanation or repudiation as to why this particular problem isn’t solved more easily by markets.
- jjoonathan 7y agoThe technological and legislative infrastructure required to turn this into a market far exceeds what would be required for simpler anti-spam measures. It comes across as unhelpful and detached, like suggesting world peace as the solution to gang violence in your neighborhood.
- nobodyandproud 7y agoWhat technical limitation? There is nothing simpler, except that some very well-funded special interest groups never want to see this happen. When I was on a limited plan, the amount of spam messages and calls were virtually zero because the limit would run up and be charged against the caller (internationally). The month I switched to an unlimited, I started getting spammed. Now much of the spam is domestic, but I fail to see how this is possibly unfeasible technically.
- weberc2 7y agoWhy should we artificially charge law abiding people for making a call? Why not disallow call spoofing? Why should we allow telecom fraud, especially when there are obvious technical solutions? And what well-funded SIGs are our to get your phone call tax plan?
- nobodyandproud 7y agoWhat’s artificial about it? Are you old enough to remember when calls cost money, and we didn’t have these problems?
- manigandham 7y agoPhone calls do cost money. Unlimited mobile calling plans are very recent, and many areas in the world are still by the minute and rather expensive.
- jcrawfordor 7y agoI think the major fault with this reasoning is that the exact same solution has been proposed many times for e-mail, going back decades, and has never come even close to catching on. I think that applying a cost - whether time or money - to producing phone calls would fail for the same reasons. Namely, the significant difficulty in making significant changes to the telephone system (e.g. changing requirements to make a call, something which has almost never happened in the history of the phone system) and the lack of incentives for the telcos to do so, considering that they make termination fees off of these spam calls.
- nobodyandproud 7y agoYou do know that people used to have to pay per call, right? There was even something called long distance charges ! Free, unlimited phone calls is a fairly recent thing. This is not a technical problem at all.
- jcrawfordor 7y agoYes, but these charges were all imposed by the telco for end users, and special arrangements for large customers have been the norm since the AT&T breakup. There is no facility to ensure that _all_ calls have paid a fee because many customers have, for decades, had arrangements to make calls with no fee required, and in general there has been no reason for a telco to have a mechanism to monitor another telco's billing practices. In other words: yes, and many people also paid for their email accounts for some years. Yet here we are...
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoMake anybody that wants access to SS7 take out a bond.
- megablast 7y agoExactly, we would not have this problem if each call cost $1000 to make.
- dredmorbius 7y agoI agree with your basic point: that this is a problem that's enabled by low-cost telecoms. We already saw that movie, in the 1990s, in Usenet and Email spam. And we know how it ends. Spoilers: everyone dies. The problem with your proposed solution is that you're going to have an awfully hard time rebottling that genie. We've got low-cost comms. And within the triple entente of costs, infrastructure, and network effects, you're going to see those re-emerge, whether on the PSTN old-school phone network (inclusive of mobile and VOIP), or on some replacement. Infrastructure, because you're talking about billions of subscribers. Even a limited network is tens to hundreds of millions. (Numbers for online community services are similar.) Costs, because users will migrate to the low-cost solution, all else being equal. If regulation requires a cost floor on one network, you'll see migrations elsewhere, and legislation and regulation virtually always lag. Network effects, because an effective and attractive network is either extraordinarily selective (The Harvard Face Book), or universal (Facebook). Much of the actual systemic value comes not from what the vendor or service provider, er, provides, but from what the users bring to the network. And a large network makes up for a lot of crud in other areas. (Corollary: the replacement service is almost certain to emerge within some elite niche, and then spread out, as did writing, literacy, publishing, telephony, the Internet, mobile phones, smartphones, and social networking.) (Corollary: alternatives which start out with the spammers and marketers already on-board and running rampant will likely fail to make the cut.) Increasing costs across the board won't work. Oh, and you've got a whole mass of vested interests propping up the current system. I've already linked Bernhard J. Stern's "Resistances to the Adoption of Technological Innovations", but the logic expressed there largely applies, and the paper itself includes several comms-based examples. Increasing costs for malfeasance, most especially at the service provider level, probably through some charge-back or penalty scheme, with (excellent suggestion from, er, you, by the way: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21494014 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21494014) a bounty available to third parties, could well be part of that. A basic outline which you'll also find widely repeated through history. Markets caused this problem through externalities, informational asymmetries, vested power relationships, sunk costs, network effects, and perverse incentives. You're not going to solve the problem by marketing it harder.
- beenBoutIT 7y agoSo if Kevin Bacon wanted to start a pirate radio station he could just set up shop and get away with it now?
- omarhaneef 7y agoDo you mean Christian Slater? Or did I forget a sub-plot in Footloose?
- beenBoutIT 7y agoI did mean Christian Slater. Although after being blown away by Bacon's performance in White Water Summer I can't help but wonder how much darker Pump Up the Volume would be with Bacon cast as the lead.
- marknadal 7y agoThey had to build a call center to call the robocallers. This was gonna cost $250M, so they decided to hire a firm to do it for them. This firm was able to do it for $207,993,210 saving the government ~$43M. Turned out the firm was the robocallers who got fined. So they just called themselves 1 time, and paid the difference on the bills: $6,790! /sarcasm
- jacquesm 7y agoNever knew you could contract it has into it's as well.
- saalweachter 7y ago"It's good to see you," Joe said. "Yes, it's been too long," Jim replied.
- jacquesm 7y agoEnglish is like C, even after 30 years it still has the potential to surprise you :)
- jcims 7y agoI love listening to people speak that are just learning English and don’t have all of the idiosyncrasies/ vernacular down. Little things like saying ‘today morning’ instead of ‘this morning’, gives you a glimpse of a simpler, more logical version of the language.
- saalweachter 7y ago'tis as the good book (https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/) says.
- jacquesm 7y agoCue 10,000 people submitting a link about the Yellowstone Supervolcano.
- vharuck 7y agoI remember asking my high school English teacher if I could use the contraction "shouldn't've" for "should not have." She said no. I still disagree.
- chapium 7y ago
- sg47 7y agoCan we try robocalling them to collect the remaining?
- smittywerben 7y agoMakes me wonder how long distance rates are charged in the first place. A little OT but did we used to call websites?
- dredmorbius 7y agoIn dialup, you (or your modem) would dial a POP server, or point-of-presence. That was a modem bank on one side, and Internet backbone link on the other, generally as a local call. The website was reached via the POP, but you could reach any website anywhere on the public Internet without having to dial up each individually. More specifically, PSTN is a public, switched, telecommunications network, in which each communication occurs over a direct, and until recently physical, circuit. The "switches" refer to how those circuits are set up and broken down. By contrast the Internet is packet routed; each data packet is routed across the network by the best available route. Users don't have dedicated circuits (though there are dedicated addresses), but rather data from multiple communications is commingled on common transmission channels. There were BBSes which you'd call directly (the job board DICE ws initially a BBS), but BBS != website. Similar in ways to today's SPAs though. https://www.techopedia.com/definition/1704/point-of-presence-pop https://www.techopedia.com/definition/1704/point-of-presence... https://networkencyclopedia.com/point-of-presence-pop/ https://networkencyclopedia.com/point-of-presence-pop/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- smittywerben 7y agoThat's impressive how POP servers communicated across the Internet backbone considering some websites were long distance. I get to read about Erlang now. Carrier-grade NAT in regards to ip addresses reminds me of my grandparents had a shared phone-line for their neighborhood. It's funny you mentioned BBS, I think that's what I was initially unclear about. That answers many of my questions, ty for the time.
- beerandt 7y agoThere needs to be postage imposed on connecting calls between systems, payable to the person called, and potentially refundable upon lack of complaint for being unsolicited. This could work for email spam, as well. Bonus if people get to set their own postage rates.
- chrsstrm 7y agoSure, because that totally would never be abused to facilitate illegal payments or to launder funds.
- beerandt 7y agoIt would obviously all have a paper trail. I don't see how it would have any advantages over check, money order, wired funds, etc.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoWell there was a guy in the UK who set up a premium number after getting sick of cold sales calls. All companies get his 10p/minute number as contact (he gets 7p of that). Only friends and family get the real underlying number. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-23869462 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-23869462
- beerandt 7y agoI like the idea, but it doesn't solve the problem of when your real number makes it onto call lists. But I do like the idea of giving out a 1-900 number to people. It would certainly get some interesting reactions, depending on context.
- mattkrause 7y agoIs there even a list? I had assumed they were just umm...enumerating all the numbers.
- dredmorbius 7y ago
- chooseaname 7y agoStop allowing spoofed numbers. Period. I'm sorry BigCorp, but this is a public nuisance and trumps your "need" for a single phone number.
- rectang 7y agoThis is the US, where money is speech and one dollar is one vote. Individual consumers don't have enough money to matter compared to BigCorp.
- tyre 7y agoClinton outspent Trump nearly 2:1 in the last election ($768m, $398m respectively) and still lost. Yes she won the popular vote by about 3m votes but that’s hardly a dollar to vote ratio. People vote their emotions, and emotions are surprisingly difficult to buy.
- __s 7y agorectang isn't talking about the presidential election
- h5erahear5 7y agoThe claim "one dollar is one vote" is directly refuted by tyre's data. It is absolutely relevant to the assertion made. But keep on downvoting HNers, ignorance is bliss is why we come to this website after all
- pessimizer 7y agoOne dollar being one vote is a cliché that refers to the wealthy having the most say in governance, not that US elections are literally the process of counting the individual candidates donations and declaring the candidate that got the most the winner. Also, stop playing the victim.
- bduerst 7y ago
- tamalpais 7y agoI enabled the Silence Unknown Callers feature [0] in iOS and haven’t answered a spam call since. The downside is that it sends every call from unknown numbers to voicemail, including legitimate ones. It’s a worthwhile trade-off. [0] https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207099 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT207099
- nikanj 7y agoSame here, and I believe the next natural step is for companies to switch to calling on Whatsapp etc.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoI tried it, and within a week I missed an important call. I was waiting by the phone, and it just never arrived. I realized too late that it had been silenced. It's very frustrating that we can't just get something like a spam filter, rather than a blanket "silence everything unknown."
- _delirium 7y agoT-Mobile does spam filtering; not sure about other carriers. The default configuration (or at least I think it is, because I don't remember changing it) is to tag the calls by setting the Caller-ID to the name "Scam Likely". You can then configure your phone to respond differently to calls from that ID (e.g. disable ringer). Alternately, if you trust their filtering enough, you can have those calls blocked so they don't ring through to the phone at all. I think it's been working fairly well for me, but I also rarely get legitimate calls from anyone other than a handful of friends/family who are in my contacts list, so I can't be too sure of the false-positive rate. Info: https://support.t-mobile.com/docs/DOC-38784 https://support.t-mobile.com/docs/DOC-38784
- MarkSweep 7y agoUnfortunately when I use our conference system’s “call my phone” feature it almost always shows the number as “scam likely”. So I guess the scammers are using the same block of numbers as the conference system.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThe next step is to fine telephone exchanges for allowing robocallers.
- piinbinary 7y agoStart billing the telecoms, and they'll fix the issue real quick
- concerned_user 7y agoOr force them to make a pool of trusted callers and any untrusted number they pay you.
- throwaway56564 7y agoTwilio, when do they become accountable for enabling robocallers.
- reustle 7y agoI've always been curious how much of this happens through companies like Twilio. Are there any numbers / studies out there that dig into it?
- nexuist 7y agoI highly doubt Twilio knowingly allows this to happen. Furthermore, if anyone linked their card with Twilio, it would not have been hard to track down who is doing this and freeze their assets (from a fed agency perspective) or at least block their account (from Twilio's mod team perspective).
- codeplea 7y agoI've been a Twilio customer for a long time. They don't allow you to spoof caller ID. You can only set outgoing caller ID to a real number that you own or have access to.
- throwaway4120 7y agoHow does not allowing spoofing caller ID help defeat robocallers. People use twilio to robocall individuals from their same area code. No “spoofing” caller ID is needed. Twilio makes is stupid simple for robocallers and I can speak with authority on this matter hence why this is a throwaway account.
- zackmorris 7y agoDoes anyone familiar with the law know why these fines couldn't be converted to tax liens or some other legal device that could be used to go after the offenders? Then the IRS could garnish wages or prevent loans to the businesses until the liens are paid, or do all kinds of things to throw a wrench in their plans and make robocalls too much of a hassle to be lucrative.
- JaRail 7y agoI'd assume they're mostly fines against foreign or shell companies. What's effectively a shell company is set up to forward calls, then goes out of business when caught.
- hinkley 7y ago"Piercing the corporate veil" is a process for dealing with this.
- hn_dead_app 7y ago"Massive arrests" is another.
- ravenstine 7y agoI see people here saying that spoofed numbers is the problem. Maybe it's a big part of it, but at the end of the day, the phone companies are complicit with the criminals because there's no good reason that these robocalls can't be treated like a DoS attack. These crooks make millions, of calls every year. My first employer was apparently making robocalls, though none of us were aware of it(there was a call center with actual human beings), and they were cracked down on by the FTC a few years ago. https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2017/01/ftc-announces-crackdown-two-massive-illegal-robocall-operations https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2017/01/ftc-a... The way I see it, there's no good technological reason why a system couldn't detect millions of calls coming from one place, compare that with the number of complaints and number-spoofs, and trigger an investigation. The dinosaur phone system needs to either go extinct or be reformed, and the telecom companies don't give a fuck. Every time I've asked either T-mobile or AT&T to block the relentless robocalls, they tell me to install some 3rd party Android app that fails to effectively block calls.
- kyrra 7y agoTelecoms can't block calls. They are not legally allowed to do it.
- yellow_lead 7y agoWe can and do block calls under certain circumstances, i.e from Invalid or Unallocated ANIs.
- Spare_account 7y agoThis doesn't appear to be universal then, because I've been told by Telcos in the UK and France that they will not block calls even when the presented number is impossible. It was made clear that any call that was made to one of my numbers would be delivered irrespective of any faulty components visible to me in the SIP header.
- Marsymars 7y ago
- yellow_lead 7y agoThis should get better once carriers have implemented STIR/SHAKEN. Many are currently doing testing right now.
- yellow_lead 7y agoFor more information including carriers' responses to FCC, including some of their plans, you can view here https://www.fcc.gov/call-authentication https://www.fcc.gov/call-authentication
- stjohnswarts 7y agosupposedly the big three have implemented it but you have to have certain phone models.
- ac29 7y agoT-mobile has, but its only supported on Samsung and LG phones right now: https://www.t-mobile.com/customers/mobile-security https://www.t-mobile.com/customers/mobile-security
- etxm 7y agoHad to google STIR/SHAKEN. > Secure Telephone Identity Revisited) and SHAKEN (which stands for Secure Handling of Asserted information using toKENs) The amount of bending over backwards to get that acronym to check out is impressive. It is such an engineer-named system. Looking forward to it nonetheless.
- notyourday 7y agoThe problem is enforcement. Sorry, technological solutions are not workable - there's always going to be a way to get through because there's nearly no risk of enforcement, which is where the work should concentrate. The thing is that the only reason why robocalls work is because there's a nexus before the phantom callers and real businesses buying those services and those businesses have records because they are paying money. So start chasing those records using existing playbook: Hire law firms that specialize in collecting fines. They will go through reams of paperwork and paper trails and eventually have a sheriff show up at a Thanksgiving dinner of a whoever owns the companies, after their corporate shields will be pierced, taking away chairs, pans, fridge and a turkey fryer. When that starts happening robocalls will very quickly.
- chapium 7y agoThis can be solved with keys
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Semaphor 7y agoI have a question, why are robocalls such a problem in the U.S.A.? As far as I know, they aren’t in Germany (or if they are, not on that level, I never got one).
- beerandt 7y agoIt wasn't too much of a problem, but it has escalated quickly in the last couple of years, especially with people figuring out how to change or spoof CNAM data, which is what shows up on caller ID. For a while, they'd use numbers only a couple of digits off from yours, or have a set pattern (like add 4 to each of your last 3 digits). Now people don't answer local calls, so they've moved on to neighboring area codes. I assume that some sort of software has hit the market automating the process, but I don't know.
- Semaphor 7y agoSo it’s purely the spoofing? I looked at Wikipedia, and we have "CLIP" (Calling Line Identification Presentation) and "CLIP no screening" (essentially spoofed numbers). Spoofing a number that you don’t own the rights for is a crime. So it looks like we have spoofing but only in a sane way, is the other kind of spoofing legal in the US? Or is there some other underlying problem?
- beerandt 7y agoNo, there's an increase in not-spoofed (afaik) calls too. Plus some of the callers have figured out different tricks, like multiple brief calls to bypass do-not-disturb settings, or as an attempt to get the person to call back the caller ID number. For me, at least, the calls also seem to be highly clustered, whether spoofed or not, for whatever reason. As far as I know, spoofing is left to phone company policy, which says it needs to be an associated number, like the same company or same address. I think part of the problem is they don't have a way to actually verify this for out of system calls. And technology has made setting up spam lines on small remote systems feasable. This is speculation, but I suspect it would be considered criminal fraud if it's done as part of a bigger crime. I don't think it's a crime in-and-of itself, but other than that, idk.
- OliverJones 7y agoLots of these robocalls are fraudulent. They say nonsense like they're the FBI acting on behalf of the IRS, with a warrant for my arrest. If somebody ran a scam like that through the USPS, they'd become a guest of the US Bureau of Prisons for a few years. Internet DoSers get prison time too. But not these parasites. If the scammers are offshore, an arrest or two in the customs hall at an airport will get peoples' attention. Prison time, big fines, and restitution will be a more effective deterrent than what we have today. The American Graffiti (1974) writers correctly described the current system of uncollected fines. https://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/6cac9bde-4762-41c2-8b76-264eba949940 https://getyarn.io/yarn-clip/6cac9bde-4762-41c2-8b76-264eba9... Even if hard time doesn't deter these people, a few big cases will at least let the federal government project the illusion they're doing something about it.
- colejohnson66 7y agoThe problem is also that a lot of them are not in the US. We can’t touch them usually.
- Scoundreller 7y agoUnless they leave the country. If/when they visit a country with... any... positive relations with US/Canada, pounce. And cutoff their bankers from the US financial system. India won’t be happy if it starts to lose its call-centre industry as a whole because of some bad actors. India and the US have extradition treaties. There’s a lot of ways to put on the pressure.
- dronestriker 7y ago>We can’t touch them usually. Sure we can... with drone strikes! I'm sure dead phone spammers would have 90% support from the public. The other 10% can cry their salty tears and pretend they're getting spammed to feel better!
- GrumpyNl 7y agoI have build and managed several voice systems witch all could easily be transformed to robocall machines. The biggest money makers on all those services, incoming and outgoing calls has always been the telcos.
- ikeboy 7y agoThe solution is simple, and I've proposed it before. If someone used spoofing to break the law, there's strict liability for some kind of statutory damages, say $100, applicable to everyone across the chain. I.e. I can sue Verizon for sending the call to my phone, Verizon can sue whoever connected to their network, they can sue whoever spoofed on their network, etc. This will quickly lead to networks requiring proof of authorization or at least posting some kind of bond to be allowed to spoof numbers. And there's no real downside. Nobody has a pressing need to spoof but not enough to post a bond convincing the phone networks that they won't break the law.
- stevespang 7y agoI agree, anyone, everywhere and anywhere in "the chain" is liable immediately - - that will change things promptly as Telecoms will not allow themselves to be liable . . .
- michaelt 7y agoSo if I buy a $20 prepaid cell phone for cash and use it to robocall ten of my friends, they'd share $1000?
- maaaats 7y agoThings don't happen in a vacuum, don't be so dismissive. There would probably have been put something in place to stop a $20 sim from doing these things in the first place.
- ikeboy 7y agoA network shouldn't allow a $20 prepaid cell phone to spoof numbers. Give it one number, if it starts spamming it can easily be blocked.
- michaelt 7y agoYes, my $20 prepaid cell phone would only have one number, and would be blocked after my friends report the robocalls. But whence comes the $1000 my friends are now owed, for the calls made before their complaints were filed?
- jagged-chisel 7y agoHow do I set up a system that has the phone company bill incoming callers on my behalf? I'll answer every call if I can charge them for the privilege of talking to me.
- ricebowlz420 7y ago"Many of the spoofers and robocallers the agency tries to punish are individuals and small operations, he added, which means they are at times unable to pay the full penalties." - cant pay the fine? Go to jail, you are breaking the law. Yet another example of the incompetence of the FCC and Pai
- luckydata 7y agoThe US' political system and law enforcement only serves businesses and not its citizens. Until that stops this is just another symptom of the problem.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- drtillberg 7y agoMy VOIP vendor provides a spam-scoring system for inbound calls from an outfit called TreCNAM. Needs more participation to be highly effective, but it's an idea! The VOIP vendor also enables call treatments that can require a caller to press a specific number after the call is connected, before it actually rings, and to whitelist specific legitimate callers. Together, those phone screening tool reduced rings from robocallers on my VOIP phone to a very rare event.
- smabie 7y agoWhile robocalls are annoying, what's the moral justification for making this illegal? If a person is allowed to call you, why can't a computer? Also the line is getting blurred recently, so it seems like a problematic distinction at this point in time.
- Zelphyr 7y agoBecause many, if not most of these calls are scams.
- smabie 7y agoThat’s nor a good moral justification. Most people using Tor are probably doing something illegal, but it wouldn’t follow that Tor should be illegal, would it?
- dredmorbius 7y agoBecause abuse by a very few destroys trust in and value of the system to all: [S]ince mid-2015, a consortium of engineers from phone carriers and others in the telecom industry have worked on a way to [stop call-spoofing], worried that spam phone calls could eventually endanger the whole system. “We’re getting to the point where nobody trusts the phone network,” says Jim McEachern, principal technologist at the Alliance for Telecommunications Industry Solutions (ATIS.) “When they stop trusting the phone network, they stop using it.” https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/05/how-to-stop-spam-robocalls-with-stir-shaken.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/05/how-to-stop-spam-rob...
- smabie 7y agoThat’s not a bad answer (“things that undermine trust in systems are bad”) but when generalized, can lead to undesirable results. For example using your axiom, undermining trust in a corrupt and harmful system would also be bad. Like for instance, speaking out against a repressive government regime.
- dredmorbius 7y ago
- abartl 7y agoVery simple: Telcos are incentivized to allow robocallers so that they can sell robocaller blocker services.
- tasssko 7y agoFrustrated UK user here. I hardly ever answer my phone anymore it just isn’t worth it. We get hounded by insurance, PPI, investment scams, trading scams, there is a new one going around now for windows. I don’t even answer my mobile any more just in the habit of checking voicemail and my reception catches dozens of calls a day. We have a virtual reception that charges by the call they answer and sometimes these add up to over £100/ month. Vodafone block outright scams now I basically get a call try to answer and it gets cancelled. Vodafone sent me a text regarding it. My landline is off just a voicemail box now. The telcos are dead if this continues, whatsapp, facetime, facebook, ios and android messenger, slack, hangouts, MSTeams, Wechat are how I communicate now. Is that a sign of things to come?
- ndzig 7y agoPretty sure you now regret teaching English to Indians.
- stevespang 7y agoThere should be legal requirements that all the details of these scumbags be published and available for all to see, their Soc. security no's (which cannot be changed), their photos, the DL's, they should be able to be hunted down and dealt with . . .
- tempsolution 7y agoCalling is broken. I wished Apple would just add an option "Block all calls unless their number is in contacts". It's ridiculous that this option is only available in Do Not Disturb. It's like Apple was trying to somehow profit from robo-callers. It's time to put calls into the grave. The next step needs to be something like we have for websites. You need to get a personal SSL certificate to call and it will be bound to your identity. Then whenever you call, a random certificate will be generated to authenticate yourself to the callee. The callee will verify that the anonymous root certificate of the caller wasn't revoked. And then either block the call or let it through. Robocallers would simply get their root certificate revoked and would be unable to carry out ANY other call in the name of that company until they paid the imposed fines and re-imbursed their victims for the lost time and annoyance. People creating these companies would lose the ability to obtain another certificate for another company until the previous charges are resolved. This is just a momentary brain dump, but essentially all problems in our society revolve around a lack of accountability. We have the technology to anonymously impose accountability in everything digital. Let's start using it!
- BrentOzar 7y ago> I wished Apple would just add an option "Block all calls unless their number is in contacts". They added it in iOS 13 under Settings, Phone, Silence Unknown Callers. "Calls from unknown numbers will be silenced, sent to voicemail, and displayed on the Recents list. Incoming calls will continue to ring from people in your contacts, recent outgoing calls, and Siri Suggestions."
- Ntrails 7y agoJfc the last thing i want is a fucking voicemail, to listen to the tortuous preamble of robo voice saying the source phone number before listening to that empty click.
- artursapek 7y agoIn my experience they never leave voicemails. The only ones I've gotten were some shit in Chinese that I get once in a while (917 area code)
- anongraddebt 7y agoI once needed to get my own health insurance plan for three months. I googled "short term health insurance" and went to one of the first websites I found. I put in my contact info ONCE. For the next six weeks I had maybe 75+ health insurance brokers calling me and texting me. Just blowing up my phone at all hours of the day. Some would try and make contact multiple times so I'd block their numbers from call and text. They would then switch phone numbers. I ended up having 50+ numbers on my block list. I was so frustrated I just decided to pay out of pocket for all my medical expenses those three months.
- YeahSureWhyNot 7y agoinstead of increasing taxes on middle class the govt could tax every phone call just 1 cent and eradicate this problem while pulling in revenue.
- dredmorbius 7y agoEven the assessed fines are manifestly too small. The WSJ article cites estimate of up to 48 billion robocalls made in 2018. $208 million is $0.005 per call. Fines need to be several times higher. And collected. As many others in this thread have said: make this the telcos' problem. They'll solve it.
- paulie_a 7y agoEveryone that works for a robocalling firm should be arrested down to the person that answers the phone. The phone companies should be fined 100k per illegal call. They have done nothing to stop fraud. At this point they are complacent
- paulie_a 7y agoI've asked my provider to just block Texas and Florida and they refuse. I don't know anyone that lives in those states. I've tried a new method when I have the time. I waste their time. Ask a lot of questions so they have to explain things. Play dumb. Keep them on the phone for as long as you can
- EGreg 7y agoWhy are we still using the legacy phone system when there is VOIP all over the place? None of the apps and networks have this issue. All mobile phones connect to VOIP. We should have been upgrading from the phone like we did with faxes.
- toss1 7y agoObviously, from only the headline, issuing fines is failing to do the work, with a shortfall on the scale of 5 orders of magnitude. The FCC needs to start criminal prosecutions, including for officers in the major carriers who continue to enable these crimes. The massive scale of the waste of resources in unconscionable, even beyond the scale of the illegal scams. This is not a hard technical problem to solve, only requires a bit of will. Perhaps implement a system of verified call call sources, all un-verified call sources pay 10¢/call -- probably instantly uneconomical. Until then, jail for these criminals, and by that, I mean the officers of the scam companies, not the call center workers
- etxm 7y agoThese have gotten outrageous. The WhiteStone health calls are incessant, I can’t even begin to comprehend how much money they are scamming if they can afford to pay people to do the volume of calls they are making. Theyre also nabbing a legitimate companies identity. [1] I got called by them 13 times in one day. Requested to be put on DNC list (obviously a waste of breath). The numbers are seem random. I don’t know if they are spoofing them somehow or if carriers sell short access to numbers but they do the first N characters of your number trick. I decided to go ahead and “get scammed” and walk through as much of the call as possible and the bullshit detection of these callers is PHENOMENAL. We will get through a few questions with me trying to answer to sound like I’m interested and then eventually you’ll get a ~“fuck you man” and they’ll hang up on you. These MFs need to be shot into a brick wall on a rocket sled. 1- https://www.linkedin.com/posts/whitestone-healthcare-llc_we-wanted-to-post-on-our-page-here-as-well-activity-6595332022019899394-v5iN https://www.linkedin.com/posts/whitestone-healthcare-llc_we-...
- hinkley 7y agoWhy doesn't my phone have a 'report spam' button that is reported to the carrier?
- lukebuehler 7y agoA lot of people point out that telecom companies should do something but aren't because it's lucrative for them or too expensive to fix. Are telecom companies not realizing how much they are hurting themselves with this in the long term? People will stop using phone numbers altogether. Using the phone has become such a pain, at least in the US, that whenever I can, I used different ways of communicating. WhatsApp, iMesage, Skype, etc. The incessant robocalls have definitely motivated me to move away from traditional phone calls faster than I would otherwise. Lastly, maybe this is what these companies want, i.e., that I just use their data plan, but then that makes me way less likely to stay loyal.
- hatsunearu 7y agoYeah but phone companies are still selling you the data plans.
- austhrow743 7y agoHow is loyalty a concern if they're all doing it? Who are you going to go to?
- jlarocco 7y agoIs there a reason the FCC can't fine the telecoms for allowing the illegal calls? My guess is they'd fix the problem pretty quick.
- adrr 7y agoThey could easily fine the carrier that is interconnecting the robo callers. The telecom lobby doesn’t want to fix the issues since they make money from robo callers and also selling services to block the robo callers.
- galangalalgol 7y agoThe souce may very well be outdide the US, with no sure way to spot spam. I'm all against imperial hegemony and all, but i doubt the UN eould care if they sent some stealth bombers after the spamers.
- nomadadon 7y agoBet campaign contributions are going great though
- Trias11 7y agoWe need to give power against robocallers back to citizens! #wedontcallfcc
- khyveasna 7y agoGDP to make sure you got
- teddyh 7y agoSo many knee-jerk “obvious” solutions in comments here, some with gratuitous violent fantasies to boot. Might I suggest that you look at how your proposed solution compares to other, older, suggestion on how the then-new email spam problem used to be suggested to be fixed: https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt Also, this is a mostly exclusively a U.S. problem. In Europe, we basically just don’t ever get “robocalls”, and have ever only heard about them in stories from the U.S. Anyone proposing a complicated technological change should explain why this is necessary when Europe seems to have found a solution already.
- ikeboy 7y agoThere's no real email spoofing problem anymore because we have signatures proving the source on every email. There's a phone spoofing problem because carriers are allowing spoofing, when they don't have to.
- teddyh 7y ago> * There's no real email spoofing problem anymore because we have signatures proving the source on every email.* (I assume that you are referring to DKIM, and not OpenPGP or S/MIME, since the latter two are obviously not frequently used.) DKIM signatures (not to mention DMARC to actually require a signature) are not actually that common either. Spoofing is mostly still rejected by a combination of plain old SPF and spam filtering of the mail contents. All in my experience, of course. > There's a phone spoofing problem because carriers are allowing spoofing, when they don't have to. Is this what Europe is doing which the U.S. isn’t? If it is, then you’re probably right. I don’t actually know. I’m just saying that whatever Europe is doing is evidently working, and any other proposed solution would have some significant benefit and proof of efficacy to be considered over a proven concept.
- hippich 7y agoWho is paying for the incoming call in Europe (honest question)? If it is caller only - perhaps it is a reason? In my home country, where receiver of the call does not pay for the call, robocalling would be uterly unprofitable.
- mullingitover 7y agoI would love it if smartphones were offered with the option to opt out of a legacy phone number, and instead just a data plan. most of the calls I receive are marking or pure attempts at fraud.
- throwawayjava 7y agoYou can get a data-only SIM on most carriers. It won't save you much money.
- mullingitover 7y agoAs the saying goes, it's not about the money. It's about sending a message.
- lukejduncan 7y agoWhy is it not possible to get a “phone” with data and no phone number?
- scythe 7y agoLots of clever ideas about catching robocallers with technology here. But I don't think that technology is the solution. I suggest placing bounties. Information leading to the assessment of a fine will result in a proportional reward to the informant. Someone knows who is making these calls. We just have to get them to talk.
- droithomme 7y agoInteresting. How much did it cost the taxpayers to collect the $6790?
- throwaway35784 7y agoIt's darling startups like twilio that enable this. We love them and hate what they do.
- coding123 7y agoJail time instead then?
- pearapps 7y agoWeird because I am pretty sure if I don't pay my bills I go to jail