19 ms·
RMS was defending his friend who, at the age of 74, is accused of having sex with a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island. There is not a defense
by colechristensen 7y ago
RMS was defending his friend who, at the age of 74, is accused of having sex with a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island.
There is not a defense for what RMS was writing or how he was trying to defend Minsky.
The prevalence of comments trying to turn this against "SJW"s or whatever "other" they can because they're a fan of RMS is disturbing.
This isn't us vs. them.
This is a man who said something wildly inappropriate in an MIT forum and got fired. He deserved it. Defending him by pointing towards people who overreact to things is a bit terrible.
The firing was appropriate and reasonable, not a response to extremists, zealots, or some other kind of witch.
I welcome anyone to provide a counter-argument.
- lostjohnny 7y ago> RMS was defending his friend who, at the age of 74, is accused of having sex with a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island. That's not what happened.
- colechristensen 7y agoRMS defending his friend was happening Minsky was accused, and those are the details. It doesn't matter if it didn't happen, RMS was defending Minsky in the situation that it did by saying the girl who was less than a quarter of his age would have appeared willing. That gets you fired. Even if it is entirely hypothetical.
- NhanH 7y agoI don't see it as RMS defending his friend. He was purely concerned with making the correct accusation. Some people considers that as "defending", which might have never been his intention. Why would he be concerned with such details if not for defending Minsky? He is weird, and pendatic. But that we knew for a long time.
- xwolfi 7y agoHe's insufferable, you mean. They don't give a rat's ass what he actually said or thought, they wanted him out for so long they couldn't believe their luck he decided to publicly redefine the morality of statutory rape on a corporate mailing list. Some people do software, like Linus Torvalds, other linger for decades doing nothing and discuss the value of rape. Hope we'll hear less of his nonsense in the future.
- lostjohnny 7y ago> RMS defending his friend was happening Although it looks like you really believe that's what happened, it is not what happened. And no amount of repetitions can change the fact that he did not "defend his friend from rape accusations". > It doesn't matter if it didn't happen It kinda matters though... > That gets you fired. Even if it is entirely hypothetical. And that's absurd. We always arrive at the same conclusion. EDIT: can I ask you why all these comments look the same? it kinda looks like a pattern to me... https://imgur.com/a/Wm92IDQ https://imgur.com/a/Wm92IDQ
- iaml 7y agoYou wrote 'it is not what happened' twice now, but don't offer another point of view on what did happen. That's not how argument works.
- lostjohnny 7y agoBut id didn't. He just expresses on honest opinion on the matter. Like he always did all of his life. > That's not how argument works. To prove you wrong I don't have to prove an alternative scenario. You are wrong, that's enough.
- iaml 7y agoYour definition of 'wrong' is certainly agreeable but not exactly relevant in this situation. Yes, technically RMS was just being nitpicky, but in the context it doesn't matter. The comment was inappropriate and any person in RMS's place has to understand that because of their high profile everything they say/do can and will be used against them. Those are the rules of the game (public relations), and if you don't play the game (like RMS), the game will play you.
- lostjohnny 7y ago> Your definition of 'wrong' is certainly agreeable It's just what it is, he wasn't defending his friend, which, BTW, is not even accused of raping anybody. > The comment was inappropriate Like this is new for RMS... I never said he is not weird, I've said he never supported or praised or defended rapists. That's enough to prove who said it wrong. It's all in the transcripts, it's all there, word by word. > Those are the rules of the game (public relations), But he's not a PR. He has never been.
- vorpalhex 7y agoAnd never shall a man accused of treason have a lawyer, for to defend someone who is accused of treason (and therefore has likely committed treason) is itself an act of treason, is it not? And surely to defend a rapist, even an accused one, is nearly as bad as being a rapist? Why, perhaps we should skip the courts all together and simply tar and feather them in the public. That's worked out well historically...
- colechristensen 7y agoHe resigned. He was asked to resign because it's a good play for MIT, you don't have to defend against a wrongful termination suit if the person in question willingly resigns. If he wanted to defend himself, he would have stayed and fought, let himself get fired, file a lawsuit. But he resigned, willingly.
- gwd 7y ago> If he wanted to defend himself, he would have stayed and fought, let himself get fired, file a lawsuit. But he resigned, willingly. Or possibly, because both the SFC [1] and the head of the GNOME foundation [2] said that they would find it unacceptable to work with the FSF as long as Stallman was still the leader, he realized there was no way staying on would be possible. [1] https://sfconservancy.org/news/2019/sep/16/rms-does-not-speak-for-us/ https://sfconservancy.org/news/2019/sep/16/rms-does-not-spea... [2] https://blog.halon.org.uk/2019/09/gnome-foundation-relationship-gnu-fsf/ https://blog.halon.org.uk/2019/09/gnome-foundation-relations...
- sangnoir 7y agoTo be fair, it is morally absurd to define ‘fired’ in a way that depends on minor details such as which country it was in or whether the victim was asked to resign or volunteered on their own volition.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 7y agoThis isn't in the courts.
- jacquesm 7y agoI actually haven't seen Minsky being accused. That court transcript says that she was 'directed to have sex' with Minsky but nowhere does it say she did and there is an eyewitness claiming he - Minsky - turned her down. So RMS is defending his deceased friend as though he was accused, it would have been more effective to question the accusation rather than to defend as though it had happened.
- xwolfi 7y agoI would have said: I take upon myself to guarantee my friend never touched that poor girl, and he always felt horrified she was exploited so. He said: The girl was most likely willing, and it's morally imprecise to call this a rape, at worst it would be a statutory rape. Who gets respect, who gets fired ? :D
- boring_twenties 7y ago> He said: The girl was most likely willing He very clearly did not say that, he said the girl was most likely presented to him as willing. How is it you've made half a dozen posts in a thread about this without even bothering to read what you're commenting about?
- jacquesm 7y ago> How is it you've made half a dozen posts in a thread about this without even bothering to read what you're commenting about? Par for the course, ditto everybody else that did not bother to read the court transcript. It's 200+ pages but doublespaced, you can go over the whole thing in an hour or two, it makes you wonder how Epstein ever managed to avoid being jailed for a long time. I'll bet that before this whole thing is over there will be many more 'names' that end up disgraced or worse.
- balaksakrionon 7y ago> The girl was most likely willing Why do you feel compelled to paraphrase (and in the process lie)?
- 7y ago
- base698 7y agoCare to elaborate?
- syrrim 7y agoHe disagreed with the wording "assault" which he felt was ambiguous. He would almost certainly have been fine with the wording "had sex with a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island". I'm sure a number of other wordings that call into question said girl's consent, the legal status of said girl on said private island with regards to sex, and so on would have been fine as well.
- roguecoder 7y agoThat is what “defending” means: he took objection to what Minsky allegedly did being accurately characterised as assault and a crime. Plenty of criminals take objection to their crimes being described as crimes, but “men should be allowed to have sex with underaged girls” is a particularly self-serving and gross position for a man in a position of power over young women to take.
- qaq 7y agofor it to be accurate you have to look into the laws of a given jurisdiction. If you take EU 17 is age of consent in all countries but Vatican and Malta with a significant portion being significantly lower.
- wott 7y ago> If you take EU 17 is age of consent in all countries There is no age of consent in France. (However there are aggravating thresholds if there was a crime: under 18 if committed by someone with authority over the victim, under 15 for other cases.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- borski 7y agoTo be fair, I don’t think he said it wasn’t a crime. He simply didn’t think it equated to the same moral depravity as sexual (physical) assault, hence why he thought it should have a different term to describe it. Not defending it, but characterizing his words correctly in context.
- ixtli 7y agoLet's be honest, the people who disagree with your comment are worried that eventually someone will out them for their terrible behavior as well! It's shocking to me how unaccustomed to being held accountable some people are. Here's a radical supposition: it's actually good when speech has consequences in society.
- linksnapzz 7y agoI'm totally certain you've sifted properly all possible consequences, as well as what does and does not constitute accountability....
- hutzlibu 7y agoWelcome to online witch hunt. Anyone defending the witch is probably a witch as well. How about a rational debate concerning factual things? I have allmost no background information, knew RMS only as the weird FSF guru .. and it is very hard for me to find facts. Most of the debate is about other stuff, than what actually happened. edit: so apparently all of it started with this: https://medium.com/@selamie/remove-richard-stallman-fec6ec210794 https://medium.com/@selamie/remove-richard-stallman-fec6ec21... A rant by a female MIT student, offended by something she rad of RMS she did not know before. She writes very emotional, but much better, in terms of facts, than what vice etc. made out of it
- ixtli 7y ago> rational debate > factual things its getting increasingly boring to have to engage with people who don't see the irony in a belief that they can be an objective observer of what is "factual" and "rational" in their lives.
- hutzlibu 7y agoYeah yeah, all information is through a subjective bubble, we can only make approximations to truth, blah blah. Save your thoughts for beginners philosophy course. That is nothing new. Of couse "factual" means, "as factual as possible". Meaning all the accusations, which apparently have been written, listed clearly.
- craigsmansion 7y agoRMS was pointing out inaccuracies in how a deceased colleague who was being accused of a heinous crime might simply have slept with a prostitute, if at all (which turns out probably wasn't the case). > This is a man who said something wildly inappropriate in an MIT forum and got fired. This is a man who said something mildly inappropriate in a forum, as is his wont. > He deserved it. A completely appropriate and reasonable verdict, no doubt. Doubts are for unreasonable people, of which one you are not. > I welcome anyone to provide a counter-argument. Somehow I doubt that.
- colechristensen 7y agoFrom the thread in question: >When this email chain inevitably finds its way into the press, the seeming insensitivity of some will reflect poorly on the entire CSAIL community. Regardless of intent, this thread reads as "grasping at straws to defend our friends" around potential involvement with Epstein, and that isn't a reputation I would like attached to my CSAIL affiliation. What do you think as an administrator if you see a comment like that about one of your prominent employees?
- chx 7y agoHe resigned from the CSAIL too. https://stallman.org/archives/2019-jul-oct.html#16_September_2019_(Resignation) https://stallman.org/archives/2019-jul-oct.html#16_September...
- rrss 7y ago> pointing out inaccuracies But, he wasn't? 1. "Minsky has been accused of assault" 2. RMS: "you shouldn't call it assault - might give people the wrong idea" 3. "It would have been literally rape in the relevant territory, 'assault' is a fine word for it" 4. RMS: "ok, even if it's legally rape, it shouldn't morally be considered rape, so don't call it assault if it was 'just' statutory rape." What inaccuracies did he point out? I see that he expressed his opinion that 'assault' is too strong a word for some cases of rape, but what inaccuracy was there in the original statement regarding the allegations about minsky?
- eloff 7y agoHow is it we value free speech, but there are certain discussions you just cannot have, even in a rational and measured way, without risking making yourself completely unemployable. You should be able to have a questionable viewpoint in a discussion, without worrying about the lynch mob ending your career. The consequences here are out of line. You can be reprimanded to take your discussions to a non company venue, in a situation like this, but fired is over the top. Stallman said “it is morally absurd to define ‘rape’ in a way that depends on minor details such as which country it was in or whether the victim was 18 years old or 17.” It's pretty clear with the age difference being what it is, this is exactly what statutory rape laws are for. But it is also incongruous that somehow if she was a year older it would be ok. It's also fucked up that if Minsky were 19, the consequences would be the same. Maybe there's a better law to be had here, but how would we ever know if you can't even have the discussion? I'm appalled by how free speech is under attack lately by the outrage machine.
- lanevorockz 7y agoCompletely agree with you and it makes me depressed that we are living on an age that we are giving up the imperfectness of humans in exchange for fake puritanism on a standard that cannot be achieved by anyone. I bet everyone here has one opinion that can definitely and very quickly destroy their lives. Let people be wrong, let them speak, let them think ... We can then convince and converge into a common good. Cancelling the guy that gave his life for the cause is appalling and is showing how evil social media is.
- widowlark 7y ago... MIT fired him not Facebook - you are not required to have perfect opinions that everyone agrees with to survive in this world, you are just required to voice them appropriately and at the correct times, which Stallman did not. Stop pretending that Free Speech is something that applies to anything other than citizens having protection from governments
- dangxiaopin 7y ago
- lanevorockz 7y agoStop the cancel culture .. LEARN TO SPEAK WITH PEOPLE YOU DISAGREE WITH ! You fake belief that you are perfect is the exact reason you will be cancelled if you ever succeed in anything
- mieseratte 7y ago> I welcome anyone to provide a counter-argument. Here's a counter. You're ascribing intent to one's writing, and unless you have a special relationship with Mr. Stallman - you don't know anything. Because of a radical, illiberal mob, Stallman's life's work has been taken from him. Few years ago I had had a Junior engineer on my team begin telling me how he finds certain speech so intolerable that he feels he has the right to assault someone for saying it. This is the reasoning behind these kinds of mob justices. So now I see a mob hurting yet another life, not because of real-world conduct, but because of speech. I see real-world destruction wrought because of speech. What never occurred to this young man was that there exist people who find the suppression of speech to be what is truly intolerable in this world. That this form of group-think is truly destructive, that actions are of consequence, not speech. Do pray the pendulum never swings in your direction.
- colechristensen 7y agoThe statements I see stand on their own. Supposing intent behind them isn't necessary. What they say is damning regardless of intent. And the intent was pretty obvious.
- yibg 7y agoDivining intent isn’t the right threshold to judge speech. If it were then I can say whatever I want in whatever environment, because how would you prove my intent? I yell fire in a crowded theatre, that’s ok it wasn’t my intent to cause panic.
- ng12 7y agoOnly because your words caused actionable harm. If you didn't intend to cause harm and there were no harmful consequences should you still be punished?
- joshuamorton 7y agoShould drunk driving be legal as long as you don't crash?
- amyjess 7y agoWhat he said, for posterity: > "The most plausible scenario is that she presented herself to him as entirely willing," Stallman wrote in his post last Wednesday. "Assuming she was being coerced by Epstein, he would have had every reason to tell her to conceal that from most of his associates. I’ve concluded from various examples of accusation inflation that it is absolutely wrong to use the term 'sexual assault' in an accusation." Source: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/09/17/richard_stallman_interview/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/09/17/richard_stallman_in... [and in my opinion: it's the last sentence that made his statement wildly inappropriate. It's one thing if he wanted to raise the possibility that Minsky was deceived, and while incorrect it would be excusable, but his last sentence is a belligerent assumption of bad faith, and it is highly inappropriate for him to use such absolute language in denying sexual assault]
- ZeroGravitas 7y agoHis use of "plausible" is interesting here. It is plausible that she wouldn't announce that she was a blackmail-trap/underaged sex worker/trafficked slave or whatever. It's not plausible that an 17 year old would be propositioning old men without any external influence in this situation. I think he's strongly implying this and that's part of what got the strong reaction. I'd suggest due to that, the statement is dodgy even before you get to the bit you highlight.
- bluecalm 7y agoWell, he could have assumed she is paid for it and does it for money. I mean, I agree that remote island full of underage girls throwing themselves at old men raise questions and most reasonable men would conclude it's too likely to be coercion rather than voluntary sex work to get involved but I still think it's not ridiculous to have discussion about it. I also happen to agree with Stallman about the wording. If you call any activity that constitutes statutory rape in some jurisdictions a sexual assault you're doing disservice to people who experience what is more commonly understood as assault as that devalues the term and the suffering that comes from it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cf141q5325 7y ago>RMS was defending his friend who, at the age of 74, is accused of having sex with a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island. Which until a few years ago was completely legal in for example Switzerland. As long of course as no one is coerced into anything. Playing the Advocatus Diaboli, why should i view this outcry as anything different then the Saudis stance on sex before marriage? Fundamentalist puritans being opposed to self determination shaming others into conformism? Its not like the US where you cant drink until you are 21, but get to join the army with 18, where sex ed is often reduced to abstinence only, where the government does its best to infringe into womens right to get abortions, where you can be prosecuted for sexting as a minor and lets not forgett where sex workers are almost across the country criminalized has any moral high ground on the topic what so ever. But thats besides the point. First the MIT donation and now this stuff over 3 corners. How about we focus on what actually is the problem here? How many people from both parties had connections to not a brothel owner but someone involved in human trafficking and coercing minors into sexwork? How he got away with this this despite being brought infront of a judge for it? Or why they were on that island in the first place and why Eppstein apparently invited so many people. The word compromat comes to mind. But these politicians arent so easy targets, people like Stallman or the guy at MIT are. The mob wants blood and it doesnt seem to matter whos. I would recommend checking your moral compass if you are at threat of being sued for slander after the discussion here.
- colechristensen 7y agoThere isn't a situation where a 74 year old has sexual contact with a 17 year old on a billionaire's private island in which everyone is willing and happy with what is happening. It is extremely doubtful that a young woman would find herself in that situation in any other way than a long path of abuse and desperation. Taking advantage of that young woman is immoral. That isn't some puritanical, anti-sex philosophy that hates fun. That is empathy to the all too common situation of young vulnerable women being used for pleasure.
- blub 7y agoIn Berlusconi's ~75yo case he was acquitted of having sex with a 17yo because the "fact is not a crime". Then he was accused of bribing witnesses 10 million €, so I guess we have to wait and see. Definitely morally dubious, especially in his case. It's not clear if the girl did it for money, or was more or less nudged into this by her life circumstances.
- kazinator 7y ago> The firing was appropriate and reasonable, not a response to extremists, zealots, or some other kind of witch. In a country where the current president was elected on a platform of "grab them by the pussy"? Ha.
- atomashpolskiy 7y ago> RMS was defending his friend who, at the age of 74, is accused So what? Lawyers do this all the time. Is it really important that the person accused was Stallman's friend? Also, what's exactly wrong with an argument that one should not conflate "having sex with Bob" with "sexually assaulting Bob"?
- austincheney 7y agoI think RMS made a completely faulty argument and doesn't understand the world assault, which calls into question his state of mind. That said, I don't really see how this is grounds for termination. Again, I am not defending the guy or his utterly bizarre opinion on the matter. He had a disagreeable personal opinion and wrote it out load... so what? He wasn't advocating for harm of any person, persons, or group. People are way too sensitive and we are giving away far too much to save face among people who aren't worth the effort. If I were king for a day and ran some kind of public facing organization here is how I would manage these things: 1. Anybody who communicates or advocates harm to any person, persons, or group gets a naughty warning. On the second offense they are permanently banned, terminated, or what ever. 2. Anybody who communicates offense or defensive language (cry babies) gets their post flagged (suppressed and locked). Sad people feed trolls. They are not hostile, but they are still part of the problem. I am sure they have all kinds of wonderful justifications, but I don't care. This would allow people to disagree within bounds of acceptable behavior while also preventing mass hysteria and echo chamber insanity.
- nikanj 7y agoThe last person who tried providing counter-arguments just got fired from MIT.
- anonuser123456 7y ago>This is a man who said something wildly inappropriate in an MIT forum and got fired In my opinion, you are conflating inappropriate statements with statements to which you disagree. The university campus is where minds should go to get challenged by different and somewhat uncomfortable opinions. RMS presents different and uncomfortable opinions in spades. But he does not present them in an inappropriate way. The thread RMS was responding to was explicitly political and opinion based. It was absolutely fair game for his response. As an example, when I attended university, I took a class (Anthro 2A) where the material presented pedophilia as normal behavior in the context of certain cultural customs. I personally disagree with that research, but I didn't call for the instructor to be fired. Cultural relativism is an important concept that should be thought about even if one disagrees. But the actual Stallman/MIT kerfluffle is actually not that big a deal IMO. The bigger deal is the mob acting on deceptive reporting by Vice & DailyBeast. It's one thing to say that Stallman's factual statements on Minsky were inappropriate. It's another to conflate them with statements on Epstein. The vast majority of the outrage is based on the reporting that makes Stallman appear sympathetic to Epstein which is a complete fabrication. It is literally 'fake news'.
- dangerface 7y ago> This isn't us vs. them. The discussion is between free speech and appropriate speech. Which is both sides have tribes supporting them Libertarian vs SJW. You might not see the divide but every one else does and you can see that. > The prevalence of comments trying to turn this against "SJW"s or whatever "other" You might not agree with or recognise the tribes but they exist. > This is a man who said something wildly inappropriate in an MIT forum and got fired. MIT is a university its a public place where adults go to seek truth, if this is an inappropriate place for adults to discuss adult subjects then where is? I get the argument it's not "public" because the land is privately owned but it is a place where the public gather. While I frequently see this argument it is never accompanied with what would be an appropriate public venue for adults to discuss inappropriate things.
- lazyjones 7y ago> The firing was appropriate and reasonable, not a response to extremists, zealots, or some other kind of witch. Many people, including you, have lost their grasp for the concept of different moral attitudes. The above is just your opinion, not mine. I do not agree with it and find it irritating that you consider your moral judgement an argument that requires to be countered.
- throwaway913 7y agoI only wish all the other pedo/rape apologists were as dumb and and socially inept as RMS and the people posting here. It would make it a lot easier to root them out. People are panicking now because Epstein finally got taken out and there are probably thousands of people guilty of Rape who can be hunted down because of their connections to Epstein. The last thing they want is to be publicly defending anything even closely related to this because it draws more attention to them. RMS is an idiot. Now the mob will be pouring over every inch of his life to see what they can pin on him. That is what these people deserve though. Epstein died way to easy and the mob is still hungry for blood.
- mighty_bander 7y ago> his friend who ... is accused It's the accused that is the problem with this. He isn't defending the proven actions of a pervert, he is defending the memory of a dead friend, suggesting that his friend was incapable of the crime of which he is accused. If defending an accused friend is now itself punishable by excision from society, then the effect of an accusation alone becomes immediate isolation. The presumption of innocence, not only in court, but in public discourse, is a vital component of a genuinely free society. I will not support people who reject it.
- james-mcelwain 7y agoThere is absolutely no obligation to presume innocence in our personal opinions. We are all freely permitted to form our own opinions based on the facts of the situation. There are good reasons that our legal systems favor the accused -- ones that I _fully_ support -- but it is an unreasonably high epistemic standard for us to operate under in our daily lives. If I don't want to associate with someone because they're an asshole, I'm under no obligation to prove so beyond a reasonable doubt. My freedom of association is more fundamental.
- colechristensen 7y agoThat he was defending his dead friend isn't the issue. He was defending statutory rape and taking advantage of vulnerable young women - it does not matter whether the actual event happened or not. RMS was defending rape in a very public forum and got fired.
- zby 7y agoCome on - if I accuse you of being 74 and having sex with a a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island - then nobody can defend you? Minsky is dead and he cannot defend himself, the girl said she was directed to have sex with him - but she did not say she eventually did it, she did answer a question about where she went to do that and she answered that which would imply that she had sex with him - but it is entirely possible that she meant the place where she was directed to do it, but eventually failed, there is a witness saying that he turned her down. These are the facts from the deposition and it is fair to point them out. There is another aspect of his emails - he also wrote that she presented herself as willing and that was entirely misquoted as 'she was willing', which was unfair. Stallman's point was that it is a bit misleading to characterise the act as 'assault' if it was she who sought out Minsky and he was not aware of the fact that she was coerced by Epstein. This is a bit insensitive splitting hair - but the misquoting was really mean.
- bandrami 7y agoErr... anyone can defend him. The fact that RMS did defend him is prima facie evidence that he was able to defend him. Now, most people would mount a defense along the lines of "I don't believe Minsky would have sex with trafficked girls". RMS, always with the innovative methods, decided "Maybe it's not so bad to have sex with trafficked underage girls". But, like it or not, he was clearly capable of making that defense. So I don't know where "can't defend" is coming from.
- zby 7y agoI am not a native English speaker - should I use 'nobody is allowed to defend' instead? He was punished for defending his friend and the parent post justifies that: "RMS was defending his friend who, at the age of 74, is accused of having sex with a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island. There is not a defense for what RMS was writing or how he was trying to defend Minsky. ... The firing was appropriate and reasonable, not a response to extremists, zealots, or some other kind of witch." As if it was enough to defend someone accused of some crime to be guilty as well. This is clearly absurd - so I am trying to get the author to explain what he really meant.
- shams93 7y agoI do a great job do triple overtime and get fired so they can save money it's hard to feel sorry for celebrities when us ordinaries are trashed so hard in the course of regular work why should I feel sorry for Epstein when the industry treats me as trash disposable labor it's refreshing that people are standing up for women finally.
- nailer 7y agoThe issue is that the girl was 17. Who owned the island is not relevant, how much money they make is not relevant, and whether they're Stallman's friend is not relevant to either the morality or legality of the matter. Being wealthy or old is not a crime. Stallman's controversial comment was: > “it is morally absurd to define ‘rape’ in a way that depends on minor details such as which country it was in or whether the victim was 18 years old or 17.” Whether you agree or disagree that is a reasonable statement to make.
- dmitrygr 7y agothis is a very very very dangerous viewpoint that you are expressing, and I very much hope that you are over simplifying. Because if you really think that somebody needs to be fired, for stating a point completely unrelated to their job, then that is a problem that we, as a society, need to address urgently. Everyone is allowed to believe anything they damn well please. They are even allowed to state it. There should not be a viewpoint holding which makes one unemployable. because as soon as that exists, there is no freedom of speech, only a caricature of it. freedom of speech is not about saying things that everyone agrees with. It is about saying things everyone disagrees with. and yes, speech comes with consequences. But those should be doled out logically, not by an angry mob forcing an institution's hand. The common argument that I hear is that free speech does not come free of consequences. Fine. But those should be clear and well defined. Not decided by a mob at any given moment. If you want to clearly state that you will not employ anyone who holds the following views, that is okay with me. But firing somebody because the mob demanded it, is against the very idea of freedom of speech
- james-mcelwain 7y ago> Because if you really think that somebody needs to be fired, for stating a point completely unrelated to their job, then that is a problem that we, as a society, need to address urgently. The issue is not voicing an opinion in private -- it's voicing it on an institutional mailing list in his capacity as a member of that institution.
- dmitrygr 7y agoLike I said: clearly specify which opinions your employees are not allowed to hold, and that is okay. Arbitrarily deciding this AFTER they have already expressed the opinion is terrible. Deciding post-facto smells of favoritism and can never be proven to be fair. It also creates a chilling effect since nobody ever knows what is and is not ok to say, since at any point in time AFTER the fact you might decide it is not ok.
- james-mcelwain 7y ago
- peternicky 7y agoI find your comment and it’s tone as “absolute” fact to be disturbing.
- hoorayimhelping 7y ago>I welcome anyone to provide a counter-argument. You're justifying the actions a lynch mob. Why does anyone need to provide a counter point? The onus is on you to explain why you think a mob taking justice into their own hands is okay. The only justification I can find is that he said something inappropriate. Who are you to decide what's appropriate? Are you the arbiter of morality for the entire world? >This is a man who said something wildly inappropriate in an MIT forum and got fired. He deserved it. Defending him by pointing towards people who overreact to things is a bit terrible. Completely missing the point of the outrage. It's the chilling effect of people silencing views they don't like that really freaks people out, pisses them off and makes them mad. The actual views in play are irrelevant - the issue is that some person was uncomfortable at something some other person said, so they silenced the man's ability to say it. Not just that, they took away his vitality and ability to support himself. Anyone with any kind of functional critical reasoning facilities can instantly understand why this is scary. It sets a precedent that completely removes the ability to have non mainstream opinions. If you think the wrong way, the progressive mob will make you seem unemployable. Because you had the audacity to say something "inappropriate," (oh also the mob determines what's appropriate and inappropriate on the fly).
- colechristensen 7y ago> You're justifying the actions a lynch mob. No I'm not. I also don't think the outcome had anything to do with the mob. There were plenty of people even before the mob knew anything, who took strong exception to what RMS was saying. > Who are you to decide what's appropriate? Are you the arbiter of morality for the entire world? I'm not. MIT decided what was appropriate for their organization and the moral behavior of its employee and associate. I am making what I think is a pretty universal moral statement in that old men taking advantage of young women for sexual pleasure is very wrong. > It sets a precedent that completely removes the ability to have non mainstream opinions. These aren't just "non-mainstream opinions" he was defending actions which most western societies consider rape. This isn't some slippery slope where people can't say anything nonconformist, this is a situation where people don't want to be associated with you when you publicly defend taking advantage of vulnerable, abused young women.
- corey_moncure 7y agoRMS stood for a world where we have the right to know and modify the code that runs on our machines. A world where we have the freedom to access ideas and discuss them. He battled for decades to protect the freedom of you and me, and he asks nothing in return. He was such an unfailing bulwark against the forces that would deprive us of our rights that his name is practically synonymous with the free software movement. He took a position in a discussion you disagree with, so you're OK with him being removed from his organizations and his name dragged through the mud. Your argument stands for a world where people deserve to be stripped of their position because they expressed an opinion you disagree with. Even if you're completely 100% right, how do 'indefensible opinions' get challenged if they cannot be expressed? How do any of us learn or improve? Has anyone taken a moment to think, what comes next now that he's gone? I hope for your sake and mine that the accomplishments of the GNU and FSF will be enough to keep us free.
- prepend 7y ago> said something wildly inappropriate in an MIT forum I don’t think what he said was wildly inappropriate for the forum. It’s an open discussion forum. People not understanding and being offended is not something that RMS or a reasonable poster could predict or prevent. I read through the entire thread and it’s not as bad as people are interpreting. I think people are inferring intent and meaning that just isn’t there. I’m pretty disappointed in FSF.
- ajnin 7y agoWhy is it wrong to defend someone that is accused of something ? Does an accusation equate to culpability ? He defended him by doubting that he did the things he's accused of, not by excusing those things. Yes, this bashing is totally unreasonable, he expressed an opinion that the charge against Minsky is not valid. One party makes an accusation, it's a perfectly acceptable thing to do for the other party to counter it. Accusation is not the same thing as proof. There is a category of accusations these days that are just the same as a jury sentence, if you're labeled, then you're done. No evidence, witness saying this didn't happen ? Still guilty.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- yoavm 7y agoIt's frustrating and hard to find real information regarding what he did say and what he did not say, so I feel I shouldn't play the judge here. I did find this direct quote of him on his website, and it doesn't sound to me, from reading this piece, that he was trying to defend Minsky: > Headlines say that I defended Epstein. Nothing could be further from the truth. I've called him a "serial rapist", and said he deserved to be imprisoned. https://stallman.org/archives/2019-jul-oct.html#14_September_2019_(Statements_about_Epstein) https://stallman.org/archives/2019-jul-oct.html#14_September... I do not think this changes everything, but if this is indeed his honest opinion, then I do feel that he might have simply communicated his opinions very poorly.
- ryangee 7y ago> It's frustrating and hard to find real information regarding what he did say and what he did not say I got your back: https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/9ke3ke/famed-computer-scientist-richard-stallman-described-epstein-victims-as-entirely-willing https://www.vice.com/en_us/article/9ke3ke/famed-computer-sci... It's the PDF of the email thread (sigh) at the end of the article. (Not gonna make any comments because of the mob roaming around.)
- jeegsy 7y agoHow can you request a counter argument when you have not provided an argument?
- spatular 7y agoI don't have US cultural background and it looks insane to me, about level of witch hunts or lynch mobs. Like one accusation of peadophilia is enough to ruin a life, and lives of others that dare to voice opinions counter to that. Same thing with rape. It doesn't matter if it happened or not. Court of law? Nah, why? Clearly if they are accused then they are guilty.
- AndrewBissell 7y ago"When someone claims they 'didn't see anything suspicious' re: Epstein, just remember he had girls around him at all times. They are lying." https://mobile.twitter.com/RadioVcs/status/1171443584806993920 https://mobile.twitter.com/RadioVcs/status/11714435848069939...
- kirghizlight 7y agoIt's worth mentioning that Minsky died in 2016, so this is not an attempt to influence a forthcoming trial, but to defend a friend's memory.
- kova12 7y agoI wonder where is the "liberal" rainbow-flag waiving mob, and why none of them remembers that gays were persecuted just a little while ago in exactly same manner. And if they do, why don't they speak out
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sgt 7y ago"colechristensen" is basically spamming this thread with the same message, repeated over and over again. I counted 20 similar comments. One begins to question this guy's sanity.
- lanevorockz 7y agoYou are burning an innocent men alive with all his legacy just because you believe that he might be wrong when defending a friend. Not even the worst dictatorships were as evil as you. When you think about fascists, think about you .. doing what you think is right as the cost of everyone elses.