6 ms·
Maybe this will finally tip the political consensus towards a more redistributive taxation policy. The main thing stopping this from happening seems to be older
by nicoburns 7y ago
Maybe this will finally tip the political consensus towards a more redistributive taxation policy. The main thing stopping this from happening seems to be older people who are doing "just fine thank you".
The worlds looming financial woes are entirely of our own making. We're not running out low on resources. We're just distributing them very inefficiently.
- reese_john 7y agoWhat would you consider a more redistributive taxation policy?
- xena 7y agoTax the wealth of the rich
- Shivetya 7y agoyou can pretty much take their wealth and still not pay the negative spending in some countries. in the US the tax system is very progressive with a large swath of the population have little to no federal tax. the truth is the the public employee pension system has been far to generous for far too long and many are counting on a bailout from Washington to keep the largess going. I will post it over and over, Illinois is a prime example of what is wrong in the public employee pension system[1]. When you have twenty three thousand retirees pulling in 100,000 per year there is a problem. Chicago is in dire situation too from both too much largess and simply kicking the debt bomb down the road [2] There is not enough wealth in the US to tax to support this level of largess and it goes by unnoticed because it was designed to not be see by the public. If the only way to fix the pension system is for them to implode it is a far better solution than to tax our way out of it because the behavior has to change. Tens of millions of Americans are counting on their 401k retirements and such and the only true source of wealth that can be taken to fix the pension systems of public employees is to go after those 401k funds. There aren't enough billionaires to take all the money from [1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamandrzejewski/2018/10/26/illinois-100000-club-94000-six-figure-public-employees-and-retirees-cost-taxpayers-12b/#1ef8c93c481a https://www.forbes.com/sites/adamandrzejewski/2018/10/26/ill... [2] https://www.forbes.com/sites/ebauer/2019/01/10/the-problem-with-chicagos-pensions-is-that-there-is-no-low-hanging-fruit/#209ac5e05742 https://www.forbes.com/sites/ebauer/2019/01/10/the-problem-w...
- scarface74 7y agoyou can pretty much take their wealth and still not pay the negative spending in some countries. in the US the tax system is very progressive with a large swath of the population have little to no federal tax. That’s only true if you believe in the fairy tale that Social Security and Medicare taxes (around 15% between you and your employer) are held in a separate account and the money doesn’t go into the general fund with all other tax revenues.
- pytester 7y ago>There aren't enough billionaires to take all the money from The top 1% own 40% of all wealth in America. There's not only enough money, this is by far the fairest way to square this circle. The vast majority of that wealth is not earned.
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoI guess you have to move up to the trillionaires, then. Because they own half of everything. I favor large inflation, which bankrupts the trillionaire while the working Joe keeps earning 'new money' and does ok.
- nicoburns 7y ago> in the US the tax system is very progressive Well that's hilarious. If the tax system in the US was truly progressive then it wouldn't have so many billionaires.
- AlexTWithBeard 7y agoWhat's your definition of "the rich"? Does it include yourself?
- cpursley 7y ago"Taxing the rich" and effective redistribution (and government spending in general) are two different things. In the United States, the top 1 percent of income earners pay a greater share of individual income taxes (37.3%) than the bottom 90 percent combined (30.5%). The bottom 50% of earners pay about 0% in income taxes. I believe this excludes capital gains. source: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-10-14/top-3-of-u-s-taxpayers-paid-majority-of-income-taxes-in-2016 https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-10-14/top-3-of-...
- ra1n85 7y agoI don't share the same view. Pensions, public and private, were supposed to take care of people after many years of work and contributions. Some now are nothing more than Ponzi schemes. I don't see how this (and the inevitable failures of this), combined with the structural problems in the economy, will inspire faith in the governments ability to properly allocate resources, acquired by people, to people.
- ptero 7y agoI agree with you and I see the main problem with the current US pension system is the lack of clarity. This allows bureaucrats and politicians to spend money collected to support old folks in the future for unrelated pet projects now. Social Security and similar schemes are valuable (even if trust fund is completely spent SS would still provide good benefits from current contributions), but I personally trust my 401k more. My 2c.
- barry-cotter 7y agoDefined benefit pensions have always been Ponzi schemes. When there’s an expanding economy and population that works fine. As soon as it stops the writing’s on the wall. That’s why defined benefit pension schemes have pretty much disappeared in the private sector. In the public sector there’s no one to say “We can’t afford this.” except politicians and regulators appointed by politicians. It’s not their money so they have no real incentive to stop it and promising public servants a great retirement wins votes now whereas the people who’ll have to pay for those pensions mostly can’t vote yet as they’re too young. This is a disaster that’s been a long time coming but it’s also been clearly signposted the entire time. Actuaries have known this for a long time.
- jonahbenton 7y agoGood god, this is an awful opinion. Every economic system and model depends on future expansion of both capital and human resources. There are no theories of at scale planning for a future has less stuff and fewer people and no growth or even shrinkage. The "can't afford" BS is the mantra of private capital, which does a great job of funding the .1% and an awful job of funding the 99.9%, which is what pensions do. The fact that expected benefits may not be fully achieved due to, I don't know, inability to predict the future has been used as a straw man to dismantle what have been in historical terms far and away the most successful at scale future funding schemes. The repeated failures of unplanned models get lost down the memory hole. We need a new term to complement "Ponzi scheme" to capture the mass reality distortion that index funds make everyone their own best investment manager.
- krapht 7y agoThe per capita gross world product was approximately ~$18k/yr in 2017. No matter how efficiently you redistribute resources, you cannot exceed this number. Instead we really need to invest more in productivity gains for the world's bottom 90%.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThat would be true if the poor just socked that $18k away into savings. We know this isn’t the case.
- krapht 7y agoWhat would be true? Sorry, I don't follow.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe world's wealthy sock away a larger percentage of their wealth than the poor. Virtually every penny the poor obtain winds up back in the economy, and because of the economic multiplier effect, those pennies have a greater impact as they wind their way through the system. https://ips-dc.org/wall_street_bonuses_and_the_minimum_wage/ https://ips-dc.org/wall_street_bonuses_and_the_minimum_wage/ > All those dollars low-wage workers spend create an economic ripple effect. Every extra dollar going into the pockets of low-wage workers, standard economic multiplier models tell us, adds about $1.21 to the national economy. Every extra dollar going into the pockets of a high-income American, by contrast, only adds about 39 cents to the GDP.
- _jgdh 7y agoThat's a false choice. It's not a choice between paying banker bonuses or giving minimum wage workers an increase. Also, while I agree with the premise that it's better to increase the minimum wage could you explain why folks investing their bonuses in the stock market and therefore directing their capital towards productive companies is worse than consumers spending their money directly?
- danieltillett 7y agoHow is stealing from Peter to pay Paul going to help solve the world’s financial problems?
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoPensions are primarily a concern of the working class, the richer classes benefit from “growth at all cost” policies while everyone else falls behind.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoIf Peter has greater than 90% of the world's wealth and Paul is starving to death then if you take 0.01% of Peter's wealth you can keep Paul alive. I don't know about solving the world's financial problems though, but somehow I didn't think your post actually was concerned with those either.
- SkyBelow 7y agoSure, but that situation has no bearing on reality if one looks at the actual numbers.
- pytester 7y agoIf Paul parasitically extracted wealth from Peter (e.g. by charging sky high rents on the san francisco flat he inherited) then taking some of it back wouldn't be the worst thing ever.
- quantguy11959 7y agoNo it won’t, most companies no longer offer pensions for new employees and instead offer a 401K plan. The pension problem will go away over time.
- marcosdumay 7y agoYes, that's the real solution here. If there aren't investment opportunities, redistributing some more money will create them.