13 ms·
>Uber is circulating a petition urging people to “protect ridesharing in California.” In the petition, Uber advocates for a policy that would offer drivers a m
by duxup 7y ago
>Uber is circulating a petition urging people to “protect ridesharing in California.” In the petition, Uber advocates for a policy that would offer drivers a minimum of $21 per hour, paid time off, sick leave and compensation if they are injured while driving, as well as a collective voice and “the ability to influence decisions about their work.”
Uber circulating a petition to ... urge Uber to do a thing?
Why don't they just do that thing?
- ekc 7y agoThe goal is to force every other company to do it as well, protecting the long-term prospects of Uber. A smart thing, and possibly a good one in the short term.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThat would basically be suicide bombing the "ride share" industry though. Everyone is losing money hand over fist. Increasing that amount will kill everyone just as dead but do it faster decreasing the amount of time that Uber, or anybody, would be able to figure out how to be profitable. I can see how faced with a binary choice between $21/hr and classifying as employees $21/hr is better but it's not a binary choice. They can pay off politicians (indirectly and with plausible deniability of course) or do other dirty things (this is Uber we're talking about here) to get the law changed.
- ghaff 7y agoWho says they'll bear the cost? I'm not sure forcing all of these services to jack up their prices is bad for Uber if they can increase their overall margin while doing so. They just can't do it today if the competition won't follow suit. Yes, they lose some volume but Uber/Lyft is probably a pretty strongly engrained habit for many at this point.
- sachdevap 7y ago> but Uber/Lyft is probably a pretty strongly engrained habit for many at this point. Might be true in the valley, but I see no reason to believe that this is true in many other markets.
- 0xffff2 7y agoReally? "the valley"? I think you'd be closer to the mark if you said it's true in most major metro areas. That still leaves many other markets, but the ubiquity Uber/Lyft is hardly a Silicon Valley only phenomenon.
- sachdevap 7y agoUbiquity of Uber/Lyft is a phenomenon across the world, but not all the markets are as flexible on the price. I question the premise that the markets will respond mildly to a significant price increase in most places. The valley just has a high density of high earners who are willing to pay the sort of price Uber would have to set for competing successfully with drivers making decent pay.
- fgonzag 7y agoUber has replaced a good chunk of taxi usage in most of the big cities around the world. Even many medium sized ones in developing countries.
- sachdevap 7y agoAnd has done so by running its business at a loss, with waves of protests erupting across the world against their anti-labor policies. A quick google search will tell you all about it. Do you believe that when Uber stops bleeding money, and pays an ultimately somewhat acceptable wage to its drives, it will still be able to compete at the new prices set by these changes? I sure don't.
- fgonzag 7y ago> Might be true in the valley, but I see no reason to believe that this is true in many other markets. I responded to this statement, in which you implied that uber had little market share in other areas. No where in your comment did you state that it was operating at a loss, you simply stated you didn't believe Uber wasn't as strong in other markets.
- lonelappde 7y agoThe price would get so high that demand would plummet -- more shared/saver rides or public transit or own drive or flexcar/cargo carshare outside of the densest Urban cores.
- ghaff 7y agoI'm not sure about "plummet" at least until you get materially more expensive than taxis. But you're right that decreases in demand mean not only fewer fares but also a less viable service at the margins. When I've looked, it's appeared as if Uber is only marginally viable around where my house is. Decrease the number of riders and I could imagine the number of drivers dropping further to the point where it's not really a usable service.
- Fricken 7y agoRide share, by the strict definition, is just the point of entry. Uber's goal is to become transportation infrastructure, in a 'privatize the gains, socialize the losses' kind of way, as with the rail barons and the car companies and the commercial airlines.
- cactus2093 7y agoWhy do you think they’ll manage to socialize the losses? So far the losses have been very privatized (VC and bank money) and if anything the gains have been socialized (the general public has benefited a lot in the form of taxi-like transportation, airport rides, etc. getting phenomenally better in most cities where Uber exists).
- my_username_is_ 7y agoThere have also been public losses. Transit ridership tends to decrease with increased ridesharing. This means more cars on the roads, less money for public transit, and more pollution.
- linuxftw 7y agoIf there was no public transit, there would be private transit. This of course means privatizing roads and not using eminent domain to build transit. Then, transit will cost exactly what it should cost, and we can lower taxes as well.
- oconnor663 7y agoThey believe they can bear the expense of this policy better than their competition, and in particular they don't want to compete with lower-cost-lower-quality firms. So it's both a (presumably sincere) ethical position and a form of anti-competitive regulatory capture. I think most minimum wage laws have some of this Baptists-and-bootleggers effect.
- Legogris 7y agoIf it were sincere, they would do these things without being required by law to do so.
- oconnor663 7y agoCompetitive forces prevent them from raising wages unilaterally, because their customers are extremely price sensitive. They're not going to commit corporate suicide over their ethical preferences, any more than most people would.
- ghaff 7y ago>because their customers are extremely price sensitive The proposal suggests to me that they think their customers are not extremely price sensitive but they're also not loyal to a specific supplier. In other words, they'll take almost as many rides even if the price goes up but they'll still go with whoever is cheapest.
- oconnor663 7y agoRight, I was struggling with the phrasing for that. The overall demand may be somewhat inelastic, but the cost of switching firms is zero.
- adventured 7y agoThey may in fact think their customers are price sensitive (the majority of customers are for any mass service; we already know that most of Uber's customers are price sensitive), while their aim is to capture their customers in a regulatory manner so that they have no or few alternatives. If they can establish a regulatory framework that favors them (Uber), they can raise prices as competition is further restricted, to more than offset the $21 / hour. Their ideal has to be to establish that favorable competition environment, enabling considerable price increases that get them closer to profitability (ie exceeds the wage cost increase by a large margin). In the current situation, Uber is facing a bankruptcy scenario with their low sales growth, extreme burn rate and with a competitive market where they can't freely increase prices. That tells you what their goal has to be. If they were certain their customers were not price sensitive, Uber would have already spiked their pricing far higher to push toward profitability.
- TCR19 7y agoThere is a push in California right now to clean up the whole distinction between a contract worker and an employee. This is geared toward the California legislature as much as it is other competition.
- drdeadringer 7y agoSomehow I've missed hearing about this push.
- staz 7y agosome form of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture ? or cutting the grass before the unionizing movement gain too much steam
- wycy 7y agoIt's much easier for a company to do $goodThing if all other companies are also forced to do $goodThing. It's not necessarily good business sense for Uber to unilaterally do it while the competition saves money by doing $badThing.
- holenda 7y agoUber would die if they did this without their competition. This seems like a good policy, so I don't see your point really.
- saurik 7y agoThat literally is the point of the person whose point you don't see.
- simonrobb 7y agoThis is exactly what happened in LA toward the end of 2018. Uber tried raising fares in order to pay their drivers more, but Lyft didn't follow suit and consequentially the market shifted toward Lyft in response. Ridesharing consumers are fickle. It seems the only way for prices to be raised are a) a stable duopoly where both companies' strategy is price matching, or b) through regulation.
- tboyd47 7y agoThey want the government to force all their competitors to do the same.
- mikeash 7y agoThis is a response to a push to unionize and legislate protections. They don’t just want to do this, they want to show that lots of their drivers support it instead of the alternative, and get their drivers to lobby against the legislation and reject unionization.
- morningcovfefe 7y agoYes and no. Unionization would result in unions negotiating against Uber independently. As the dominant player I can see how unions would negotiate harder against Uber than (say) Lyft. A law would mean Uber/lyft/etc. would all have the same playing field - which is better for Uber.
- throwaway_law 7y ago>“the ability to influence decisions about their work.” Wow...on one hand UBER is in an existential crisis regarding the status of drivers (employee vs independent contract). On the other UBER is now passing around a petition in order to give drivers rights (which UBER controls) that are commonly understood to be inherent for contractors. Moreover, a contractor generally has complete control over their work, and UBER by passing around this petition is essentially admitting UBER controls drivers work which is typical of an employer/employee relationship.
- malandrew 7y agoinfluence is not control
- throwaway_law 7y agoThey didn't say the petition was to give drivers the right to "influence" in a vacuum as it it could be interpreted as anything, such as "influence the company" or "influence their pay scale" or "influence company policy", it was specific "influence decisions about their work." you could have just as easily quoted any other word, "decisions" "about" "their" "work" as those words are not "control" either, but when you put it all together, "influence decisions about their work" that sounds a lot like control. Contractors are supposed to have control over their work already, if it makes it easier remove "influence" and if you think there is a more fair interpretation of "decisions about their work" lets have it.
- EpicEng 7y agoBecause it wouldn't hurt their competition that way. This isn't altruism.
- fbonetti 7y agoThey're trying to wield the power of the government to ensure that none of their competitors will be able to survive. It's the same reason why some big companies, like Amazon, are lobbying to increase the federal minimum wage, seemingly against their own interests. Smaller competitors won't be able to absorb the shock of the wage increase and will be forced out of business. The net result will be a less competitive market.
- HenryBemis 7y agoKnowing the filth of Uber (at many ranks/depts) they could just be testing the waters to see what they can get away with. Politicians do this all the time. They use the media/news outlets to circulate rumors of "10% tax increase on X" and once they measure the outrage they eventually impose the 5% they initially planned. This way the masses are happy for avoiding the 10%, and the politicians are happy because they were really planning for a 3%, so yey. I woulnd't be surprised if Uber measures the attractions/reactions the same way, and in the end of the day delivers in a similar manner.
- RonaldSchleifer 7y agoI suspect it's all just PR trying to get ahead of the administration diddling with thoughts of breaking up all the tech cartels. After all, if no one notices good deeds, they don't count, right? It's the currency liberal American runs on, Virtue Signals ... V$.
- bsder 7y agoBecause the goal is to try to end run AB 5 in California, not to actually ... you know ... not be evil.
- dev_dull 7y agoA perfect and logical move for an established company. First, get into an unregulated market. Then, attempt to make that market highly regulated, which discourages and prevents new comers from using the same techniques you used (and thus, lowers competition). See social networking, see banking, see search engines, see... well, it happens everywhere.
- Loughla 7y agoHow was the taxi industry an unregulated market? I thought that was the entire uber shtick - ignore the regulations.
- sieabahlpark 7y agoTrying to up that stock price . I don't see how they're going to afford their drivers if they're already blowing 2b on them
- zaroth 7y agoThat’s not what their petition says, which is linked at the top of TFA. [1] They are petitioning to change AB5, because of claimed negative side effects of that regulation on their driver pool. [1] - https://p2a.co/H9gttWA https://p2a.co/H9gttWA
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoif you put a survey on your site, or send people a survey via email, asking them do you think we should do this, probably very few people will respond. But let us suppose that you have developed a reputation for not being nice, if you propose something nice people will think you are being devious, if you send a survey you won't know how many people actually want you to be nice. But if you can get a petition out there then people will think hey, I can force those not nice people to be nice by putting in my two cents. Now you find out how many people really want you to be nice, furthermore then you can market it later - we heard, we responded, and those people all think hey my voice is important and feel good about themselves and maybe feel good about you and think maybe they really are nice after all? It is a brilliant piece of marketing really, that will of course be taken over by everyone and ran into the ground and poisoned as a method to the point where nobody will believe honest petitions anymore either - but that is years away.
- Reedx 7y ago"When a large company calls for regulation, what they are really requesting are regulatory costs that serve as barriers to entry, protecting them from upstart competitors. It means nothing else. Ever." https://twitter.com/arrington/status/1112179332892385280 https://twitter.com/arrington/status/1112179332892385280
- sharadov 7y agoThis will if it passes also lead to their demise. Ultimately that VC tap will dry up!