23 ms·
YouTube faces creator backlash
- minimaxir 7y agoI want to make programming/data science/AI videos again on YouTube, but given the current state of YouTube I'm very unmotivated to do so.
- edgarvaldes 7y agoI wish every content creator was aware of the importance of having a backup plan. It's sad to read so many stories about creators losing not only the audience and revenue, but alse the content itself after YT shut them down.
- Scoundreller 7y agoHaving a backup plan to YT is kinda like my backup plan if my house burns down: a rough time. It’s not insta-death, but it’s not going to be like it was for a while.
- majewsky 7y agoThe backup plan defines how long "for a while" will last. Anywhere between a few months and the rest of your life.
- Scoundreller 7y ago> the rest of your life Hey, I wouldn’t have drawn Mickey Mouse if I didn’t care about the success of my heirs I never met -Wally D.
- Draiken 7y agoAnd unlike on this scenario, you can't have insurance on whatever YT can do to you. You're likely starting from (almost) zero no matter what.
- not_a_cop75 7y agoWhy is this surprising? Youtube has become the gatekeeper, not the facilitator of new and exciting video tech.
- xfitm3 7y agoI'm glad to see backlash – we need neutral platforms where controversial content will not be punished because of advertiser driven guidelines.
- crikli 7y agoWe need neutral platforms where content will not be punished because of political agendas. If content doesn't align with a progressive viewpoint, at best FB/Twitter/YT/IG ignore it, more commonly they ban/block/derevenue it.
- jrockway 7y agoI am pretty sure you can upload a video to your favorite web host and publish as much controversial content as you want. People want YouTube's captive audience of billions and the pre-existing monetization network. But they are upset that there are arbitrary rules for accessing that audience/money. I am pretty sure that 99.9% of Youtubers wouldn't exist if there were no possibility of ever making money from their videos. Wherever YouTube stands right now, it's still better than the situation 20 years ago where a few network executives controlled what sort of video programming would be produced. It might not be perfect, but there are plenty of people who started from nothing that are making money from their creative work; something that wouldn't have even been possible just a few years ago. So maybe it's not all bad.
- komali2 7y agoTikTok is popular because of the insane decision to shut down Vine. Other apps are filling in that void, now.
- sergiotapia 7y agoI still can't believe they shut that app down. It was so massively popular. Was it just because it wasn't making any money?
- sp332 7y agoWell it never had a way to make money. Also there was a lot of "executive churn" which got in the way of actually shipping code. https://www.theverge.com/2016/10/28/13456208/why-vine-died-twitter-shutdown https://www.theverge.com/2016/10/28/13456208/why-vine-died-t...
- morcutt 7y agoThis might have had played a role. https://www.mic.com/articles/157977/inside-the-secret-meeting-that-changed-the-fate-of-vine-forever https://www.mic.com/articles/157977/inside-the-secret-meetin...
- duxup 7y agoWhat a strange dynamic social media has sometimes.
- sergiotapia 7y agoThis is why I like tiktok more, I rarely see the same people twice. Kills the whole "celebrity" aspect entirely for casual users like me. It's comfy to sit just before bed for about 15 and laugh a bit with tiktok.
- NeoBasilisk 7y agoTo some degree, I do appreciate the fact that it was shut down just to illustrate the fact that all of these sites and services are not "real" and could disappear at any time. I think it is good that people at least keep this fact in the back of their minds, so a concrete example from time to time can be helpful.
- jedberg 7y agoYouTube's problem is their allergy towards using humans. AI technology isn't advanced enough to replace empathy yet. They simply need to add more humans into their processes. Copyright claims is a perfect example. That system is abused by large companies who know how to exploit their algorithms and they know it is worth it because there will be no humans in the loop to stop them. If YouTube wants to remain viable, they just need to bite the bullet and hire a whole bunch of people.
- CSMastermind 7y agoI've seen videos analyzing the YouTube trending tab and suggesting that human moderation suppresses videos from 'controversial' creators like Joe Rogan and PewDiePie. It's dangerous to become the arbiter of taste, I can understand Google's aversion to more human involvement beyond just the problems with scale.
- cowpig 7y agoThe algorithms are a proxy for some youtube engineers' tastes
- majewsky 7y agoThat's a popular conspiracy theory, but it doesn't hold up to Occam's Razor. The simpler explanation is that content from all sides gets buried to some extent, but it appears biased to people because they only notice when their own content is buried.
- Scoundreller 7y agoWhy is it hard to believe that an engineer would engineer something that agrees with their own beliefs?
- true_religion 7y agoIt’s because of the way the conjecture is structured. It proposes that we believe a multi billion dollar corporation would risk their profit margins on the tastes of one engineer in the shadows.
- ancorevard 7y agoGoogle's decision to be the arbiter of acceptable speech will be its undoing.
- tinus_hn 7y agoHow exactly is that scenario going to play out?
- Karunamon 7y agoGenerate enough outrage and laws can change. While current law recognizes the difference between a publisher and a platform, recent activities could very well cause pressure for publisher-like liability when these platforms begin exercising a high degree of editorial control. The social media giants' problem is that they want to have their cake and eat it too. They want the editorial control, and they want to be absolved of any liability when they host terrorist propaganda (think ISIL), pedo bait, and other garbage. There's also the recent court decisions regarding politicians' usage of blocking. That ruling creeps right up to the line of recognizing "private" social media providers as a public square of sorts. The situation we're in is not tenable for much longer.
- Nasrudith 7y agoThat wouldn't work how you want it to and wouldn't be a good idea - especially if expecting outrage to be in your service. The end result would be a choice between a troll and spam storm or precurated everything.
- Karunamon 7y agoI always thought a great idea for stepping over this whole problem is a robust tagging/categorizing system, and then make certain tags opt-in to view. That would be the least amount of work and least likely to be upsetting to reasonable people. That aside, the one worry I share is that the outrage is going to drive a legislative solution that ends up splitting the baby and sucking for all parties concerned. I was entirely serious when I said this situation wasn't tenable, though. Too much emotion/polarization/etc for something to not give soon.
- manishsharan 7y agoThe amount of advertisements youtube forces upon viewers is also insane. Sometimes they force 2 consecutive ads for one 5 minute video.
- tinus_hn 7y agoThe uploader chooses the amount of ads.
- nodja 7y agoMid roll ads are put there by the content creator. So you probably got the inital ad + a mid roll ad placed by whoever created the video.
- CraneWorm 7y agosigh... * use Ublock Origin * use youtuble-dl if you intend to watch something multiple times to save bandwidth * SUPPORT your favorite creators on Patreon and/or via donations
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoTikTok is a mobile-only vertical video platform consisting of memes and kids dancing to popular music. YouTube is a platform where long-form, high definition, well produced content is becoming increasingly more prevalent. I genuinely don't see how the two are even remotely alike. I appreciate that TikTok is the "new hotness" but I don't see its relevance to this conversation about YouTube or why the author felt the need to shoehorn it into every paragraph.
- kbos87 7y agoNeither of those are insurmountable challenges for TikTok should they want to solve for them. The hardest part is becoming the destination people think of when they think video. TikTok looks like it’s getting some traction here.
- quest88 7y agoIf TikTok plans to make money from ads it will have the same problems YouTube does. Advertisers will get restrictive on what types of videos they want their products on. They'll also need their own copyright detection system when lawsuits start coming their way. Then we'll have come full circle.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ethiclub 7y agoA move to a more oligopoly-like market is a step forward though, no?
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoTikTok is an "the ads are the content" type place, think Zach King (sp?), he makes clever videos as adverts but they also comprise his channels content on TikTok. If TikTok can/do monetise that usage of their system then they can get a payout from advertising. Or they can get TikTok to the height of popularity and slowly kill it by adding more and more ads ... the 'YouTube Way', one might say.
- FillardMillmore 7y agoI think one of the problems that YouTube has is their three-strikes policy and how they interact with said offending user. When a video gets flagged, it supposedly is queued up for manual review. Upon manual review, if the YouTube employee deems that the video has broken one of its rules, it will take the video down and it will notify the uploader that they have received a strike. That's all fine, but the problem is really in how they handle this interaction. They tell the user which "set of rules" they've broken (e.g. "Hate speech, discrimination or other forms of bigotry based on race, gender or religion"), but they get no more specific than that. They do not offer a timestamp for the exact moment in which you violated their rules. The result is as you'd expect. I'm sure many terrible videos are rightly taken down this way, but there are plenty of people who don't believe their video violated any rules and are seeking clarification on what they did wrong. It would also be beneficial for the relationship between YouTube and its creators if there was an opportunity for restitution. For example, maybe YouTube informs the user that their video has violated a rule and if they don't take it down within some period of time, they will receive a strike and it will be taken down automatically (of course, with the knowledge that some types of videos should be taken down immediately). Maybe when YouTube takes a video down, they could timestamp it and tell the user that they can re-upload the video without that specific part. As it is now, there are people who make their livings on YouTube, and these somewhat vague rules and the nebulous enforcement of them does not instill creators (I'm talking about creators who post about divisive or controversial things - could be something as simple as viewpoints on modern political news) with a feeling of security and the end-result may be that they simply move to a different platform. If YouTube listens to the complaints of this 'FairTube' group and engages them, I think that'd be best for everyone.
- cfv 7y agoDisney, Sony and their many tentacles randomly steal from youtubers ALL THE TIME, then are expected to review claims of wrongdoing by themselves on good faith, and this is about as "creator friendly" Google will ever get. Those rules suck. It's time to leave for greener pastures.
- majewsky 7y agoYouTube unfortunately is the greenest pasture when measured by audience size. Otherwise people wouldn't be putting up with this shit.
- mullen 7y agoYouTubers are getting flagged by big media companies because YouTubers are using their music or other media without getting a media license. This is not a mystery unknown rule. YouTubers know to not use music they don't have the rights to.
- Karunamon 7y agoThey are also getting flagged for things that are obviously fair use. The idea that a travel vlogger loses their entire video's monetization because they walked by a restaurant playing music is absurd. The music isn't even a substantial part of the video.
- llacb47 7y ago*Fair use may apply
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lucaspottersky 7y agofalse. you clearly don't know what you're talking about, sorry. youtubers are getting strikes for background music, using famous chord progressions, teaching music snippets, mentioning songs etc.
- justaguyhere 7y ago
- ilikehurdles 7y agoLong, long overdue, but it seems like Vimeo is starting to pick up steam in response. I'm really not sure if their policies around DMCA claims are (or would be) any better, but I've noticed folks gravitating toward it as an alternative.
- bad_user 7y agoYouTube faces no competition for creators. There's Vimeo, but you either keep paying a monthly fee, or they drop your content due to the 5 GB maximum limit for free accounts. So if you want to publish stuff and no longer worry about it, you need to make sure that you have a subscription going with a valid credit card. Vimeo is only worth it if you're looking to host video content behind a paywall. Also for website owners Vimeo drops tracking cookies with no way to turn the behavior off, whereas YouTube has a -nocookies mode that doesn't drop any cookies. On the other hand YouTube has started to serve ads on embedded content as well and in the -nocookies mode they can't notice Premium accounts either. These are technical issues that could be solved by alternatives, but aren't. We aren't even talking about the lockin effect of YouTube having the huge audience that it has. Nowadays it's more lucrative to host videos on YouTube even if they are meant for embedding it on your website. Also TikTok is cool, but it's very niche and it's in no way competition for YouTube. There's also the issue that if you're worried about privacy and ads, the fact that TikTok is free (and therefore ads or data driven) and owned by a Chinese company ... is a problem.
- jszymborski 7y agoThe armies are assembling, however. Linus Media Group has Floatplane, CGP Grey and friends have Nebula... YouTube, like Netflix, doesn't have a special sauce. It has creators, and those creators are happy and eager to leave.
- bufferoverflow 7y ago> YouTube, like Netflix, doesn't have a special sauce But they do have the eyes. If you want your videos to be seen, there's no Youtube alternative. Twitch would be, but they seem to be banning people for political reasons too. Network effect is real and very strong. It will be very hard to create real YT alternatives. We have Bitchute and PeerTube, but they severely lack content and the viewers.
- jerf 7y ago"Network effect is real and very strong." I'd say it's real, but weak. The value to me of the next incremental YouTube content provider isn't very large. If one of my favorite providers leaves, I won't find it hard to follow them. What they have is the only practical advertising-based monetization platform. That's the real moat. You can use YouTube to build enough of a base to then create a backup monetization base with something like Patreon, but I don't know how to get you to that point without starting on YouTube first.
- bla3 7y agoYouTube has been facing some form of creator backlash for years now.
- abledon 7y agois the youtube trending page algorithmically generated or human-curated? Its complete garbage. If the first 20 videos are really what most people want to watch... god help us lol
- gadders 7y agoCongratulations, Carlos Maza.
- peteretep 7y agoWonder if the creators will get organized enough to create a co-op company to run a video sharing site where they get all the pie.
- moate 7y agoNarrator: No, they will not.
- dbuder 7y agoCreators rely on Youtube for their livelihood and Youtube will yank it away and say talk to the hand.
- dbg31415 7y agoI hate that the YouTube ads aren't at all targeted to the video that you're watching, or even your profile. Google has like every bit of data they could possibly want on me... and I literally have never seen an ad for anything I would care about. Worse, like I'm trying to sleep, and I turn on some ASMR or meditation video, and if I forget to turn off the "auto play" feature (it's annoying to turn off from the TV interface), then I'm hit with what can only be described as used-car-guy-volume ads. "BUY NOW! LOW LOW PRICES!" Now I just use a video scraper to download the videos I like so I can watch them while I sleep. Nobody wins when they don't tie ads to content, or ads to users.
- Circuits 7y agoDoes this article read like a promotion for this TikTok to anyone else? I did a google search for "YouTube competitors" and TikTok did not come up on the list. I got: DailyMotion, MetaCafe, Twitch and a few others but definitely not TikTok. In my mind, there is really no way an app can replace something like YouTube.
- a0-prw 7y agoUnless Youtube enters into a serious dialog concerning Fairtube's demands, IG metal's lawyers will be challenging Youtube in court over "false self employment". Could get very expensive for YT: https://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=oZZ5Kouj_hQ https://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=oZZ5Kouj_hQ
- lucaspottersky 7y agoI have compiled a few videos from youtuber music educators that I follow. The current situation is worse than most of us think. One of them, Paul Davis, even had a copyright strike for playing HIS OWN music. LOL! So ludicrous! - Craziest COPYRIGHT STRIKE from YouTube ever?! (Paul Davis) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YvH77m_3MVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YvH77m_3MVU - What I want to teach, but can't, thanks to Universal Music Group. (Adam Neely) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nryFmUjtwEY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nryFmUjtwEY - Why Record Labels STILL Suck! (Rick Beato) - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QoTl9V8cjH0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QoTl9V8cjH0
- Eiriksmal 7y agoMore recently than Adam's October 2017 video, he had another copyright strike for, presumably, showing a repeating clip of the Single Ladies music video without playing even one second of the music itself. He recreated the song with a chintzy MIDI soundfont. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rRKBXQotnA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rRKBXQotnA His comments: https://twitter.com/adamneelybass/status/1124722129495306240 https://twitter.com/adamneelybass/status/1124722129495306240 https://twitter.com/adamneelybass/status/1124840588543713285 https://twitter.com/adamneelybass/status/1124840588543713285
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cabaalis 7y ago"To learn more about copyright, you may visit..." It must be nice to have such a dominant position that you can patronize your "partners" in such a way. I'm constantly amazed that this company does not invest more in human copyright legal reviews when their product is pretty much just obtaining rights to share copies of other people's work.
- Max-q 7y agoOn YouTube, if you make a 10 minutes long video, but include 10 seconds of copyrighted material, the copyright owner gets 100% of the revenue, the creator 0%. I think this is YouTube creators main objection to the plattform.
- annadane 7y agoCan we also fix the recommended videos so it's actually related to what you're watching and not the most reactionary garbage?
- Causality1 7y agoI miss the days when you could watch "Bill Cooking Chicken part 1" and the related videos would be "Bill Cooking Chicken part 2" and "Bill Cooking fish part 1" instead of "I wasted $200 on Wish.com" and "More Adventures in Replying to Spam" and "Ten Flaws of the Borg Collective".
- dredmorbius 7y agomps-youtube using either channel or search, saving to playlist, and then stepping through that list is such a vastly superior experience to YouTube itself it's not even funny. https://github.com/mps-youtube/mps-youtube https://github.com/mps-youtube/mps-youtube
- fareesh 7y agoImagine you work hard editing for a day / days, and put out a video and go to bed. You wake up the next morning and find that after the first 3,000 views, the video was de-monetized and the remaining 500,000 views went generated no revenue. You complain to YouTube, they manually review it, and your video is re-monetized. Your views for that video barely increase for the rest of eternity. That bug just cost you X revenue. Multiply for the entire month. At the very least, YouTube can offer a service your video can go into limbo before it's sent out to your subscribers, where all of these "mistakes" can be ironed out. Perhaps the platform is de-monetizing video based on mass reporting - leaving the system open to be gamed by anyone who is okay with the ethics of brigading/report bombing. This is a VERY common thing these days. The other possibility is that the AI is generating false positives and de-monetizing as a result of it. Whichever the case may be, it ought to be possible for content creators to publish a video that is not mistakenly de-monetized for the vast majority of their viewers.
- ramijames 7y agoI think de-monetizing is part of Google's profit plan. They provide content for no cost, but can still show ads and earn revenues. It's a giant scam.
- paxys 7y ago> but can still show ads and earn revenues De-monetized videos do not show ads or earn revenue, so that actually hurts Google as well (of course it has indirect effects that are beneficial for Google overall).
- hinkley 7y ago"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it."
- warent 7y agoThis is a little too cynical for my taste. Google isn't exactly a monument of ethical business, but I seriously doubt that Google would intentionally demonetize videos for the purpose of stealing from content creators.
- TrackerFF 7y agoYoutube is kinda like Ebay. Ebay used to be a great garage sale / thrift-store place where individuals could sell their stuff, no hassle. Then they started catering to Ebay stores, and then finally they wanted to become Amazon 2.0, almost pushing individual sellers away. They're now basically geared toward large stores that act and operate like any big amazon store - you're pretty much expected to eat any losses that may come up, and write it off as "cost of doing business". Same with Youtube. Used to be a great place for small individual creators, but now it's basically just a stream of memes and high-production vids that are the equivalent to visual fast-food. Sure, you can still post as a small-timer, but there will be no help, and you're at the mercy of the big companies and their relentless search for copyrighted material. Or if you're not in the creative space, there's still a chance you'll get screwed by arbitrary tripping the controversial content-wire. All that kinda narrows down the scope of what one can create, and thus we see the rise of low-effort content farms . (It's not that there's no good content - there's a ton of good high-quality content, but as we've seen the past years, even the good channels with a decent amount of followers can get demonetized at the drop of a hat)
- rrggrr 7y agoInteresting point, in that it makes me realize Ebay is about the only domestic US online competitor to AMZN that is a factor.
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoEbay still works for very specific niche interests. For example I follow several individual sellers of rare and specific kinds of succulent.
- spookthesunset 7y ago> Same with Youtube. Used to be a great place for small individual creators, but now it's basically just a stream of memes and high-production vids that are the equivalent to visual fast-food. What are you talking about? Youtube is full of great high quality content from individual creators. So much so, I'd wager youtube gives "real tv" a serious run for their money. Almost all my video-based content consumption is youtube these days.
- rackforms 7y agoIt's been absolutely fascinating to watch the YouTube v. community drama play out. I think many forget the exact same situation has been and continues to play out for Alphabets other major community, website owners. The difference of course is we don't really have active and vocal "followers" in the way YouTube creators do, so for the most part, when a website owner like myself gets penalized for some abstract and out of my hand reason, or a algorithm change destroys your business overnight, it happens silently, beyond the headlines. I can't stress this enough -- Google has been a powerful, often positive force for the wider Internet. But they're also a cruel, heartless, and often maniacal source of pain and sorrow.
- Quequau 7y agoI am a big fan of machining and metal working videos. Whatever changes YouTube did last year basically gutted that niche, with many channels simply abruptly giving up mid project. I have no idea what exactly they changed but from my perspective as a casual viewer it had a large and negative impact.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoAccording to anecdotes I've seen online (so take this with a massive grain of salt), some videos showing how to use tools like drill presses and CNC machines have been demonetized due to youtube's policy against educational gunsmithing videos (https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6162278?hl=en https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/6162278?hl=en)
- munmaek 7y agoIt's obvious youtube is for mainstream media now, with content creators being a leftover wart, minuscule on youtube's radar. Content creators deal with an opaque algorithm that demonetizes videos based on how the wind is blowing, or it would appear. Weeks or months of work can be wiped out by an arbitrary demonetization preventing content creators from getting paid for their video's views. JonTron discusses this [1]. It's very easy to violate the "advertiser-friendly" guidelines. They're vague: "violence", "harmful content", "controversial or sensitive issues". Under profanity: "strong profanity used in video even if bleeped for comedy, documentary, news, or educational purposes". ??! It has been obvious for a long time that daily content uploads are better for the algorithm than longer, quality videos uploaded less frequently. If you look at the LinusTechTips network of channels, they produce at least 5-7 videos per week. [0]: An analysis of 7 months worth of trending tab videos, or roughly ~40k videos that reached the trending tab. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDqBeXJ8Zx8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDqBeXJ8Zx8 [1]: https://youtu.be/TZ31u3vI934?t=364 https://youtu.be/TZ31u3vI934?t=364
- RankingMember 7y agoThere really needs to be a solid competitor, but the thing is that as far as I know YouTube still isn't profitable on its own, so it's not exactly a space investors are falling over themselves to dump money into.
- swebs 7y ago>So yeah, now R. Kelly somehow owns the rights to JonTron's Buying Things Online Wow, the whole Youtube system is a mess. I had no idea it was that bad
- prvc 7y agoWhat would their business motive be for pivoting to mainstream content? Doesn't that eliminate the one thing that differentiates them?
- nfoz 7y agoUnpopular opinion, but this whole career choice of "YouTube content creator" seems like a frightful gamble in the first place. You've intrinsically tied yourself into a particular company's product. I guess I don't see YouTube's website as a public space and I don't see how anyone is "entitled" to monetization. But to be more sympathetic, in this case it just sounds like YouTube should have done most of its automated content scans before posting the video in the first place.
- la_barba 7y agoOkay? But you can apply that logic anywhere to anything. Its also a "frightful gamble" that Google needs Microsofts and Apples blessing to operate on their platform. They have intrinsically tied themselves to a particular company's product. They also need Cisco's blessing for routing their packets. The default configuration of all of these products could be to ban google's products and services because they spy on their users or -insert-other-privacy-rationale-. I don't think just because you use and depend on another companies product that you should expect them to be malicious towards you.
- anbop 7y agoBut Google has the resources to fight Apple and Microsoft, in the markets and in the courts, if denied a level playing field in a way that is illegal or bad optics. YouTube content creators, and content creators in general, have no defense against this since the big aggregation companies like YouTube, Twitter, and Instagram have market power over hundreds of millions of creators instead of just a few powerhouses.
- la_barba 7y agoI fully agree. I'm just pushing back against the sentiment of shitting on the little guy, because of a personal opinion that what this person is doing is vapid or devoid of value to me.
- _delirium 7y agoI agree with that in principle, but increasingly lots of gigs are tied to some kind of platform as intermediary, so it's getting harder to avoid tying yourself to some company's whims. I guess you can try to diversify and at least hedge your bets, but that's easier to do with some kinds of jobs than others. Besides YouTube, some other platforms that many people's businesses/livelihoods depend on in one way or another: Google AdSense, Amazon Marketplace, Amazon Associates, Steam, Patreon, Square, Uber, ...
- NKCSS 7y agoThe whole ContentID/de-monetization thing sucks. YouTube made a video about it themselves to explain how it works, which is pretty informative: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cYurafmTwcw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cYurafmTwcw
- ajnin 7y agoYoutube is a monumental money-making machine for Google because of the large amount of ads. Creative content is only incidental, it is not the primary purpose of Youtube to foster creation, only to gather ad revenue. It shows in the way they treat creators and viewers vs advertisers and rights holding companies. So this backlash is justified, but for what, TikTok, another closed garden controlled by another media comany ? I'd personally want to see rise an alternative made of peertube and micro donations, where users would chose to pay for infrastructure and content creation, but I don't know how to make this happen.
- Synaesthesia 7y agoWe have to all make it happen. You won’t get it done on your own, and neither will I. But collectively we can.
- jdlyga 7y agoThe copystriking system is totally ridiculous. The person who claimed the video should not be the one to decide appeals if they incorrectly claimed your video.
- intreego 7y agoThere is definitely a wave that is happening on other video sharing platforms but I suspect that it won't be a big sea change as the content on YouTube is deep and embedded so the YouTube still casts the widest net. Tik Tok and Astronaut.io are interesting but as I type this post word from a 15 year old teenager says that the alternatives are boring so the attention span required is short. The alternatives are entertaining but will really only be a threat when learning takes place on them. The demographic is different and learning will need to take place it 15 seconds or less. It might also be interesting to note that there are approx 200 variables Google looks for when deciding who rides the wave or not.
- thoughtstheseus 7y agoDo what ally law did and make your own site.
- Causality1 7y agoDoes YouTube mistreat and exploit its creators in a myriad of ways? Absolutely. Is it a fair platform and does it behave in reasonable ways? Absolutely not. That said, I feel that a reminder about the nature of YouTube monetization, AKA the YouTube Partner Program is in order. The YPP puts ads in and around your video and gives you part of the profit from running those ads, but what does that mean? It means YouTube is: >Finding advertisers >Persuading them it can pick content (yours) that is profitable to advertise on >Handling the entire negotiation and payment work behind implementing that advertising >Handling the entire technical aspect of adding those advertisements to your video That is an enormous amount of work YouTube is doing for its content creators for free. You are not in any way entitled to YouTube doing that work for you. Having your videos categorized as not eligible for the YPP is not in any way depriving you of the ability to make money from them, just the ability to automatically make money from them with no effort on your part. Without access to the YPP, you are still free to find sponsors, find advertisers and run your own ads, receive donations, or rely on patronage services like Patreon. That means you have every single avenue of revenue generation (aside from paywalling your content) available to you that you'd have if you were hosting the videos yourself on a personal server. Hell you can even do that if you want to set up some kind of script that uploads your videos as Private and only adds viewer usernames to the whitelist after they pay you. It would be a terrible idea, but YouTube would be entirely within its rights to charge content creators for the bandwidth consumed by their viewers and offer no assistance at all for making money off your content. YouTube owes you nothing.
- dba7dba 7y agoOne of my favorite youtube channel by 'Indy Neidell' on WW2 has been demonetized. He and his team cover WW2 week by week, one video with historical analysis/story for every week. They recently completed a series for WW1 and it was amazing. Even as a semi serious history buff, I learn new stuff. But they have been demonetized, seriously hurting their ability to put up videos. He put up an extensive view on this and states there is no rhythm or rhyme on what gets restricted or not.
- rehemiau 7y agoI hope Floatplane succeeds and we have a nice subscription-based platform for creators
- techrich 7y agowell when you attack good channels like mark dice, sargon of akkad etc then there will be backlash
- NeoBasilisk 7y agoYoutube's copyright claims system is absolutely abysmal. I didn't know that TikTok is owned by a Chinese company, so I assume that they are much more resistant to copyright trolls?
- devenblake 7y agoHere's why YouTube can go fuck itself: I have a YouTube channel. My first video will be five years old on September 14. I kept putting out content for a number of years, content which I thought was funny and would surely be well-received. But people never watched my videos! I get 20ish views per video. They never get recommended to anyone because I'm a smaller channel, and then I never become big for that reason. (Or maybe my videos just suck. Some of them definitely do, but I've made some that I'm proud of.) I joined TikTok, YouTube's 60-second-max competitor. Out of boredom I made a video synced to one of those songs. Fifty views on my first one. Eventually I started making more content. I've clocked around 150K views on my videos combined, 40K likes, and 1200 followers. I made my first video around February and my second around June. While YouTube discourages small creators, non-celebrities, and those that don't have massive amounts of cash to throw around on sets, TikTok lets whoever's talented become at least relatively popular. TikTok's algorithm is pretty well-documented by its community: When you post a video, TikTok shows it to a certain amount of people. If enough people who see it "like" it, it moves to a larger amount of people, and so on until everyone on the app sees it. This is easy, straightforward, and transparent (for the most part, there are special cases and such). YouTube's algorithm is: [redacted]. It's amusing to me that a Chinese company would be more transparent about this. YouTube doesn't understand its community and it's probably too late to save it, it got a monopoly and stagnated. My story is one of many others.
- makomk 7y agoIn the current media climate, the risks of recommending small channels probably aren't worth it. The moment something dodgy gets recommended and journalists get ahold of it, the loss of advertiser income site-wide costs both YouTube and other creators far more than they could ever get from better recommendations. The incentives are intentionally stacked against you.
- felipemnoa 7y agoHad never heard of them. Now I have and will be giving them a try. I definitely could see this word of mouth threatening YouTube if not outright killing them. Competition is always good. (Runs off to check TikTok) .... (After checking out some videos) That was actually refreshing. Many of the videos were fun to watch and put a smile on my face. Not bad TikTok!
- lone_haxx0r 7y agoThe one thing I dislike about Youtube and no one talks about is their aggresive lossy compression. My monitor is only 1080p but I set the quality to 1440p or 4K if the video supports it, as those resolutions allow a higher bitrate and I can enjoy videos without noticeable distortion. I prefer my computer to downscale the image instead of Youtube butchering the whole thing by limiting the bitrate to an extreme. I understand that Youtube has to optimize their storage and bandwidth, but still, if I see a video with too many compression artifacts I just close it.
- burfog 7y agoIf you close a video with too many compression artifacts, then you'll miss out on internet history. For example, Numa Numa: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cqd1Gvq-RBY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cqd1Gvq-RBY
- jrobn 7y agoSounds like a symptom of centralized silo services, period. This wouldn’t be a problem if each of those creators had a website with their content on it. The copyright holders would have to issue a DMCA to for that 10 second of radio music, which, while not perfect, is better than this YouTube content claim garbage completely controlled by claimants. Then maybe copyright law would be molded into a better system. Which is exactly what these copyright cartels DON’T want. They want to avoid any judicial review whatsoever of their actions.
- webbrahmin 7y agoYoutube creator here. I am running a Youtube channel for the last few years and it is my full-time job. About a year back I criticized youtube on twitter. Soon afterward my views started dropping. Though it cannot be concluded that my tweets were responsible it is difficult to explain how a channel which was very popular in its niche will suddenly fall off the cliff? I am over 40 years old and I am unable to find regular employment. For the last 6 months, I am learning to program and trying developing 3 web apps. I am hoping that one of them will reach ramen profitability.
- busymom0 7y agoWhat is your channel? What type of web apps are you working on?
- webbrahmin 7y agoDirectory apps. My self-education is still underway. I hope to build a SaaS product soon.
- flycaliguy 7y agoWhat was your channel?
- webbrahmin 7y agoThe channel is still active. I cannot reveal it publicly out of fear of a second backlash from Youtube. I still earn about $600 a month from the channel. At its peak I earned c. $3000 a year.
- webbrahmin 7y agoRead $3000 a month
- vincengomes 7y ago2 years back, i uploaded a wildlife video which surprisingly became popular. A year back i noticed im now eligible for monetization as i had crossed the minimum required numbers for Subscribers and Views. One month after applying i got rejected saying the content was duplicate. I thought it was a mistake and applied again and again to no avail. My guess is, someone has content-ID'd the video and monetizing it. The video now sits at 7M+ views and it occassionaly irks me knowing somewhere someone is making money out of that video.
- busymom0 7y agoI am surprised there isn't any way similar to Google reverse image search or TinyEye which can do the reverse search for videos. Have you looked into it if that's possible?
- jjcm 7y agoI'm working on a side project right now that tries to address the issues we have with monetizing content and creatives at the moment. Ad revenue as we've seen with Youtube and countless other platforms simply isn't viable at scale. You have to play too safe to not associate your brand with any controversy, it degrades the user experience, and it means creatives have to walk on a tightrope not to get demonetized. Patreon is probably the best current system that's out there, but it doesn't provide a good way to get eyes on the content. I'm trying to create an open source reddit meets patreon system, with the model described by this interactive prototype: https://syd.jjcm.org/soci/ https://syd.jjcm.org/soci/ I've got the frontend sorted, an API fully specced out, and some rough backend code created, but I'll be honest in that I'm not a backend guy so I could use some help. If anyone is interested in trying to solve the problem send me a message at j@jjcm.org. I've got an active job ad in the who's hiring page with more details: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20331491 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20331491 I'd also be open to just paying someone remote to help out. At the end of the day I just want there to be a better system available for creatives.
- mycall 7y agoI welcome someone at axios to make a dynamic mind map of all their compilations. It would make for an interesting journey.
- JDiculous 7y agoYouTube is always facing creator backlash. I don't see anything new in this article. For example, I'm not a fan of how the algorithm seems to prioritize clickbait (clickbait is the cancer of the internet) and longer videos. This leads people to load up their videos with filler to hit that 10 minutes length, and then sensationalize their titles, often into "questions" that the video will then fail to subsequently answer. I've had a video get a false copyright claim - it sucked, and it steered me away from making the kind of political videos that use news clips. But there are no viable competitors, I guess because hosting video content is expensive and network effects. Facebook is probably the closest competitor, but there's too much noise and it's not really much of a search engine for videos. Tik-Tok is not a competitor - it serves an entirely different market (the one formerly served by Vine and Music.ly) of short mobile clips. Until Youtube starts shadowbanning channels and playing a "Big Brother" censorship role, I'll continue to post there. (I've heard rumours of Youtube shadowbanning channels, but I'm not convinced that they're legitimate, though I haven't really looked into it)
- blueboo 7y agoIt’s not gonna be much of a backlash when content creators have so little leverage.
- DoubleGlazing 7y agoI ageee that YouTube sucks for many reasons. They have a weird undocumented algorithm that defines what gets popular and as a result creators are constantly playing games to bait it. Their monetization/demonetization policies are just bonkers. Their copyright enforcement system is Kafkaesque. Plus, as a consumer they seem to be going down the facebook route of trying to curate my viewing choices in a way that suits them. But they can do that as they are a private company. They don't owe anyone anything. If you rely on YouTube for a living without a backup plan then you are dumb. YouTube is no longer the only player in online video. If you don't like what YouTube is doing then look at alternative platforms.
- Hitton 7y agoAlthough Youtube sucks in many regards (namely handling copyright claims and deleting/demonetizing videos for wrongthink), one thing I really like about it is their terms of use. I come very rarely upon so creator right friendly service. You give rights to your content to Youtube only for purposes of operating and promoting Youtube, which means that it won't eventually become remixed by third party and put behind paywall without you having anything to say about it. And this license which you grant to Youtube ends if you remove your videos. Also it doesn't have indemnification clause. Compare it to virtually all other services which request irrevocable right to do pretty much anything with your content and also demand indemnification.
- calimac 7y agoYouTube is the Silicon Valley billionaire and their lemming dev teams view of the way social hierarchy should be. It failed their world view failed. The people crest the content. Give the creators a level playing field. Subpoena the algorithm through a federal antitrust case and expose it through court filings and PROVE ONCE AND FOR ALL; YouTube has their finger on the scale promoting videos the executives and dev teams view as “better”. Regardless of their rationalization, they are operating free of any platform exemption and must be open to litigation.