24 ms·
The human body is already close to thermal limits in many regions
- EGreg 7y agoWhat happens if the permafrost melts? Can we have a runaway greenhouse effect and reach a hothouse state like millions of years ago, or even worse due to the amount released all at once? What do the models say in the worst case? Will humanity barely survive at the poles, in that case?
- zaarn 7y agoWorst case is a second venus if the process truly runs away and no longer relies on biochemical greenhouse gases but purely chemical processes that work beyond 100C. If the permafrost melts it'll release a lot of methane and CO2, in part captured and in part from material beginning to rot a few thousand years too late. Humanity might survive at the south pole, but we'll more likely go extinct in a worst case. Unless it's a venus scenario, life itself will go on.
- adrianN 7y agoCO2 concentration has been a lot higher in the past (e.g. before all the coal deposits formed) without turning Earth into Venus. I think we can safely say that we'll never turn into another Venus. At the absolute worst we'll reach a moist hothouse scenario: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runaway_greenhouse_effect#Earth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runaway_greenhouse_effect#Eart... The more likely worst case is climate similar to this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleocene%E2%80%93Eocene_Thermal_Maximum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paleocene%E2%80%93Eocene_Therm...
- zaarn 7y agoVenus is the worst case, I never said this would happen at current CO2 levels but it could happen if they continue to elevate and chemical processes put out more CO2 while biochemical processes stop using up CO2 due to high heat. There is a true absolute runaway that could theoretically be achieved in an absolute worst case scenario.
- pojzon 7y agoWe, humans, will be long gone before we reach pollution levels required to change Earth to Venus.
- raverbashing 7y agoI suspect the permafrost melt has an important detail that some people are forgetting: Methane has a short half-life (7 years) in the atmosphere though it eventually turns into CO2 This (I think) could cause an overshoot, then a reduction of the total greenhouse effect
- Xcelerate 7y agoWhy aren't people more worried about these kinds of things? Is it just too abstract and removed from day-to-day life to care?
- anonydsfsfs 7y agoDenial is part of it. Jared Diamond talks about this in "Collapse": "consider a narrow river valley below a high dam, such that if the dam burst, the resulting flood of water would drown people for a considerable distance downstream. When attitude pollsters ask people downstream of the dam how concerned they are about the dam's bursting, it's not surprising that fear of a dam burst is lowest far downstream, and increases among residents increasingly close to the dam. Surprisingly, though, after you get just a few miles below the dam, where fear of the dam's breaking is found to be highest, concern then falls off to zero as you approach closer to the dam! That is, the people living immediately under the dam, the ones most certain to be drowned in a dam burst, profess unconcern. That's because of psychological denial: the only way of preserving one's sanity while looking up every day at the dam is to deny the possiblity that it could burst. " - page 436
- viscanti 7y ago> concern then falls off to zero as you approach closer to the dam! That is, the people living immediately under the dam, the ones most certain to be drowned in a dam burst, profess unconcern. It's a fun story but it doesn't prove causality. Maybe their faith in the dam is why they moved there.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoThat seems very far fetched: by the description that river was well populated before the dam was built, so the ones left closest is by majority those that stayed after it was completed.
- YinLuck- 7y agoJared Diamond is cringe.
- adrianN 7y agoIf this concerns you, you should consider joining the Citizen's Climate Lobby: https://citizensclimatelobby.org/ https://citizensclimatelobby.org/
- dang 7y agoUrl changed from https://phys.org/news/2019-07-heatwave-human-body-thermal-limits.html https://phys.org/news/2019-07-heatwave-human-body-thermal-li..., which points to this.
- perfunctory 7y agoIf this doesn't scare you I don't know what will. We have to do something about it. By 'we' I mean you and I. As someone said - if you don't think you can change the world you will just be one of the ones who didn't. We need fundamental cultural and policy change. The question is how to achieve it. Despite popular believe I don't think voting matters. Think about any significant societal change in the last century or so. Women suffrage, civil rights movement, anti-war movement, gay rights. None of these were initiated by the parliament. They all started as a popular rebellion and direct action. So what are we to do. - Change your lifestyle. Less flying, driving, meat. - Divest fossil - Get out of the techno bubble and get your hands dirty with direct action and civil disobedience. e.g. [1] [1] https://rebellion.earth/ https://rebellion.earth/
- frostburg 7y agoIsn't it realistically way too late for (ideologically appealing, I understand) lifestyle changes to solve anything? De-growth won't save you from heatwaves or rising sea levels. Mitigation at this point would probably involve extensive dam systems, nuclear reactors and at worst gambling with geoengineering.
- esotericn 7y agoBoth are required.
- frostburg 7y agoIt's hard to build the dams, reactors, geodesic domes and whatever else without more mining, concrete plants, energy intensive logistics and transports, etc. It doesn't seem possible to do both things without failing at both with terrible consequences.
- esotericn 7y agoFar less of that would be required if we used less energy, and it's additive. Eating beefburgers, flying Australia <-> Europe for holidays, driving a Hummer, using plastic for everything, and so on and so forth, just isn't necessary. My street has twice the number of cars it did when I was younger. The idea that "terrible consequences" will come about from people taking the piss a bit less is really very silly. It makes me think of the Four Yorkshiremen sketch but inverted (when I were young, we had all the things...)
- emerongi 7y agoIf people start migrating away from those regions en masse, is there a chance it will trigger a war?
- ggm 7y agoYes. The middle east includes regions fractured by lack of water and competing state interests. Not all tensions derive from Sunni, Shia & Jewish religious/state issues. Turkey controls headwaters that millions depend on. Wars in Africa can be traced to shrinking rivers and lakes. Tensions between north and south Sudan, Uganda and Rwanda,
- nabla9 7y agoIf you are a young male, joining a gang and getting a gun (religious cult, tribe, criminal or national military) is a way to ensure food security for themselves and even to their family. When you see pictures of people starving, they never hold AK-47 in their hand.
- Tinfoilhat666 7y agoThere will be wars. Some say that the Syrian War was affected by climate change https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2015/03/150302-syria-war-climate-change-drought/ https://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2015/03/150302-syri...
- env123 7y agoThere will be, I just woke up this early morning thinking about climate change, and thought people will definitely want to migrate to cooler places but some nations will object to this due to conflicting interests In another viewpoint on climate change, do remember that the Earth rotate around the Sun in elliptical manner, it's not perfect circle - there will be surely a time when a new Ice Age will happen - we're just at a period when Earth is getting closer to the Sun on it's rotational axis
- arkades 7y agoI'm not sure I understood your comment about the shape of the earth's orbit. The earth's orbit around the sun is an ellipse. But it's an ellipse that takes one year to traverse. The closest thing that gets us in terms of an "ice age" is winter. And, in fact, "winter" is what happens when you're closer to the sun, due to a change in the angle of incidence of sunlight (in the northern hemisphere). Are you referring to something else?
- Bombthecat 7y agoYesterday, a friend reminded me about the story of the Easter islands. I remember reading / hearing about it. But then forgot about it. They destroyed the whole forest on the island and with it, they destroyed them self... I bet, they were in a similar situation, people saying that we should stop. That it changes things. And... they didn't stop until the bitter end. I think we will be like the easter island. We won't stop.
- seren 7y agoActually, there are some researches saying that the often cited conclusion about Easter Islands (notably in 'Collapse') might not be accurate. See for example: https://gizmodo.com/new-evidence-contradicts-theory-that-easter-island-soci-1828307589 https://gizmodo.com/new-evidence-contradicts-theory-that-eas...
- graeme 7y agoThe account confuses me. Diamond's central argument was that the Islanders cut down all their trees, and thus no more could grow. This article suggests they got all their stone from a single quarry, and so must have collaborated around that quarry. ....this doesn't seem to contradict the central claim of a society destroying its resource base. Am I missing something? It's also not incompatible to have collaboration around a central resource and conflict elsewhere. Though I mainly think it's a sideline to the tree story.
- seren 7y agoMaybe, this was not the best source, but there are articles disputing that the population decreases happened before the first contact with European explorers in 1722. http://islandheritage.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2010/06/RNJ_23_2_Mulrooney_Etal.pdf http://islandheritage.org/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2010/... I don't think it does challenge the idea that the deforestation led to the collapse, but maybe it was not the only cause.
- graeme 7y ago
- runeks 7y agoA person attempting to emit less CO2 because people somewhere are dying from heat stroke seems as sensible to me as attempting to increase ones CO2 emissions because people somewhere are freezing to death.
- coconut_crab 7y agoThis is why it feels much hotter and suffocating at night than day where I live, at 10PM the temperature is 35oC with 70% humidity (thank to urban heat island effect). At least sweating cools my body down during the day, at night all it does it drenching me in sweat and I still feel hot. I have tried to reduce my carbon footprint by consuming as little as possible, but just I myself alone is not enough. This requires a whole refactoring of how our cities should be built, how our civilization should work and I just don't see that happening any time soon.
- perfunctory 7y ago> but just I myself alone is not enough Sure. Start talking to your friends, family and colleagues. Join groups of like-minded people.
- manjana 7y agoIn case this ever became a reality could one not dig a retreat in the ground or simply start living underground? It might sound silly, but if needs are desperate..
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoThis is already a thing; see Coober Pedy [1] in Australia, there's houses carved out of mountains, etc. This is also likely how people will be living on Mars. And houses can be built to emulate living underground, with e.g. shutters on the outside (another thing that has been around for centuries). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coober_Pedy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coober_Pedy
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoThere were people in Turkey some thousands of years ago living underground. I’m sure they were doing that for a reason. Can’t recall the name of the place / discovery.
- bamboozled 7y agoTerrifying, I’m starting to hope we do more with climate change so we can not only survive, but stop talking about it. I wonder if in human history there has been such a long running dire topic to endlessly discuss without any solution in sight ? Maybe the Cold War ?
- viach 7y agoNot a problem IMHO - all the shopping centers have good climate control systems /s
- aaron695 7y agoIf you wonder why people ignore the Global Warming BS here's a quote from a peer reviewed article that tells a few facts about WBT. It tells the truth, it's centuries away (When we'll be much more capable to deal with it, unless in 100 years time our technology is still crap.... right) and it's not deadly anyway. "Heat stress is the net heat load to which an individual may be exposed from the combined contributions of the metabolic cost of work, environmental factors and clothing. Humans can adapt to temperatures exceeding both human skin temperature (35 °C) and even core temperature (36.8 °C). However, WBGT exceeding these limits pose a risk to human health and well-being. These risks have implications beyond the individual. For example, apart from discomfort, heat stress adversely affects human labour capacity and performance. In a previous study [3], it was suggested that by 2200, the labour capacity across many parts of the world may be reduced by up to 60% in hot months under RCP" https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/9/5/187/htm https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/9/5/187/htm
- Kiro 7y agoI'm amazed how conservative HN comments are when it comes to climate action. You really love your flying and driving here. Personally, I've stopped doing both.
- nabnob 7y agoYup, no one wants to consider actual radical change because it might require a lower standard of living.
- rebuilder 7y agoThis is why I think that in addition to swift action to curtail emissions, we need strong international organisations for discourse, crisis management and mutual aid. If we walk into a new age of mass migrations and instability with the currently popular mindset of nationalist separatism, I don't see how we'll be able to avoid another world war. What will happen between India and Pakistan, for example? These are both nuclear powers.
- johnchristopher 7y agoCould it be either Russia or the US have contingency plans regarding those countries ? Like... nuke them now or send them a suicidal elite special forces mission to take out the top and assume command in the name of peace keeping ?
- black_puppydog 7y agoDoesn't get more "typical US brute force approach" than that, eh? Imagine what would happen if India or Pakistan (a muslim country on top of everything else!) did that to the US. How do you think "assuming command" would go down there?
- johnchristopher 7y agoI am not from the US though and I don't live there. The question is still valid though: are we thinking things through and what are our leader's intentions in case something like that happens and are they thinking about how to prevent it in the first place ? Ten years ago we talked about how the India/Pakistan nuclear arsenal could end up in the hands of Al-Qaeda. What were the plans and which one was put in motion (if any) ?
- carapace 7y agoLike the UN? (Sorry for the snark.)
- mirimir 7y ago> It is therefore hardly surprising that extreme heat drives migration. Such mass displacement makes extreme heat a worldwide issue. So this is the real reason for the US Border Wall, right? That would be an ironic acknowledgement that global climate change is a serious risk.
- kossTKR 7y agoYes almost all policy making / war efforts are created from realpolitical or resource oriented goals. It's the old orders of power and the conglomeration of corporate entities that actually create the shooting script for various events including the creation of a border wall. The identity politics or the thin veneer of hollywoodesque narratives above most especially foreign policy is just exactly that, fantasy, while it's the military-industrial complex that in reality drafts the plans together with PR companies. Look for example at military historian Gwynne Dyers's talk here from 2010 both foreshadowing the refugee crisis, Syrian War and the border wall all from climate extrapolation without the identity-smokescreen. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mc_4Z1oiXhY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mc_4Z1oiXhY The whole border issue is extremely muddy though as it's not classically right-wing to protect the working classes from wage dumping by not letting millions of people in but has become a left-wing issue because class consciousness and economic policy has mostly been replaced with superficial identity based issues because they are allowed by the status quo. This is because they don't interfere with the increase in inequality and fall in real-wages happening in plane sight while pop-leftwingers are busy screaming about identity based issues (not that those aren't important). From a resource perspective one could argue that the ever more transnationally oriented elite couldn't give two f's about protecting the sovereignty of yesterdays empires and nation states - but i think the US is still seen as a very valuable asset because a somewhat stable country with a large middle class is still important in a global system of resource extraction and exploitation - and also as a buffer around the US military which in essence is just a mercenary army created to protect US corporate assets and interests. All in all, the border will be created no matter who is president because the plan has been laid out in military circles for decades , because climate change has never actually been tabu in the corporate intelligentsia as we also see in the Exxon papers from 50 years ago. It's all part of a plan to squeeze as much value out of the global capitalist ponzi scheme and protect US assets just up until everything turns into chaos. Exxon has known this together with most other elite wealth management entities - that is why the next step is border walls with machine guns and watchtowers, then a short balkanisation with feudal rule and mercenary armies protecting the elite before everything collapses and the private jets are pointed towards a new Antarctica or new Zealand bunkers. If this sounds conspiratorial look no further than to Jeff Bezos statement this week that his space travel efforts are very much because he knows we are headed for total collapse of earth ecosystems. Thiel, Bezos, Musk, the Rothhcild family, Saudi Aramco or whoever are all very much aware of the coming collapse and fragmentation - this is why they all invest heavily in "let's get of earth or into the ground" tech.
- czbond 7y agoThe article mentions the "wetbulb" effect and that it stops at 95F. Is this temperature relative to the surrounding humidity? Because much of the U.S. South sits above that for the summer months.
- ceejayoz 7y agoYes. > The wetbulb temperature includes the cooling effect of water evaporating from the thermometer, and so is normally much lower than the normal (“drybulb”) temperature reported in weather forecasts. With 100% humidity, the air temp and the wetbulb temp are the same. At lower humidity levels, they diverge.
- czbond 7y agoThank you.
- rjmunro 7y agoSomething that would help the risk of power outages killing air conditioning, would be to power air conditioning directly by solar panels installed alongside. There is a high correlation between solar generation and air-con demand, although it's not perfect, as e.g. heat can persist into the evening, so you could have a grid connection to allow the air con to continue working in the evenings, and to absorb any excess power but in the event of grid failure, the air-con power should just follow the solar generation directly. I don't know if such a system exists commercially at the moment. Even in the event of wide scale power outages, it would not lead to wide scale deaths as most people would have air conditioning that still worked. Air conditioning failures would be a very serious issue, though, requiring evacuation to another building.
- gnode 7y agoThis could help in some low density cases, but probably not in dense cities. It would require some changes to the inverters such that air con could still be powered in a blackout, due to anti-islanding concerns (feeding power into an isolated portion of the grid can cause injury to workers and further electrical faults). An easier alternative for these rare cases is probably just to have a backup diesel generator.
- rjmunro 7y agoPower outages are not rare everywhere. Where they are rare, a diesel generator that is hardly ever used is likely to not work the time you actually need it. When the grid is working, powering your A/C from solar is still a good idea, and returning power to the grid when you don't need the AC is often helpful. In terms of emergency power outage in hot day situations, you don't need to cool the whole building, or cool it to a comfortable temperature, it just needs to be below a "wetbulb" of 35°C in a single room people can shelter in until power is restored.
- olivermarks 7y agoYou would need a huge number of solar panels and batteries to power an air conditioning unit. Dehumidifiers are far more energy efficient (removes the hot water droplets suspended in air to cool air temp)
- peacetreefrog 7y agoWe need a carbon tax stat IMO. Economist John Cochrane had a good blog post about this recently (I actually posted to HN a few days ago but it got buried): https://johnhcochrane.blogspot.com/2019/05/ip-on-carbon-tax.html https://johnhcochrane.blogspot.com/2019/05/ip-on-carbon-tax.... From the end: "Climate policy was headed to this kind of bipartisan technocratic resolution in the 1990s before it became a tool of partisan warfare. The challenge, from both sides, is to remove the political baggage that climate policy has accumulated." He then makes that appeal to both sides: "To my climate-skeptic friends: Given that the government is going to regulate carbon, this is the way to do it with least damage. To my green-warrior friends, if the government is actually going to reduce carbon, not just subsidize cronies and engage in worthless value-signaling gestures, a trade of carbon taxes for absurdly costly regulations and subsidies is the only way to get anywhere."
- saeranv 7y agoPlease correct me if I'm wrong, but my impression is that this is not something that "both sides" are equally responsible for. In Canada/US, conservatives/Republicans generally refuse to implement a carbon tax; whereas the center-left and left parties generally do. Additionally in the US, the Republicans don't even believe in climate-change. Hence Chomsky's argument that the Republican party is the most dangerous organisation in human history: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/noam-chomsky-republican-party-most-dangerous-organisation-human-history-us-politics-mit-linguist-a7706026.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/noam-choms... So I agree we need carbon tax, but I find it frustrating to pretend this is a issue both sides are at fault for.
- coldpie 7y agoYes. Anyone whining about "both sides" on almost any issue in 2019 is an idiot.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- peacetreefrog 7y agoWell, depends what you mean by "at fault". I agree it's better to believe in global warming than deny it exists, but I agree with Cochrane that many of the attempts at at fixing it so far are basically "worthless value-signaling gestures". Cochrane thinks (not sure I agree with him) that the onus right now is more on the traditional left than the right. "...climate policy advocates have gone far beyond a technocratic idea of simply, well, reducing carbon. 'And nuclear energy' is usually noticeably absent. Carbon capture technologies, equally good at reducing carbon are usually noticeably absent. Other agendas like 'climate justice' creep in -- worthy or not, anything else that creeps in means less carbon reduction per dollar. A carbon tax reduces carbon any way that reduces carbon, which is really good at, well, reducing carbon, and not getting distracted with other agendas. That is a strong reason why carbon taxes, and especially such taxes in return for less regulation are resisted on the left." Whether you agree re: who is at fault, given that most people on HN are prob on the "do something about climate change" end of the spectrum, if you are personally skeptical of a carbon tax vs something like the green new deal or Jay Inslee's climate change plan, I'd encourage you to look into it more. Cochrane's blog post and and also this would be good places to start: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/01/17/this-is-not-controversial-bipartisan-group-economists-calls-carbon-tax https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2019/01/17/this-is-n...
- vectorEQ 7y agotrivia: all planets in our solar system are warming up. do you think our carbon emissions are affecting jupiter too? that being said i'm confident carbon taxes will convince our sun to leave us alone.
- obelos 7y agoPrediction: we’ll wrap an existing Earth city in an environmentally-controlled bubble before we get a bubble to Mars.
- justwalt 7y agoIt’s time to invest in glass.
- mrhappyunhappy 7y agoI think a much overlooked topic is urban planning. Just thinking about Phoenix and the hundreds of homes and apartment complexes blasting ac 24/7 with little or nothing in terms of tree shade. Trees can provide and immense amount of sunlight protection and reduce the heat in a dwelling. I get that they can also fall on your roof, but still, almost nobody planting anything, especially in large apt. Complexes
- cerealbad 7y agoa lot of people would lose income if the climate stopped changing.
- dennisgorelik 7y agoGreenhouse effect increases temperatures mostly in cooler areas of the Earth (which is, mostly, beneficial for people, because it allows to grow more food) and does not affect temperature in already hot areas (close to the equator). If you want to live in a colder climate -- just move North: Canada (almost empty), Northern United States (Alaska is almost empty), Northern Europe, Russia (almost empty). I moved to Florida, because I like warmer temperatures. A lot of other people are moving to warmer South too (from colder North). I will vote against laws that may bring temperature down.
- hi5eyes 7y agosimple engineering problem, improve the ways humans cool/develop some water cooling system for our bodies and scale it
- papito 7y agoUntil the AC units stop being effective, nothing will change.
- krupan 7y agoWe discovered metal that emits more energy than we know what to do with years ago. This energy produces zero carbon emissions. This metal seems to be the obvious solution to carbon emission problems, yet nobody talks about it. Why? https://xkcd.com/2115/ https://xkcd.com/2115/
- krupan 7y agoTimely: https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/07/29/why-earth-overshoot-day-and-the-ecological-footprint-are-pseudoscientific-nonsense/#11b28cb27e76 https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/07/29...
- carapace 7y agoWell, for one thing you linked to the less-impressive XKCD: https://www.xkcd.com/1162/ https://www.xkcd.com/1162/
- banku_brougham 7y agoCouldn’t be more stark: we waited too long. The few that would benefit have tamped down the interest of the exceedingly many who will pay. Name a catastrophe that can compare with this scale — even the effects of that city-killer asteroid hitting Brussels would be easier to deal with.