22 ms·
FAA Finds New Risk on 737 Max, Orders Boeing to Make Changes
- mevile 7y agoI wonder if they're just now finding new things by simply running the software in a simulator, what more will they find, and what does this say to their continued assurances as to the safety of this plane?
- blackflame7000 7y agoOn the flip side, all airplanes have flaws to some degree or else they would never crash. A deep audit of everything in the end should make things safer. And Boeing also has a solid safety record on their other models 777 and 767
- ceejayoz 7y agoAircraft don't have to have flaws to crash, unless you count the human pilots, air traffic controllers, maintenance crews etc. as flaws. You could have a perfect aircraft with no flaws, and a human could still manage to crash it. See the Germanwings flight for a good example.
- blackflame7000 7y agoThe flaw was allowing a single pilot in the cockpit and allowing the co-pilot to get locked out. But yes I do agree that in theory its possible to have a perfect aircraft and still crash due to some act of God. Nevertheless the context was with respect to making an aircraft with known flaws safer
- VBprogrammer 7y agoYou could hardly describe that as a flaw when the alternative was 9/11. It's a trade off on balance of probabilities. A suicidal copilot can still to this day crash any aircraft with only slightly more creativity. For example hitting the fuel cutoffs at 500ft after takeoff.
- avar 7y agoThe alternative isn't a repeat of 9/11. You're assuming that passengers aren't a whole lot more motivated to overpower hijackers after 9/11 than before. One reason 9/11 could happen is that passengers generally assumed a hijacking was mostly a scary inconvenience, not a life-or-death situation.
- magduf 7y agoExactly; another 9/11 situation is impossible now. They just need to keep doing screenings of passengers and their carry-ons to make sure no one can bring obvious weapons on board; anything else is unnecessary and possibly counterproductive. If someone tries to hijack the plane using razor blades or whatever, the passengers will literally murder them.
- ceejayoz 7y agoIt still doesn't hurt to keep them out of the cockpit, though. Quickly stabbing the pilot to death is likely to at least kill or injure a plane's worth of passengers.
- magduf 7y agoTrue, but what if the pilot is having an emergency, or the copilot has decided to commit suicide while the pilot went to the bathroom? There should be a way of getting the door open quickly if enough people authorize it (perhaps at least 2 crewmembers).
- VBprogrammer 7y agoI'm not sure if you were being sarcastic or not. If not you have a lot of faith in people's willingness to sacrifice themselves to save others.
- magduf 7y agoI guess you haven't been paying attention, because there have been hijacking attempts since 9/11, and they did not go very well for the hijackers.
- jussij 7y agoBoeing also has a solid safety record on their other models 777 and 767 and an incredibly poor safety record for their 737-MAX model. The problem for Boeing is the history of flying has many examples of planes with poor safety records being rejected by the flying public. Only time will tell if the 737-MAX joins that illustrious group, but the more the plane stays in the news for all the wrong reasons, the better are it's chances.
- blackflame7000 7y agoThe original 737 had a terrible safety record at first because of a rudder hard-over flaw. It then went on to become the most used in history
- pvg 7y agoThat doesn't sound right. The 737 went into service in the late 60s. There were two confirmed fatal accidents involving rudder hardover in the 90s.
- blackflame7000 7y agoBy Original I meant the NG version
- pvg 7y agoBoth accidents attributed to rudder hardover took place before the 737 NG first flew in 1997.
- blackflame7000 7y agoThere were a lot more than just 2 rudder incidents. USAir Flight 427 United Airlines Flight 585 Eastwind Airlines Flight 517 Silkair Flight 185 Copa Airlines Flight 201 China Southern Airlines Flight 3943 MetroJet Flight 2710
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y ago> Boeing also has a solid safety record on their other models 777 and 767 You seem to be overlooking the 787 - a few early models set on fire. Sure, nobody died, but that was more luck than judgement.
- _ph_ 7y agoI think there are several factors at play. First of all, the 737 MAX is getting scrutinized extremely thoroughly now. Whatever went wrong with the original certification, authorities are looking with extra attention so they are not missing anything this time. Then I think, that as a consequence of the analysis of the two crashes, in general a better understanding of certain flight states has been reached. In the light of this better understanding, other bugs might be discovered which previously have been missed.
- _jal 7y agoAside from the 737, what other Boeing planes have seen significant design work recently? I'm becoming more curious about those.
- mehrdadn 7y ago787? Thought not sure how recently you're referring to.
- ralph84 7y agoBoeing's other current big commercial aircraft development program is the 777X. They are working through engine issues before first flight. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_777X https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_777X
- blackflame7000 7y agoBoeing doesn’t make engines, GE does
- Scoundreller 7y agoEngine Alliance (GE and Pratt & Witney) and Rolls Royce are the 2 players. Because engines are purchased separately from the aircraft, the buyers and engine manufacturers must be in a bind, since the buyer needs to pay for the engines for Boeing to fit them, whether the plane enters service or not.
- kjar 7y agoThis plane appears to be a (sorta) flying dumpster fire rushed to market against Airbus with tragic consequences. One design flaw after another is MAX failure.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThe industry is pretty homogeneous and somewhat of a revolving door between the few OEMs. What are the odds that the code on this plane is orders of magnitude worse (in terms of code quality) than every other similar bit of code in the sky? Edit. I should have to say this but I'm not defending Boeing here. I'm saying it's not at al unforeseeable that the other planes, even ones by other manufacturers are just as bad. Clearly they thought nothing was abnormal about this one until it started falling out of the sky. I see this kind of like diesel-gate. If one of them is cheating they're probably all cheating.
- closetohome 7y agoOr conversely what are the odds that the others have similar undiscovered or undisclosed issues?
- ls612 7y agoFairly low, given that every other type in widespread service has been flying much longer than the MAX with a very good safety record
- BuildTheRobots 7y agoAnd Boeing do have form when it comes to software. https://www.engadget.com/2015/05/01/boeing-787-dreamliner-software-bug/ https://www.engadget.com/2015/05/01/boeing-787-dreamliner-so...
- caf 7y agoUpgrades to the 737 do have a particularly constrained design space, though (due to the oft-mentioned very low ground clearance).
- Xcelerate 7y agoI made a post about three months ago (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19578201 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19578201) that my main fear with the 737 Max was that they rushed the plane into production and more mistakes were made than with just the MCAS system. Unfortunately, that seems to be the case. I doubt Boeing will ever convince me that enough "patches" have been made to make the plane safe to fly on.
- markbnj 7y agoIf after all of this the much more knowledgeable pilots are willing to get on the thing and fly it, I'd be comfortable getting in the back.
- SkyMarshal 7y agoWhy bother given how it easy it is just to chose another itinerary with a different type of plane? It's not like there's only one itinerary/plane type per route or anything.
- michaco33 7y agoNot all pilots have the choice.
- brokenmachine 7y agoOr, the pilots will fly it because they want to keep their jobs.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ngcc_hk 7y agoNot going to trust that model, like dc10 (?). May work not engineer. But as customer, only get 1 life. Not as software beta tester.
- 333c 7y agoHow can you practically avoid a model of plane, other than avoiding all airlines that operate them?
- crimsonalucard 7y agoYou can check the model before purchase.
- 333c 7y agoI just tried this on Southwest's website, and it was hard to find but I was able to do this. Thanks!
- jussij 7y agoJust visit a flight tracking website before booking. In addition I'm sure airlines not flying the MAX will be using that fact as a marketing tool (i.e. we only fly Airbus etc) so you could limit your bookings with just those airlines. As an example of this, here in Australia I know one of the carriers is planning to fly the Max some time next year. If they go ahead with that plan, I will be making sure not to book with that carrier at least for the next few years.
- qaq 7y agoAirlines never use safety angle there is industry wide consensus on that.
- bigiain 7y agoFrom what I hear, at least one of the carriers here that _was_ intending to fly them this year, has cancelled all the maintenance courses for them... They aren't going to be flying them until 2025 apparently, so all the engineers booked on courses to do maintenance for the 747MAX8 are getting re-booked for Airbus courses...
- qrbLPHiKpiux 7y agoThe computers are all part of the problem with this and it's a trend I've noticed for a long time now. Regarding critical output and human input.
- vardump 7y agoI don't think it's a problem that there are less crashes than ever. Even though traffic keeps increasing.
- JudgeWapner 7y agoI see your point. At some point computers simply cannot help us anymore for certain tasks and can actually begin to be a detriment. Software bugs notwithstanding, too much computer means less human piloting and less actual hand flying experience. It might lead to a lower bar of acceptance to be a pilot, or discourage the types of people who actually love flying (since it's mainly done by the computer). More software can mean more complacency, less attention and engagement, less feeling of authority (by being so conditioned to surrender to the computer) and less "feeling" for what is right and wrong in any situation ("the light is green, that means no issue with this thunderstorm, company policy says fly the route when the light is green") . It's perfectly okay to let some jobs (or mechanical assemblies) be manual even when they could be made auto.
- segmondy 7y agoThese same computers enable you to come online and spew this garbage.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoNot "the computers" but the software running on those computers. Software that was specced and implemented by humans.
- zaroth 7y agoAn issue recovering from uncommanded stabilizer trim which is not MCAS-related? I’m going to assume there’s a real issue they are trying to report on, but Gell-Mann effect is strong with this one and some key information is missing.
- rjvehn 7y agoThere are a myriad of issues that put the planes at risk, but I think that the fact that when the control system (MCAS) is engaged causes it to ignore feedback is the biggest issue of all. "But with the MCAS activated, said Fehrm, those breakout switches wouldn’t work. MCAS assumes the yoke is already aggressively pulled back and won’t allow further pullback to counter its action, which is to hold the nose down. Fehrm’s analysis is confirmed in the instructions Boeing sent to pilots last weekend. The bulletin sent to American Airlines pilots emphasizes that pulling back the control column will not stop the action. Fehrm said that the Lion Air pilots would have trained on 737 simulators and would have learned over many years of experience that pulling back on the yoke stops any automatic tail maneuvers pushing the nose down." [0]. If you bought a new computer, how pissed off would you be if you lost data not because of a hard-drive failure, but because of a weird design decision of the 1 penny caps lock key? Imagine spending the time to setup a proper RAID system and losing everything because of a design decision in the keyboard. I mean if the media keeps reporting about the small stuff that's wrong, it's going to make people go "well planes are complex and things happen" and almost ignore the seriousness of a design decision that ignores user input. [0]: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/faa-evaluates-a-potential-design-flaw-on-boeings-737-max-after-lion-air-crash/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/boeing-aerospace/faa-e...
- rossdavidh 7y agoOf all the many problems of the Boeing 737Max situation, and there are several, for once I don't think the media reporting is one of the biggest. But, your basic point stands.
- iClaudiusX 7y agoThe root problem is the culture at Boeing and the FAA has shifted from safety first to profit first. The investigative reporting from The Seattle Times[0] indicates that safety engineers were pressured to avoid delays to rush out a competitor to the A320. Furthermore, their safety analysis was based on flawed assumptions to meet an artificial constraint of not requiring pilot simulator training in order to appease the airlines they were selling to. Finally, the FAA is allowing industry to self-certify critical systems with lax oversight. It is easy to get lost in the technical details of why a particular catastrophe happens. The common throughline is a broken culture where deviance is normalized and those who speak out are ignored. It's the same story with Chernobyl, Fukushima, the El Faro, the USS Fitzgerald and USS John S. McCain, Air France 447, and now the 737 Max. [0] - https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/times-watchdog/the-inside-story-of-mcas-how-boeings-737-max-system-gained-power-and-lost-safeguards/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/times-watchdog/the...
- GiorgioG 7y agoRIP 737Max. I don't see how the airlines can risk flying this PR nightmare again.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoThey'll do some rebranding and resume business as usual after the FAA approves their tweaks. Boeing will have lot of inventory ready to ship and there will no doubt also be some lucrative discounts for airlines currently staring very hard at competing offers from Airbus. Airlines will be flying these planes for decades.
- easytiger 7y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/jun/18/british-airlines-parent-iag-reveals-plans-buy-200-boeing-737-max-jets https://www.theguardian.com/business/2019/jun/18/british-air...
- sambe 7y agoYeah, this is pretty weird and a little scary. I wonder if they are using it as a negotiating tactic - get offered a super low price and then give that price to Airbus to match? Airbus have already enthusiastically said they will bid on this business.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoMy guess is that Boeing essentially gave the plane away in order to have one please, just one! success story at the Paris air show. I can't imagine any airline making a deal at 50% list price with the current perception of that death trap with the public. 50% of list price, btw, is in the ballpark of usual discounts granted to end customers by Boeing and Airbus[1]. While I'm not privvy to any internals (obviously) my take is that IAG essentially gets the plane for free in exchange for a PR win for Boeing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_between_Airbus_and_Boeing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_between_Airbus_and...
- jussij 7y agoThe FAA suffered a major loss of credibility in their handling of the first round of testing/accreditation of the MAX. The FAA can't afford another stuff up this second time around and as such I suspect they will be checking every aspect of the plane in very fine detail. That could spell more trouble for Boeing.
- brentm 7y agoI think overall we should consider this process a very positive thing, FAA and Boeing (and Airbus as well) are all going to learn a lot from this process which will make air travel safer in the future. It's unfortunate that it took two tragedies to get us here but if you look at the history of aviation improvements this isn't the first and it won't be the last time.
- cjbprime 7y agoThe reason people are outraged is that "don't use a single sensor to decide that the plane should perform an uncontrollable nose-dive" isn't the outcome of new learning. That wasn't competent airworthiness seventy years ago. It's a lesson the industry thought it had already internalized. We shouldn't applaud mistakes of the distant part being repeated recklessly as some kind of improvement.
- mantap 7y agoWhat seems to have happened is that the system was originally designed with more conservative parameters. Testing showed that these parameters were insufficient to prevent a stall so they "turned it up to 11", and didn't re-evaluate the original design.
- salawat 7y agoIt wasn't that it wasn't sufficient. It was that they found similar behavior happening in a low-speed part of the flight envelope. That required increasing the authority and losing the G-load safeguard.
- rfugger 7y agoI'd be pretty comfortable flying it after all this attention and review. It will probably be the best reviewed passenger plane software developed in America, if not the world once this is over. Boeing deserves a 9-figure fine though, and its shareholders should lose massively to make sure this doesn't happen again.
- mantap 7y agoI'm not convinced. The pressure on Boeing to fix this ASAP is immense. That is not a good environment for writing safety critical software. Especially if they are doing a "broader software redesign". I don't believe that software quality can be enforced from the outside.
- rosege 7y agoYes, having to use your employee car parking for these jets is not a good look that I'd imagine they are keen to have going on for long. https://www.flyertalk.com/articles/boeing-has-so-many-grounded-maxs-theyre-parking-them-in-the-employee-parking-lot.html https://www.flyertalk.com/articles/boeing-has-so-many-ground...
- karthikb 7y agoInteresting tidbit in the video. At 1:43 you see a MAX in Jet Airways livery - an airline that ceased operations and terminated all flights about 1 month after the grounding began.
- snowwindwaves 7y agoFor anyone writing software controlling machines it is pretty much the status quo. It has to be darn near perfect, updating it later if it is even possible will be expensive and inconvenient As much as it is a shitty environment if you have 6 months to fix it and all of the company resources you can think of to ask for that is lots of time.
- snovv_crash 7y ago
- ranci 7y agoKeep outsourcing your developer jobs to India, seems to be working out really good for you.
- kahirsch 7y agoWhen the Boeing CEO had his press conference in April, he said "we've confirmed that the MCAS system as originally designed did meet our design and safety analysis criteria and our certification criteria."[1] I yelled at the screen "you know that means the criteria are flawed, right? If the procedures didn't catch this mistake, that means there are other mistakes that weren't caught!" A flabbergasted reporter then asks him if he means to say that MCAS was designed to push the nose down 21 times. The CEO then blamed the pilots for not following procedures! He repeatedly avoids avoiding admitting that any mistakes were made. He was so intent on avoiding blame that he gave me no confidence that Boeing could learn from its mistakes. The longer he talked, the less confidence I had in Boeing as a company. I have no idea why this guy still has his job. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xOQmQpKHVWA&t=9m30s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xOQmQpKHVWA&t=9m30s
- joering2 7y agoMeanwhile he claims 737 will be their safest plane ever: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DE4tX0eIDEQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DE4tX0eIDEQ Edit: unsure if this video is correct, but the MCAS system is classical "solution" to how in software a junior programmer would patch their software by adding more complexity to the code without realizing what that changes would further affect. It felt like they gave up on some solid solution and just decided to added a sensor who would overwrite pilot manuver. A similar situation would be downgrading a size of tires on a new model of a car (to be competitve with other auto makers that lower the price) and simply adding software blockage that you cannot turn wheels as violent as you could before because on thin thread that would lead to a car tipover. The whole video - if correct, paints a grim picture of profits above PAXes... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H2tuKiiznsY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H2tuKiiznsY
- dehrmann 7y agoWith all the attention on this plane and the resources Boeing has, they really should have caught this before the FAA.
- scarcelycoher 7y agoYou can't be serious! Did you literally yell those words at the screen?! That's pure madness.
- teh_infallible 7y agoI hate the fact that all discussion focuses on the software and ignores the airframe.
- cmurf 7y agoWhat's the problem with the airframe? What's the problem with the larger engine nacelle causing a different pitching moment? I've yet to read either of those violate any portion of FAR 25. There is still an open question whether the MAX should have or will have a separate type certificate from other 737's, thereby requiring pilots of a type rating to fly the MAX, thereby requiring full disclosure and training on all differences. Which pilots should have had anyway, even if it didn't require a new type rating.
- mrpippy 7y agoI wish I had a more authoritative source, but this matches my understanding: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19512161 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19512161 As a side note, it’s really unfortunate that we won’t get an NTSB-level (both in detail and widespread respect for the organization) report on what went wrong and how it happened. I’m not sure the Ethiopian and Indonesian authorities will really (be able to) dig into MCAS and all the details of its development as deeply as we’d like. I expect that some of the reporters covering this story will write books (Dominic Gates and Jon Ostrower in particular), and those will be the most authoritative accounts.
- cmurf 7y agoThe NTSB will issue a report. It's an American made airplane involved in an accident, so they are required to investigate. They just don't have primary jurisdiction over the investigation, per ICAO rules.
- tremon 7y agoWhat's the problem with the airframe? The #1 problem with the airframe is that it is not identical to the original 737 airframe. Therefore it shouldn't have been certified as a 737, and it should have required pilot training. Boeing has been using software to emulate a 737 airframe to avoid the pilot training costs. This approach itself is fraught with problems, and I hope the FAA puts a hard stop to these non-solutions.
- bjourne 7y agoSince this thread is already full of armchair airplane engineers opinions about the root cause, I'll add mine too: Never ever write new software under the condition that it must work EXACTLY as old software. It can't be done and you'll always miss something. Case in point: Wine. They've been at it for years and the emulation layer is still far from perfect. It works 99% of the time which is good enough for games, but I wager not for airplane control systems.
- kunday 7y agoFair point. Compaq in 1980's is probably the best case for reverse engineering and building a robust system. In some cases it out performed IBM PC's. However, I have to admit, reverse engineering a home desktop is different from a airline software, considering that bugs can instantly kill people.
- wnkrshm 7y agoAlso, if you rebuild a system in isolation, you have to reproduce all the bugs - since you do not know which of the bugs are load-bearing, i.e. other systems have been engineered to depend on the bugs, whether by accident or intentionally.
- kunday 7y agoAbsolutely correct. (cough) javascript at Microsoft.
- TazeTSchnitzel 7y agoWine is not a good example. They don't have access to the source code of the original system, and they haven't had the resources to cover the entire footprint of the Windows APIs.
- skykooler 7y agoThat's a good point. It'd be like comparing Boeing building a new plane to, say, Tupolev trying to build an identical copy without any blueprints.
- Havoc 7y agoBoeing seems to have a safety culture issue. Which is a lot worse than one dodgy plane...
- dandare 7y agoAs a web/game developer, one thing I never understood is the alleged complexity of these control systems. There is no image/voice recognition, no graphics engine, no rocket science. What are they even doing? Or is it all a big lie? Lines of code, from the internet[1]: Pacemaker: 100k Boeing 787: 5M Chevy Volt: 10M Modern car: 100M [1] https://www.visualcapitalist.com/millions-lines-of-code/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/millions-lines-of-code/
- baby 7y agoWhy I can’t understand is why audio is still shit, and why they can’t get immediate live help from some 24/7 support. Don’t we have the technology?
- 238475235243 7y agoThere's a number of pieces: * Writing everything three times for three different computers with three different architectures in three different ways (e.g. numerical vs symbolic integration) * Using obsolete programming languages for the same reasons doctors use latin * Has to be usable by poorly trained pilots, while tired, on the other side of the planet in complete darkness with half the systems failing. * Nobody dies if you web/game crashes. The plane has to still be flyable in unimaginably bad conditions like a total engine loss by deploying a windmill (ram air turbine), therefore every scenario is accounted for. Caveat is we usually find new scenarios by crashing planes, not by thinking about them first. Kind of a definitional thing: if you'd thought of it, it wouldn't have crashed.
- dandare 7y agoWriting everything 3 times: I believe this is not the case for a car or pacemaker. For the Boeing: 5M/3 = 1.3M lines of code. Still makes no sense. Obsolete languages: Old language (or Latin) does not bloat the size of your code astronomically. Usability in specific conditions: does not apply to a car or pacemaker. Yes, for an airplane, it can make the design phase lengthy and difficult but the actual size of the code will not bloat astronomically. From some of the discussions I have seen on HN, writing safety-critical software is not a question of adding millions of lines of code - to the contrary, safe software must be clean and readable.
- timvisee 7y agoPlease, don't link paywalled articles.
- leetcrew 7y agoposting paywalled articles is explicitly allowed in the site guidelines. complaining about paywalls, on the other hand, is not.
- pseingatl 7y agoIs the defective processor also used in the 737-800/900 non-grounded aircraft?
- ulfw 7y agoIf only the FAA wasn't corrupt and did their job of testing, verifying and CERTIFYING the 787 and 737max in the first place rather than outsourcing it to the VERY MANUFACTURER Boeing. I don't know where y'all went to school, but I was never able to self-grade my year-end exams. Absolutely unthinkable banana republic behaviour and not a single head rolled (except for the about 350 poor dead souls who had to pay for this corruption with their life).
- bumby 7y agoI think Hanlon's Razor is a more likely answer to why the FAA failed
- hrktb 7y agoDid they take the ongoing multi-faceted bribes by incompetence, with no malice involved ? Hanlon's Razor is useful in some scopes, but imagine applying it to banking, politics, corporate regulation or law enforcement. Depending on your position, not doing due diligent and acting ethically is malice.
- bumby 7y agoNot doubting you, but has there been evidence of bribes in the case of the 737-MAX? I'm genuinely curious. It may be mismanagement or incompetence, but I don't know if it gets to the degree of malice. Here's how I see it working: FAA is obligated to provide oversight. FAA is also not given resources to do due diligence themselves (e.g., one inspector may be responsible for multiple airframes, meaning there is no possible way to know the systems in intimate detail to catch everything). To mitigate the lack of resources, they contractually obligate or delegate the oversight to the manufacturer who (presumably) does have that system knowledge. However, it's still the FAA's job to ensure the manufacturer is doing due diligence on oversight. This can easily become a catch-22...without resources to catch the manufacturer errors (e.g., FAA was apparently unaware of software configuration changes), it makes it tough to throw the red flag when everyone is clamoring to keep the schedule moving. They have to defer to the system "experts". The above is not based on personal experience with this particular case and I'm not saying the FAA is not culpable. I just don't think it's due to deliberate malice. It's the same issue all over the government in terms of oversight. Oversight functions are often the easiest to scale back during budget crunches which, over time, will increase the risk of bad events. Then there is an uproar, the pendulum swings the other way, people want to fund oversight functions until they are once again lulled into complacency by the lack of bad events (which is actually an indication that the oversight is working). There is likely some degree of bribes in most government organizations. It's a cancer that needs to be removed, but the real question is whether it's at a level that makes true governance infeasible. I would love to see the government acting as a proper and impartial oversight role. But are taxpayers willing to pay for it? Sure, we can make a case for increased funding to support the FAA after 737-MAX, but what about what about when things seem to be going smoothly? And this is just one sector...would taxpayers be willing to provide the same resources to the FDA, EPA, OSHA, and all the other stretched-too-thin organizations?
- hwestiii 7y agoThis all points up the glaring conflicts of interest in the corporate business environment. Most of us think that Boeing is the business of building airplanes, but as a publicly traded company, its real business is making money for its shareholders, and aerospace is just a vehicle toward that end. The Boeing CEO's steadfast refusal to take responsibility for these two crashes are nothing more than CYA designed to limit or defer financial responsibility for >300 deaths and protect and privilege shareholder value above the safety and well-being of the flying public.
- navigatesol 7y ago>but as a publicly traded company, its real business is making money for its shareholders This is such a tired argument. How much money do you think Boeing is going to make for its shareholders if its planes are crashing and fleet is grounded?
- linuxftw 7y agoYou're right. The real motivation is always making money for the executives and board-members. Bonuses are paid for revenue, not for not killing folks.
- navigatesol 7y ago>You're right. The real motivation is always making money for the executives and board-members. What sort of mindset must one have to assume that once a person becomes a "manager" or "executive" they are suddenly immoral or evil? Such an odd worldview. I guarantee no one at Boeing make the conscious effort to kill hundreds of people for a bonus. Mistakes happen. People of all standing are corrupt. We fix the issues and move on, not cry about executives, board members and shareholders (of which most people on this board are striving to be).
- linuxftw 7y agoI don't need an armchair assessment of my worldview, thanks. It's well known that large US companies offer perverse incentives for their executives. As long as they don't do anything super illegal, there's often no recourse. I mean, recent history is replete with examples of executives optimizing-for-bonus.
- dominicr 7y ago“Addressing this condition will reduce pilot workload” is a funny way of saying they're going to stop planes crashing themselves! We're all quite used to having problems described in the least threatening way but I'm thankful that I've never had to do so about something that could result in people dying.