20 ms·
The internet is an SEO landfill
- sova 7y agoIt's a strong observation, now what do you propose we do about it?
- swayvil 7y agoFilter out all commerce-related results. It would be the same as a spam-filter, right? A pattern-identifier. This seems obvious and doable.
- sametmax 7y agoJust because you observe a problem doesn't mean you have a solution. That doesn't remove the value from the observation, as long as it's not a way to just regularly complain at everything without a goal.
- dmix 7y agoWe tried paying a big SEO consultant with a long track record of big-name successes (allegedly) $10k/month and the poor results we’re getting had as much to do with the whole hiring high paid consultants who waste your time in weekly meeting busywork than actual SEO not working. Not a good idea for small businesses or startups, even if you can afford it, IMO. SEO is still a long term investment that every company needs to make for the benefit of their users, helping people find you and your information on search engines is a good thing (assuming you’re providing real value). The only problem are the spam sites who still succeed occasionally on the fringes. Which was why we were motivated to get SEO (and SEM) help in the first place - as one of our biggest competitors is a shameless gray/black hat spammer that their poor customers keep finding on Google.
- orkon 7y agoI kind of agree, and I think nowadays it's hard to promote a product on the Internet or even get noticed without putting a lot of effort. When the Internet was smaller, I guess it's been easier. Off-topic: the author's product seems similar to my open source tool https://github.com/justcomments/newsletter-cli https://github.com/justcomments/newsletter-cli which allows sending emails via AWS SES
- prepend 7y agoI think it’s possible, it just doesn’t get a lot of attention because the scale is small. I have friends who run small businesses and just have simple sites and blogs about their customers and they have more business than they can handle. Granted it’s just a living, but it’s almost all traffic through google through organic results. Interestingly, their competitors frequently have these bullshit, SEO sites that come in below and able their organic results. They come and go but my friend has been around for 10 years. Customers do mention that they like a “real” site.
- agumonkey 7y agoI wonder if the web will saturate and clog, start to cost more to keep up and maintain and lose users that feels walking around and talking is simpler.
- onefuncman 7y agothis is already true
- agumonkey 7y agohow much ? is it nascent or do you see slightly large changes ?
- joshwcomeau 7y agoGreat intro, but where’s the actual article? (Also it’s pretty harsh to say that it takes “little talent” to become an SEO expert. Like all industries, there are charlatans selling snake oil, but there are experts who have invested a lot of time in developing their skill sets, and it’s not nice to be so dismissive.)
- bdcravens 7y agoI don't even think the author is talking about charlatans. I think the point is the barrier to entry is pretty low, and how do you define what is an "expert"? "SEO expert" is just a few letters you stick on your LinkedIn profile or business card; some will be experienced, ethical experts that get results for sure. I see it the same way I see network marketing: yes, some turn Mary Kay or essential oils into viable careers, but that doesn't invalidate the common criticisms.
- luckylion 7y agoFrom my personal experience with SEO people: the experts make large sums of money running their own sites. The non-experts run around with lofty promises and "consult" for other's sites.
- walshemj 7y agoIf it requires so little talent why in 2019 is the quality a lot of websites so poor? some examples is why do sites still misuse H tags or have problems like creating a simple xml site map that handles escaping characters when required
- shripadk 7y ago"but where’s the actual article?" There isn't. It is another article that will end up in the SEO landfill the author is complaining about along with other "spammy" articles that already exist in the landfill. In essence, this is another "spammy" article to promote his product cleverly disguised as an anti-spam/anti-SEO article. I suspect an SEO agency actually told him to write this article to generate conversation (people who resonate with the intro will share it on all social circles and cause it to go "organically" viral). As they say, all publicity is good publicity. This is as meta as it gets!
- tardo99 7y agoThis is all made worse by the fact that search is a monopoly.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jormungand 7y agoUnfortunately SEO ruins great, witty and brief marketing texts.
- jacques_chester 7y ago> Unfortunately SEO ruins great, witty and brief marketing texts. SEO content marketing is basically a descendent of direct marketing -- the stuff you used to get in the mail, in two-page spreads in Reader's Digest and so forth. Direct marketers have known for a very long time that long-form copy sells better. They had the numbers to prove it long before "analytics" was a common idea -- the very term A/B testing refers to the "A" and "B" sides of a newspaper print roller being able to print two versions of an advertisement. Source: Tested Advertising Methods by Caples. A fascinating, if depressing, read.
- ghgr 7y ago> the very term A/B testing refers to the "A" and "B" sides of a newspaper print roller being able to print two versions of an advertisement. Really? That's interesting. But how could they tell which version converted better? Maybe distributing each version in a different area?
- jacques_chester 7y agoThat was the beauty of it. As the newsprint passes through, one paper will get A, the next will get B, the next A and so on. The plates are otherwise identical for each page being printed. This perfect 50/50 split pretty much controls for all the plausible variables. Location, time of day, you name it, the odds of a reader seeing either A or B was exactly 50%.
- hiccuphippo 7y agoBut why is that? Do search engines rank better when a text is longer? Or is it that with more words there's a higher possibility that one will match with what the user is searching? And doesn't it all just make users waste more time searching for something concrete? Maybe there's space for search engines that can summarize a page if it's long and give the user what they want.
- alt_f4 7y agoI agree that paying for SEO is probably pointless; unless you're just paying for some Google ads yourself. But the problem with your product isn't SEO, it's that anyone who knows what SES is, also knows how to use it for the thing you're selling, without paying an additional fee.
- ajonit 7y agoThat is an incorrect observation. There are people making a living out of selling exact similar scripts as the OP. (Sendy comes at the top of my mind)
- jonex 7y agoIt started off strong, nicely illustrating the background leading to this mess, but then the conclusion falters, in particular the accusation of: "Don’t the makers of Search Engines know this? Of course they do. It’s just not in their interest to bring clarity." without any suggestions on what they could be doing to achieve that clarity. To me, it sadly seems like a losing war between the SEO-spammers and the search engine developers. There's no law of nature making it possible to separate fake content from true content. If The spam is good enough, I'm not even sure a human can do it. Maybe the concept of trust-less content distribution will have to come to an end at some point and we will start ranking searches based on more or less manually maintained trust graphs?
- saagarjha 7y ago> If The spam is good enough “Good spam” is just real content.
- jonex 7y agoYes, more or less. But with the difference that it doesn't even attempt at being true. We've been spoiled by the internet of old, where geeky types wrote blogs and created web sites sharing their intricate knowledge of their favourite topic. Of course there's a fair share of conspiracy theorists and incorrect ideas, but it was generally in good faith and somewhat easy to filter. Now you won't find those anymore, instead we get SEO-optimising sites with text sourced via Fiverr resembling meaningful content but without any ambitions whatsoever of correctness nor meaningfulness. Best case, it just ends up in frustration as you realise that it's just filler, worse case, it actually misleads you with some made-up fact that you couldn't see any reason to lie about.
- ksclarke 7y ago> “Good spam” is just real content. Harvested and put on somebody else's site that is covered with ads.
- luckylion 7y agoNo, it's not. Good spam looks like real content, but isn't accurate. It's an article about the most eco friendly kitchen appliance that reads just fine, but littered with factual inaccuracies and exists solely to give the impression that somebody has taken the time to write an actual article on the topic. It's often below GPT2 level, and I'm sure we'll have great fun with autogenerated SEO content in the future.
- gk1 7y agoAnd yet, this site had two pages made — I suspect — primarily for SEO purposes: Mailchimp Alternative and Sendgrid Alternative. Organic search is the highest or second-highest source of traffic for every startup I know. Yes there are too many SEO charlatans, but to ignore such a large traffic source is not smart.
- jacques_chester 7y ago> And yet, this site had two pages made — I suspect — primarily for SEO purposes: Mailchimp Alternative and Sendgrid Alternative. The author opens with exactly that gripe: > I have a product that can be explained in one or two sentences. It is fairly well documented. Yet i’m being asked to write 4,000 word articles describing and comparing my product with the competition. Why? Because SEO.
- scarface74 7y agoNot every startup. I’ve worked for 3 small B2B SASS companies that have a sales team that went after only “whales” for revenue. I much prefer that model instead of leaving your business’s future in the hands of Facebook/Google.
- blue_devil 7y agoI suppose people upvoted this for the refreshing quality of a candid rant.
- caiocaiocaio 7y agoGoogle any recipe, and there are at least 5 paragraphs (usually a lot more) of copy that no one will ever read, and isn't even meant for human consumption. Google "How to learn x", and you'll usually get copy written by people who know nothing about the subject, and maybe browsed Amazon for 30 minutes as research. Real, useful results that used to be the norm for Google are becoming more and more rare as time goes by. We're bombarding ourselves with walls of human-unreadable English that we're supposed to ignore. It's like something from a stupid old sci-fi story.
- theturtletalks 7y agoSo true. Whenever I look up something now I just add Reddit afterwards. It's been working well so far, but I guess that can be manipulated as well.
- outime 7y agoNot OP but yes, I’ve also been doing this for a long time and it does help.
- minitoar 7y agoOr “wiki”.
- carlob 7y agoor use duckduckgo's bangs
- CondensedBrain 7y agoSite searching Reddit can at least give some ideas for different words to try. Most of my problems finding things on Google stem from its declining ability to make a reasonable guess based on what I put in. It's not enough to have a word anymore. You have to know the right keyphrase or it shows a whole different world of results. It used to show its best guess, then branch off from it with less specificity and more variety and, in general, a result reflecting what I meant within a few pages. Now Google is so desperate to get it right on result #1 that it never admits failure no matter how many pages you go.
- nemild 7y agoThe irony is that this page will help improve the SEO of this domain.
- spzb 7y agoIt's not irony if that was the desired effect
- jacquesm 7y agoThis is a direct effect of using search engines to navigate the web. If we'd stuck to following links curated by actual people (link-rings and other nice inventions) then we'd have never had this problem in the first place. Unfortunately the garbage is here to stay and the good content is totally drowned in a sea of trash.
- dageshi 7y agoIf search engines were never invented the web wouldn't be a fraction as useful or popular as it actually is today. I know it's fashionable to hate Google nowadays but come on.
- _mdpn 7y agoThe older I get the more I realize that there is often an inverse correlation between popular and useful/valuable.
- scarface74 7y agoI was “on the internet” before Google and a little before the web became popular when all you had was Gopher, Usenet, and Veronica. The internet was much less useful then. On top of that, without the web becoming popular, there wouldn’t have been the investment in fast home internet or fast cellular data.
- luckylion 7y agoWould you have needed fast home internet without the web being popular though? Granted, they didn't look as good, but I know plenty of sites that loaded more quickly 15 years ago when my internet speed was less than a percent of what it is now. Of course, the past is always rosy, especially when you were young, and new things are always exciting and lose their novelty when you get used to them, but I found the internet much more interesting back then.
- 7y ago
- ehnto 7y agoSearch results are so heavily weighted toward commerce, products and services because those are the people that can spend money on SEO. It's made the internet, seen through the eyes of search results, seem like an aggressive, shady market bazaar. I try searching for anything remotely bike related, bike community, mechanical information, or just general cool bike stuff and I can't find the human community underneath all the fluff articles trying to sell me shit. The internet, as free as it is, has been overflowed with commercial activity. Which pretty closely reflects the real world, but damn that's a shame.
- jacquesm 7y agoOne nice solution would be a search engine that throws out anything related to commerce or linking to commerce.
- orkon 7y agoThen the search engine itself would be probably thrown away :-D
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoMy favorite parts of the internet have no relation to ads or commerce at all.... including wikipedia. When you’re looking for information commerce is a massive distraction.
- snlnspc 7y agosadly true, but an open source engine like searx could be made to do such a thing
- baxtr 7y agoMaybe the mentioned “consultants” told him to write an SEO rant and post it on HN? Hmm...
- draugadrotten 7y agoYes, of course. "Simultaneously they have a team ... basically seeding a link of my site on as many other sites as they can get hold of. "
- hartator 7y agoIt’s hard to take this seriously when the author is trying to sell a tool to help send email spam.
- yborg 7y agoThe mere existence of a blogpost by a guy complaining that it's a hassle to shill his thing that generates spam on the Internet on the Internet makes the point better than anything written in it - it's almost the pure essence of SEO garbage itself. Whether the irony is unintended or it's deliberate marketing, it's a perfect embodiment.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoI'm always at aw at how people can psychologically say SEO is easy. Getting to the top of many SERPs can mean millions of dollars in monthly revenue. If it's so easy, and the author is so smart about it, why doesn't he just take it? It's like people who say 'well of course CRO is easy, you just make it easy for people to check out and check the stats and iterate'. Overly arrogant engineers many times think everyone else is stupid for not being an engineer, but forget that more than just engineers are needed. I'm guessing that is how you end up with Google +.
- bdcravens 7y agoDunking a basketball is easy: you just have to jump high enough.
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoIt reminds me of myself and my nerdy friends in high school. We would say 'being a football player is so easy you just run and grunt, not like us who love math... math is for those who are REALLY smart'. It took me a long time before I could look back at that attitude and cringe at the arrogance and lack of understanding of the complexities of the world. The fact that this article is getting upvoted while my comment is getting downvoted is telling.
- bscphil 7y ago>If it's so easy, and the author is so smart about it, why doesn't he just take it? The title suggests one possible answer to that question - the author has moral qualms about turning the Internet into a landfill. (Then again, given that this article is itself almost certainly supposed to double as shitty SEO marketing / clickbait, I have my doubts.)
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoWell every site that ranks does SEO. So the issue shouldn't be in the methods, but in the end game. Like, what value are you bringing. He could bring value and get a ton of money. For example mortgage calculators. There are a million. Pick one, and rank it. You'll be making millions while providing value. Strange he isn't doing it, since it is so easy and all. I mean, whatever his goals in life, a few million a year will probably help push that.
- dheera 7y agoIt would be awesome if Google had up/downvote buttons like Reddit and use them to eliminate all the fluff in search results, even if on a targeted community basis. For example if a recipe has no pictures, too many ads, not clear instructions, or no equivalent volume measurements (e.g. "4 grams sugar (about 1 tsp)") I'm likely to downvote it, and those properties can be learned from multiple downvotes.
- spiderfarmer 7y agoUpvoted.
- spectre256 7y agoIts a really nice idea, but I wonder if it would work in practice: 1. Would a significant amount of real humans who actually cared about the content cast a vote (up or down)? 2. Would it be even remotely possible to protect against fraudulent voting at Google scale? (remember they can't even prevent fake business listings on Google Maps, which is at least theoretically closer to verifiable from, for example, business records)
- theturtletalks 7y agoI don't think it will work in practice. Reddit and other voting platforms require a login to prevent spam voting and do people want Google to know which articles you like and don't? Reddit works because anonymity which Google will not provide.
- microwavecamera 7y agoBut Reddit, along with most major sites now, is also rife with the same marketing manipulators and "influencers" the article is commenting on. Digg tried something similar before Reddit and was pretty much ruined by biased organized vote manipulation (brigading). Not that I agree with Google's "trust us plebes we know better than you" model of secrecy either. The SEO problem is the prime example of why this doesn't work also. Search engines have become a vital resource for the modern internet. We need an open, publicly funded non-profit search engine.
- cottonseed 7y agoI just wish search engines would let me block sites. There are maybe a dozen SEO land grabs in my domain that are trashing my search results and provide no value.
- jpindar 7y agoThere are browser add-ons that do that.
- inetknght 7y agoI think search engines need to realize the value of raising their results' quality by allowing users to tell them which sites they think are scummy.
- vntok 7y agoMake it an easy-to-click report button and pretty much every site whose politics I disagree with will get a downvote... every article by a person I disagree with as well. The question is: how useful is that to the search engine, or indeed to myself?
- stordoff 7y ago> pretty much every site whose politics I disagree with will get a downvote If this happens to all sites, wouldn't only the poorer sites stand out? I don't see why one strand of politics would be significantly more likely to downvote.
- qtplatypus 7y agoThe more extreme the politics the more able you are to rally the troops for report bombing. You can see this on sites like YouTube.
- GraemeL 7y agoI use a user script called Google Hit Hider by Domain that adds this functionality to pretty much every major search engine. Can't imagine searching without it these days.
- corodra 7y agoQuestion, and seo is not my field of expertise at all. Doesn't it seem odd that an seo consultant says to pay for search result ads? In my mind, the point of seo is not to pay "per click". You may pay for a great article to be written, and pay for it to be on a site, which is fair to me. But I then expect it to be noticed because of it's own merits, quality of writing and quality of "publisher". If you also have to pay for an ad for it, why bother with the publisher or even "seo quality" writing? Just write quality while ignoring seo tactics, put it on your own domain and pay for the ad yourself. Again, I'm no expert and I have no skin in this game. Anyones two cents? Especially if you own an ecommerce site of some sort.
- toast0 7y agoIf you're paying an SEO consultant, you are probably wanting more traffic, SEM is going to get you more traffic, possibly at higher cost, but also in a much easier to count way. Way back when, I worked at a travel information site that put a lot of effort into SEO and SEM. For SEO, it was mostly trying to make sure important terms showed up on the page importantly, and making sure our internal linking was using useful links, and some light link exchange with quality sites. We were never able to pinpoint any changes with results, though. SEM was pretty much pure arbitrage -- find the pages that make the most $/pageview, find keywords that are relevant, bid so we make whatever margin the corporate overlords require. This was all easy to track and very actionable -- if keywords did well, increase the spend, if not, turn it down. We presumably got some non-trackable benefits from exposure, assuming some people who clicked through our pages would come back and use our site some more later.
- nickserv 7y agoI'm not an expert but have worked with some, developing seo tools. What I've seen is that Google or FB ads are used by big clients that can afford it as a quick and easy way to get visits. An seo 'expert' whose main recommendation is to get Google ads is no expert at all. They can be part of a marketing campaign but are by no means the most cost effective way to getting good rankings, and users are more likely to click on organic search results than ads.
- schachin 7y ago
- spinach 7y agoIt's in part because of the search engine's business model, just like other free apps like Facebook that suffer similar problems where the person who is consuming the product is not actually the customer. A free product from companies that aspire to be multi-million, multi-billion dollar global companies and are celebrated by those in the tech industry for doing so, even with a 'free' product. The idea of a liberal and free internet and free products with an idolization and celebration of wealth of those same companies doesn't work. We end up with the landfill. We got what we paid for, didn't we (nothing).
- alexashka 7y agoThere are more general terms for the author describes, it's 'advertising' and 'marketing'. This is the cost of having a free market - people are free to compete on it. This is the cost of freedom of speech - idiots get to talk. You can fix this to an extent with laws - for example you can't advertise cigarettes to children. Just be aware that you can't have it all and live your life :)
- gist 7y agoLet me give another perspective on this from "the school of 'old school'" Back in the day of yellow page advertising one of the barriers to getting business was placing an expensive advertisement in the yellow pages (for certain types of businesses). I can personally attest to the advantage of doing that. That is I was able to build a business from nothing ZERO sales to over $2m/year using a yellow page ad as the only advertising expense (also used direct mail though). Many of my competitors never wanted to spend the money for a similar ad. (You had to pay for an entire year). It just seemed to expensive to them. It was. That was good though, not bad 'psychological barrier to entry'. Back in the day it was several thousand dollars per month without knowing (the first time) what kind of results you would get. My point is having to pay that money (and the effort of designing an ad and paying for it) showed commitment to what you were doing (at that time). It's just another way to differentiate from the competition. We were entirely self funded also and took business away from large corporations that did the exact same thing as we did. In the end having to pay for that ad was a good thing, not a bad thing. I don't know all of google's logic with why they decide who gets SEO juice or not but I wouldn't discount what I am talking about as one of the reasons that things work this way.
- gfodor 7y agothis article is really something. the author is complaining about the spammy nature of the "Internet" when they are in fact complaining about the spammy nature of search results, particularly those on Google. and yet, the whole thrust of the argument is a complaint about difficult it has been to participating very aggressively in the dynamic that leads to this spammy nature. if they have a problem with this, they have a problem not with the Internet but with search engines as the primary discovery mechanism of web sites. and if they have a problem with that, participating in the literal exact thing that results in what they are complaining about without reflecting on their own behavior is very odd.
- nickserv 7y agoI'm inclined to thinking the article is actually a great marketing technique for this product. I mean, it's peddling a way of sending marketing emails via AWS... Nothing spammy there!
- oconnor663 7y ago> Don’t the makers of Search Engines know this? Of course they do. It’s just not in their interest to bring clarity. Because they're in a perpetual arms race against spammers. The search engines don't have a choice about any of this.
- zo1 7y agoI reckon that arms-race only exists because the web is fundamentally broken due to having/allowing some level of anonymity. If you could perma-ban a spammer's real world identity or that of his company (or any company they're a part of), then there would be no need for the arms race. Just a continual "negotiation" whereby bad behavior is informed and requested to stop. And if that entity decided to ignore such a request they'd get the nuclear option of being permanently banned from the platform. You could argue that such a system would not be that different to real-world licensing requirements/restrictions as applied to lawyers and doctors. Just follow the identity like you would the money, and you could solve a good chunk of this issue.
- buboard 7y agoIf it s an arms race they are quite the losers. Google s image search is basically unusable for free material. Bing or yandex are way better
- swayvil 7y agoFilter out all commerce-related results. It would be the same as a spam-filter, right? A pattern-identifier. Google obviously wouldn't do it so we'll create a layer over Google, like LMGTFY does. This seems obvious to me so I'm probably missing something.
- ex3xu 7y agoI think what frustrates me most about the current state of SEO is that it is a race to the bottom for both businesses and consumers. Below a certain threshhold of notability, traffic essentially becomes correlated with SEO spend. Even the business that wins the SEO war in its local community can end up with issues, as for certain industries the disproportionate number of eyes on the first few links can easily balloon into an unmanageable amount of service calls and customer support infrastructure needs, when all the while perfectly adequate businesses languish away on the second and third SERPs ends up fighting over the remaining 5% traffic scraps. In an ideal world, traffic numbers would be correlated with some combination of product quality mixed with a sort of load-balancing effect so that each quality company could match their available supply to the demand. I still believe, perhaps naively, that search engines could have profitably built infrastructure to serve the needs of consumers in this way -- focus group-like services for commercial search that would require companies to pay for the privilege of submitting to objective evaluations of their products in exchange for more traffic. In a structure like this, the incentives of search engines and end users could be aligned. Instead, Eric Schmidt and the rest of the market share MBAs came into the picture and we got precisely the opposite -- instead of holding businesses beholden to the needs of end users, now we have this insidious and dystopian perpetual advertising machine where not only are businesses now beholden to the needs of a faceless SEO algorithm, funneling money away from R&D and into this annoying waterfall of trite crap noted by this article, but IMO even worse is that end users are essentially beholden to the needs of the corporations -- either by getting creepily data-mined and harvested for the benefit of the highest AdWords bidder, or by getting inundated by constant ads, as anyone who has tried watching YouTube without AdBlocker on can attest to. I don't think I'm being hyperbolic when I say that nobody wins except the search engine stockholders. I was totally heartbroken when Google sold out and created AdWords. I naively had thought it would never happen -- Brin and Page were literally on record saying, “Advertising funded search engines will be inherently biased towards the advertisers and away from the needs of consumers” (Anatomy of a Large-Scale Hypertextual Web Search Engine, 1998)[0]. So I've had embarrassingly heated discussions with Googler family members where I raise this issue, and their defense has been essentially that AdWords is a necessary evil that funds all their infrastructure expenses, as well as their cool R&D and "20% time" and all their ML advancements that they get to do, like AlphaGo, Waymo etc. But I really think that when your company depends on perverse incentives in this way, the end result will ultimately drift away from their original job of serving consumers, and eventually exist only to inflate their own share price and run what amounts to a protectionist racket. The only difference is that the threat of withholding SEO traffic is much cheaper and efficient option than mafia shakedowns.
- beefield 7y agoI guess if google was willing to do no evil for a moment and actually think what would make both their search better for the user and www better place overall, they would put a big button next to each search result saying roughly "Hey, dear google. Every thing I have ever seen in this domain is full of crap. Please do not ever again show any page from this domain in my search results" And then use the information from this button to lower the search score for any domain with high level of users willing to ignore a domain completely.
- progval 7y agoWhile I would personally love such a feature; there's the issue of computer illeterate people who accidentally click on it for a domain they care about, forget about it, and then have no idea why the google is broken
- hombre_fatal 7y agoSame reason why turning off wifi/bluetooth on iOS only turns it off for 24 hours. I reckon it avoids an incredible amount of confusion.
- luckylion 7y agoWon't work: SEOs already send user signals by literally paying normal, average persons to once in a while do a search for something and click on each result until they arrive at example.tld. The thinking is that Google tracks keywords + clicks, and if people search for "keyword" and aren't satisfied with the info on domain1, domain2 and domain3 (demonstrated by clicking on the next result) but are satisfied after visiting example.tld (demonstrated by not clicking on any other results), Google will rank example.tld higher. It's not cheap, and I consider it to be more Voodoo than proven fact, and most SEO people are generally more the religious type than the scientist, so they won't run tests. They do it, see that they rank well and continue to do it. I've suggested sacrificing chickens, but nobody listens to me (or they won't admit that they do).
- shripadk 7y agoThis functionality can be misused by your competitor(s)! There already is the issue of companies fraudulently clicking on search and display ads just to damage the advertising budget of competitors. This would only open up another dimension for abuse.
- booleandilemma 7y agoSEO is essentially voodoo bullshit right? The people I’ve met who hawk it are the same people who in the same breath refer to themselves as UX professionals, interaction designers, or some other nebulous term. It’s yet another thing that requires little to no training but gives these people clout in their organization and a role to play.
- macspoofing 7y agoCould it be anything otherwise? For any given search term there may be millions of results but only 50 or so will make the first page. No matter what you do, you can't expect to be one of those 50. We've reached an era when you can't simply rely on the search engine to do your marketing for you. You'll have to do the traditional route of marketing where you take the responsibility of getting the word out on your product. This is similar to YouTubers complaining when their traffic takes a nose-dive because YouTube tweaked some recommendation algorithm. In other words, this is what the long-tail looks like.
- xkcd1963 7y agoProtagonist shames people who work in marketing, calls them bottom feeders, low skill workers and spammers. Protagonist’s product offers ‘marketing emails’ service
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoI'll add to that: Protagonist is trying to make money selling email marketing services. It isn't working. He wants to make money (it's not a charity) There are millions of dollars per month to be made in ranking #1 for Mortgages. Protagonist says it is easy. Protagonist isn't making the money that would bring in. But it's easy. That it takes no skill. But he can't make the monies. Why this article is upvoted is very odd. The article does bring up an interesting topic, there are issues with the incentives SEO places. Just like the incentives that directories placed, anyone remember AAAA Plumbing Services? Or before that, with paying writers per word/line (I'm looking at you books from the 1800s) Aligning incentives is hard. And it's interesting. But the arrogance of the person who wrote the article is amazing, not to mention the cognitive dissonance he must experience. I personally couldn't get over that to really appreciate the larger topic being covered.
- pixl97 7y agoWell, protagonist isn't wrong... they just also happen to be a bottom feeder too.
- ndarwincorn 7y agoI noticed that too and am shocked this comment isn't at the top. Related, I'd find an attempt to measure the amount of waste in SEO blogspam and email spam/ham very interesting. I.e. who gets the real landfill designation.
- Nicksil 7y agoDoes that make their point(s) any less valid?
- Yoofie 7y agoIt takes one to know one?
- 7y ago
- lostctown 7y agoI append "reddit" to any query not meant for a productive task. Except now the internet is mostly reddit for me, which kinda bums me out. Especially given the new js-heavy design. In 2019, if I want reliable search about something I know nothing about I must first search on google, then try again with "reddit" appended, then change www.reddit.com to old.reddit.com, then parse through what are often questionable answers from anon users, possibly still influenced by marketers, and then maybe, I get the answer or next lead that I was looking for.
- whamlastxmas 7y agoGoogle used to have a filter to only show discussions which I used constantly until they removed it. It's the only way to find actual reviews of some products without a million pages of blogspam
- thirdsun 7y agoOh, you're right - I was going to say that I often used this filter, but apparently I didn't even notice it's gone.
- mythrwy 7y agoAm I the only one who thinks Reddit really sucks? It's a cesspool of kiddie memes, shock, ill informed opinion and political posturing. Besides, if I wanted to search Reddit I'd go to Reddit. It being front page for _everything_ I search for now is so annoying.
- voxl 7y agoYet you browse and comment on this website, clearly a bastioned of informed opinions, and no political posturing. Really it's worse off for not having the occasional meme.
- SahAssar 7y agoReddit has a lot good communities sharing good info for niche subjects. The top 100 or so subreddits are as you say, but there are some good ones further down. And the reason to not use reddits search engine is that it still is very bad.
- swayvil 7y agoI have the solution! If the domain contains a shopping cart then filter it out. What do you think?
- Theodores 7y agoKind of the opposite. Amazon and other big retailers dominate, sometimes you want to know what other people are selling and to buy from them. Right now there isn't a lot of point in ecommerce as the land grab has already gone. My idea of a better filter is to rate pages on the quality of the HTML. SEO is never about that and the search engines essentially ignore all the element tags. If there was an incentive for people to write non-bloated HTML that used all the elements and had proper document outlines rather than just look pretty then I think we could eliminate people who can't do decent web pages, including Amazon.
- walshemj 7y agoThis is a service for spammers complaining about SEO LOL
- dreamcompiler 7y agoThe Internet needs a good non-profit search engine that has no conflicts of interest. It could be funded by a foundation like Wikipedia or by the government like PBS, but the world sorely needs this resource.
- hedora 7y agoMost people forget (or never realized) that the main benefit page rank had over previous search engines was that it briefly bypassed pay for placement. At this point, if search results are dominated by SEO paid placement, then Google search should be as ripe for disruption as the search engines it replaced. I think a non-profit, curated index is a good first step to disintermediating this whole shady (and spammy) industry.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoYep. That was Google in the early days before they got into the advertising business and before their IPO.
- albertgoeswoof 7y agoI don’t think it’s searching for things that’s the problem, it’s creating things of value. There’s no reason to create a great piece of content if no one sees it. To get people to see it you need to fill it with fluff for google.
- ksangeelee 7y agoThe very existence of 'things of value' is what motivated people to build crawlers and search engines in the first place. There are many reasons to create 'a great piece of content', even if nobody else is likely to see it (e.g. for my personal reference, consolidating my understanding, just for fun, etc.). Filling it with fluff simply reduces its 'greatness'. I think the problem is figuring out how we systematically identify things of value. My personal feeling is that the solution lies in having good 'seed' URLs with which to build indexes. This might be done using curated lists, as a number of people here suggest, or perhaps through crawling and scoring the content.
- zackmorris 7y agoOff the top of my head on a Sunday, a few laws that might help remedy the SEO situation: * Make all posted internet content public domain (no limits on scraping). * Make any scraped public data used for profit be available to the public via a license similar to the GPL (similarly to how medical research of public data should be shared with the public rather than hidden behind a paywall). * Legally separate search from industries such as advertising and shipping (apply some antitrust legislation for once). * Require some sort of tech support for redress of grievances (if a human can't be reached within say 10 business days, allow escalation to a government agency that can apply injunctions or other red tape to encourage monopolistic companies to play nicely). * Implement steep fines for market manipulation, similar to insider trading laws. If a search engine pulls the listing that another business's livelihood depends upon, and it can be proven that (for example) a competitor or business partner initiated the pull, then it should open the search engine up to collusion charges. Frivolous pulls not remedied after say 10 business days would be treated as malicious and open the search engine to an audit of its relationships with its clients in that space. Please if anyone has more ideas, let's hear them. I'd vote to look at the merits of any new laws rather than their likelihood of being implemented, which I realize is likely quite low!
- bartimus 7y ago> Why? Because there’s so much competition in my line of business and i need the initial paid traffic. So this in itself is a problem. Why would your business be more relevant if there's much meaningful competition? It really depends on what you're searching for. Taking the bike example. No search engine could ever give a meaningful result when just searching for "bike". You need to get more deep into the material and search with specialized terms. "bike internal hub" looks pretty fair in Google.
- dmerrick 7y agoI checked out his product and I can see his predicament... a lot of other services do the same things. He's just doing it in a simple way (with what appears to be a very sane pricing model).
- nullwasamistake 7y agoI blame Google. They could easily derank sites with paywalls, interstitials, and 4mb of trackers but this goes against their core business. When paywalls stopped being considered "cloaking" I knew the free web was done for Google search. I'm not sure if there's much research on the subject, but in my experience a huge majority of "slow" sites are directly caused by tons of tracking and ad code.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoBut paywalls, interstitials, and trackers don't mean the website isn't what the user is searching for.
- nullwasamistake 7y agoHow many of us are actually okay with any of that? I've never paid for an "article" subscription and don't know anyone that has. Google should provide at least the dumbest notation of "this site is paywalled". What you click is no longer what site you end up on. I would much rather just see the 99% of internet pages that are free, remove that other shit from my search results. But it's Google's bread and butter so they never will Oh, poor content farms can't make money that way? Good. I'm fine with my internet feed looking like 1999. The internet was far more useful before it was a medium for a bunch of assholes to make money off "content"
- swayvil 7y agoWhat would be a good name for a commerce-free search engine?
- smt88 7y agoWikipedia is basically an information search engine without commerce or social media. The problem is that your results page is the article itself, and you need to scroll to the bottom to get to an external site. It's theoretically possible to change the UI or analyze Wikipedia to make a pretty solid search engine powered by millions of person-years of curation.
- swayvil 7y agoThat is an extremely valuable insight. Thank you very much!
- skywhopper 7y agoThis is just the flip side of what was at the time a revolutionary search strategy: prior to Google search results were even worse than they are now. Altavista and the rest were just indexing content and providing naive text search over their cache of the Internet and spammers had ensured that only very specific searches having nothing to do with commerce were discoverable. Then Google came along with PageRank, which rated pages based on which and how many other sites linked to them. Suddenly the Internet was usable again. For a few years. But spammers caught on and the algorithm has had to become more complex. But companies are so desperate for attention and there’s so much money floating around that the huge swaths of entirely fake content have sprung up and become more and more sophisticated. Unfortunately Google still rules and it takes some unsavory activity to get a new product or service to surface effectively. That’s not actually a new phenomenon, it’s just different mechanisms. But I feel sorry for anyone in the situation described here. I would not be able to bring myself to do effective PR in this or any other age.
- syphilis2 7y agoI'd love a search engine comprised of everyone's bookmarks.
- simonswords82 7y agoAt least one firm already tried that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delicious_(website) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delicious_(website)
- panic 7y agoPlease bookmark our site for a chance to win $100!
- sixtypoundhound 7y agoI think this verges on the definition of irony: the guy who wants to stuff my email inbox putting SEO on blast....
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- titzer 7y agoAn advertising agency should absolutely not be trusted to "Organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- systematical 7y agoIts been this way for 15+ years.
- hollerith 7y agoThe internet is fine (as far as I can tell). The web is an SEO landfill.
- buboard 7y agoMore precisely ‘the web shown in the front page of google results’
- onemoresoop 7y agoIs Bing or DuckDuckGo not affected by this problem also? Just asking..
- buboard 7y agonot much different, however it is google's first page that sets the standards for SEO tricks.
- blunte 7y agoIndeed most of the content on the web is SEO fluff or veiled attempts to push an affiliate link. Worse, almost every site has a cookie “preference” popup (when everyone knows the preference is just the minimum necessary cookies), a newsletter signup popup, and a browser notification request popup. Add to that the autoplaying videos that will pop out into their own overlay if you scroll away plus the rotating ads of different sizes which cause the page content to shift up and down... oh and the fancy morphing page headers that hang down over the content you’re trying to read if you don’t scroll enough at first. The web is currently a shitshow of comic proportions, the likes of which not even the most cynical comedians accurately predicted. The desktop app situation isn’t as bad, but it follows a similar trend of demanding more from the hardware and user (and network) while providing less. It might actually be better overall if mobile and desktop performance had not increased in the last decade. I swear the end user experience hasn’t on average improved even a fraction as much as the hardware capability has. What a dismal road we are on.
- pdimitar 7y agoI still remember to this day the experience I had with the Miranda IM messenger -- I was signed it to at least 6 services (ICQ, AIM, Yahoo and a few others). 40MB of RAM during the time when 1GB RAM on an average PC became the affordable norm, no lag ever, instant rendering, everything works instantly, plus a lot of possible customisation -- themes, emoticon packs, you name it. Same with web. Search for something, get 7 useful results on the first page, get your work done in minutes. No banners, no ads, no consent popups, no constant nagging for signups. Just content and some personal expression -- which, while comical at places, is still vastly preferable to the crap show we are enduring today. Fast forward 12-15 years forward and I am absolutely amazed how awful the state of the desktop and the web is. Things are only getting worse with time.
- nine_k 7y agoMiranda was cool. I vividly remember it. I also vividly remember banner ads at that time, there were a few popular sizes. Some of the first ad-filtering proxies based their blocking algorithms on the sizes. When AdWords came it felt almost beneficial, because connections were slow and often metered. SEO tricks proliferated at the time (say, 2000), too, of more stupid sorts because search engines were not that sophisticated yet, including Google.
- Havoc 7y agoIt does seem to have worsened lately. Especially the crappy Consent to cookies things that block half the screen with an advert covering the other half. Even with a adblocker and pi hole it's becoming unbearable
- Yhippa 7y agoYou can thank the GDPR for the annoying cookie popup.
- flukus 7y ago99% of these cookie warnings are not GDPR compliant, they offer no option to opt-out and continue reading the site (cookies are not required for a blog post to function and even if they were these don't need the warning) and they opt-in by default, all the tracking cookies are still there no matter whether you accept or not. Anyone that thinks this is GDPR compliance shouldn't be allowed to touch a computer.
- schachin 7y agoThis post is just flat out wrong. We are not using tricks when we tell you to create content. We are telling you what Google considers quality. Tricks are for blackhats and they can work and there is nothing wrong with that, but what you are talking bout is actual white hat SEO that Google demands from sites to be considered quality enough to rank. And the "it's easy" garbage. Go ahead. Let us know how easy it is when you are done doing it by yourself. This post is full of bovine feces.
- bartread 7y ago> We are not using tricks when we tell you to create content. We are telling you what Google considers quality. That may very well be true but taken to its logical conclusion all you're really admitting is that Google does a very poor job of accurately assessing the quality of any given piece of content. And that pretty much nails the point of the post.
- dang 7y agoIt sounds like you know a lot on this topic and have good information to contribute, but could you please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here? For example, the rule that asks you to edit out the name-calling ("garbage", "bovine feces") is an important one.
- schachin 7y agoThis post is just flat out wrong. We are not using tricks when we tell you to create content. We are telling you what Google considers quality. Google has trillions of sites to sort out and they have parameters that sites have to meet in order to be one of the top 10 that they pick. Tricks are for blackhats and they can work and there is nothing wrong with that, but what you are talking about is actual white hat SEO that Google demands from sites to be considered quality enough to rank. And the "it's easy" garbage. Go ahead. Let us know how easy it is when you are done doing it by yourself. This post is full of bovine feces.
- schachin 7y agoBTW I see a lot of -- Google does not give me back what I ask for when I type is X -- and that is true. That is NOT because of SEO however. That is their use of AI in language interpretation and how it is being used in algorithms, which really, well sucks. If you want them to get better go to Twitter and tell them how irrelevant they have become or how much you hate the ads or all the featured spaces - because you know what SEOS have been telling them for a long time, but they ignore us. If regular users started telling them? They might listen. _________ But this post? It is bovine feces.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nickfromseattle 7y agoThis is 100% how search engine optimization works, the consultants are correct. As a marketer, when I search for marketing information on Google 70%-90% of the time all of the stuff on the 1st page generally isn't teaching me anything I didn't already know. But as someone who does this exact thing, I know how expensive good content is - hiring an author to write 3,000 words of valuable information for a reader can cost $500 - $1000 per page. Add another $400 - $1,000 for the consultants time on that page. Or you can hire writers that produce lower value information for $30 - $120 per 3,000 words that ranks just as well as high quality content. The first thing I thought when I saw Elon Musk's writing AI was how powerful of a search marketing tool this is. Reducing your content cost to effectively zero gives you a HUGE competitive advantage. I know a publisher programmatically generating content and generating millions of organic search visits a month for marginal costs reaching 0 - they pivoted to a tech company after identifying their #1 problem was content costs were too high and ad revenue was too low. Now they're selling this technology to other publishers.
- pdimitar 7y agoWhat I don't like about your line of thinking is that creating such content should even cost money. Knowledge should be free at our point in time and supposed evolutional stage. But it's not. I'd gladly donate some local lectures on the stuff I know if I had the time. But I wouldn't charge money for it. Knowledge should be free. And internet should have become mega yellow pages on steroids like a decade ago.
- colechristensen 7y agoIf you think knowledge should be free, contribute to freely available knowledge in some useful way you can.
- pdimitar 7y agoI do. My main barrier to being more useful and community active is my limited time. As I said above, I wouldn't charge a penny if I had the time to share more knowledge.
- colechristensen 7y agoOpen question: How could you create a sustainable search engine business optimizing for quality results? i.e. not tailoring results for maximizing revenue
- fiatjaf 7y agoSearching for "transactional ses" or "aws ses transactional" on DuckDuckGo gives me sendwithses.com easily. The same searches on Google never find anything.
- greggeter 7y agoWe'll rely more on bloggers to curate resources. I do that more now.
- zeofig 7y agoI still don't know what SEO stands for (presumably search engine something) after reading this article. Nice.
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoIs this merely a continuation of the inevitable "Eternal September" effect? The internet is a reflection of its users. That's why HN'ers tend to look back on 'what it once was' very romantically, because back then it only catered to the technically-minded, the critical thinkers, and so the content matched the demographic. In hindsight (because I'm not smart enough to have seen it before it happened, and only just smart enough to join the already-joined dots) this was inevitable. Catering to world + dog means anything goes in the pursuit of eyeballs (= sales). Whatever search system is put in place will be manipulated towards this goal. If a large proportion of the users don't care / don't notice / accept this is normal, then it IS normal. Television, Radio, newspapers, and magazines are all (predominantly) advertising landfills.
- pg_is_a_butt 7y agoSEO has always been a corrupt venture. The Internet isn't anything.
- p0larboy 7y agoA plumber open shop in a highly competitive neighborhood with thousands of other plumbers right at the customers' fingertip. He is highly-skilled, or at least he believes himself to be. But he doesn't believe in marketing. "Marketers are bottom-feeders." Said plumber did not do well. Blame everyone except his ego.
- vxNsr 7y agoI honestly think the only way back from this is to curated lists like in the old days. Or specialized search engines. as a user I'm often using byzantine strings of words to get the result I want because of all the SEO if I had access to an engine that only had programming related stuff, or only had recipe related websites, or only political stuff I think I would have an easier time searching it would also give the creators of the specific content an easy place to post their wares. Kinda like specialized torrent sites. Ever since I got access to content specific torrent sites I haven't used public sites, and I have only had to use private general sites once or twice. Because the search-engine is content specific it'll be better at organizing the information and surfacing what I'm interested in finding, I think there will still be a place for google but it'll be less useful than it is today.
- fitnesshealth 7y agoHere is more interesting post to read: https://searchengineland.com/seo-has-killed-the-my-internet-46685 https://searchengineland.com/seo-has-killed-the-my-internet-...
- daveheq 7y agoI don't know why this ranked here. This is an overly-simolistic cynical take on SEO and search engines. Get into detail, state examples supporting your assertions. Sure search engines make money on junk SEO, but it's not their primary motivator and at least Google works to diminish junk SEO. Their product just does better and makes more money on quality content; Google knows this and it's why they're still the top player in the game.
- halr9000 7y ago> And that’s what the internet has become. Full of gossip, junk content, paid posts, con articles, click bait links, sock-puppetry, spam, regurgitated spam, free e-books, self aggrandizement, fake followers, fake news, - all designed to achieve one thing - con the Search Engine - and you. Most of this is junk, but TBH the free e-books don't bother me one bit. I even like a few of the peddlers who deploy this tactc, if the content is any good.
- volandovengo 7y agoWould suggest that SEO is just one of many tactics to acquire users. I bet that from this article - you'll get waaaay more customers for your early stage product than ranking on google would have gotten you at this early stage. I used to be obsessed with SEO - now I realize that many companies, search just isn't the best way to acquire customers. I saw this - currently investing in SEO and moving up the rankings steadily because long term - it feels like a great source of brand awareness.
- m0rdecai 7y agoThere are bad actors in every industry. Good job generalizing here. I’m one of those “bottom feeders” you wrote about to promote your service. I’m sorry you got conned by a snake oil salesman. It sounds like your BS detector is broken. It’s a shame you didn’t do a bit more research to find a credible SEO service (or learn to do it the right way yourself). "Good SEO” isn’t about “tricking search engines”. It’s about empathy for the user, and has a strong UX component. If you're creating hollow content, or a poor experience otherwise, why would you expect users to convert, let alone come back to the site or tell a friend about it? My SEO philosophy/approach is to gain a solid understanding of the intent behind a query/problem, and then create the best experience possible to address/answer that query. When you do a better job at answering the user question than the other sites out there, and your "UX metrics", (i.e. bounce rate, time on site) validate this experience, you're on the right path. It's obviously more complicated than this, but that's where I start. “Good SEO” is a long-term bet. “Tricks” that get you ranking on the first page are useless if search visitors bounce from your site once they realize your content is rubbish. Will AI-generated content create a best-in-class experience for a user? I have a hard time believing that it would. Anyway, I hope you’re enjoying your free traffic.