49 ms·
8chan served with search warrant [pdf]
- manfredo 7y agoSo, the FBI is asking for IPs used to comment in two posts whose authors later committed acts of terrorism. Doesn't surprise me, I had thought they would have done this already.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dev_dull 7y agoI'm surprised there's an actual search warrant. I would think these websites get so many requests for IPs that there's not some way the websites hand it over without a warrant.
- astrange 7y agoWebsites in the US (which doesn't, I believe, include this one) have to follow the Stored Communications Act, which specifically forbids disclosing customer information just because someone asked.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 7y agoMaybe for the actual communication, but not IP addresses: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=d2ca30a5-542c-48ed-a700-c6dad7911357 https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=d2ca30a5-542c...
- ronsor 7y agoI've said it many times: 4chan is a hive of degeneracy and 8chan is where people that have been banned from 4chan go.
- gee-urly-cool 7y agoThen you haven't said much of anything at all.
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 7y agoUnlike 4chan, 8chan isn't a centralized website managed by a single moderation team. Much like on reddit, anyone can create a board on 8chan and there are thousands of them. Because of that, I don't think it makes sense to treat 8chan as a single community.
- Eleopteryx 7y agoBut the nature of 8chan's user base isn't being dictated by its design. It's still an overwhelmingly right-wing site that gained its prominence from the Gamergate controversy. As a frequent user of reddit I would openly declare that overall it's an observably left-wing site. People across the political spectrum certainly use it, but it's still a left-wing site. Neither site was designed to cater to a certain types of users. But it seems dishonest to say certain ideologies, sentiments, patterns of speech, etc. don't take prominence on either platform simply because that prominence isn't an intrinsic aspect of the software that these communities use.
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 7y ago>But the nature of 8chan's user base isn't being dictated by its design. It's still an overwhelmingly right-wing site that gained its prominence from the Gamergate controversy. As a frequent user of reddit I would openly declare that overall it's an observably left-wing site. It's somewhat true, but still, reddit hosts right-wing communities like /r/the_donald, while 8chan hosts, for example, /leftypol/. Both sites consist of multiple, separate communities.
- antisemiotic 7y agoTo be fair, /leftypol/ has many users who'd get banned from more civil leftist communities before they can finish saying "liberals get the bullet too".
- avar 7y agotl;dr: The FBI wants the IP addresses of people who commented on an 8chan thread created by the Poway synagogue shooter[1] prior to his attack in an effort to find any co-conspirators. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poway_synagogue_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poway_synagogue_shooting
- dewyatt 7y agoIt sort of sounds like they want to put every individual that posted in that thread on a watchlist.
- dsl 7y agoWatchlist? Jail. Material support to an act of terrorism. Edit - from the search warrant application: "will be found evidence of violations of federal law, namely, intentional obstruction, by force or threat of force of persons in the free exercise of religious belief, resulting in death, in violation of 1 S U.S.C. § 247(a)(2), willfully causing bodily injury to persons through the use of a firearm because of the actual or perceived religion of said persons, resulting in death, in violation of 1 S U.S.C. § 249(a)(l), and damage to religious property, in violation of lS U.S.C. § 25 247(a)(l )" Edit 2: Lots of legal eagles on HN today that are upset at the word "material." Sorry? If you read the full search warrant it sounds like he torched a synagogue, and was encouraged to follow up with a shooting.
- nyolfen 7y agowhat material?
- userbinator 7y agoEven those saying no and telling him not to do it?
- krapp 7y ago>Even those saying no and telling him not to do it? Would this be an example of the dry irony the chans are so well known for?
- ineedasername 7y agoHere's the crux of their reasoning & requested information in seeking the warrant, from the linked PDF: As discussed above, Earnest made a posting in which he thought to draw attention to his forthcoming attack on the Chabad of Poway, share his views through his open letter, and offer people the opportunity to observe the attack itself. Several people responded, both individuals who were taken aback about the posting as well as people who were sympathizers. As a result, some of the individuals may be potential witnesses, co-conspirators and/ or individuals who are inspired by the subject posting. Based on agents' training and experience, following attacks such as those conducted by Earnest, other individuals are inspired by the attacks and may act of their own accord. For example, as described above, Earnest himself was inspired by the Christchurch event in New Zealand. Regardless of the nature of the comments, the evidence sought to be seized as described in Attachment B is relevant as evidence of Earnest's bias and motivation in committing the hate crimes set forth in Attachment B. Even comments made in response to the subject posting or about it are relevant to Earnest's motivation for his violent attacks to the extent that as explained above, some of the posters may be potential witnesses, co-conspirators and/or individuals who are inspired by the subject posting. As discussed above, Earnest stated in the subject posting, "I've only been lurking for a year and a half, yet, what I've learned here is priceless." This information suggests that Earnest was inspired and/or educated by individuals who commented on his threads. Based on this information, there is reasonable cause to believe that the information sought, specifically IP address and metadata for all commenters, constitute evidence of his motivation in committing the offenses described herein and are thus relevant and material to an ongoing criminal investigation, information that may be sought by an order issued pursuant to l S U.S.C. § 2703(c) and (d). That is, the information may lead to the identity of individuals who inspired and/or educated Earnest or are aware of his motivation in committing the attacks.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- maxheadroom 7y agoMy only qualm is with this portion: >...and/ or individuals who are inspired by the subject posting That's a very overarching goal as it would, in theory, require continued surveillance of all subjects to determine inspiration - either in the past, present, or even the future, yeah? I mean, you can't just take a snapshot of time, time_t now = time(0); tm *gmtm = gmtime(&now); and consider that no other people would be "inspired" in the future by this event, yeah?
- DataWorker 7y agoStrange they don’t have that information already. Could this be a parallel construction sort of a thing where they pretend they don’t have the data already?
- ineedasername 7y agoWhy would it be strange? And what alternative method of obtaining it would they have? It doesn't seem like a stretch to get the warrant approved, so I don't know why they'd go to any great lengths to have gotten the same information in a method that couldn't be used in courts.
- swebs 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PRISM_(surveillance_program)
- meowface 7y agoThe FBI can't just ask the NSA to hack every US company every time they want some information from it. I'm sure they do for the big dogs, as revealed from their collaboration in targeting Tor hidden services, and for anything concerning espionage and national security, but the vast majority of the time they're stuck trudging through the long legal process like every other law enforcement institution (such as your local PD). I doubt 8chan was high on their radar before this attack.
- DataWorker 7y agoHow could 8chan not be on their radar after Christchurch?
- anigbrowl 7y agoKnowing about it and having the multiple kinds of know-how and budget to monitor it are two very different things.
- 7y ago
- dsl 7y agoThe original 8chan thread has been removed, but here is their own follow up thread regarding the investigation: https://8ch.net/pol/res/13196423.html https://8ch.net/pol/res/13196423.html (Warning: 8chan...)
- AYBABTME 7y agoThe comments in there are disgusting, wouldn't have thought that people actually believe and preach this crap.
- claudiawerner 7y agoIt's worth noting that this board on 8chan makes it an open policy to permanently ban people who post dissenting opinions with the reason that they are "shills" and coordinating a misinformation/propaganda attack.
- faissaloo 7y agoAn important thing to remember if anyone tries to bring up free speech.
- danans 7y agoHistory is overflowing with examples of people, groups, and nation states preaching, and practicing that crap. As a kid, I heard similar stuff from my classmates and their parents and grandparents, and I was in the suburban Midwest, not a place strongly associated with anti-semitism at the time. Today's purveyors have just been offered more powerful media to amplify and propagate it.
- Chris_Chambers 7y agoAww, baby took his first steps outside of his safe space echo chamber.
- briga 7y agoWell, mass-shootings wouldn't happen if there weren't people who believed it. It turns out that anonymous 'edgy' internet forums are an ideal breeding ground for that sort of ideology. The absurdly offensive dialog that goes on there is often just an act people put on to fit in with the crowd in a consequence-free environment--most of them are probably just harmless lonely teenagers with nothing better to do. But it would be hard to tell at a glance which posts are serious and which aren't.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI don't know about 8chan but when it comes to 4chan, there's a certain sport in what people comment in threads. There's countless threads of people claiming to be planning something awful (terrorism, suicide, robbery, eating Taco Bell, etc.) And in the comments you'll see people say all kinds of things, that if taken at face value, are pretty horrible (and maybe even criminal conspiracy.) But the crux is that these people are not serious (though I'm sure some are), they're just saying it for the sport of calling the bluff of anonymous people they perceive as trolls or brooding teens. It's like the scene in Futurama where Hermes is threatening to jump off a building to his death and Bender says, "Do a flip!" This doesn't make it right. And doesn't absolve them of the legal hot water they'd find themselves in. But I hope these individuals, if charged with a crime, get lawyers who will vigorously defend this point. Edit: I want to re-state that I emphatically do not hold any opinions on this topic. I'm just trying to share a bit about what these image boards can be like.
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y ago> But the crux is that these people are not serious (though I'm sure some are), So which is it? Serious or not? How do we know which is which? > they're just saying it for the sport of calling the bluff of anonymous people they perceive as trolls or brooding teens. By what definition of the term is this sport? If anything it's callous, and probably illegal in most jurisdictions.
- microwavecamera 7y agoIt's all fun and games until someone gets shot.
- xwdv 7y agoEven then, it’s still fun and games if you know where to look these days.
- happytoexplain 7y agoI agree thoroughly with this prudent assessment. One thing I'd like to add is that, after far too much of my life spent on 4chan, I believe the line between a total joke and an expression of a sincere sentiment is much blurrier even than it seems. It's much more subtle than a crowd of irreverent kidders dotted with occasional cold blooded misanthropes.
- shaki-dora 7y agoThe "oh it was ironic" defense sounds especially weak when OP subsequently shoots up a synagogue. Guess he didn't get the irony? And neither did the Christchurch incel a few weeks earlier? That incident should have maybe informed the community's opinion on the future viability of that particular excuse. It's also telling that both un-ironic murder sprees resulted in general approval, and no visible signs of regret on these boards. Or, you know, shutting them down.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI have no opinions or expertise on the legal merit of any kind of defense. I'm just sharing what happens and what's going though the minds of most of the people in these threads. Trolling the trolls is just what you do on /b/
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y ago> I'm just sharing what happens and what's going though the minds of most of the people in these threads. How can you know what's going on in the minds of most people? Have you conducted surveys? Where's the data? If we've got data, let's go with the data. If all we've got is opinions, let's go with mine.
- Waterluvian 7y agoYou just have to spend some time on 4chan and have common sense. I won't link it but right now I took a minute to find an example. There's a thread on /b/ where someone claims their mom found their bottle of urine and asked what should they do. Countless people said to basically murder their mother. So do you think those people are truly encouraging a murder? No. They're going along with the fiction. It's just part of what 4chan does...
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y ago> common sense. Isn't as common as one might think. > So do you think those people are truly encouraging a murder? In the general sense, probably not. I'm willing to bet at least some of them are serious some of the time. > It's just part of what 4chan does... By that logic, walking in to a synagogue and unloading a clip is just part of what online forums do. Is that an argument you're prepared to make?
- Causality1 7y agoI visited 8chan once several years ago shortly after it was founded. What I saw there convinced me it's not a place you want to frequent, especially from your own internet connection. If someone said to me "hey you have just got to see this thing on 8chan" I'd walk somewhere with open wifi first.
- jasonvorhe 7y agoI would reconsider if I ever want to have contact with the person suggesting that again.
- neilk 7y agoI have no expertise in the legalities here. But I’ve found that quite often, on the internet, when you think you’ve found a forum of hilarious ironic commenters... a lot of them are very sincere. Irony is currently used as a conscious strategy by the extreme right. They know that it gets a pass from ordinary people. While permitting the sincere to organize in plain sight. I don’t know what to do about this, but this is the world we’re living in.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThe problem is that while most of them aren't, some of them are. If you doubt the sincerity, just observe /b/ for a day. It's filled with fiction, but yeah, every so often you see something that looks real.
- mulmen 7y agoHow do you know? What trains this feedback loop other than your own perception?
- serf 7y ago>How do you know? Two ways : 1) Staggeringly rare real-world events are reported frequently -- so a good number of them, by virtue of their rarity in real life, must be false. There are daily threats of wide-scale violence, but only a very small percentage of these threats turn into a real event. 2) The impossible is often reported. These comments can be thrown away at face value by most people -- besides maybe the most dedicated 'researchers' (Alien abduction, magic , general occultism woo). Now, if you're asking 'How do you know which threats are false?', that's a much more difficult question, and i'd be surprised if there was a generalizable 'answer', aside from full-on mind-reading.
- Barrin92 7y agoone pretty obvious fact would be the adoption of "chan-slang" by people who have turned entirely serious in their advocacy of those extremist views, with they themselves openly advocating that those were the channels on which they were radicalised. A similar dynamic is playing out on youtube, as a recent ex-member of this subculture attests: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/08/technology/youtube-radical.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/08/technology/yo...
- jackweirdy 7y ago"In contrast with (my) generation, which had spent most of its time online learning to code so that it could add crude butterfly animations to the backgrounds of its weblogs, the generation immediately following had spent most of its time online making incredibly bigoted jokes in order to laugh at the idiots who were stupid enough to think that they meant it. Except that after a while they did mean it, and then somehow at the end of it they were white supremacists. Was this always how it happened?" Patricia Lockwood, London Review of Books, Feb 2019
- tty2300 7y ago"Haha I was only pretending to be retarded"
- tyrust 7y agoI don't see the value of such broad generalizations.
- dmos62 7y agoI agree. The whole citation reads unsavourably. To paraphrase: my generation used said medium to be creative, while that other generation used same medium to express bigotry. That's the kind of statement that puts up a forest of red flags about the author's credibility.
- _Nat_ 7y agoI wonder how true anecdotes like that might be? For example, what portion of trolls who said [offensive thing] ironically for shock value ended up internalizing that [offensive thing] later on? And is this like the concern that violent video games normalize violence?
- warmwaffles 7y ago> In contrast with (my) generation, which had spent most of its time online learning to code so that it could add crude butterfly animations to the backgrounds of its weblogs Patricia Lockwood sounds like she is praising her generation for being holier-than-thou and basically adding to the issue. There is no way this is just limited to the following generation. It's deeper than that and most likely something to do with the human condition.
- baruchthescribe 7y agoThis thread was deleted from 8chan less than ten minutes after it was created - too fast for even any archives to be created - and the poster was instantly condemned as a criminal for carrying out this criminal act. That is an extremely impressive response, especially when compared to anything from Big Tech. I haven't quite figured out the timelines in the court documents but it's clear that the authorities were in the subsequent discussions and took the screenshots themselves because of the (You) markers next to their comments.
- mikeyouse 7y ago8Chan deletes any threads that contain threats (with the associated logs and details) and then immediately reposts them as images in a different thread. They actively abet heinous acts.
- hackermailman 7y agoOr the original poster does this themselves after being banned, hence the (You)'s in the screenshots and mods are busy reviewing a hundred other flagged threads while these new threats are reposted. 8chan is user created and managed the mods aren't exactly professional any fool can create a board.
- kyledrake 7y agoI'm a little confused why they're going with a search warrant here instead of a subpoena. The only reason they would want to do this usually is if the admin was refusing to comply with a subpoena, but the search warrant says nothing about this AFAICT. This is pretty unusual for FBI evidence gathering procedure.
- morpheuskafka 7y agoOnly thing I could think of is if he was still facing state charges only at the time it was drafted and served? Then there would be no case to issue it under. I guess they could have done a grand jury subpeona, but that comes with certain secrecy requirements.
- tomatotomato37 7y agoActually you do have a point, looking back over the operational history of 4chan interaction with law enforcement wasn't that unusual; during that canada van attack thing the entire site went down while police collected evidence and the response was basically: https://desuarchive.org/a/thread/171969632/#q171978582 https://desuarchive.org/a/thread/171969632/#q171978582. I don't know why they decided to escalate to a search warrant.
- chippy 7y ago4chan has always been transparently cooperative with law enforcement whenever they ask. They don't demand subpoenas or are obstructive - I imagine 4chan has good relations with various agencies. 8chan is another beast and I'd imagine that site to be as toxic as what goes on. I would imagine no good relations nor prior willingless to play ball. They state they "comply with US law" and are "responding" to the police. Doesn't seem as friendly as 4chan's approach. Of course in the US it's common to "never talk with the police" so I should affix by saying that I'm a European and have more trust in the law
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- p_rude 7y agoIronic racism is still racism and in my experience the "irony" usually just a flimsy facade for a person's true feelings
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoSo, basically, "I don't understand irony so everyone must be evil"?
- faissaloo 7y agoIt's more so the case that dogwhistling and irony have a very blurry line.
- fastball 7y agoI'm unconvinced that "dog-whistling" is something worth worrying about.
- faissaloo 7y agoThat's ok, reality doesn't require your input.
- fastball 7y agoDespite your rudeness, I'll remind you that the burden of proof that "dog-whistles are worth worrying about" is not on me. It's an intriguing concept, but the negative impacts of such behavior (as well as if it actually even exists) needs to be proven, not assumed.
- objectivetruth 7y agoBurden of proof? Nah, we're not in court, those of us on board the reality bus don't really care if you come along for the ride. Some cursory Googling did return some academic results on this, so I bet you could find the info that most of us take as CLEAR evidence of human nature.
- anongraddebt 7y agoFrom what I can tell, 'polite' and 'respectable' culture (a.k.a the dominant culture) in America is center-left if not minimally progressive. At least, this is the case for social issues. In the 90's, the dominant counterculture was some version of leftism. On the fringes, there was vitriol and anger towards the 'polite' and publicly 'respectable' dominant culture of the time - some version of evangelical and catholic right-wing ideology. Atheism was still edgy. Raging against an undefinable machine had artistic meaning. We can throw in as many other causal factors as we want in an attempt to explain the current socio-political state of the country, but we can't really deny that it looks as if the new counterculture exists somewhere on the right. ---- I remember the days when John Stewart was edgy. Now, you'd be hard pressed to find a mainstream comedian, who focuses on politics (Colbert, Noah, etc.), that isn't clearly center-left. The coastal, cosmopolitan, affluent, center-left culture is practically a monolithic gate keeper of what is and isn't 'respectable'.
- supergauntlet 7y ago>We can throw in as many other causal factors as we want in an attempt to explain the current socio-political state of the country, but we can't really deny that it looks as if the new counterculture exists somewhere on the right. If you're arguing this in good faith I'm sorry, but this is outright delusion. The political ideology that controls the highest office in the country and half of the legislature is counterculture? Seriously? Can you see how absurd this claim is?
- shearskill 7y agoThe “alt right is the new punk rock” is one of their marketing pitches. Apparently it works, but only for a certain demographic.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- anongraddebt 7y agoEvery political or social collective/group/movement/whatever wants to be seen as hip and cool or whatever. So, the fact that alt-right individuals market themselves this way should come as no surprise. It also never came as a surprise that the center-left labeled themselves #TheResistance when they already had a monopoly on the popular vote and a monopoly on mainstream press and hollywood, which is just shorthand for saying that they marketed themselves as hip and cool and edgy (or whatever) even though they are quite clearly the dominant culture. How many anti-Trump SNL episodes must there be for this to be patently obvious? What percentage of speakers on college campuses got deplatformed due to being right-wing vs. left-wing in the past decade? If the right-wing doesn't harbor the counterculture, but rather the left-wing still harbors it, then why were electoral models so blown to bits in 2016 thanks to phenomena like Trump supporters not identifying as such in polls/surveys?
- AnaniasAnanas 7y ago8chan supports for posts via tor. I do wonder how many of the posters there used it, making fbi unable to locate them.
- irvwash 7y agoTor posters are assigned an ID of "000000". I only see two posts with that ID in the screenshots in the document.
- otakucode 7y agoI have always thought of 4chan, at least their 'random' board, as akin to a sort of performance art. It reminds me of the experimental film scene in the 70s and 80s in NYC. The theaters were filled with prostitutes, pimps, thugs, drug addicts, etc. The experimental films which were shown were not anything that could be shown to mainstream audiences, things like Andy Warhol's 'films' that were downright pornographic, or just a camera pointed at the Statue of Liberty for 24 hours, just experiments with the medium. Also shown were works by the likes of Alejandro Jodorowsky and others who went on to create other bizarre cult classics. While the things being done in those theaters had no real place in the mainstream, many of the people in the audience at that time as children or young adults went on to become the most popular directors and influential filmmakers of the 90s through to today. There is no question that they were grimy, deviant, subversive places where crimes of various sorts took place. But they were also important artistic and cultural crucibles, and the experiments that took place there sometimes happened upon techniques or ideas that later enriched our world. It's not always pretty to see how the sausage is made.
- pjc50 7y agoThe difference is that the New York scene produced Warhol and 4/8chan produced mass murderers. The intent and result matters.
- charlesism 7y agoThe Factory milieu produced at least one would-be murderer, and probably worse. Not that I agree with the original comparison. Culturally, the Warhol crowd were a stop between the somber, black-clad Existentialists of the 50s and the somber, black-clad ‘goths’ of the 80s.
- collyw 7y agoMass murderers were live streamed on facebook, why doesn't that get the blame?
- krapp 7y agoFacebook does get the blame. Many people on HN at least do blame Facebook for spreading hateful propaganda and fake news and for fueling acts of genocide. Twitter gets blamed as well. But the chans are unique in that their culture (ironically or not) actively encourages and demonstrates the beliefs that lead to such violence. The shooter in this case mentioned having been inspired by /pol/ and mentioned the New Zealand shooter, who is being treated as a hero and a martyr by /pol/. Facebook and other social media get blamed for passively encouraging violence and hate, while the chans get blamed for actively encouraging it as a cynical and ironic piss-take on society.
- molticrystal 7y agoThe below was from the twitter account of 8chan in regards to Poway and the NZ shooting. ------------------------------- 8chan (8ch.net) Verified account @infinitechan Apr 28 https://twitter.com/infinitechan/status/1122494322283167745 https://twitter.com/infinitechan/status/1122494322283167745 The Poway shooter's post on 8chan was taken down NINE minutes after creation. There are only screencaps available and no archives exist since the post was deleted so quickly. The loudest groups publicizing this crime and giving attention to this CRIMINAL are the fake-news media. ------------------------------- 8chan (8ch.net) Verified account @infinitechan Mar 16 The 8chan administration is responding to law enforcement regarding the recent incident where many websites were used by a criminal to publicize his crime. We always comply with US law and won't comment further on this incident so as not to disrupt the ongoing investigation. ================================= From what I can tell the current 8chan is a fork of https://github.com/ctrlcctrlv/infinity https://github.com/ctrlcctrlv/infinity It does seem that the IP addresses are stored with the POSTs if this is the code they are still using or are based on https://github.com/ctrlcctrlv/infinity/blob/2bc5b6dbf31af50f54e73f88569496e19b143aad/inc/functions.php#L1265 https://github.com/ctrlcctrlv/infinity/blob/2bc5b6dbf31af50f... On a side note, even if the posts were erased from the database, with the salt for the hashing function of the IP addresses known which make the 3 byte ID, the board and thread id, you could recover the IP addresses & aliases and cross-check with the ISPs to see which ones were accessing 8chan at the time. Here is a code on how the IDs were generated, at least at one point in time: return substr(sha1(sha1($ip . $config['secure_trip_salt'] . $thread . $board) . $config['secure_trip_salt']), 0, $config['poster_id_length']); https://github.com/ctrlcctrlv/infinity/blob/2bc5b6dbf31af50f54e73f88569496e19b143aad/inc/functions.php#L2745 https://github.com/ctrlcctrlv/infinity/blob/2bc5b6dbf31af50f...
- irvwash 7y agoThe fork lives at https://github.com/OpenIB/OpenIB https://github.com/OpenIB/OpenIB. IPs are hashed at https://github.com/OpenIB/OpenIB/blob/master/inc/functions.php#L38 https://github.com/OpenIB/OpenIB/blob/master/inc/functions.p.... Hashing them was part of the point of the fork. $identity = crypt($userIP, '$2a$07$' . $hashSalt . '$'); poster_id is probably called with the hashed IP address.
- x38iq84n 7y agoI understand 8chan is like 4chan but with less regulation and more controversy... Why is it registered or operated from the US, instead of, say a company in Tuvalu that rents servers from a company in Pakistan, but the encryption keys are with the company that manages the servers, from South Sudan?
- cf498 7y agoBecause of the US free speech laws. The US is the location where the rest of the world usually hosts there problematic content. It is, or was, also rampant with non nude child pornography sites. While illegal in most of Europe (and other countries I assume), the situation in the US seems to be very different. The whole thing came up in Germany when the government used the numbers of chiid pornography sites they couldnt take down to push for a censored internet. Most of those sites were hosted in the US. If you host your stuff in Sudan or Tuvalu or Pakistan, you simply get removed on the first report. Why should they continue to host you? The same thing happened a while back with a Ukrainian or Russian ISP provider who didnt react to reports, the whole ISP was simply dismantled. Only because the cooperation between the countries governments isnt optimal doesnt mean the local countries will turn a blind eye to abuses from their servers.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThe owner is based in the Philippines who also owns one of the largest Japanese imageboards and some of the hosting infrastructure. Not to be confused with Frederick 'Hotwheels' Brennan who used to run it subsequently quit and moved back to the US after selling his interest.
- OrgNet 7y agoHow many time did they fax those screenshots?
- TheLuddite 7y agoGood, serious measures should be taken against these Internet cesspools.
- soyguzzler 7y agoget rid of cesspools and their content might just spill over to your yard.
- Bakary 7y agoFrom a law enforcement perspective, it's better to have them all in one spot.
- vvvij 7y agoIt's amusing yet so tragic seeing coastal urbanites trying to figure out the ethos of both imageboards. Someday you'll get it, guys.
- vivekd 7y agoI'm an early adopter of 8chan. I don't participate in the more racist or extreme boards on 8chan. I want to argue that there is value in 8chan. For example during the egyptian protests, one of the most popular boards was devoted to egyptian content. I don't know what they were talking about because it was in Arabic but I'm glad that the egyptian people had that forum. Right now one of the top 50 boards is HKpol. It deals with the protests in hong kong and he content is mostly written in chinese. Yes we can criticize anonymous free speech forums for their misuse, and I can certainly see how they might be misused. But I think forums for anonymous free speech can also provide a lot of benefit, particularly for people living in parts of the world where they might face persecution for wanting basic freedoms.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sugarbaby-- 7y ago/hebe/ was less dangerous than /pol/ BACK HEBE TO 8CHAN .
- sugarbaby-- 7y agoHebe was less dangerous than /pol/