11 ms·
Global recession fears grow as factory activity shrinks
- jaimex2 7y agoI can't see a global recession from this - just one in China and Australia which is already in one.
- marsRoverDev 7y agoI find it hard to believe that this will be contained to Australia and China. Australia certainly deserves what it gets (my home country) given its attitude towards debt and housing, but I think the contagion is real.
- sonnyblarney 7y agoContagion is real - but - contagion spreads along specific vectors, some more damaging than others. A China 'slowdown' will probably not hurt the US, in fact, it may give the US leverage. A China 'crash' will surely have emotional contagion among investors, which of course matters, because if they pull the plug on activities it'll translate into real world effects ... But the 'material' contagion of a Chinese crash ... it's harder to predict. I suggest that the issue is far more likely to be damaging as a 'trigger' to a bubble burst or something else, rather than materially damaging in and of itself.
- raducu 7y agoI think people fear that the trouble in China is reduced global demand, not just the trade wars or a local problem.
- sonnyblarney 7y agoYes, it will have knock-on effects, but a serious China slowdown is in and of itself no reason to cause recession pretty much anywhere. Again, it could burst some kind of bubble and start a recession, but a China slowdown itself is not enough.
- raducu 7y agoI was trying to point out that since China's factories are so much export oriented that seeing decreased factory activity most likely means a weak global demand. If the problem was with chinese real-estate, yes, the risk for contagion was minimal.
- dageshi 7y agoAustralia and most of Asia largely went through the financial crisis in 2008 with very few problems compared to the US/Europe and China as a deliberate policy has kept its financial system closed to itself, there are fewer ways for a recession to spread between China and the rest of the world in the same way it did during the financial crisis.
- quickthrower2 7y agoI don't think Australia is technically in recession.
- omeid2 7y agoAustralia is far from recession, but a global recession is as matter of time. The only way that the economy "grows" indefinitely is if it regularly dips, and that is exactly how it has been working since WWII, with dips/recessions at 1975, 1982, 1991 and 2009.
- taneq 7y agoOnly because the global commodities market picked up at just the right time. Just like we rode out the GFC pretty well, coincidentally saved by the last mining boom (although to be fair, the stimulus spending at that point did also work pretty well). It's surreal watching our major parties both trying to claim credit for the global economic climate.
- omeid2 7y agoThe major parties jump to grasping any straw. Why are you surprised!
- grey-area 7y agoIt's part of a trade war that shows no signs of subsiding. It will badly hurt the largest economies in the world, which all depend on trade. If we're lucky it won't lead to global war.
- kylehotchkiss 7y agoCouldn’t this be caused by people’s waning desire to buy the next big thing and keeping their devices longer? Rushing for the latest and greatest phone doesn’t feel as exciting as it used to. Laptops and TVs last half a decade or more now too.
- konschubert 7y agoIt could. That would be nice. But there’s no reason to assume that it’s that. Much more likely it’s simply a normal recession where the purchasing power goes down.
- baxtr 7y agoI work in the travel industry in the West and we see a significant drop in sales compared to the last 2 years. That supports your hypothesis since travel is something usually consume every year.
- nerdponx 7y agoI seriously doubt this is happening on any kind of aggregate scale.
- baybal2 7y agoI believe it is more less it. People in my circles who pay big money for serious market research papers showed me some in December. There was a very visible trend of people deciding to downgrade for their third or fourth smartphone. Here is a repost of my post from December: > Very true, I'd say a downgrade is the trend. I saw like 10+ people deciding to switch from "superphones" down to mid-range models, and even dumbphones for their new phones. People who had ultrabooks, often try Atom based notebooks and sufraces. The key deciding factor for such people, I think, is having a good screen and bearable ergonomics (no microscopic keyboards, or batteries.) The data I have access to tell that the "big screen, small CPU," is the category with the biggest year on year growth. Atom based 14 and 15 inchers are selling like hot cookies. > As a person working in the industry, I can say that's a very visible trend. People switch their devices more due to battery and physical wear than actual need for more features. > In that respect, things got very "Japanised" in respect that Japanese cellphone makers are often making new models every season with no real changes other than cosmetic. > Japan is also the only developed market where "dumbphones" ever saw few upwards trends in last
- lordnacho 7y agoWhether or not this is the start is not so important, but remember it's been a while since the last one, and it's a common thing to occur in the economy, or any other ecological system. It's also something that has an important role. Investors at some point need to decide which businesses are viable, which are not. Workers need to consider career changes. Corporate entities need to consider which projects are worthwhile. All those kinds of decisions are put to the test when not everything can be given a long horizon. Finally, there is a twist this time. We've been running a financial experiment with few parallels over the last decade or so.
- coolaliasbro 7y agoThese considerations are requisite only in a capitalist system. In other economic models it is not a given that ”[i]nvestors...need to decide which businesses are viable... Workers need to consider career changes." In fact, the division between investors on the one hand and workers in the other is a large part of this problem. If we socialized gains and privatized losses (in the sense of never bailing out those agents that got themselves into bad situations), these cycles would at worst be much less severe and frequent.
- navigatesol 7y ago>If we socialized gains and privatized losses (in the sense of never bailing out those agents that got themselves into bad situations), these cycles would at worst be much less severe and frequent. You should look at the severity and frequency of economic cycles around the world throughout history and I bet you'd reconsider this position. Often times they lead to the collapse of entire nations or worse, war. Is that worth it to teach an overleveraged business a lesson? Remember, "businesses" don't make these decisions in a vacuum; they are run by and consist of people. People win and people lose in every cycle (just not always the same or most deserving groups).
- shanusmagnus 7y agoIf we socialized gains and privatized losses, there'd be less severe cycles because there'd be less economy to have cycles on.
- temp129038 7y agoCurious: does anyone actively sell stocks in this situation - even if it's in a retirement portfolio you'd presumably not touch for a long time? I've sold some in the last few weeks though I know the general advice is not really to do anything.
- grey-area 7y agoThis has been visible for at least the last six months. Best time to sell was last August. This is the time to start buying, not selling.
- nerdponx 7y agoIf you bought Bitcoin at $1k, missed the peak at $2k, and sold at $1.5k, did you win or lose?
- imtringued 7y agoYou lost because the gains aren't high enough to compensate for the even higher risk. Gambling $1k in Bitcoin is doable. Putting half your retirement funds into Bitcoin just isn't feasible. Because of this you will see the 50% ROI only on a tiny percentage of your portfolio.
- nerdponx 7y agoIt's not a dumb question, frankly. But the saying is that "the markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent". Yes, if you time the market by selling high and re-buying low, you can make more money. But the general advice is not to sell because a typical market participant isn't going to be able to time the market. That said, I don't believe in the efficient market hypothesis, so I think people who claim that you can't time the market at all are either wrong or lying.
- imtringued 7y agoYeah sure but if you have the ability to time the market then you wouldn't ask this question in the first place. You'd spend your day working 40 hours a week managing million dollar portfolios. Therefore telling people they can't time the market is perfectly good advice.
- baybal2 7y agoAs somebody who worked in OEM electronics since my first real job 12 ago, I can say for sure that manufacturing in China was on a downward slope since it peaked at around 2010. A way more alarming indicator is the receding semiconductor spendings, both net and capital, for the last 3-4 years. This means that not only stuff generally classified as "light industry goods" going down. It means that big players in the industry expect much more "inelastic goods" like server chips, telecom gear, and other businessy/enterprise stuff to also go down. To a lot of people, it was clear that we are heading for "a long winter" in the industry for quite some time. People saw it as early as 2016.
- Gibbon1 7y ago2016 you started seeing lead times for a whole variety of ordinary semiconductors and discretes stretch way out. I think they were expecting a recession but demand continued. Feels like manufacturers are edgy and don't want to get caught out.
- baybal2 7y agoI'd say, back then major players realised that they need to get more careful with capital spendings. In short term, there was a demand overshoot, but now their decision seem remarkably rational.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI think in 2001 3Com got stuck with a $1 Billion worth of inventory that had to be scrapped. Sales of durable goods tend to fall off a cliff during recessions.
- Nano2rad 7y agoFear of recession is irrational. There is no need for continuous growth.
- sasaf5 7y agoI like this sentence. Please elaborate or give some links, I would like to read more. Edit: why the downvotes? I am sincerely interested to read more about the necessity of growth or the lack of it.
- frozenport 7y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntary_Human_Extinction_Movement https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voluntary_Human_Extinction_M...
- carlmr 7y agoI get where you come from. You have to see though that for a lot of people recession means losing their jobs, being unable to provide for their families, etc. The fear of recession is entirely rational for anyone without a savings account covering the next 2 years.
- ironic_ali 7y agoEveryone should be spreading their savings around different banks. Banks will only pay back a certain amount if they go bust - and it depends on the country how much that is.
- mschuster91 7y ago> Everyone should be spreading their savings around different banks. Which savings? 60% of the US population has less than 1.000 $ in liquid savings per [1]. In Germany it's 33% per [2]. When the recession hits (not if but when) people are going to get fucked. The 2008 crisis wiped out what many people had and its aftermath left them unable to rebuild their savings, and social security institutions have been wrecked since neoliberalism took over - I certainly expect (food) riots once recession hits. The Yellow Vests in France are an example what a still relatively rich but angry population can do, and extrapolating from that reveals a not very nice future. [1]: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/most-americans-couldnt-cover-a-1000-expense/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/most-americans-couldnt-cover-a-... [2]: https://www.focus.de/finanzen/news/finanzen_news_armut_in_deutschland/armutsgefaehrdung-in-deutschland-fast-ein-drittel-kann-sich-unerwartete-ausgaben-unter-1000-euro-nicht-leisten_id_8805287.html https://www.focus.de/finanzen/news/finanzen_news_armut_in_de...
- sytelus 7y agoTLDR; Terrifs are the root cause. With continued increase terrif recession might be official within 3 quarters. JP Morgan has taken u-turn and is expecting 2 rate cuts from feds. Other central banks around the world are planning rate cuts as well. South Korea production fell by 2X than expected. Not all economies are loser, however, India and Vietnam might see increased business.
- zZsFBVZ9bjdJd 7y agoHard to take you serious when you misspell "tariff"
- futureastronaut 7y agoTerrific!
- bamboozled 7y agoWell, hopefully we see a decline in CO2 emissions for a while because of this.
- sytelus 7y agoProbably not. Recession first impact vulnerable industries that depends on government subsidies, growth and innovations. The alternative energy companies are therefore first to be impacted. This is often exaggerated by reduced prices of conventional energy as consumption drops. You would typically see pull back in manufacturers releasing electric cars or people investing in building solar/wind farms.
- bamboozled 7y agoOr demand just slows down and we make less stuff and therefore less emissions ? Not everything needs to have complicated side-effects.
- frankbreetz 7y agoThe last decline, or non-increase I suppose, in CO2 was attributed to a global recession
- tanilama 7y agoI don't know though. I believe that I have saved carefully for the worse to come, but I am not sure would it be sufficient or not. Certainly not big capital spending whatsoever in next year. Risky time indeed.
- Theodores 7y agoFactory activity in Asia is a good indicator in a world where none of us can easily see the wood for the trees. Shame the article wasn't big on actual numbers. We all have our local bubbles to contend with. In the US there are tariff taxes that affect the world but are a US thing. Then, in the UK, there is the joy of Brexit. You would not guess there was a problem if you were to be out and about in the UK this last weekend, however, read the papers and you will see stories about how that there is no inward investment, auto manufacturing is kaput and the High Street is losing many shops. Speak to some people and these indicators can be seen as unimportant, after all, isn't everyone buying online these days so the High Street demise is more of a shift to other fulfilment means, with no net loss involved? It can all be handwaved away. With the example of Brexit the predicament can be blamed on Brexit and is therefore not part of a global recession, even if the frozen UK economy contributes to the big, global picture. I am sure that in every market there is some local whataboutism, an ability to blame a local recession on silly politicians, a business scandal or some other local factor. In this way we could all walk into a global recession without anyone seeing it, thinking it was just us that was feeling a bit skint. There are always people thinking we are on the verge of some mega crash. Personally I have been expecting the housing bubble to collapse for many decades but it has not happened. I have given up on that one now. I once worked in weather forecasting and, if you listened to me, then you would always have expected rain (I didn't understand low-lying clouds too well). Because of this tendency and bias that we all have it can be hard to make sense of media pundits and their forecasts of the economy. We also only listen to those that we are inclined to agree with. There are always some indicators that are fact oriented and helpful, I think factory activity in Asia is one. What I am surprised at is that there isn't a good indicator based on internet search activity. For instance, with the housing market in northern climes there is what the mortgage industry says for PR and then there is reality. Sales of flooring products, and by proxy, internet searches for flooring products may be a better indicator. Nobody fetishes over getting new carpets or laminate floors, people don't overly window shop for it, they just buy that stuff when they move home or have money to upgrade their existing dwelling. It is a purchase that can be easily put off. I need a 'basket' of these indicators and some Google Trends 'fu' to see the wood for the trees.
- mxuribe 7y ago
- RickJWagner 7y agoI think it's likely we'll see a lot more economic news in the months ahead. As Bill Clinton famously told us, US politics are largely anchored in the economy. Public perception of the state of the economy is going to be very much in focus through November of next year.
- frankbreetz 7y agoI feel like I have been reading these "global recession fears mount" for about the last 6-7 years.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoSince Taper Tantrum in 2012, it's been non-stop. I wonder if this is how economic reporting has always been. I wonder if it's just click-bait feeding off of fear in readers' lizard brains. From the outside, /most/ of the worries really do seem legit this time. I'm young, so I don't know what other times were like. But at the least -- the worries aren't fake news. Taper tantrum seemed real. The European Banking Crisis -- I'm still not sure how nothing happened there, especially with Italy. China has really been the backbone for global growth since 2008, and Kyle Bass is making a pretty convincing argument that at least some of that has been an illusion. I know I hear over and over again that this is "the most reluctant bull market in history". I'm sure every time is different. But I'm wondering if one of the things that really is different is how much uncertainty has been at the core of this market. There are very few people this time that believe everything is rosey.
- frankbreetz 7y agoI'm with you, I also feel too young to know if this is how it has always been or not. We are in the longest period of growth for some time, and the aforementioned temper tantrum, so it does seem like we are due for a recession, but it is hard not to tune the noise out.
- z2 7y agoI'm with you on the 'too young to know from experience' boat, though there are groups that have been trying to measure the probability of recession through macro indicators across consumption, production, and employment. https://www.chicagofed.org/publications/cfnai/index https://www.chicagofed.org/publications/cfnai/index From speculation, while there are tons of factors that may be giving this business cycle legs, I think one that's not spoken of enough is that many business may be a bit less cyclical today. Thanks to the cloud, companies can scale up and down on a whim rather than slowly build up an excess of hardware and staff to maintain them. Even industrial companies like rail car manufacturers have gotten smarter by leasing factories on short term and using temporary labor.
- KuhlMensch 7y agoHm, I think some people may have missed this bit: The trade conflict between China and the United States escalated last month when Trump raised tariffs on some Chinese imports to 25% from 10% and threatened levies on all Chinese goods. If that were to happen, and China were to retaliate, “we could end up in a (global) recession in three quarters”, said Chetan Ahya, global head of economics at Morgan Stanley. It strikes me as quite a precise predication. Though of course, that does not mean it is correct.