14 ms·
A modern Japanese man, working in tech in California, in his late thirties or early forties spoke with his parents back home in Tokyo five years ago about two h
by mistrial9 8y ago
A modern Japanese man, working in tech in California, in his late thirties or early forties spoke with his parents back home in Tokyo five years ago about two houses the family owns, which are in desirable areas, well-maintained and currently occupied. The taxes and financing are such that there is no current scenario where the man could own one or both of these homes. It is simply too expensive. None of the people in this vignette are poor, they are all moderately wealthy people, who have fairly substantial income, and some savings.
Move the story to California. A three bedroom home in the San Francisco Bay Area, covered by Proposition 13, purchased by ordinary working people with good financial habits, around the 1970 time frame, and a working late-thirties, early forties person with some savings and good financial habits, cannot afford to take the home under almost any circumstances due to property taxes (cost of ownership) and competition for financing (loans not available in practice due to terms).
There is a lot of emotion on both sides of the Pacific in each of these cases. Individuals are quick to point fingers at the other individuals. It has been decades in the making, and the situation is not new. Many on both sides of the Pacific are renting at high prices (no accumulated capital) and deferring (or avoiding) having children.
- caprese 8y agothe allegory to this is that if you are successful in overcoming these odds, you get to be part of the problem! Congratulations, no pat on the back, just vilification. The fingers now get pointed at you
- anovikov 8y agoBut this is normal for some highly attractive areas. Looking at the U.S. as a whole, situation is pretty much normal - housing is very affordable.
- Spooky23 8y agoThis is changing as income stagnates and loans remain cheap and too easy to get. Our whole fiscal policy is about printing money through home ownership. It’s creating all sorts of bad behaviors.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoHousing is not affordable in many areas of the United States, after you adjust for local wages.
- munificent 8y agoIf you take a sample of all houses across the US and look only at their prices, yes, there's lots of affordable housing. But that picture ignores demographic shifts and jobs. If you look at the prices of houses relative to jobs available in the area, the picture is much worse. In small towns and rural areas, there's lots of really cheap houses. In the town I grew up, you can find tolerable houses for sale for $100k. But there are no jobs there. Even at that low price, you're unlikely to be able to afford it at any sort of local wage. Meanwhile, in the city where I live now, the median home price is $750,000. If you aren't in one of a shrinking number of vital industries like tech, that's also unaffordable. Over the years, I've watched friend after friend get priced out of the city. The main problem I see is that jobs are moving much faster than physical infrastructure and housing can keep up with.
- anovikov 8y agoBut if someone is priced out, someone else come in right? Definitely the population of these places does not fall, it rises. What's the problem if some people have to leave?
- DFHippie 8y agoCertain segments of the economy get priced out of the area. If you want to go to a restaurant, there need to be places for the waiters and cooks to live. If you want someone to pick up the trash, there need to be homes for garbagemen. A hospital needs nurses, janitors, and receptionists as well as doctors.
- anovikov 8y agoHow technically do people who own their homes outright, get 'priced out'? Just due to the real estate tax? Anyway, they get priced out, but they pocket hundreds of thousands or millions of free money from insane appreciation of their homes. And can start a new life in a cheaper place - probably getting about same money for the same job - but with whole lot of money in the pocket. Why should we feel sorry for them?
- mistrial9 8y agothis offhand opinion is not substantiated in "The State of the Nation's Housing" 2017, published by the Joint Center for Housing Studies of Harvard University
- rb808 8y agoI didn't know about Japanese property tax, a quick google shows there are a lot of taxes, 1.7% annually. 2% on registration. + some extras https://resources.realestate.co.jp/buy/guide-to-japanese-real-estate-taxes/ https://resources.realestate.co.jp/buy/guide-to-japanese-rea...
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThat’s about on par with the top ten highest property tax states in the US (~1.5-1.7% annually).
- rb808 8y agoAgreed, just most countries in the world don't have any property taxes, so was surprised to see Japan as having them. edit: I do agree there are some common property taxes globally, but they're just a few hundred or at most 1-2k a year, not like 1-2% in some of the US states (and Japan) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Property_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Property_tax
- walshemj 8y agoI think most developed countries do in some form
- luckydata 8y agomost advanced countries in the world DO have property taxes. Why do you think that's not the case?
- cheerlessbog 8y agoSome places they are capped rather then percentages, I believe this is the case in the UK.
- rcxdude 8y agoThe UK doesn't have a direct property tax. The closest thing is the council tax (which is linked to the notional value of your home in 1991), but that is generally paid by the occupants, not the owner (and may be discounted or increased if a home is left empty depending on the disposition of the local council). It also doesn't update as the market changes, because it's effectively frozen 30 years ago.
- bhouston 8y agoHigh rent delays child bearing. I wonder how much of the story of the falling japanese population can be attributed to that?
- cobookman 8y ago+100. because rent is expensive, both parents need to work. Because both parents need to work they need to pay for daycare Costs. Rent is expensive because both parents are working allowing price to go up. Because parents wait longer. Their earnings are higher. Allowing daycare Costs to increase. Tldr it's a vicious circle
- knodi123 8y ago> Tldr it's a viscous circle It's a syrupy, goopy circle?
- mgbmtl 8y agoSubsidized daycare can boost the economy: more people having kids, and more people on the workforce. (Quebec/Canada has a mix of semi-state-owned daycare, which are great, but few, and subsidized private daycare, which aren't as good, but usually not that bad)
- Chris_Chambers 8y agoSubsidized daycare attracts scum who abuse children and exploit the system for free money. Several daycares have been caught falsely claiming to be taking care of hundreds of absent children so they can pocket money stolen from the taxpayers since they’re paid per child claimed. For each corrupt daycare caught, there are probably dozens more getting away with it. We might as well just be paying mothers to stay home with their children rather than adding insult to injury by stealing those mothers’ tax dollars and distributing it to human filth.
- snidane 8y agoI'd be curious. Is there a correlation between rising living costs (comprised mostly of housing costs) and lower birth rates? Japan is a social laboratory for the west and we see similar phenomena in the west these days.
- Kalium 8y ago> Move the story to California. A three bedroom home in the San Francisco Bay Area, covered by Proposition 13, purchased by ordinary working people with good financial habits, around the 1970 time frame, and a working late-thirties, early forties person with some savings and good financial habits, cannot afford to take the home under almost any circumstances due to property taxes (cost of ownership) and competition for financing (loans not available in practice due to terms). California actually has ways to inherit not only the home of your parents and grandparents, but also their tax rate.
- javajosh 8y agoReally? How?
- Kalium 8y agoProp 13 was amended twice - Propositions 58 and 193. Those allowed Prop 13 tax assessments to be inherited with property to children and grandchildren. There's some broader legal commentary, which I'm not properly equipped to evaluate, here: https://krasalaw.com/lawyer/2010/08/24/Estate-Planning/Maintaining-Your-Prop.-13-Tax-Base_bl1153.htm https://krasalaw.com/lawyer/2010/08/24/Estate-Planning/Maint...
- TulliusCicero 8y agoWhich is bad. It's possible it may end up benefiting me since my parents own a home in the bay area, but I still think it's bad. The entire prop 13 + zoning + property value situation is terrible, it's a total pyramid scheme: older generations get wealthy through wealth transfers from the younger generation from inflating property values. But it can only work once or twice before the property values are so comically high that even high income DINK couples can't afford to buy in.
- aey 8y agoWhy is that bad? A family lived in the city for generations, and now due to the tech boom and a property bubble they should be forced to move? It makes a hell of a lot more sense for FAANG to open offices somewhere else.
- dgzl 8y agoProperty taxes: even if you own your land, you don't actually own it.
- snidane 8y agoIncome taxes: even if you own yourself and your labor, you actually don't.
- rcpt 8y agoYou seem to be confusing the fee simple notion of land ownership that we have in the United States with allodial title which doesn't happen anywhere because it's a terrible way to run a society https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fee_simple https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fee_simple https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allodial_title https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Allodial_title
- tomrod 8y agoI doubt there is confusion. Land ownership in the US requires taxes else some level of government claims ownership. This means you do not truly own the land, just merely rent it with a complex social contract. I agree with some forms of property taxation, for the record, but think that single family owner-occupied homes should be tax free.
- samhain 8y agoExactly, there is an effective rent for owning a home, even if it's entirely paid off. The taxes you must pay, the insurance on the property, and the upkeep for maintenance (amortized roofing expenses/AC units etc). I have family members that are ecstatic when their property value increases, because they love the idea of being people who live in a very valuable home. But this is the only home that they have. And then their taxes go up. In order to cash out their "investment" they have to move. Which means, if they don't rent, buying back into the same over-inflated market. It's a wash, and the only thing that changes is the amount of money they are paying in taxes.
- GreaterFool 8y ago> The taxes and financing are such that there is no current scenario where the man could own one or both of these homes. This is curious. Could you share some numbers? I thought the financing wouldn't be an issue due to incredibly low interest rates.
- mistrial9 8y agoit is the costs associated with transfer of ownership, and the taxes on the new valuation IIR