21 ms·
Post-surgical deaths in Scotland drop by a third, attributed to a checklist
- ctingom 8y agoIs this checklist used in the United States?
- jessaustin 8y agoChecklists are the reason that California has 4.5 maternal deaths per 100k live births, while USA as a whole has 26.4. [0] If hospitals cared about this sort of thing, there wouldn't have to be state regulations for this. If states besides California cared about this sort of thing, they'd have the regulations too. [0] https://www.usatoday.com/deadly-deliveries/interactive/how-hospitals-are-failing-new-moms-in-graphics/ https://www.usatoday.com/deadly-deliveries/interactive/how-h...
- balthasar 8y agoCut down post-surgical deaths by using this one weird trick.
- ste1n 8y agoGreat interview with Dr. Gawande here: https://fs.blog/atul-gawande/ https://fs.blog/atul-gawande/
- _ph_ 8y agoSeveral times in the discussions here I read about the checklist in question: but these are obvious items, why do they need to be checked? I think that is the very point of check lists: not to miss actions, because they seem to be trivial/obvious. Be it because the stress levels are high or because one is focussed on the "real problem at hand". In a sense, the more intelligent/capable/experienced you are, the more you are at risk of missing something as you are focussed on the big picture. As a software developer, while not having checklists as printable documents, I highly appreciate the checklist approach. This can take several shapes. When doing a software release, I perform the necessary steps always in the same order. This makes it easier to correctly perform everything needed. And of course I check the result of every step for the expected result. Checklist-like approaches can be even very helpful when debugging issues. I often enough get to resolve "the software doesn't work" like issues. And of course, there is no obvious reason, like a meaningful error message or stack trace. To debug this kind of issues, I start with simple and trivial things. While not a static list - the cases are too varying for that - I tend to start with asking and checking very basic questions, like: is there enough free disk space? Repeating the steps which, according to the bug reporter, lead to the issue. At each action taken, verify that any observeable result matches the expectation, even if those actions are not close to the bug. This approach has usually two outcomes. Either a very trivial explanation for the problem is found, because some seemingly trivial step fails, or at least, I know, that all the things tested are note related to the problem. Excluding a wide range of possible problems can be surprisingly helpful in narrowing down the actual problem.
- caboteria 8y agoI started using a checklist for my motorcycle track days a few years ago when I almost forgot the key to my bike. I remembered as I was pulling out of the driveway. Now I've got a thorough checklist, and a track bike that doesn't use a key.
- quickthrower2 8y agoWe had death by Powerpoint recently on HN. Is this life by Excel?
- danjc 8y agoDoes anyone else think that a nearly 1 in 200 chance of dying following surgery is very high? I'm not sure I'd want surgery for a non-life threatening condition if the chance of death is that high.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 8y agoI suspect your chances to die from surgery for a non-life threatening condition may be a lot lower than 1 in 200, while your chances of dying if you are 80 years old, on the brink of death, with multiple different conditions at the same time, and having difficult surgery.
- Ensorceled 8y agoFor 30 years, every place I've gone to, I've implemented release process and release day checklists because they didn't exist. I've experienced push back every time: "We haven't needed these before.". At all of these places, release issues were always "bad luck". All of my teams have acknowledged these were awesome and reduced release day stress. I completely understand why this took effort to get implemented and why it seems obvious in retrospect.
- miguelmota 8y agoChecklists are great. Less cognitive load having to recall things. I use Trello boards for maintaining my personal checklists. Recommend it.
- zeristor 8y agoPerhaps they could pick up the Japanese train drivers pointing and calling: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LmdUz3rOQU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LmdUz3rOQU Referring to things in multiple ways is supposed to have a more thorough confirmation, although not a good idea to point whilst wielding a scalpel.
- externalreality 8y agoI have Dr. Gwande's book for years now.
- Razengan 8y agoAny recommendations for good apps for routine checklists (i.e. repeated daily)? (preferably cross-platform and without subscriptions.)
- kristianp 8y agoBefore checking in code: * have the unit tests been built and run? * have I reviewed all changes and removed commented out code, tidied up? Edit: oh, you meant apps. I read your comment as asking for good items for checklists.
- bullen 8y agoWhat is the list?
- richev 8y agoI create short-lived checklists all the time. For an up-coming food shopping outing, or a to-do list for the weekend. My favourite ones are for vacations... My wife and I will be taking our son (who will be 5 months old at the time) on his first trip that will require long haul flights (Australia - Vietnam - UK) so I'm currently working on a checklist for what to have in our hand luggage, and a separate one for the hold luggage. For me, it's part of the looking-forward aspect to such a trip, plus there are lots of things that we really don't want to forget, or run out of. And anyone who's scuba dived will be familiar with the three item checklist that forms part of the pre-dive "buddy check". * B A R (buoyancy, air, releases) in the UK * A B C (air, buoyancy, clips) in the US and probably elsewhere A potential life saver!
- externalreality 8y agoDidn't read article - [check]
- hyperpallium 8y agoChecklists: boring and tedious! To catch errors, I started double-checking math problems, by generating a checklist on the spot. But I also made fewer errors, and developed more intuition. I think checking itself was a deeper practice; and also gave an overview of the task (less cluttered by detail) that helped me make connections at a higher level. Checklists: insightful and tedious!
- taoufix 8y agoThis reminds me of the Japanese railway employees pointing at things. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LmdUz3rOQU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9LmdUz3rOQU
- tigerlily 8y agoBanana boxes are fantastic. Even so, checklists help me audit my adventure inventory to make sure I have everything I need before I set off. I even use checklists for making sure the apartment I'm about to rent has everything in order. Things like check under the sink for leakages.
- wastra 8y agoI am an anaesthetia doctor. There is, in fact, only mixed evidence of checklists actually helping in various health systems around the world. At a national level, Scotland began using checklists, but the whole health system and population is always in flux, so attribution of such a big change just to checklists is bold. It may also be that checklists do (temporarily?) improve broken or highly resource constrained peri-operative care: but this leaves open the question as to whether correcting underlying staff/morale/equipment/logistic problems would have, or should, play a role. Checklists I have seen used during my career are often rushed through, with more time usually being spent appropriate to the complexity of a situation. Local culture will strongly impinge on effectiveness of (yet another?) checklist. The safety culture in medicine is improving dramatically, but there is tension between protocolizing everything into checklists, and individualizing care to each patient. AI will be part of the solution to this. An important checklist commonality in medicine is the request that _anyone_ should speak up if they think something is wrong. In analyzing situations where patients were harmed, e.g. wrong side surgery, it is common to hear that someone, a nurse, a technician, did notice, but was not empowered to speak up. As a doctor, I am used to the power to speak up and act, but I value others' eyes in many situations. More complex and highly dynamic medical situations will always require the attention, knowledge and skill of those involved.
- coob 8y agoI can recommend the book Black Box Thinking [1] by Matthew Syed. It covers how not only checklists but also the learning culture that produced them can be applied to other industries and areas. [1] https://www.amazon.co.uk/Black-Box-Thinking-Surprising-Success/dp/1473613779 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Black-Box-Thinking-Surprising-Succe...
- PhaedrusV 8y ago.... They haven't been using checklists? I've been getting so upset at the medical community recently. Pilots solved most of these problems decades ago. We've been trying to help them figure out these tools that we developed to save lives, but it seems like things are only changing one funeral at a time.
- _carl_jung 8y agoThey have, since 2008. You're right about pace though, unfortunately rolling out change into bureaucracy is painstakingly slow.
- jplayer01 8y agoUnfortunately, there's a lot of resistance to using checklists, from the nurses to doctors. I wish they'd just swallow their pride and worry more about how to improve than how it makes them look when their mistakes become visible and explicit to the people around them.
- ColinWright 8y agoThis is something of a case of "Physician - heal thyself". I've advocated the use of checklists in software for decades. I wrote something 5 years ago and posted it here[0][1]. The discussion was enlightening. Read the discussions, keeping in mind the comments here about the resistance encountered by people in the field. Many of the points in the discussions are useful and can be used to create and adapt checklists, but no, they are being used to dismiss them out of hand. Checklists? We don't need to stinkin' checklists. I've given up and just use them in my companies. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7655018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7655018 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18522627 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18522627
- lugg 8y agoReminds me of the old you are not done yet list. Couldn't track the one I'm thinking of down but found this: http://www.thebraidytester.com/downloads/YouAreNotDoneYet.pdf http://www.thebraidytester.com/downloads/YouAreNotDoneYet.pd... I feel like I could use a checklist or two.
- feederico 8y agoShould you want to know more about checklists, here's the very Atul Gawande https://youtu.be/dfl8Xt8W09A https://youtu.be/dfl8Xt8W09A
- madrox 8y agoI instituted checklists across team process and can't recommend it enough. Our pull request process reduced subjectiveness in PRs and approval time. It also seemed to improve the quality of what got through the PR process. We also had them for deploy process, sprint planning, and a few other domain specific areas. We had other teams give input, which helped with compliance challenges like GDPR and COPPA.
- KboPAacDA3 8y agoThe saga of how this checklist came into existence is detailed in Dr. Gawande's book The Checklist Manifesto.
- ahaferburg 8y agoOr the much shorter article https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist
- bumby 8y agoIf I remember correctly, they had similar results (>30% improvements) with their pilot study in Michigan
- intertextuality 8y agoI work on software related to medical drilling. Nurses run through simulations (mostly a situation where something has gone wrong) and get graded. It baffled me to learn that this is NOT the norm at hospitals. Due to the stress of a situation-gone-awry and inexperience, some horrific things can happen.[0][1] In some situations you may only have a few minutes to enact corrective procedures. In any case without checklists (and without experience from running routine simulations) it's very easy to make mistakes or forget what to do. I thought the checklists themselves were standard but it appears not...? The more I learn about hospitals' operating practice the more wary I become. I have no idea why hospitals aren't like the aviation industry and have checklists and expiring certifications. (Or maybe I heard wrong and I'm just completely wrong here.) [0]: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/05/10/premature-baby-decapitated-mothers-womb-gynaecologist-pulled/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/05/10/premature-baby-d... [1]: https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/Dental-Anesthesia-Under-Scrutiny-After-Child-Dies-381594491.html https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/Dental-Anesthesia-Unde... > Mead said the principal risk is a patient’s airway. He explained that a child’s breathing tube can collapse without warning under sedation. > “It happens instantaneously,” he said. “You have maybe half a minute to make critical decisions about how you're going to manage that child's airway. You can't do that if you don't have somebody competent there helping you.”
- cwbrandsma 8y agoI was part of a start-up developing checklist for high risk pregnancies. The checklists were developed by some of the best doctors in the country, who had already proved the worth of using checklists in their own practice. Even with all of that, we had unending push back from every single hospital we talked to. Eventually it killed the company because deals could not be closed. I still hear of hospitals saying they want checklists, and they keep saying that until they see one, and then they don't want it anymore. Also, it wasn't a cost issue. The package was pretty cheap all told. The push back was in the "system getting in the way"...which was kind of the point unfortunately.
- istjohn 8y agoAtul Gawande talks about the importance of developing checklists collaboratively with the people who will use them as opposed to imposing them top down.
- prennert 8y agoIt is fantastic to see this pan out in real life. I read the checklist manifesto by Atul Gawande who helped to author the WHO checklist. It really one of these mind expanding books that everyone should read. I have seen below comments that ask why checklists are not standard even though they were pivotal in reducing flight accidents. The reason is that knowledge is often siloed, and people tend to overestimate themselves. How many checklists are you using at work? If none, ask yourself why, and if they could be helpful. The book also talks about the design of checklists which is not trivial at all.
- spenrose 8y agoThe study: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/bjs.11151 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/bjs.11151
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kasperni 8y agoHere is a link to the actual checklist: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/9789241598590_eng_Checklist.pdf https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/97892... I'm a bit perplexed that something so simple, can reduce post surgical deaths by a third.
- treis 8y ago>I'm a bit perplexed that something so simple, can reduce post surgical deaths by a third. Because it didn't. It attributes the entirety of a decade long decline to the check list, which is obviously nonsense. I'm not saying that checklists aren't good, but they're not miracle workers.
- Camas 8y agoThey didn't just measure the difference and call it a day. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/bjs.11151 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/bjs.11151
- treis 8y ago>The Scottish Patient Safety Programme (SPSP) is a national initiative which aims to improve in‐hospital mortality rates in Scotland. The SPSP was established in 2008 and had perioperative management, including implementation of the WHO surgical checklist, as one of its four key initial workstreams. This programme offered a systematic approach to improve patient safety across all hospitals in the country26. >After testing, review and feedback from health boards across Scotland, the surgical checklist was included as one of the ten Patient Safety Essentials to be implemented across all health boards in Scotland37. The surgical checklist was not a stand‐alone intervention. It was, however, the only Patient Safety Essential that targeted surgical patients specifically during the interval studied37. Thus, the addition of the checklist to the other parameters within the SPSP may have contributed to the improvement in results observed in the present study. >It is acknowledged that attributing causal links to the findings in population‐wide data set analysis is not possible. What you said they didn't do is kind of exactly what they did. Yes, there is some attempts at hand waving, but it's silly to boil down the success of a large and multi pronged program to a simple checklist.
- wazoox 8y agoIn France, a surgery checklist is available since 2008 or 2009 but alas, it's not mandatory.
- michaelt 8y agoAnd here is the checklist [1] These seem like very common-sense things to check - Is this the right patient? Are the instruments sterile? Have we counted all the surgical equipment after the procedure? [1] https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/9789241598590_eng_Checklist.pdf https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/97892...
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoThe issue is in the margins. Maybe a shift-change caused the surgical team to be different from normal, so people aren't as comfortable with each other. There's social/professional pressure to fit within a hierarchy, especially with new people. Maybe a few people lower on the totem pole think something might be off, but don't want to say anything lest they risk appearing to undermine the surgeon. So, at first it appears that a whole room of people would need to independently make the same mistake. But that's not so; only a few critical people need to make the mistake, and with enough ambiguity in the process (easily caused by anything happening 'out of the ordinary'), it won't be corrected some percentage of the time. Even seemingly trivial things. The FAA found this occurring in the cockpit, especially from the '3rd seat'. A pilot and first officer may be 'in the weeds' dealing with the immediate threat of a situation, whereas others have the benefit of distance to reflect on a situation and observe more clearly. They don't get tunnel vision, and are in a better place to diagnose a tricky problem. However, they may not feel empowered to speak up, or feel they don't have the information the pilots do. Aviation has, broadly, sought to correct this and encourage anyone to speak up. Recently, this happened during the flight before the Indonesia 737 crash where similar AoA/MCAS issues occurred, but a 3rd pilot helped to address the situation.
- falcolas 8y agoIt's always worth remembering that "after" can be after 10+ hours of continuous high-stress concentration, so remembering lots of little things can be very challenging.
- lordnacho 8y agoThis is pretty interesting. There seems to be a whole other list referenced: "Is the anaesthesia machine and medication check complete?" Also the team are supposed to intro themselves along with their roles. I wonder if it often happens that someone is missing?
- wonder_er 8y agoThe potential benefit of having checklists is enormous, and people's lives are on the line. Many people rightfully ask > Why has this not been adopted everywhere _yesterday_? A book I read a few years ago might have the answer. _Catastrophic Care: How American Health Care Killed My Father—and How We Can Fix It _ [0] Here's the description, to evaluate if you want to give it a read: > In 2007, David Goldhill's father died from a series of infections acquired in a well-regarded New York hospital. The bill was for several hundred thousand dollars--and Medicare paid it. > These circumstances left Goldhill angry and determined to understand how it was possible that world-class technology and well-trained personnel could result in such simple, inexcusable carelessness--and how a business that failed so miserably could be rewarded with full payment. > Catastrophic Care is the eye-opening result. > Goldhill explicates a health-care system that now costs nearly $2.5 trillion annually, bars many from treatment, provides inconsistent quality of care, offers negligible customer service, and in which an estimated 200,000 Americans die each year from errors. Above all, he exposes the fundamental fallacy of our entire system--that Medicare and insurance coverage make care cheaper and improve our health--and suggests a comprehensive new approach that could produce better results at more acceptable costs immediately by giving us, the patients, a real role in the process. [0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13642523-catastrophic-care https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/13642523-catastrophic-ca... edit: formatting
- nwah1 8y agoIf we had a medicare-for-all system, we could provide some economic discipline by having high deductible plans, even if those plans are completely covered by a government-funded HSA plan of equal value. As long as the HSA could be withdrawn for retirement if unspent. We also need transparent pricing and reviews. Sites like ZocDoc are trying to fill the niche of something like Yelp but for doctors. There's lots of easy low hanging fruit here.
- cheerlessbog 8y agoEssentially they pay for procedures and not for outcomes. Imagine if we compensated plumbers that way.
- MarkMc 8y agoA great book on this subject is The Checklist Manifesto [0]. An interesting point made in the book is that checklists help to correct the subtle psychological problems that occur in an operating theatre. Without a checklist a nurse who sees a potential problem might be hesitant to halt the procedure when the surgeon is ready to start. But with a checklist the surgeon must get explicit permission to begin from the nurse who is performing the checklist. [0] https://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right/dp/0312430000 https://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right/...
- rb808 8y agoI'm not convinced about using a lot of checklists. I have no doubt when checklists first come in everyone follows them and there are some measurable improvements. The problem I have twofold. A few years down the road will people still really follow the checklists religiously, or quickly just fill out the boxes. The second part is people's jobs get dumbed down by this, I'm sure we've been in some situation where there is a structured system which you have no control, you just fill out forms, its disempowering so you learn not to think, just do your part of the system and hope it turns out OK. Its where bureaucracy and red tape starts. I've quit jobs like that because I found it demoralizing. Will be interesting if there was a follow up 5 years later. EDIT: Didn't you get the memo about your TPS reports? That is what I'm trying to avoid.
- tonfa 8y agoThe checklist was given elsewhere in the thread: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/9789241598590_eng_Checklist.pdf https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/97892... it really doesn't strike me as something that dumbs down the job...
- wccrawford 8y ago"dumbs down" is such a loaded phrase, but I'd argue that it's accurate here and most other places it's used. Anything that makes something easier is dumbing it down. However, I want it "dumbed down". I want it to be easier to prevent mistakes. I want smart people to use more of their brainpower on things that can't be solved by some words and boxes on paper. If the surgeon is thinking about the surgery instead of what he might have forgotten about the pre-op, that's good, IMO.
- rb808 8y ago> If the surgeon is thinking about the surgery instead of what he might have forgotten about the pre-op, that's good, IMO. Agreed. The only issue is that if the surgeon isn't thinking about the surgery because he's still doing all the routine paperwork.
- 8y ago
- thinkcontext 8y agoThe article (really a blurb) mentions Atul Gawande, he's written extensively and accessibly on how to improve healthcare both cost and quality. I can't recommend his writing enough, especially his New Yorker articles where he tackles subjects like unnecessary care, electronic health records, doctor training, etc. Article on checklists in the New Yorker https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/12/10/the-checklist
- dosy 8y agoHere's the actual 19-point checklist in English[0, pdf] and other languages[1] [0]: https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/9789241598590_eng_Checklist.pdf;jsessionid=8AD52FAEB1F160A0AE7503FE60E01E0C?sequence=2 https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/97892... [1]: https://www.who.int/patientsafety/topics/safe-surgery/checklist/en/ https://www.who.int/patientsafety/topics/safe-surgery/checkl...
- quizme2000 8y ago"The Checklist Manifesto" by Dr Atul Gawande details how resistant to change Medical Professionals can be to procedure. I thought it was hyperbole until I sat in on a certification training for a hospital group and the toxic cloud of chatter about not changing anything because it didn't make a difference was jaw-dropping.
- LeonM 8y agoMy former roommate is a pilot. When I first met him, I noticed that he uses checklists for just about everything, even the most basic everyday tasks. After some time, I decided to apply that same mentality to my own life. Both in private and work situations. I get it now. Checklists reduce cognitive load tremendously well, even for basic tasks. As an example: I have a checklist for when I need to travel, it contains stuff like what to pack, asking someone to feed my cat, check windows are closed, dishwasher empty, heating turned down, etc. Before the checklist, I would always be worried I forgot something, now I can relax. Also, checklists are a great way to improve processes. Basically a way to debug your life. For instance: I once forgot to empty the trash bin before a long trip, I added that to my checklist and haven't had a smelly surprise ever since ;)
- hinkley 8y agoI spend a lot of time getting checklists together at work, mostly for other people, and then ruthlessly removing extraneous items from the list (usually by fixing unreliable things that are of the sort: step 5: Do X. step 6: double check that step 5 actually happened) I get lots of credit for the former, but maybe one in five people see the latter as the bigger contribution. We end up having to deal with things when we are tired. You have to make them so an idiot can do them, because some day you will be that idiot. All day exhausting meeting followed by a major emergency. Kid up half the night with a fever. New video game just came out. Bad dreams, whatever.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI would likely forget something if I didn't have a travel checklist. Something I keep in my Evernote notebook called, wait for it, checklists :-) They are especially handy when on multi-stop travel where I'm spending all my time worrying about the logistics of the travel and meetings. It has definitely saved me from losing a number of phone chargers and razors over the years.
- andersonvaz 8y agoWhy care if dishwasher is empty?
- grigjd3 8y ago
- samstave 8y agoThe "checklist manifesto" is a staple in American Healthcare... And when I was consulting on hospital builds and go-live... this was the methodology we used. https://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right-ebook/dp/B0030V0PEW https://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right-...
- turc1656 8y agoThe article is short so doesn't really delve into what happens after those deaths - specifically investigation into cause or the legal ramifications. I was hoping to get that info because the first thing that popped into my mind was that people are/were apparently dying due to unnecessary reasons if a simple checklist prevents 37% of surgical deaths. If that's the case, the only way I could imagine classifying those deaths would be "gross negligence" and therefore not subject to the protections of the legal agreements you sign before surgery.
- DanBC 8y agoI can't talk about Scotland because they have a devolved system and I have no idea how it works up there. I can talk a little bit about England. There are two main ALBs (arms length bodies) that will be involved: NHS Resoulation (the organisation that handles legal cases) and NHS Improvement (the organisation that handles QI work). NHS England and NHS Improvement are merging and I don't know what the new name will be. NHS Resolution used to be called NHS Litigation Authority. https://resolution.nhs.uk/ https://resolution.nhs.uk/ https://improvement.nhs.uk/ https://improvement.nhs.uk/ The information that NHSi has about "Just Culture" is here: https://improvement.nhs.uk/resources/just-culture-guide/ https://improvement.nhs.uk/resources/just-culture-guide/ If you have a look at this flow-chart you can see that they're trying to find out if an incident that caused harm was deliberate, grossly negligent, caused by wider system failings, etc. https://improvement.nhs.uk/documents/2490/NHS_0690_IC_A5_web_version.pdf https://improvement.nhs.uk/documents/2490/NHS_0690_IC_A5_web... If you have a look at NHS Resolution's page about learning from harm you can see that they're keen for healthcare professionals to 1) Say sorry, 2) explain in full what went wrong 3) Explain how that's going to be prevented in future. https://resolution.nhs.uk/services/safety-and-learning/ https://resolution.nhs.uk/services/safety-and-learning/ This expands upon a legal duty of HCPs and NHS Trusts in England: the Duty of Candour. Here's the advice for doctors: https://www.gmc-uk.org/ethical-guidance/ethical-guidance-for-doctors/candour---openness-and-honesty-when-things-go-wrong/the-professional-duty-of-candour https://www.gmc-uk.org/ethical-guidance/ethical-guidance-for... And nurses: https://www.nmc.org.uk/standards/guidance/the-professional-duty-of-candour/read-the-professional-duty-of-candour/ https://www.nmc.org.uk/standards/guidance/the-professional-d... And other registered healthcare professionals: https://www.hcpc-uk.org/assets/documents/10003f72enc07-dutyofcandour.pdf https://www.hcpc-uk.org/assets/documents/10003f72enc07-dutyo... And organisations: https://www.cqc.org.uk/guidance-providers/regulations-enforcement/regulation-20-duty-candour https://www.cqc.org.uk/guidance-providers/regulations-enforc... If a patient does decide to sue I think they can only recoup their actual losses. I think we don't have punitive damages in England.
- stefs 8y agowhile i don't contest the usefulnes of checklists ... "... some of the largest population-wide reductions in surgical deaths ..." _reductions_. but how does it compare using absolute rates? it's usually easy to achieve good numbers when the baseline is sub-par (diminishing returns).
- projektfu 8y agoOne of the issues I've seen in implementing checklists is actually the urge of people to put extreme detail into the checklist and people not putting items in a reasonable order. If you look at the referenced checklist (https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/9789241598590_eng_Checklist.pdf https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/44186/97892...) it is a very approachable list that acknowledges good skill in the people involved. Note that the "before patient leaves" checklist mentions the sponge count but the pre-incision checklist does not. That's because a sponge count is simply part of the job of an instrument nurse and something they always do when they open a pack of sponges. It's also hard to insert checklists into established procedures. One thing you could do is attach them to important parts that are not allowed to be used until you read the checklist. For example, you could refuse to unwrap the main surgical pack until the pre-incision checklist is followed. Pharmacy could wrap the anesthetic induction drug in the first checklist. The surgeon could be responsible for signing the final checklist in order to get paid. Keep checklists simple, use them every time. Put them in places where they have to be used.
- specialist 8y agoWise cautionary note. Use the right tool for the job. Back when we used to burn "golden" CD-ROMs for releases: Our checklists were getting too unwieldy, we were still making mistakes. So I started a Go/NoGo process, aka Roman Evaluation. Any one could stop the release for any reason. We'd fix the problem(s) identified, try again the next day. (Of course, we fed each release's results back into process during the post mortems.)
- skwb 8y agoSounds more like TPS model.. "Build a culture of stopping to fix problems, to get quality right from the start. (Jidoka)" [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Production_System https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Production_System]
- pradn 8y agoI haven't heard of the term "Roman Evaluation". Where does it come from?
- agumonkey 8y ago2019, age of AI/ML .. checklist is the most impactful health improvement. Interesting
- mmaunder 8y agoDoes this include the new(ish) timeout procedure? Docs and nurses will take a beat before surgery to say the patients name, what the procedure is and I think one or two other very basic things. This has been done for a few years now in the USA and I find it fascinating. So basic in such a sophisticated space and I have heard it has had a profound impact on patient safety. Any surgical staff around to tell us more?
- DanBC 8y agoI'm not surgical staff. The checklist does include this discussion phase. Here's the English version: https://improvement.nhs.uk/documents/450/SFHFT_-_Invasive_Procedure_Policy_-_Appendix_A_-_Surgical_Safety_Checklist.pdf https://improvement.nhs.uk/documents/450/SFHFT_-_Invasive_Pr...
- qubyte 8y agoA few others have mentioned it, but this reminds me of shisa kanko, the pointing-and-calling system used in Japan. https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/pointing-and-calling-japan-trains https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/pointing-and-calling-j...
- docker_up 8y agoDoesn't this indicate some sort of malpractice in Scotland? I would think that forgetting important procedures leading to death is the definition of malpractice.
- DanBC 8y agoThe English NHS was dealing with about one million patients every 36 hours. https://www.england.nhs.uk/ https://www.england.nhs.uk/ They were doing over 8 million surgeries per year when the checklist was introduced. For 2016/2017 the summary of "never events" is here: https://improvement.nhs.uk/documents/2347/Never_Events_1_April_2016_-_31_March_2017_FINAL_v2.pdf https://improvement.nhs.uk/documents/2347/Never_Events_1_Apr... There were 189 wrong site surgeries, and 114 retained foreign object post surgery. That's not good enough, but it's not terrible. The month by month data is here: https://improvement.nhs.uk/resources/never-events-data/ https://improvement.nhs.uk/resources/never-events-data/ I have a comment about the regulatory framework (in England) here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19683366 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19683366
- matthewmacleod 8y agoI'm not really sure what your point is. Ultimately, any kind of negligent behaviour would be "malpractice", but that's not something that can be completely eliminated. Mistakes always happen, regardless of care or attention paid; it seems like the focus should be to develop systems which can minimise their occurrence, minimise the severity of them if they do occur, and help to provide information that can reduce recurrence. I find the approach of things like rail and air accident investigations to be really useful. The goal for the investigation of any accident should not be about apportioning blame, but understanding why accidents happen and how their occurrence can be effectively reduced or eliminated.
- rmmm 8y agoFreakonomics Radio had Dr. Atul Gawande on a year ago (April 2018) and discussed medical checklists among other things. http://freakonomics.com/podcast/atul-gawande/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/atul-gawande/
- drumttocs8 8y agoThat's terrifying. Thousands and thousands of lives have been lost simply because we were forgetting to do the right things? And we created a process to fix this in... 2019?
- DanBC 8y agoThe process was introduced in 2008. This news is that we've now run research across an entire country (Scotland) for the surgery carried out between 2000 to 2012 to find out how much harm has been prevented.
- ggregoire 8y agoNot sure why people don’t do checklists for everything. Professionally and personally.
- tvchurch 8y agoThis makes me think of Charlie Munger's insistence on checklists: https://www.amazon.com/Poor-Charlies-Almanack-Charles-Expanded/dp/1578645018/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=Poor+Charlie%27s+Almanac&qid=1555515945&s=gateway&sr=8-1 https://www.amazon.com/Poor-Charlies-Almanack-Charles-Expand...
- barking 8y agoThis is how fast food franchises work and is why you get a consistent experience from them all. All the processes are documented and checklists abound.
- macspoofing 8y agoChecklists are the foundation of a proper quality system even in software development. I manage a team of programmers that develops a regulated product in healthcare (Class 2 Medical Device) - we use checklists extensively throughout the development cycle, in release planning, release kick-off, feature kick-off, in design reviews, in risk/hazard meetings, to track in-house and external validation, and post-release activities. I'm surprised how little checklists are used in software development. In our application, checklists track even simple things. Suppose you're adding some new feature we have a checklist that tracks related activities such as: - Does it need a toolbar button? - Does it need a keyboard/mouse input biding? - If so did you add a keyboard binding to the default configuration list? - If so did you add the binding information to the user help file. - Should it be exposed in Mobile Native App? - Should it be exposed in Mobile HTML App? - Should it be exposed in HTML App? - Was the button label localized? - Was the identifier added to the toolbar mask list? - Does it need to be added to the context menu list? - Does the behaviour need to work with Reset? - Does the behaviour needs to work in a collaborative session? - Does the button need a feature flag? etc. It's a quick list that we can get through during feature kick-off before unpacking commercial requirements and starting a sprint and during final validation to make sure al the i's are dotted and t's crossed.
- skorbenko 8y agoAtul Gawande wrote a fantastic book[0] on the topic. [0]: https://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right-ebook/dp/B0030V0PEW/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=checklist+manifesto&qid=1555516277&s=gateway&sr=8-1 https://www.amazon.com/Checklist-Manifesto-How-Things-Right-...
- ausbah 8y agocan anyone comment about applying this "checklist process" to software development? has anyone used it to help with debugging, testing, merging, etc.?
- insertnickname 8y agoAutomated tests are a checklist for when you refactor code: "The code is supposed to do A, B, and C. Does it still do those things?" If you practice TDD, the tests are just-in-time checklists for your implementation work. The problem with relying on tests written after the implementation is that the checklist might be incomplete. If your checklist is incomplete, then you can't rely on it. Of course, even a highly disciplined practitioner of TDD cannot produce a test suite that is guaranteed to be complete and correct, but there is an enormous difference between a checklist that is adequate 50 % of the time and one that is adequate 95 % of the time. Look for ways to avoid simply "going through the motions". Checklists (including TDD) are about avoiding making mistakes, not merely about noticing when you do make mistakes.
- CGamesPlay 8y agoI've used it in situations where writing automated tests would have been too difficult compared to running through a checklist each time. I made a web game based on a variant of Chess, and I would run through the checklist before I committed to verify I hadn't broken anything. https://gist.github.com/CGamesPlay/1b3e150c5448c51fd6ea71ea684f5640 https://gist.github.com/CGamesPlay/1b3e150c5448c51fd6ea71ea6...
- edpichler 8y agoFor people interested in this, I strongly recommend reading the Checklist Manifesto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Checklist_Manifesto https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Checklist_Manifesto A checklist is a practical tool to document processes.
- kentosi 8y agoI love prepared checklists! It's the ultimate productivity hack for me. I spend time upfront preparing the list, and then I go into auto-pilot everytime I use it. No stress, no cognitive load, no questioning whether you've forgotten something. I use one for travel (did I pack a neck pillow?), night-time (did I pack my gym clothes for tomorrow?), and recently for the gym (what workouts am I doing today?)
- gfiorav 8y agoI'm an aviation enthusiast and have started developing check-list for maintainers of the software I develop at work. I hope it will reduce cognitive stress in situations of on-call.
- pithymaxim 8y agoChecklists are probably good but looking at the actual paper[0] I don't think we can conclude "a third" with much confidence. The mortality rate for surgeries was already declining--the argument is that it declined faster during the implementation period (Fig 2; 2008-2010). Also it appears the types of admissions changed a lot during the same period based on the stark difference between Fig 1 (unadjusted) and Fig 2 (adjusted). I'm surprised that the researchers didn't use better data or variation (e.g., hospital-level mortality or the timing of the rollout) to strengthen the case. So much can be lurking beneath annual country averages... [0]: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/bjs.11151 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/bjs.11151
- jpollock 8y agoGiven the number of surgeries/year in Scotland (2009/2010 20,048) [1] the checklist saved: Death rate after fix: 0.46% Number of deaths after:93 Death rate before fix: 0.46/(1-0.37) = 0.73% Number of deaths before: 147 Number of lives saved per year: 54. [1] https://academic.oup.com/bja/article/119/2/249/4049141 https://academic.oup.com/bja/article/119/2/249/4049141
- anderspitman 8y agoI've seen a huge personal impact adopting principles from David Allen's Getting Things Done methodology, which in some ways is simply a checklist management system. As others have mentioned, it's not just preventing me from forgetting to do things. Capturing my thoughts and intentions externally reduces stress and frees my mind to have more new thoughts. My creativity has skyrocketed since I started writing down every project/product idea I have, and adding to them over time. Currently using Trello (which works great for this), but eventually I'd like to switch to something open source or make my own system tailored to my needs.
- indiandennis 8y agoI used to use trello too, but I switched to notion, which is more free-form and let's you organize things how you want. Sounds like what you might be looking for.
- anderspitman 8y agoI've seen it mentioned. I'll take a look, thanks
- monocasa 8y agoGoing one step further, the Japanese train industry has a concept called "pointing and calling" where they literally point at the thing that should be complete and call out the task. It noticeably improves completion of these tasks. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pointing_and_calling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pointing_and_calling
- bch 8y agorelated early paper: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa0810119 https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa0810119
- tedmcory77 8y agoDr. Gawande’s book “The Checklist Manifesto” can be life changing if properly applied.
- WordSkill 8y agoI lived in Scotland for a decade or so. On the surface, the provision of healthcare seemed good, and the media constantly tells you it is, but it tended to fall apart once you needed it for anything serious. I heard of the experiences from countless others and, sadly, encountered it myself. As the patient, even though you are paying for the service through high taxes, you are not seen as the customer. This leads to a certain sense, when you do need a medical service, that they are doing you a favor, that you are somehow the recipient of charity and should be grateful for what you get. Decisions about what medicines or treatments are available are often political, with certain high-profile conditions sucking up scarce resources at the expense of others. The focus is very much on managing public opinion. There are many situations in which cost considerations have a horrific impact on lives. For instance, if there is a medicine which can prevent you losing your sight, but it is expensive, you will be offered it only for your second eye after you have lost sight in your first - the reasoning being that it is only worth spending that much money to prevent total blindness, but sight in one eye is enough. If you think that your high taxes mean that your healthcare needs are covered, think again. There is also a deep-rooted coverup culture that circles the wagons around bad doctors and poor processes. In my case, a ridiculous misdiagnosis had a real impact on my life for over a year. The other healthcare professional only came clean about it after the lead doctor had retired. Again, you are not seen as the customer, as the one paying all their wages, so, you should just shut up and be grateful for what you get. I often laugh when I hear inexperienced American talk about how much better the health system is in the UK. Sure, health insurance is expensive, but the actual healthcare is leagues ahead of anything available via any sort of national health service. Being recognized as the customer, with real rights, is of pivotal importance in receiving the care you need, when you need it. In fact, you often come across UK citizens with a rose-tinted view of the National Health Service, but such opinions tend to change rapidly once you actually need something more than an occasional General Practitioners appointment. The whole thing is a cruel joke.
- DanBC 8y ago> I often laugh when I hear inexperienced American talk about how much better the health system is in the UK. Sure, health insurance is expensive, but the actual healthcare is leagues ahead of anything available via any sort of national health service Exactly the same private healthcare is available to you in Scotland, if you chose to pay for it.
- cs02rm0 8y agoThe checklist seems to be here: https://www.who.int/patientsafety/topics/safe-surgery/checklist/en/ https://www.who.int/patientsafety/topics/safe-surgery/checkl... As a software engineer, I'd hope this was done in software, where it could be trivially filled in by multiple people, checked across the organisation, not go missing or get drinks spilled on, etc. Knowing the NHS south of the border, I assume it's not.
- fiftyacorn 8y agoPapers probably easier - these NHS software projects always end up disasters
- Gpetrium 8y agoIt would be interesting to see the implementation of an Alexa/Google' smart speaker & tablet system to provide support to doctors & nurses. For example: Doctor - "Smith, please provide checklist for Septal Myectomy" Smith - "Confirming list for Septal Myectomy?" Doctor - "Yes" (Smith raises first point) Doctor -"Check" (Smith raises other points until the end of the list) Smith - "You have completed the checklist for Septal Myectomy, please review it on the screen if you so desire. Is there anything I can help you with?" Doctor - "Thanks Smith, no need for anything else" I would be eager to support a project that would provide this kind of support to doctors and other professionals.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoChecklists are great; checklist bureaucracy not so much. Sometimes such bureaucracy is necessary. For example when you are flying a cesnna 172 from the nineteen sixties, you are basically flying a glorified lawn mower. It has procedures for starting up. Not following those will lead to disasters like your engine quitting, or worse self destroying. Hence a lot of checklists in aviation tend to be about engine management. These are important, they keep you alive and save you from high maintenance cost and accidents. Cars used to be similarly complicated but these days you simply turn them on and drive. Likewise, checklists for modern airplanes that have elaborate engine management software tend to be a lot shorter and also focus more on other things (check the amount of fuel). Checklist are easy to automate for a lot of use cases and doing so increases safety because computers are a lot better at checking lots of things than we are. After checklists become part of your process and increase your effectiveness, automating them can increase your efficiency. The analogy in software engineering is replacing release processes with CI and CD. It used to be that people were enduring such things as commit freezes, meetings about blocking issues, go/no-go decisions, etc. This could last for weeks or months. Also the process of actually creating release artifacts and publishing those was a lot of work. These days, some systems release whenever a change is merged to a particular branch. All the checks around this are automated (tests pass). The entire process of releasing can be automated.
- cynoclast 8y agoNASA engineers have been trying to tell doctors this for decades. What's brain surgery to a rocket scientist?
- heroHACK17 8y ago'wE mOVe FaSt AnD bReAk THingS'