19 ms·
The Urgent Quest for Slower, Better News
- tvanantwerp 8y agoThere are so many interesting, rich, deep topics to study that I just don't have much interest in news anymore. It's so bite-sized, barely informative, and usually of no practical or emotional value. A great deal of our desire to "be informed" would be better served avoiding the news altogether, finding substantial things to focus on.
- etep 8y agoI have a theory that news occurs with a far lower frequency than people think, far lower than even when people try to account for their knowledge of the 24 hr. news cycle. In my theory, most of what counts for news, is either a story update (737 Max stories), or not news (say Trump "news"). My hypothetical news organization would strive to identify the unifying element of a given news item, and then keep one article about them. The article would include the following elements: a summary, a timeline, a fact set, and a commentary or critique. All subsections would be allowed to evolve, but the "story" would be one thing. I've considered trying to self fund this somehow, but I've never convinced myself that it would really get traction.
- asteli 8y agoHave you seen Wikipedia's current events portal? [1] It's pretty much what you describe there, sans critique (level 1, factual reporting). In trying to escape the aggregators and filter bubbles, I have blocked all news sources on my phone (including HN!) save for Wikipedia. Since the stories are only high-priority and slowly evolving, I spend a lot less time on reading news, and am happier for it. [1]: (For convenience) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Current_events https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portal:Current_events
- etep 8y agoWasn't aware of it, will try it - thank you!
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- max76 8y agoI'd pay a approximately $10 monthly fee for this if it was minimally biased and had wide coverage of all news stories. I'm unsure if enough people would to become profitable, but some market exists. For some long running stories that I only tune into occasionally, such as the Muller Investigation, I do not have enough context to fully understand the newest headlines. The only place where full comprehensive coverage will be in one place is in a book, and while I often buy books of that genera it will not be released until after the topic is concluded. This seems to be a one-stop-shop for everything about a news topic. I think you'll have more success if you find a niche to start with. Maybe US National Politics & Economics, which covers your two examples. Finding your zone and sticking to it can separate you from the mainstream news which follows hype much better than a startup organization can. I think this type of project is a great candidate for Crowd Funding. Crowd Funding can give positive reinforcement for a product/market fit and to help attract journalism talent.
- felixyz 8y agoI would pay for something that let me keep up with actual news, with a time lag that allowed me to get a more stable picture after the first flurry of opinions and overselling had exhausted most of its energy.
- jimbokun 8y ago"I have a theory that news occurs with a far lower frequency than people think, far lower than even when people try to account for their knowledge of the 24 hr. news cycle." I gave up Reddit for Lent, and I've been shocked how little news actually happens in a day. I compulsively check Apple News (I know, baby steps), but without all of the Reddit commentary, wise cracks, trolling, and mutually reinforcing outrage, it all just seems very repetitive. "Yep, Barr still hasn't released the Mueller report." "No, the House still doesn't have Trump's tax returns." "Candidate X is too progressive/too moderate/too male/too old/too young to be the Democratic nominee, even though it's still almost a year before any Democrats can vote on them." "Still no trade agreement with China." "Trump makes hyperbolic claims about an action he might take, but doesn't actually take any action." That seems to be the daily news summary every day for the past few weeks.
- tomohawk 8y agoFrom the guys who are STILL flogging the Trump collusion fake news...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Animats 8y agoThat's what the Economist is for.
- the_secretary 8y agoAs a counter indicator?
- starpilot 8y agoOr the FT.
- dionian 8y agoall of those sources parroted the Russia conspiracy hoax without question didn't they
- chlvsl 8y agoFT is much better. The Economist has grown worse over the past several years.
- sterban 8y agoI have loved Economist, The Intelligence podcast everyday. 20 minutes covering 3 topics with experts.
- dangravell 8y agoThe Economist is good, but I find it still a little too frequent for me, especially considering it costs about £5 a week. This for me is a little too much for something I probably won't get through every week. I tend to just buy it when I go on holiday when I know I have the time to get through it. I'd prefer a digest version once a month, the same size as the weekly version, with "more important" news and the same cost.
- clydethefrog 8y agoLe Monde Diplomatique is a monthly newspaper that focuses on international reporting. I find their reporting very good, although they are outspoken about their leftist position (just as the Economist is outspoken liberal). https://mondediplo.com/about https://mondediplo.com/about
- sorenn111 8y agoAmen, faster and more frequent news is certainly broken. However, I worry that we are fighting against human nature. The use of smartphones has demonstrated, I believe, that people will blindly chase their dopamine hits coming from a variety of formats because it is ingrained in human nature. The dopamine reward pathway gives a good feeling and people are naturally inclined to follow the path of least resistance to more hits. If an organization or app tries to fight this, then people will simply use it less. People will naturally gravitate towards (thus pushing the market towards) easy methods of getting a little dopamine rush. The consumption of fast and frequent journalism is just a symptom of human nature and I have my doubts that there will be a unilateral disarmament by apps and companies to use such tools. I personally try to recognize this and cut myself short when i keep scrolling, keep refreshing on my phone, etc. However, I am not that good at stopping myself and I am aware of when I do it and work on it. What about people who are unaware of their habits? Looking down at your phone and refreshing likely has become second nature for billions of people. How can industries fight against this human nature? (I did not cite any sources I know, if I'm dead wrong on any points please let me know!)
- gnud 8y agoThis is really not a new fight. It used to be tabloids vs "real" news - I'm not sure how different today's online battle is. Except for some reason, most of the "real" news are becoming tabloids when moving online.
- currymj 8y agoIt may be that now editors and journalists get instant feedback about number of clicks, shares, ad impressions and so on, so that they can chase dopamine hits just as much as the audience can.
- hhs 8y agoInteresting view. With respect to the news industry: the TV format seems to have evolved. Have you seen HBO's Last Week Tonight? In a half-hour, John Oliver (and his writing team) recap the key news in 5-6 minutes and then finish by investigating one topic in depth. That is quite a model. It looks like shows similar to this are being made now, such as Netflix's Patriot Act. But the print industry hasn't changed much. I wonder how they will evolve?
- thewordis 8y agoI subscribed to Delayed Gratification quarterly for this purpose. https://www.slow-journalism.com/ https://www.slow-journalism.com/
- sevensor 8y agoThis is the first I've heard of Delayed Gratification. That's a hefty subscription price -- is that their main source of revenue?
- thewordis 8y agoIt appears they get their money from subscriptions, yes. There aren't any ads in the magazine. They also do some classes on how to make infographics and write articles.
- leoh 8y agoIs it that hefty? I'm seeing a price of 55 GBP for the US.
- sevensor 8y agoWorks out to almost $20 per issue for a quarterly. So it's a lot more per issue than Time. Not saying it's not worth it. (Time is for dentists' offices and bird cages.) My comment about cost isn't a gripe, just an observation about their business model. It takes real belief in your product to charge that much for writing, when we're so used to getting it for free.
- notacoward 8y agoReading the print version of a newspaper isn't going to help, because they're just as guilty as anyone of putting up repetitions and very minor updates of the same few stories instead of actual, y'know, new things that have happened. Just look at what's on the NYT front page right now. * "The Border Is Broken. And There's No Plan To Fix it." Yawn. This has been in heavy rotation for weeks. Also, poor grammar. * "Black Hole Image Revealed for First Time Ever" Super cool, but after the first thirty stories I saw about this I'd like to hear about some other scientific advance. * "William Barr Testimony Highlights: Attorney General Says He Thinks ‘Spying Did Occur’ on Trump Campaign Video" Also on heavy rotation for days now. * "Israel Election Live Updates: As Gantz Concedes, Netanyahu Set for Victory" OK, one out of four so far. You get the idea. Google News is even worse. * Trump urges inquiry into 'attempted coup' against him * Israel Election: Netanyahu Appears Headed For Win In Close Race * IRS commissioner "working on letter" in response to request for Trump tax returns * Police investigating death of 20-year-old college student who collapsed at Hilton Head Island off-campus party * The E.U. Seems Ready to Put Brexit on Ice. But for How Long? * How Stephen Miller tightened his grip over Trump's immigration and border policy Those are almost all retreads, again excepting the Israel election. Some are damn near duplicates of each other. It's as though even the most "modern" news sources are still stuck on one new headline per day. Every morning when I check in, there's 90% overlap with the previous day. We're not being overwhelmed with news; we're being overwhelmed with olds. My own urgent quest is not for news that's slower or better according to some arbitrary notion of quality. I'll judge that for myself. All I ask is for news that's news.
- openasocket 8y ago> "The Border Is Broken. And There's No Plan To Fix it." Yawn. This has been in heavy rotation for weeks. Also, poor grammar. That's a long form article about a variety of issues with the immigration system, from immigration courts to how migrants are detained. It's very informative. I read a lot on the subject and I found more than a few facts in here that I wasn't aware of. > "William Barr Testimony Highlights: Attorney General Says He Thinks ‘Spying Did Occur’ on Trump Campaign Video" Also on heavy rotation for days now. How has that been reported "for days now"? That quote is literally from his testimony earlier today. > "Black Hole Image Revealed for First Time Ever" Super cool, but after the first thirty stories I saw about this I'd like to hear about some other scientific advance. But it's not like the NYT has 30 stories about this, the fact that we have a lot of different news sources isn't a bad thing. Though you do have a point about a lack of scientific reporting
- steelframe 8y agoI stopped reading the news about a year ago. I felt like my emotions were being manipulated by a sharply-honed system built precisely to invoke outrage and draw you in to read more and more of it. I've been able to direct my focus and energy to much more productive tasks since I disconnected. Of course I entirely missed that whole Supreme Court thing until after it was over, and I have no idea what people around me are talking about when they discuss some iteration of the most recent outrage. To some extent it's like they're living in a different culture than I am. I still feel that it was a good decision, and I continue to ignore the news. I might come back if enough journalism sources can take the New Yorker's suggestion to heart.
- clay_the_ripper 8y agoDid the same thing about 4 years ago and haven’t looked back. I find though that a lot of people are actually offended by it since I have no clue what thing they and everyone else is outraged about. I get accused of not caring, being disengaged, blah blah blah. It’s difficult to explain to people who are still deep in outrage mode, so I mostly avoid taking about it. My life is so much better since cutting out the news. I am happier, more focused and able to actually concentrate on the things that I care about. I prefer to think about how I can positively impact people around me and my local community, rather than embracing the culture of outrage about things happening thousands of miles away that are ultimately irrelevant.
- irq 8y agoHonest question, how do you turn off your empathy for the suffering of your fellow countrymen? Which is what ignoring their plight would require (at least, it would for me).
- narrator 8y agoThere is a lot of bad stuff going on all over all the time. Focus is what's important. There are billions of people on this earth. You could cry at hundreds of stories every day if they were told in great enough detail. Those stories could be embellished or made up, paid for by someone with an agenda to promote and you wouldn't know the difference. Save your outrage for things you have first hand knowledge of or knowledge of through trusted contacts. The world did ok before 24/7 news, so it's not like you, king of the world, need to be up to the minute informed on whatever thing you're supposed to take your outrage vengence upon today.
- truebosko 8y agoI stopped using Twitter to help slow down my news consumption. Then I found I was reading the same thing each day on the front page of NYTimes, Guardian, my local papers (Toronto) Now I check every few days, but I adore the sub sections on NYTimes. Wether it be food, technology, science, opinion. All fun to read and "slower"
- alexmingoia 8y agoSkip the news entirely. What value does it add to your life? I’m happy reading blogs and periodicals with my RSS reader (feeder.co), which I check in the morning over coffee. I choose what’s in my feed, not some algorithm, advertiser, or news editor vying for clicks.
- chiefalchemist 8y agore: "Skip the news entirely. What value does it add to your life?" Yes and no. If it were, by definition, truly news then it would / could add value. The problem with the current media environment is what's passed off as news is in reality fake news. That is, it lacks relevance and importance. That's. Not. News.
- OJFord 8y agoDo you know if feeder.co supports mathjax/similar in rendering?
- chiefalchemist 8y agoActually, what we need first is: 1) A common and agreed upon standard definition of news. Facts alone are not news. News also has importance and relevance. It's not news simply because a (major) "news" outlet publishes it. I ate eggs for breakfast. That's truth / fact. It's not news. 2) A common and agreed upon standard definition of journalism / journalist. Again, working for a "news" outlet does not make you a journalist. Journalism is a verb. It's a series of actions. It's not a (self-anointed) title. 3) Transparency and full disclosure about what is news (objective) and what is op-ed (subjective). True story: I've seen a friend who has formal higher edu training in journalism (major'ed or minor'ed, I don't recall) take a (political) position on FB and then back up his "facts" with an op-ed piece. This isn't uncommon. Edit: Typos
- Zaphods 8y agoI'll take a stab: 1) News is an account (story) of an event. The degree with which it is "true" is the degree with which it holds the events to account, and the degree with which the news organization/publisher holds itself accountable for that account/story. Good news is accountable and provides accounts of events. "Truth" is the wrong focus; "fact" is far too malleable (hence the status-quo legitimacy of "alternative facts"); accountability is the goal. 2) A journalist is someone who writes accounts/stories for a news organization/publisher and, in turn, is held accountable (either professionally or legally) for their story. Anyone can be a journalist, but few are willing to hold themselves to the standards of accountability good journalism demands. 3) The division between news and op-ed is marked by the degree and nature of accountability. News organizations are accountable for the news. News organizations call for op-eds and those op-eds have a different standard of accountability. That's why we call them op-eds. If a news organization will not hold itself accountable for a story then it is an op-ed. We are far too focused on "truth" "fact" and "objective vs subjective". Instead we should focus on what the use of journalism and the news is. The use is accountability. And the special nature of news and journalism, what differentiates it from fiction and bullshit, is that it is also held to standards of accountability.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago1) Being an account of X isn't a high enough bar. 100% of what I see on "the news" is an account of something. The problem is, the line between TMZ and Fox or CNN is less defined. 2) " but few are willing to hold themselves to the standards of accountability good journalism demands." Well yeah. But it's because the dentition of journalism has become "anything done by self-proclaimed journalists." It's entirely self-serving. There is no higher standard. Mainly because the pot is afraid of calling the kettle black. 3) We might call them op-eds but plenty of "news" orgs are all too comfortable presenting their op-eds as news and/or journalism.
- tombert 8y agoI remember when Jon Stewart said years ago that the 24-hour news cycle is really designed for 9/11; for anything less than a catastrophic event like that, they have to manufacture problems. I think the worst offenders of this are Fox News, but it's not like CNN or MSNBC are blameless. Spending days talking about the latest typo on in the president's tweet ends up with a bizarre view of reality; even if you're not watching Alex Jones or Sean Hannity, there's this bizarre, us-against-them, almost-conspiratorial vibe to a lot of what's in the news. BTW, I'm hardly better; I used to check Donald Trump's Twitter daily as well, for almost two years.
- stcredzero 8y agoI think the worst offenders of this are Fox News, but it's not like CNN or MSNBC are blameless. I remember being disgusted at Fox News, especially during the WMD debacle. I was right there with Jon Stewart when he criticized it as "Faux News." Certainly, "it's not like CNN or MSNBC are blameless." In recent years, they've become every bit as bad. there's this bizarre, us-against-them, almost-conspiratorial vibe to a lot of what's in the news Start counting the subtle references to these. It's pretty much everywhere across mainstream news sources.
- tombert 8y agoI still don't think CNN or MSNBC are as bad as Fox News yet. Sean Hannity is basically Alex Jones-lite, and Tucker Carlson is pretty much completely disingenuous (and if you want to talk about us-versus-them, I recommend counting the number of times he says "elites" during his show). Plus, Fox and Friends is pretty much just an elaborate propaganda program for the president at this point. Even if you agree with Trump's policies (I don't), I cannot see how anyone could not see the blatent and purposeful right-wing propaganda of Fox.
- stcredzero 8y agoI cannot see how anyone could not see the blatant and purposeful right-wing propaganda of Fox. It's easiest to see propaganda, when the lies are about you/your side. To see how CNN or MSNBC fit Noam Chomsky's "propaganda model" you have to look at the times when they pushed narratives against the truth. To do that, you need to have some perspective outside the bubble around CNN and MSNBC, or be unlucky enough to have them push a lie or false narrative about you. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tkcd_MQgEL8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tkcd_MQgEL8
- iancmceachern 8y agoI've been thinking about this for a while, even pitched the following: Good news. News that makes the world better (aka journalism). Distilled deductive logical reasoning, observations and theories. Not gossip, gawking, envy, or mindless time sinks. For me this pragmatically works out to a combination of hackernews, hackaday, massdevice, arstechnica, atlasobscura, and podcasts/pbs/npr.
- _cs2017_ 8y agoThe article and the comments express the desire for news to be an effective tool to inform and educate the public. While appealing, this idea has never worked in the past, and there's no evidence that it can work in the near future. The reason is not that the media or the journalists do something wrong. Rather, the vast majority of the public is simply not interested in being educated or informed. You can send the best art / math / business professor to a school, but if the students are not interested in that field and have no need for a good grade, there will be very little learning done. The public is quite capable to take any information they are offered, and convert it to an argument in favor of their political or social beliefs; it is also very capable, when given a choice, to select the lowest quality information. It's unclear to me how anything can be done to counteract those tendencies. And as long as these tendencies stay in place, it seems rather futile to discuss "better news".
- matt4077 8y agoThis sort of cynic pessimism is getting out of hand... By most any measure, today's western democracies are the best place, and time in history, to be alive: life expectancy, crime, food availability, mobility. This is also true of education and "being informed", although those are harder to measure. But literacy rates, high school and advanced degree proliferation, books being published, and of course internet access should be decent proxies. That's not even including the vast improvements people who aren't white, able-bodied men have seen. Just ask around among women over 70 and you will find plenty who wanted to go to medical school and were stymied for whatever reason. My mother was told that, yes, she can matriculate. "But as long as I am professor, no woman will pass [some required class]"
- jjulius 8y agoNone of what you wrote addressed the point of the comment you were responding to, which is that it's hard get people to be informed about the news if they just don't care. I'm not arguing that what you said is inherently wrong, it just doesn't have anything to do with the question at hand. The OP wrote that, "You can send the best art / math / business professor to a school, but if the students are not interested in that field and have no need for a good grade, there will be very little learning done." Let's take that and combine it with the women going to medical school that you referenced. OP is suggesting that the women going to medical school might put all of their effort into the classes that directly pertain to their field. But if they need an elective class (let's say, some kind of art class, for instance), then they might go into that and put forth the lowest effort possible to achieve a passing grade if it doesn't interest them. OP's suggesting, and rightly so I believe, that the general populous does the same thing with politics. Those that care about it invest more time in reading about it, while those that don't care about it won't invest more time in reading about it and will typically choose the lowest-effort, easiest-to-digest sources of news. Going back to OP's original question, how to we counteract those tendencies?
- stcredzero 8y agohttps://quillette.com/ https://quillette.com/
- 52-6F-62 8y agoQuillette has proven to be of consistent poor quality, IMO. (and further, I've found it dishonest) Please note that it's founding and leadership team includes alumni of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rebel_Media https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rebel_Media. That latter outfit is not known for it's...veracity.
- stcredzero 8y agoQuillette has proven to be of consistent poor quality, IMO. (and further, I've found it dishonest) I've found them willing to take unpopular positions for the sake of truth. What have they done which is dishonest? https://quillette.com/2019/04/08/what-explains-the-resistance-to-evolutionary-psychology/ https://quillette.com/2019/04/08/what-explains-the-resistanc...
- fwip 8y agoBeing unpopular doesn't mean you're right. Looking up a few articles, it seems that they're just racists in lab coats.
- stcredzero 8y agoPlease provide a citation. As far as I can tell, you're just engaging in namecalling.
- PlasticTank 8y agoPretty much par for course these days, anyone who says something that offends me must be wrong. Before the truth will set you free, it'll piss you off.
- fwip 8y ago
- Razengan 8y agoAs in most things today, this will only improve if there is more money to be made by the improvement.
- TySchultz 8y agoI hear this same statement come up in conversation a lot more recently. A lot of us agree that the news seems broken, though every time I have this conversation we can never find a good solution to the problem. I had tried making a simple app to fix the problem. Simple NLP to group articles from different outlets. But I even find myself going back to the news feed and not using my own project. https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/keda-news/id1272869301?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/keda-news/id1272869301?mt=8
- sterban 8y agoThis was one of my goals in building https://statesreport.com https://statesreport.com. It won't necessarily be the first site to break news, but the goal is to provide better news based on NLP + ML classification.
- rb808 8y agoThe Lindy effect is a concept that Taleb talks a lot about. Basically the best estimate of how long anything perishable will remain useful is how long its been around already. ie the stuff that will remain useful in 10-50 years are the ideas/texts/plays/ideas that have been around a long time already. Recent news is likely worthless in an equally short time. So best to learn from centuries or millennia old books, rather than looking at twitter feed - or breaking news. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lindy_effect
- bubblewrap 8y agoThere is a problem, but sure as hell the New York Times isn't the solution.
- cleetus 8y agoThese links discuss "news diets" as a counter to the problem of news as low-quality information and/or information pollution: http://www.raptitude.com/2016/12/five-things-you-notice-when.. http://www.raptitude.com/2016/12/five-things-you-notice-when.... http://www.dobelli.com/en/essays/news-diet/ http://www.dobelli.com/en/essays/news-diet/ And here's a similar recent discussion on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19084099 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19084099
- f055 8y agoYour dobelli link is 404 :( anyway, this whole problem isn’t new but it’s very hard to solve. How to stay informed but not bloated? I don’t know... here they compare mainstream news to fast food so I guess that’s one way to look at it: https://thecontext.net/opinion/2017/04/4/the-post-truth-and-the-context.html https://thecontext.net/opinion/2017/04/4/the-post-truth-and-...
- gwern 8y agohttps://www.gwern.net/docs/culture/2010-dobelli.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/culture/2010-dobelli.pdf
- UI_at_80x24 8y agoI found I liked watching news after I got a police-scanner and could listen to things as they happened. Police/Fire/Ambulance scratched the itch of "what is going on right now" better then the news of 'What happened yesterday' that the media offered. It also had the added benefit of being LOCAL, when my local news mostly covered tidbits of national interest. I'd still tune-in to local radio to get the followup or fuller-details of an event.
- ljm 8y agoI've had several discussions about this and, as inhumane as it might sound...I'm not sure what value news has in its current form. I don't feel like I'm learning more about other humans, I'm just being spoon-fed a carefully crafted narrative. If the purpose of news is to disseminate useful information then it has failed. It's now about opinion, entertainment, advertising and maximising engagement (usually by getting people pissed off because misery loves company). There was a recent story in the UK about a young man from the North West who plotted to murder an MP, who also happened to be a paedophile and a white supremacist (according to reports). Most of the news is a dramatic retelling of how a young kid could get to that point so soon. Our national broadcaster, the BBC, gave him the gift of notoriety and I can't imagine what that has done to his ego except to say he was right. That isn't news, it's fetishising a burgeoning problem in our politics and titillating readers. Upskirting celebrities getting out of cars and getting sly bikini shots from a telescopic lens somehow has more priority over proper investigative journalism that can have a positive, legal outcome. In a more simplistic way, we revel in the pain of other people.
- jaabe 8y agoI subscribe to a paper that comes out each Friday, called weekendavisen. Until May last year it didn’t have news on the web, they do have an electronic paper now but I’ve never visited. It’s high quality news in lengthy articles, in fact I’m not even in its demographic because it has a lot of culture stuff as well and I don’t really care about that. I really like the fact that it’s relevant though. Because it only comes out on Fridays, only the stuff that actually mattered during the week makes it in there. If something big happens I’ll turn to internet public service, but otherwise I mostly ignore news outside of my weekly paper. I highly recommend it if you want to stay informed but cut the bullshit and have a similar option.
- p1itopre 8y agoI noticed some time ago that I do not learn more about a topic the more frequently I check on it (i.e., multiple times a day). So, I make it a point to only visit websites that update daily (e.g., https://www.nytimes.com/section/todayspaper https://www.nytimes.com/section/todayspaper) or weekly (https://asia.nikkei.com/Print-Edition https://asia.nikkei.com/Print-Edition). I also started to read news in the morning for 15-30 mins from a paper subscription (Financial Times). I hope this kind of news consumption catches back on.
- jdreyfuss 8y agoI like the idea of "slow news." I imagine my ideal state would be a combination of slow news and rapid fire updates. You get depth on the things that deserve depth, as well as a shallow horizontal understanding of the most current happenings across the board. From the reader side, the challenge would come in making the time for the slow news part when the rapid fire updates never stop, and in resisting the urge to equate seeing the rapid fire updates with actually being informed on the issues (i.e. "I don't need to read this in-depth look at the border situation; I've already seen a bunch of small updates on that"). From the publisher side, monetization is the ever-present issue
- rhizome 8y agoIt struck me today: are URLs the only kind of "viral" anybody considers to be good? I'm not talking about dormant viruses or symbiotes or whatever, but viruses in general seem to generally have been a problem for humans throughout history (or at least since their discovery).
- Accacin 8y agoI try and avoid the news whenever possible. Nothing good can come from it. I do however subscribe to a newspaper/magazine called 'Private Eye' that comes out fortnightly. Let's me catch up on the important news :)
- specialist 8y agoI would like a "fortnightly" version of HN, reddit, etc: Show me the popular stories from two weeks ago, after things have settled down. I really only want the conclusions vs the real time updates. It'd also help mitigate my compulsion to participate.
- noyesno 8y agoCheck out hackernewsletter.com. The only downside is that you will be too late to add your own comments.
- eaurouge 8y agoI see a number of comments celebrating the choice to live in a bubble uninformed and blissfully unaware of local and global events. Admittedly, a number of news sources are quite bad at actually reporting the news. But there still are quite a number of news organizations and news reporters that take their roles seriously. You can find them, that is if you are actually interested in being informed. I'm sure there's some virtue signalling going on here, similar to the "I don't watch TV" from years ago. It just strikes me as odd that people will gloat about their ignorance, on HN of all places.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoWhy don't you suggest some accurate news sources that have a net-positive effect on the reader's life and mood, rather than shaming?
- akvadrako 8y agoI think if you mentioned which organizations you actually thought were credible people would disagree. Personally I’m constantly looking for a decent news source but haven’t found any. I settle for multiple bad ones on different sides of the issues.
- asark 8y ago> I see a number of comments celebrating the choice to live in a bubble uninformed and blissfully unaware of local and global events. I'm pretty sure my being aware of local and global events, plus voting, plus demonstrating, plus organizing, plus god knows how much time arguing politics on the Internet has done... pretty much nothing at all. I've quit all of it (except the arguing on the Internet part, naturally). Almost none of the news is important, because it's not effectively actionable (for most people). It's fine if you like the news as entertainment. It's not fine to look down on people for not liking the entertainment you do. As for ignorance, if you want to be an informed voter/activist/whatever then very little of your information diet should be news. Most of it should be books.
- simonsarris 8y agoIt seems odd that you would call a lack of news reading ignorance. (What do you call a lack of fake news reading? How do you know what's fake news until the facts are borne out?) IMO if you want to be ignorant, read the news. If you want to be informed, read last week's or last year's news, which should cure one of a few delusions. If you want to learn something, perhaps read history instead.
- j-c-hewitt 8y agoI don't think it's that urgent because most people do not need to read most news. For people with particular responsibilities, it can be helpful to be up-to-date on the narrow field of news related to your responsibilities. For most people, there may only be a 5-10 relevant news events per year. The fact that you can access news from everywhere in the world instantaneously and at low monetary cost does not make it inherently useful, and if anything, it's likely to mislead you profoundly about your level of knowledge about the world and the stories that you are reading. Stories about plane crashes and mass earthquake deaths and things like that are mostly about titillation and encouraging a morbid fascination with death. It also discourages people from focusing on the things that they can control in their life. The press doesn't like to admit it, but a lot of the 'hard news' is just /r/watchpeopledie in a necktie.
- tareqak 8y agoDoesn’t slower, better news conflict with how news is primarily funded today i.e. advertising? Tabloid news has existed much longer than I’ve been alive, and their style (attention-grabbing, exaggerated titles) matches the kinds of ads they display. A newspaper on a slower circulation cycle would need to attract advertisers that market on similar cycle if the newspaper is dependent on ad revenue (e.g. month-long offers). A subscription-only / patron-only news service makes sense for the typical customer of a Bloomberg terminal, but what about everyone else? Do they just pay for headlines or three-sentence summaries? You might say that most people don’t need that frequency of news, and for most topics I would agree. However, there are topics like sports that create news on such a frequent basis, and topics like politics where one could argue that being accurately informed in a timely manner is a responsibility and a necessity for a well-functioning democracy. Tl;dr I don’t think you can separate the news from the manner in which it is funded, and the issues in quality and business-viability that we’ve heard a lot about is evidence for it.
- techbio 8y agoI want the best version, vetted and comprehensive, of all the news in the previous week. If it's breaking news, I want to have a single point reference of the current best information. This requires editors, that's it.
- n00bdude 8y agoNews that ain't fast is Yesterday's Paper We need better sources w/ the usual HQ Hacker News Scouts
- thoughtstheseus 8y agoA basic issue I find is the commentary. Give me facts and data, not commentary.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- makecheck 8y agoUnfortunately this is one of those things where if 99 media companies agree and one doesn’t, all the attention will go to the one that claims to have the latest “scoop”. The story will be completely undeveloped, half the stuff they say will eventually be proven wrong but they will get all the views. And therefore, gradually, the other 99 would follow suit to stay in business. As long as money/advertising is so lucrative when so much trash is funneled so quickly, this will be a problem. We pretty much have to find a way for companies to gain as much money some other way, e.g. “I’m a billionaire, I will give half a billion dollars to the station that wins a quality journalism award”. If you’re an individual and not a media company, waiting awhile for the full developed story is definitely better. Heck, waiting awhile and unplugging works for lots of things. For instance, if you can convince yourself to ignore a hot new TV show for a year (so that it’s “new to you” a year from now), it’ll probably be cheaper; and, you can benefit from average ratings and other info to tell you if the show/season turned out to be not worth watching at all.
- WheelsAtLarge 8y agoNews has been turned into an entertainment-sport where they make sure that there are always two opposing sides. It's manipulated by a few into giving you enough information to be outraged and inflamed but not informed. You can be on the right or the left it does not matter. What matters for the news business is that you get fed enough information so that you continue to watch and they make a profit. The heads of the news channels are ex-entertainment heads who make sure that people continue to watch by feeding people more outrage. The best thing people can do is stop reading and watching the news on a daily basis. Most of the news that is reported is useless since there is no substance to it and will disappear without any impact relatively fast. I believe that if it's important you'll hear about it eventually. "Slower better news" will never happen since it's not in the interest of the news business to create it. We have to be the ones that need to stop consuming it and figure out how to stay informed without being manipulated.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoHint: read American news from non-American sources, like BBC or better, German/French sources if you can handle the translation. Better yet: from Canada, i.e. the CBC. Then you see it from the outside, where narrators have less skin in the game, and it's all less click-baity.
- vanderZwan 8y agoSomewhat surprised that there is no mention of The Correspondent yet. The Dutch version has been quite successful for quite a few years now, and they're launching an international version later this year[0][1]. (Having said that, the authors of De Correspondent sometimes come across as oblivious to how their world views are shaped by living in the cultural bubble that is the Randstad[2]. There is a certain arrogance to the writing style that just makes it feel like the kind of thing that people living in Amsterdam would write, and it sometimes rubs me the wrong way. I guess that makes it the Dutch equivalent to the New Yorker.) [0] https://thecorrespondent.com/ https://thecorrespondent.com/ [1] https://decorrespondent.nl/ https://decorrespondent.nl/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randstad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Randstad
- bjelkeman-again 8y agoI am looking forward to their English language release. I supported the crowdfunded effort. My wife raves about the Dutch version. I hope the English one can live up to the expectations. Otherwise I tend to read the Economist, mostly on paper, to get a broad international analysis.
- sejtnjir 8y agoI subscribed to the Correspondent based on the proposition of in depth quality journalism until it decayed into long form leftist outcry and nothing else. I wonder if this type of decay is inevitable.
- vanderZwan 8y agoAs long as one remains oblivious to their own biases the rest of the world will appear to be wrong all the time.
- m0zg 8y agoNew Yorker should thoroughly retract the discredited "very fine people" hoax before suggesting that we need "better news". Apologizing to Trump and to their readers would be a responsible thing to do as well. https://www.google.com/search?newwindow=1&ei=jo-uXIS-Npj9-gTi_LzoDQ&q=new+yorker+trump+%22fine+people%22&oq=new+yorker+trump+%22fine+people%22 https://www.google.com/search?newwindow=1&ei=jo-uXIS-Npj9-gT...
- alehul 8y agoPersonally, I found it helpful to view information consumption like this: All information has a time horizon over which it is likely to be valuable. For some outrage news stories, it's just a few hours, while for more thoughtful political analyses, it's a year or two. Even if you read voraciously, if you're consuming information with a short time horizon of value, you're going to be facing a constant downward momentum of useful knowledge, as the information you know becomes outdated or irrelevant. Focus as much as you can on reading content that will be valuable for the foreseeable future, and you can avoid that downward momentum of information 'expiring'.
- musicale 8y agoMuch of internet news seems to follow the TV news model: lurid "breaking stories" interrupts and soundbites designed to capture your interest and trick you into watching advertising and vapid commentary. The important information is usually summarized quite adequately in a couple of headlines or sentences the next day, and it's usually easy to dig up more information if you really care.
- billfruit 8y agoI feel that journalists haven't shown enough self criticism on serious issues with how they operate like click-bait-ism, hyperbole-laden head line writing and the Gell-Mann amnesia. On the face of such and other issues I see them mostly on an defensive stance than that of any serious self introspection. It is rare to see even acceptance of these and other problems from them, let alone thought of any solutions. They need to get off their ivory towers, and be transparent about their own vulnerabilities.
- AFascistWorld 8y agoArticle spinner.
- hnuser355 8y agoI simply buy a weekly newspaper and read it. I’m always 1-1.5 weeks behind so I never feel as “emotional” or follow things that closely. I want a general feel for some of the things happening in the world and that is it
- balasan 8y agoWe are experience trust scarcity in online media because trust hasn't been part of social media's business model. By extension it stopped being part of the news publication's business model (everyone is forced to compete for clicks). That and because on the internet, nobody knows you're a dog. Ironically we are increasingly willing to get into stranger's cars and allow strangers stay at our homes because a few corporations like Uber and Airbnb were able to quantify, materialize and monetize trust. So it's not that much of a stretch to imagine an internet where trust plays a role in the way we distribute, consume and exchange information online. Hacker News is a case in point. Ready for the shill? We're building Relevant to make it easy to set up communities similar to HN, each with its own trust/reputation metric (based on personalized pagerank algorithm). So instead of using clicks / votes, all users and content get a trust/reputation score. The result is that rankings don't represent popularity, but relevance, resulting in better feeds and making communities easier to moderate. These trust metrics are much more resistant to sybil/sock-puppet attacks and can be used to build healthier business models, from prediction markets to advertising. https://relevant.community/relevant/top https://relevant.community/relevant/top
- blackflame7000 8y agoI think the issue is too much trust. Too many people believe that because a Network, Publication, Author, or Anchor published quality work in the past, therefore, they can be trusted to reliably deliver news in the future. People's sources, access, knowledge, agenda, and effort vary wildly and each story needs to be judged on its own merit.
- balasan 8y agoRight, so maybe scarcity of trustworthiness, or trust metrics/signals is more accurate. Plenty of popularity/click metrics, but how often do we really want to know what the masses think about complex nuanced topics?
- rkagerer 8y agoEvery day I visit Google News and Hacker News. I get a lot more joy out of the latter.
- kristianc 8y agoThe FT works well for me. I subscribe to both the FT and the Economist precisely because slow news is what they do. The FT tends to studiously avoid clickbait, avoid reporting every detail of 'this politician said that' and goes straight for the hard analysis of what it means.
- gumby 8y agoSlow news still exists, and always has. Weeklies and monthlies are low pass filters. In my teens I was an avid news reader and then I heard the aphorism "as worthless as yesterday's news" and I realized: if it won't be useful tomorrow I most likely don't need to know it today (obviously there are a few exceptions, like road closures). And I started to read news sources that reported with higher latency (CSM used to send its small, 7-page newspaper though the mail) and discovered I really never missed anything important.
- skilled 8y agoWhat news? When was the last time any major outlet reported a news story that originated from the heart and not the overbloated ego? Not to mention, when was the last time someone reported a news story without using terms like "left" or "right" or "socialist". As someone who does not give a single ounce of care for the political circus that people are enslaved by, do you realise how dumb it all looks from sidelines? Yeah, pretty dumb.
- TACIXAT 8y agoI would really like a big news service. These focuses might be a little morbid, but like major catastrophes (e.g. Idai), a single pre election explaining the stances, a post election on the results. Right now articles are being written on one person saying something about an event of interest. You can read 10 paragraphs a day on the Mueller report when nothing has really progressed on that front. I would love something that just lets me know when big stuff actually happens (e.g. wake me up when the report is out).
- hyperpallium 8y agoThis cannot happen, because of the defining characteristic of "news".
- ilaksh 8y agoA big source of the author's complaints actually is that there is a lot of news that comes out that opposes his worldview. To me that area is more the problem. Most of what's counted as news comes from one somewhat extreme worldview or another. Usually it depends on the organization. Certain publications consistently come from the left and others consistently from the right and maybe there is a third category which is coming from a different direction. And actually left/right are not exact, but it seems as though people are polarized into two or maybe three camps, with often completely different worldviews in each of them. It's actually like people are living in completely different universes. Each group is convinced that theirs is the true universe and the other is almost entirely false. More in-depth articles could theoretically help by creating more opportunities for supplying factual detail and nuance. However, almost all of the in depth articles I see are clearly coming from one of the extreme worldviews. I guess tests might be, can what you are reporting be verified in anyway, and would someone with a different worldview be able to gain information from it? Does it seem impartial. To some degree it's an almost impossible task because even basic perception is tinted by worldview. But news can try to stick to uncontroversial facts and avoid assuming that other worldviews have no validity. The other aspect is that the monetary incentives push them towards feeding a particular worldview rather than taking a chance of contradicting it with something too nuanced. My guess right now is that there may be a way to improve the availability of truly primary sources of information by taking advantage if the internet. That can eliminate the bias that many news outlets would take on interpreting events. Politics seems to be the most difficult case but also the most important. Maybe it would help for people to realize that they are occupying parallel universes.
- peterlk 8y agoI have started reading the news differently in recent months. If the story seems to incite outrage, I paint all actors in the story as acting in good faith. This is obviously not true, but it helps break the cycle of feeling like the world is going off the rails, and I think it is a good method for figuring out what's actually going on.
- jv22222 8y agoI think I'm going to try an experiment and switch my browsing/hn/news time to listening to music instead. I feel like I need to do _something_ in that downtime. Maybe music will calm the soul. See you guys in a few weeks!
- ac130kz 8y agoAre those fonts a special journalist joke? They are 100% unreadable, I just don't understand why a reputable newspaper/journal would use such font selection.
- hutattedonmyarm 8y agoLooks fine for me[0] The title has a weird font, but still legible [0]https://i.imgur.com/0CkHdIP_d.jpg https://i.imgur.com/0CkHdIP_d.jpg
- araker 8y agoI've stopped follwing the news cycle 4 years ago. I realized it wasn't a proper source of information. News needs to be published fast, so there is no time to do a proper source check. It it short, so there is no room for other views. It needs to be simple, easily understood, so it uses the dominant world view as a frame. News needs to get attention/clicks, so it is focussed on negative events, creating a skewed view of the world. I only read analysis, long reads, investigative articles and news sites that do not focus on news, but on (global) developments. A good example is https://thecorrespondent.com https://thecorrespondent.com (english version not active yet), I'm a member of the dutch version and I really enjoy reading investigative pieces about our tax system, healthcare, forgotten dutch histories and so on. All in all I can say that when I stopped following the news cycle, the mental clutter really reduced and it made me feel better.
- lefstathiou 8y agoArgh, it pains me that even professionals cannot get the word "peruse" right... "I skim e-mail newsletters in my in-box, scroll through my Twitter feed, and peruse the news apps on my phone; later, in the office, I tap through my notifications and monitor more than a dozen news-related apps, including Facebook and Twitter, while juggling other tasks. I usually feel as though I’m managing to stay abreast of the day’s biggest news stories, but my reading tends to be fragmentary—I’m only skimming a story or absorbing a partial update."
- _emacsomancer_ 8y agoI'd prefer slower, better everything. Right now it seems that 'next quarter' is long-term for most purposes.
- lotusko 8y agoyes,A few years ago, I planned to implement a new consulting model that lagged information.
- fbn79 8y agoScientific papers are the only news worth reading
- TDettmering 8y agoHalf of my browser window was ads and cookie warnings and x-articles-left warnings. I just closed the window right away.
- blackbrokkoli 8y agoI think that there is an often overlooked product that solves this problem very well by it's very nature: Weekly newspapers. Especially when you read them as paperback they take out all the haste. You can't "refresh" them. The style tends to be less lurid, because it is pointless to write an hot article with Tuesday's information if you print on Sunday. Topics are way more broad in my experience but still capture the Zeitgeist of current topics in whatever culture you live in (it has to be a good newspaper, of course). There is of course a certain desire to read everything, since you paid for it, but it's finite: It is not a permanent rat race to read all the news, when you're done, you're done. Even if you don't use whatever paper you get to it's fullest, you will still realize: You do not actually become an "informed voter" by knowing the exact updated body count of some colorful tragedy on the other side of the world. Reading one well researched multi-perspective article with depth will do just fine!
- anbop 8y agoJust read the news less often. Nobody really needs to know the news on a day to day basis unless your personal safety is at risk. Just read a monthly magazine like the Atlantic and learn the overall themes of what’s happening.
- vermaden 8y agoI stopped checking 'general' news long ago. Recently I searched for some 'valuable' news source - kinda meritum from the news - but nothing like that exists ... ... so I started my own 'news' for UNIX/BSD/Linux related stuff - Valuable News - https://vermaden.wordpress.com/2019/04/08/valuable-news-2019-04-08/ https://vermaden.wordpress.com/2019/04/08/valuable-news-2019... Because various UNIX/BSD/Linux related news sites also make a lot of SPAM and no-so-much-news ...
- skrebbel 8y agoJust want to quickly namedrop https://thecorrespondent.com/ https://thecorrespondent.com/ who are setting out to do exactly this (and have been doing it for some years already in the Netherlands). If you're interested in slower, less emotionally charged news, consider signing up.
- blablabla123 8y agoI don't think this is a problem of the media but rather of the consumer. In the pre-Twitter time people used to be concerned about those consuming only tabloids or trash TV news. At best, possibly even none at all. In fact the offer of "slow news" is so much larger than "fast news". The New Yorker is actually an example of very slow news ;-) Also on TV/Web streaming there is a lot of slow news like BBC News for instance. The truth is most people find this too boring, they are just not interested in Politics. Maybe new formats like VICE are improving this. Maybe this problem didn't even got worse but it just became more visible in the age of Google News where you suddenly see that you can read the same article on 200 different news pages - sometimes just copy&pasting from Reuters. And yes, news is always biased. That's why one should read different sources with different biases... That's a very time consuming task if you are only consuming slow news.
- galfarragem 8y agoThe sweet spot - like in most phenomena - seems to be in the middle: for trend correction we need informed people, not people addicted to trivia, neither people that only care about their own belly button. From a stream of 'news' to History essays, there is a place somewhere in the middle for monthly/quarterly 'digested news'. Even weekly news (like the Economist) seems to be too much.
- raubtier 8y agoI would say there's a urgent quest for news, as in not propaganda.
- a-saleh 8y agoI read weekly-magazines mostly and listen to podcasts. Locally, mostly Respekt, a czech magazine, often cooperating with the Economist. It is decent. I like it.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoMaybe slightly off topic but the word "quest" implies (to me at least) something long term and ongoing, and yet "urgent" seems to contradict this. If anything, "urgent quest" seems like an oxymoron. I guess in this day and age of instant gratification, even our quests need to be urgent.
- bookofjoe 8y ago"History is news that stays news."—Stewart Brand
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jammygit 8y agoThis will be on the front page for 8-24 hours, then it will get replaced by something newer
- stebann 8y agoThis is a harsh truth everywhere. News are being killed, as the reality, information and the data associated with it, all have been broken, categorized and used to manipulate people so that they can not conceive another reality and views. Many people is just looking through the lenses that paints better their own egocentric conception of the world or just the cases they need to rationalize what is happening on this confusing times. News regulation has been labeled as "useless" or "censorship" too soon. The problem is the same with other industries that have some mind-shaping power, people should have some freedom to "control" the industry and the way the information flows through their processes and from/to the society in general. This is not a trivial problem and the fact that people is vulnerable to be manipulated and their biases harnessed in some non-obvious way makes it more difficult. Also we have the problem that we haven't been educated into metacognition, structured and critical thinking. Education systems should prepared people for information overload and into processes to derive the truth even when they face an adverse and hostile environment.