39 ms·
Nuclear power is the fastest way to slash greenhouse gas emissions, decarbonize
- jseliger 8y agoIt is always interesting when the NYT and WSJ agree: https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-climate-needs-nuclear-power-11554420097 https://www.wsj.com/articles/the-climate-needs-nuclear-power...
- justicezyx 8y agoEven more so when both titles are not clickbaiting
- danso 8y agoBoth the OP and the WSJ article are op-eds, written by people who are not paid by the publications. Op-Eds get their name from the phrase, “opposing/opposite the editorial page”, so it’s not particularly accurate to think of this as the NYT and WSJ stating a position.
- lstodd 8y agoDecision to publish is always with the editor/board/sponsors.
- Krasnol 8y agoYeah, I'm sure that wasn't cheap.
- vslira 8y agoBipartisan legislation incoming
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoIf you want to see if an environmentalist really believes that climate change is as bad as scientists say it will be, look at their stance on nuclear power. If they are against it, they are basically denying the seriousness did climate change. There is no way you are going to convince voters that they need to cut their energy usage, especially before the worst of the climate change effects are felt. You need to provide steady, stable carbon free power. Nuclear power is the only current technology that can provide it. If you really care about slowing down climate change, you need to be all in on nuclear power.
- OrgNet 8y ago> If you really care about slowing down climate change, you need to be all in on nuclear power. and the opposite is happening...
- DATACOMMANDER 8y agoInteresting that this is being downvoted, since it’s spot-on.
- madhadron 8y ago> There is no way you are going to convince voters that they need to cut their energy usage Indeed. Thus the question is what undemocratic institutions, can we use? Can we put in treaties that reduce national sovereignty like the TPP? Can we make it a second order or third order effect of regulations on how insurance works so that most people can't follow the chain back to the source?
- fakwandi_priv 8y ago>Germany’s rate of adding clean energy relative to gross domestic product, it would take the world more than a century to decarbonize, even if the country wasn’t also retiring nuclear plants early. Why doesn't the article explain why the Germans are retiring their plants? I think these articles should go more in-depth regarding the pro's and con's. From what I read and hear Nuclear power is a great source of energy but I feel when convincing other people of this you need to portray the good and the bad.
- mpweiher 8y ago> why the Germans are retiring their plants Politicians bowing to the wishes of an ill-informed public.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 8y agoNobody really believes science that goes against their deep settled beliefs.
- lispm 8y agoThere was a decades long discussion about nuclear energy in Germany. You can bet that the public was much better informed about nuclear, than the politicians and the nuclear industry liked. There were a bunch of failed nuclear projects like the pebble bed reactor, the fast breeder or the storage sites. Watching them made the decision to get out of that type of industry much easier. Germany had the same level of corrupt nuclear industry, which is known from Japan and which has been exposed there.
- loeg 8y ago> Why doesn't the article explain why the Germans are retiring their plants? It does, although it doesn't draw the connection directly. > I think these articles should go more in-depth regarding the pro's and con's. The con's (both for Germany, and the US) are (quotes below from the article): > irrational dread among the public and many activists > ... > people estimate risk according to how readily anecdotes like well-publicized nuclear accidents pop into mind. For Germany in particular: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_phase-out#Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_phase-out#German... Tl;dr, Germany politic interest in nuclear phase-out began around 2000 as misdirected "green" activism and was escalated by irrational public fears in response to Fukushima in 2011.
- Creationer 8y agoThe problem isn't cost of power generated, its the ability to respond to rapid volatility - when clouds obscure solar panels, and when the wind stops blowing. Nuclear cannot do this so it is useless. Batteries and gas power plants can which is why they are being rolled out. Wind, Solar, Gas, Batteries and Electric Vehicles are existing solutions to the climate problem. The market will implement them slowly, since they are cheaper and superior to legacy solutions, but we need political effort to do it more quickly.
- plasticchris 8y agoA certain baseline power requirement must be met. It's also interesting to see the volatility of solar and wind be used as an argument against baseline generation, as this has traditionally been an argument against renewables.
- pfdietz 8y agoIt's an argument against renewables only when the renewables are expensive. When renewables are cheap, then nuclear is placed in an impossible situation, as nuclear either displaces the renewables when they ARE available (incurring a large marginal cost), or only runs when they aren't (forcing nuclear's large fixed costs to be amortized over much less output). It's likely that a cost optimized grid will have little or no nuclear in it.
- DennisP 8y agoUnless you do solar and mostly skip wind, in which case you can build enough nuclear to run the nighttime load and solar for just the extra daytime load, then you can run the nukes 24/7. That minimizes both nuclear downtime and storage requirements. But if we're going to build a lot of wind, that still doesn't necessarily doom nuclear, if we can lower the capital cost of nuclear. The article describes some fairly simple ways to go about that; a recent study at MIT had the same recommendations. Down the road a decade or so, molten salt reactors will start to be available, and those look to have much lower capital costs and good load-balancing.
- addicted 8y agoNuclear power can save the world.... If the US can build reactors at 1/10th the cost they do right now. That’s the solution. Not the much cheaper clean energy sources that already exist and are being built out in record numbers... Nuclear is great. It just loses out because it’s too expensive and worse, it gets more expensive with time. If the reasoning behind that is based on irrational human fears then first propose a solution for irrational community fears. You’ll also be able to solve the SF housing and homelessness crisis at one go then.
- rargulati 8y agoCan you give more information on why this is? Any recommended reading to better understand where and why the costs increase?
- DennisP 8y agoThe article explains pretty well why it's expensive, and how to fix it.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoHere's a recent report about what makes nuclear expensive and how to fix it [1]. [1] https://www.eti.co.uk/library/the-eti-nuclear-cost-drivers-project-summary-report https://www.eti.co.uk/library/the-eti-nuclear-cost-drivers-p...
- istjohn 8y agoFTA: New nuclear power plants are hugely expensive to build in the United States today. This is why so few are being built. But they don’t need to be so costly. The key to recovering our lost ability to build affordable nuclear plants is standardization and repetition. ... Currently, as M.I.T.’s Richard Lester, a nuclear engineer, has written, a company proposing a new reactor design faces “the prospect of having to spend a billion dollars or more on an open- ended, all‑or‑nothing licensing process without any certainty of outcomes.” We need government on the side of this clean-energy transformation, with supportive regulation, streamlined approval, investment in research and incentives that tilt producers and consumers away from carbon. ... [I]n 60 years of nuclear power, only three accidents have raised public alarm: Three Mile Island in 1979, which killed no one; Fukushima in 2011, which killed no one (many deaths resulted from the tsunami and some from a panicked evacuation near the plant); and Chernobyl in 1986, the result of extraordinary Soviet bungling, which killed 31 in the accident and perhaps several thousand from cancer, around the same number killed by coal emissions every day.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- onetimemanytime 8y agoseems like air travel, a crash in Siberia with 57 victims makes world news. 1200 car crashes and deaths at the same period don't. (made the numbers up but air travel is much safer)
- acidburnNSA 8y agoIt's exactly like air travel. We use that analogy in the industry all the time. The question for me is, OK so how did the airline industry make most people ok with it? And does that work for nuclear public education too? It's funny, people who live near nuclear plants are very significantly more supportive of nuclear plants. Anecdotally, I grew up 9 miles from an operating plant and love them.
- OisinMoran 8y agoIf this interests you, I would highly recommend reading this article on molten salt reactors [0]. TL;DR: Molten salt reactors are safer (can't have a meltdown if it's already melted), smaller (could fit on the back of a truck), able to run on more abundant materials like Thorium (which in turn come from more politically stable regions), and to top it all off: not only do they leave much less nuclear waste, they can actually use up current nuclear waste, turning it into much less harmful and shorter lived stuff in the process! Also, Mike Shellenberger [1] is a great proponent of nuclear power and has some great points on why the current focus on renewables is damaging. Well worth the follow on Twitter. [0] https://www.knowablemagazine.org/article/technology/2019/nuclear-goes-retro-much-greener-outlook https://www.knowablemagazine.org/article/technology/2019/nuc... [1] https://twitter.com/ShellenbergerMD https://twitter.com/ShellenbergerMD
- theothermkn 8y agoA quibble: The point about meltdowns is cute, but probably wrong; the insurance against meltdown is a negative thermal coefficient of reactivity, if I understand correctly. In other words, the thermal expansion drives the fuel out into the piping as the reaction heats up, away from the compact reacting core, and also reduces the density in the core, allowing more neutrons to escape.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoAll reactors have negative temperature coefficients of reactivity, including LWRs (the water moderator boils away), SFRs (the core thermally expands), and MSRs (the fuel density decreases). The key to avoiding radiation leakage out of any nuclear plant is decay heat removal [1]. If you can passively remove decay heat, your reactor is very safe. MSRs do this easily, as do other reactors with low-pressure coolants (like sodium metal-cooled reactors). [1] https://whatisnuclear.com/decay-heat.html https://whatisnuclear.com/decay-heat.html
- hannob 8y agoAlso Molten salt reactors don't exist yet appart from a few research reactors, which you forgot to mention.
- quelsolaar 8y agoNuclear is not a viable solution, due to public opinion. A nuclear reactor has an incident once every 10.000 years. If we divide that with the number of reactors we get an accident every 30 or so years. (Harrisburg, Chernobyl, Fukusima, ligns up well with that) Every time there is an accident, the public turns against nuclear for 5-10 years. Add to that that it takes a decade to plan and build a reactor, and you realize that once we double or triple the number of reactors, accidents will be so frequent, that the public wont stand for additional expansion within the time it takes to build more reactors. We need 10x nuclear to solve global warming. Thats a major accident every 3 years or so. Yes, Nuclear can be made safer, but probably not by as much as needed. Even a country like Japan, who has high safety standards, and a historical heritage of nuclear fallout, has had an accident, and most new reactors are likely to be built by China who has less then stellar safety record.
- acidburnNSA 8y agoJust a month before Chernobyl happened, the staff at the Experimental Breeder Reactor-II in Idaho successfully demonstrated something new and incredible: passive shutdown. They had the reactor at full power and killed the pumps. It shut down and started cooling itself with natural circulation (no external/backup power needed). No control rods were inserted. This state would last indefinitely. Then they did it again, this time cutting off the heat sink. Same result [1]. This was the ultimate energy source. But we all turned our backs on this team. Clinton cut funding in '94 and the reactor shut down. Advanced low-pressure reactors can do this, and eliminating loss-of-decay-heat-removal accidents takes the probability of a large early release well into the 10^-7 or even 10^-8 range according to probabilistic risk assessments. So even though nuclear is, by the actuarial tables, almost as safe as you can get in energy systems, you're right that the public opinion is a big hurdle and that Fukushimas are not acceptable. These low-pressure designs get us there, and it's been demonstrated. Molten salt reactors, liquid metal cooled reactors, and some gas cooled reactors all have this capability. It's basically the main event of what the nuclear industry called Gen IV reactors [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EBR-II#Passive_safety https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EBR-II#Passive_safety [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_IV_reactor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generation_IV_reactor
- jjordan 8y agoGeneration III+ reactors are orders of magnitude safer than everything else that was built before the turn of the century. China is actually leading the charge right now, with AP1000 reactors under construction. One of the plants just went live last year: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanmen_Nuclear_Power_Station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sanmen_Nuclear_Power_Station The US needs to find a way to make building reactors affordable.
- ajross 8y ago> The US needs to find a way to make building reactors affordable. Early reactors were hailed as paragons of safety too. Fukushima, remember, had a triply-redundant (or whatever) power supply to ensure that cooling power could be provided even in the event of a simultaneous meltdown and grid failure. Oops. I mean, look. It's... fine. Go nuclear. I agree with you, that these are probably safe designs and are probably not going to poison anyone due to misanalyzed failure modes. Nuclear is carbon free power and preferable to coal and gas for sure. But in a world where we can build out solar and wind as cheaply as we can gas plants and handle the grid buffering with batteries, I just don't care much anymore. If we run out of ridgeline real estate and still need more power, we'll call you. The US doesn't "need" to do anything with nuclear, at all. The nuclear industry (and its geek proponents here on HN) needs to find a way to make itself worthwhile on a balance sheet.
- lstodd 8y ago> But in a world where we can build out solar and wind as cheaply as we can gas plants It might be that your world is Arizona desert. Please do not dive into latitudianizm.
- DennisP 8y ago> in a world where we can build out solar and wind as cheaply as we can gas plants and handle the grid buffering with batteries I notice you left the batteries out of your cost comparison with natural gas. Building enough battery for a carbon-free grid without fossil backup is not so cheap.
- tamaharbor 8y agoWhy would anyone want a nuclear reactor in their backyard? They don’t even want wind turbines or solar arrays.
- mempko 8y agoNuclear could have saved the world 30 years ago. I'm afraid it's just too risky now. Nuclear is not dangerous if we have organized human life managing it. However, the risks are such that there may not be the know-how or organization in the future to keep the plants going or have an organized decommissioning of the existing plants. The technology change would also need to be drastic because we cannot rely on cold ocean waters to cool the plants. In other words, we should have done it 30 years ago when the risk of societal collapse wasn't so great and we had the confidence that we can maintain this technology.
- viach 8y agoNope. If we build 100x reactors, there will be new reasons why it's not enough already and we need 1000x more. There are unspoken and unpopular things that could really work - limiting consumerism, and decreasing population.
- icelancer 8y ago> limiting consumerism If you solve this problem, you'll solve a problem much greater than energy consumption. This is not unspoken and unpopular, it is thought to be impossible given the human condition. > decreasing population Good luck with that one.
- moonlet 8y agoNuclear power can save the world if we can prevent any more Fukushimas. It requires so much more responsibility than wind or solar seem to on the part of plant operators.
- skrap 8y agoStrong public policy can save the world. Nuclear can help. But, without public policy, nothing will happen. So call it cap-and-trade, or green new deal, or cap-and-dividend, but we need it now.
- pdevine 8y agoCan we talk about the waste that’s cast off when the reactor has finished its use of it? I understand the material will remain radioactive for centuries. Nobody wants that in their backyard.
- Lramseyer 8y agoNot to downplay the issue, but global warming is a much more urgent issue. It's expected to cause far more disasters a lot sooner than any potential disaster from our nuclear waste. To answer your question more practically though, our nuclear waste would fit into a building the size of a football field. There's even a proposal to put it in some mine/cave in the western United States.
- ern 8y agoI would be pro-nuclear except for the waste problem. I don’t trust humanity to be able to confine the waste for centuries. For all we know it could be seen as some sort of “treasure” by future, ignorant, civilizations, dug up, and spread around in trinkets. If there is a way of permanently and completely removing them from the biosphere, I’d change my mind.
- icelancer 8y ago...if the alternative is climate change continuing to worsen until renewable technologies (particularly energy storage and transmission) are up to par and scale, which one do you prefer?
- ern 8y agoThat's a tough call, but I'd prefer pushing harder on renewable research or finding a permanent solution to the nuclear waste problem, because, as bad as humans are at dealing with medium term consequences of our activities (see climate change), we have no track record of dealing with the long term, and ultra-long term consequences of what we do.
- 8y ago
- scarygliders 8y agoCan we just get something straight about the Fukushima Dai-ichi nuclear power plant? Although it was a 1960's design, the reason it failed the way it did was because of one design flaw... Its backup generators were not placed up on the hills above it. Rather, the backup generators were situated below sea level underneath the reactor buildings. DERP. Fukushima Dai-ichi survived the Magnitude 9 earthquake. It did not survive the tsunami because said tsunami overcame the tidal wall in front of it, and then the backup generators got flooded. But for that one event, if the generators were placed up on higher ground, the outcome would have been so much different. I have first-hand knowledge, due to.. 1) Knowing the area. I lived in my Japanese father-in-law's mountain house, situated 1.5km out of Miyakoji-machi, Tamura-shi. That town was just inside the 20km evacuation zone from the power plant, the mountain house was just outside at 21km - myself and my family lived in our own house in the outskirts of Koriyama city. 2) My (now deceased) Japanese father-in-law was president of the Hitachi subsiduary company which built Fukushima Dai-ich No.4 reactor, which wasn't operating at the time of the earthquake and subsequent tsunami but did suffer an explosion thought due to hydrogen gas from the spent fuel situated in the Spent Fuel Pool in its upper level. 3) Mentioned in point (1) above, I owned a house in Tobu New Town on the Eastern outskirts of Koriyama city, and I was working at Flextronics in Koriyama at the time the M9 quake occurred - things got a tad 'exciting' at the time. I should write a book. My point is that nuclear power is safe, as long as all disaster scenarios are taken into account - in Fukushima Dai-ichi's case, for some reason (possibly financial?), it was decided that the tsunami barrier was sufficient (it wasn't) for the job, and at some point in time it was decided that placing backup generators underneath the buildings was sufficient - that unfortunately did not turn out to be the case :/ And lastly, I still fully support the idea of nuclear power.
- skookumchuck 8y agoOr just put the generators on stilts, in a bunker, or simply hardened them against flooding. There were other design flaws, too, like venting hydrogen inside the building rather than outside.
- scarygliders 8y agoIndeed. I'll point out, however, that the Error Cascade began with the loss of the underground backup generators - hydrogen would not have been a problem if the backup generators were operative.
- z3t4 8y agoI think this can be a win/win. Higher levels of carbon dioxide mean more plants, and more oxygen, which leads to bigger animals. And nuclear waste leads to mutations ...
- desuyone 8y agoHow about we put the reactors in the middle of the desert, then there is no danget of killing a city and no risk of nuclear material leaking into the sea. You really don't need that many people to staff a reactor and if you really do, you can always build a train so people don't need to live close. I know power transmission is an issue. But we have gotten a lot better at that as well, with things like that big DC underwater powerline from scandinavia to the middle of europe.
- djakjxnanjak 8y agoIs the resistance to nuclear power mostly at the state/local level or is there also a lot of federal opposition? I wonder if some western state with unpopulated land could make a lot of money by doing a huge nuclear project and sell the power to California with UHV lines. The politics seem kind of similar to pipeline projects, but the ultimate goal would be to save the earth rather than burn it down so maybe there would be less opposition. Maybe you could even generate enough energy and wealth to convert some legacy fossil fuel businesses (and the politicians they own).
- pfdietz 8y agoThe resistance is from those being asked to pay for it.
- djakjxnanjak 8y agoSeems like many of the costs are design and management overhead that would probably be less of an issue at larger scale?
- tathougies 8y ago> I wonder if some western state with unpopulated land could make a lot of money by doing a huge nuclear project and sell the power to California with UHV lines. You mean California? California is mostly empty, unused space.
- pfdietz 8y ago
- stevespang 8y agoPURE GARBAGE. There are nearly 300,000 tons of spent nuclear fuel waste still piling up at reactors around the world.1 1. https://www.knowablemagazine.org/article/technology/2019/nuclear-goes-retro-much-greener-outlook https://www.knowablemagazine.org/article/technology/2019/nuc... The cost of building and operating a nuclear power plant WAY exceeds solar and wind, hands down.
- ekianjo 8y agoFor folks who think solar/wind/other sources are just as good or better, why not invest in all energy sources anyway? In most cases anyway this will be private investment and there is no reason not to experiment with all types of energies (including new types of nuclear reactors) instead of waiting and see if renewables can achieve their promise. If you are going to make bets, take as many bets as you can.
- rorykoehler 8y agoPeople don't want to invest in nuclear because nuclear disasters scare the shit out of them.
- ekianjo 8y agoWe are talking about new nuclear reactor designs, not like the ones from the 50s. And frankly nuclear plants, even with their disasters, have killed very few people compared to all other sources of energy.
- wiggler00m 8y agoRenewable energy is cheaper than nuclear, or will be imminently. Proponents of nuclear tend to ignore the long-run costs associated with nuclear (eg. waste transport and storage), and the potential for cost blowouts due to acute disasters like Fukushima (estimated cost to taxpayers: USD $100 Billion). The fact tax money is going towards Fukushima highlights another problem with nuclear power: the agency problem. The individuals and organizations that planned and built Fukushima are not directly shouldering the full cost of the problem it created. You can extrapolate from this to many other problems and risks associated with nuclear power, because the timeframe is long relative to the life of a human. If the average human lifespan was 200 years or more, maybe this would be less of an issue, but as it is now, profits now will inevitably trump responsibility tomorrow (and by tomorrow, I mean 30+ years from now). There's also the risk of weaponization, which increases as the number of plants increase, particularly if those plants are built in countries which currently do not possess much technical nous. It's not a technology that should be disseminated, because the risks are real, and catastrophic in their consequences. If this sounds paranoid, Warren Buffett had this to say about the threat of cyber, biological, nuclear, or chemical attack on in the US: "“What’s a small probability in a short period approaches certainty in the longer run. (If there is only one chance in thirty of an event occurring in a given year, the likelihood of it occurring at least once in a century is 96.6%.) The added bad news is that there will forever be people and organizations and perhaps even nations that would like to inflict maximum damage on our country. Their means of doing so have increased exponentially during my lifetime. “Innovation” has its dark side. There is no way for American corporations or their investors to shed this risk. If an event occurs in the U.S. that leads to mass devastation, the value of all equity investments will almost certainly be decimated. No one knows what “the day after” will look like. I think, however, that Einstein’s 1949 appraisal remains apt: “I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones.”" [Source: 2016 annual letter to Berkshire shareholders]
- BurningFrog 8y ago> Renewable energy is cheaper than nuclear, or will be imminently. Renewable energy at that scale is still theoretical and hasn't shown its downsides yet. Nuclear has shown all its downsides, and they have been 95% corrected. It's a mature, known technology.
- kjar 8y agoThis falsehood gets rolled out regularly. New reactors take a decade to manufacture, have nearly zero private investment, and the icing on the turd cake produce waste lasting for centuries.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- samstave 8y agoSerious question I have thought about previously: Why is there not a singular global body that includes all nations to build out, manage and secure ALL nuclear power plants. Basically a single body, comprised of all the top minds and efforts of every nation's nuclear SMEs - which will create a grid of nuclear power all over the world and every country contributes based on their draw from the system?
- externalreality 8y agoSo there are problems. Its also the fastest way to the destroy the world. If you dot the world with these things we become one climate disaster or earth quake away from having written a check that our collective asses can't cash.
- fastball 8y agoNot if you use a molten salt design.
- euske 8y agoIn 2011, a week after the Japan's earthquake, NYTimes wrote an article that was rather critical of nuclear energy. I wonder when the flip flop happened. "Living With a Nuclear Question Mark in the Backyard" https://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/17/nyregion/17towns.html https://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/17/nyregion/17towns.html
- grzm 8y ago> "NYTimes wrote an article that was rather critical of nuclear energy. I wonder when the flip flop happened." The New York Times, like most newspapers, is not a single, unified voice it its articles, and much less in editorials published under Opinion sections, such as this submission.
- natch 8y agoA key overlooked aspect of Nuclear is that it is the big government, centralized, big industry, big bureaucracy, anti-freedom, anti-self-determination option. Renewables like solar and wind can be local, scaled down to the needs of a single family property, and kept under the sole control, if desired, of an individual owner. Nuclear is fundamentally not that way. If this article isn't it already, expect to see in the near future that the powerful elite subset of climate deniers will pivot to accept climate change while advocating for nuclear as a solution, all because their cronies stand to benefit from massive construction projects and associated safety, security, and control projects.
- lispm 8y agoThat was one of the main reasons here in Germany to quit that type of industry. There were people from the industry which had exposed this.
- Gatsky 8y agoWith nuclear energy, the cost and hazards of waste are explicit and priced into running costs. This is as it should be. Fossil fuels get a free ride by comparison. The more I look I see there are two types of industries out there... those that profit by creating value, and those that profit by shifting the cost onto someone else.
- hairytrog 8y agoIt doesn't stop there. I don't think solar and wind have decommissioning and waste costs built in.
- ozborn 8y agoNuclear fission is a compact, high powered energy source. It is a practical and cost effective energy source for energy generation on submarines, warships and spaceships. In 2019 however, it is not any longer worth advocating as a source of power for civilization on Earth (or any of the Inner Planets in this Solar System) given the last decade of cost reductions in solar and wind power coupled with low cost battery development. This is well understood by the market, politicians and the general public, even if the nuclear lobby hasn't come to terms with this reality. Even if plants could be built 6 times cheaper as this article suggests - which is both unlikely (given the track record of the industry) and unwise for ratepayers (given the history of cost offloading on the public) nuclear is unlikely to compete with renewables for the foreseeable future. The entire article is written as a polemic (which is fine) but it argues against various straw-men and obfuscates the problems with nuclear power today. Some examples include: Caiming it is "fantasy" that renewables alone can power the transition to a carbon free economy. Their argument? "Wind and solar power are becoming cheaper, but they are not available around the clock, rain or shine, and batteries that could power entire cities for days or weeks". This confused statement doesn't actually address the best argument of renewable energy advocates - that renewables could power entire cities if given sufficient generation and storage capacity. An argument indicating the limits of renewable power generation and battery production is required, but the article makes no such argument because it would not hold water. Also, if there is no daylight for weeks (nuclear winter?) there may be bigger problems to address than carbon emissions. Also, the article does itself no favors by comparing itself to coal. This is a dying energy source (especially in the US) - the fact that nuclear is better than coal impresses no one. Another trick used is sentences like this "By contrast, in 60 years of nuclear power, only three accidents have raised public alarm". It is quite likely that most nuclear incidents raised no alarm because they weren't reported. The public incidents cited were simply too large to go unnoticed. Does anybody believe the only lethal accident or cancer causing radioactive lease in the Soviet Union was Chernobyl? Another crazy claim is "Nuclear waste is compact — America’s total from 60 years would fit in a Walmart — and is safely stored in concrete casks and pools, becoming less radioactive over time.". This is simply not correct as written. If America's waste was well managed it might fit into a Walmart (I didn't do the math), but it is isn't. It is a poorly manged mess, even leaking into groundwater like at Hanford. Hanford's cleanup wouldn't cost $113+ billion to clean up if nuclear waste sat in well organized casks in a Walmart sized warehouse. And Hanford is is just one (large) site (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanford_Site https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hanford_Site). Finally, the article deals with nuclear proliferation with this paragraph: "Nuclear power plants cannot explode like nuclear bombs, and they have not contributed to weapons proliferation, thanks to robust international controls: 24 countries have nuclear power but not weapons, while Israel and North Korea have nuclear weapons but not power." Again, no one is claiming that that nuclear plants explode like nuclear bombs (straw man). However, claiming they have no contributed to weapons proliferation requires a special reading of the paragraph where proliferation counts only as documented cases of nuclear material migrating across borders to be incorporated in nuclear weapons. The fact that nuclear plants produce material for nuclear weapons (whether it crosses a border or not) means nuclear power can (and does) contribute to weapon development. Israel may not have nuclear power plants, but it has "research" nuclear plants (Dimona) that probably produced the material for its bombs. It's unclear to me if this is a good faith opinion piece.
- jlebar 8y agoCoal is literally 1000x more dangerous than nuclear power. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents#Fatalities https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents#Fatalities Humanity's inability to understand basic math will be our downfall -- perhaps already has sealed our fate.
- devwastaken 8y agoThough it's the most amount of deaths by year currently, their argument generally is about if a nuclear plant close to population pops off. A single city would be 1000x what coals killed.
- YjSe2GMQ 8y agoIt would not. 1. The grandparent's source quotes the coal death rate of ~100k/PWh. 2. Global coal processing is at ~50 PWh/year: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_consumption https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_energy_consumption 3. This means ~5M people die to coal each year.
- tathougies 8y ago> Though it's the most amount of deaths by year currently, their argument generally is about if a nuclear plant close to population pops off. Then move the plant farther away?
- beders 8y agoCan we get something straight about nuclear power? A 1% failure rate is not acceptable. We don't need nuclear power. Renewables are cheaper, storage solutions are available and there are whole countries on close to 100% renewable power. There are still radioactive boars running around in Bavaria as a result of the Chernobyl incident. It is still unclear how many billions of dollars of cleanup costs for Fukushima the Japanese tax payer has to spend. And how many will die of the aftereffects. Why would anyone sane invest in a power technology with such a destructive potential? Especially if the alternative are far safer, easier to produce and easier to decommission. (another dirty secret of the nuclear industry: Who is going to pay for the decommissioning of old power plants and the cleanup: Yup, it's you, because the funds allocated for it are not sufficient). The $500m spent on decommissioning the Brennilis Nuclear Reactore in France could buy how many wind turbines and solar cells? Keep it in the ground. Not just the oil, but also the uranium.
- itsthewrongway 8y agoIf we are talking purely about reducing greenhouse gasses regardless of sector, the fastest way to do so is if we just quit eating meat. And there is no new technology needed :). https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelpellmanrowland/2018/06/12/save-the-planet/#36cacfef3c81 https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelpellmanrowland/2018/06/1...
- simonCGN 8y agoPossibly the most expensive one if you count in disposal costs of radioactive elements after the useful live ended
- walkingolof 8y agoNuclear power is nothing that can be trusted with private companies, the long term nature is directly incompatible with an entity that can go bankrupt and "die". Renewables connected with battery/pumped/hydrogen storage is by far our best bet.
- dav43 8y agoRenewables total cost of ownership is significantly lower. Nuclear is not required anymore.
- dillonjeff 8y agoI am pro-Nuclear power as long as we keep the power plant as well as the spent fuel in your backyard.
- Sam_PFS 8y agoHi Everyone, My name is Sam Samida-Pugh, and I am the CEO and Founder of Progressive Fusion Solutions (PFS), a fusion energy research company I started when I was 16. I've been operating PFS for 2 years now, and so far, our team has constructed 2 fusion reactors, raised $17k in funding, and presented our research at TRIUMF, Canadas National Lab for Particle Physics. Our fusion area of focus is that of the Polywell, a method of fusion which is commercially viable on a small, and inexpensive scale in relation to other fusion projects. We have 3 patents on the Polywell, and it is our goal to demonstrate energy extraction from one of our models by 2025. Currently, we are looking to raise $2 million to advance our company to its 3rd stage this year. If anyone is interested in learning more, or is aware of anyone who may be interested, then I kindly invite you to visit our website: https://www.progressivefusionsolution.com/ https://www.progressivefusionsolution.com/, or send me an email through progressivefusionsolutions@gmail.com. Cheers, Sam
- nabla9 8y agoThe question is What is the fastest way?, not what is possible in the future. People disagreeing in this thread fail to address the reasons stated in the article why renewables alone are not complete solution and why nuclear is good choice to compensate. Germans made attempt to increase renewables only but ended up increasing coal use because rationing electricity was not an politically feasible option when renewable electricity production was low. Without nuclear energy you can increase renewable usage up to 50% economically if you build better grid and add some overcapacity and recharge car batteries at night, but you must fire up coal or natural gas electricity plants for the nighttimes and exceptionally cold or hot time periods. If you build nuclear plants they will not throttle down for days or when renewable energy is plenty and electricity price goes negative. This decreases the profitability of both renewables and nuclear. In some time in future, it's possible to go full renewables but you need very robust smart grid, large scale energy storage (not lithium-ion) etc. That's possible but it's not the fastest way. Building more nuclear power is the fastest way to drive down CO2 in addition with renewables.
- jplayer01 8y agoThe biggest problem with nuclear power is how unacceptable mistakes or failures are for anybody who's the slightest bit anti-nuclear. It means that failures are concealed and not dealt with adequately and safety culture as would be necessary isn't sufficiently implemented. The process of improvement is stifled by this cultural need to cry "shut it all down" the moment an accident happens. Imagine if people reacted the same way to aviation - it never would have become as safe as it is now (and yet still hundreds of people died this year alone, 3 months in). Nuclear power can't become safer (and it already is pretty damn safe) in modern cultural contexts. That's not the fault of the technology, it's the fault of everybody here, the media and everybody claiming how unsafe nuclear is and how we should stop using it (and screw the consequences of not using and refining such an amazing technology).
- baybal2 8y agoIs the author related in any way to Justin J Goldstein? That one used to be a big lobbyist.
- Bombthecat 8y agoStill no answer to the question : what do we with nuclear waste... Only answer I get is : more money will solve it or one day...
- akvadrako 8y agoIt's just a non-issue. All of the world's nuclear waste could fit in one warehouse and isn't that dangerous. You can either put all of it in a building somewhere or keep it in smaller buildings on-site.
- Bombthecat 8y agoAnd putting it in a warehouse solves the problem?... I excepted more from hackernews... I'm disappointed.
- kmlx 8y agoplease correct me if i'm wrong, but doesn't the climate have so much inertia that NYC will be underwater no matter what we do? i mean, we could go all renewable at this very moment, and NYC will still be submerged, along with most of humanity. at least that's my understanding from this paper: Consequences of twenty-first-century policy for multi-millennial climate and sea-level change https://www2.bc.edu/jeremy-shakun/Clark-2016-NCC.pdf https://www2.bc.edu/jeremy-shakun/Clark-2016-NCC.pdf so what's the point of these discussions? shouldn't we start building-out Mars or something?
- jokoon 8y agoGreenpeace has been known to fight nuclear power, as have far left green parties. It really saddens me. Reaching good power output with renewable energies is laughable. I keep hearing that germany generated a lot of power with wind, like 80%, but it lasted one week, and it makes me really wonder about the accuracy of that news. Wikipedia is moot about germany wind energy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_Germany The amount of solar panels, dams and wind turbine you need to reach the power output of a nuclear plant is ridiculous. I wish we would consider the cost of kWh for each non carbonized energy. A french consultant showing cost graphs: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fuzGG9W7obs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fuzGG9W7obs
- turbohz 8y agoMaybe that's a feature. Forcing to make more efficient use of energy.
- Brakenshire 8y agoNuclear is cheap if governments back the loans (all the cost is up front so a 2% or 5% interest rate has a massive impact on final project cost), and if the projects can be delivered consistently on budget (conspicuously not the case for any of the most recent designs with passive safety features).
- jokoon 8y agoNot cheap, but probably still cheaper than renewables, per kWh. Also the problem with renewables is the power output curve, which are unpredictable because of sunlight and wind fluctuations, which will be compensated with coal/gas energy. Less of a problem with nuclear.
- pfdietz 8y agoNuclear is much more expensive per kWh than renewables. The intermittency of renewables renders nuclear unable to coexist with them. Nuclear is inflexible and wants to be able to sell all the time, but can't do that when renewables crash the price on the power market. You might say this is a renewable problem, but it's just as much a problem of nuclear being too inflexible to adapt to a dynamic power market.
- Gondolin 8y agoI am flabbergasted that some commenters here argue against nuclear because of waste and accidents, while ignoring that - coal produce radioactive waste too - it kills a lot more persons (without taking into account global warning) due to air pollution - the economic cost of nuclear may be underestimated, but this is nothing compared to the economic cost of global warming. Renewable (wind and solar) are extremely important, but nuclear replace coal and gas. Renewable alone are not enough, especially since we will need a lot more electric energy for transport and to decarbonise the atmosphere; so both are needed. It boggles my mind that Germany made a great effort on renewable, and used this extra energy to close nuclear plants rather than coals ones. (At the beginning they even had to open more coal plants!) This means that Fukushima (which made Germany close its nuclear plants) killed a lot more people in Germany than in Japan. People's priority are wrongly aligned: first close coals and gas plants using renewable, and then think about reducing nuclear plants once we have good storage technology. Recall that coal is 1000 times more deadly than nuclear per unit of energy (including the nuclear accidents). Taking global warming into account, this is way worse; if nothing is done we are talking about billions of death to total collapse of human civilisation. Compared to that, the human and economic cost of nuclear waste and a few potential large nuclear explosions due to accident/malice is trivial. Nuclear energy is a vital tool against global warming, and I am very concerned for the future of my children that even well educated people (I have these same arguments with my university colleagues) don't realise that.
- lazyjones 8y ago> I am very concerned for the future of my children that even well educated people (I have these same arguments with my university colleagues) don't realise that. Perhaps it's not very convincing to claim that "a few potential large nuclear explosions due to accident/malice" aren't as bad as an average temperature increase of 1 degree or so. Certainly seems borderline insane to me.
- kuzehanka 8y agoThe worst nuclear accidents that could possibly happen have already happened. We couldn't have a worse nuclear power disaster than Lake Karachay even if we tried on purpose. And yet the sum damage they caused is a negligible blip compared to how many people die due to the use of fossil fuels on any given month of any given year. The environmental impact of nuclear power vs. fossil fuels or even renewables is just a negligible number no matter how you spin it. I too am confused like the GP poster as to how otherwise intelligent people just break down into baseless fearmongering about imaginary disaster scenarios while ignoring that today's conventional energy industry is literally thousands of times worse. If every single operational nuclear power plant had a meltdown incident after operating for 20 years, they'd still be orders of magnitude less damaging than what we're doing today. The environmental impact and safety numbers are just that far apart. https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldwide-by-energy-source/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldw...
- jinfiesto 8y agoNuclear is a political non-starter. No one wants to live near a nuclear power plant, and people tend to fight tooth and nail to fight the placement of nuclear power anywhere near them. The result of this is that nuclear power plants get foisted onto communities that don't have the political clout to fight them, or get thrown where there isn't anyone to fight. What ends up happening is that power plants get placed by politics instead of by science and engineering. Further, it appears (at least to me) that proponents of nuclear underestimate the degree to which we (as a species) underpredict the likelihood of catastrophic events. In general, we're pretty bad at assessing the risk of so-called "black swans," but when the downside is so high, I understand why people are skeptical. I personally am pro-nuclear, for many of the reasons described in the article, though I don't think the case is as clear cut as most nuclear proponents. On a rational level, I can understand that the likelihood of disaster is vanishingly small. I still don't want to live anywhere close to a nuclear power plant.
- trickstra 8y agonuclear power is also a local maxima. It won't be enough in the long run and it comes with it's own set of problems that are way too similar to our current fossil fuel problems. Do you want to get stuck at this local maxima? It will be extremely hard to get out of it once it's needed.
- theshrike79 8y ago"But but the ACCIDENTS and the WASTE". France has FIFTY THREE (53) nuclear reactors, how many incidents have they had? Without googling, name one? The problem isn't nuclear reactors, it is the superstitious levels of fear people have of them. Somehow people believe that a reactor produces mountains and mountains of "toxic waste" every year. When in reality it's nowhere near that.
- perfunctory 8y agoIt's paramount we expand nuclear power. Despite potential risks. We absolutely need all that electricity to... do what exactly? Mine bitcoins?
- Gravityloss 8y agoThe 1.6 gigawatt Olkiluoto 3 EPR has cost 5.5 billion and the building has taken 14 years so far (it's not ready yet). And this is happening in a high functioning low corruption country. The lightbulb wasn't the real invention - it was the lightbulb making machine that had the real impact on the world. The same way, we need a way to safely, quickly and cheaply build and operate nuclear power plants. The way might be small modular reactors, something like 200 megawatt sized. They can be built in well controlled circumstances in a factory. Installation on site should be fast. Currently, a nuclear power plant construction requires lots of welding and concrete casting. In these projects it is slow and expensive because of extra safety needs and regulations. On site construction should be minimized instead. One could run multiple smaller reactors in one site so safety areas would not be greatly increased. Emergency and maintenance shutdowns would have smaller impact on the grid than currently with multiple gigawatt sizes. With smaller reactors, innovation and experimentation should also be a lot faster. If you build one reactor every 20 years, you don't get a lot of incremental innovation.
- yk 8y agoWell, the nuclear renaissance since 2010 is marked by a decline in the number of reactors [0] and we just do not the capacity to build more, because the production of pressure vessels is severely limited. Plus most nuclear reactors are around 30 years old [1], so many will be decommissioned over the next 20 years. Therefore it is simply not possible to build up the share of nuclear in the power generation mix, except with extending the operation time of light water reactors (from a design lifetime of 30 years), or build reactors without a pressure vessel, that is something akin to an RMBK. Right now, over the next 20 years the clean alternatives are solar, wind and hydro. Nuclear power can at the earliest be expanded in the late 2030, at which point it has to compete with fusion, and hopefully orbiting solar. [0] http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/facts-and-figures/reactor-database.aspx http://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/facts-and-f... (has actually just the total electricity number, [1] http://www.euronuclear.org/info/encyclopedia/n/nuclear-power-plant-world-wide.htm http://www.euronuclear.org/info/encyclopedia/n/nuclear-power...
- pfdietz 8y agoIt will not have to compete with fusion in the late 2030s. It will likely never have to compete with fusion. Fusion is just ridiculously bad from a practical point of view.
- moonbug 8y agohttps://www.worldnuclearreport.org/ https://www.worldnuclearreport.org/ for a comprehensive overview of the current worldwide state of the nuclear industry.
- warabe 8y agoI am Japanese, who was in Japan and experienced Fukushima melt down in 2011(although I was not in Fukushima, Tokyo). From my perspective, people in HN village are missing a very crucial point. Nuclear power is not a problem of engineering or math, it is a problem of human nature. Yeah, I can understand the technology can control nuclear reaction 100% well, but who operate reactors? Who decide how reactors should be operated? Who develop software to control reactors? The answer is people! People in HN are so smart and very rational, so they cannot see sometimes irrational decisions are made(as happened in Fukushima) and they cannot understand some idiots do terribly stupid things(as happened in Tokaimura JOC accident). As long as human beings are involved, nothing can be perfect and safe. Also, I see in some comments people think impacts of nuclear accidents and wastes can be limited and localized. In Japan, as of 18/08, 60000 people still live in temporary housing due to Fukushima incident. We still struggle to remove debris out of nuclear power plants, and it's said it will take around 30-40 years. For me, the impact of this disaster is anything but "trivial". *edit: grammer
- daveheq 8y agoCountries other than America are just going to have to prove to the US that their safe nuclear works long-term.
- ftr45 8y agohope people will listen this obvious article , nuclear is cheaper, safer and need less resource's than any other type of energy https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-deathprint-a-price-always-paid/#658c4855709b https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-d... https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2018/09/frances-nuclear-clean-energy-is-over-three-times-faster-and-cheaper-than-germanys-solar-and-wind.html https://www.nextbigfuture.com/2018/09/frances-nuclear-clean-... https://www.oecd-nea.org/ndd/pubs/2015/7057-proj-costs-electricity-2015.pdf#p60 https://www.oecd-nea.org/ndd/pubs/2015/7057-proj-costs-elect...
- peterashford 8y agoI find the view that nuclear is the only clean option very odd when we have countries which are 100% renewable right now. And a number of countries which are very nearly there already. I see people raising issues about batteries but I'm not sure that a lot of the countries doing 100% or nearly so are using batteries at all. That looks like a straw-man to me
- samhain 8y agoI think you'll find that the majority of those countries are 100% "on certain days." Meaning that they still need to be supported by natural gas plants at the renewable site, or by nearby countries who do not have 100% renewable. Hydro power is the most efficient way of storing the extra energy right now. So people talking about batteries would be talking on a much smaller scale, or don't know what they are talking about. A large portion of the energy currently consumed is by oil tankers that burn crude directly during transport of goods across the ocean. The benefit is for transportation of the energy and fueling costs. I suspect that we will need to make energy so cheap on land and for cities that it is more cost effective to create burnable fuel for ships than to extract the oil from the ground. We are currently struggling to get our cities even at parity with renewable, but maybe with the surplus renewable energy on good days, we could convert that energy to some kind of liquid fuel that could eventually be used on these tanker ships and in planes. The only counter argument that I've seen that seems to make any sense is that we could use up too many resources trying to reach parity with the current energy consumption. Think like we run out of neodymium for all of the electric engines for both our cars and wind turbines, or run out of materials that go into making all of the solar panels. If that's actually a problem, then it seems like we would need more resource efficient ways to generate more power. So it might take a combination of renewables to power our cities, then a nuclear process heat from maybe one of the next generation reactors to efficiently create the liquid fuel for ships and planes.
- cx42net 8y agoA few things annoy me on this article. About deaths: The author says nuclear causes fewer deaths than the rest. Maybe that's true, but he (voluntarily?) omits to take into consideration long term health issues related to incidents. The Tchernobyl accident released radioactve cloud that affected many people that died of cancer or are having health issues related to it. Worse than that, it's almost impossible to track who got sick because of those clouds. So yeah, maybe just a "small set" of people died DIRECTLY following nuclear incidents, but long term effects cannot be ignored just for the sake of the argument. Next, the waste. "stored in a walmart, that degrade over time". Again, the author omits to say the duration ... over time is an understatement here, you will be long gone before that "waste" is not dangerous for environment. I stopped reading after that. The post is written in a way to force you to accept his arguments by omiting half of the true story. That's not journalism.
- mariushn 8y agoSelecting such a photo for an article aiming to promote nuclear power defeats the purpose. I actually thought that was a coal plant, until reading the fine print. Maybe the content was written by some folks, and media selection was made by others against nuclear?