23 ms·
Why Did San Francisco Schools Stop Teaching Algebra in Middle School? (2016)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dang 8y agoDiscussed at the time: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11945033 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11945033.
- cosmie 8y agoI'm conflicted on this. Having moved 18-20 times across 7 states before high school, I'm intimately familiar with the inconsistencies between curriculums that existed before common core. I was taught some things 3-4 times while others I missed entirely. I also, through a series of (in hindsight) unfortunate events, ended up at the point of taking calculus my freshman year of high school and had three years of no math before college. While it was convenient as a high schooler, it really bit me when I started college and dropped straight into advanced calculus after a three year hiatus of all things math. Harmonizing with the common core is fantastic. But school districts should also strive to harmonize with surrounding districts when it comes to "extras" like this, as well.
- foota 8y agoAs someone who graduated a couple years ago this policy change feels ridiculous to me. The difference between someone entering college with either one or two years of calculus and someone entering with precalc completed is huge, and any policy that moves away from that is a bad idea. The benefits imo are mostly around allowing more flexibility in scheduling for taking classes that require prereqs of calculus, which you're blocked from the first year otherwise. This can be compounded if you come in with many of your school's general requirements met, as this can make it hard to find classes to take that will be helpful towards your desired major. Additionally, some programs have (poorly designed) hard pipeline dependencies that mean you're set back from a couple quarters to a year if you enter without calculus completed.
- Consultant32452 8y agoThis is just another nail in the coffin of public schooling. We've watered down the high school diploma so much that 20% of high school graduates are functionally illiterate. Based on the increasing requirements for bachelor's degrees where it doesn't seem to make sense on the surface, it seems employers have caught on to how meaningless it is.
- duado 8y agoWho is “we”? Public schools at the local level in the US are very diverse. If you have the money you can find public school systems as good as Ivy League colleges, with a self-selected peer population of students with highly engaged parents.
- crispyambulance 8y ago> The difference between someone entering college > with either one or two years of calculus and > someone entering with precalc completed is huge... I am not so sure about that. Too many students enter college with a half-assed grasp of math because they were rushed and pressured through the subject matter before they were ready to handle it. Combine that with grade-inflation and the fact that so many students just can't focus on one thing at a time, leads to a really sub-optimal outcome IMHO. Students who go through private schools with mastery-based curriculum are far better prepared for rigorous college math, not because they take 2 years of calculus, but because they've actually mastered the subject matter that they've studied. There should be no shame in slowing things down but keeping the course work rigorous for college-bound students.
- lordnacho 8y agoThe only sensible reason to not teach algebra in middle school is because you've taught it in primary school. Moving it to high school sounds crazy to me. What do you do between doing your times tables and fractions in maybe 3rd or 4th grade and 9th grade? Geometry? I'm any case it's quite fortunate there's online resources like Khan Academy where kids can learn on their own.
- 0815test 8y ago> What do you do between doing your times tables and fractions in maybe 3rd or 4th grade and 9th grade? Geometry? Other countries do a sort of "pre-algebra", mostly focusing on non-trivial word problems which are then solved by setting up the equivalent to an algebraic equation, but in natural language arguments as opposed to symbols. AIUI, this sort of onboarding towards algebra is lacking in the U.S. system, and much of the difficulty that folks seem to experience w/ algebra and higher-level math might have something to do with that. (Of course, Geometry could also play a role in filling that gap. Euclidean geometry has traditionally been studied quite early, as a general introduction to mathematical rigor.) Edit: Discussed in Andrei Toom, Word Problems in Russia and America [pdf] http://www.de.ufpe.br/~toom/travel/sweden05/WP-SWEDEN-NEW.pdf http://www.de.ufpe.br/~toom/travel/sweden05/WP-SWEDEN-NEW.pd... The reference to Russia is a bit misleading - of course Russian math education is traditionally among the strongest and most effective, but the same approach to using word problems as an introduction to algebra is found in plenty of other places.
- Mirioron 8y agoIn Estonia basic algebraic equations are part of the mandatory mathematics course at age 12-13 (grade 6 here).
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoIsn’t 12-13 grade 7 if schooling begins at 5?
- 8y ago
- sanxiyn 8y agoWhat is so abstract about Algebra I? Isn't it pure rote? I mean, it's so rote that I am confident everything in Algebra I can be solved by Mathematica (or Maple) automatically.
- Ericson2314 8y agoThe roteness is different than arithmetic. It's rote constraint solving and they don't teach you the algorithm in full generality.
- Proven 8y agoTo be more inclusive - without the hard stuff everyone is happy and can complete the curriculum without unnecessary stress
- Mirioron 8y agoWhat do they mean when they talk about algebra here? Is it simply equations with variables or something more?
- barry-cotter 8y agoThe aim is to get the standards low enough for everyone to pass. It’s equations with variables.
- Mirioron 8y agoI see. I find that odd, because kids already do basic algebra in primary school. The exercises are simply written a different way. 4 + x = 9 is considered algebra, but 4 + ___ = 9 (fill in the blank) isn't. I don't see why you wouldn't be able to teach this same thing with symbols to kids in grade 8.
- barry-cotter 8y agoAbstraction is really hard. An economics professor of my acquaintance said he started requiring calculus for his game theory class so he could be sure everyone was competent with algebra. Every time you increase the level of abstraction you lose some people. Some of them can be taught it but some can’t, no matter how hard they or their teachers try.
- SilasX 8y agoInteresting. That’s probably the best reason I’ve heard for why calculus and computer science prerequisites should be similar, even when the latter doesn’t use the former: if you don’t have the abstraction capacity for calculus, you probably won’t have it for programming.
- FakeComments 8y agoIn my experience as a math tutor, they’re untaught natural abilities via poorly constructed (and hence, understandably confusing) “math” lessons taught by humanities majors turned primary school teacher. I often make the same point, and have occasionally found just rewriting it as “4 + [x] = 9” is enough to help span the conceptual bridge. Sticky notes in white board equations is another way to make this point.
- if_by_whisky 8y agoSomething feels off about this whole debate. I took algebra in 7th grade, so I naturally lean towards the "push it earlier, not later" camp. But the more I think about it, the more I'm convinced that the way we group mathematical concepts together in grade school is fundamentally boring for students. It seems like nit-picking to fall hard on one side of this "8th vs 9th" dichotomy when I actually suspect the whole math cirriculum could use a revamp from the ground up. Maybe we should consider basic discrete math in elementary school. Maybe basic calc in 6th grade. How can we get substantive, critical thinking skills earlier into the curriculum so we don't have to just assure students: "trust us, math will get interesting if you can just stick with it through calculus and linear algebra".
- yostrovs 8y agoThis development is part of a ground up movement that aims to change education from an activity in which learning is done to an activity in which the correct opinions are formed. Math, not being an opinion-based matter, gets dumbed down so that other topics can be put forth to the students.
- danbard 8y agoIt’s the kill zone competitive strategy applied to education (competitors to your children) instead of big tech. Make sure nothing can develop that threatens your family’s market position.
- mcguire 8y agoDo you have any evidence for your conspiracy theory? If not, it's not helpful for the discussion.
- ams6110 8y agoRaising kids to think about things on the basis of opinion and emotion makes it easier to get their votes when they are adults.
- Nursie 8y agoI learned basic discrete maths - simple set theory, the notation around it, simple manipulations, at the age of around 10 or 11. IIRC. This is in the UK, at a private school. Worked for me!
- hmahncke 8y agoFWIW, students in SFUSD who want to get calculus as a senior are required to “double up” on math one year - for example, taking algebra and geometry simultaneously.
- chaboud 8y agoThis feels like a joke. As a San Francisco parent, this almost certainly drives us towards private school, a luxury that not everyone has. I took algebra in sixth grade, and I'd learned the material in fourth from mother. Holding until 9th grade is baffling.
- shawndrost 8y agoIf you're worried about social justice/equity, I have great news for you: the SFUSD "joke" created dramatic and positive improvements across student demographics, including (and especially) black and Latino students. In most districts, private school is often better than public school. This is especially true in California for a variety of reasons (first and foremost Prop 13). You may wish to send your kids to private school (makes sense to me) but from the data I've seen, these changes significantly improved SFUSD's math offerings. Source: I am on an SFUSD community board and have read up on this a bit (eg https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2018/06/13/a-bold-effort-to-de-track-algebra-shows.html https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2018/06/13/a-bold-effort-...) but I'm always interested in learning more!
- geebee 8y agoThanks for your reply, and for the links. I followed them and read through them, but I did it quickly, I'll take another look later. I don't think the data supports the change as an unqualified success. The article you posted (again, I quick read it) doesn't compare calculus enrollment before and after the change. This article from the chronicle provides that data: https://www.sfchronicle.com/education/article/SF-schools-move-to-delay-algebra-shows-13518860.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/education/article/SF-schools-mov... "While more students are taking precalculus now, the enrollment in Advanced Placement calculus courses has declined by nearly 13 percent over the past two years. Enrollment in AP Statistics, which requires only Algebra II as a prerequisite, has surged nearly 50 percent." My understanding is that all courses other than calc that require algebra have seen higher retention and enrollment. So we could view this as a qualified success, a trade-off: better results pre-calc, at the cost of fewer students taking calc. Keep in mind, we don't know how many of the students who are now succeeding in Stats would have been succeeding in Calc, were it not for the change. We are also only given percentage increases/decreases. Without starting populations, we actually don't know if the increase in Stats offsets the decrease in Calc. Unfortunately, this is precisely the trade-off people were worried about. Fewer of the top students are taking calc. Any claim of success must address this. FWIW, I do agree with that last bit from the article, about calc in high school not being quite as essential as (some) people think. If an entering college student has very strong algebra, trig, and pre-calc (let's say the ability to solve elaborate algebraic equations involving trig functions, logs, various exponentials, tricky multivariable quotients... and really gets it), then I don't think the lack of formal calc would be all that big a problem. Then again, calc is a good way to get into those kinds of equations.
- danbard 8y agoIt seems that an excellent predictor of policy in SF is: will it increase inequality and the advantage of the very rich while being presented with liberal rhetoric? Then do it. This is a great way to keep smart but poor kids from competing with private school kids.
- yostrovs 8y agoSince the graduates of SF public schools are expected to leave the city and make room for wealthier folks, the use they will still have for the city is as ambassadors of San Francisco's political views to the rest of the country, where they will be able to afford to live.
- FakeComments 8y agoGlibly, metastasized leftists. I think that’s the most natural model for a virtue-signaling economic sinkhole that can’t sustain a viable population, but is trying to spread its governance ideas anyway: it’s literally analogous to unhealthy cells using false signaling to sinkhole resources while replicating their damaged DNA — a cancer. It’s not just SF: Seattle, NYC, and basically every major metro that subscribes to particular left-wing ideas. For the perspective on Seattle: https://youtu.be/bpAi70WWBlw https://youtu.be/bpAi70WWBlw
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoThis is also across the board in most California districts. Not just SF. (This article is dated 2016) I posted this because in our Bay Area school district, algebra and geometry was an accelerated course with just 35 students. (In just one school of the district) Selected by lottery. It costs 7500/year but they want to get rid of it. Teachers are also planning to strike. To me, it looks like funding in CA public schools is no longer about education but about the care and feeding of public sector unionized employees. Parents are horrified but in the same neighborhood thread, teachers are using it to ask the parents to support them. Students are given extra credit if they show their support for work the rule(only school work hours and no more clubs and extra classes like this) and strikes and walk outs. It’s all mind blowing to me(I don’t have kids in the public school system) and I can’t wrap my mind around this. I have been approached by friends who are parents and don’t want to be vocal about their kids children in the community forums as I don’t have the vulnerabilities of parents whose kids are already in the system. Certain Asian/Indian parents send their kids to tutoring classes which is seen as elitist and reactions have been borderline racist. I just tell my friends to pull their kids from public school if they can afford it or homeschool them. I am very impressed with khan academy. I looked into it and I find myself learning from their classes. I have to ask ...what is the point of public education in CA anymore? Should educational methods change and the way we teach subjects change? Conformity is tyranny at this point. Teachers overload kids with useless assignments and the real learning happens after school in tutoring centers. And then the kids have to learn extra curricular subjects especially as they get closer to applying for universities. This is supposed to make them ‘well rounded’ but it only makes them depressed, stressed and uninterested in education. They become cynical and jaded and entirely unprepared when they go to college. It’s worse for the smart kids as they are bored but still have to go through the motions. Maybe it’s time to revamp public education.
- jimhefferon 8y agoIt'd be good to hear from some Middle School teachers. Any here?
- grawprog 8y agoThey started teaching us algebra in grade 5. It took me until my first year university to really fully understand it. A lot of this was due to my own lack of efforts but also due to lousy teachers. The math teacher I had university was probably one of the best teachers i've ever had for any subject. I pretty much owe my ability to understand math to that teacher.
- rtkwe 8y agoIt's an unfortunate fact that teachers that really enjoy and understand their subjects is a rare treat and most people won't have the chance to encounter one in all subjects till college. I think there would be a lot of use for teachers to get additional training in whatever field they're teaching so they have a deeper understanding than just what they remember and what's taught by the book. I don't even really blame the teachers so much because they got into the work to teach generally not to teach a specific subject they may get stuck with.
- rdtsc 8y agoThis seems so strange to me, this sharp distinction between algebra and non-algebra. I might have gone to school in the Soviet system so everything was backwards and such but we were introduced to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elementary_algebra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elementary_algebra very early and just did simple expression transformations, variable substitutions. That was a lot early than 8th grade. I even taught my 2nd grader a few of those. I have observed the curriculum so far in US, at least up until the 2nd grade and it's a hot mess. Even for double digit addition problems they jump right into "cool tricks" and "mathematical thinking" while there are just really a few steps to memorize and, guess what, kids are great at memorizing stuff. Later on it's time to show a few short-cuts and kids even discover those themselves. Now going back to algebra, I am firm believer that a simplified version of this has to be introduced much earlier. It's a bit like a spiral, do basic arithmetic, geometry, number line manipulation, simple word problems, next year do the same but more complicated, add some algebra in there and so on. But I guess that's just too boring and teachers, and probably higher level authorities, decide that they need to do "something" so they start making changes just to they can slap something on their resume. Developers do that too some extent, "here let me rewrite all this..." we can certainly understand that, but doesn't mean it's a good thing.
- tomohawk 8y agoCurriculum, most especially through 6th grade, is driven very much what whatever fad catches hold in the education establishment. It changes every 2 - 3 years. It's really just a symptom that there is very little accountability for the people making these decisions. Put out a curriculum with poor results? Who's going to notice? If anyone does, who will have the power to do something about it?
- linuxftw 8y agoThis lack of feedback can be extrapolated to the entire government. It's a well defined problem: https://mises.org/library/economic-calculation-socialist-commonwealth https://mises.org/library/economic-calculation-socialist-com...
- zxcvvcxz 8y agoI think in places like SF they are more concerned with teaching young children about sex and condoms and people with mental illnesses, not algebra.
- dang 8y agoOk, since you're continuing to post unsubstantive comments after we asked you to stop, I've banned this account. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.
- geebee 8y agoI read this article with a lot of interest a while ago, since I have a kid in middle school in SFUSD. Having been through the system, I think the whole thing is pretty stupid. People, seriously, the problem with math achievement in SFUSD is not a function of whether we favor concept development or technical approaches. The problems are far deeper. We can only dream of being at the the point where this sort of debate is actually what matters. I think what happened is that US educators looked at Finland (among other places that have high math scores) and saw that there is more development of concept and less emphasis on technical drill. So they went back and made a curriculum that does, like, the concept thing. Interestingly, they just don't seem to want to copy that part where math teachers (well, all teachers) are a highly talented and respected group of professionals, drawn from the upper tier of graduates. I think that the US failed to understand that Finland does things this way because it's how talented teachers who are good at math teach math. You can't put this in a curriculum, hand it off, and get the same results without that talent base. And if you have that talent base with autonomy to do the job properly, well, they'll probably do it regardless of the curriculum. Until we address this (it's not the only thing we need to address), this whole debate is worthless.
- duado 8y agoLowering educational standards to meet the needs of the 20th percentile student is preternaturally stupid and is why we’ll be moving out of San Francisco before our kids are in school.
- halfnibble 8y ago""" ...unequal access to high quality education is a comparable injustice to unequal access to the ballot box and is "the clearest manifestation of the nation's caste system." """ The real caste system in education is those who can afford to send their kids to a high-performing private school vs. those who cannot. This solution only exacerbates that problem.
- droithomme 8y ago> the real caste system in education is those who can afford to send their kids to a high-performing private school Is the problem here is not with the public school system, but rather with the existence of high performing private schools? Should these schools be banned? Perhaps along with private tutoring? Such policies might well lead to increases in equality of outcome.
- nickysielicki 8y agoI went to a parochial grade school and hated it. I begged my parents to take me out, and by the time 7th grade came around, they gave in. Unlike my siblings, I went to public school for 7th and 8th grade. In retrospect, if I ever have children, I would make every sacrifice imaginable to ensure they go to private schools. No amount of complaining from them would ever make me reconsider. I believe that actively working to prevent top students from making too much progress over the median student is the norm in all public schools. It is wrong that we primarily divide the thousands of students in a given school district by the year they were born.
- snarf21 8y agoI agree with your last point whole-heartedly. We need to start adjusting for ability and proficiency as early as 2nd grade. The big challenge with all teaching is that you must teach to the "middle" ability child. Instead of splitting by age we should be splitting into groups like the top 45% in one class, the next 35% in the next and the bottom 20% in the last. This lets each child have more or less time based on the aptitude and creates smaller deviance between the "middle" and top/bottom of each group.
- soVeryTired 8y agoThe stigma of being in the bottom 20% is hard to get rid of, though.
- snarf21 8y agoAbsolutely true. However, everyone knows who the kids are that got an F on the test anyway. In this structure, they get more help and may be more able to get a C- instead. It is even more so with math since everything builds on previous knowledge unlike something like history.
- tropo 8y agoStigma isn't all bad. It's a motivating factor. Decades ago, the norm was to post grades on the wall for all to see. We lost a lot of motivation when we got rid of that.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jccalhoun 8y agoThe article really buries the relevant info: >the CCSS Math 8 course that eighth graders are now expected to take includes 60% of the material from the old Algebra I course. This includes linear equations, roots, exponents, and an introduction to functions. The new course also offers students a taste of geometry and statistics—hardly your typical middle school fare. So it isn't really that big of a deal...
- SubiculumCode 8y agoI would not advocate for removal of algebra from middle school. But I would consider advocating removal of add/subtract/multiply/divide facts from grades 1-5, and replace the time with learning of how to reason. I feel like learning you math facts, rules for multiplication, etc challenge children early on, but could be taught to a naive middle school child within a couple of weeks or less. Thus teaching this to young children seems like waited effort with little transfer benefit. On the other hand, getting children interested in learning, learning how to organize thoughts into an argument, etc...there is clear benefit for that, I wonder.
- gumby 8y agoWhat an interesting article. I ready it for a bit of morning outrage and now find the issue far more complex and subtle than I had thought. My own child entered the US system in grade 8 as it happens and due to language issues was tracked into algebra, which was mostly stuff he’d had a couple of years before (not because he was an advanced student, simply how his German system had worked). He wasn’t able to get back on track until the end of the year. So I of course assumed this change would be a disastrous concession. Now I’m not yet sure what to think.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI am curious if you are in CA and if your child was picked because english wasn’t ‘spoken at home’. CA has a funding formula that takes money from all districts and put it in a common pot. Better well funded schools are no longer assigned according to affluence of neighbourhood. Funding for schools is then redistributed act to principles of no child left behind..which means that if there are more kids in a school that avail free lunch/meals or if they don’t speak English at home(English not native language), then the school can ask for more $$ from Sacramento. In my school district, kids fluent in English are often tracked to non English speaking/English as second language streams to tap into these funds. It’s a bit of a mess because affluent areas don’t get enough funding but teachers need salaries for standard of living costs in said affluent areas...so most of the funding goes to salaries and then to cover unfunded pension liabilities of staff. Eventually students perform due to parent involvement and extra tutoring classes after school hours. They do end up over worked and stressed out.
- gumby 8y agoThat's interesting! Yes California, but it was a private school (chosen mainly because it had a low snooty factor but also because it had both English literature and English language/writing as two different subjects) so the problem was he didn't know any of the vocab when given a placement test so they just threw him in the default classes.
- gumby 8y agoI'm a fan of "common pot" but it doesn't work as well as one might like: in the public schools here in Palo Alto the parents routinely hold auctions that raise multiple millions of dollars which goes into paying for things that I think every kid should be getting (art, PE, music, an aide in the classroom etc). PTA donations got so extreme that the school district had to implement the same "one pot" approach just to spread the money around the schools in the Palo Alto school district.
- ben7799 8y agoI wonder what level the public school 8th grade teachers are at with their Algebra at this point and what that has to do with this. I get the impression there are very few 8th grade math teachers who studied math in college as their first choice and then transitioned to education. There are too many more attractive STEM careers if you are inclined towards math, and the best math teachers in a school district are likely to be teaching the advanced 11th and 12th graders. I took Algebra in public school in 8th grade in 1990. The public school was pretty bad, I remember how frequently we (the 8th graders) were correcting the teacher, he was that bad he was screwing up the examples on the board almost every class. I got sent to Catholic School for high school. Everyone in the math department had an advanced math degrees. Calculus was taught by a PhD. The curriculum blended Algebra/Geometry/Trig/Calculus across all 4 years instead of the "one thing at a time approach." I remember being very cognizant of thinking I was probably better at algebra by the end of 9th grade than my public school 8th grade teacher had been. The quality difference in the teachers for math was mind blowing between the two schools.
- WhompingWindows 8y agoThe article restates a presumption that by offering advanced students harder coursework, they are "leaving behind" the rest of the students. However, by the very same logic, if 20% of the kids get ahead by one year, aren't we just leaving behind 80% there, vs 100% in the no-algebra-offering scenario? In most analyses of STEM, the top echelon of US students is NOT behind the rest of the world's top echelon: it's only in the medians/means, accounting for the vast number of poorly performing Americans, do we see the international STEM education gap. Therefore, I'd argue this policy is actually detrimental to the one and only group of students we are doing well with in the USA, namely the top tier of students.
- tanilama 8y agoThis mentality is just regressive. I find funny such evil and stupidity can be carried out in the name of fairness and equality. Well done.
- KorematsuFred 8y agoWhy should some pen pushing bureaucrats get to decide what is good for American kids ? Shouldn't that be left to parents ?
- shawndrost 8y ago(I sit on an SFUSD community board.) There are many strong opinions (ITT and elsewhere) about how algebra should obviously be taught in middle school. The data I've seen does not support those conclusions. Eg [1][2]. This is kind of an interesting article, but it really does not convey the essential facts at hand. Middle school alg harms student achievement. Many/most students end up retaking it anyway (!!!) and there is a simple and effective fix. SFUSD should be lauded for braving the political heat. Maybe there is a kind of educational system where middle school alg is a good idea. But our system is not that kind of system. If you live/vote in SF please support evidence-based practices and common sense. <3 [1] https://www.edweek.org/media/2018/06/11/v37-35-algebra-chart600.jpg https://www.edweek.org/media/2018/06/11/v37-35-algebra-chart... [2] "But in a 2015 study, the University of North Carolina's Thurston Domina and colleagues tracked how California's uneven 8th grade algebra-for-all rollout played out across districts. In a surprise finding, they discovered that higher enrollments in early algebra were linked to a decline in students' scores on a state math test." https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2018/06/13/a-bold-effort-to-de-track-algebra-shows.html https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2018/06/13/a-bold-effort-...
- cwbrandsma 8y agoWhat form of achievement are we talking about? I’m seeing schools were anything less than all A’s is a failure. Are we dropping because kids are getting C’S?
- shawndrost 8y agoI'll recap the links I dropped in case they're hard to digest or whatever. They cover two measurements of achievement: * Before this change, 40% of SFUSD students had to retake Alg. After this change, it was 10%. * In a separate study focused on statewide 2008 effects of middle school alg, "enrolling more students in [middle school alg] has negative average effects on [10th-grade standardized test scores]". This SFUSD plan does not seem dumb from what I can tell, and I'm an informed and interested observer. Change my mind!
- supernova87a 8y agoThe problem is that a country's technological advancement is not usually based on the mean performance of everyone, or the equity of the population in general achieving a minimum level. A country's advancement is based largely on the outstanding rockstars / top performers and their innovation. I'm afraid this is trading off wanting to help students who are low achieving, at the expense of the highest performers getting to achieve their potential. Of course the step that SFUSD took led to fewer students retaking the class later. You make a class easier / later, and of course everyone will pass more successfully. But did it measure how many students were held back from higher achievement? Of course not, there is no good way to quantify that. China and India, who let far fewer aspects of equality, racial/group concerns, privacy and self-esteem issues interfere with their schooling, are going to eat our lunch.
- golemiprague 8y agoThe whole school system in many countries of the western world is subverted to cater for the lower non common denomination. With the increase in diversity there are more extreme distribution of IQ, conscientiousness and other traits which creates very polarised classes or schools in general. It is not without reason that the leading countries in studies are places like Japan or Finland, countries with a very homogeneous society and culture. People may argue that their system is good but I can bet Japanese methods of learning and behaviour will just not work in most other places around the world that are not culturally and racially close to Japan. Add to that the undercutting of the working class by mass immigration and you got a whole lot of people who shouldn't have been in the high education system in the first places fighting for the accreditation that doesn't fit their skill or tendency just so they won't have to compete for under or minimum wage paying jobs with illegal immigrants. Diversity is not our strength, diversity is a disaster and the cause of most of the problems in the western world right now. Diversity is a strength when each group is predominantly segregated to their own country, then true creativity and the unique cultural and personal traits of each group of people can shine and generate the multiple cultures this world have. There will always be some level of intermixing, that's normal and we should thrive to treat well and cater for all people in our society, but we should also start to think how to limit this to a reasonable level which will not affect society.
- AngryData 8y agoPeople were only learning algebra at 8th grade?! That is garbage! My school introduced algebra in 5th grade, legit algebra I was in 6th grade.
- MagicPropmaker 8y agoSo because not all kids are able to grasp these concepts in middle school, nobody can learn it in middle school.
- BXLE_1-1-BitIs1 8y agoI hear so much moaning about students with "poor math skills" when it's really poor arithmetic skills. The moaners typically wouldn't recognise a differential equation if it hit them in the face.
- fmajid 8y agoIt has more to do with the left-wing ideology of the San Francisco school district, and its loathing for anything that might resemble elitism. There's a reason why private schools are so expensive in SF. Parents are abandoning public schools faster than new private schools can expand to meet demand.