33 ms·
Facebook Loses Top Executives, Including Chris Cox
- endofcapital 8y agoSo the possible #2 (it was debatable as to whether Sandberg or Cox would have take over) and the person who run Whatsapp just quit. Some pretty big power struggles going down it seems.
- nhf 8y agoFor those who aren't FB insiders, what is the read on this? Do the two Chris' reputation in the company have any bearing on how this is read?
- howard941 8y ago> As part of this, I’m sad to share the news that Chris Cox has decided to leave the company. "this" reads as though Cox's departure is a result of the decision to build out a "privacy-focused social platform".
- draw_down 8y agoNo it doesn't, read the paragraph immediately following the one you quoted from.
- holler 8y agothat's what I thought as well, and I can't help but get a major sense of skepticism when Mark mentions "facebook" and "privacy-focused" in the same sentence.
- jey 8y agoThis quote is from to the original link used by this post: https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2019/03/a-note-from-mark-zuckerberg/ https://newsroom.fb.com/news/2019/03/a-note-from-mark-zucker...
- dboreham 8y agoThat's how it is intended to read.
- milin 8y agoAnd nothing about the massive downtime fb just experienced yesterday.
- sgt 8y agoLuckily it's not a critical service, nor is Instagram. WhatsApp is probably the most critical as a lot of people depend on it every day, even for business purposes.
- kzrdude 8y agoWhy is that, is it incidental or based on the features they offer?
- chc 8y agoOut of the handful of messaging services with end-to-end encryption, I'm pretty sure Whatsapp is the most popular. So the security would probably be the main driver, and the popularity would be why Whatsapp in particular.
- edgarvaldes 8y agoThere are countries (Brazil, Mexico) where B2C use Whatsapp as an official communication channel: displayed on flyers, TV ads, etc. Whatsapp is huge here, so it is only natural to be used as a commercial tool as well.
- eugeniub 8y agoWhatsApp is a Facebook product.
- cheeze 8y agoAgree. I don't think something like FB or even Amazon.com going down has huge impact. People just come back later and get what they need done. OTOH, having a subscription based service in specific going down can be catastrophic because you lose so much customer trust (think Azure, Spotify, etc.). In that sense, I guess amazon.com can be bad too with things like prime video, etc.
- tuxxy 8y agoAre these choices of the individuals or were they asked to resign? It seems pretty odd that all these people would just decide to leave _at the same time_.
- ProAm 8y agoYes
- munk-a 8y agohttps://outline.com/yTPSbh https://outline.com/yTPSbh (An outline version for those tracking aware or blocked on corporate nets)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hashberry 8y agoInteresting spin from the NYTimes ("Facebook Loses Top Executives, Including Chris Cox"[0]): "The departures follow two years of scandals for Facebook around data privacy and disinformation. The issues have buffeted the Silicon Valley company, causing internal turmoil and a redirection in strategy." [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/14/technology/facebook-chris-cox.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/14/technology/facebook-chris...
- annadane 8y agoThis is what pisses me off. I'm more than willing to criticize Facebook when they deserve it but IMO the media blitzkrieg has said more about the media than Facebook. Not that FB hasn't done scummy things but my faith in the whole attack angle has been reduced
- chc 8y agoThey leaked tens of millions of people's personal information to third parties without so much as notifying them. There were congressional hearings about their privacy violations. Facebook is very publicly pivoting to emphasize personal privacy much more than they have before. It seems like a pretty legitimate bit of context more than an attack.
- lph 8y agoThey’re very publicly pivoting to /claiming/ to take privacy seriously. I don’t know why anyone would believe them, given their track record, continued willful ignorance about the actual definition of privacy, and vested interest in mining every detail about their users to achieve better ad targeting.
- JeremyBanks 8y agoFacebook has been consistently and intentionally abusive of their users since its founding. The media isn't being too aggressive now: they've been too lenient for the previous decade. The outrage has finally caught up with the outrageous reality.
- 8y ago
- throwaway23445 8y agoChris was one of the rare people who understood both the technical side and business side of a product/business. There were so many times where an engineer would start blabbling big terms to avoid doing something or an PM spouts MBA Bullshit and Chris just shuts it down. What outsiders who focused on the PR never knew is that there was a balance of power in FB that kept things going forward. Now, with these changes along with Jan Koum leaving last year, I don't know if there is anyone with enough influence to counterbalance the Sheryl-driven short-termism view. For people without real defined values, "privacy centric" is yet another empty cover to do exactly the opposite.
- debt 8y agoAs the leader of Facebook's products he essentially was directly responsible for the total neglect of the Facebook Developer program which caused the biggest PR disaster in FB's history; not to mention, the misuse of user data collected through the program by Cambridge Analytica. I fail to see how he was a good leader vs riding the wave of Facebook's success. Sounds like Facebook eventually outgrew him anyway so they fired him.
- Gimpei 8y agoWhat was the philosophical difference between the two? Short-termism vs what?
- lwb 8y agoLong-termism?
- james_s_tayler 8y agoSheryl-driven development?
- hashberry 8y agoI'm curious about this as well. From her Wikipedia article[0] and experience in online sales, maybe it means this: > Author Shoshana Zuboff called Sandberg "the Typhoid Mary of surveillance capitalism." [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheryl_Sandberg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sheryl_Sandberg
- Toine 8y ago> But after 2016, we both realized we had too much important work to do to improve our products for society "Primum non nocere." I cannot help but laugh at this statement. I think Facebook has done, and is still doing, way more harm than good for society. Like many other addiction-based services, it generated massive revenues for very few people, at the expense of society.
- andrei_says_ 8y agoThe doublespeak is staggering. Fb is in the business of destroying people’s privacy, robbing them of their attention, and manipulating political choices for the highest bidder. It walls off people’s relationships and communication and focuses on making its product as addictive as possible. Even if we don’t mention some of the darkest practices like defrauding children of money, FB is intentionally evil, and they know it. I just re-watched Cal Newport’s talk on social media and I’m enjoying my second week without fb and Twitter. Highly recommended. https://youtu.be/3E7hkPZ-HTk https://youtu.be/3E7hkPZ-HTk
- stickfigure 8y agoMy friends and I derive significant value from keeping in touch via Facebook. I find your attitude condescending and insulting.
- ordinaryradical 8y agoI just don't understand how anyone can believe his vision for "a privacy-focused social network" is even possible this late in the game. There is too much money riding precisely on the reductions of privacy Facebook has enabled for this to be realistic anymore. The ad dollars come from knowing you, not concealing you. Plus, once you're a public company, the rules change—you have shareholders to honor—and if you got to that IPO by being shady or unethical, backing out of that position is going to be nigh impossible. Their entire business model developed itself on a privacy-destroying data-suck of colossal proportions so where is profitability without that? "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it."
- coliveira 8y agoThis is a PR stunt, as pretty much everything FB says about data privacy.
- hashberry 8y agoSome theories: 1. Rebranding Facebook as secure and private 2. If this increases usage, more opportunity to display ads 3. Their data shows they gain more information by monitoring what people publicly share, not say in private 4. Removes all responsibility to work with law enforcement and governments for illegal activity, since it's encrypted
- ilovecaching 8y agoCould you ever consider that Zuck has enough money, and that he really believes in making a product to connect people for the greater good and use ads to make it available to everyone?
- iaabtpbtpnn 8y agoNo, because Facebook is a public for-profit company, not a non-profit seeking to benefit society.
- AceJohnny2 8y ago
- arunv 8y agoChris Cox is a huge loss for Facebook. His first day speech is still the reason Facebook has the strongest culture in the valley.
- jameslk 8y agoI'm not familiar with this. Kind of a big assertion to make. What was his first day speech?
- evgen 8y agoAt FB you have your first-day orientation and as a part of this Cox came in and gave a speech. I have no idea if it is the same speech to every week's 'class' or an evolving variation on the same themes, but it was a pretty good speech and is probably one reason why people are so eager to drink the kool-aid for the first few years.
- DataJunkie 8y agoI remember the speech. It had no effect on how much I looked forward to waking up in the morning to go work there.
- tyre 8y ago> Facebook has the strongest culture in the valley For a company so regularly beset by scandal, this feels like a bold assertion. Culture of what?
- arunv 8y agoAny other company in their shoes would have had a mass exodus. Chris was a big part of making employees feel like they shared a piece of the dream. Whatever your thoughts about Facebook, the fact that some of the smartest people have worked, and continue to work at a company "beset by scandal" should give you pause.
- 8y ago
- i_am_nomad 8y ago“privacy-focused social platform” See also: “sobriety-focused keg party” “health-focused donut shop” “quality-focused downvotes”
- sixothree 8y agoThis sort of thinking fits into the old mindset of how people envisioned facebook. Just a year or two ago the prevailing consensus was "don't post it if you don't wan't it public". But people have since realized that facebook collects far more than what you give them. It pays for data. It mines data from millions of web sets. It follows you around in ways people don't understand. maybe "key part where the host sneakily follows you around on a daily basis to better understand your drinking habits" would be more appropriate.
- mohsen1 8y agoWhat happened to their "Blockchain" division?
- i_am_nomad 8y agoIt’s forked.
- Touche 8y agoCan someone tldr; this please? It seems like some people "left" the company because Facebook is taking a PR hit on its bad privacy practices. Is that right?
- exabrial 8y agoThey just spent the last 5 years drilling into their employees a culture where online privacy doesn't exist, I think it's going to be pretty steep turn of the ship. Nevertheless I hope the announcement is not merely lip-service. I'd love to see the same commitment out of Google.
- zecg 8y agoGoogle+ was good privacy-wise.
- o10449366 8y agoIn what sense? Google exposed the information of 500,000 Google+ users and tried to conceal it. "Chief Executive Sundar Pichai was briefed on the plan not to notify users after an internal committee had reached that decision, the people said." [0] [0] https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-exposed-user-data-feared-repercussions-of-disclosing-to-public-1539017194 https://www.wsj.com/articles/google-exposed-user-data-feared...
- ElijahLynn 8y agoWhat is the tldr of this?
- mindgam3 8y agoI've known Chris Cox since freshman year of college and he was an informal advisor to my first startup. The NYT article referenced in hashberry's earlier comment includes a key quote: “For over a decade, I’ve been sharing the same message that Mark and I have always believed: Social media’s history is not yet written, and its effects are not neutral,” Mr. Cox said in a note to employees on Thursday. “As its builders we must endeavor to understand its impact — all the good, and all the bad — and take up the daily work of bending it towards the positive, and towards the good.” “This is our greatest responsibility,” he added.' When the Chief Product Officer says on his way out that "social media is not neutral" and encourages all employees to bend it towards the good... you barely have to read between the lines to understand what's really happening. The real story here isn't the "spin" from the NYT. It's the fact that Facebook is hemorrhaging its best people as those on the inside finally start waking up to the fact that Zuckerberg's vision of Facebook as a good thing for the world was a lie. If the guy who is officially in charge of product and who has been there since 2005 can't make a difference, what chance does anyone else have? Source: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/14/technology/facebook-chris-cox.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/14/technology/facebook-chris...
- debt 8y ago"hemorrhaging its best people" I don't consider people that oversaw one of the biggest cases of user data misuse in history which, by the way, could've been easily prevented, as the "best people". Sounds like Facebook is making the changes necessary to rectify the mess they oversaw.
- DataJunkie 8y agoI used to be a fan of Facebook, but I was never obsessed with it. I even used to work there. I'm over it. It's useful for groups, some of the ads really are useful, it's nice to sometimes keep up with people that are far away, but the news feed has had done way more harm than good for our society, including my own life. After the 2016 Election, Facebook posts lead to so much drama in my family that certain "branches" of the tree have unfriended and blocked each other and we haven't spoken since. My dad and I constantly argue because he will see some comment I made on someone else's post and have to give his own opinion, or read to me what the other person said back. There is no way to turn this part of the feed off. Overall, it is a totally unpleasant product to use now. The only reason I want it to succeed is because I own stock from when I worked there.
- prewett 8y agoIf the only reason you want the company to succeed is because you own stock, that sounds like a good reason to not own the stock. Besides, if other people start feeling the way you do, the stock is not likely to do very well, so if you believe your feeling is representative, you might want to consider it a sell signal.
- DataJunkie 8y agoI agree. I am not good at the stock market.
- therealdrag0 8y agoThis and another NYT had quotes implying they're gonna try shift towards more private communications. I hope they pull it off, but I wont hold my breath.
- mullingitover 8y ago> There is no way to turn this part of the feed off. Unfollow everyone, and you don't get sucked into interacting with the facebook feed. Use it for Messenger, groups, and events. I've been doing that, and facebook is a perfectly good communication utility without any of the grief. Honestly, we as users should demand a simple switch that entirely disables the feed. It turns facebook from a socially messy skinner box into something benign and generally quite useful.
- keyle 8y agoSide note... Outline.com doesn't want to outline nytimes articles anymore...?
- shosko 8y agoWhy would anyone want to work for Facebook these days? When you are maintaining the largest advertising stream since TV while actively destroying society's discourse, I'm not sure what redeeming qualities it has. I think the most important thing any of us can do is get away from Facebook and move towards pursuits that fix problems, including the ones Facebook helped create.
- x3n0ph3n3 8y agoMy wife has been doing taxes for a few people at Facebook (including engineers and PMs) -- many of them make an absurd amount of money. (>$800k / year)
- freyir 8y agoI deleted Facebook, and it’s still finding ways to annoy me.
- streblo 8y agoI'm not sure if it's a fiduciary duty of an accountant not to disclose this kind of stuff, but it should be.
- iscrewyou 8y agoAs long as she doesn’t associate names with those salaries in the conversation, i don’t think it’s unethical. Or she doesn’t act on those salaries and commit some kind of security fraud, it’s just a conversation.
- x3n0ph3n3 8y agoIt's no different than with an ER doctor. They can say "some idiot wearing a McDonalds uniform came in with a bottle stuck in his ass" but they cannot say "John Smith came in with a bottle stuck up his ass."
- hypertext7 8y agoThat's great for the ones that make that much, but this kind of information is what's causing Bay Area housing and rent prices to sky-rocket. I have worked with multiple engineers in two large corps and most people make anywhere between 100k and 200k.
- hemantv 8y agoSome of the good things are happening, they are starting to lose good talent, it's only a matter of time before they are replaced. Repeating what I said earlier https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17614163 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17614163 This company is the drug dealer of Silicon Valley. They have consciously destroyed a generation attention span using psychological tricks.
- yaseer 8y agoFacebook is big tobacco. Intelligent people generating profits that knowingly harms society (even if you do get some joy from a cigarette, that doesn't justify working for a tobacco company). I really hope the smart people at Facebook see the obvious parallel, and choose another career. History will judge you.
- jedberg 8y agoNot exactly. Tobacco has no benefits to society except possibly a dopamine hit for the user. Facebook has a lot of positives to go along with its negatives. For me, it's the only way I stay in touch with a lot of my friends from high school. And I know that it's only because of Facebook, because Facebook didn't exist for the first 10 years after I graduated, and most of my friends didn't get on it until about 15 years after graduation. It was great finally reconnecting them with them all. They are people whose company I enjoyed, but we just didn't have the time to have individual conversations every week with the 50 people we knew from school. Having a way for them to broadcast updates has been super helpful. Also, the Portal is great. I got a pair when they came out, and it's easy enough that my four year old will call her grandparents regularly without my help. It's the only platform that we've found that is easy enough for both the four year old and my parents. I use messenger and WhatsApp to keep in touch with friends in other countries. They are easy to find because we're friends on Facebook. So yeah, Facebook still has a lot of positives for society. I don't judge someone who works there just for working there. I hope that they are working to enhance the positives and minimize the negatives. From what I've seen with the folks I've talked to, that is always the case.
- arendtio 8y agoI hope you are aware that the positive effect you describe also has a negative side. Those people who refuse to join Facebook (for good reasons as we were taught) are getting isolated. So who can tell what the net result is?
- mav3rick 8y agoThis is such a stupid argument. If 5 people do something that the 6th person doesn't want to ..doesn't mean the onus is on the 5 to stop doing it.
- musicale 8y agoHere is my informal ranking of Facebook's biggest problems: 1. Facebook itself (built on multiple harmful feedback loops) 2. Facebook's business model (selling eyeballs, etc. to advertisers) 3. Mark Zuckerberg (expansion justifies anything) 4. Facebook's customers (advertisers who only care about influence) 5. Facebook's users (rotting apples in a rotten barrel)
- variable11 8y agoLeaving the company should not make them immune to prosecution for criminal collection and sale of personal data.
- untog 8y ago> The differences stemmed from Mr. Zuckerberg’s asserting control over his company and its apps — Instagram, WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger — by rolling out a plan to integrate the services into a single privacy-focused platform, according to six people involved in the situation. I'm mystified as to why Zuckerberg would let them leave over this. It very simply doesn't seem like a good idea (how many WhatsApp users know FB even owns it? What good does it do to remind them?) and when you've got major product heads disagreeing with you it's time to make a clear argument. So far I haven't seen one.
- o10449366 8y ago(Reposting since the parent comment I replied to was deleted) Twitter, YouTube, Facebook, and Whatsapp have all been (and continue to be) exploited to spread messages of hate and ignorance. It seems strange to me that Facebook is coming under so much criticism relative to the other platforms when, from my perspective, they've also been the most proactive about trying to address these issues and dedicated significant resources to moderation. That isn't to say that these moves have been successful or productive, but I haven't heard anything from Twitter recently regarding trying to minimize hate speech and ignorance on its platform (and its the worst service for divisiveness, in my opinion). Google only just recently demonetized anti-Semitic and anti-vax material on YouTube and only after significant backlash from its advertisers (not its users who have been calling for a response for years). Why is this?
- _bxg1 8y agoI don't see how they can make money on truly private communications channels. If they aren't gathering data, and they aren't showing ads (who would put up with ads in IM?), where does the money come from? Is it just a way to hold on to users for future monetization?
- _underfl0w_ 8y agoI think it's actually just a red herring. I think one could better define "private" in this context to mean "between two individuals", with the false implication that they mean "away from advertisers". Facebook has proven itself an exception to Hanlon's Razor by this point, so I'd say its probably deliberate.
- _bxg1 8y agoPerhaps, but WhatsApp is already (allegedly) "truly private". I've never understood how it makes money.
- marcotaves 8y agowhat would be a manner of having people creating their family and friends comments and photos on an enviroment mostly hosted on one of the group members phone, so information is mostly...let me think...information at a ceartain level of size lets say 1 Giga for example, then it would autosave the oldest data, so in this case no more then for example 10 days of data is stored, because the storage is at local device phone of a member of a group...so the old info is saved on the local server or even at a central server but contained in the access and supervision of the host member of the group...just ideas...no underlines... I sometimes imagine I would like to see a socialmedia where no need for names, there is a map, like runescape map or mix of google maps and google earth and runescape map and at certain points you can see a mark like a map mark or something and a sign that reads I was here on summer on a rainy sunny morning and started to snow and I was there to meet someone I date in the newspapaer but when I sit on the bench was a brazilian guy and we becaome good friend really and after half hour of talk We realiza I was not talking with the guy I was supose to know , to meet in a casual newspaper date and it was so fun... Or you see a little pink heart on the map near the lake you use to go as teenager to summer camp or vacations and it says Jenny was sitting near by this tree in the summer of that year... or you see a little starbucks coffee paper cup on the Map point of your corners coffee place where you saw the red haired girl yesterday and the comment on that arrow says Hey, guy on blue shirt, im the red shirt... Or just say a name like a given name like... I was in this school when I was 6 and I remember my friend Alexandre with blue eyes... on an little icone at the map, righ... I think it would be a fun social network... I hope all people and employees on social media jobs around the world be well and confident that things are going better... ...thanks...
- ulfw 8y agoThe rats are leaving the sinking privacy nightmare ship? If the co-founders of your only significantly growing products (Whatsapp and Instagram) leave (publicly in disgust about product direction) and your Head of Product for similar reasons now too this makes me wonder what working in Product Manaqgement at Facebook is like these days. It's the Zuck way or the out-the-door way? Why would any semi-creative person want to work under those circumstances?
- known 8y agoFB seems to be a reincarnation of https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Napster https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Napster
- WhuzzupDomal 8y agoHas no one heard of planned obsolescence? Facebook has outserved its usefulness; it is little better than a rudderless ship under the current leadership and business model. The bell has tolled; and the Feds are at the gates. Cease operations and move on. There's a plot available in the social media graveyard next to MySpace with Facebook's name on it.
- trophycase 8y agoThat's not what planned obsolescence is, but there are certainly cycles of capital whereby businesses build great and useful products with the initial help of capital infusions, then slowly degrade the usefulness of said product or increase their exploitativeness in order to reduce costs or increase prices. Perhaps that is happening with facebook now.
- Criper1Tookus 8y agoHm. Yesterday's NY TimesFacebook article was about a federal criminal investigation. Today's is about senior execs jumping ship. I love coincidences.
- zestyping 8y agoInteresting. The article seems to emphasize that the conflict was over merging the messaging apps (Messenger, Instagram, WhatsApp). What are the upsides and downsides of merging the messaging apps? I wonder if there's any way that could turn out to be a good thing.