27 ms·
U.S. users are leaving Facebook by the millions, Edison Research says
- forgotmysn 8y agothat sounds like a drop in the ocean that is fb's massive and growing userbase
- max76 8y agoFacebook growth numbers haven't been strong lately, but it's still growing [0]. With 2.3B monthly active users 15M isn't much to worry about unless a specifically profitable sub-population is doing the leaving. [0] https://www.statista.com/statistics/264810/number-of-monthly-active-facebook-users-worldwide/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/264810/number-of-monthly...
- seppin 8y agoIn the country with the highest value per user to advertisers, yes i'd say this is a huge deal.
- thisacctforreal 8y agoIf it is 15M US users, that's 4.5% of the US population.
- _red 8y agoYou may be an older person, but for anyone with teens an interesting aspect is that they hardly use it. FB is turning into a "how to talk to grandma" network.
- aylmao 8y agoIsn't that what it's supposed to be? Facebook has the market of young people captured pretty broadly with Instagram. I doubt they would appeal so much to older people if they focused in appealing to younger people.
- forgotmysn 8y agoIn the US, sure, but globally they are still growing in almost every demographic.
- JohnFen 8y agoYep, and if I remember right, that was the same pattern that the prior dominant social platforms saw before they collapsed.
- cm2012 8y agoFacebook isn't going to lie on their quarterly filings on user growth. It's far more likely this random company's polling methodology is flawed.
- philipodonnell 8y agoFacebook lied about their video engagement numbers for a long time while telling others measuring it that their methodologies were flawed.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoEnron and Arthur Anderson weren't going to lie on their quarterly filings either. Not saying it's true or false, but there's also the possibility that user count methodologies can change to create the appearance of growth.
- oooooooooo000 8y agoHow do you suppose that Enron "weren't going to lie" on their quarterly flyings? This analogy is a bit rich.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoIt's rich that you created an account specifically to make this comment. Lying on financial reports is not uncommon and there are high profile examples, so a sweeping appeal to honesty on the part of a multi billion company caught lying in the past is foolish.
- cloudsinthesky 8y agoArticle discusses the differences in measuring what a user counts as, so the numbers are difficult to pin down exactly. Anecdotally, I still _have_ my account, but no longer log in. It has been 2-3 months now, so I ought to be counted as such - that is, not an active user despite having an account. I don't use insta or whatsapp or messenger either - but I still have my FB account. I wonder how many people there are like me, with nearly dead accounts but could still be 'counted' if you wanted to.
- newen 8y agoYeah, I'm late 20s overeducated and I never post nowadays and go to Facebook once a month or so. My feed is almost dead now and none of my friends post like they used to. Decent amount of activity on Instagram though but not like it used to be with Facebook when I was in college. Though probably because we graduated and grew up I don't know.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- matthberg 8y agoLooks like a small summary of: https://www.marketplace.org/2019/03/06/tech/exclusive-look-numbers-showing-users-leaving-facebook-by-the-millions https://www.marketplace.org/2019/03/06/tech/exclusive-look-n...
- sctb 8y agoThanks, we've updated the link from https://www.fastcompany.com/90316249/report-facebook-has-lost-15-million-u-s-users-since-2017 https://www.fastcompany.com/90316249/report-facebook-has-los....
- b_tterc_p 8y ago> How the study was conducted: A total of 1,500 persons were interviewed to explore Americans’ use of digital platforms and new media. From January 3rd through February 4th, 2019, telephone interviews were conducted with respondents age 12 and older who were selected via Random Digit Dial (RDD) sampling through both landline phones and mobile phones. The survey was offered in both Spanish and English. Data was weighted to national 12+ U.S. population estimates. I wouldn’t put much faith in this estimate. While facebook’s is probably an overestimate of people actually engaged in their platform, this survey doesn’t seem very useful to me.
- ryana 8y agoI am always sad to see responses like this. Statistics is a very well-defined mathematical discipline, and any good research firm will use weighting techniques to adjust for demographic-based likelihood of response. The results they get from this are very accurate. If you have concerns about Edison's methodology or application of standard survey weighting then I think that could be a fruitful conversation. But implying that 1,500 responses can't be predictive for a country of 350 million is woefully misinformed.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoPhone surveys were accurate when robocalls and cellphones didn't exist. Now you're only sampling the people who aren't discerning enough to reject unknown numbers.
- underwater 8y agoHaving concerns about their methodology would imply that they've actually shared it. The closest they get is a hand-wavy answer to the discrepancies between Facebook's data and their own: > We're saying, "Do you currently use Facebook?" Facebook is probably measuring it on, “Do you ever open the app, or do you ever use it on any level?” That answer doesn't event make sense. Given that Edison have gone to the press to promote their report and this particular number, you'd expect them to have a good answer on the discrepancies. They should definitely know what the Facebook numbers represent, especially given Facebook publicly disclose their definition of an active user in SEC filings.
- kojackst 8y agoNote: personal opinion bellow It seems to me that the overall interest in Facebook is decreasing. The social network hasn't had any interesting feature added to it in the last couple of years. It's becoming boring and boring, so that's why I believe people are leaving. Still, Instagram and WhatsApp are running strong with barely no competition. We don't see any news about their user base decreasing and news channels don't seem to dislike them. Facebook is doing a good job making sure their biggest three platforms are seem as independent from one another, keeping Instagram and WhatsApp almost free from controversy. Personally I see no loss for them here. Besides, they will promptly acquire any new players that look promising, or shamelessly copy them as they did with Snapchat.
- simonsarris 8y ago> The social network hasn't had any interesting feature added to it in the last couple of years. I actually found some great rugs (owners did not know what they had!) and furniture on the FB marketplace. Much better finds than on craigslist, and easier to verify that the seller is a human.
- oooooooooo000 8y agoIndeed. There sure are a lot of accusations of FB lying in these comments, but it seems people have no problem upvoting much more obvious lies like "FB hasn't launched any new features in 2 years". Whatever fits the HN narrative goes, I guess.
- rhcom2 8y agoSlightly pedantic but Facebook Marketplace was launched in 2016 so the point could still stand.
- oooooooooo000 8y agoThe point doesn't still stand, but I'll save you all the googling: FB launched Watch on August 9, 2017. You could also say "only in the last year" and it'd be easy to find something else with 2 minutes of googling.
- JohnFen 8y agoI'm not sure losing that age group has much to do with Facebook's scandals. This is purely anecdotal, but with my daughter and her social group, Facebook stopped being a service of interest to them quite a while back. Not because of data issues, but because (to use my daughter's words) "Facebook is for businesses and old people".
- Leace 8y agoWhat does your daughter use to connect with friends? Just curious.
- basil-rash 8y agoMy brother is in that age group and he uses discord and normal text message groups.
- xeromal 8y agoProbably less of a suite of tech like FB and more a bunch of small single-purpose apps like snapchat and instagram.
- trophycase 8y agonot OP. But instagram, tik tok, vsco, snapchat
- the_pwner224 8y agoNot parent, but I am a college student at a large university in the US. Instagram is just huge, for the entire [university] population here. Snapchat is still used but not as common - Instagram is eating up Snapchat's userbase. GroupMe is used by the entire population for group chatting, and many males (especially more 'nerdy' guys) use Discord as the preferred general chat application.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoSnapchat is the most annoying platform I have ever experienced for messaging. Disappearing messages (with no option for them to stick around) is literally an anti-feature. Instagram is just annoying, because it's an image sharing platform being used as a messaging platform. I actually get annoyed when people message me on Instagram, because it means that their messages to me are scattered over different platforms.
- mpoon 8y agoThe headline is disingenuous. I suspect a lot of folks are taking away from the headline that Facebook the company is on the ropes, however looking into the primary source[1] indicates that they are only talking about Facebook the product. The press is not making that distinction here. A vast amount of people leaving "Facebook" are just going to Instagram. [1] https://www.edisonresearch.com/infinite-dial-2019/ https://www.edisonresearch.com/infinite-dial-2019/
- colmvp 8y agoMost of my friends despise Facebook, but at the end of the day we're still using their other products like WhatsApp and Instagram.
- floatingatoll 8y agoOriginal source: https://www.edisonresearch.com/infinite-dial-2019/ https://www.edisonresearch.com/infinite-dial-2019/ > Regarding social media, the latest study finds the number of current users of Facebook continues to drop. The study shows an estimated 15 million fewer users of Facebook than in the 2017 report. The declines are heavily concentrated among younger people. https://www.slideshare.net/webby2001/infinite-dial-2019 https://www.slideshare.net/webby2001/infinite-dial-2019 Slide 9-14 or so contain the relevant demographic and year-over-year breakout.
- turc1656 8y agoCouldn't have happened to a nicer company.
- YeahSureWhyNot 8y agoI deleted my Facebook more than a year ago and never missed it but I had to go back on Facebook multiple times this week because I created a page for my new business and I was surprised how repelling the whole thing was. I was confused why am I disgusted by it but it was really pushing me away.
- weisser 8y agoPOW for status is so difficult it’s practically nonexistent. Utility hasn’t been increased to compensate for inability to earn social capital. https://www.eugenewei.com/blog/2019/2/19/status-as-a-service https://www.eugenewei.com/blog/2019/2/19/status-as-a-service
- socrates1998 8y agoAnecdotally, I work with teenagers and none of them have a Facebook pages. It's viewed as a place for old people and parents. For me personally, it's almost impossible to deal with. Way too many political posts from my friends and family. It's probably best use for me is local events and an occasional major event from a friend/family member. Still, I find myself going there less and less. From a small business standpoint, it's just not worth the time, effort and money to advertise there. It's much more effective to focus on getting referrals with my current clients. I really wish there was a paid social media service that everyone used. I would gladly pay $5-$10 a month for something that didn't sell my data.
- gwbas1c 8y ago> For me personally, it's almost impossible to deal with. Way too many political posts from my friends and family. Bingo, that's what's doing it for me. Before the 2016 presidential election, Facebook was fun. It was also a great way to get news. But now, what I'm finding is that a lot of people on Facebook just don't know how to behave in a public forum. It makes it painful, because someone always knows someone who's a jerk online. I really don't know what changed, to be honest. Did Facebook change, or did too many people come to the party?
- ashelmire 8y agoLots of things changed. Facebook began as an exclusive social network for upper-class students. Gradually it grew to encompass not just all of America, but the entire world. It turns out, many of us well educated people don't really want to network or socialize with poorly educated people. Police started monitoring our activities, so the events all but disappeared. The world changed, too. Facts used to matter; we read books and the newspaper, not 25 reasons to be an idiot on Buzzfeed. Truth used to matter; less of the nation was as polarized. It was easier to get along without people shoving their ignorant political ideas in your face. Then 2016 happened, with the Russian trolls and other psyops used against us, and some of us realized we'd fucked up by buying into and encouraging others to join this network and others like it. I could probably go on for a lot longer, but that's the gist of it.
- kissickas 8y agoI'm shocked by the decrease in twitter usage (compared to other social networks) in 2017.[0] I have seen a huge uptick in friends tweeting, mostly in replies to Trump's tweets, and several times a week news stories come to the top of my feed purely generated by a single tweet of his. [0] the credited article for the story, linked in the second sentence https://www.marketplace.org/2019/03/06/tech/exclusive-look-numbers-showing-users-leaving-facebook-by-the-millions https://www.marketplace.org/2019/03/06/tech/exclusive-look-n...
- oooooooooo000 8y agoIt does feel like social media as a whole may be peaking, or at least nearing full saturation. People can only take so much. And there are a lot of options these days.
- narrator 8y agoTwitter has been shamelessly deleting a lot of interesting right of center accounts (e.g Thomas Wictor, Imperator Rex) for no good reason, so a lot of people have given up on it for political discussions. Jack Dorsey was on the Joe Rogan podcast with , of all people, his lawyer and got called out for censoring and gave a lot of non-answers.[1] if you read the youtube comments it's almost 100% negative on the direction they've been going with censorship on that platform and Jack's lack of candor as to what exactly they're trying to do. Edit: Why the downvotes? Did I trigger some sort of HN Godwin's law by mentioning Americans outside the San Francisco/LA political bubble as a possible cause of Twitter's loss of popularity? [1] https://youtu.be/_mP9OmOFxc4 https://youtu.be/_mP9OmOFxc4
- jessaustin 8y agoHe's no Elon Musk...
- Simon_says 8y agoYou're downvoted because a significant fraction of HN readers live in leftist filter bubbles and are never exposed to serious criticisms of their ideas.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ebertx 8y agoI disabled my Facebook account 4 years or so ago and didn't miss it. That said, I now have a daughter with an extremely rare genetic disorder. Although there are a number of databases out there specifically to help parents find other families with rare genetic disorders, we didn't find anyone until we resorted to Facebook. This is only one anecdote, but from my personal experience thus far, Facebook is still unfortunately the best place to find a needle in a haystack.
- efields 8y ago(edit: typo) FB has completely swallowed the Groups space. We are new parents and my wife connects with other new parents in a local group specific to our son's age cohort. FB Marketplace is also very useful, as other people have mentioned. I got off FB services a few months ago, but would join again if they had a standalone Groups app.
- josephwegner 8y agoThis is my same experience. Son has JIA. There is a JIA-specific website that connects you to JIA-specific support groups.... but there are none active near me, and I live in a very big city. I expressed this frustration to my wife who uses Facebook often, and she joined an active JIA community in moments. I guess now we have two anecdotes. That makes us a statistic, I think?
- nix0n 8y agoFacebook still has profiles on all 15M of them.
- sleavey 8y agoI've blocked ads ever since ad blockers were a thing. Facebook have finally managed to consistently get past uBlock Origin, and seeing ads in my news feed for the first time is really, really annoying me. They look similar enough to real posts that I read them automatically before I realise, which I find really disturbing. It's enough that I'm seriously contemplating not using Facebook any more.
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoIf you use the facebook.com website (not the app) they are _torturing_ HTML to get ads past the blockers. Stuff like putting every letter in a separate span or div, weird encoding tricks, etc.
- throwawaymath 8y agoDo you examples? That sounds educational.
- sleavey 8y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19115460 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19115460
- exodust 8y ago> I'm seriously contemplating not using Facebook any more. You talk the talk but can you walk the walk?
- andrei_says_ 8y agoThat’s still a billion users too many. I can’t wait to see the commodification and decentralization of the services fb provides. Identity, chats, content distribution and subscription, events etc. My accountant still has an @aol email. I hope to see the same reaction to fb pages, events etc.
- throwawaymath 8y agoI doubt that reaction will happen. I would expect Facebook to follow Microsoft’s lifecycle instead (which was founded in the same era as AOL).
- bitxbit 8y agoSomething seemed very off about FB’s metrics in the past 2-3 quarters. It could be my own bias but I expected to see a more pronounced slowdown/contraction based on my own anecdotal evidence.
- arisAlexis 8y agoand they flock to Instagram
- chris_mc 8y agoGood, I hope it dies. I don't use Facebook for the obvious reason (privacy) and my family almost refuses to contact me in any other medium. If I didn't take the initiative to contact them via email or phone, they'd forget I existed.
- kjar 8y agoRight we are supposed to believe FB at this point - laughable.
- DigiMortal 8y agoI've always been so tempted to leave it Okay so i'll download all my history of data and all that, that's fine I may just go through and see who I care about and let them know im leaving? idk. I think i stay for my grandpa at this point
- GuillaumeBrdet 8y agoIt's amazing how its only acquisitions keeping Facebook alive besides Messenger.
- dymk 8y agoAcquisitions which were developed and grown a great deal after becoming part of the company.
- GuillaumeBrdet 8y agoI am not denying that! It's just interesting how the core product is really taking a bad hit lately. I am curious to know where FB would be today without them.
- ciacci1234 8y agoWhat are people's thoughts on not deleting FB to better secure your personal identity. In the context of leaving google's services, I see people say that they sit on their email so no one else can take it, but I never see that sentiment about deleting fb. Is it just that the bar to successfully impersonate someone via fb is higher and email is lot easier to manipulate? I am particularly interested because I am planning on deleting my personal fb soon.
- two2two 8y agoIt's easy to not delete and stop using to serve your purpose. I loathe facebook et al., but some employers (fewer and fewer these days) want to see my online presence. To not have a facebook was considered strange, so for that reason, I keep it around. However, as far as maintaining an identity, or holding on to your custom facebook url, that’s a non-issue. Delete away, and create again—facebook is intelligent enough to reconnect you to all those people if need be. Personal identity is strengthened by other's endorsement. That's easy to get again with FB, especially if you're who you really are. It's difficult to take someone’s identity in that sense and it be valuable to the person doing it.
- JohnFen 8y ago> some employers (fewer and fewer these days) want to see my online presence. That's a really huge red flag. I don't think that I'd be willing to risk taking a job with a company that asked for this.
- ryanianian 8y agoI live in a somewhat large gated community that has a pretty active facebook group. The group is somewhat loosely moderated by the HOA (for better or worse) so in general people stay on-topic and neighborly. It's great for asking for recommended contractors, asking if somebody has a thing they can borrow, etc. This is one of the few things that keeps me on facebook. Of course facebook is a terrible venue for this group - with its algorithmic feed, horrible search, and showing "notifications" when nothing of consequence has actually happened. If there were a more prevalent network I'm sure the group would move but there's really no other alternative that already has a critical mass of users and people aren't going to sign up for a new service unless everyone else in the neighborhood is already there.
- atwebb 8y agoNextdoor really needs to get it's act together on siloing neighborhood discussions, it's basically built for this.
- echelon 8y agoNextdoor is terrible. I get push notified of every lost cat or dog. Or whenever the local grocery store is out of cabbage. Or "suspicious people" walking around. I can't find a way to get any value out of it.
- romwell 8y ago>Or "suspicious people" The bane of Nextdoor. Every person within 100 yards is suspicious, especially if they have "Hair color: african" (I kid you not, this one is from my neighborhood Nextdoor).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- axaxs 8y agoNextdoor is awful. I think the idea was really good, but I've really just come to learn that by and large, my neighborhood is full of idiots. I guess the whole reason for social media is that we can choose who to be around, whereas we can't chose our neighbors. I only lasted about a month before the constant barrages of arguing over leash laws, petty snide comments, and self promoting 'handymen' drove me away.
- ykevinator 8y agoWhat's that in percentage?
- thstart 8y agoDefine 'Lifelog' [DARPA]. "an ontology-based (sub)system that captures, stores, and makes accessible the flow of one person's experience in and interactions with the world in order to support a broad spectrum of associates/assistants and other system capabilities". The objective of the LifeLog concept was "to be able to trace the 'threads' of an individual's life in terms of events, states, and relationships", and it has the ability to "take in all of a subject's experience, from phone numbers dialed and e-mail messages viewed to every breath taken, step made and place gone". Define 'FB'. The Facebook service can be accessed from devices with Internet connectivity, such as personal computers, tablets and smartphones. After registering, users can create a customized profile revealing information about themselves. Users can post text, photos and multimedia of their own devising and share it with other users as "friends". Users can use various embedded apps, and receive notifications of their friends' activities. Users may join common-interest groups. Compare & Contrast. DARPA senior employees > FB? DARPA TERMINATES PROGRAM FEB 4, 2004. FB FOUNDED FEB 4, 2004. DARPA = FB
- tedmcory77 8y agoAnecdotal data; I’ve purposefully stopped posting, liking, commenting, and am transitioning all my business hooked in things to a “business acccount” I’ve made with a goal of deleting the non business one by May 1. It’s crazy how many places FB wormed it’s way into.
- DeonPenny 8y agoThey are going to Instagram though. Thats one of facebook smartest move. Buying all the other social media sites.
- nabla9 8y agoThis is also one of the biggest failures of the modern antitrust law. If giants like FB can't innovate and must buy competition to survive despite all the advantages they have, something is wrong.
- travisoneill1 8y agoCounterpoint: Many new innovative companies are being founded in this space and those that are successful are richly rewarded (by selling to FB). The system is working exactly how it is supposed to.
- nabla9 8y ago>The system is working exactly how it is supposed to. US system is designed to be anti-markets and pro business, so you have a point. Good for startup, good for FB, bad for consumer and competition. It's still against what anti-trust law was supposed to be.
- JohnFen 8y agoAlso remember that in the US it's perfectly legal to be a monopoly. What is illegal is abusing your monopoly position by engaging in unfair practices (which is a rather fuzzy and hard-to-prove thing).
- AdrianB1 8y agoI lost too many "friends" on Facebook: I knew these people for many years, but I was shocked what they posted - from stupid to incredible things, mostly politics and mostly far left. I started cutting all these people and I was left with less than 20 when I closed my account.
- anarchy8 8y ago> mostly politics and mostly far left You're upset that your friends have different political opinions than you? And you're blaming Facebook for this? Why?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- frabcus 8y agoIt's not difference of opinion that is the problem - it's often quality of argument. Political discussions generally these days are very low quality - not actually trying to work out the best policies that will work best for society. Just posting memes. Little listening. Each side in an echo chamber. People unable to explain why they think things.
- 0xffff2 8y agoIs that wrong? I have virtually no interest in politics. It's unlikely that I'm going to remain friends with anyone who expresses particularly strong political views, left or right. I just don't care, and find it too exhausting to be bothered most of the time. If the only place I see/hear those views is on Facebook, it might be easier to drop Facebook than to drop those friends.
- shrimp_emoji 8y agoHow do you do it? I find myself so wrapped in what feels like a fundamental struggle for our future, which could be so amazing or so horrible depending on the glacial shifts in collective will and which I may be able to influence if only I ignite enough low-bandwidth arguments. Posting is warfare.
- hojjat12000 8y agoI only haven't deleted my account because of the facebook messenger and all the messages that I have there. I should find a way to back it up to a readable format and delete the thing.
- tokai 8y agoYou can download all your chats. https://www.facebook.com/help/212802592074644?helpref=faq_content https://www.facebook.com/help/212802592074644?helpref=faq_co...
- standardUser 8y agoIt feels like Facebook now contains all of the negative parts of social media - complaining, arguing, chain posts, fake news, relatives, etc. While Instagram now has all the pleasant parts - pretty photos of families, vacations and food! So these days I find myself using Instagram regularly and Facebook almost never. Having said that, I'll never leave Facebook until something else replaces it. It's the only place I have to keep in touch with a couple hundred people I would otherwise have no contact with. And it's still common for various groups of people I know to use it for event planning. I also find myself having to share invites and news with people I know who are not on Facebook. They appreciate it, but I consider it a pain in the ass that they could easily resolve by getting a Facebook account again and just checking it once a week.
- fullshark 8y agoInstagram to me seems like the worst parts of social media, in that it's a vanity feeding mechanism amplified. Which in turn makes it an anxiety inducing experience if you aren't doing "cool things" that make other people jealous.
- toomanybeersies 8y agoI agree with you completely. Instagram is social McDonalds. Quick gratification from pretty pictures of friends doing cool shit, ranked so that the prettiest friends appear on your newsfeed first. Try putting a serious post on Instagram, nobody will see it and it will fall flat. Meanwhile I put out a post on Facebook asking for help (after my house was burgled) and had about 15 people messaging me within a couple of hours willing to come around to my place and lend me a hand. You can't even share links on Instagram, so I'm sure that the GoFundMe that was set up to help cover the money that was stolen from me would've gotten a lot less money than it has. I like Instagram as an entertainment platform for looking at cool photos, and for posting the occasional photo myself (never of myself, always landscape of event photography), but it's absolute trash as a social media platform.
- sanxiyn 8y agoI consume Instagram like TV (they even launched IGTV, although I don't use it and it's terrible). People mostly don't get anxiety from watching TV. Maybe it has to do with the fact I don't use Instagram as SNS.
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoGoing cold turkey is never easy. If you're having trouble withdrawing, consider what I did over the past few years: 1. Turn off notifications for the Facebook app on your phone; next 2. Turn off notifications for the Facebook Messenger, Instagram, et cetera apps on your phone; then 3. Delete the Facebook app from your phone; then 4. Delete the Facebook Messenger, Instagram, et cetera apps from your phone; and finally 5. Log out of Facebook on your desktop. It took me 2 years to go through from step 1 to step 5. It has made me happier and more productive. I still have a Facebook account. But the friction of grabbing my laptop and logging in forces me to consider "is this what I want to do? Or am I thoughtlessly reaching for the crack pipe?" (It's been months since I've cared to log into Facebook. Feels more like trudging through spam in an old e-mail inbox, now, than anything compelling.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- frabcus 8y agoI quite like the plugins that remove the newsfeed too - or unfollow (not unfriend) everyone. It's a nice intermediate step so you can still use events and messages, but the most annoyingly addictive bit is gone. The light versions of the apps can be a useful step too. Finally, after logging out - deactivating your account, and then deleting your account (or better, getting a trusted friend to do so for you) are the last steps. (If you're interested in UX, are you a little bit curious what the UX for those two is like?)
- tytso 8y agoRe: users giving up Facebook but moving to Instagram, Malinda of Google Translate Sings called it in her "Honest 2018 Christmas Song": https://youtu.be/70QwQ5kgxzk?t=33 https://youtu.be/70QwQ5kgxzk?t=33
- imgabe 8y agoI wonder if there's a market for a paid Facebook. Charge $5 per month for a Facebook like profile. Communicate with your friends. Share photos. See updates (in chronological order!). No data mining. No advertisements. No "brands". No emotional manipulation to maximize engagement (actually, the less time you spend, the more profitable your $5 is). I'd pay for this if it existed, hopefully enough of my friends would too.
- miguelmota 8y agoDeleted facebook years ago and never regretted it. It's always the same people posting the same stuff. It's simply just boring for me because I'm not interested in personal lives of people. Twitter on the other hand is great for news updates and it's the only mainstream social network I use.
- jopsen 8y agoI'm a lot less active on Facebook, but... it's still super useful for coordination, finding people, groups. The thing that convinces me FB isn't going away is my dad using groups to debate wood working.. he's never participated in anything online before.
- reaperducer 8y agoA bunch of my Facebook friends are taking a break from Facebook for Lent. It'll be interesting to see how many realize they don't need Facebook in their lives and simply don't come back.
- jaimex2 8y agoIf you combine Instagram they haven't really lost anything.
- ehsankia 8y agoExactly. Everyone's leaving Facebook for Instagram, so at the end of the day, basically nothing is changing.
- throwaway5752 8y agoThis has been up a while and has a lot of comments, and there is no mention of Cambridge Analytica? A lot of people talk about polarization on Facebook around 2016... that was the intended result of deliberate and concerted efforts. Whether or not user metadata disclosure was done intentionally, the data was then used to radicalize target populations on certain political issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Analytica_data_scandal#Use_of_the_data https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Ana... Of course people are leaving and don't trust them.
- awalton 8y agoWhat's the accounting for people who still have Facebook accounts but realistically never or very infrequently check them? I've had no interest in using my Facebook since it became Babybook, and maybe I'll poke at it once a month to see if I've missed someone's huge life event (you know, other than people having babies)... but that's it - I just have no more interest in surrendering my thoughts, photo copyrights and what's left of my privacy there anymore.
- johnwheeler 8y agoIt seems like social networks are inherently fads with low switching costs (how many of your facebook friends do you really need to drag over to the next one).
- MarkMc 8y agoFacebook says their North American monthly active users have increased 1% since 2017. Edison Research says there are 6% fewer US users since 2017. I'm curious to understand the reason for this discrepancy. Edison says, We're saying, "Do you currently use Facebook?" Facebook is probably measuring it on, "Do you ever open the app, or do you ever use it on any level?" Here's how Facebook defines monthly active users: We define a monthly active user as a registered Facebook user who logged in and visited Facebook through our website or a mobile device, or used our Messenger app (and is also a registered Facebook user), in the last 30 days as of the date of measurement. So is Edison's explanation reasonable? Maybe people only think they "use" Facebook when they scroll through the feed - and people are still using it for other purposes.
- buboard 8y agousing facebook has become a sort of taboo in certain cycles, so people may be misreporting it intentionally also, a significant drop in users should be detectable by every website which relies significantly on facebook traffic
- trumped 8y agolol facebook is probably just deleting a few troll accounts....
- charliebrownau 8y agoGday Platforms that censor speech List :- * Facebook * Twitter * Google & Youtube * TUMBLR * Pateron * Stripe * Paypal * Twitch * Spotify * Apple * pin interest * LinkedIn * Mailchimp * Wordpress * mastodon * azure * Mastercard * Godaddy * MEDIUM * Shopify * Cloudflare * pusher * WIKI * Reddit * teespring * Slack * coinbase * GOFUNDME * VISA * Square * Bitpay * ROKU * Netflix * Indiegogo Regards Charliebrownau
- toomanybeersies 8y agoI'm going to go against the grain here and say that I really like Facebook and think that overall it's a good platform with some flaws. Right now I'm messaging 2 different groups and about 5 different people, while organising an event that's happening in a few weeks, and organising supplies and camping for a festival on the weekend. After this festival in the weekend, I can post the photos I took on Facebook, where everyone can tag each other in the photos, so they can be easily found. For me it's an integrated social and event management platform. It works incredibly well for this purpose. If I need to find a generator for an event, I can ask in a group chat, or even put up a timeline post asking for one, and it will probably manifest. I had a friend who's laptop died and he needed a temporary replacement, so he put up a post and later that afternoon was in front of a new laptop. There are some really shitty features that I hate about Facebook though, to the point that they induce anxiety. For messenger, being able to see when people were last active and when messages have been seen really makes my anxiety build up. I know that people aren't ignoring me and just take time to reply, because I do exactly the same myself, but it still plays in the back of my mind. The second really shitty feature is that the people you interact with more are the people you keep seeing on your newsfeed or at the top of your messenger. I had a bit of conflict with a friend a while back, so we were giving each other some space to cool down. I kept seeing all her posts at the top of my newsfeed, and she kept appearing on the top of my contacts list for messenger, Facebook would even give me notifications that "Alice and 89 others have responded to events near you tomorrow". It actually did my fucking head in to the point where it was causing significant problems with my mental wellbeing. I understand exactly why Facebook does this, to increase activity and engagement. But fuck it pisses me off.
- theoh 8y agoThe positive features you mention are related to network effects or essentially to Facebook's "first mover advantage". As I see it, you should consider Facebook as merely the incumbent in this "connecting" role, i.e. don't give the Facebook organization any credit for the market position they find themselves in. The software must be adequate enough but that's a separate issue from FB's immense asset, its subscribers.
- Barrin92 8y ago
- charliebrownau 8y agoGday Platforms that DONT censor speech * Minds + mewe (FB alt) * Gabai (Twitter alt) * Bitchute (Youtube alt) * Tutanota + Protonmail(email alt) * Wire (skype alt) * subscribestar (Donation alt) * Startengine (Kickstarter alt) * peertube (DIY self host youtube stream style server) * Voat (Reddit alt) * Movim (Tumblr alt) * Pixelfed (Instagram alt)(one admin is an leftist) * @GetTogether (meetup.com alt) * searX.me or Duckduckgo or startpage (search alt) * OpenStreetmap - instead of Google maps * Linux - Win/MacOSX replacement * f-droid.org - Google Play Store ALT * Mumble - Discord ALT * Gitlab (Github alt) * spreadshirt - shirt merch alt * imgtc or tineye - free image upload site Regards Charliebrownau
- tungwaiyip 8y agoFacebook's investor presentation shows MAU stay flat at 242 millions in Q4'18. I don't see a 15 millions drop. (The numbers for DAUs and MAUs do not include Instagram, WhatsApp, or Oculus users) https://s21.q4cdn.com/399680738/files/doc_financials/2018/Q4/Q4-2018-Earnings-Presentation.pdf https://s21.q4cdn.com/399680738/files/doc_financials/2018/Q4...
- aboutruby 8y agoThanks for the link, very interesting document, it really shows an impressive scale. And for the metrics, it's probably coming from the fact that a lot of people use Messenger without using Facebook, but it's still considered "using Facebook".
- kazinator 8y agoSomeone switching from FB to Instagram does not genuinely count as someone leaving Facebook; they are just switching to a different implementation of Facebook owned by the same company. And the only reason most of them are switching is to follow the herd. They don't want to be left behind in some place where they are not able to obtain as much validation (fishing for likes and followers). That type of personality needs to be "where everyone else is". Their lives are exactly the same, except with a different social networking application.
- georgeecollins 8y agoEven if you feel like it is impossible to leave Facebook, the truth is they make most of their money from ads served while you are in their ecosystem. Just spending less time on their platforms is good for you and good for reducing their relative power in the market. We are all better off in a world where Facebook and Google face an economic harm if they abuse their monopoly power. I don't think consumer action is the best way to cause that harm, but it is the way that is available to everyone on this forum.
- aboutruby 8y agoAt this point Facebook is so big that "millions leaving" could be people dying, people losing their accounts, etc. It's very small compared to their scale of more than 2 billions users.
- toufiqbarhamov 8y agoThat’s true, if that’s where it ends and doesn’t represent a burgeoning trend, and if it doesn’t have a feedback effect leading to greater losses. After all if a fire starts in a mansion, well the fire is tiny and the mansion is huge, why get all excited over nothing? You have to leverage what you know about fire if you want to appreciate the threat it represents to the structure.
- stevehiehn 8y agoI ended up mostly moving to Instagram because I could follow people's lives and not their political opinions
- buboard 8y ago> the biggest drop is in the very desirable 12- to 34-year-old group i wonder if millenials and kids are a profitable or desireable demographic these days
- iamgopal 8y agoThey optimise what they measure. When I'm on Facebook, I like some type of posts and they continued to show me similar posts, without realising that, I'm coming to the facebook and like those posts but I'm not coming to facebook to like that post. My frequency of visit reducing and I think they do not have any idea why, since all my visit shoes good portion of engagement.
- dotcoma 8y agoNo problem. Bots will take up their place, and clueless companies will keep on wasting dollars by the millions. https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucerogers/2019/01/18/will-it-take-an-adtech-crash-to-end-digital-ad-fraud/#a9232991368d https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucerogers/2019/01/18/will-it-...
- stared 8y ago12-35 is a huge age range (3x!). Either it is a really strange methodology (biding underage and adults? seriously?) or it is to distort the interpretation. I bet the decline is not uniform - does anyone know which age ranges are down (or up)?
- gerdesj 8y agoI started reading some comments here and then fired up FB in another tab because I have been away from it for quite a long time. The first post is: "Add a phone number to your Facebook account" No. FB knows my number indirectly via friends anyway but I have not ever given it permission to actually admit to knowing it. I never will. To be fair, I have never received a call that I could attribute to FB abusing that chain of cough trust.
- pkulak 8y agoCareful not to cut yourself on that edge.
- maybelater 8y agoBut what is your point? Facebook asked for your phone number, as many services do, and you declined. You assume they have your number already, but they don't use it, but they asked you. I don't follow...
- hhs 8y agoI wonder if Facebook UX researchers review feedback from threads like this? This seems like useful qualitative information for them to improve their product. But then again, I wonder if their target population is different. In that case, it could be that Facebook is being strategic on what things to prioritize and they're banking on certain sub-populations, because they can't win over everyone, for their bottom-line?
- viburnum 8y agoFacebook actually pretty useful for events and looking up businesses if you have a fake account with no friends. I recently disabled my account but there were things I missed so that's why I made a fake account.
- molotovbliss 8y agoYour shadow profile already has your other account linked, I would bet. https://browserleaks.com/canvas https://browserleaks.com/canvas
- klyrs 8y agoSo many lulz. Sure, they're quitting farceblat, but where are they going? The graphics suggest that instagram is picking up the slack, with a little jump for snapchat. With insta owned by facetrash, the headline is highly overblown
- morningmoon 8y agoWe only show trace numbers of people leaving social media altogether. They're obviously just transferring their usage. The big gainer, interestingly, is under the same roof as Facebook. It's their co-owned Instagram. We already knew this. Another day on HN, another clickbait FB post.
- paulpauper 8y agoThe < 35 age demographic are spending more time on Instagram, which is owned by Facebook, and this explains also why Facebook's stock has done well recently and is not a concern.
- jonstewart 8y agoAFAICT, Facebook consists solely of one’s baby boomer-aged aunts sharing ridiculous memes and other such factually-challenged posts.
- no_wizard 8y agoHere's the kicker, which I think others have pointed out, but I want to say this succinctly: First, to quote the article: > The big gainer, interestingly, is under the same roof as Facebook. It's their co-owned Instagram Now, to my point: The average person does not care about privacy, just the illusion of privacy (I suspect people reading this site intuitively know this. At some level, nearly everyone is in different ways, it turns out.) Instagram provides that illusion by not injecting opinionated content into your feed (The most obvious example: you aren't seeing injected news stories in your Instagram feed, generally its only ads and people you follow, and the ads are marked) Rest assured, they're getting their data's worth, maybe not the same way, but photos (particularly metadata on the photos that most smart phones, for instance, default collect) are just as (if not more so) valuable, not to mention there are still a myriad of other ways of collecting privacy intrusive data about users. Hows about that? (just to show my assertion is not completely unfounded, check out this survey: https://www.pewinternet.org/2015/05/20/americans-views-about-data-collection-and-security/ https://www.pewinternet.org/2015/05/20/americans-views-about... The survey says: 9 out of ten americans care deeply about privacy (particuarly around data privacy and collection) Yet, our actions, even faced with the outright knowledge of those very things being actively and routinely violated by services, is not enough for people to leave platforms for good, simply, people shift between social media outlets, like those leaving Facebook over privacy concerns yet still continue to use Instagram, in fact, Instagram is projected to grow as noted in this article, in part because of people migrating away from Facebook)
- dd36 8y agoI think they do actually care about privacy but are only ever offered illusion. The problem really is lack of choice.
- no_wizard 8y agoAgreed, as noted in the survey I linked to, 9 out of 10 people (in accordance to this survey, but even its more realistically 7 out of 10, its still a lot of people) claim to. I think its a few things: 1. Awareness. I don't think people are aware of how/what services are collecting data and how that data can be collected 2. Influence. Its hard, I imagine, for a lot of people to drop social media altogether. Its not all vanity. My wife has a disability that sometimes leaves her bedridden for weeks. Without social media, she wouldn't be able to communicate with our friends unless they call/text/come over, which they do, but its not always feasible one of those things will happen, so following them on Instagram and chatting via Facebook Messenger is really helpful in keeping her spirits up in those times. 3. Inertia. I think a lot of the current outrage against Facebook has been media driven, in particular, I think after Trump got elected - (just a side note here before I continue, I'm talking about a criticism of media in general, not democrat vs republican politics or anything of the sort)- I have a strong feeling, that I can't really substantiate, so take it as you will, of course (I acknowledge I could be wrong), large main stream news outlets started digging around about the mechanics of that election, and stumbled into the Cambridge Analytica scandal as a result, increasingly their practices came under fire, in part because I think some large media organizations (rightly, in my opinion) blame their data harvesting practices on getting Trump elected in the first place. This also brings up another point I find so sad: despite the openness of the internet, the mass media still reigns supreme in being able to influence the masses, and I (anecdotally) feel like the power of freely and ubiquitously available knowledge via the internet has not had the impact on this sort of thing that one would have hoped. It was one of the promises of the internet in the 90s, that we would all vastly become more informed and it would take vastly less effort (and it does, if you are looking for it).
- lsiebert 8y agoI co-run a small board game group in SF, and we have been using FB for years to organize events. I've considered moving to eventbrite or meetup.com, but the app buy in with FB and FB messanger means we can post an update or send an IM and assume people see it, which isn't the case with either alternative, unless people check email. I really wish there was a ubiquitous open standard open source IM client, so people could download one client and use it for everything.
- BartBoch 8y agohttps://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/ Unfortunately, this happens way too often.
- no_wizard 8y agoLike XMPP https://xmpp.org/ https://xmpp.org/ ? I'm with you, and I didn't mind XMPP (having implemented a Jabber server before, it wasn't all bad) Same deal with IRC (which I think is the best protocol wise). They all suffer from the same problem: the openness of the standard is not data collection inclusive. The upside is better privacy, the downside is its incredibly hard to fight spam in such wide open systems. Also, for a the briefest of overviews about the some notable issues with mass adoptions on XMPP, check this: https://blog.samwhited.com/2019/02/whats-wrong-with-xmpp/ https://blog.samwhited.com/2019/02/whats-wrong-with-xmpp/
- osrec 8y agoI was a regular user of Facebook, now I'm not. I never used Instagram, but I can see that becoming as tedious as Facebook for people who do. I use WhatsApp every 5 minutes, but I don't think Facebook monetises it yet to any large degree. I have a hunch that as people leave the "whimsical" platforms, only the universally useful WhatsApp will continue to hold on to users. If they don't monetise it, they may well have to operate it at a loss. If they do monetise it and become greedy by killing the UX with ads, people leave anyway. They've got a very fine balancing act ahead of them. It won't be easy for Facebook.
- fartcannon 8y agoThey monetize the data though? They monetize the heck out of the data. Why not just use something that doesn't? Be the change you want to see.
- osrec 8y agoBut they probably use the data to target users with Facebook/Instagram ads. If those platforms go south, then what's the data going to be used for?! P.S. I use Signal. Problem is no one else does :p
- dandigangi 8y agoGood
- lgregg 8y agoThis isn't really too surprising, I rarely ever go on my own account anymore.
- pnw_hazor 8y agoSocial media is weird. At the beginning of this year I unfriended everyone and unsubscribed from every group/page except for a couple parent groups of schools my kids are at. It was odd how it felt like betrayal to unfriend people I know and love. Though experiencing those feelings for something as dumb as FB did confirm to me how evil social media is. The human mind isn't really configured to handle social media. It feels so personal.
- quickthrower2 8y agoTry to close your FB account, they’ll make you feel like your killing puppies before you finally get out.
- swozey 8y agoI deleted my FB last year and was really concerned, like you were, about offending people. I messaged my then girlfriend "hey I'm deleting fb" just so she'd know. I have friends that while we're not super close we'd talk a few times a week, usually just sending funny jokes. They didn't see me on messenger so they just texted me. They didn't even realize I'd deleted it. One of my closer friends who invites me to her kids birthdays and what not went to send me an invite and made me an evite when she didn't see my account. She was surprised when I told her I just deleted fb. I realized I really had never gone to anyones actual profile page in maybe a year or two. Hell, the last profile I may have actually taken more than a cursory glance at was my ex when we first started dating. I guess nobody else does either when you can just @them. With that said I do feel very out of the loop but it's allowed me to focus on my own life and I'm on a social media cleanse (doh, hn) anyway. Interestingly enough I do keep having feelings about reopening it but I permanently deleted so I can't and I'm glad I did. Prior to that I had temporarily closed it and reopened it a handful of times.
- nameisu 8y agoI was getting ads to join Facebook on some apps on my android phone. This is the start of the end.
- ajcodez 8y agoI’m sure readers on HN are excited about the day of privacy reckoning but I stopped using Facebook because the news feed sucks. I’ll stare at a photo of someone I don’t remember trying to recall how I know them and then for the next month it’s photos and videos and requests for travel recommendations from them until I block them. It’s clear despite all the data Facebook has collected the company has no clue who I care about or what I’m interested in.
- jaabe 8y agoI think the news feed sucks even if it’s a picture of current contacts. It probably always has, I mean, there must be a reason Facebook wanted news, brands and whatever else there. I just never followed things, so right now the most exciting part of my FB news feed is the commercials for board-game kickstarters. I still use Facebook though. It’s still the best place to organise events with friends because it’s still the only platform everyone is on. I wish it wasn’t, but because the various other platforms and messaging app didn’t share an open protocol, no other platform has “everyone”. Eventually when enough people quit FB, no platform will be good at organising events. Or maybe we will finally agree to use e-mail. :p
- fyfy18 8y agoI only use Facebook for Messenger for the same reasons - everyone is on it. If that wasn't the case I'd happily delete my account. The thing about Messenger is it's pretty good too. My wife and I used to use iMessage. When I switched to Android last year we decided to try Telegram. Notifications are often not send and calls are buggy at best. Messenger just works though, just like iMessage did.
- resters 8y agoIt's obvious that Facebook is having some challenges from the dramatic increase in the number of inline ads (promoted posts). FB is scrambling to generate enough revenue to avoid spooking investors. What the investors will be missing if they abandon Facebook, however, is that Facebook has one of the most valuable data droves in history. Long after the kind of dark patterns and data collection policies used by Facebook have been outlawed, the trove that has already been collected will provide AI with plenty of information on human behavior for many decades into the future. Imagine if you are studying the human genome and you are forced to stop collecting new DNA samples after you only have 1.74 Billion samples collected. Not a bad place to be in considering that no new competitors will be allowed to collect samples in the way FB does today in the "wild west" of privacy violation.
- adamweld 8y agoSpooking investors? Aren't they kind of past the point of needing to raise money, and onto the challenge of completing world domination?
- shostack 8y agoThey'd actually somewhat recently taken steps to reduce the number of posts, and instead push advertisers to bid more for fewer impressions. If successful, this has the impact of getting them more revenue with a better UX since there are fewer ads and in theory higher-quality brand advertisers who can afford more for those impressions.
- HeavyStorm 8y agoI closed my Facebook account around 2012, maybe even earlier. Recently I had to reactivate it (oh, and that's when I found out that Facebook never deleted my account). It still active but I simply don't use it. And I believe that's the best compromise for most people. It's still there, and if you need to lookup someone, for instance, just log in. Elsewise, just don't use it.
- thstart 8y agoFB - LIFELOG (DARPA) canceled same day FB is formed - FEB 4 - 2014. LIFELOG team transfer -> FB. Building 8 - China. Zuck’s fairy tale - no more lies.
- charliebrownau 8y agoWho knew when you almost ONLY censor people that support RIGHT WING politics , lie to the public , refuse to have one standard rule for everyone and have a active political bias and have multiple data leaks and censor speech People cant trust you as a company and a brand and leave in droves
- peteretep 8y agoBy far the biggest factor that had me stopping checking Facebook, and indeed LinkedIn, is number of utterly fictitious notifications they generate. There was a time a few years back when that red dot made me drop everything to check FB, but these days it’ll be some completely bullshit message they’ve made a notification out of. Feels like they got greedy for my attention and killed the golden goose there. I check it about once a day now, and in the browser not the app. If the notifications were still meaningful I’d probably still have the app and all the metadata that sent them.
- deanalevitt 8y agoExactly. I removed FB from my mobile devices for just this reason.
- HenryKissinger 8y ago(cries in Samsung)
- propogandist 8y agoYou can use adb to uninstall apps like FB and Chrome in a few minutes, with your phone connected to a computer https://www.xda-developers.com/uninstall-carrier-oem-bloatware-without-root-access/ https://www.xda-developers.com/uninstall-carrier-oem-bloatwa...
- dbdjfjrjvebd 8y ago> This works because applications truly aren’t being fully uninstalled from the device, they are just being uninstalled for the current user
- pjc50 8y agoIf it's not running and doesn't send you notifications or demand updates, do you care all that much?
- calimac 8y agopeople are finally waking up. A decade later they figure out that they’re being mined
- devaroop 8y agoThe world is finally growing up
- distant_hat 8y agoA large part of the problem for Facebook, at least personally, is that its too popular. Initially I only had my college friends on it. With them I had a different dynamic and different kinds of things I'd share. Then the first wave of relatives (cousins, etc) joined. This leads to more content on your feed, but you have to be more careful about what you'd share since its going to reach a different network. Also, its weird if your boss or colleagues want to join your network. Then the oldies joined, parents and grandparents, that means either you set up elaborate rules for who can see what, and remember to set them up every time you update something, or you post bland content that you don't mind anybody seeing. I am not off Facebook, but my engagement has gone down to about a couple of times a week. Their notifications are increasingly meaningless and I am not the only one doing this. On the other hand, I feel Facebook as a company is doing great. WhatsApp is incredibly popular for exactly the reasons Facebook itself is not, private groups that you can share stuff with as needed. Less chance of people seeing material you did not intend for them.
- homero 8y agoThey're leaving to Instagram which is Facebook. Some may not realize this.
- straxorx 8y agoleaving facebook? does it even get affected? I think that non-tech guys doesn't give a damn about it.
- chinathrow 8y agoI have no mercy for them. I have no explanation other than pure evil for the thing which i describe below - happy to hear other thoughts on this. 1) On mobile Chrome, in a not private tab, I flag an ad served via the FB ad network, to be precise it was on imgur. 2) On my smartphone, I strictly and only use FB with https://mbasic.facebook.com https://mbasic.facebook.com in mobile Chrome in a private tab. I never logged in in the not private tab. 3) I log-in to FB in the private tab a couple of minutes later and I get a notification that they received and reviewed the complaint from 1) That was a huge WTF moment for me yesterday - I would love to learn on how they do it and why they think that's something the user would be happy to experience.
- chrischen 8y agoYes but they're going to Instagram, and the Stories feed is not much better than the newsfeed in terms of developing strong, true interpersonal relationships, not wasting time, and improving onself vs mindless consumption. The good news is facebook has failed at creating a product that is truly lasting, so they have to keep this charade up of constantly reinventing the time-waster product.
- aussieguy1234 8y agoLooks like I'm launching Libr (https://librapp.com https://librapp.com) at the right time. I started it because of Tumblrs new censorship policies, but it looks like there's a good opportunity to set it apart from Facebook and Twitter and their ML powered unethical tracking
- Tepix 8y agoYou don't have a privacy policy yet you are asking people for their data.
- arthurcolle 8y agoBasically if you have any kind of publicly available contact information/presence, and you have friends that really care enough to want to reach out to you for a meaningful, enriching interaction, they can figure out how to reach out to you. This facebook culture of needing this centralized service to dictate whether or not you exist as an individual is complete bullshit and I reject it outright. The idea that we're trading away true autonomy for the "ease of social interaction via the web" when most facebook interaction actually is people looking at the endless feed of nonsense/memes/political garbage on the news feed, and not any kind of meaningful 1-on-1 messaging, is the ultimate farce. Furthermore, whats even worse about the facebook normalization thats occurring, is this idea that, "oh, you don't have $(OUR_OFFERING)? What's wrong with you? How can I possibly reach out to you?" What do people really get out of facebook? I'd be willing to wager that there is no value creation occurrring. Either you're wealthy enough that they'll figure out how to hook up your anonymized profile info in such a way that you will get sold useless nonsense, or you're poor enough that they will try to dominate what your impression is of the "broader Web experience" Why are we all paying $(MAX_INT) dollars a month on a cell phone subscription if we're all supposedly intimately connected via Internet platforms? Meanwhile, people feel more depressed than they've ever felt before, and socialization is declining across all quantifiable dimensions. So either I'm missing something, or its just a huge joke at everyone's expense. I finally got around to deleting my facebook recently and while, as with all addictions, has been challenging, I feel myself slowly taking my life back from the social media theatre that has taken over human life over the last decade, give or take a few years.
- erkose 8y agoWhere are they going? Instagram? This is not leaving Facebook. edit: How do you down-vote the fact that Facebook owns Instagram?
- ArtDev 8y agoAs my son said: "Facebook is for old people".
- autoconfig 8y agoWhenever the topic of Facebook gets brought up I see a lot of comments on how "the news feed sucks". That it's filled with hateful comments. Leaving facebook is great because it takes toxic people out of your lives! What seems to be missing from the conversation is that Facebook to a large extent is what you make it to be. _You_ decide who to follow, who to keep as your friend, whose post you want to see. There is nothing stopping you from simply removing everyone except your family members and your good friends in which case I'd argue it actually becomes a great tool and a net positive.
- drdeca 8y agoIf what things end up on the timeline aren’t a simple result of what feeds you select, that makes the feed one sees less under one’s control, doesn’t it?
- fwn 8y agoThere's some things you can't influence though. There's, for example, no way to disable page invite notifications.
- thirdsun 8y agoI think a lot of that has moved to WhatsApp - at least here in Germany people create and participate in groups for all kinds of social circles and activities: From never ending, ongoing groups, like family, friends, clubs / sport teams or work to temporary and occasional groups dedicated to events like birthdays, travel with friends, festivals, etc. The concept of groups is easy to grasp and it's much simpler than organizing Facebook in a similar way. It includes people who don't have a Facebook account (all they need is a phone number and even grandma can join in) and participating feels much less public than posting anything on Facebook. Of course I imagine Facebook won't mind that transition and development all that much.
- johnfn 8y agoThis is an oversimification. I have hundreds of friends on Facebook but the algorithm somehow does an amazing job of choosing my top ten most toxic friends and highlighting their most toxic posts. Unfriend all of them and it finds the next top ten most toxic. Saying “Facebook is what you make it to be” ignores the fact that Facebook does a fine job of making itself be pretty terrible.
- jasonbarone 8y agoThe crazy thing is, for me, Facebook was actually useful for following news ever since Google Reader died. I spent quite a bit of time following many pages (people and businesses) in order to stay up to date on news, and I was incredibly happy at the results. I even went the extra effort to unfollow "Friends" that I didn't want to offend by unfriending. Facebook simply screwed up everything. They removed custom lists a few months ago, so instead of chronological posts that I could navigate with lists, it's now back to a single algorithm-based feed. Many of the people I spent time unfollowing continue to blast me with notifications for literal shit posts that I can't disable. Did you notice that when you swipe a notification in the feed, there's no way to "Hide all notifications like this" or "Hide notifications for Events from xxxx"? It's unbelievable what Facebook is doing to ruin the experience. It's now impossible to disable specific categories of notifications or from people, without just unfriending them. I moved back to Twitter and barely touch Facebook now. The product decisions are just plain frustrating. It's now no longer an app for following news.
- thegabriele 8y agoI still use it as a news feed: even with no sorted posts and all the weakness you pointed out, i found no other aggregator like FB. Notifications send no warning on my smartphone (i disabled them all), except the red dot inside the app: i click once in a while, just to "cleanse" it. I believe they know that social media are subjected to fashion just like everything else: the best way to keep on riding the way is peraphs be the one who kill the old (fb) while nurturing the new (Instagram/whatsapp). In this manner, the numbers are always growing - and that's the only metric they care about.
- CobrastanJorji 8y agoExactly. It feels very much like giant company syndrome. Some directors picked metrics like "frequency of fresh content on top of newsfeed," then that metric become a goal for some manager a few levels down, and when metrics become goals, they stop being good metrics. Nobody with the power to stop it would have been focused on "average value of content item," and everybody else had a motivation to get whatever content their group was in charge of some visibility, so it's more or less inevitable that it'd all go to shit.
- mmjaa 8y agoI'm old enough to remember when online social networking meant logging onto a BBS and chatting with whoever else was also connected. To me, Facebook is just another BBS that has pushed past its prime and is overloading me with candy (cough ANSI graphics, boo! cough) in order to keep me connected - its an age-old formula, and while the density of information being pushed is orders of magnitude greater than it was back in the 1200bps day, the mechanics are still the same. So what was old is new again. And just like the BBS era, we seem to be fitting on a curve where the potential for disruption is very real. What I perceived happen to the Golden BBS Age is, the users grew up. They became a bit more technically competent. They learned to use other tools ("Winsock, TCP/IP") that - at first, were quite daunting - but once mastered, gave them wider access to a far broader range of information sources - the Internet. So perhaps there is some of this factor occurring here, too. People are tired of the man-behind-the-curtain technological manipulation of Facebook and its related services, just like we tired of tyrannical BBS ops booting us for wrong reasons back in the day. So, where will the sophisticated new, liberating technology come in? Like, back in the end-of-BBS days, there were a lot of tool vendors selling shovels and pick axes along the road - the "Winsock for Dummies" and "Easy TCP/IP" products that made BBS'es irrelevant. Is it IPFS? Is it Mastodon? I believe, if there is hope, it lies in the OS vendors. Just like these additional services eventually became integrated (nobody needs to install a TCP/IP stack any more - you've already got one), social networking needs to become a feature of the OS. Trouble is, the OS vendors have been mostly asleep at the wheel for too long, having been lured into walled gardens themselves. But, if there is hope, its in the eventual integration of advanced technologies into the default, out of the box, OS stack, such that there is no need for a centralised monopoly of subversion any longer. Imagine if Microsoft or Apple decided to nuke the scene, and add IPFS and Mastodon tech to the default stack. This would wipe Facebook out in a matter of months - just like happened to BBS's when the Internet finally got the tools from smart vendors that were needed to make intelligent Users again...
- asdfk-12 8y agoI hope they can figure out how to make it work over at Facebook. I would happily pay for a service that clearly stated how they use my personal information, and curates news and provides a platform to interact with friends on/offline, as well as with a greater community. But it doesn’t do any of that well. & that’s why I deleted my account.
- huxflux 8y agoThat was about time.
- rasikjain 8y agoFB in the initial days was useful. Now its full of crap and spam articles. Stopped visiting many years back. LinkedIn is still useful for connections. But I believe they need to change their algorithm and policies to make sure the users don't flock to the other networks.
- rblion 8y agoFacebook is the next AOL or Yahoo, I've been saying this for years. They have a critical flaw in their design and in their philosophy, technological innovation can't fix this either.
- GrryDucape 8y agoAnd this was their best decision imho.
- kawfey 8y agoMy twenty-something friends and I used facebook extensively to run all aspects of our social lives, but now we exclusively use it for messaging and event planning. Nobody reads posts, comments, or notifications unless it has to do with an event. A few of us have been dropping off and now we're starting to use chat programs (groupme, now Discord) to socialize. I have to stay on to keep track of goings on in my amateur radio hobby, which as you'd expect is chock full of old men, a majority of which are on Facebook. I think the generational lag has finally caught up to them.
- anonytrary 8y agoThere are way too many articles about Facebook that are simply: 1. Title implies Facebook is going down. 2. Body clarifies that everyone is just using Instagram
- mcv 8y agoThe only reason I still have a facebook account is because a friend at the W3C posts interesting stuff there. (Ironically, once of his recurring issues is that we need to take the internet back from the big corporations, yet he's the one keeping me at Facebook.) As soon as he leaves, I will leave too. A couple of years ago, friends lived abroad for 3 years and used Facebook as their primary means of communication with people back home. I think that was when I started to check Facebook more often. Sometimes every week.
- nkkollaw 8y agoFacebook is like a boring family dinner that you have to attend. Many people kind of _have to_ have a Facebook profile, but definitely check it rarely. Personally, I keep it only because I have a few apps that use their API.
- philshem 8y agoI deleted my Face&#*k account in 2010. But I can't remember exactly when I created the account. Based on my user ID (17502xxx), is it possible to determine roughly when I created my account? For the record, Facebook in the early days, when it was only colleges in the Northeast US, was wild, wild fun.
- giancarlostoro 8y agoI tried joining when they added high schools and you needed a social proof to join. But I was homeschooled so they wouldnt let me on cause nobody knew me from the same school I was registered with. Good job Facebook. I wish social media needed more social proofs to try and weed out certain types of problematic accounts. I only finally went back to Facebook once it was open for everybody. Deleted it a few times now keep it for family only. I dont go on it every waking day though.
- sigi45 8y agoI thought FB will become something like family and friends sharing. Taking part in other lives but in an efficient way. But it didn't happen. Very rarley are there any picture galleries. And lots of stuff other people share? Always the same. So the realization set in that it isn't that interesting to have a social network. I only need a chat and we replaced our family chat with whatsapp.
- glenrivard 8y agoYet over 30% growth last quarter.
- danilocesar 8y agoI quit facebook a while ago but then I went back. Not for the posts or updates but because of the market place and seeling groups. It's, by far, the easiest way to sell stuff in Brazil. I thought about having a 'fake' account, but having a 'real' one with photos and friend list helps a lot to earn trust from buyers. Then, when I have nothing to sell, I disable my account again.
- danilocesar 8y agoMy biggest disappointment with Facebook is that it - at least my feed - became toxic. There's only post complaining about politics, calling right/left people dumm, and fake news, a lot of fake news. And now they are engaging in this fake notification scheme (same with twitter and LinkedIn)... As i explained in another post, facebook is only useful for me because of the marketplace...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- throwaway_9168 8y agoI am leaving a link to what I think should now be an obligatory reference to the Facebook Free Business post by DHH every time this topic comes up: https://m.signalvnoise.com/become-a-facebook-free-business/ https://m.signalvnoise.com/become-a-facebook-free-business/
- sureaboutthis 8y agoThe only reason I signed up for Facebook, just five years ago or less, is because someone posted a scientific paper or video there. This post wound up being not worth looking at and I didn't go to Facebook for anything until about three years ago when I went to a funeral and found some long lost relatives I hadn't seen in decades and others I never knew. "Are you on Facebook?", they asked. So I went there and friended them. It was kind of fun or interesting for a few posts but, the only one I was most interested in talking to, I talk to on the phone or email more often than Facebook. The rest is idle chit-chat about people and things I know nothing about or care about. So now my Facebook involvement never goes further than to visit the login page, see if I have the red notification icon that someone posted something directly to me and, if not, leave.
- swozey 8y agoNot sure your age range, but I'm an older millenial (mid-30s) and I couldn't tell you the last time I picked up the phone and called someone to chat without intention (making plans, etc) or sent a non-work email that wasn't related to something financial/house-buy/sale related. I deleted FB last year but when I did use it it was purely as a messaging platform. My personal gmail about 10 years ago turned into more of a graveyard for spam and receipts than a communication platform.
- sureaboutthis 8y agoWell, yes. If I have nothing to say to someone directly, I do not call them but I also do not spray message everything I have to say to everyone on Facebook.
- upofadown 8y agoThese sorts of things normally come and go. So the thing that is currently on top is going to show the greatest decline. There isn't really a lot of analysis required. The implication that something like Facebook might be good for the ages is kinda nuts.
- JTbane 8y agoI use Facebook solely for keeping in touch with acquaintances (chat) and planning events on a (mostly) ubiquitous platform. The blogging/posting functions are pretty much useless to me.
- iak8god 8y ago> The biggest drop is in the very desirable 12- to 34-year-old group. 12-34 is a very wide range. While I do know a few people toward the high end of that age range who did have FB accounts and deleted them, I wonder how much of the drop in this bracket is because younger people are simply never signing up for FB accounts.
- rcchyssser 8y agoIf 'mericans are not spending their workdays uploading personal information to FB, what will they do at work?
- T3RMINATED 8y agoEdison was a thief dont forget. So why trust any company that bears his name?
- qudat 8y agoI stopped using it once my mom wanted to be my friend on FB. Now both my parents use it all the time and are always wondering why I'm not on it.
- danschumann 8y agoI think their AI is programmed to keep people on the site and therefore they leave bugs in like: When you scroll down and a video pops out, you're suddenly at the top When you like a message in chat, on desktop, you have to hover a few times until it shows up. These are bugs, but they keep you using the site longer.. I just leave when they do that.
- danschumann 8y agoOooh wait, a new one! Every time I go to the site, it says I have 1 unread message, but it goes away when I open messages. This keeps me on the site long enough to look at my messages and click "mark all as unread" again.
- AngeloAnolin 8y agoOne area I see why FB is losing a lot of users is that there's just too much noise generated, where the content which people may find to some degree useful is being crowded by the same repetitive ads, notifications, (fake) news and headlines that are being circulated around within your interests (friends, followed stuffs, etc.). I recall when FB was immersive because it provided you content which you relate to - people you know, people you follow, interests that makes you feel that this social tool is enriching your life. Nowadays, FB is like a river with too much garbage on it. You won't enjoy swimming, much less even enjoy what you are seeing.
- duxup 8y agoI like to think that it is because of the privacy issues, but in reality I think it is just the experience sucks.
- irrational 8y agoAt one time people thought I was crazy for not being on Facebook, but the more time goes by, the more never getting on Facebook looks like the smart move.
- Taylor_OD 8y agoFacebook isnt for the USA anymore right? Their growth across the globe has to be far greater than their USA based growth. They had their time but other websites, several of which they own or have a stake in, are in now.
- newshorts 8y agoI just don’t log in because it makes me feel terrible and longing. If they sold my data, then some companies have some really outdated material on me. I’m fine with that.
- sabujp 8y agouhh FB + instagram usage > FB usage alone, so where's the loss?
- thorwasdfasdf 8y agoHacker news peeps seem to not like FB, giving an impression of a dieing service. But, look at the revenue: "Facebook reported revenue growth of nearly 32 percent in the U.S. and Canada compared to last year, bringing in $8.43 billion in its fourth quarter 2018 compared to $6.39 billion during the same period in 2017."
- beepboopbeep 8y agoBeing on facebook is like sticking your pant leg in a briarbush. It's random bits of window and content that just tries to cling to you. Nothing about it is fun or engaging. Instagram is quickly going that path as well. That said, any bets that FB's user count will magically continue to increase quarter over quarter?
- At1C 8y agoMy new hero's are Smart People who don't use Fbook I call them Mind Athletes who fight for privacy.
- larrydag 8y agoI never installed the FB app for the very reason of being metadata spammed for anything.
- edisonjoao 8y agohttp://foxie.cool http://foxie.cool join the new wave!