19 ms·
“Courageous” If anyone has ever had to cancel a car sale you’ll realize how much of a hassle it truely is to “return a car” Your credit report will show a loa
by BoorishBears 8y ago
“Courageous”
If anyone has ever had to cancel a car sale you’ll realize how much of a hassle it truely is to “return a car”
Your credit report will show a loan even after it’s been cancelled for weeks.
I once cancelled financing for a car due to it not being as described. Started looking for a new car and found it.
Got denied for a loan because my score showed a 60k loan with 0 payments made. It took almost 2 months to fully remove it from my report and start with a clean state
In summary, Tesla is essentially saying “you can’t test drive it but if you don’t like it you can cancel your car search for a few months and ding your credit score for nothing”
This is like mattress stores that give you a “free trial”, they know the resistance to actually doing ending your “trial” is crazy high
- Dylan16807 8y agoThis is very good advice to keep in mind, but it's not Tesla's fault if the credit reporting agencies are terrible.
- gowld 8y agoIt's not Tesla's "fault", but it's cutting corners in a bizarre way for the auto sales industry. I don't want to risk $35K+taxes/fees and get an Aldi shopping experience.
- BoorishBears 8y agoI think they both deserve credit, in reality returning a 30 thousand dollar object is never going to be smooth. The finance has already written you a check, they’ve already done all this leg work. You’ve already driven it, if you’re purchasing it in earnest you might have already invested in charging infrastructure for your home, a whole laundry list of friction. Then there’s what happens to the car you returned. I wouldn’t want to be the guy stuck with a car that went through multiple 1000 mile “test drives” with Tesla’s reconditioning track record of delivering cars with toe nail clippings in the seat rails (traditional dealers do have offers like this from time to time, but it’s exceedingly rare they’ll actually let you keep the car for more than a few hours, and most importantly they don’t require you to buy the car first, they’ll take a deposit or let you rent the car)
- natch 8y agoOnce you drive it, you are not going to want to return it, so all this is moot for most people.
- Judgmentality 8y agoI tested one years ago (not the model 3) and hated it. There are plenty of people who don't want to own a Tesla even when cost isn't a factor.
- Pfhreak 8y agoWhy would those people buy one though? The parent's comment was that people who purchase the car are unlikely to want to return it after driving it. They were not saying, everyone who drives one will want to buy one.
- Judgmentality 8y agoBecause now you can't drive one without buying it first.
- dpkonofa 8y agoThat's not true, though. You can still go to a Tesla dealer and test drive one. You can't necessarily test drive the exact model that you would buy but that's exactly the edge case that the new return policy is meant to address.
- Judgmentality 8y agoDid you miss the part where they said they're closing their stores?
- dpkonofa 8y agoWhere did they say they're closing all their stores? All they said was that they were moving sales to online only. They'll still have service centers and other physical locations unless there's a source somewhere that says they're closing all physical locations...
- gcbw2 8y agoDoes it matter to the victim who is at fault? ...also, there's a $1,200 delivery fee. Is this the new "restock fee"? it is conveniently left out of the marketing materials.
- city41 8y agoCars have always had delivery fees. Delivering something that weighs several tons is not cheap.
- phamilton 8y agoYes, but you can normally test drive a car without paying the delivery fee.
- dpkonofa 8y agoYou can test drive a Tesla without paying the delivery fee too.
- gnicholas 8y agoHow do you do this if they close “many” of their showrooms, as Musk described it? edit: This was an honest question, and instead of downvoting, perhaps you could enlighten me?
- phamilton 8y ago> We are also making it much easier to try out and return a Tesla, so that a test drive prior to purchase isn’t needed. They are certainly pitching the idea that "buy and return" is the new "test drive". So the question is "Do you have to pay the delivery fee?"
- tedivm 8y agoThat's not the full story though. When delivering to dealerships they are often delivered in a more efficient manner, so the per unit cost of delivery is lower. Even if that wasn't the case when you go to a dealership that delivery cost is part of the price. Claiming the car is $35,000 when it's literally impossible to buy it for that is a bit misleading.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- simonebrunozzi 8y agoGiven they don't allow test drives, they should try to come up with a smart solution - perhaps partnering with a financial institution?
- matwood 8y agoDon't forget that Tesla is already known to be terrible at getting paper work filed on time or at all.
- intopieces 8y agoWere you denied a loan from the same institution that issued the first one? I can't imagine a credit union turning down the same customer they just approved because 'computer says no.' I'm not sure that Tesla is saying you can't test drive it. There are other ways to evangelize the car and let people test drive it, ones that don't involve massive rents in premium retail spaces. Toyota brings the Mirai to my local Farmers Market, for example. They could easily organize such events for the Teslas.
- sjg007 8y agoProbably did manufacturer financing.
- BoorishBears 8y agoThe first loaner confirmed they couldn’t even process a new loan while the old one was in limbo. They even put my case in for special review and apparently part of the wait was ensuring the check wasn’t being used. I even tried going with a different finance company to secure the exact car I wanted (it was an excellent offer I had driven the dealer to) and they came back with a flat no.
- FireBeyond 8y agoHuh, interesting. My Credit Union was willing to finance a loan for a new vehicle while waiting for any documentation that the existing auto loan was totalled. They just said "Make sure that you have the settlement check to us within 60 days, please", and that I paid off the remaining $1,200 "in a timely manner".
- wil421 8y agoI can confirm the same. Had 16k loan that was being paid by Liberty Mutual due to their driver totalling my car. Check was in flight and my Credit Union processed close to a $30k loan for a new car.
- BoorishBears 8y agoI’m guessing it’s different in the case where the check has already been cashed and the loan has been secured (ie. they have a title) In my case they hadn’t secured the loan yet. I doubt they’d be so flexible even if the car had been totaled as I drove it off the lot without the loan being secured.
- AdrianB1 8y agoI would be happy to be given this chance in Europe, I would order right now, but at double the price and limited availability we have other problems to deal with.
- vinay427 8y agoBefore this announcement, the pricing wasn't double. It was only a few thousand more, at least in Germany, after considering tax.
- Kurtz79 8y agoRemember that US prices come without VAT and car imports from US have 10% tariff in EU. Say, for Spain the price of the long range model is 59K€, if you remove taxes and after currency exchange the price comes to 47K$. Add oversea shipping and the cost is not that much higher than the US. https://insideevs.com/tesla-model-3-pricing-info-released-europe/ https://insideevs.com/tesla-model-3-pricing-info-released-eu... https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-model-3-long-range-325-miles/ https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-model-3-long-range-325-miles...
- hutzlibu 8y ago"In summary, Tesla is essentially saying “you can’t test drive it but if you don’t like it you can cancel your car search for a few months and ding your credit score for nothing”" Where do they say that? On the site is a big "Test drive" button which goes to https://www.tesla.com/drive https://www.tesla.com/drive which, I asume, will let me test drive a Tesla. Without Buying.
- irq 8y agoYou won’t be able to test drive _the specific car you are buying_ before committing to purchasing it. You’d only be able to test drive another instance of that model, but not the specific one you’d be committing to for X years. This deprives you of the ability to, e.g., avoid purchasing a particular instance of a vehicle that has some annoying defect or flaw.
- cmmartin 8y agoDefects and flaws will be repaired for free though
- josefx 8y agoDo you also get a replacement car for the time you can't use the one you bought?
- PedroBatista 8y agoWow! How nice of them.
- dmode 8y agoYou can always refuse delivery if you are not happy with the car
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- emiliobumachar 8y agoThat's industry standard, isn't it? Who test drives specific new cars before buying? Would you be as okay with buying a new car after is was test-driven by several random strangers?
- havermeyer 8y agoThis recent article makes it sound like it can be a nightmare to get your money back, too: https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2019/02/21/tesla-refund-and-return-problems-detailed.html https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2019/02/21/tesla-refund-and-return-...
- leetcrew 8y agoif you are financing an (entry level) luxury car, you are doing something wrong.
- boardwaalk 8y agoIf you're not financing any car (if you can get a sufficiently low rate), you are doing something wrong.
- jedberg 8y agoSee my comment above. I get better returns investing the cash than the interest that I pay.
- jetako 8y agoHow do you figure? I've been financing a car at ~3% interest for the past 4 years. My investments have returned triple that over the same period.
- ghaff 8y agoThose investments are not zero risk though. I don’t disagree with the general point but suggesting you should take a loan if the rate is less than the S&P return for the past year is questionable.
- vsl 8y agoNothing is zero risk, including owning a car; include the risk in your calculation. Your time frame is not one year, but typically 3-5. If your loan is at 2%, you don't need your stocks to hit 8% every year. You need them to be no worse than 2% p.a. over the entire period of your loan. That's significantly smaller risk than the risk of stocks not performing at your expectation of much higher return.
- chosenbreed37 8y ago> How do you figure? I've been financing a car at ~3% interest for the past 4 years. My investments have returned triple that over the same period Would you be willing to disclose in general terms what you have in your portfolio of investments. Keen to learn.
- azhenley 8y agoYou can test drive them.
- markdown 8y ago> If anyone has ever had to cancel a car sale you’ll realize how much of a hassle it truely is to “return a car” Why is it supposed to be easy? If it were easy you'd have too many people buying a car "for the weekend", costing the company money and driving up prices for everyone.
- BoorishBears 8y agoThats literally what Tesla is saying you should do. Like to the tee, they literally use the example of taking the car out with your friends on a road trip as a test drive.
- jeffparsons 8y ago> "financing for a car" ... "ding your credit score" To my mind the mere fact that someone would borrow money at all to buy _a car_ is a huge red flag against their creditworthiness / financial responsibility. But I keep reading online that people who otherwise seem pretty sensible do this as a matter of course. Is it possible that living in a city with functioning public transport has sheltered me to the point of naivety? That is to say, is having a car really so essential to holding down a job and accessing services in most of America (etc.) that taking out a loan to acquire a car becomes a necessary evil?
- jedberg 8y agoI could have paid cash for my cars. I chose payments because the rate was literally less than the investments returns I get on that cash. It’s all about opportunity cost. If you have better things to do with the cash then it makes sense to finance.
- Wowfunhappy 8y ago> That is to say, is having a car really so essential to holding down a job and accessing services in most of America (etc.) that taking out a loan to acquire a car becomes a necessary evil? Yes, it is, and it really sucks that we in Amercia designed so many of our towns and even cities this way.
- FreedomToCreate 8y agoThe Auto Loan industry is huge. I would be surprised if more that 20% of the population could pay 35000 cash. Most people less that 40 barely have a liquid cash of 50K. To pull out 35K and regrow that remaining 15K back to 50K would take a year for someone making 100K. Instead you could take a loan which typically go for 3% for good credit, and keep that 50K in a high interest bank account (2% or more) and pay essentially a few hundred dollars over four years to make sure you have cash available for a true emergency. Why risk that. Obviously you could argue that someone with only 50K liquid cash shouldn't buy a 35K but that is not how our economy works. A few hundred bucks so you aren't broke is not crazy. Additionally in most of the country a car is essential to live, especially in suburbs and small communities. Everyone could buy a 15K corolla but everyone wants the cooler thing
- eatbitseveryday 8y agoPay in cash? I find it hard to argue for getting a car loan when the car's value is above a certain amount. Certainly if the car provides value greater than it is worth (i.e., ability to provide mobility to/from employment location) but a Tesla is more in the "luxury" category.
- BoorishBears 8y agoSooo many people saying this not understanding that tying up 60 thousand dollars in a depreciating asset in one go when interest rates are hovering a little above 2% shows a certain level of financial illiteracy that is not conducive to getting good returns on your money.
- outworlder 8y agoIf 'finantial literacy' is an issue, why would these people (or anyone else for that matter) buy a new car? They are taking the massive first year depreciation hit.
- BoorishBears 8y agoPeople parrot this too, someone has to buy new cars for old cars to exist. Buying a new car lets you take advantage of warranties, free maintenance on some brands, having new tech years ahead of what’s otherwise availble (if you’re interested in that), not worrying about a questionable history (I’ve seen cars seriously damaged by driving habits in hundreds of miles of driving by abuse), and a myriad of other factors. At the end of the day money is not just for hoarding. You can want to buy a new car as a treat, or a reward, and still do it a financial literate way. Financial literacy != only spending money in the most utilitarian and minimal way possible, otherwise we’d all eat rice and legumes and live in shoeboxes to show how “financially literate” we are.
- Sohcahtoa82 8y ago> not worrying about a questionable history (I’ve seen cars seriously damaged by driving habits in hundreds of miles of driving by abuse) This is especially true with sports cars. At one point I was considering buying a Nissan GT-R. I could get a brand new one for $120K, or a 5 year old one with 35k miles for a hair under $70k. You'd think the used one is a no brainer! But we're talking a car with ~550 horsepower, something someone could quite likely have been taking to a race track on a regular basis, putting untold amounts of wear on the engine and drive train. I admit $50k is a lot to pay for peace of mind, but when you're like me and own a car until it dies, I like to know how it's been treated, and being the only owner is the only way to know that.
- treve 8y agoMaybe don't take out a 60K loan for a luxury item? I understand a car is essential for some people, but 60K is a very expensive one.
- BoorishBears 8y agoYou’re like the 3rd person to say this and I have to assume you’re not that good with money if you think tying up 60 thousand dollars in a car when interest rates are at 2 percent makes sense. There’s a level of financial knowledge that’s just dangerous enough to hurt you, and I’d say this is it.
- treve 8y agoYet here we are, one of us is having problems with credit, because they took a 60K loan on a luxury item and then decided they didn't like it. What was your next big loan for?
- BoorishBears 8y agoAnother car maybe? I’m not having any problems with credit, do I detect a tinge of jealousy in your overtly rude comment?
- treve 8y agoNot at all. Just different spending habits. Never been in debt in my life, and I'm pretty happy with that.
- MPSimmons 8y agoIf you want to test drive a Tesla, I recommend going to a supercharger, finding someone with a car configured like what you're interested in, and talking to that person. Even after hundreds of thousands of Model 3s have been sold, I still get nods from other Tesla drivers and chat with people at superchargers.
- elcomet 8y agoI mean can't you just pay cash ? If you buy a tesla you are likely to have that amount of cash available I guess.
- sametmax 8y agoThe problem is not the car. It's the credit score system.
- viscanti 8y agoHow often are vehicles returned before zero payments? It sounds like you had that case on a vehicle before this where presumably you could have test drove the car. This move makes sense to me. They're able to shave off thousands of dollars for each buyer. Presumably most people aren't returning cars immediately or if they really care about checking the car they rent one for a day instead of the limited test drive from the dealer. So I think most buyers will think it's worth it to save a couple thousand at the cost of having a slightly harder return process.
- BoorishBears 8y agoThe car was 400 miles away. I had the check in hand when I went down to see it and it wasn’t as described simple enough. You’re essentially saying people should fork out hundreds to test drive a Tesla (that’s the going rate for rentals unless you’re saying they hunt down someone to just give them a car) or buy it sight unseen, neither of which is reasonable for a mainstream buyer when you start talking about the “affordable” Model 3 this change supposedly allows. I also don’t get what you mean by buyers saving a couple of thousand. They’re still paying delivery fees and such.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- resters 8y agoTesla could delay executing the loan for the first week to avoid the inconvenience you describe. Typical dealers want to execute the loan immediately because accepting a return is extremely rare, but for Tesla it's part of the business model to avoid needing a dealership in the first place, so it would make sense to set up the accounting in a way where the loan is locked in but not executed until the return period is over.
- BoorishBears 8y agoI’m assuming you’re talking about dealer provided financing because in my case the loan had to be “executed” to get the car. I was issued a check for the amount of the car, and while the check had never been cashed canceling the check and loan and having it removed from my CR took weeks
- resters 8y agoI'm not an expert on the details, but I'm guessing that is a "legacy" finance issue. No reason why a contract couldn't be designed that treated the first week and the rest of the finance term differently, where the buyer agreed to both, and the return was greatly streamlined. I think the biggest issue with a typical car loan is that the market value of the car decreases after it's driven off the lot, so Tesla must have some plan for dealing with that aspect of the first week returns. My guess is that they are declaring a vehicle "new" if it has under 500 miles on it, and they include the distance the car may be driven for delivery in that 500 mile "new" buffer. Thus if you take the car on a weekend getaway and return it with under 500 miles on it, it is still new (by definition) or at least as new as the Tesla that was driven 450 miles from a distribution center to a customer's door. Normal dealers sell vehicles all the time that have been "demos" for sales people and may have a few hundred miles on them. They typically sell them for a bit below invoice, but a mint condition vehicle with < 500 miles is new as far as most people are concerned. It's possible that Telsa is doing something more clever than the above, but if not that's a fairly low cleverness way of accomplishing it. There is probably a mileage limit that one must stay under in the first week to be eligible for a return.