12 ms·
What's interesting is if you did this for just about any other country, there would be a wall of star spangled banners. If you ever travel outside the US, you
by lordnacho 8y ago
What's interesting is if you did this for just about any other country, there would be a wall of star spangled banners.
If you ever travel outside the US, you inevitably hear about what the US is doing, what they're discussing, who the important people are, etc. The reverse is not true:
- Everyone outside the US knows the top US politicians. You even know what issues they are discussing, like gun control and healthcare.
- You'll know the names of the states. How many other foreign countries do you know the subdivisions of?
- You might also hear about the US sports leagues.
- You know what movies are big in the US. You know what songs are popular.
- A2017U1 8y agoOne little thing my American expat friends always find strange: maps are centered "wrong". As in the US is located at the top left and Asia is on the right. I'm quite sure this is the world standard map, but apparently many grew up only with one that has the states centered.
- kerng 8y agoThere isn't a standard map I'd say. Wherever you go, the "home continent" is typically centered. I was (naively) surprised the first time I went to USA long time ago and saw maps that had the Americas in the middle - but thinking about it, it made sense.
- aristophenes 8y agoI'm confused, I grew up in the USA and for global maps the US was never centered. It was always on the left, like every map here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Maps_of_the_world https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Maps_of_the_world , and Africa is in the middle. If the Americas were centered on a world map you'd have to cut Asia in half, with it being on both the far left and right. It makes a lot more sense to make the split in the middle of the Pacific ocean and that's how I've always seen it done, I can't even picture a world map with the Americas in the middle. Is this a misunderstanding?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kerng 8y agoAh, thanks for clarifying. I was totally under the impression it would be the norm. Here is an example of a map: http://www.freeworldmaps.net/world/america-centric/physical-world-map.jpg http://www.freeworldmaps.net/world/america-centric/physical-... I think it was on west coast or Hawaii I saw those. But what really made me think it's the norm was that the a Universal Pictures logo also has the Americas in middle and their intro ends with the Americas centered also: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KpNkgRv_8XE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KpNkgRv_8XE Quite interesting.
- ghaff 8y agoYeah, that's not typical and the reason is pretty much practical. If you center at or near the Greenwich Meridien, the edges of your map are more or less right between Alaska and Russia and go down the middle of the Pacific Ocean where there's very little land. Of course, one 2D map projection can't cover the whole earth effectively but centering a typical projection on 0/0 gives you something that works for most of the areas people are looking for on a world map.
- pasta 8y agoThe standard map has zero degrees in the center.
- bakery2k 8y agoIn Australia, I've seen maps with North America in the top right.
- alluro2 8y agoThat's just because you guys are looking at it upside down :)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- burlesona 8y agoThat surprises me (as an American). Just about every map I’ve ever seen here, and all the ones used in school, have the Atlantic Ocean in the center and the US in the top left. Actually I’d point out this annoys some Alaskans in my family, as that projection usually cuts part of Alaska off and leaves it dangling on the far right of the map. But we’re so euro-centric it just seems like the “correct” map even though it makes looking at part of our own country more difficult.
- grecy 8y agoYep, this is a good one. When America is in the middle then Asia is broken in half. With America off to the side the "edge" of the map is the International Date line, thus no land-mass is broken.
- aloisdg 8y agoit is related to soft power[0] and we argue that it is a form of imperialsim[1]. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soft_power [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperialism
- Santosh83 8y agoDepends really which section of the media you analyse. The majority of headlines on media channels and newsprints here are mostly on domestic matters. News about/from the US will find mention on the international section unless it is 'big' news. And most people in the world probably don't know US politicians beyond the current President and his/her main challenger (during election time).
- malmsteen 8y agoYes and no. Most people know the state because of movies, not because of news. But I agree we talk a bit too much of the US (here in france)
- simplesleeper 8y agoI know the subdivisions of most of the countries I've been to, which includes most of Europe, Australia and USA... The US spends a lot of money exporting its media, so it can't be surprising that everyone follows its movies and songs or that in London we occasionally have to endure a temporary hysteria about hand-egg (american football)
- jaabe 8y agoI agree that there is certainly a US focus in the world, but you could frankly replace “US” with any G8 member or China, and everything you’ve listed would be true for me. It would also be true for all our Scandinavian neighbours. I’m part of what you could fairly call the cultural elite of my country, and as such I’m not representative for every Dane, but knowing what goes on in important countries, is frankly part of being a small nation. Anyway, that also means the US doesn’t dominate as much as you might think. Even with Trump, the most important countries in our news sphere much of this year have been Sweden (election), Germany (der mutti crisis and CDU chairman), France (reforms and later revolts), Russia (Putin being evil in a new way each month) and Britain (brexit).
- qwertay 8y agoAs an Australian I know the names of quite a few Chinese cities but I think I know a whole lot less about the country because of the language barrier and the fact that most of the websites I use are blocked in china so I don't meet the people online much.
- cromwellian 8y agoLanguage barrier would prevent memory of a lot of these. Consider the Shaanxi province vs the Shanxi province. It’s much harder to recall things you can’t spell in you vocabulary to break them down and where pronunciation is similar.
- lordnacho 8y ago> Anyway, that also means the US doesn’t dominate as much as you might think. Look at Berlingske today. There's a story about the US/China trade war that's brewing, there's a story about the US stock market going down, there's a story about the US government shutting down, and a story about a hypothetical US withdrawal from Afghanistan. By contrast, there's an opinion piece about Ireland and Brexit. And there's story about Germany and China. And it tends to be like this. All the other countries are there from time to time, but the USA is always there x3.
- 8y ago
- TimesOldRoman 8y agoKnowing about France is equivalent to knowing about California. US states behave a lot like EU members and knowing many US states is not indicative of anything.
- pixl97 8y agoYep. How many US counties would a person from outside the US know about.
- erikbye 8y agoThese are just the ones that come to mind right now: oakland county, providence, dupage, king, fairfax, essex, norfolk, san bernardino, los angeles, orange, spokane, sedgwick, sonoma, fresno, queens, cook, wayne, almeda, sacramento, san francisco, oklahoma... Don’t ask why these are the ones that come to mind, but I would bet I know 70-80% from books and movies, the rest from news articles.
- ghaff 8y agoKnowledge of counties are somewhat of a function of the state. In some states, counties (or their equivalents like Parishes in Louisiana) are fairly powerful. In others, they're almost meaningless. I live in Massachusetts and I could name maybe 3 or 4 counties--and that's because I've lived in two of them.
- selimthegrim 8y agoI don't think MA has much more than that :)
- ghaff 8y agoIt actually has 14 apparently.
- burlesona 8y agoThis. My international friends often express surprise at how things are in the US. I’ve told them they should try thinking of the US as the EU and the States as the EU member nations. Then our federal dysfunction suddenly makes a lot more sense to them.
- nothrabannosir 8y ago> You'll know the names of the states. How many other foreign countries do you know the subdivisions of I prefer to compare the USA with Europe as a whole, its member countries as states. In that light, I wager many Americans would know quite a few. Norway, France, Germany, Poland, Spain, Italy, Sweden, Ireland surely would make the majority? Maybe even Belgium. Are we still allowed to say UK? Americans love to chastise themselves for lack of knowledge of foreign countries. But, to compare a >300mm economic powerhouse to a <10mm sideshow? Neither would I. Don’t be so hard on yourselves :D
- boomboomsubban 8y agoWhat percentage of Americans could confidently name one state of India or one province of China? Our education system somewhat talks about Europe, but most of the world is basically ignored.
- jacobmoe 8y agoCan students outside the US name Indian states or Chinese provinces? I assumed that was a general "west not thinking about the east enough" problem.
- bunderbunder 8y agoConcrete example, for anyone who didn't get their primary education in the USA: In the school system I went to, "world history" really meant, "post-Renaissance European history." China and India never really entered the stage. But the East India Company did, which did make it necessary to at least acknowledge their existence in passing. edited to add: That said, I get the GP's point about excessive self-flagellation, and agree that it's OK to cut people some slack for not having a super-precise grasp of the local geography in places they'll probably never go. When I see major cities that lie within just a few kilometers of US borders described as, e.g., "Toronto, Canada" instead of "Toronto, Ontario", though, I still wonder.
- nothrabannosir 8y agoIndia is not as important on the world stage and as relevant to as many other nations as the U.S.A. or China are. And China's provinces are not as independent and as relevant as America's states. China is much more centralized. The states aren't just provinces. It's not happenstance that they are constantly talked about. Hell, it's in the bloody name of the country.
- soneca 8y agoNot so sure about all these statements, but regarding to the headline count on newspapers I mostly agree. Wars have a very strong role in it. Both in the countries in this map and in US dominanting headlines here in Brazil when they go to war.
- buboard 8y agoI ve noticed that most americans are not aware how important the US is for the rest of the world. I don't even think it is a matter of education, except for some elite northwestern european countries, where it matters. Most people learn a lot about the US through the movies and random news headlines. It's what always happens with global leaders.
- saagarjha 8y ago> I ve noticed that most americans are not aware how important the US is for the rest of the world. My experience has generally been the opposite: many Americans overestimate their country’s importance in the world. Just because the U.S. does or says something doesn’t mean other countries will necessarily go along with it.
- mruts 8y agoI honestly don't think you could over-estimate the USA's role in world's affairs for the last 100 or so years. The West is lead by the USA. And I don't even live in the US and I think that.
- smackay 8y agoThere are two parts to this. One is (cold war) propaganda where there is a somewhat vague feeling that the USA has to a greater or lesser extent a set of shared (western) values and aligning ourselves next to them is probably in our own long term interest given the uncertainty that a world dominated by Russia and now China, or, gasp, religion (yes, I know) might bring. The second is aspirational - generations of Europeans and probably other countries too have looked to the USA (and Canada, Australia, etc.) as a way of improving their lot through emigration. For all it's flaws, I loved my time in the USA and appreciate the people and a lot of what it stands for. Despite of all the imperial crap that comes out of Washington D.C. the USA still represents a sense of hope for a lot of people. America still has a lot to offer the world. It's role in the world is greater than Holywood or the government. Merry Xmas.
- briandear 8y agoVery relevant: (Bono: America is an idea) http://www.aei.org/publication/bono-america-is-an-idea-thats-how-we-see-you-around-the-world-as-one-of-the-greatest-ideas-in-human-history/ http://www.aei.org/publication/bono-america-is-an-idea-thats...
- reindeerer 8y ago> It's role in the world is greater than Holywood or the government. Right, of course, how could we forget the petrodollar.
- hliyan 8y agoThis is not entirely accurate, except in those same countries that appear in the US's collective conscious (e.g. Russia, China). The news in my country, for example, does not have the luxury of focusing a lot on other countries -- we have enough things to deal with domestically. Although India and China do come up a lot because it is believed that we're at the center of a tug of war between those two nations.
- saagarjha 8y agoI don’t think I could name any provinces in China, but I’m sure many Chinese know about New York and California.
- hliyan 8y agoI think that has more to do with TV and Movies than news...
- umanwizard 8y agoYou’ve really never heard of Sichuan, Hunan, or Canton (aka Gaungdong) ?
- ghaff 8y agoI would have known those were regions of China (and cuisines). I would not have known with any certainty that they were actual provinces.
- saagarjha 8y agoDepends on how you ask. Yes, I’m aware that those are Chinese provinces, as in, if you had provided me a list of Chinese cities and provinces I could have probably picked those out, or associated them back to China if the task was to match a province to its country. But I don’t think I could produce any of these if I was asked to give the name of a Chinese province.
- laughingman2 8y agoCould this be a manifestation of power law at work through historical accidents/events? i.e., the amount of information in the vogue about countries is distributed as a power law with ~20% of countries like the US, China taking 80% of the share of international headlines. But I do remember Scientific American(mention unintentional, but could be the same power law) debunking power law's presence in many networks.
- everyone 8y ago"What's interesting is if you did this for just about any other country, there would be a wall of star spangled banners." Pure conjecture. Making that statement however does tell us a lot about you.
- bloak 8y agoWhat you've written there would definitely be an exaggeration for the UK. I would guess that most university-educated British people would not be able to point out more than a couple of US states on a map. Very little interest in US sport here, as far as I know, except perhaps tennis and maybe golf, for a minority of people. As for films and pop music: hard to say, seeing as the same films and songs are probably being pushed here. Of course, a significant proportion of university-educated adults have no interest in films or pop music and couldn't name a single recent pop song from their own country (though they'd be able to name songs that were in the charts when they were teenagers). US trivia finds its way very easily into UK news. Probably lazy journalists take anything off social media that is in a language they can understand and copy-paste, with the result that in the UK media there is more of that kind of story from the US than from the UK. Trump's antics get reported. I'm not sure British people are generally aware of there being any other politicians in the US.
- austincheney 8y agoHere are my assessments as somebody who has traveled to South America, Europe, and spent 4 years living in the Middle East. > Everyone outside the US knows the top US politicians. You even know what issues they are discussing, like gun control and healthcare. That is only vaguely true. People outside the US tend to know of these issues in the media about as well as the average American, which isn't very well. > You'll know the names of the states. How many other foreign countries do you know the subdivisions of? I don't find that is true. Most Americans don't even know of most US states and I find people outside the US are about as aware of US geography as the average American. Americans that frequently travel abroad tend to be well versed in geography particularly where they are traveling to. Likewise, foreigners who travel to the US to be far better aware of US geography than the average American. > You know what movies are big in the US. You know what songs are popular. That is absolutely true. Everybody is in love with American media.
- thrav 8y agoIn terms of states, I don’t think they meant, “everyone can’t point to Delaware on map.” I’d wager it’s more like, “People know Texas, and California, New York, and Florida, Hawaii, etc.” I’d wager most people can name several. This is mostly because of point 3, movies and media.
- jorvi 8y agoAmerican states are also the size of countries. A more apt comparison would be counties, which barely any foreigners know.
- petronio 8y agoAnd if we're going there, it's more likely they'll know more European nations than U.S. states. I think there's probably few European nations that people wouldn't recognize by name (e.g. Andorra, Azerbaijan, Slovenia).
- austincheney 8y ago
- marcosdumay 8y agoAs a Brazilian, that's not exactly my impression. > Everyone outside the US knows the top US politicians. You even know what issues they are discussing, like gun control and healthcare. "Everyone" is not the right word here. People speaking english on the internet probably know about those to a superficial level. There's a lot english speaking of people on the US, so we hear about your issues. > You'll know the names of the states. How many other foreign countries do you know the subdivisions of? People that knows some US state names also usually know some of other countries. > You might also hear about the US sports leagues. At least for Brazil, Spanish is the one everybody knows about. > You know what movies are big in the US. You know what songs are popular. Agreed here, people really like US movies and songs.
- arwhatever 8y agoRegarding at least the location names, the US is definitely a massive exporter of pop culture and our pop culture tends to mention place names frequently.
- amalcon 8y agoPart of this is just that USA's chief export is culture. People know about subdivisions of other countries when their country imports a lot of culture from there. E.g. most Americans will know about Sicily and Champagne, because of cultural (mostly food) imports from those places.
- keypress 8y agoNot that true in myopic UK. We know your president, and big news events. I can't even list one US box office movie from this year.
- kylec 8y agoNo? Honestly kind of surprised Avengers: Infinity War didn't cross your radar. That movie was huge.
- keypress 8y agoNo, totally honest. Not interested in movies.
- kylec 8y agoI think that reflects more on you than “myopic UK” then
- keypress 8y agoBadly worded, I'm not chasing after new and US releases. I do watch films and I do follow the news, though not that obsessively. And while the UK press will flag Trump's exploits and major disasters, the US doesn't get that much of a look-in. We are an island nation and quite blind beyond our waters. The information is there to find, but it's not thrust in our faces. Heck my niece has more interest in Korean popular culture than the US. People generally are only concerned for their own back yards (HN has a blatant US bias, perhaps unsurprisingly as it was born there).
- ci5er 8y agoSo- you are Manhattan...
- zxcvvcxz 8y agoThis is because America is the wealthiest and fastest-growing economic nation in the history of the world. It has the right combination of laws, institutions, freedoms, infrastructure, and people, to create a new life. There's a reason it's by far the top destination for immigrants around the world.
- umvi 8y agoThen why is there so much harsh criticism of America from Europeans? Seems like Europe should be the top destination for immigrants seeing as it has superior healthcare, workers rights, gun control, drug policy, etc.
- chx 8y agoA significant portion of people, for real, decide their immigration destination based on movies. I've answered many questions on various Q&A sites, in English and Hungarian both which decidedly has this impression.
- gvd 8y agoI think you get the US plus a bunch of other countries that you hear much less about in the US.
- supergirl 8y agothat's how you think it is.
- HAL9000Ti 8y agoNone of those feel true at all in western europe
- ascar 8y ago> What's interesting is if you did this for just about any other country, there would be a wall of star spangled banners. So the US has the most headlines for about any other country? I highly doubt it. All your following points actually contradict that assumption.
- kbutler 8y ago> You'll know the names of the states. How many other foreign countries do you know the subdivisions of United Kingdom - England, Scotland, Wales, ... Canada - Quebec, Ontario, Alberta, ....
- ionised 8y agoThat's just what happens with empires/superpowers thoough. Rome would have been the #1 talked about country evereywhere else when it was at the top of its game. Same with the British Empire etc.