17 ms·
IBM’s Old Playbook
- skwog 8y agoRelated reading is Cringely’s long history of writing about IBM Blog: https://www.cringely.com/tag/ibm/ https://www.cringely.com/tag/ibm/ The Decline and Fall of IBM https://www.amazon.com/Decline-Fall-IBM-American-Icon/dp/0990444422/ref=as_sl_pc_ss_til?tag=icr0c-20&linkCode=w00&linkId=&creativeASIN=0990444422 https://www.amazon.com/Decline-Fall-IBM-American-Icon/dp/099...
- cwyers 8y agoI would pay hard money to read Cringely's take on this.
- dsr_ 8y agoYou can very likely read it for free in a day or three at https://www.cringely.com/ https://www.cringely.com/
- pchristensen 8y agoYou'll probably get it for free before the end of the year.
- J-dawg 8y agoLooks like he’s written it. It’s surprisingly positive! https://www.cringely.com/2018/10/29/red-hat-takes-over-ibm/ https://www.cringely.com/2018/10/29/red-hat-takes-over-ibm/
- cwyers 8y agoYeah, wow, not what I expected at all. I don't know if I buy what he's saying? It seems to rely on things happening that I have my doubts about, like Ginni Rometty departing.
- jimbokun 8y agoHe seems to think the impact of the RedHat CEO on IBM will be like Jobs returning to Apple. (Except for the "returning" part.)
- pcurve 8y agoHe loves writing about IBM. lol. Very insightful analysis as usual.
- NikolaNovak 8y agoInteresting read; I wonder if VMWare is subtly in similar position - transitioning their company from providing software which ran on bare metal and essentially managed the datacentre; to trying and not succeeding at their own cloud offering; to now attempting to provide layer on top of somebody else's cloud - currently a successful strategy, but perhaps one that'll see them squeezed out due to costs long term?
- zapita 8y agoYes that is pretty accurate. The difference is that Vmware is further along in revenue, and has already leveraged their position in compute to diversify into adjacent markets (storage and networking). Red Hat has failed to do that. And of course Vmware has already been integrated into EMC years ago, quite successfully. Although you could argue the ongoing Dell/EMC saga could jeopardize that... Depending on how well you think it’s going.
- user5994461 8y agoVmWare is part of Pivotal/EMC. They sell cloud foundry that is an on premise cloud directly competing against OpenShift from RedHat. From what I've seen, they're doing a lot more sales than RedHat.
- zapita 8y agoYes Vmware does a lot more sales than Red Hat. However Pivotal CloudFoundry is not their best-seller... I doubt it’s even in the top 5. Vmware’s empire is built on Vsphere/esx (their core business) and, more recently Vsan (storage) and NSX (networking). The former is the largest. The latter two are the fastest growing. Container platforms are a relatively new category, so sales are not huge. In that category Cloudfoundry might be slightly ahead, but I think Openshift has more momentum because their early bet on Docker then Kubernetes is paying off. Pivotal has PKS but it feels half-hearted.
- jacques_chester 8y ago
- roymurdock 8y agoA lot of ink spilled to reach these conclusions: > one of the most important takeaways from the Red Hat acquisition is the admission that IBM’s public cloud efforts are effectively dead > while IBM will certainly be happy to have the company’s cash-generating RHEL subscription business, the real prize is Openshift, a software suite for building and managing Kubernetes containers > IBM is betting it can again provide the solution [to cloud lock-in], combining with Red Hat to build products that will seamlessly bridge private data centers and all of the public clouds To sum up - IBM lost the hardware cloud wars and is making big bets on cloud software. The author doesn't answer the key question posed at the end - does the problem of cloud vendor lock-in actually exist (and the implied question - if it does, how profitable is it)? I suppose that's the info he wants you to pay for ;)
- nine_k 8y ago> IBM lost the hardware cloud wars This makes me scratch my head. I heard Power9 is getting more and more traction in some clouds, notably Google's. Maybe IBM lost the "bog-standard VM-based cloud" wars, where the "standard" is what AWS / GCP / Linode / DO, etc offer. But that space is indeed crowded; doing something where you have little competition makes a lot of sense. (I wonder if they'll be able to.)
- ALurchyBeast 8y agoIBM bought SoftLayer 5 years ago, and was unable to capitalize on their niche (bare metal). Instead they decided to double down on provisioning VMs, which SoftLayer was never that great at. The set of features IBM's VM's provides compared to any other modern cloud is terrible (headed backwards in Gartner charts). It's barely getting any better, meanwhile Google/AWS/Azure are gobbing on features. IBM effectively failed in their integration of SoftLayer. They bought SoftLayer but failed to modernize them. Why will RedHat be any different? Take a look at what's left of SoftLayer today. Most folks who had the necessary skills to keep their ancient php platform relevant have left a long time ago. I'm sure IBM is on their 5th iteration of their "next gen" VM provisioning system by now, due out any quarter...
- alienreborn 8y agoWow, that revenue graph is pretty shocking and enlightening to me. I know IBM is a huge behemoth but never knew it had much higher revenue than Microsoft for most of 2000s.
- amdelamar 8y agoThey really are a sleeping giant. And they had half a million employees at one point. Now I think its more around 380k.
- PascLeRasc 8y agoAnd yet no one really knows what they do. How many regular people have had their life improved in any way by IBM? Compare to Apple's strong stance on user privacy and easy-to-use technology, Google's wealth of free high quality services like Maps, Gmail, Youtube, and good affordable notebooks, and streaming companies like Netflix providing high-quality media content for much lower prices than cable, with little to no ads. IBM can't go bankrupt soon enough. They're a waste of engineering talent and have contributed nothing to the world.
- cbm-vic-20 8y agoApple, Google, and Netflix are consumer-facing entities- most people in the western world are customers of at least one of these companies. IBM does not sell to consumers, so you generally don't hear about "life-improving" things from them, since they don't really need to advertise or compete that way.
- amdelamar 8y agoExactly. They're not consumer facing. But I do think that selling off ThinkPads hurts their image as their logo is no longer on devices. Last time I saw an IBM logo on a device was at T.J.Maxx on the cash register that looked very dated.
- PascLeRasc 8y ago
- wiremine 8y agoMost of my experience with IBM has been pretty reliable: 1. They bring the A players to the sales process 2. They bring the B players to manage the account (technically and commercially) 3. They bring the C/D players to do the actual work. Wondering if I'm an outlier or if this is a standard mode of operation for them? I wonder how this plays in with their OSS strategy? Who works on things like OpenShift?
- empath75 8y agoPretty standard for consultants in general. I worked for a contractor where we did proof of concept after proof of concept for Kubernetes deployments and the people working on the proposals were literally the only people at the company that understood Kubernetes. It was a pure bait and switch. We had nobody that could actually implement what we were selling.
- thrower123 8y agoVery rarely does sales get dinged if they make a big deal for something that doesn't exist yet, or even something which is completely impossible. They cash their bonus checks and move on to the next mark, tossing a big mess into the laps of the people that have to implement. In a lot of the bigger shops, people move around so often that they aren't anywhere near by the time the shoe finally drops.
- lozaning 8y agoEnterprise storage reps make used car salesmen look like angels.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- arethuza 8y ago"They bring the A players to the sales process 2" Not in my experience - at my last job we had multiple meetings with them to try and sell us one of their products (CIO was ex IBM and was pushing us to use it) and everyone technical who was involved on our side was profoundly unimpressed. Was also a bit bizarre that about 6 of them came along to a meeting with 4 of us - we never did find out what most of them did.
- ilovecaching 8y agoI'm really worried about Redhat. IBM is currently a sinking ship, they've laid off parts of their workforce, they're failing to capture the cloud market, and the Redhat buy seems to be a ploy to maintain relevance. I'm seriously anxious about Redhat being drug under during IBM's death throes. Redhat isn't going to save IBM. They sold because they had an unsustainable business, and Openshift is still a risky play to run a stable business on. The container space is starting to get awfully crowded, and cloud providers can provide better tailored experiences and skip containers altogether with serverless. As a long time taker of Redhat certs, I hope they pull through and still look something like the Redhat I have loved and known.
- samstave 8y agoSeems like Redhat is to IBM as a new puppy is to a failing relationship... However, I am not optimistic that a Glorious Future will be the outcome from the RedHat acquisition; While at Mirantis, I was assisting in RedHat's implementation of OpenStack with Intel/IBM and it was a nightmare. OpenStack, at that time was very difficult to implement with smooth success (much like a JBOSS / WebObjects / Tomcat nightmare implementations back in the early days) -- and the BigCo process-procedure-competency-silos that goes along with it... I can only expect that adding more layers of abstraction and ambiguity of ownership will make for headaches. Here is to hoping that my pessimistic outlook is proven wrong.
- lima 8y agoOpenStack is still a nightmare, no matter what distribution. OpenShift, on the other hand, is a breath of fresh air (k8s in general is - the quality is so much higher). Things just work and the docs don't conveniently leave out all the important details.
- Bombthecat 8y agoTry to install kubernetes by hand.. It reminds me of the old days of "dependency hell"
- throwaway5752 8y ago"The best thing going for this strategy is its pragmatism: IBM gave up its potential to compete in the public cloud a decade ago, faked it for the last five years, and now is finally admitting its best option is to build on top of everyone else’s clouds." Ouch, but hard to argue against.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y agoToo bad that Java thing isn't working out so well.
- TrevorAustin 8y agoMore than anything I've read recently, this article makes me bullish on Microsoft, who are successfully executing the playbook IBM ran to right the ship in the '90s: > The problem for IBM is that they are not building solutions for clueless IT departments bewildered by a dizzying array of open technologies: instead they are building on top of three cloud providers, one of which (Microsoft) is specializing in precisely the sort of hybrid solutions that IBM is targeting. The difference is that because Microsoft has actually spent the money on infrastructure their ability to extract money from the value chain is correspondingly higher; IBM has to pay rent
- tguedes 8y agoThe bearish argument to your bull is that it's fine that Microsoft dominates the hybrid cloud, but where is the growth after that? New companies are entirely serverless with no need for a hybrid solution. So where is the growth after they've converted all their existing Microsoft customers to Azure?
- yuy910616 8y agoThe bullish argument to your bearish argument...the ( yet to come) generation of github users growing up using azure cloud
- lobsterloga 8y ago"This is where the Red Hat acquisition comes in: while IBM will certainly be happy to have the company’s cash-generating RHEL subscription business, the real prize is Openshift, a software suite for building and managing Kubernetes containers." Small problem with that. Most of the progressive enterprises are trying to move AWAY from containers to fully serverless architectures (Lambda, Google functions, Azure, etc.) Kubernetes is still hot but the momentum is definitely with Lambda and its ilk.
- kamaal 8y ago>>Most of the progressive enterprises are trying to move AWAY from containers to fully serverless architectures (Lambda, Google functions, Azure, etc.) Serverless runs on? Also Lambda is not a replacement for your webservices. Lambda is very expensive for non-trivial scaling requirements. And yeah bulk of the backends in the industry aren't always web based products.
- lima 8y agoEnterprises moving to serverless are rare. Many still struggle to move off dedicated infrastructure or mainframes. And serverless is a risky bet, anyway - vendor lock in, costs and security being important concerns.
- freehunter 8y agoI'm a consultant who works with enterprises of all sizes (all sizes that could still be considered "enterprise" sized at least) and I've only encountered one that has used anything serverless, and then only in one production application. And I touch basically every IT application/environment across the entire business. Now I don't want to say my experience is perfectly indicative of what big companies are doing in general, but I certainly haven't noticed this trend. Even containers are just starting to catch on in the enterprise market, and a lot of enterprise software doesn't currently support containerization.
- AndyNemmity 8y agoI was an enterprise consultant, and I'll vouch for your experiences. It's moving in that direction, but it's a few years out of what people think. Like, hdfs is far more common now. Technology starts at the larger companies, and trickles down over time.
- josephmosby 8y agoAnother factor that is going to pinch IBM here: they're getting hit from the other side with professional services firms (McKinsey, Big Four, Booz Allen, etc.) now jumping into cloud implementation work. Also smaller but legitimate technical firms like Pivotal who capitalized on IBM dragging their feet in this marketplace. So, if IBM's strength was "we can do services from anywhere," that gets busted by the rest of these players who can now compete at the same logistical level. And if they aren't hiring the best engineers, they're going to get slammed by Microsoft who will pay top dollar for them.
- technofiend 8y agoDoubly so because their investment into RHEL legitimizes the technology for anyone still so conservative as to be unsure. Well if _IBM_ says it's legitimate, it must be so. But really once that barrier to entry is gone (as you said) anyone with enough credibility can sell the tech because it's open source. Arguably unsure people may want to buy Red Hat for support but they'll quickly find it's available elsewhere cheaper and possibly not needed at all.
- user5994461 8y agoThe support from somewhere else raises the question of from where? Which raise the risk that IBM could kill CentOS. Once done, there is no choice for company but to pay for RedHat or migrate to Debian.
- Conan_Kudo 8y agoThis makes the openSUSE Leap -> SUSE Linux Enterprise supported upgrade strategy interesting, because if someone started out with openSUSE Leap 15.0, they can trivially attach a SUSE Linux Enterprise 15 subscription to it and convert the system, and remain fully supported by SUSE in the process. So with that available, if SUSE isn't completely stupid on how to go to market, they'll actually figure out a way to capitalize on that.
- 8y ago
- HHalvi 8y agoOff topic : Ben's articles on Stratechery were pretty much only becoming about one or two things only i.e Bundling and Aggregation. I am happy that from the Instagram's CEO article to this one all of the posts did not disappoint me at all and are not a unhealthy repeat of the same themes and or theories.
- crb002 8y agoMissing the key component. IBM mainframe colocated with a big three cloud provider. That's the secret sauce to shave latency.
- sjg007 8y agoI guess what IBM needs to do is to go talk to its customers. Server-less is an interesting development. To avoid lock in though we would need a library API layer. Much like what Kubernetes provides at the application layer.
- jacques_chester 8y agoBoth IBM and Red Hat have fulltime participants working on Knative (as well as Pivotal, SAP, VMWare and Google).
- gaius 8y agoconsumer technology will obliterate all computer science over the last 20 years What does this quote actually mean?
- jimbokun 8y agoIt means things were not going to go well for IBM with that CEO at the helm.
- whatupmd 8y agoI work on IBM clouds all day and what they have been doing for the last several year(s) is embracing Linux, much the same way that Microsoft has been embracing Linux with containers, WSL, github, and Azure. The first thing I thought when I read this news was - good maybe they’ll take their 360,000 employees, make them all use Linux, and as a consequence standardise a developer laptop to compete with MacBook. The second thing I thought was - if there is 360,000 people with Linux laptops in your enterprise, what sort of creative uses could you come up with for container orchestration. The third thing I thought was - I wonder how much they pay in Microsoft licensing per year.
- nradov 8y agoIBM sold their laptop business to Lenovo years ago.
- whatupmd 8y agoNot talking about starting a laptop business - talking about a major corporation with 360K people that are all-in on Linux. Someone needs to fulfill that hardware requirement - it doesn't have to be IBM. What does that sort of requirement do to the IT ecosystem.
- cocoa19 8y agoAnd IBM shifted to use Apple Macs.
- adrianmonk 8y agoNot necessarily sure it'll work out for IBM, but the article brings up an interesting parallel. In its previous comeback, part of its strategy was positioning itself one layer above the commodity layer. (The article says, "The actual technologies underlying the Internet were open and commoditized, which meant IBM could form a point of integration and extract profits, which is exactly what happened.") Now with open cloud technologies aiming to make cloud providers (Amazon, MS, Google) into commodities, this new effort also shares that strategy. Of course the other ingredients are that it must be a value-add that customers actually need and nobody else offers a better version of. But buying Redhat seems like a reasonable stab at achieving that. Overall, their strategy seems to make sense at a very high level.
- jorblumesea 8y agoAt this point, is IBM anything more than an accenture/infosys/cognizant style consulting firm with patents? I'm having a hard time understanding why they're supposedly different compared to any of the big players in that space.
- MR4D 8y agoIBM just gave Ubuntu (Canonical) the biggest gift it can possibly imagine. Now, will they be able to capitalize on it?
- 013a 8y agoI find the directions the cloud space is evolving in completely fascinating. I suspect we're going to see some major shifts over the next decade. Primarily: Azure is already super successful and I see it taking a solid #1 over the next few years. The main reason is that Microsoft is doing what they do best: offering a product in every category. Want Kubernetes? They've got it. Need issue management? Azure DevOps. Chat? Teams. Email and Office? 365. Once you're in that ecosystem you're just going to bleed into all of their products before suddenly you're a Microsoft shop. Moreover, Microsoft has done an extraordinary job at revitalizing the user experience of many of their products. Azure DevOps and Teams has its issues, but they're miles ahead of the products they're replacing, and truly only maybe 10% behind the 'best in class' of each category. Compare this positioning to Amazon: AWS still only competes solidly in the cloud space, without extending out into the rest of "development team support" that Azure/Microsoft does. They were also ridiculously slow to accept that Kubernetes won the container war, and even today EKS is a comparatively garbage product when lined up against AKS/GKE (no managed worker nodes, $0.20/hour for the control plane, reliance on eksctl to do anything easily which isn't even an official AWS product, etc). Amazon will be fine, but I worry about Google Cloud's future. They're industry leaders when it comes to new technology, no one else is even close, but that doesn't really matter when its open source and Microsoft is so quick to implement everything they make directly into Azure. Why isn't Google Cloud more successful? I think its enterprise support and respect, which isn't something you can just buy especially with Google's lackluster history in that domain.
- jacquesm 8y agoThe really scary thing about Google Cloud to me is that Google has a very long history of axing projects. I'm just trying to imagine what it would be like to be totally tied into GC and to receive an email along the lines of 'Dear customer, to serve you better we have decided to retire GC by the end of this year, as per your contract you have three months to move'.
- 013a 8y agoGoogle takes G-Suite/Enterprise focused products very seriously. I can't think of many major examples of them axing one of their enterprise products (or really any, though I'm sure there's one or two fringe examples). In other words, I think they have an issue of reputation here, but that reputation is mostly unfounded because it applies to a different class of products. I also think GCloud is very unique in that all of the capex that Google spends on it comes back to benefit Google. All of their product offerings need servers and world class networks behind them. So even if GCloud remains a solid third/fourth place in the cloud race, I doubt we'll see them go anywhere just because Google itself is probably using it internally to some degree. I mostly worry about the scope of investment from management. I want to see way more products out of them. More managed databases, a better managed NoSQL database than Firestore, lower prices, more enterprise focused things like automated security auditing, better support. We're just not getting it; they're so focused on shiny trivialities like Firebase and Stackdriver while missing the basics.
- ggm 8y agoIf you force-divested IBM into constituent parts which one(s) would retain the IBM branding and why? PowerPC was the last time I was aware of IBM making significant change in the VLSI market. Before that, it had been definitional in a number of things, not networking (!) but certainly high density storage.
- watertom 8y agoIBM today is Unisys of 1990, it's 2017 did you know that Unisys still sells Mainframes? IBM has become completely dependent on consulting, and they did that because their hardware business has been shrinking. They are only selling hardward to a captive audience. The only companies buying Mainframes or AS400's are existing customers, but those customers are also converting portions of their business to other technologies, but not on IBM hardware, or the IBM cloud. It appears that IBM is still a technology company but it's an illusion. IBM is dying and there is nothing that anyone can do about it, they won't fold, but in 20 years IBM will be as relevant as Unisys is today.
- hacknat 8y agoAs someone who has had to deal with two cloud-phobic industries now (auto and healthcare). I have to say the hope of the hybrid cloud being a differentiator, for RedHat/IBM, is misplaced. Getting these players into the cloud is always hard, but the hybrid cloud doesn’t really soften the ground internally at most of these compliance heavy organizations. They are all aware of how awesome and wonderful the cloud is, it’s always politics that get in the way. Once an organization goes through the incredibly difficult process of allowing cloud projects (which involves lawyers, rewriting policies, compliance officers, etc), the organization usually puts all projects going forward onto the cloud and views the old stuff as legacy. The idea of trying to bridge the two is rarely considered worth it. Of course there are exceptions. However where I see hybrid clouds do well is in organizations that are taking the task of porting everything to the cloud very seriously, but they know the project will take a while, so it is worth everybody working off of the same infrastructure playbook until they can shove everything in the cloud. The days are dark for the folks that missed the cloud bandwagon over a decade ago.