6 ms·
CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing causes lots of mutations
- searine 8y ago>CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing causes lots of mutations This is still a very controversial statement, and far from definitively proven. Yes, even with a nature paper. I also take issues with the phrase "lots". So far this effect has been observed only locally. I believe the result, and I think it needs broader investigation but a summary like "gene-editing causes lots of mutations" is not accurate.
- rc_bhg 8y agoYeah I fear like all this will do is give rise to some false conspiracy theories about CRISPR.
- vedtopkar 8y agoNot quite true. There is a decent amount of literature describing off-target cleavage events as well.
- ejstronge 8y agoI don't think this is a controversial statement at all. Any CRISPR-Cas9 paper published will at least discuss the prospect of undesired mutations; this is a well-known concern. You may be interested in my comment from the last time this journal article was posted to HN. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17544250 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17544250
- searine 8y agoSpeaking as a biologist. Among my colleagues, it is still very controversial. It should be noted that "controversial" scientifically means something different than in the general public. What I mean is that we see and believe the current observations but are still waiting to fully understand the extent and reproducibility.
- ejstronge 8y ago> Speaking as a biologist. Among my colleagues, it is still very controversial. I'm also a biologist. I guess I don't understand where your concern arises. I and others I know have used CRISPR-Cas9 to introduce arbitrary DNA mutations at loci of interest. We see many different types of lesions, ranging in size.
- searine 8y agoI shouldn't have brought credentials into this, its bad form on my part. But anyway, I was just relating what I've heard from colleagues and my dis-taste for the articles definitive title.
- dekhn 8y agoThere is a wide range of literature that supports the claim. Some of it is garbage but there's enough evidence that any scientist should be suspicious of claims there isn't.
- searine 8y ago>Some of it is garbage This is why it is controversial.
- dekhn 8y agoI said some of it is garbage. Not all. Making claims in this area is fraught with incompetence and lying, so my warning is to skilled readers who need to be reminded of the value of skepticism.
- searine 8y agoI agree. I am taking issue with the articles title "CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing causes lots of mutations" From the current literature, there have been bad and good examples of this, but it is still a field in flux. We do not know conclusively what the effect is, how large, and how local. This makes blanket statements like "CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing causes lots of mutations" controversial.
- peterwwillis 8y agoYeah. It seems a bit like saying "use of cars causes lots of deaths". As we learn how to drive that should hopefully become less of a problem.
- jackgavigan 8y agoEvery time I read about gene editing, I think of the short story Sisters by Greg Bear: https://www.baen.com/Chapters/ERBAEN0036/ERBAEN0036___1.htm https://www.baen.com/Chapters/ERBAEN0036/ERBAEN0036___1.htm
- dandigangi 8y agoNot entirely unexpected to see stuff like this come up. We're still in the early days of what gene editing is and will become. Keeping my fingers crossed for its future.
- LinuxBender 8y agoIsn't this the basis for the movie "I Am Legend"? In all seriousness, how likely will the gene mutations from people self experimenting lead to a contagion? There are many CRISPR kits that people can buy to do their own experimentation.
- proaralyst 8y agoI suspect you're much more likely to give yourself cancer than cause an I am Legend-style mutation.
- LinuxBender 8y agoProbably so, but I don't have any statistical data to form an opinion. Does anyone track genetic incidents / blunders at a global scale?
- bru 8y agoActual source: https://www.sanger.ac.uk/news/view/genome-damage-crisprcas9-gene-editing-higher-thought https://www.sanger.ac.uk/news/view/genome-damage-crisprcas9-... Paper: https://www.nature.com/articles/Nbt.4192 https://www.nature.com/articles/Nbt.4192
- caio1982 8y agoSometimes I think these gene editing techniques are more like having a fantastic hex editor... but with a 5GB binary.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- solarkraft 8y agoExcept the hex (or binary) editor isn't quite perfect yet. Improving this is obviously very important for gene editing.
- k__ 8y agoI think the problem is also, that the code which was the base for the binary is also pretty crappy legacy code without encapaulation etc.
- TeMPOraL 8y agoOr built with an optimizing compiler. Point being, just like with typical binaries, you can't easily read what the program will be doing; it's not apparent in the structure of data.
- throwaway5752 8y agoI think that if you wanted to reframe it this way, it's more like like editing a 800MB binary with sed/regexes (with some degree of random side effects injected sometimes)
- mxwsn 8y agotl;dr: (1) The paper's main finding has been known by the DNA repair community, (2) relying on DNA double-strand breaks for genome editing has been known to be non-ideal in the long-term, and (3) current ex vivo therapies are unaffected since we can screen cells after editing. The root cause here is the DNA double-strand break induced by Cas9, and the ensuing DNA repair processes that occassionally produces large deletions (the paper reports two thirds or 32/48 were less than 50 bp and 21% or 10/48 were greater than 250 bp). This has been largely known by the DNA repair community for 20+ years. Currently, our most powerful genome editing techniques rely on CRISPR's ability to induce double-strand breaks, such as HDR (for inserting designed sequences, used in gene drives for instance) and NHEJ (for knocking out genes, used in all current early-phase therapies under development). However, a double-strand break is among the most traumatic experiences a cell's genome can experience. We're currently taking advantage of the cell's freak-out attempts to repair its DNA for genome editing purposes, but the process is noisy and produces highly variable and stochastic outcomes. HDR, for instance, has a baseline efficiency of less than 20% in many cell types and conditions of therapeutic interest. Many papers have shown dramatically increased HDR rates at the expense of altering the cell's DNA repair pathways, but these were never going to be humanity's dominant therapeutic approach -- messing with DNA repair is dangerous and closely linked to cancer. The holy grail is a genome-editing tool that is highly precise, with no off-target effects (edits only exactly in the genome where we want) and highly precise on-target effects (results in the same change everytime we apply it) and flexilbe (many designable changes). The messiness of cellular DNA repair is a major challenge to the second goal. The scientific community has recognized this and has been working on CRISPR-related genome-editing technologies that rely less or not at all on inducing double-strand breaks, thereby skipping the messiest part of the genome-editing process. One example is base editing, where the endonuclease domains of Cas9 are disabled (called dCas9, sometimes explained as "dead" Cas9), and alternative enzymes that transform nucleotides (such as C->T) are attached to dCas9. In this setup, dCas9 provides the "homing" targeting while the attached enzyme enacts the editing without inducing a DSB. As it stands now, base editing is very exciting, but further work remains to develop base editors for all possible nucleotide transformations (a -> b for all a != b in {A, C, G, T}); it's not as flexible as HDR. I do want to note another therapeutic domain of ex vivo therapies, where the messiness of DSB-associated genome editing strategies is much less of an issue, since cells can be screened after editing in vitro to control which genotypes we're inserting back into the patient.
- zfrenchee 8y agoCas9 does not edit DNA, it cleaves DNA. What happens afterwards is up to the cell. The hype machine has ignored this fact. One of my favorite George Church quotes: "CRISPR: some call it genome editing. I call it genome vandalism". Base Editors can actually edit DNA, but only single bases at a time. http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/10/novel-crispr-derived-base-editors-surgically-alter-dna-or-rna-offering-new-ways-fix http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/10/novel-crispr-derived-... There's a big prize waiting for the person who can harness DNA repair pathways in conjunction with Cas9 to make precise, multi-base DNA edits. Lots of folks are working on that now.
- 21 8y agoDoes it cleave a whole segment off (two point cut), or just a single cut?
- distant_hat 8y agoSingle cut.
- replies_to_all 8y agoShut up, shut up, shut up.