15 ms·
Munro Teardown Shows Tesla Model 3 Solidly Profitable [video]
- karpodiem 8y ago...at what selling price? M3 Long Range starts at $49K, which can be configured with a $2500 deposit for delivery in a few months. The M3 short range (starting at $35K) can't be configure for delivery at this time.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ProfessorLayton 8y agoThis needs an answer. One would hope it is profitable at 40% above it's base price. The real question is if they'll be able to eek out a profit when they start selling to the masses.
- greglindahl 8y agoThe short-range Model 3 is just the long-range one with a smaller battery and a less fancy interior package, so it's not rocket science to estimate its margin from the long-range car teardown.
- jsight 8y agoIt also lacks the glass roof. Maybe there are a few other small feature differences as well? But I agree, it isn't exactly impossible to estimate its cost from the cost of the LR PUP version.
- compcoffee 8y agoGood, I hope Tesla can find their space and actually become a feasible company. My "commuter" vehicle is paid off in 2 years, so I hope in 3 or 4 EVs are widespread enough to buy one. I drive about 120km round trip, so an EV makes a lot of sense. Don't let my comment history fool you; I'm pro EV, and even pro Tesla. I simply believe TSLA is overvalued, because they aren't going to rule the world. That said, there's a big gap between "theoretically" profitable, and GAAP profitable. Tesla's problem won't be the margin on their assembly and parts; it will be the ongoing maintenance and potentially demand for cars that, up to now, are far more expensive than advertised.
- mberger 8y agoI'm in the same boat. I'm not rich enough to afford a Tesla so I'm hoping the Leaf or similar hit the 20k - 30k mark when I'm ready to buy. I have a 4km (!) commute so range is not an issue. What will be an issue is fitting my house with a charging station.
- lelaurent 8y agoWhy on earth do you go by car for 4km?
- MR4D 8y agoRain. Wind. Snow. Freezing temperatures. Hot & humid temperatures. Bad neighborhoods. Heavy briefcase. All sorts of reasons. Several years ago in Houston, we (there were several of us) drove across the street to have lunch most days. Over the course of a year, I never walked the route. Line of sight was maybe 500 yards, but a busy freeway was between the restaurant and our office. While you might think I'm crazy, I don't recall ever seeing any other business-dressed people walk under that freeway. you would be soaking wet from the heat & humidity by the time you got to lunch.
- ambicapter 8y agoY'all need pedestrian tunnels.
- MR4D 8y agoFunny enough, we have them downtown. They've flooded a few times due to the monstrous rains we get here (see hurricane harvey). I think Minneapolis figured this out the best with a downtown connected by skybridges on the 2nd floor connecting tons (most?) of the buildings).
- compcoffee 8y ago>Y'all need pedestrian tunnels. Yeah, and? Most people also find pickup trucks excessive. And yet, they are the most profitable vehicles on the planet. So much so that Tesla wants to make one. There's a whole world outside the urban bubble, for better or worse.
- hayd 8y agoWhich was the original video where he didn't like the fittings etc?
- devin 8y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QCIo8e12sBM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QCIo8e12sBM
- Nokinside 8y agoTL;DW of the original video is * Electronics, batteries etc. are far ahead of others * Car drives very well. * Traditional car parts are total crap. Chassis very heavy without any safety or other reasons. Munro says in a interview that had Tesla outsourced the manufacture and design of of the car minus the scateboard to a company like Magna they would have hit every target and even Toyota would be crapping their pants now. If the traditional mechanical parts of the car would have been even decent, Tesla would have mopped the floor with everybody. Tesla has been throwing money away because they didn't outsource and they have been loosing time against competition that comes behind.
- sharpercoder 8y agoOutsourcing stuff usually hurts in the longer term as company knowledge is not build up within the company itself. For many parts this is crucial in a car, for other parts it has no effect.
- ygra 8y agoThey did this with the Roadster, though.
- Theodores 8y agoFisker outsourced everything. Fisker who? Valmet Automotive build the A Class Mercedes, they used to build the Porsche mid-engine products and plenty of other quality cars. It went badly wrong with Fisker. Outsourcing is no magic bullet, design, management, sales, marketing, supply chain management, finance and plenty of other stuff has to happen. The bit we only ever see on the news is final assembly - the production line. The sub-assemblies are not shown. There was a time when things like seats were made in house by the auto makers. Over time the likes of Johnson Controls have ended up doing all of that. The 'persons needed to make a car' goes down dramatically if you have a guy and a forklift dropping off the seats at final assembly with those seats coming from a supplier. If you have a gigafactory sized floor full of women and sewing machines making seats, dashboards and steering wheel covers then 'persons needed to make a car' goes up considerably. There was a famous strike in the UK where the women that made the seats went on strike - allegedly they were not getting equal pay. Ford could not sell cars without seats in them so it was not a good situation. The real reason for outsourcing some parts and not others is because the outsourced components can be better than what you can make in house, even if you are Elon Musk.For instance, in a crash you do not want that plastic dashboard to shatter into pieces that can kill the driver, you want it to disintegrate more gracefully. Although the Tesla may be with its own funky design the interior is almost certainly mostly outsourced to the same companies that make all the other interiors but specified differently. The example in the Munro teardown of the rear view mirror, that is something that can be specified correctly for a contractor to make, for someone on final assembly to just glue in place. The other brands - GM and BMW presumably have traditional embedded electronics driving the thing, not some high end 'PC' tucked under the back seats. So they have to specify a more convoluted mirror. Tesla did learn from the original Roadster on what they needed to do to build a car. There was a poor cultural fit between what they were trying to do and their 'leaded petrol' friends at Lotus etc. were doing. As evidenced by the unfortunate Fisker Karma there is no way to magically build a car just by getting the whole thing outsourced.
- fhood 8y agoWow, and absolutely brutal amount of work must have been put into those reports. How do they estimate the cost of parts made inhouse?
- jseutter 8y agoHeh, I loved the answer when I read about it a while back: https://jalopnik.com/the-fascinating-company-that-tears-cars-apart-to-find-o-1787205420 https://jalopnik.com/the-fascinating-company-that-tears-cars... In short, get a bunch of experts together and review each part, then add up the result.
- froindt 8y agoLooking at the shape of a part, estimated quantity required, etc. an experienced manufacturing engineer can give you a very good guess as for how it was made. One of my industrial engineering professors encouraged us to bring any parts we were uncertain of to him for analysis (and I did stump him one time with the plastic molding on the end of a DVI cable). There are fixed costs and variable costs for production. Creating the dies and molds is a very large fixed cost which gets spread across all units created. Based on the size of the part, estimated tolerances required for successful operation, and other factors, an estimated die or mold cost could be created. The material, electricity, and labor are variable costs of production, all of which can be quite easily estimated. Now, on the rear view mirrors they had cost down to the penny. Unless they have some other datasources they're using, I'm guessing it's an estimated cost. Unless I learn more, I'd be skeptical of those prices. I'd be more comfortable if they posed an estimated cost per component and rolled it up into an estimated cost for the rear view mirror assembly.
- martythemaniak 8y agoThis isn't the first time this kind of teardown has been performed and they all show the same thing. The $35k base model made at scale later this year will be profitable. I know this doesn't sit well with the whole "Musk is a fraudster/bullshit artist" wave that's hit HN and most online forums recently, but sometimes things are really simple. They'll make the car and sell it a profit.
- karpodiem 8y agoI'll believe it when I see positive cash flow being generated through reading a 10-K statement filed with the SEC. Historically, Tesla has never done this without selling ZEV credits (there were those two quarters it posted a profit but the amount of cash they've burned is many times greater than those two miniscule profits they posted). I say this because selling ZEV credits isn't an advantage, any automaker can do this if they sell vehicles, even if those vehicles are sold at a loss.
- compcoffee 8y ago>The $35k base model made at scale later this year will be profitable." We've been hearing about it forever. Let's see it. It's always "coming". >"Musk is a fraudster/bullshit artist" wave that's hit HN and most online forums recently" Give me a break. You're "wave" is my, finally, balance. Tesla, or more specifically Musk, has got far more postive press than they deserve. I never see any Nissan, Porsche, Audi, or rarely, GM articles on this site. Meanwhile, every time the Tesla blog/Electrek make a post, it's upvoted here.
- danhak 8y agoIt will come as soon as the company exhausts demand for the higher-ASP variants. In what world does it make business sense for a production-constrained company to prioritize its least expensive products?
- kasey_junk 8y agoWhen the least expensive products have higher margins than the most expensive ones?
- adrr 8y agoI don't understand how the rearview mirrors can be up to 5X difference in price and have the same features(eg: auto dimming). Also BMW and Chevy are likely sharing the rearview mirror with other models so the price difference even makes less sense to me.
- lgbr 8y agoBecause the mirror is otherwise extremely simple. There are no buttons or other electronics like you might find in the Bolt which would have OnStar.
- adrr 8y agoThere isn't going to be a cellular system and cpu for on-star in the rearview mirror. It's going to be a board that probably plugs into the infotainment system board. Also model 3 rearview mirror has a camera so $24 is very suspect. https://electrek.co/2017/08/01/tesla-model-3-driver-facing-camera-autopilot-tesla-network/ https://electrek.co/2017/08/01/tesla-model-3-driver-facing-c...
- londons_explore 8y agoLow res cameras are only $2-5 now anyway. https://m.alibaba.com/product/1307752426/VGA-OV7670-Camera-Module-Lens-CMOS.html?spm=a2706.7843667.1998817009.26.f8c942d4z41ejP https://m.alibaba.com/product/1307752426/VGA-OV7670-Camera-M...
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoIt's right there on the page: > Tesla Model 3 has a frameless electrochromatic mirror with no powered functionality, whereas the BMW i3 has buttons and powered functionality build-in. The Chevy Bold has powered functionality including backup camera display. So the Tesla just has a mirror with, presumably, one set of wires going to it to power the dimming. The others have buttons, electronics, a bundle of wires, and an LCD display in the case of the Bolt. The BoM difference probably isn't too terrible, but the cost of assembly, as well as testing/QC of those features, likely results in the cost difference. Extrapolating from that, I'd imagine that settling on one powerful touchscreen has saved Tesla some cost in a variety of places. Not just lowering BoM on things like buttons and electronics, but also ease of assembly, modularity, etc.
- ggm 8y agoThere was a story about people inside Tesla identifying weld simpification. I'm interested if the teardown was before or after that change, because my working assumption is construction time impacts cost. But not bill-of-materials inputs, so the impact on the cost side, might be low, it just goes to flow-rate of amounts of cars made. Love to know: does changing manufacture of fixed-size parts like this alter cost?
- larrydag 8y agoThe old saying "time is money" definitely important in manufacturing
- olivermarks 8y agoHaving a hard time believing this - as they say in the video 30% profit margins are v rare in the auto industry. I trust Munro though...
- agumonkey 8y agoSurely stock owner will review this thoroughly
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- barbegal 8y agoI'd say there isn't enough detail in this video to say. Munro said 30% net profit but I think he meant to say gross profit. Costings may have been based on like for like labor costs but in reality labor costs are highly variable with the California factory being one of the most expensive (one of the reasons why Toyota decided to stop manufacturing there). In addition it wasn't clear which exact model, sold in which country the 30% was based on and at what scale of manufacture. Taxes, grants, customer options and volumes change the pricing very significantly. My take away is that at the right price point, cheap enough labor and sufficient volumes the Tesla model 3 could have gross margins of 30%. Whether it is saleable at that price point and volume is unknown but more likely than the i3 and Bolt.
- danhak 8y agoAll-electric drivetrains, $5000 software-enabled options, over-the-air service, vertical integration and direct sales are v rare in the auto industry too. Reasoning-by-analogy does not always hold up when comparing tech newcomers to incumbent players.
- newnewpdro 8y agoEVs should have far better margins than ICE vehicles, at least in the interim transition period where prices still reflect the cost of comparable ICE vehicles. They're far simpler to manufacture once all the electronics have matured enough to be integrated. If you look at the Model 3, the power system is largely bundled with the battery. So the gigafactory is pumping out that module where much of the cost and complexity resides, and the rest of the car is largely devoid of precision machining processes. ICE vehicles have complicated transmissions and engines, lots of machining and delicate assembly processes. I expect there to be a period where the margins on EVs are quite fat thanks to inertia in the market's price expectations established by high-cost ICE vehicles. It'll wane once the competition matures and the undercutting commences. These cars should be much cheaper to manufacture (as well as operate/own/maintain).
- Animats 8y agoThat's bill of materials cost. What's killing Tesla is labor cost in assembly. Tesla has about 10,000 employees in Fremont, to produce about 3500 cars a week., per Bloomberg.[1] (No, not 5000 cars; they got up to 4500 once, though.) Modern auto assembly plants typically run about 15-30 labor hours per car.[2] Tesla's Fremont plant is somewhere over 110, even in good weeks. In bad weeks, the ratio is much worse. The point of the teardown is that the design isn't inherently expensive. If Tesla ever gets their assembly plant working properly, they could make money. Musk commented "go to Ford, it looks like a morgue", after apparently visiting the Ford Rouge plant. Ford's PR person replied "No doubt the vibe is funky in that 'makeshift tent,' but it's not bad either across the street at the #FordRouge plant where a high quality, high-tech F-150 rolls off the line every 53 seconds like clockwork." That's what's supposed to happen. Cars coming off the line at a steady rate, union workers not being worked to death. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2018-tesla-tracker/ [2] https://www.motortrend.com/news/toyota-chrysler-have-north-americas-most-efficient-plants-1859/ https://www.motortrend.com/news/toyota-chrysler-have-north-a...
- Shank 8y agoIt's always worth noting the disclaimer that Bloomberg has on their tracker: > Given the exponential trajectory of a production ramp up, there may be sudden increases in output that this model is slow to catch. When you're looking at Tesla's numbers, the tracker becomes more reflective of progress several weeks after a production peak. Given that the 5,000 peak was hit relatively recently, this means that we should expect the tracker to reflect this substantially later.
- HNthrow22 8y agoWhat the hell dang and co? If you're going to remove all anti-musk stuff but allow astro-turfing and just natural praise then I must have the wrong idea of what kind of website this is. I thought this was a place for discussion, not a marketing tool to promote SV's public image. I must have the wrong idea.
- sctb 8y agoThis whole anti/pro-Musk psychosis needs to stop. This site is for discussing intellectually interesting things and that's it. We don't remove stuff, but users will flag stories purely about someone misbehaving on Twitter because it's off topic. Finally, the guidelines specifically ask you to not make posts like this. So please don't. > Please don't impute astroturfing or shillage. That degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about it, email us and we'll look at the data. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- notananthem 8y agoIt isn't solidly profitable, in fact, its solidly unprofitable. They haven't been profitable yet.
- melling 8y agoThe company has been unprofitable. The video claims the profit margin on the car is 30%. I've heard from a couple of analysts that Tesla needs to produce between 50,000-60,000 Model 3's a quarter to be profitable. Musk has stated that Tesla will be profitable in Q3 and Q4.
- quickben 8y agoAssuming it survives until then (bond's maturing, etc).
- melling 8y agoI think Tesla's only bonds due this year are $230 million in November, then $920 million n March 2019. They still have about $3.5 billion in cash. Also, I believe next March's debt can be converted to equity if the stock price is about $360.
- jsight 8y agoIt would be crazy to think that they won't survive until the end of the year. Although if cash flow in Q3 and Q4 are bad, Q1 of next year could be the end.
- Proven 8y agoLOL
- vonnik 8y agoThis reminds of the teardown German engineers did back in May to reach the same conclusion: https://medium.com/@chrisvnicholson/analysis-teslas-model-3-can-turn-a-profit-6c5e9b13afe9 https://medium.com/@chrisvnicholson/analysis-teslas-model-3-...
- jillesvangurp 8y agoAlso check this analysis of the same report by German Handelsblatt (in English): https://global.handelsblatt.com/companies/german-fears-covert-look-hood-tesla-930180 https://global.handelsblatt.com/companies/german-fears-cover... For reference, that's a quality German news publication making the point that German car manufacturers are getting worried, which is probably an understatement. Basically last year, Tesla outsold the German manufacturers in their home market for electrical vehicles. This year is not looking much better. The total amount sold in Germany per month last year was about half what tesla is claiming to do per week last recently. Meanwhile the model S is outselling essentially all similarly priced traditional cars in Europe as well. Unsurprisingly, VW, Audi, Mercedes, etc. have all announced electric vehicles starting to ship "from next year" (numbers unknown, presumably nowhere near 5k a week any time soon). Most manufacturers are being hand wavy about early 2020s type time frames for volume production. If they do have cost issues like this analysis suggests, they'll be struggling to compete on price and volume for quite some time. So, Tesla undercutting them on price and volume is a big deal. Tesla doing battery production and other components in house is a big deal as well. Tesla opening up more giga factories in places with cheaper labor (e.g. China) or in Europe (Germany is being rumored) is a big deal as well. I've been reading all these comments about the imminent implosion of Tesla here on hacker news and I just don't see it. Basically people pulling numbers out of their ass and predicting they won't even last until end of the year. Last time I read comments like this about a company was when I was reading internal comments on the iphone launch while working at Nokia. Needless to say, Apple did rather well regardless of those comments. Basically high placed Nokia seniors were arguing passionately the iphone was shit, the cost was way to high, and no way Apple could match their logistics, and btw. the latest Nokia phones had feature X, Y, and Z so obviously Apple was fucked. Spectacularly wrong on all fronts and Nokia was history five years later because it never managed to recover from being so spectacularly wrong in time to come up with decent, competitive products. I learned a lot about seemingly smart people being completely wrong and suffering from confirmation bias in that phase of my career. I'm seeing exactly the same patterns in the car industry today. I'm seeing a company doing more or less what Apple did to traditional phone manufacturers about a decade ago doing more or less the same for cars. The same kind of arguments and the same disbelief as Tesla ticks off milestone after milestone. Also the same kind of excited user base. Teslas are selling in a way that is very similar to how the iphone market has been rock solid for a decade now. I wouldn't be surprised to learn that most Tesla owners were also early iphone adopters. Sure Tesla is behind schedule. But what schedule is that other than their own ambition? What clock is ticking exactly? What other manufacturer is shipping 5K electric vehicles per week; or even planning to, or realistically close to our producing and undercutting Tesla on price and quality?