21 ms·
Tech Giants Take Their Talent Hunt to Cambridge, UK
- EliRivers 8y agoThe UK could pitch itself as a place rich US tech companies can buy top talent at low price. I have seen some (not many, to be honest) US tech companies open offices in the UK so they can pay half or less for staff, compared to what they'd pay at home. If Brexit goes as badly as it might, the pound could be even cheaper.
- ForHackernews 8y agoWhy are UK tech salaries so low compared to the US?
- cyberpunk0 8y agoBecause when tech companies come to places in the us they become gentrified and everything becomes expensive. In most cases tech companies coming to an area has a devastating effect as people who had lived in an area forever are forced out due to the insane spike in cost of living.
- ryanx435 8y agoNo. You are putting effect before cause. It's the high salaries that cause gentrification, not gentrification that causes high salaries.
- Balero 8y agoWhen high paying companies come to London/Oxford/Cambridge/Bristol the effect is just the same, it's not a US only phenomenon.
- walshemj 8y agoCambridge and Oxford have been gentrified for a very long time
- justincormack 8y agoBecause outside of financial services, there aren't that many highly profitable companies, Google or Facebook profitability levels are not common in Europe. Salaries have been rising though, and London salaries are twice or more than much of Europe.
- sievebrain 8y agoThey aren't common in America either!
- petercooper 8y agoI think there are lots of reasons, both sociological and economical, but my hunch is that demand for the most productive tech employees is lower since it's so easy to lean on American-produced innovations and services rather than build our own in the UK. Consider that Azure, AWS, Google Cloud Platform, etc. are all huge in the UK, yet most of the work on them is taking place in the US. Ditto for Oracle, Office 365, the Google Suite and even consumer stuff like Craigslist, Reddit or Apple's services (that the UK never home produced something like Reddit continues to boggle my mind). Why pay for the best people in the industry to work in the UK when we can just stand on the shoulders of work being done in the US? If you look at industries where the UK does take an innovative role like finance or bioinformatics, the salaries seem a lot more competitive, though are still not at US levels due to the UK's lower cost of living I guess.
- Balero 8y agoThe UK has a higher cost of living, with London pretty much equal to NY or SF and other high cost cities. The other equivalents are cheaper in the US.
- petercooper 8y ago¯\_(ツ)_/¯ That's not my experience of both places, and I've not found any data that supports London being as expensive as SF including https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?country1=United+Kingdom&city1=London&country2=United+States&city2=San+Francisco%2C+CA https://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?cou... - I've found it much easier to live in London on a budget than SF where you'd throw your personal safety and comfort into jeopardy by cutting too many corners.
- chrisper 8y agoIn the US you also need to put aside much more every month.
- dood 8y agoThose numbers look quite wrong, I don't think they're comparing like-for-like. For consumer goods it seems they're comparing a cheap UK supermarket to Whole Foods in SF, and for rents they must be ignoring square footage and/or using different definitions of city center to get those comparisons. I checked out rental prices in SF on a recent visit and found SF pretty good value compared to London.
- Balero 8y agoThere are a number of reasons. Probably the biggest is that the UK doesn't have the number of large tech companies in one place needed to push up wages. ARM is in Cambridge, Rockstar is in Newcastle, Dyson near Bristol. The only exception is in Banking where the salaries are much higher than the UK average (but still lower, as tech is views as second to other roles, not as the primary focus). Other reasons are that the UK has a better social safety net. That to many people in many places in the uk there is no such thing as an engineer, if you work with computers you work in IT (and can you fix my laptop please?). There is in many places (especially older companies with non-tech middle managers), also a management problem. You can't pay an engineer more than a (non-technical) middle manager, because the manager is (obviously) more important, as they can tell then engineers what to do. And all the engineers do is what management tells them to, so they're replaceable. This is obviously not a good environment for productive engineering, but explains why some companies see engineers as a cost centre rather than a revenue generating centre.
- olavgg 8y agoThis is typical european business culture. Times are changing, though, more and more engineers start their own company.
- geebee 8y agoWhat's so interesting is that the same companies that do this will tell you that there is a very serious shortage of software developers. And they'll say this, with a straight face, with absolutely no mention of the pay, as if supply exists completely independently of demand.
- shanghaiaway 8y agoUK companies do not produce as much value, hence they are not able to pay as much as FANG.
- tinktank 8y agoLOL. I'm sure all the investors up to their eyeballs in the loss-making, ever hyped unicorns would beg to differ.
- shanghaiaway 8y agoWhich UK company makes the same profit per employee as FANG? None.
- tinktank 8y agoWhich one of your so-called value-adding unicorns are actually making a profit?
- sievebrain 8y agoIsn't N in FANG Netflix? I thought Netflix was loss making. And Amazon has spent years being break even or making losses (albeit for good reasons).
- adav 8y agoAnecdotally, and when compared to America, it could be due to a combination of many factors including: - More regulation around employee protection - Excellent talent drawn from less wealthy EU states who may be willing to accept a slightly lower wage than locals - Lots of STEM graduates from UK universities - A different work life balance - Tech skills are not seen as valuable as law/banking/medicine - A more profit-first rather than growth-first startup mindset
- adventured 8y agoIt's not STEM supply pushing down the salaries. Japan has fewer per capita stem graduates than the US, with a highly developed technical economy, and dramatically lower engineer salaries than the US (with a GDP per capita roughly the same as the UK).
- meheleventyone 8y agoThis makes me think the question is better phrased the other way around. Why is SV compensation so high compared with the rest of the world?
- barry-cotter 8y agoA virtuous circle of people who make a fortune investing in other people hoping to make a fortune in the hope of making their fortune bigger. Silicon Valley is the place where agglomeration economics kicked in for information technology. That’s not really surprising. It had to be somewhere. Film has Hollywood, Finance has New York and London, Chemistry has the Rhineland, high fashion has Milan, Paris, New York and London. What’s special about Silicon Valley is that nowhere else comes close, that the minimum efficient scale for a great many software ideas is small, that it’s new, the addressable market is close to the entire global economy, and most importantly, they’re talent constrained, not capital constrained.
- meheleventyone 8y agoThanks, to me that is definitely the simple and obvious answer. It’s the one I come to as well viewing things from the outside. I do wonder if it’s too simplistic and appealing because it is so neat though.
- pjc50 8y agoAren't the high US salaries themselves extremely location-specific? It's more like CA/NY vs rest of world in terms of salaries.
- fgrep 8y agowould be interesting to know, people talk about SF only, but how salaries look in places like Phoenix or in states like Wyoming, Montana and Vermont ? are there any sw jobs there ?
- jinder 8y agoI think what most people are missing in these comparisons is that London's tech market is hugely contractor oriented, and so it makes more sense to compare day rates. Finance in London pays typically £500-600 per day for average level frontend and backend work. There's the potential to earn much higher if you're good at what you do.
- commandlinefan 8y ago> London's tech market is hugely contractor oriented Is that because of labor regulations there?
- timellis-smith 8y agoNot in my experience. Most companies I know much rather have permies than contractors. Pay tends to be quite a bit higher for contractors but without all the perks like pension contributions and leave that a permanent position has. However, as a contractor, you have more control over your life. As a contractor, it's also easier to get exposure to different tech, rather than be stuck doing the same thing day in and out.
- a_imho 8y agoMainland Europe has even lower salaries in a similar timezone.
- chrisper 8y agoSwitzerland is doing just fine.
- a_imho 8y agoIt is an obvious outlier though.
- MrBuddyCasino 8y agoErr no, certainly not. German salaries are at least on par with London, and ~twice as high than the rest of the UK.
- tigershark 8y agoNot from what I know.
- MrBuddyCasino 8y agoMaybe my numbers are off, but at least in Munich startups are ~80k, automotive ~100k. What are you seeing?
- collyw 8y agoIsn't Munich the German equivalent of London? The expensive but well paid part?
- MrBuddyCasino 8y agoYou can get similar salaries in other Tier 1 cities like Hamburg, Frankfurt, Düsseldorf or Berlin. Of course its different in small cities (except Walldorf or Wolfsburg), but you also have lower expenses. Its not as centralized as UK.
- slivym 8y agoLot's of companies do that, but the UK is kind of a strange place to choose to do that. If you want cheap, go hire a team of 10,000 engineers in Penang (I'm looking at you Intel). If you want expensive, choose silicon valley. If you want 2nd tier, take a look at Canada. You can choose the UK, but why? Their time zone means you'll never be able to meet with them at the same time as your Malaysian and Californian offices. They're cheap - but no where near as cheap as the far east. And they've got a metric shit tonne of employment rights, which most US companies not only don't want the cost of, but also disagree with ideologically.
- Balero 8y agoThe timezone, whilst often being a negative, can also be a positive. If you need a service that is always up and supported, having three teams (GMT-8, GMT, GMT+8) is one of the best ways to do this. This puts the UK in the perfect place for a company needing this based in California. Also there is a good overlap for companies based on the east coast to do hand over, which I believe is common in finance.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- justincormack 8y agoThe employment rights in the UK are minor compared to most of the rest of Europe, and while you cant fire at will, it is easy to get get people out if you want to.
- noir_lord 8y agoTech multinationals are almost by definition 24/7 operations. The UK for an American tech company is a large stable country within 1-2 hours of the timezone of the largest single market in the world and has a shared language and culture. If you want to sell into Europe then Britain made sense...until the fuckwits voted for leave (yeah I'm bitter, they fucked over everyone my age and under).
- samdoidge 8y ago
- curiousgal 8y agoThat is exactly what every multinational has been doing in the Third World for decades! Software developers in Tunisia, for instance, get paid 5k per year. If the salaries are enough to cover the cost of living then workers will be happy. 100k in SF is the same as 70k in London which is the same as 5k in Tunis.
- smnscu 8y agoHave been to our offices in Tunis, can confirm. Shit's grim, apparently their currency devalued 3-4x in the recent years, making everything absolutely dirt cheap, and their salaries worthless. Friendliest people I've ever seen, though.
- supergarfield 8y ago> 100k in SF is the same as 70k in London which is the same as 5k in Tunis. Not really. Only some things are significantly affected by the local cost of living: rent, food, nights out for instance. Sure, they probably make up the majority of your spending, but CoL is almost irrelevant for - Buying luxuries: a Porsche or an iPhone are nearly the same price everywhere in the world - Going on vacation - Savings, if you don't intend to stay where you currently live forever Depending on your lifestyle, these categories could easily make up most of your income, in which case $5k per year is terrible even if it covers the CoL in Tunis.
- pertymcpert 8y agoiPhones same price everywhere? Lol. When the GBP was a bit stronger you could fund a trip to NY and buy an iPhoneX/Macbook instead of buying in the UK.
- supergarfield 8y agoSure, maybe occasionally there are anomalies, with extreme price hikes for specific things in specific places. Right now iPhone X prices seem to be reasonably close everywhere (not-so-great-source: http://www.businessinsider.com/apple-iphone-x-prices-around-the-world-2017-9 http://www.businessinsider.com/apple-iphone-x-prices-around-...). I think this doesn't affect my point though, which is mainly that iPhones are just as expensive in generally cheap places.
- angarg12 8y ago> As the tech workers land the big salaries, home prices are skyrocketing, and the locals are being squeezed out. Joke is on them, I'm a new tech immigrant to Cambridge and I still can't buy a house here.
- samwillis 8y agoWe gave up on trying to buy in Cambridge and moved north to Stamford, its just over an hour on the train (one stop past Peterborough) and about the same by car (if you avoid the worst of the rush hour, will be 45 min with the new road in 2020). Lovely here, much nicer then a villages near Cambridge and about the same time to commute!
- cup-of-tea 8y agoThree hours of my day is worth way more than what Cambridge employers are willing to pay unfortunately.
- Doctor_Fegg 8y agoGood choice - Stamford's delightful. (Grew up in Rutland, still very fond of the area.)
- cup-of-tea 8y agoHouse prices have been skyrocketing for ages already and it's helped by the fact that Cambridge is within commuting distance of London. There's no way your average senior dev could afford to buy a house in Cambridge at this point.
- angarg12 8y ago> According to the recruitment website Hired, the average tech salary in London is $78,000 a year, versus $142,000 in Silicon Valley. And this is one of the reasons for the brain drain that the mention before. Silicon Valley firms pay significantly more than the competition, and they are still paying almost half of what they do in the US. It isn't only about money, but it would be naive to deny it's impact on people's decision on where to live and work.
- adventured 8y agoIn complete terms it's more like 3x that $78k figure. The salary would be bad enough. The big US tech companies are nearly all publicly traded. So that $142,000 is really $250,000 or more in total compensation. The UK, and Europe more broadly, not only can't compete with the salaries, they can't compete with the ability to dish vast stock compensation thanks to the immense market caps that Google et al. have. If you're really great at something, Google can trivially give you millions of dollars in stock if it makes sense. What company in Britain can compete with that? The skeptics will say something about healthcare in the US as a counter. The top 1/4 in the US have easy, fast access to some of the most elite medical care on the planet. And if you're making $142k in salary in the US, your healthcare is entirely paid for. There are only two strong counters, one is that the quality of life can be very high in parts of wealthy Western Europe, and the other is cultural (preferring one culture over another).
- robert_foss 8y agoMy personal counter is that I just couldn't morally accept contributing taxes to a nation which: - Exploits the poor and non-citizens - Overthrows governments and bullies smaller countries - Has only the most rudimentary social security system - Does not really have a concept of healthy work/life balance. With little time off and none at all for people with newborns. - Takes near-zero environmental responsibility - Literally spies on the entire population of the rest of the world ...
- leg100 8y ago
- eddd 8y agoWhy would you chase people from Universities who have high salary expectations when you have the internet? It is beyond me. Developers storm remote positions, yet the industry is super slow with adoption.
- zavi 8y agoBecause in-person collaboration is more effective.
- cup-of-tea 8y agoHaha, erm... source?
- detritus 8y agoGeneral life experience? I don't doubt that the parent wasn't being absolutely comprehensive in the scope of their answer, but surely you appreciate that direct communication in person is.. well, at the very least 'efficient'? I can't believe you're actually wanting a source for this, lol
- cup-of-tea 8y ago> but surely you appreciate that direct communication in person is.. well, at the very least 'efficient'? No, I don't. I believe written communication is far more efficient. Cavemen talk. Writing is the greatest technology we've ever invented. Forget all your latest devops crazes, you can't do anything useful without writing.
- detritus 8y agoLook, I work alone and find some situations best described by writing down long and comprehensive emails - but if you're going to accuse face-to-face contact as being 'caveman talk' I'm sorry but I'm going to wonder if your empathic or social intelligence is somehow dialled down. My life experience tells me that there are vast tracts of productivity that are served very well by direct collaboration with other humans.
- sjg007 8y agoMicrosoft has been in Cambridge for decades.
- justsomedude43 8y agoI wouldn't move to US for $140k from my £40k salary in the UK unless they point a gun at my face and force me to do it. So to each their own I guess.
- handbanana 8y agoWhy’s that?
- bepotts 8y agoPeople on the internet love to exaggerate how bad living in the US is. The US is a big country and there's plenty of places that most people wouldn't like to live (every country has locations like this), but if you're a tech worker, there's no place better in the world to live than in the US. You don't have to live in the Bay Area, you can live in Seattle, New York City, Boston, Los Angeles, or Atlanta. Don't like the city? Okay, there's plenty of affordable suburbs to live in all over the country. Plus your cost of healthcare will either be free or heavily subsidized, taxes will be lower, you'll be making more money, and the opportunities for career advancement, VC funding (if you want to go the startup route), and opportunities to network will be much greater here. America is an amazing place to live, whether the internet wants to believe it or not.
- fooker 8y agoAmerica is an amazing place to live if you do not have to be stuck in the same place for decades waiting for a green card.
- 6ak74rfy 8y agoThis. The visa scene is US is fickle and very unfriendly even for folks in high tech companies. For instance, the Green Card process is same for a software developer (no matter what company she is in) and a taxi driver. Of course, I don't have anything against taxi drivers, but I do believe education and professional qualifications should play some role in the Green Card process.
- countryqt30 8y agoI would believe the highest NET salary (the only kind that matters) of all is clearly in either Switzerland or Singapore, where you have a total tax rate of roughly 10 % at a 150k salary. The absolute salary is the same or higher than in SF, USA, but you can keep 90 %. Additionally, foreign income is taxed 0 %. Capital gains are taxed 0 %. It's hilarious to see that American's (especially the ones from SF) believe they earn the most. Yes, they are at the upper end if you consider "absolute gross salary", but at the tiny lower end for "net, after-tax salary" and "investment income". As for stock options, your employers typically give you stock options, great bonuses and a 401k-like plan, e.g.: You can invest 5 % of your salary and we (the company) will 4x this. So this is a little like 4x free return on 5% of your salary if you max out.
- ensiferum 8y ago“How do we stop the A.I. brain drain to the U.S. — or to the U.S. companies anyway?” Uh.. create an alternative work place with comparable benefits and compensation?
- swebs 8y agoNo, no, how do we stop brain drain to US companies while still paying less than half of what those companies pay?
- drej 8y agoI used to work in Cambridge, a tech job of sorts. It was swell, the quality of life is great, London really close as well. There were only two downsides. One, pretty bad public transport and driving was often not an option. Two, very few flats, so you’d mostly share with others in houses. Last but not least, there is a great divide between the students, the so-called professionals (meaning tech, medical research, aeronautics etc.) and town people. The frictions were commonplace.
- vilhelm_s 8y agoWhat kind of frictions did you see?
- jingleheimer 8y agoIt's town vs gown. You have separate areas and generally don't mingle. There is an age difference as well as a cultural and class difference. Much of Cambridge is gated off into colleges that a town person can't go unless escorted by someone connected to the university. I was in the gown group, but even within this group there are additional degrees of stratification.
- vilhelm_s 8y agoI went to Cambridge as an undergrad, and indeed I interacted basically exclusively with other undergrads. Now as an adult I'm living in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and there are tons of undergrad students on the street, and I basically never interact with them at all (nor go into the the various university buildings that are scattered throughout the town). But I wouldn't describe that as friction? If anything, it seems the opposite of friction, there are separate groups of people who are smoothly gliding past each other... I guess what I'm wondering is, do you feel there are any concrete problems or inconveniences caused by the town/gown distinction?
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoIt's much the same in Oxford, add in the hordes of tourists and I would say it's not a good place to live unless you are an academic.
- scotchmi_st 8y agoI get the style this article is going for, but Cambridge Science Park (and surrounding areas) have quietly been a major hub for tech for at least the last 2-3 decades. Lots of biotech research, but Microsoft Research has been there since as long as I can remember (I went to school around the corner) as well as major offices for Intel, ARM and any other major player you can think of. If I had to give an answer to the question 'why now?', I would say because of investment, and also Cambridge has really modernised as a city in the last few years. Plus it is a genuinely nice place to live- good schools, you can cycle and walk everywhere, and cars aren't really allowed in the city centre.
- lordnacho 8y ago> According to the recruitment website Hired, the average tech salary in London is $78,000 a year, versus $142,000 in Silicon Valley. Does anyone have a like-for-like comparison? What do the FAANGS pay for the same thing in one place or the other? Is Glassdoor reliable for these stats? I don't think the comparison is so easy, because London has a huge financial tech market which SV probably doesn't. But those incomes might end up in the "finance jobs" column rather than "tech". HFT coders get paid a fair bit, but could reasonably claim to be either.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThose incomes enter into the consultant column.
- chaostheory 8y agoThis is a bit strange that this is news considering a lot of the foundations of the tech industry were created at Cambridge and it's never stopped, with ARM being the most visible example. I'm assuming that average people outside of Europe are not aware of Cambridge's importance. Is it also true of the avg person in Europe as well?
- carbine 8y agoGenuinely surprised at how much most people on this thread seem to consider salary as the most important variable when it comes to where you'd want to live. Relocating TO the US from other countries is often a nightmare, no matter how talented you are. And I personally care more about how much I like the culture and environment around me after work and on the weekends than how much I'm being paid. SF is really great, but it's not London. All that is to say, there's more to it than money. At least for some people.
- zeristor 8y agoStrangely the discussions seem to be focused on salaries and the cost of living in the UK. The article talks about academics being lured away from teaching, which is a problem, I imagine that academics could perhaps guide students in the companies they employed at, like a paid course? Although there's a difference between pure research and getting stuff done. With all these people working at US companies it creates hubs of knowledge, networks of people, that in turn could spawn new companies, which in the long run is surely a good thing.