21 ms·
Perhaps it is simpler to say that Intel was disrupted
- 33degrees 8y agoReading this makes it very clear why Apple would be moving towards using its own chips in laptops.
- baxtr 8y agoI think it was a very smart move of them to hedge for exactly this situation by introducing the A series chips (and to this end building the capabilities in-house). Of course, hindsight is 20/20 and we’ll probably never know a 100% if that was the core reason to do that, but if it was the case, it was brilliant.
- MBCook 8y agoI’m not sure that was the plan so much as their ruthless search for power efficiency and integration on the phone. But wow does it look like it will pay off.
- robdachshund 8y agoThe A series is just custom ARM. It's really nothing groundbreaking. They created ARM chips to power phones and tablets. The possibility of moving full computers to ARM was just a bonus, not some genius plan.
- baxtr 8y agoLike iOS is just custom NetBSD?
- toasterlovin 8y ago"Just". Apple's mobile CPUs are several years ahead of all the competition in terms of single core performance.
- macintux 8y agoEvery successful Apple innovation goes through the same phases. 1. Well that's stupid. Why would they do that? Nobody needs this. Within a few months... 2. Huh. This is actually really sweet. Nobody else has this technology. And then a few years pass... 3. It's really nothing groundbreaking.
- baxtr 8y agoExcept for the things Steve presented... they started at 2.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoIt will be nice not to pay the Intel tax.
- Analemma_ 8y agoThis is Tim Cook's Apple we're talking about, where margins are king. The cost savings from switching away from Intel, if and when that happens, will not be passed on to the consumer.
- MBCook 8y agoLargely agree (dropping prices some would help with sales). But I think Tony’s point was it would be nice for Apple to not have to pay the tax. It would help their bottom line.
- Redoubts 8y agoWas there ever an Apple where this was not the case? They’ve been making $5000 computers for decades.
- perl4ever 8y agoThe LC II was a big deal as a cheap color Mac when it was introduced at $1700. Of course, inflation. Today that's $3000.
- imtringued 8y agoThe Windows ARM laptops are hardly cheaper than their intel counterparts but they have worse specs and inadequate software compatiblity.
- MBCook 8y agoBesides everything else going on, they left 68k because it was falling behind and couldn’t compete or speed up enough. They left the G3/G4 line when once again they were stuck and Intel was running away. So they went to Intel. They’re now on the same treadmill as everyone else. Can’t do better, can’t be totally stuck. But Intel isn’t progressing very fast, and they don’t seem to be focusing on the things Apple wants like ultra-low power. But Apple’s chip division is kicking ass. The 10.5” iPad Pro is a monster, and could easily power a MacBook faster than an Intel chip. The real question is what to do on the MBP and iMac Pro. Apple has never been keen on AMD for some reason, not sure if they have a chance on the high end. My impression is they don’t compete on low end/low power but I don’t know how accurate that is.
- robdachshund 8y agoPretty sure an ARM tablet chip is not going to beat Intel, even on the low end. Otherwise we would have moved on already. Also, apple does like AMD and uses their gpus because they have bad blood with nvidia. Apple primarily makes laptops and AMD has not been competitive until they developed Ryzen.
- godzillabrennus 8y agohttps://9to5mac.com/2017/09/22/iphone-8-geekbench-test-scores/ https://9to5mac.com/2017/09/22/iphone-8-geekbench-test-score... The iPhone 8 CPU is competitive with a Core i5
- melling 8y agoi’d rather have Apple turn the iPad into something that can replace a laptop for most people. If they don’t do it, expect Microsoft to perfect a future version of the Surface.
- robdachshund 8y agoI mean, you just described the surface. Apple has been making god awful decisions for the past 5 years or so. MS is beating apple at their own game. The iPad pro is a great example of how out of touch apple is.
- vxNsr 8y ago>>>.The iPad pro keyboard cover is a great example of how out of touch apple is. FTFY. The first time a colleague requested an iPad pro with a keyboard and got it, I was blown away by how much origami apple expects you to do to properly use it.
- freehunter 8y agoI haven't used the keyboard cover but just the basic Smart Cover, I constantly feel like I must be using it wrong. A lot of times, I am using it wrong unknowingly and after a minute or two the whole thing collapses. Not to mention it's impossible to use the Smart Cover in portrait mode so holding recipes while I'm cooking means propping it up against the toaster.
- scentoni 8y agoI've been using an origami cover for my iPad 12.9" and am reasonably satisfied with its different configurations, including portrait. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B072JZ1K55/ https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B072JZ1K55/
- vxNsr 8y agothat link shows what one might call intuitive origami, apple's "smart cover" falls in a category all its own. a good 60% of time you fold it incorrectly when opening or closing it and it can take up to a minute of finagling before you figure out how to fold it so it stays shut/open.
- lyime 8y agoIf Apple does in fact move towards their own AX CPUS for PCs then might start with a hybrid approach before completely eliminating their dependency on the x86 instruction set.
- nfriedly 8y agoI think the touchbar MBPs include an ARM CPU, so in a sense they already started the hybrid approach.
- scarface74 8y agoI don't think Apple cares enough about a line of products that make us less than 10% of their CPU line to go through the engineering effort to create ARM based laptops. I think it's more likely that Apple will make iOS more flexible on the iPad and make it a true laptop alternative.
- cpeterso 8y agoOr Apple could decide that the resources spent tending x86 hardware and dev tools for just 10% of their products would be better spent on one architecture (ARM) across all products. Switching Macs from x86 to ARM would be a one-time investment compared to the ongoing costs of maintaining separate x86 and ARM product lines.
- scarface74 8y agoHow is it a "one time investment"? They still would have to create processors specifically for the high end where thermal limits aren't as big of a concern that are used in their desktops.
- svantana 8y agoNot necessarily, they could run them at a higher clock and perhaps put two or more of them on the motherboard for the high end units. Keep in mind that the iphone 8 is already on par with their fastest 13-inch macbook pro.
- scarface74 8y agoHow would that compare to the top end Intel chips that Apple is using in the iMac Pro and the forthcoming Mac Pro?
- redial 8y agoThe watch is less than 10% and the HomePod is less than 10% and they seem to manage just fine custom designing chips for them. And at some point the outlier in your example is going to be the Mac, and I don't think Apple would care enough about it to go through the engineering effort of creating x86 laptops when all their expertise is in ARM.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI was thinking something similar. It might also explain the slow progress on the Pro and MB Pro as they wait for Apple CPU silicon to be reborn. Time will tell.
- microcolonel 8y ago> ...key assumptions...: > ... > Discrete graphics I get the impression that Steven is willing to make up the history to match the conclusion.
- MBCook 8y agoHow so?
- microcolonel 8y agoIntel were the first to mass market with reasonable "integrated" (even if it was just part of the northbridge, it would be in every platform) accelerated graphics.
- sjm-lbm 8y agoHe also totally ignores the i740 - not a major part of the story of Intel and perhaps a misstep, sure, but to act as if they hadn't tried to take a discrete graphics chip to market well before AMD bought ATi is crazy. Also, he seems to act as if Itanium was developed in response to AMD64: >Brilliant brilliant choice by NT team was the bet on the AMD 64 bit instructions. Seeing AMD64 all over the code drove them “nuts”. >That led to Itanium…more proprietary distraction. It was pretty close to the opposite. IA64 was Intel's plan for the future for more than half of the 90s, and the spec for AMD64 wasn't even published until 2000/2001 or thereabouts. Actual AMD64 processors came out about two years after Itanium. His quote to support the above assertion even mentions this, which confuses me more.
- theandrewbailey 8y agoWas this post written on a phone? The amount of abbreviations ("Ppl", "gfx") and emojis is bothersome.
- popsomoa 8y agoIf that bothers you, maybe the internet is not for you... :P Anyways, seeing people communicate and expressing themselves in different ways is pretty cool to me.
- ed312 8y agoColloquial expressions and shorthand generally make a written work harder to comprehend for a broad audience. Broad comprehension and dissemination is generally what you want in written work.
- gadnium79 8y agohttps://i.imgur.com/miXFGZh.png https://i.imgur.com/miXFGZh.png
- tzahola 8y agoJah, szerintem is gecijó a diverzitás! :P
- myWindoonn 8y agozo'o .u'i mu'inai ma xunai .eidai do tavla fo lo jbobau .ui lojban
- joemi 8y agoI knew it was going to be a rough read when the first paragraph said "Let’s explore in this annotated twitter thread." Maybe it shows my age, but I loathe twitter threads, be they annotated or not. And if you need to annotate a twitter thread, maybe it should have been posted on twitter in the first place.
- dagenix 8y agoWhat's the deal with all of the random italics disrupting the flow of the article?
- MBCook 8y agoI believe they’re quotes from Ben Thompson’s article, but it took me until about halfway through to figure that out.
- DiabloD3 8y ago"In 2006 AMD (struggling) bought ATI for $5.4B. Intel just didn’t even notice. It was super weird." I think this is the best line in the whole thing. Intel didn't notice, and it was super weird, and it was the best thing they ever did. Fun fact: the first thing the engineers did with their new toy was bolt then-new R700 pipes to a hypertransport bus, so it used hypertransport to fulfill memory requests instead of a native Radeon GDDR controller. The purchase of AMD and the Christmas morning giddiness of unwrapping that gift and turning it into what eventually became the prototype of the APU was the most brilliant thing ever. To put it in perspective, lets count all x86 sales: all the desktops, all the laptops, all the servers, all the weird little things like x86 chinese tablets, all of it. Combined Xbox One and PS4 sales (both massive APUs, essentially) dwarf all of the sales both Intel and non-console AMD do; it dwarfs it in per chip and per thread. Intel only claims more sales in dollars than AMD (incl. MS and Sony deals) because of Intel tax, no legitimate reason. Similarly, lets do the same with Radeon sales vs Nvidia GPUs... take all of the Nvidia GPUs (desktop, laptop, ARM SoCs like the Shield and the Nintendo Switch, server compute, etc), and all the AMD GPUs that aren't XBOne and PS4... console sales dwarf everything else that both companies make. AMD won both races and no one even paid attention: AMD makes more x86 CPUs (both per chip and per thread), and more GPUs. Optimizing performance software (ie, games) has far more focus on both of AMD's platforms than anything else. Intel and Nvidia are now the underdogs in their own races. This happened silently, and the cheer-leading for Team Blue and Team Green drowned out reality for a bit.
- claytonjy 8y ago> Intel and Nvidia are now the underdogs in their own races For Nvidia specifically I think that's only true of the gaming market (maybe crypto as well?), but my understanding is their massive increase in value over the last half-decade or so is predominantly from the deep learning market, where they continue to dominate by no small margin due to CUDA being a hard dependency of the major DL frameworks. I don't have any hard numbers on it, but I wouldn't be surprised if the CUDA-tax is more than the Intel-tax ever was.
- microcolonel 8y agoThe CUDA tax is serious, however in this case it is mostly the fault of competing vendors that there is no CUDA or almost-CUDA implementation, since it is fairly high-level, unlike an ISA and the accompanying treadmill of patented features which move the expiry date of the "platform" 20 years into the future every couple years.
- seanalltogether 8y agoFrom the article it sounds more like Intel kept building up a moat that everyone got sick of crossing.
- erikpukinskis 8y agoYa.. I go back and forth in my head a LOT about the importance of moats. Constantly second guess myself. You sacrifice SO MUCH velocity building a moat, and you cut off any possibility of other companies helping “rise all ships”. But at the same time, aren’t there competent cloners lurking behind every corner ready to jump on your product market fit and outpace you? This article pushed me a little further into the “don’t worry about moats; make your partners successful” camp. But I waver.
- bluedino 8y agoIntel is resilient, if anything. They have had a ton of flops and misdirections. The 186. iAPX. i740. Xscale. Itanium. The FDIV bug. Pentium 4. AMD has had Intel up against the ropes more times than they can count. Faster and cheaper 386 and 486 clones threatened them. The K6 came around and beat the Pentium II. AMD leap-frogged them with their 64-bit chips. Intel has always came back and stomped them right back into oblivion. They'd probably be close to turning the lights off if it weren't for Ryzen.
- farseer 8y agoSorry to nitpick but Pentium 4 was a temporary flop until the HT version came along for which AMD had no answer. And I don't think the K6 beat Pentium II. Having bought a $2000 K6-2 computer in 1998 with maxed out RAM and graphics, I instantly regretted that decision as all my friend's mediocre Pentium II's ran applications and games better than my K6-2.
- loser777 8y agoNot even a nitpick, the claim that P4 HT had "no answer" from AMD is just false. https://www.anandtech.com/show/1517 https://www.anandtech.com/show/1517 Intel never definitively reclaimed x86 until Conroe/Core 2.
- beagle3 8y agoThe original HT implementation was so incredibly bad that people would turn it off to improve performance on multithreaded loads.
- georgeecollins 8y agoSo true! It only worked on example code, it was very difficult to get an improvement in a real world app.
- netinmate 8y agoIBM was considered resilient, now they are on the way to becoming Unisys.
- stcredzero 8y agoIntel was disrupted, for sure. Basically, I'm left wondering if there was some key brain-drain that occurred to Intel. Back in grad school in the mid 90's, most of the profs thought that Intel would collapse under the weight of the x86 ISA, but one prof knew people in Intel and told me about their roadmap going out to 2010, with plans for kicking butt. All of that played out! This shows amazing foresight. However, in recent years, Intel seems to have gotten itself painted into a corner with regards to die sizes, while AMD has strategically shifted to combining chips with smaller die sizes to increase yields and increase margins with more competitive pricing. "Interposers, Chiplets and...ButterDonuts?" -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3kGSbWFig4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G3kGSbWFig4 Something has happened with Intel, which has lost its vaunted intelligent "paranoia."
- marcosdumay 8y ago> Intel seems to have gotten itself painted into a corner with regards to die sizes, while AMD has strategically shifted to combining chips with smaller die sizes This line has a "Moore's law ended" marked all over it. One player expected it, the other didn't.
- MBCook 8y agoAMD has basically always been behind Intel in process, so they couldn’t count on that to get them to the top, they had to do something else. Intel has always been on top so they had less incentive to prepare for that. As Ben thompson said in his article Intel just assumed they could keep going without running into process shrink problems of the magnitude they have.
- bsder 8y agoFor FIFTY YEARS, the corpses of those who predicted the demise of Moore's Law and were wrong have littered the graveyard of semiconductor companies. Intel survived because they bet on Moore's Law--while DEC and IBM could get 30-40% more performance out of good design, Intel could just wait 6 months. That eventually crushed the companies that could do excellent VLSI design. Suddenly, now that Moore's Law finally broke, everybody needs VLSI designers back. However, those designers are all gone--dead, retired, or so screwed over by management that they are never coming back. I know a lot of people in their late 40's to early 60's from that industry and they all have similar sentiment: "I will run a hot dog stand before working in a semiconductor company ever again."
- SubiculumCode 8y agoI can't comment on the veracity of the article, but I'd like to just add that the article was a compelling read. I am a fan of AMD because I like competition, especially from a spunky competitor. I'd say the same about Nintendo, which keeps finding ways to win by focusing on fun over specs.
- airstrike 8y agoWhile it may be simpler, it may also be inaccurate. The fact that Intel's dominance isn't as pervasive as before does not mean it's no longer #1. AMD has a long way to go. One a related note, to my knowledge AMD is still essentially absent from the Autonomous Driving market, with NVIDIA and Intel fighting to be top dogs through different approaches¹. With some estimates for the size of that market (including non-chip portions) going as high as trillions of dollars², I hope for AMD's sake it has a plan to catch up sooner rather than later. __________ 1. https://www.benzinga.com/top-stories/18/02/11148965/which-chipmaker-leads-the-autonomous-driving-space https://www.benzinga.com/top-stories/18/02/11148965/which-ch... 2. http://fortune.com/2017/06/03/autonomous-vehicles-market/ http://fortune.com/2017/06/03/autonomous-vehicles-market/
- digitalzombie 8y agoThey're too busy playing catch up with deep learning rocm library. I wish they're aren't so behind in everything I care about and give us some competition so those graphic card goes down in prices already.
- hajile 8y agoJim Keller left AMD to go work for Tesla. https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/20/tesla-building-an-ai-chip-for-its-cars-with-amd.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/09/20/tesla-building-an-ai-chip-fo...
- kijiki 8y agoAnd he recently left Telsa to be SVP in charge of the Silicon Engineering Group at Intel: https://www.anandtech.com/show/12689/cpu-design-guru-jim-keller-joins-intel https://www.anandtech.com/show/12689/cpu-design-guru-jim-kel...
- baybal2 8y agoWhen Manchester United will hire him?
- 8y ago
- jillesvangurp 8y agoOne angle that is missing to this story: Nokia. Nokia bet big on Intel by partnering with them at the worst possible moment. In a nutshell, Intel was looking to get in on the mobile action and Nokia was willing to partner. This was ten years ago. When platforms failed to come together because Intel was not delivering the goods, Nokia had to scramble to get new phones ramped up around alternative platforms. Nokia lost a lot of valuable time this way right when Apple and Android started kicking its ass. I wouldn't point at it as the root cause for Nokia's rapid collapse but it certainly was a contributing factor. E.g. Meego was years late to the market partly because of this and ultimately killed off in favor of the deal with Microsoft (another ill fated bet). And yes, Intel Atom was a big part of that failing as well. Bottom line is that Intel tried and failed to get into the mobile market repeatedly and failed while being way too comfortable milking desktops and servers. Now that that market finally seems to be drying up, they have a problem and still no viable strategy to deal with it. Atom flopped. Itanium flopped. AMD is back looking stronger than ever. MS is has retired the wintel brand years ago and is seemingly open to running on ARM and getting quite cozy with Linux. Apple is widely rumored to also consider switching to their quite credible in house ARM based processors.
- hajile 8y agoAfter the N9 was a success, they could have bet on both. Buy an OS from MS and offer Meego/SwipeUI in one or two high-end devices. Elop simply seemed more interested in selling.
- subway 8y agoMeego on the N9 was absolutely amazing. I just wish Alien Dalvik had been made widely available to help bootstrap the ecosystem.
- ahartmetz 8y agoOh yes, it was amazing. Due to my involvement with the Qt toolkit used by both, I used the N9 and BB10 (Blackberry's QNX based phone OS), in that order, before switching to Android. The N9 OS had a soul somehow, the BB10 OS was pleasantly (very) fluid and efficient. Now I'm on Android, it runs all the apps and doesn't microstutter much anymore. Oh well.
- ksec 8y agoThis is a much better piece then the @stratechery one. And my thought on @stratechery were the same as S.Sinofsky, it wasn't the integration that is the problem. It was a go to market. I think the word "go to market" is better than what I described as "vision and execution". Had its execution been perfect, its Roadmap of better IPC, more Core, and 10nm / 7nm node, it would still have lots of room to adjust. Although I think a better execution is only just delaying the problem. Like the article have said, it really is a multiple things. Had Intel set out to make the best SoC for Netbook. Had Intel set out to make the best Graphics within those die space. This is the classic case, where Steve Jobs describe companies with a monopoly are ran by sales and marketing people.[1] And Product people ( Pat Gelsinger ) are driven out of management decision process. I still remember in one of the video interview, Pat Gelsinger; I cant remember if it was EMC or VMware era, clearly describe how x86 would rule Sever space as long as it continue to improve and innovate. And trying create a half hearted SoC with x86 into Mobile wouldn't work. And it was all too late. ( I can no longer find that video ) And some people might think S.Sinofsky view on Intel graphics a little strange, remember Intel graphics didn't became good until Apple forces them to be better. And S.Sinofsky left M$ in 2012, the design of those Surface devices must have happened during 2010 era, and to make matter worst the graphics on Atom were generation behind what Intel had on the desktop. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-AxZofbMGpM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-AxZofbMGpM
- old-gregg 8y agoAny gamers or graphics experts here? I keep hearing that Intel's integrated graphics is terrible, yet being a typical desktop user/non-gamer, I've always avoided dedicated GPUs in favor of Intel on purpose. Intel GMAs always offered better battery life, better Linux compatibility, better operating temperatures (and zero additional fan noise) yet they did everything a non-gamer can ask for: hardware-accelerated video playback, desktop effects like the ones Steven writes about, etc. Recently I looked into AMD's 2400G APU with much superior graphics but I don't understand what is it for. Sure it can sort of run some games at mediocre frame rates on last-century 1080p monitors, but not higher. But everything else Intel will do just as well... Looks like all these integrated GPUs are starved of memory bandwidth anyway. So what's the point of these APUs then? Where's the AMD graphics advantage? And what's problem then with Intel's integrated graphics?
- mynameisvlad 8y agoHere's an Anandtech benchmark from the relatively recent release of Ryzen+Vega: https://www.anandtech.com/show/12425/marrying-vega-and-zen-the-amd-ryzen-5-2400g-review/5 https://www.anandtech.com/show/12425/marrying-vega-and-zen-t... Essentially, the current gen Intel GMAs are more or less equivalent to AMD's last gen APUs. Ryzen with Vega is around 3x faster. In the past, AMD tended to focus on the iGPU at the expense of the CPU, but with Ryzen, it's also comparable to Coffee Lake while maintaining the massive GPU lead.
- nfriedly 8y agoMy macbook runs on Intel integrated graphics, and I frequently want just a little bit more performance for day-to-day work. In particular, if you set a 4k monitor to 1440p effective resolution in macOS, it renders a 5k (1440p doubled) image and then down-scales that to 4k. This seems like it would be ideal but in practice, things are too laggy. I upgraded from a 1440p monitor to a 4k one, but I ended up going down to 1080p effective in order to get acceptable performance due to intel's under-powered integrated graphics. I'm fairly positive that AMD's APUs would be sufficient in this scenario. On the gaming side, I also just got a GPD Win 2, which is a little handheld gaming computer that runs on a Intel Core m3 (graphics and all). At 720p, the Intel integrated graphics can actual run a lot of games, especially older ones. But OF COURSE I'd like to see better performance there. Unfortunately, AMD doesn't have anything available yet for that power/TDP range (7w).
- georgeecollins 8y agoI remember getting money from Intel to put MMX instructions into a game and later getting money to use hyper-threading. In both cases, at the time, the improvement was at the margins and not worth the work it hadn't been subsidized. It seemed like the best thing you could say about it was that it didn't work on an AMD chip.
- tomerv 8y agoNowadays, MMX (and newer SIMD instruction sets) are a crucial part of many optimizations. Hyperthreading is provided in all modern processors. Basically, those technologies proved themselves.
- georgeecollins 8y agoAt the time the SIMD instruction set did not exist and the MMX instruction set was difficult to apply in a way that got us an advantage in our application. When you say all modern processors have Hyperthreading, are you sure you don't mean multithreading? I am not sure every processor has hyperthreading. I am not knowledgeable enough to argue about the overall value of MMX and Hyperthreading but I think the point of the article at the top of this page is that it in the end -- although maybe not at first -- it was counter-productive.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bgorman 8y agoThis article is missing many critical details. Most notably it doesn't touch on the core identity crisis Intel has been having since the i386. When Intel cut off third party "fabs" from producing its chips, it became reliant on high margin chips that were completely vertically integrated. In a sense this incentivized the company to ignore lower margin fields like embedded and mobile. Obviously the iPhone changed the game in mobile, and showed that there is a space for high-margin mobile parts. Intel was equipped for this transition because they spent years optimizing their CPU->Factory connection. Their factories were optimized to bump out CPUs, not mixed silicon, to the point where Intel's own wireless group would produce wireless Chips at TSMC. Intel faced dwindeling consumer demand, which led to factories not being full, which led to less investment in chip fabrication. Keep in mind in the last several years, Intel's main chip performance advantage was due to the superior manufacturing abilities of it's factories. Better factories mean more transistors per inch, more transistors means more cores and IPC (assuming competent designers). Intel's inability to produce general silicon hurts them to this day, as Intel's effort to open its fabs to the general public have largely failed (Intel Custom Foundry). A further issue that plagued Intel was it's inability to produce integrated mobile SoCs in a timely manner. Intel Acquired infineon when they realized they needed a quick pathway to building an integrated 4G modem. Ultimately the product was not built in time, but at least now this investment is kind of paying off as Intel has won the modem spot in modern iPhones. However Intel was not able to put together a product competitive enough with Qualcomm due to the time it takes to mobilize enough resources to build a high end SoC.
- arbie 8y ago> Intel's inability to produce general silicon hurts them to this day, as Intel's effort to open its fabs to the general public have largely failed (Intel Custom Foundry). Their refusal to fab ARM chips hurts them more than the design-rule complexity of their process.
- yuhong 8y agoThinking about it, I wonder if some of the reasons for the unethical tactics Intel did in the mid-2000s was fear that the revenue would decline quickly if the market share goes to say 10%.
- treis 8y agoAm I missing something here? Intel's operating income is higher than it's ever been. They aren't being disrupted by any meaningful measure of disruption.
- scarface74 8y agoEveryone is ultimately proprietary even in the Open Source world. Once you invest heavily in any sort of architecture or platform, you’re not moving anywhere with your current investment. I’ve argued this point repeatedly in real life and on HN. The people who don’t want to use any of AWSs proprietary infrastructure or developers who want to use the repository pattern for the sole purpose of “not locking themselves” into one vendor. I’ve never in 20+ years seen a major organization switch from a well known vendor to save a few dollars. Even if you theoretically can change your infrastructure, the risks and the amount of regression testing you have to do hardly ever makes it worthwhile to switch infrastructure. As far as open source coming to the rescue, if someone else doesn’t takeover an open source project, more than likely, your company won’t either.
- pdimitar 8y agoI am largely in agreement with you, however there are many well-documented cases, right here in HN, about companies bleeding a lot of money due to their usage of AWS and a few others. Such services are really good when you are starting off -- they eliminate a huge upfront time cost, and for most startups time to market is the difference between life and death. And as you start, they are pretty cheap as well. However, once the startup takes off and becomes cash-positive and has to scale, then AWS in particular becomes a huge point in your balance sheet. It's a very well executed vendor lock-in, I will give them that. Many companies are using European VPS hosting and once they have mid-level business contract that guarantees 99.9999% uptime because the provider can replicate to 3 separate physical data centers, they are happy both with the service and the cost. Granted they need their own Ops teams but long-term this scales much better and is sustainable. Managed cloud infrastructure is mostly overrated and the complexity of it is by design. AWS in particular is borderline crazy lately, they have dozens and dozens of inter-connected services and "AWS consultant" is now a commonplace title in CVs.
- scarface74 8y agoAmazon doesn’t “lock you in” with VPS hosting. If that’s what is costing you, you can access all of AWSs other services over the internet. You can setup a VPN from your colo center to AWS and still access all of thier managed services. How is it less complex to host your own database servers, load balancers, queuing system, redundant storage, CI/CD servers, ELk stack, redundant memcache or Redis servers, distributed job scheduler (I’ve used Hashicorps Nomad in the past), configuration servers, etc. These are just the services that you don’t have to manage the underlying servers and you get redundancy. I’m first and foremost a developer. But the money the company I work for saves by not having to hire dedicated people to manage and babysit servers more than makes up for the cost of AWS. It just so happens that I know AWS well enough and have experience as an “architect” (and have the certifications to give them a warm and fuzzy) to be competent at the netops and devops side of things.
- georgeburdell 8y agoAs someone who left Intel last year for one of its customers in the Valley, I have to say I'm sad that the future looks pretty dark for them. In the exit interview, I said I might come back if the CEO and my department head left (they both did), but I didn't know the company was such a mess. That said, Intel is viewed from the outside as sort of an old monopolistic monolith, but a lot of that profit gets plowed into a bunch of truly innovative semiconductor R&D going on that I do not believe is being replicated by competitors. 3D XPoint is probably the most visible example. AMD, TSMC, Samsung, etc. I doubt will pick up the torch.
- pdimitar 8y agoSo where do you feel their competitive advantage lies right now, by the way? You make it sound both like they do struggle lately but they have stuff lined up that cannot be competed with. Slightly confusing for me, could you elaborate?
- georgeburdell 8y agoWell the two are not mutually exclusive. I worked there for close to 5 years on a few different silicon-related projects that I characterize as unique in the market and not a single one has even made it into an announced product. These were not small endeavors, so either the development times for silicon are extremely long or Intel cannot execute on its ideas. Regarding the former possibility, I heard from people who were around since the beginning that 3D XPoint was in development for a decade before it was announced in 2015.
- pdimitar 8y agoOh, I agree, but what you describe seem to be latent / possible-in-the-future breakthroughs. Until they see the light of day they are irrelevant IMO.
- dan_hawkins 8y agoAnother angle: BK's 2016 lay offs were done in such a bad style that experienced engineers began leaving company in large numbers. I guess that drained the company with a lot of talent.