50 ms·
Birth Rates Dropped Most in U.S. Counties Where Home Prices Grew Most
- gnadx 8y agoSeems like it's more likely home prices are the key factor, not home values. Subtle but important difference I'd say. If you can't afford a place to live, you probably can't afford to have children.
- CydeWeys 8y agoIs it a difference? Home values are determined by looking at what comparable houses in the neighborhood are actually selling for. You can't value homes if no transactions are taking place because then you have no idea what it's worth. Asking prices are meaningless; prices of actual sales are all that matter.
- jtbayly 8y agoYes there is a difference in that one implies current ownership and the other implies inability to own. Also, actual sales mean actual prices, not asking prices.
- dragonwriter 8y agoIt's more likely that people deciding not to have children have more money to spend, which, given supply constraints on housing, increases market clearing prices for housing.
- mattigames 8y agoWith the rapid destruction of soon-to-be-depleted resources and worsening climate change I argue that "Baby Recovery" is a very misleading titling of birth rate decline; the next generation will likely have a better quality of life if there are _fewer_ of them, not more.
- robotrout 8y agoThere won't be fewer of them, because they will be supplemented by immigrants. Many western countries are actively encouraging 3rd world immigrants in an effort to bolster their faltering entitlements ponzi scheme with more warm bodies.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Bucephalus355 8y agoI very much see what you’re saying and think a lot of current data backs up your view. I do want to point out that Thomas Malthus in the 1700’s had a very similar argument though and “overpopulation” was to then as “global warming” is today in some (only some) regards. At the very least, as Daniel Patrick Moynihan said, “families are the platoons of society”. I never wanted kids, but as I got into my 30’s, you can feel something missing from life without kids, in the same way you can feel something missing without a long-term partner. I don’t want to make the mistake of forcing my American middle-class ideals of “family” onto others, but often progress in the world is achieved by the desire to make it better for our children, and not our future selves or some theoretical “other humans”.
- conanbatt 8y agoAnd Malthusian theory is a joke of economics from beginning to end.
- rz2k 8y agoMalthus had an interesting idea about some resources growing geometrically and others growing arithmetically. There wasn't real world data to back up the supposition. His conclusions seem to have been based on naive mathematical understandings, and misinterpreting processes that approximate logistic functions being at different stages of transitions. With changing marginal growth rates, even similar processes could appear to be fundamentally different from each other if they are in different stages. Climate science in this century is based on mathematically sophisticated models, and beyond the comparative theoretical rigor, they have been shown to have good predictive power.
- plassma 8y ago“Children are expensive”
- ekianjo 8y agoThey are expensive because we want them to be. We have never had so much disposable income and so few children in History.
- asdsa5325 8y agoYou must be referring to this: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DSPIC96 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DSPIC96 Note that the real definition of "disposable income" just means income after taxes. Since housing costs come out of disposable income, and housing costs have been increasing far faster than income, you are not actually on base.
- orangecat 8y agoAs income potential increases, so does the opportunity cost of raising children. If you're making $50k/year, you're not giving up month-long European vacations by having kids. If you're making $500k/year, you might be.
- toasterlovin 8y agoAbsolute resources available to raise children goes up though.
- someguydave 8y agoThat's because the disposable income is mainly going to bid up the price of real estate. Nobody is making more real estate and the existing owners patronize the government to lock out competition. The federal government then pours gas on the fire by subsidizing demand through housing loan guarantees. Meanwhile, as the young prospective parents work harder than ever to save for children, the government claims that they aren't producing enough new citizens to keep the welfare state going. This is taken as justification for bringing in immigrant labor. This suppresses wages for everyone, making saving and reproducing harder. No, I don't believe the free market is a zero-sum game. But it's not exactly free either.
- toasterlovin 8y agoKeep in mind that there is probably a significant selection effect going on there. In other words, if you don't plan on having children, expensive cities are still an option for you. Whereas if you plan on having children, they are not.
- pitt1980 8y agoConsidering the ratio of career gains that go to those working in a few expensive cities, even if this is largely selection effects, I'm not sure this paints a very rosy picture of the society we're creating. I'm reminded of how few heads of EU states are parents https://www.marketwatch.com/story/do-childless-leaders-mean-the-death-of-europe-2017-05-26 https://www.marketwatch.com/story/do-childless-leaders-mean-...
- JumpCrisscross 8y agoThere is a Brazilian show on Netflix, 3%, that explores (caution: spoiler for Season 1) a sterile elite ruling over a dystopia.
- toasterlovin 8y agoThis stage of the demographic transition is a huge problem, IMO. The more I think about it, the more it seems like a ratchet (as in, it only moves in one direction): Basically, two incomes are useful, so both people in a relationship pursue careers. Now they have more money to compete on the housing market. This seems like a good move, so others follow suit. At first this is largely a win for people who pursue this route. But, as more people do this, it becomes necessary in order to compete for real estate in good neighborhoods. Now there is an advantage to be had by putting off having a family even longer, or having even less children. So people do this. But as more and more people follow suit, the advantage evaporates. And so on and so forth until you have demographic implosion. For the life of me, I can’t see a way out of this in the short term. Maybe a wholesale transition to remote work?
- nomocrypto 8y agoSane zoning laws would be much easier and do a lot more to ease the burden on people (I currently live in an “OMG no high rises! Won’t someone think of the neighborhood character!?” city and the rent is ridiculous). We just have to have the political will to change them, which unfortunately means angering very powerful monied interests, including Betty and Edgar who really love their now-valued-at-$500,000 house next to downtown.
- kanox 8y agoCorrelation is not causation. Low birth rates and high home values are both also highly correlated to education and women in the workforce and high income and economic growth and trendy hipster bars and many other nice things. Picking just two items and claiming that "people don't have children because homes are expensive" is not very enlightening at all.
- surfmike 8y agoThe article specifically says they might not be causal. The correlation is interested, however; anecdotally I know many of my friends feel like buying a house is a necessary prerequisite before having kids so a causative effect is plausible.
- lev99 8y agoI haven't gotten a dog because I feel like renting isn't stable enough environment for a dog. I get the owning a home is a prerequisite for children point of view.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chongli 8y agoYou could also say that women in the workforce are correlated with high home prices and educated women are correlated with women in the workplace. I think there really is no root cause here. They're all interconnected factors.
- asdsa5325 8y agoLiterally from the article: > As a further caveat, the correlation observed here is by no means proof that home value growth causes fertility declines. One alternative explanation could be the possibility that there is clustering into certain counties of people with careers that pay well enough for expensive homes but make it difficult to have children before 30; this could cause both trends observed in the chart above. There are many other confounding factors that could explain this relationship as well, such as the possibility that cultural values or the cost of child care varies across counties with some correlation to home values.
- nitwit005 8y agoIt's almost as if you could afford more of something, like housing, if you spent less on another thing, like children.
- quickthrower2 8y agoMoreover you tend to need more space, and therefore a more expensive house, if you have children. Also without children you can live somewhere regardless of worries like school catchments.
- lkrubner 8y agoFrom previous: "In nations in the West, an important limiting factor is the ability to get one’s own apartment. That is, the ratio of average male wage to average rent. In the USA, the happiest year for this ratio was 1958, when people were spending 22% of their income on rent, on average. Not by coincidence, this was the peak year of the Baby Boom. In some sense, it was the best year in history to be a young white male in the USA. It was the year when it was easiest for an 18 year old male to get out of high school, get their own apartment, marry their high school sweetheart, and start a family. And of course, young people did this in huge numbers, which is why 1958 remains the peak year for teenage pregnancy in the USA." http://www.smashcompany.com/philosophy/do-men-become-warlike-if-they-do-not-have-women http://www.smashcompany.com/philosophy/do-men-become-warlike... 1958 is when men had the best wage to rent ratio, and that helped create families and have children. And likewise, nowadays, as rents increase faster than wages, we should expect the birth rate to decline.
- sandworm101 8y ago>> which is why 1958 remains the peak year for teenage pregnancy in the USA. There are plenty more factors impacting teenage pregnancy than the cost of rent. I also hesitate to talk about teenage pregnancy rates in any sort of positive light. There is a very fine line between a 18yo married to her "high school sweetheart" who has a great job, and an unwed 17yo highschool senior who, in 1958 society, had a very rough time. I'd suggest that the later was the more common.
- jetrink 8y ago> I'd suggest that the later was the more common. I doubt that was the case. According to the CDC[1], less than 15% of teenage births were to unmarried teenagers in the 1950s. In 1960, the birth rate for teenagers aged 15-17 was a quarter that of teenagers aged 18-19. 1. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr49/nvsr49_10.pdf https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nvsr/nvsr49/nvsr49_10.pdf
- sandworm101 8y ago"Births" ... not pregnancies. There is a monumental difference. We know about the births because they are vital stats. But for the pregnancies, at best, we know about the reported pregnancies, the girls who went to doctors and those doctors contributed to the stats. That doesn't cover the girls who did not see doctors nor those who, for whatever reason, did not carry the child to term. >> less than 15% of teenage births were to unmarried teenagers in the 1950s. And exactly how many of those occurred less than 9 months after the wedding? Being pregnant and unmarried in 1958, even temporarily, was not a happy place from which to start adult life.
- ppeetteerr 8y agoIt's a rather specific sample (2010-2016, ages 25-29). I wonder how much of this is coincidence. Is it not possible that both birthrates and home prices have nothing to do with one another but happen to be just following independent trends?
- toasterlovin 8y agoBirth rates are highly likely to be tied to house prices in some way, though if it is causal, and which direction causality flows in, if it is, is probably not knowable. All you really need to know is that larger families compete with smaller families for real estate. But smaller families generally have more available income and they need less real estate. Those facts alone are bound to link birth rates to housing costs.
- ppeetteerr 8y agoI agree with you and you could even make another argument. It could also be that people these days spend more on experiential activities than physical goods and both child rearing and home ownership are suffering as a consequence. Correlation studies are fun but hardly informative.
- fooker 8y agoI once attended a lecture by a well known statistics professor, who demonstrated a similar correlation between the price of a kg of apples and the rate of divorce in his country.
- paulddraper 8y agoAre apples and divorces plausibly related? Or was the professor simply drawing from an enormous number of metrics to find a spurious relationship (and report just that).
- ajmurmann 8y agoThat snake was trying to tell us something!
- gsich 8y agoAn apple is not mentioned there ;)
- im3w1l 8y agoWell price of apples should approximately reflect general food affordability.
- paulddraper 8y agoHm...so economic hardship causes high apple prices and high divorce rates.
- timr 8y agoThank you. It's depressing how nobody here is observing the obvious, uncontrolled co-variate in this "analysis": per-capita income: https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2016/december/link-fertility-income https://www.stlouisfed.org/on-the-economy/2016/december/link... Correlation vs cause is no problem for HN if the correlation in question confirms a bias!
- DoreenMichele 8y ago
- kyrieeschaton 8y agoThis is fundamentally Steve Sailer's model of affordable family formation vs the blue state model.
- beezle 8y agoGiven that Zillow home value 'estimates' are poor, often all over the map in areas with near idential homes, I would not take anyting they offer up with more than a grain of salt.
- lev99 8y agoTo be fair to Zillow, looking at historical home sale data is a much easier problem then predicting what a home will sell for the future.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- anoncoward111 8y agoThere's correlation here, but likely not causation. The real underlying cause in the drop in birth rates is an increase in working hours, an increase in commuting times, an increase in college tuition and health care costs, and also an increase in divorce rates. These days, even getting married is an expensive financial arrangement. Having kids is just another layer on that. Housing prices have increased because of cheap loans and supply-restrictive regulations.
- hshehehjdjdjd 8y agoGetting married is expensive? How so?
- anoncoward111 8y agoThe legal fees themselves aren't very expensive. If you can resist the societal pressures to have a large and extravagant wedding with many guests, then even the wedding itself isn't particularly expensive. The main cost of getting married is getting divorced. Legal fees add up a lot here, and the division of assets is costly. Now, you could argue your marriage won't end in divorce, but 60% of marriages in the US do.
- fixermark 8y agoPerhaps worth noting: that "60% of marriages end in divorce" number is quirky when you pull back the skin. 60% of marriages end in divorce, but most people who marry do not get divorced from their first marriage. The 60% number is bumped out due to the segment of the population that get married 3 or 4 times.
- anoncoward111 8y agoInteresting, thank you :) I'm still seeing divorce rates of 30-40% for first marriages, depending on generation. Anecdotally, I know a lot of people who are either divorced in their 30s, or still unmarried in their 30s. Considering the difficulties a woman has conceiving beyond their mid 30s, I think the explanation is here in our faces. My grandma had 5 kids and was married at 19.
- Karishma1234 8y agoI think this is a wonderful way to tackle climate change. Higher housing if leads to lower birth rates then it might be good for planet. I wonder if there is analysis been done as to what birth rates we need to achieve to ensure the planet is fit to live for our kids.
- fixermark 8y agoI believe the driving factor of climate change isn't total world population though; it's fossil fuel exhaust generated for energy. There's correlation with total population but not necessarily direct linkage; if there are fewer people, but each person is consuming 2.5x as much electricity as the generation before, we wouldn't expect to see the fossil fuel burn rate lower.
- tremon 8y agoClimate change is not all about electricity or fossil fuels though. Agriculture also has a massive impact, because of deforestation to create more arable land or, overuse of fertilizers and other chemicals. And the need for more/better agriculture is definitely driven by the growing world population.
- baybal2 8y agoIf ~25% of American debt and fund market is dumped on property market, I believe they can simply buy all of the housing stock.
- adiusmus 8y agoAll the people who believe in overpopulation are becoming rare because they are less fertile than those who do not. Evolution is already optimising overpopulation believers out of the gene pool. Governments are also punishing overpopulation believers by increasing migration in response to low birth rates. This is a world wide phenomenon. Have a great day.
- fixermark 8y agoObvious conclusion: children wreck property values. (this result published in "The Journal Of Correlation Implying Causation ;) )
- Rebelgecko 8y agoworded slightly differently, "adding 1+ people to your family who don't work will decrease your disposable income"
- sobani 8y agoNo, having more children will lower the value of the property you currently live in.
- sobani 8y agoflip-side of that: The value of your property depends on the value of the properties around you. Therefore, if you intend to sell your home, 'remove' some children in your neighborhood and you can increase your asking price!
- shamaku 8y agoAgenda 21
- bayesian_horse 8y agoConsidering generations in the past, and still in a lot of poor countries have raised multiple children in the smallest of spaces, I just don't believe there is a causative relation. Much more plausible to me is the association to women's education, causing women to delay their first pregnancy and opt out of further children. Also there seems to be an association between general misery or fatality and birth rates.
- bojan 8y agoWhile it is of course possible to raise a lot of children in a tiny space, it is not something you necessarily want to do. Especially if no-one in your environment is doing it. It is not really a happy life if you have to spend your evenings in utter silence because there is a baby or a toddler sleeping in the same room two meters away.
- bayesian_horse 8y agoAll these arguments assume rational arguments, especially economical, are the most important factors in deciding to make children. I believe that irrational factors are easily overlooked but predominant. There is a certain biological drive to raise children, stronger in some people compared to others. And various factors modulate this drive, again unconsciously. Most of the time, in free societies at least, it is the woman who makes most of the decision. If she really wants to have a child, nothing and nobody can stop her, short of a reproductive problem.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- yolo1897 8y agogood news, people become responsible
- oriol16 8y agoLow birth rates also correlate with a tendency to see women and men competing against each other, instead of complementing their roles. Where women acquired male roles, birth rates drop. You can observe this behavior both between and within countries.
- albertgoeswoof 8y agoThis is just sexism. Women should stay in the kitchen in your view I suppose.
- frockington 8y agoStatistics aren't sexist. Looking for reasons to be outraged is counter prodctive to any discussion
- albertgoeswoof 8y ago> women and men competing against each other, instead of complementing their roles How is this not sexist? You're saying that men and women have specific pre-defined roles in society (which you are defining). That's sexism at it's core, and leads to people saying that women should stay at home and men should go to work.
- daodedickinson 8y agoduh
- hanoz 8y agoSpeaking for the UK, it is certainly the case that couples put off having children until they've bought their own home, and the shameful reason for this is that renters have no security of tenure here. Unless you're in state subsided social housing you live with the permanent threat of being turfed out of your home at only two months notice, for no better reason than the landlord wants to do something else with it. Finding a new home and organizing a move is difficult and unsettling enough for a young working couple, but with children involved its on another level, not least because it could well mean a change of school, or result in siblings in different schools.
- OliverJones 8y agoDuh. The boomer generation (of which I am a member) has systematically disinvested in future generations. We've stripped resources from education, housing, and infrastructure. And we've successfully concentrated ourselves into certain geographical areas (counties) and driven housing prices up. And now our generation's birth rate has (except for trophy wives) fallen to zero. That happens to every generation. So, young people who want to live in our enclaves have to work really hard, or have to live in our cellars. Those who can afford it don't have time for kids, and those who can't go to live in areas we consider less "desireable."
- rsynnott 8y agoI don't really buy this. A really, really obvious counter-example; Germany. Germany has pretty cheap housing by Western European standards, but also a low birth rate by Western European standards. On the other hand, Ireland has the highest birth rate in the EU, and some of the most unaffordable housing.
- nopinsight 8y agoAcross countries, culture and perhaps public policies are huge confounding factors. Comparison within the US is at least less influenced by those factors.
- ainiriand 8y agoI might as well leave this here just in case: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_causation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_cau...
- 0x445442 8y agoI think there are also cultural differences between areas where real estate prices differ that have effects on the birth rates of those areas.
- jstewartmobile 8y agoOswald Spengler in 1923: "And at that point, too, in Buddhist India as in Babylon, in Rome as in our own cities, a man's choice of the woman who is to be, not mother of his children as amongst peasants and primitives, but his own "companion for life", becomes a problem of mentalities. The Ibsen marriage appears, the "higher spiritual affinity" in which both parties are "free"—free, that is, as intelligences, free from the plantlike urge of the blood to continue itself, and it becomes possible for a Shaw to say "that unless Woman repudiates her womanliness, her duty to her husband, to her children, to society, to the law, and to everyone but herself, she cannot emancipate herself." The primary woman, the peasant woman, is mother. The whole vocation towards which she has yearned from childhood is included in that one word. But now emerges the Ibsen woman, the comrade, the heroine of a whole megalopolitan literature from Northern drama to Parisian novel. Instead of children, she has soul-conflicts; marriage is a craft-art for the achievement of "mutual understanding"... At this level all Civilizations enter upon a stage, which lasts for centuries, of appalling depopulation. The whole pyramid of cultural man vanishes. It crumbles from the summit, first the world-cities, then the provincial forms, and finally the land itself, whose best blood has incontinently poured into the towns, merely to bolster them up awhile.* At the last, only the primitive blood remains, alive, but robbed of its strongest and most promising elements.*" https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Oswald_Spengler#The_Decline_of_the_West_(1918,_1923) https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Oswald_Spengler#The_Decline_of...
- rgejman 8y agoThis data is also consistent with the idea that people leave expensive areas in order to have children in cheaper areas.
- phkahler 8y agoIdiocracy was inspired by the real world.
- millzlane 8y agoReminds me of the opening scene of the movie Idiocracy. It makes sense that those that can afford the greater priced homes are thoughtful enough not to have lots of children. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YwZ0ZUy7P3E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YwZ0ZUy7P3E
- prirun 8y ago"Large differences from the trend reflect the fact that only 19 percent of the variation in fertility changes can be predicted by home value changes." I would think high university tuition and student loans also play a big part in decreasing disposable income to the point where college-educated couples are delaying starting a family or having fewer kids. I think most people believe that a 4-year college education is mandatory for a decent life in the US these days (I don't agree), so it's rational for a couple to decide to have only 1 kid that they can afford to educate vs 2. Kids used to be able to pay for their own tuition with a part-time job. It may have taken 6 years to graduate, but it was doable. That is a lot harder / impossible now.