16 ms·
GDPR will pop the adtech bubble
- shawn 9y agoAnd that’s on top of the main problem: tracking people without their knowledge, approval or a court order is just flat-out wrong. The fact that it can be done is no excuse. Nor is the monstrous sum of money made by it. I use Piwik (https://github.com/matomo-org/matomo https://github.com/matomo-org/matomo) and track visitors without their knowledge or consent, because I need analytics. Piwik is also configured to respect the "Do not track" header, so opting out is as easy as indicating that you don't wish to be tracked. Is that wrong? And I use Piwik precisely because it's self-hosted. I know for a fact your data doesn't get sold, because the data never hits any server except mine. If this seems acceptable, it's also why legislation seems worrisome. There are a lot of corner cases that law tends to overlook. But hopefully the requirements won't be too onerous.
- simion314 9y agoWhat site you run and why you need to log my personal data(IP,browser,other identifying data) do you have good reasons to keep it forever or you purge it after you analyze it?
- anilshanbhag 9y agoHow is IP and browser personal data ? If you think it is, you should not be on the internet.
- simion314 9y agoIP and browser fingerprinting is used to identify you around the internet, why would someone need to fingerprint me if it has good intentions. If you wnat some stats on who visits you like countries, what browsers and OSs they use , you can count them and discard the data after you would not need to keep it.
- ealexhudson 9y agoUnder GDPR guidance, IP addresses are considered personal data because they can be used to identify an individual in a moment in time. Personal data consists of things that identify individuals, but also things that can be used in conjunction with other information to identify individuals. You might not like that, but the regulators are pretty clear on this point.
- geocar 9y agoThe ICO does not consider IP addresses personal data since more than one person could use a computer in a household.
- evfanknitram 9y agoThat seems like a weak argument though. Two humans can also have same name and zipcode. They can also have same personal number and bank account number if they are in different countries. Without tracking and correlation, most information on its own is useless.
- geocar 9y agoYes. That's The ICO's position: https://ico.org.uk/media/for-organisations/documents/1591/personal_information_online_cop.pdf https://ico.org.uk/media/for-organisations/documents/1591/pe...
- bostik 9y agoThis reads like you are intentionally trying to misunderstand. GDPR has two categories of user information: direct identifiers and indirect identifiers. Direct identifiers are pieces of data that allow to target a person, or a very small group of persons from a single data point. Indirect identifiers are anything that you could use to build a marketing cohort. Combining a few indirect identifiers allows to target very specific groups of people. Or, using the very examples you quoted: - The tuple (bank account number, country) is enough to target an individual. - The tuple (full name, zip code) is enough to target a very small group of individuals. By adding just one more element you can identify individuals.[ß] Each one of the four data points counts as user information under GDPR. Doesn't matter whether they are direct or indirect. Disclosure: I wear the DPO hat at Smarkets. As a gambling company we are legally required to know quite a lot about our customers. ß: For the nitpicking armchair lawyers: unless you happen to have a gated community for John Smiths.
- smt88 9y agoSo your face is also not personal data, in your opinion? The sensitivity of data can change based on context. My name isn't sensitive until it's attached to something like browser history or medical files.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sethhochberg 9y agoThe article we're in the comments for is about the GDPR - as defined in article 4 of the GDPR, IP addresses constitute personal data. In many cases, a specific IP address, even a dynamic one, can be used to uniquely identify a natural person. https://gdpr-info.eu/art-4-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-4-gdpr/ Even though in many cases this won't help you identify a specific natural person (ie, you don't know whether whether you're dealing with a specific person or multiple people on a shared connection, and an IP address on its own usually isn't enough for you to de-anonymize a person), they're still a considered a personal identifier, are often coupled to a general physical location, and are now explicitly legally protected. Couple an IP address with a browser user-agent, and you've got the basis for a strong unique fingerprint for a specific person.
- bjelkeman-again 9y agoI actually think you need to do some homework if you honestly think so.
- closeparen 9y agoAnything and everything that’s about a person in any way is personal data.
- IncRnd 9y agoIP and browser information are definitely PII, which is Personally Identifiable Information. Those are PII, because they can be used to personally identify an individual.
- switch007 9y agoPII is not a GDPR term, by the way.
- IncRnd 9y agoCorrect. There is a similar concept, but it is not the same as PII in the US. Recital 26: To determine whether a natural person is identifiable, account should be taken of all the means reasonably likely to be used, such as singling out, either by the controller or by another person to identify the natural person directly or indirectly. To ascertain whether means are reasonably likely to be used to identify the natural person, account should be taken of all objective factors, such as the costs of and the amount of time required for identification, taking into consideration the available technology at the time of the processing and technological developments. Since the concepts mentioned in the comment, IP and browser information, are already being used to single people out for tracking, those particular types of information can definitely be viewed as the equivalent concept under GDPR, as defined in Recital 26.
- oldcynic 9y agoIP address alone on an anonymous web access log need not be. Start combining it with persistent cookies or a logged in user etc and it clearly becomes personal data as it is then enough to identify someone. The clause in the regulation is quite clearly worded: "Natural persons may be associated with online identifiers provided by their devices, applications, tools and protocols, such as internet protocol addresses, cookie identifiers or other identifiers such as radio frequency identification tags. This may leave traces which, in particular when combined with unique identifiers and other information received by the servers, may be used to create profiles of the natural persons and identify them."
- njx 9y agoHow can a SAAS defend chargeback claims without IP address? Stripe stores IP address and the proof that the user paid for the subscription using the same IP and created an account ties them together.
- PeterisP 9y agoHave a timeout, that may be a valid reason to store it for the chargeback limitation (120 days IIRC) but definitely not a valid reason to store it forever, as the parent post was talking about.
- nikanj 9y agoWhy do you need analytics, aside from ads and ad-tech?
- eganist 9y ago...to understand whether I'm reaching my target demographics e.g. for the sake of the success of my non-ad-related business?
- dawnerd 9y agoAnd to see what devices you should support? If all your traffic mobile? Maybe the mobile version gets more love. Lots of old ie users? Guess you gotta use old school css. Now that I think about t I’ve never used analytics for anything ad related.
- lovich 9y agoIf someone hits you from an iPhone 6 in turkey you can just incrementally your count of those two values without needing to store that IP 13.157.207.156 is in turkey and has an iPhone 6 and youve correlated that data through Facebook's ad network so that now they having a profile built around them despite not even having a Facebook account. Everyone's been sucking up all the data they can just in case they need it, and actual people are being harmed by it through data breaches. I get why people are upset about these changes happening to their businesses, but what did everyone expect when the industry has failed to self regulate against their worst excesses? The rest of society isn't just going to let you hurt them so you can make more money
- simion314 9y agoHow can you tell what demographic am I in just from my IP and browser fingerprinting? Do you have more sites or correlate the data with third parties? I think is fine if you just count the browser,OS, and country the user is from but I don't think is OK to keep more details then that
- jasonlotito 9y agoSecurity, such as analyzing how quickly a form is filled out, or whether the person is coming from a location that is known to be home to a lot of fraud, and other such checks, for example. Using that data as well to improve learning so we do a better job of detecting fraud and not flagging legitimate customers appropriately. Also, using analytics to determine if a user is having issues on the site. For example, are users having a difficult time filling out forms, or becoming confused, and being able to provide help in an appropriate manner. These are just two things I immediately thought of. Security, and customer support. I'm sure there are many other users of analytics aside from ads and ad-tech.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoYou shouldn't need to keep any personal information on your visitors to get meaningful data.
- lajhsdfkl 9y agoHow can AB testing work without storing personally identifiable information?
- user5994461 9y agoAB testing doesn't require personally identifiable information.
- lajhsdfkl 9y agoHow do you bucket users into a control and enabled group without having some way of identifying them? (usually ip address)
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoWhy are you bucketing users? If you have some sort of current session for their presence on the site, flip a coin and assign them your A or B. Store nonpersonalized info about their experience on the site associated with the given A or B.
- Sylos 9y agoYou could for example bucket them based on the last digit of their IP address. So, everyone whose IP address ends in 0, 1, 2, 3 or 4 gets the new version, everyone else gets the old version. You don't need to store the IP address for that, you just need a rule that decides which version to serve as the user requests it.
- bostik 9y agoGenerate stand-alone, opaque identifiers for whatever sessions you want to analyse. Make sure these tags are ephemeral and decoupled from anything else. Then, store only the flow data, discard everything else. Or if you need to keep some data around for the test duration, delete all of it once your A/B test has concluded.
- mulmen 9y agoI don't see how self-hosting has anything to do with it honestly. This is about tracking people without their consent. It's about preserving rights of individuals. Self hosting is no more or less acceptable than third party hosting. It's not a technical issue.
- jimktrains2 9y agoAre you also against access logs?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoOnly if you’re not scrubbing IP addresses and other PII within a reasonable window of time.
- jimktrains2 9y agoIP addresses are not pii. (Maybe personal data under the gdpr, but they are not pii.) Also, what pii is tracked (by default) by piwiki or ga or access logs? I certainly cannot think of anything.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Also, what pii is tracked (by default) by piwiki or ga or access logs? I certainly cannot think of anything. Cookies and other artifacts in the request headers or query parameters that can identify a unique user.
- jimktrains2 9y agoIdentify a unique user does not mean that it's pii if I cannot produce the real world identity of the user from the cookie.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago
- abraae 9y agoSounds like you'll have some urgent reading to do when/if you receive your first GDPR access request.
- scollins 9y agoSerious question: What are the odds of someone offical even noticing that you are in violation of GDPR? It's not like they'll enforce GDPR and collect $7.89 in fines from small businesses.
- themodelplumber 9y agoWhy would you care about someone official? I'd care more about a bot that is set up to save the officials some work.
- alkonaut 9y agoA good question. But that’s not how these things work. The law has to be self enforced or it’s useless - since as you say, how will small to medium businesses ever be caught violating? Megacorps comply because of mega fines. Small business comply because their owners or future buyers are a larger Corp who fears that their sub-subsidiary might be in violation, causing a future mega fine. So small businesses who care about the value of their company follow these rules. It’s almost exactly the same reason small business buy software licenses. It’s not of fear of fines but because otherwise they don’t look like a serious company. I question I have been wondering is how many companies will leave some violations such as data in backups - simply because removing it is too expensive so it’s a risk worth taking. I honestly haven’t understood how backup of data fits into the requirement to delete data of a certain age?
- isostatic 9y agoAll it takes is one disgruntled employee
- bostik 9y agoGDPR has the concept of backups and their expiration windows covered. I'll pick an example from my work. Data can be deleted from the active set, at which point it takes extra effort to retrieve it. (If you can't SELECT it anymore from the warm slaves, it's gone.) But as long as you can make a point-in-time-recovery from your backups, the data is still present in the inactive set. Using the inactive set requires, by definition, extra effort. So you need to state that fact in the data protection/retention policy, AND put reasonable technical enforcement mechanisms ("controls") in place to ensure that backups are expired and fully deleted after a given retention period. The older your unexpired backups get, the less valuable they should become.
- M2Ys4U 9y agoYes, that is wrong. You MUST tell your users that you are tracking them, and what the data you collect will be used for.
- belorn 9y agoPiwik has several blog post about this very topic, for example: https://matomo.org/blog/2017/09/gdpr-potential-consequences-matomo/ https://matomo.org/blog/2017/09/gdpr-potential-consequences-... You can disable the tracking parts in Piwik, or you can assume a legal stance under one of the 6 exceptions like "Legitimate interests" (https://matomo.org/blog/2018/04/lawful-basis-for-processing-personal-data-under-gdpr-with-matomo/ https://matomo.org/blog/2018/04/lawful-basis-for-processing-...).
- amag 9y agoThanks, that's very interesting! I wasn't aware that IP address is considered personal data under GDPR... That seems exploitable...
- mulmen 9y agoIn what way are you thinking IP address as PII is exploitable? My first thought is that you could impersonate a person by spoofing their IP address. PII identifies a person but I don't think anyone is advocating for (solely) IP-address based bank logins.
- lajhsdfkl 9y ago>Since tracking people took off in the late ’00s, adtech has grown to become a four-dimensional shell game played by hundreds (or, if you include martech, thousands) of companies, none of which can see the whole mess, or can control the fraud, malware and other forms of bad acting that thrive in the midst of it. Fraud? Malware? What does this have to do with adtech? >And that’s on top of the main problem: tracking people without their knowledge, approval or a court order is just flat-out wrong. The fact that it can be done is no excuse. Nor is the monstrous sum of money made by it. What a compelling argument /s. Is it wrong if I sit on my porch and record in a notebook the hair color of different people? Is it wrong if I observe that one of my coworkers has a Harley Davidson sticker on his laptop? There is no AdTech bubble given that Adtech is a completely viable business model. These laws may shut down third party trackers but Ads are here to stay. If the EU ads were to create regulation such that Ads become an inviable business model they would simply tank their own economy given how many services/ content creators rely on ads. edit: also I have to laugh since I was downvoted less than 20 seconds after posting. I'll post another statement that will make people mad Ads are the reason the web is open and the reason poor people have free access to information. An ad free web is a web that only rich people can use.
- simion314 9y agoThe laws would hopefully stop the tracking of users. IS there a good reason why you can't analyze the page you put your ad in and decide what category on ads will fit, so on tech pages put tech related ads. Tracking me and creating a profile on me should be illegal. Showing ads is perfectly fine
- lajhsdfkl 9y ago> IS there a good reason why you can't analyze the page you put your ad in and decide what category on ads will fit, so on tech pages put tech related ads. There isn't and this is what many people do. But that isn't the argument is it? Can you tell me why observing what people do on my website is unethical and why it should be made illegal? Also can you explain why information that is placed on my server belongs to someone else if I didn't enter into a contract with them specifying that was the case? If someone has access to your laptop and downloads their photos onto it, who do those photos belong to? Put another way, if someone shows you a photo, who does the memory of that photo belong to?
- blklivesmatter 9y agoRights to export but ... no rights to delete ? Facebook I cant delete my locked account ?
- blklivesmatter 9y agoRights to export but ... no rights to delete ? Facebook ???
- Animats 9y agoFrom one of the references in the article: The Google consent interface greets site visitors with a request to use data to tailor advertising, with equally prominent “no” and “yes” buttons. If a reader declines to be tracked, he or she sees a notice saying the ads will be less relevant and asking to “agree” or go back to the previous page.
- wpietri 9y agoWhich is certainly fine with me. I'm always amused that the notion that I will regret not having "relevant" ads. Where "relevant" means more likely to get me to buy things I was not intending to buy. Ads make sense to me in the age of information scarcity. But now if I need a thing, searching always turns up what I want. If I need to figure out what kind of thing to buy, I can read review at places like The Wirecutter. If I want to keep up with what's new in a field, I can follow experts via Twitter, mailing lists, etc. And if I have a problem I don't know how to solve I can talk to friends or use social media. Please do give me random ads; they're easier for me to entirely ignore.
- FooBarWidget 9y agoIsn't what you're saying in your first paragraph just strawmanning the definition of "relevant"? If you do not want to buy anything no matter what they show you then those ads are by definition not relevant. If they make you want to buy then the ads are by definition relevant. They aren't brainwashing you, at the end of the day the one in control of the credit card is still you.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> They aren't brainwashing you, at the end of the day the one in control of the credit card is still you. Right, because we're all perfectly rational robots with full control of all of our emotions and impulses, and the advertisers totally don't employ cutting-edge research in psychology to manipulate us.
- 9y ago
- just_observing 9y agoOff-topic: A responsive website for Doc Searls would be welcome.
- kapauldo 9y agoHa, I noticed that too, I read this is the feedly text extractor because the site was unreadable.
- chinathrow 9y agoCan anyone from an adtech company shine some light on what work life is right now with the deadline of May 25 approaching? Curious to learn more.
- solomatov 9y agoOne surprising side effect of this might be that the hordes of machine learners and data scientists who used to work for adtech might go to healthcare/bioinformatics where we might get new breakthroughs.
- vowelless 9y agoA lot will just move to finance... However, financial firms are usually pretty against open academic research that would allow publication of papers. Many researchers truly value the ability to contribute to this field openly. Perhaps you are right and they will move to health.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- solomatov 9y agoDodd-Frank isn't repealed and AFAIU, it made taking investor money much harder than it used to be. We can see the next most lucrative fields where ML can be applied to by Alphabet's portfolio: * Calico, Verily - healthcare * Waymo - self driving cars Another fields which comes to mind is robotics but Google liquidated their holdings related to this (Boston Dynamics) for some reasons.
- fnord123 9y agoHopefully some find their way into rocketry research to help further commoditise space travel.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI'm trying to. It's not simple, if you're not in the US or Germany :<.
- vertexFarm 9y agoGermany, eh? Interesting. What kind of companies in that field are in Germany? I wish I knew more about this subject.
- hartator 9y agoIt’s kind of interesting that the company that ads that people think are the most intrusive are from Criteo, a french company, while GDPR do its best to target US companies.
- lima 9y ago> GDPR do its best to target US companies Citation needed.
- TheForumTroll 9y ago>while GDPR do its best to target US companies I thought I was on reddit for a second there..
- adamnemecek 9y ago...and nothing of value was lost.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- uvesten 9y agoFinally!
- rossdavidh 9y agoOddly, I think the article underestimates the size of the change coming. I think one side affect of the surge of IT into advertising, is that it has become easier to measure exactly how well advertising works. By and large, it doesn't, very well. I am reminded of this, from Paul Graham, about his time at Yahoo: http://www.paulgraham.com/yahoo.html http://www.paulgraham.com/yahoo.html "...The reason Yahoo didn't care about a technique that extracted the full value of traffic was that advertisers were already overpaying for it. If Yahoo merely extracted the actual value, they'd have made less." I'm pretty sure that, the more we learn about how well advertising works, the less money people will be willing to pay for it. What's happening to billboards and newspapers right now is probably coming to several other industries soon.
- wool_gather 9y agoIf true, it makes a very amusing reversal from the usual story. Rather than peddling their wares to suckers, the placers of the ads have themselves been suckered into buying a product that doesn't work as advertised!
- rossdavidh 9y agoThe rumor is that both the Cruz campaign and the Trump campaign found Cambridge Analytics' products to not work as advertised.
- pjc50 9y agoThe SNP had an introduction to them, and the delegate reported back exactly that: not trustworthy and not a good idea to work with.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThe more you think of it, the more it seems to be totally expected. It's the advertising industry we're talking about. They're not exactly a paragon of honesty. On the contrary, I suspect everyone tries to bullshit everyone else. The few observations I made from working next to people in marketing & advertising supports that viewpoint. EDIT: reminds me of that one story about A/B testing, which pretty much directly told us how adtech companies are bullshitting their own customers. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10872359 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10872359 I highlighted the more interesting parts back then: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10873226 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10873226.
- qwerty456127 9y ago> tracking people without their knowledge, approval or a court order is just flat-out wrong. Requiring them to check an "I agree to be tracked" checkbox and signing an agreement (which has just happened to me yesterday in an EU country in accordance to GDPR) before they can use a product/service is hardly much better. This reminds me of the Android app permission system which requires you to allow an app to do everything it wants (including ridiculous requirements like when a game requires access to your contacts list) or just give up the idea of installing it (as for me I just grant the permissions at the installation time and then block everything redundant with XPrivacy). So I doubt it is going to do much good, a way like the cookie law doesn't really do anything but just introduces useless cookie warning banners.
- icebraining 9y agoRequiring them to check an "I agree to be tracked" checkbox and signing an agreement (which has just happened to me yesterday in an EU country in accordance to GDPR) before they can use a product/service is hardly much better. That's specifically not allowed under the GDPR. Either the information is needed to provide the service (and needed means actually needed, not "my business model depends on it"), in which case they don't need to ask, or the use of the service can't depend on that consent. (By the way, even if the information is needed, they still need consent to use it in other ways, and the same applies) See the ICO guidelines on the issue: "If you make consent a precondition of a service, it is unlikely to be the most appropriate lawful basis." https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/lawful-basis-for-processing/consent/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da...
- qwerty456127 9y agoI have visited a drugstore to buy some vitamins yesterday. They have handled me a touch-screen where I had to check a checkbox (saying that I agree to allow my medicines shopping history to be stored and analyzed to track my health (which I obviously don't want them to do actually)) and an electronic signature tablet with a stylus where I had to put my signature. This was a mandatory condition for continuing using a discount card that gives bonuses when you buy meds. I could opt-out but this would mean I won't be given discounts any more.
- keldaris 9y agoI don't quite share the level of optimism the author seems to have, but I hope he's right. If so, good riddance, just a shame it took this long.
- ohiovr 9y agoThis combined with this reality: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-iran-nuclear-bolton/bolton-us-sanctions-possible-on-european-firms-over-iran-idUSKCN1IE0M9 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-iran-nuclear-bolton/bolto... Means map makers will be in business soon. Might not be a bad idea to get some potasium iodide.
- trendia 9y agoHow is this related to GDPR or the adtech bubble?
- ohiovr 9y agoBecause it makes doing business with europe illegal. Sanctions are war. GPDR isn't war, but depending on who looks over the laws in europe, giant part of our economy will be illegal to europe also.
- kenning 9y agoOr you could avoid adtech and misleading clickbait, which everyone hates
- hannasanarion 9y agoOr you can just, delete stuff when people ask you to? That's pretty much the only new burden of gdpr, and there are plenty of exceptions you can invoke.
- natural219 9y agoOne other fundamental shift that information technology makes to advertising is that digital tools, reviews, and marketplaces somewhat undermine some primary functions of advertising. I no longer care about brand or advertising information when buying commodity products on Amazon; I simply sort by # of reviews * avg score, read a sample of reviews at each star level, and I already have a general picture of the product's quality and consumer satisfaction. The parts of advertising meant to demonstrate "Hey, we're a quality company that can afford this prestigious advertising slot, therefore the reliability of our products is assured" has been eaten by frictionless digital review platforms. Of course, advertising and branding serve other purposes as well, and will always be some part of the purchasing decision. But social software and AI will likely continue getting better at matching consumers with products over time.
- genericone 9y agoI think that is coming back, however, as the whole fake Amazon review scandal continues to play out and demonstrate that anonymous reviews in an open digital marketplace are no replacement for a trusted brand. Not better and not worse, whether it is reviews or brands, at the end of the day its simply another way to gauge 'potential' product quality. Sometimes good brands screw you over with shitty products, sometimes bad manufacturers hire fake reviewers to shill for them.
- tzakrajs 9y ago> Advertising isn’t personal, and doesn’t have to be. Customers are being educated by companies, personal experience and news media why they are seeing the ads they are being shown. Just because advertising doesn't have to be personal, doesn't make that a sufficient argument for not doing it. > Advertising makes brands. Certainly brands are useful for trust, but often brand dominance blinds customers from smaller players and solutions. It's a trade-off. > Advertising carries an economic signal. Are there no other signals to determine economic strength of a company? Good advertising should project value and tilt perception in their favor. > Advertising sponsors media, and those paid by media. Companies study their customers without cookies to learn where better to advertise for them. This isn't new because of cookies. Tracking cookies gave the ability for small advertisers to understand their customers and their other consumption in ways that only the largest marketers could. > Adtech is built to undermine the brand value of all the media it uses, because it cares about eyeballs more than media, and it causes negative associations with brands. The author keeps making the assumption that strong brands are better than aligning customers with products that fit them well. > Adtech wants to be personal. That’s why it’s tracking-based. Though its enthusiasts call it “interest-based,” “relevant” and other harmless-sounding euphemisms, it relies on tracking people. The author again is throwing the baby out with the bathwater with no imagination for regulatory controls to limit the scope of access for customer data. > Adtech spies on people and violates their privacy. Emotional language, privacy is something that isn't monolithic for all people. There is nuance here. > Adtech is full of fraud and a vector for malware. So is the internet at large. > Adtech incentivizes publications to prioritize “content generation” over journalism. And on the other side of the coin, adtech incentivizes growth of smaller outfits to be competitive because it allows advertisers to find their platform. The author failed to mention all of the new media companies that have sprouted up now that they can compete with larger outfits. Customers have never had more choice. Who is to say the bias of a large firm is more advantageous than a smaller firm? > Intermediators take most of what’s spent on adtech. Bob Hoffman does a great job showing how as little as 3¢ of a dollar spent on adtech actually makes an “impression. The most generous number I’ve seen is 12¢. It's not about brand impressions. It's about conversions. > Adtech gives fake news a business model, because fake news is easier to produce than the real kind, and adtech will pay anybody a bounty for hauling in eyeballs. This is being worked on right now by the adtech platforms, it has a ton of visibility and public interest. > Adtech incentivizes hate speech and tribalism by giving both—and the platforms that host them—a business model too. Tribalism is not inherently a bad thing. Hate speech is a symptom of hate. Adtech is not making people hate each other. Hate speech is widely decried and has tons of visibility and public interest. > Adtech relies on misdirection. Again the author implictly is valuing brand presence over customers finding what they want. > Compared to advertising, adtech is ugly. Not ugly == expensive. Is that added cost necessary in helping customers find the right products and services? If not, it's superfluous. > Adtech has caused the largest boycott in human history. Which shows that the system can be worked around by users when it is too onerous.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- throwaways31415 9y agoNo it will only make Google and Facebook richer while pushing anyone else to the bottom or off the edge of the list. Everything else is just wishful fantasy.
- tomrod 9y agoI've been anticipating something like an ad-tech bubble pop for years -- most digital ads don't seem to add much by way of tangible value and hijack the decrease to information-acquisition costs that make the Internet a value-add on society. Oh, I'm not saying no one was ever influenced by digital ads, only that the wholesale adoption appears to be driven less by an understanding of their lift and more by "fear of missing out" by companies.
- tzakrajs 9y agoTracking cookies gave the ability for small advertisers to understand their customers and their other consumption in ways that only the largest marketers could. The author thinks big brands are everything and can't see how letting smaller players sell to customers could help the economy. He uses an arbitrary standard of privacy to argue on the behalf of the largest household brands. I think he's missing the forest for the trees.
- icebraining 9y agoCan you flesh that out a bit more? What are those ways?
- tzakrajs 9y agoCustomer focus groups. Literally paying customers to spend time with staff to learn their habits and thoughts about the advertising. The big brands have the funds and expertise to directly gather enough data to come up with strong predictors of behavior.
- icebraining 9y agoFocus groups are always made with the consent of the participants, though. You can still use tracking cookies if you also get consent.
- tzakrajs 9y agoYou use the word "though", but I don't see how your argument doesn't integrate with mine. Can you tell me what I am missing?
- vertexFarm 9y agoThe GDPR is about a lot more than cookies. I think you're going to have a hard time arguing that current massive internet advertising surveillance and analysis industry is friendly towards small business.
- 9y ago
- islanderfun 9y agoCompletely oblivious and ignorant here: If a company has no official office in Europe, how does this affect them? All advertisement and business focus is say only in the US, is it business as usual? What if an EU citizen decides to sign up? Are US companies forced to deny customers not par of say an IP block (half assed method I know, but just speaking in general)?
- isostatic 9y agoAs long as you don't target EU customers, you're fine.
- sunsetMurk 9y agoDo you have any references/citations for this? Would help me out! I'm trying to put together a one-pager for my team.
- isostatic 9y agoWhen the regulation does not apply Your company is service provider based outside the EU. It provides services to customers outside the EU. Its clients can use its services when they travel to other countries, including within the EU. Provided your company doesn't specifically target its services at individuals in the EU, it is not subject to the rules of the GDPR. https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/law-topic/data-protection/reform/rules-business-and-organisations/application-regulation/who-does-data-protection-law-apply_en https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/law-topic/data-protection/refo... IANAL etc
- FooBarWidget 9y agoI recently wrote about this subject (with sources). See these: https://www.joyfulbikeshedding.com/blog/2018-04-17-should-non-eu-websites-ban-eu-visitors-under-the-gdpr.html https://www.joyfulbikeshedding.com/blog/2018-04-17-should-no... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17058645 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17058645
- briandear 9y ago
- yuhong 9y agoI mention the GDPR briefly in my Google/DoubleClick essay: http://yuhongbao.blogspot.ca/2018/04/google-doubleclick-mozilla-essay-final.html http://yuhongbao.blogspot.ca/2018/04/google-doubleclick-mozi...
- kapauldo 9y agoI am unconvinced that tracking and profit are connected. Google doubleclick was plenty profitable before tracking. Second, the real fraud in ad tech is fraudulent clicks. Privacy is a moral and emotional issue, but I don't think it's related to profit, I think this link is way overstated.
- JulianMorrison 9y agoI felt the point that adtech isn't advertising, but direct marketing, deserves to be called out as important.
- Confiks 9y agoThe introduction of the article itself reads as an advertisement for shorting "adtech". What stock would you propose that would be?
- dpq 9y agoI'll play the devil's advocate and say that I'm actually disappointed by this development. A very long time ago when AdSense was young I was thrilled by the idea that instead of being bombarded by stupid ads designed to cater to morons people (including myself) will be getting relevant ads - ideally, ads about stuff that I am actually willing to buy right now. Kinda like legilimency. Too bad that this will be impossible for a long time to come now.
- mpweiher 9y agoHmmm...just target it to the content of the site? Just like targeting search ads to be relevant to the search?
- radesta 9y agoThere are many sites which are topic agnostic, others which have less text and therefore are more difficult to classify by ad crawlers and target based on topic. It's also difficult to conceive enough advertisers on the demand side for many niches. In this scenario targeted advertisement would fill in for the lack of demand
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fanf2 9y ago> perhaps a $trillion or more has been spent on adtech, and not one brand known to the world has been made by it Google.
- adventured 9y agoYou can add Alibaba, Baidu and Toutiao to that list. Nearly all of their revenue comes from adtech. Just three platforms used by a billion people. Yahoo was also made possible by adtech, it was / is a brand known to over a billion people. Facebook, Twitter, Snapchat - they only exist courtesy of their adtech. Can you imagine how difficult it would be for Twitter to sustain itself with a paid model? There's such an extreme imbalance between the people that post regularly and are power users, vs people that just occasionally consume. The median user that reads a few tweets per day - at best - is never going to pay $60 or $100 per year for that product. Even if you have five million power users on there paying $100 per year, Twitter instantly goes bankrupt, they could never charge enough.
- fnord123 9y ago>Facebook, Twitter, Snapchat - they only exist courtesy of their adtech. Where are the ads in snapchat? Or is the money made from selling people's information on to ad tech people?
- tomtheelder 9y agoOut of the three you listed, only one has actually made money. Snapchat and Twitter have lost incredible amounts. Also, I think what the article is suggesting is that brands don't typically get built on the back of advertising _initially_. All three of those started without it and added it in later once they were highly entrenched to try to monetize. I still don't think it was a very good point in the article, though.
- jamiequint 9y agoTwitter has been net income positive each of the last two quarters.
- 9y ago
- jacksmith21006 9y agoGDPR will help the big guys not hurt. The smaller guys it will be tough implmenting and make it more expensive in terms of expense to revenues.
- hadrien01 9y agoI took ten minutes to implement GDPR on a small ecommerce website: we deleted Google Analytics (HTTP logs and carts tracking is more than enough) and replaced Facebook widgets by a simple link. Newsletter was already opt-in only, we don't sell private data, and user account deletion was already possible.
- taysic 9y ago'user account deletion was already possible.' Do you not use backups? How was this done within 10 minutes?
- scrollaway 9y agoAs long as the backups expire within a reasonable amount of time there's no problem with this.
- hannasanarion 9y agoGDPR doesn't say you have to purge backups. That's nonsense spread by people who have assumed it's stupid without reading it.
- taysic 9y ago"The individual can be assured that their personal data will not be restored back to production systems (except in certain rare instances, e.g., the need to recover from a natural disaster or serious security breach). In such cases, the user’s personal data may be restored from backups, but the controller will take the necessary steps to honor the initial request and erase the primary instance of the data again." It sounds like you need to erase the data again even if you used a backup. That means you need a separate database of the entries you deleted. So it's still unclear how that could be integrated within 10 minutes.
- jknoepfler 9y agoAlthough I like the GDPR and would support similar legislation in my country, I honestly don't see the gloom and doom story. The EU market is a small part of the global story, and while this change clearly makes that market harder to enter, the article doesn't make the case that the EU represents a sufficient share of the adtech market to pop a bubble. In general it's easy to believe negative press about hated entities (for example, see liberal credulity about Trump's vulnerability in the US). I don't see the argument passing the bar for evidende, whether or not I want to believe it. edit: the argument that adtech stinks is not evidence in support of the article's thesis. crappiness is not a predictor of a bubble, and the author makes no attempt to connect the idea that ad tech stinks (which is stated ad nauseum) with the claim that the GDPR will bring about a global sea change for adtech)
- PeterisP 9y agoEU market is something like 25% of all the global market revenue, both for total industry and for the main international players individually. 25% of total revenue is large enough to adapt instead of avoiding the market, and it would be expected that every multinational player will be compliant, and thus also require their suppliers to be compliant - i.e. Google won't be buying data from a random adtech company if it might be "contaminated" with EU data obtained without proper procedures, the potential financial risk is just too great.
- jakeogh 9y agoSurreal to see people cheering on an attack on memory itself. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbYXBJOFgeI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbYXBJOFgeI
- hannasanarion 9y agoThat link has nothing to do with this. Also, GDPR has news, archival, public interest, and free speech exceptions, soooo maybe read the damn thing before posting FUD?
- jakeogh 9y agoIt really does. This is how incrementalism works so well. The exceptions[0] you cite are for practical purposes pointless; since you would need to defend your use of them, and the regulations can be incrementally tightened. The EU def of free speech is absurd anyway, the recent pug owner who got a fine for a dog trick is a harbinger. GDPR is about compliance. It further normalizes the idea that the gov can regulate memory, all the way down to who visited my property (if I was in the shrinking EU). [0] https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/exemptions/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da...
- njx 9y agoTracking IP address for SAAS companies is important for defending chargeback claims. For e.g when a customer demands a chargeback through their bank, Stripe notes down the IP address of every transaction. It is important to note this IP address and check if the user created an account using the same IP address. How are SAAS companies to provide sufficient usage proof when it comes to defend chargebacks?
- dangrossman 9y agoYou would be allowed to track IP addresses to prevent fraud. This is from Recital 47 of the GDPR: "The processing of personal data strictly necessary for the purposes of preventing fraud also constitutes a legitimate interest of the data controller concerned." "Legitimate interest" is one of the legal bases for processing personal data under the new regulation.
- Bizarro 9y agoDespite the propaganda being thrown around on HN, GDPR only affects businesses that have operations in the EU.
- peteretep 9y ago> I just said greatly simplifies what the GDPR actually utters, in bureaucratic legalese You can read and understand the whole thing in about 30m, as a lay-person.
- matchagaucho 9y agoThe second order effects of GDPR could actually be a boon to IT and tech: * Accounts Payable analytics (should I pay this ad bill?) * More Pay-per-Action (PPA). Less Pay-Per-View (PPV) * Standardized pixel tracking managed by Advertisers * Bot vs human agent detection (who/what actually viewed this ad?)
- Steeeve 9y agoFor a long time I've been saying that we can do better with online advertising and revenue generation - and that there's a wide open market for the startup providing the solution. There are a lot of practices that are distasteful that simply don't provide value that overrides their distastefulness. But quite simply the revenue is there to be had, and nobody is going to venture off in a new direction when you can make easy money doing exactly what everybody else is doing. The market may shift with GDPR, or it may just shift in europe. Or maybe the market doesn't shift at all, but some company policies change. I think in the end what causes the current incarnation of internet advertising to go away is going to just be a better idea.
- joering2 9y agoSomething tells me it will be similar to the fear mongering of cookies policies circa 2014. Meanwhile as ICO reporting, only on average 50 companies/sites have been investigated and punished, per year. https://ico.org.uk/action-weve-taken/cookies/ https://ico.org.uk/action-weve-taken/cookies/ Most likely with GDPR being so damn popular, they will be overloaded on day one. Heck, I personally have 5 different emailers I never provided my email to, that I just wait for the end of May to report! Do I believe each will be prosecuted and extracted out of $25MM in penalties ? Nope.
- booleandilemma 9y agoThis makes me glad I work for a company that makes money selling an actual product, and not just selling people’s data to the highest bidder.
- manigandham 9y agoIt won't do much. It'll definitely get rid of some low-value companies but that's about it. People think that adtech has some incredible insights but 99% of data is terrible. If you check your profile at any major site, you'll quickly find that you're probably in several conflicting segments that have nothing to do with you. Context is still king for any marketer who knows what they're doing, but unfortunately the industry is overwhelmed with subpar talent and politics through layers of agencies that buy buzzwords like "AI" and "data". Barely any adtech companies have a direct link to a person, and any links that did exist are even harder now with adblocking, 3rd party cookie deletion, ephemeral mobile device ids, IP renewals, and other noisy and loose signals. Interestingly, big companies like Facebook and Google that have user logins and 1st party data connections will actually benefit from the higher industry regulation and are not going to lose any of the data that users willingly give to them. ISPs are another major source of data, along with credit agencies and banks, and now giant ecommerce companies like Walmart and Amazon, all of which have very accurate and exhaustive histories and will see little change from GDPR. Overall it's well-intentioned, and good progress, but what it will do is vastly overstated.
- hsljekskfh 9y agoi am hopeful for the idea that shifting from ads to paid services will reduce clickbait. right now may be seen as the yellow journalism moment of the internet.
- Vinnl 9y agoWhat you're describing sounds very much like a bubble that is going to pop...
- manigandham 9y agoI said that GDPR will not affect much, other than a few companies that add up to a microscopic market share. Where's the bubble?
- Vinnl 9y agoThe bubble is those companies, although I guess the original article would argue that their market share is (currently) not microscopic.
- chrononaut 9y agoI wonder how many "parts" of the Internet are simply going to be inaccessible over the course of the year to individuals residing within the EU as websites take a rudimentary "block all EU traffic" approach as a first swing at preventing their services from being offered to EU residents.
- Zooper 9y agoJust be sure to marvel at the speed with which they're all simply replaced.
- dabockster 9y agoAnother gold rush? Count me in!
- bitmapbrother 9y agoDoc Seals has been proclaiming that the ad tech bubble is going burst every time he appears on the Gillmor Gang. It's gotten to the point where he now sounds like a broken record. I guess he thinks that if he repeats it long enough it'll eventually come true. I'll be looking forward to his follow up appearances where he backtracks and explains why it hasn't.
- beezle 9y agoSurprised the pop up doesn't say "agree to tracking and you'll be shown fewer and more relevant ads" and when they click decline "you will see 2x as many ads, are you sure?". Hardball!
- b1daly 9y agoThe real answers here should be in the data, but as an anecdote I experienced something that genuinely impressed me the other day. I’m in the market for a new mattress, and the other day on a whim I stopped at a mattress store (in real life). After I left the store, within an hour, I looked at a site I commonly look at (a political site), and saw a banner ad for the mattress store company. In any case, it’s hard for me to believe that targeted advertising doesn’t work, because without it, I see adds in product categories I will never buy in.
- Moru 9y agoOn the other hand I'm not in the market for a new mattress but I see advertisement for it everywhere. Might it just be that mattress ads are common this time of the year? A quick check of one of scandinavias more known bed and furniture chains (if ikea does not count...) shows they are having a sale of mattresses right now so if I didn't have ads blocked I would probably have seen some.
- Animats 9y agoFrom the article, it looks like the big winners in this will be companies which both run ads and have customer accounts. Google and Facebook, basically. Companies which have no relationship with the customer have no way to ask for permission to use customer data. This is a killer for third-party adtech companies which need that permission. So the middlemen get cut out, and advertisers deal with Google and Facebook directly.
- pawurb 9y agoI've just published a post about how I prepare my blog and side-project for GDPR: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17063156 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17063156
- zerostar07 9y agoGDPR may cause a drop in tracking-based ads, but websites can then just increase the number of ad slots for display and content-based ads. So what's changing is that the user is forced to choose between "less ads with tracking" and "more ads , no tracking". That 's not against the GDPR. So, expect more ad-tech, not less.
- harrumph 9y agoAside from generating revenue for what are surely wasted impressions, why does the online ad industry constantly show users web ads for things they've already purchased? Does this not represent conspicuously wasted spend on the part of these advertisers? It's been going on since the DoubleClick days and never ends. How can this industry bill clients with a straight face when their display decisions are made this crudely?
- imrawr 9y agoI work for a large adtech company. It's funny how people think they're tracked. Besides websites like Google and Facebook there is no personal information stored. No emails, no names, no way to figure out who that person actual is. Not sure why everyone is freaked out about personalized ads.