26 ms·
What many posters here miss is that there is a big group of tech people that have no interest in dealing with legal matters more than the bare minimum, and over
by pdimitar 9y ago
What many posters here miss is that there is a big group of tech people that have no interest in dealing with legal matters more than the bare minimum, and overall deem them risky. I am one of them. People like me are well-aware of the fact that if we are not experts then we're absolutely gonna lose because a dedicated lawyer can and will dig up material you couldn't prepare yourself to defend from.
Thus, complying with something somewhat ambiguous like the GDPR is still an expense -- of time, money and risk -- that many small website owners won't be willing to spare.
Look, it's not hard to encrypt all personally identifiable information; there are ready-made frameworks that let you choose which DB columns you encrypt and how. You can generate a key for each user on creation and have their data encrypted with it. The problem is NOT that.
The problem is what happens if a legal firm or an agency targets you. Even if you adhered to the spirit of the law, they can dig up evidence that you didn't obey the letter of the law (since GDPR is quite loose and ambiguous).
Small tech owners can't fight such litigations. I am kind of baffled how this point evades so many people in this thread.
- going_to_800 9y agoI'm a small business owner and this is my concern at all. What stops a competitor to just pay a lawyer to sue you or report you to GDPR authorities. Even if you are 100% compliant(which I doubt), you'll still have lots of issues, stress and wasted time with the audit.
- pdimitar 9y agoExactly. Even if you win, you won't win anything of much value -- most (if not all) of the money will likely go to your lawyer. And you have a lot to lose, mostly wasted nerves and time you could have spent improving your business -- or simply living your life stress-free. Defending even from bogus lawsuits is a huge expense of human energy for the non-experts (I'd wager that's 99% of the world's population).
- drey08 9y agoWe're a medium-sized software company, and we had to create a dedicated GDPR position so someone can look into everything and decide whether we're GDPR-compliant, and if not, how we can fix it. GDPR really complicates everything, even though most uf us (devs) are actually in favor of it (because we don't really like the idea of companies tracking us forever).
- riffraff 9y agoarticle 12 accounts for this, the DPA can refuse to act or fine a reporter if the request is unfounded or abusive. Maybe as a countermeasure for abuse it's too small, but it's not a totally absent concern.
- svennek 9y agoSuing you directly will not fly in the EU (maybe in the UK, but that is only going to be an issue for 1 year or so). I suspect the DPA will start with a letter, where you will need to explain your current practices. Then, nothing more happens (if you are mostly-complind and good-willed). Maybe you will get some written instructions to better yourself.
- GordonS 9y agoSue you for what? What "suing ammunition" exactly does the GDPR provide your competitors with? The authorities are not idiots, and have limited resources - they are only going to be chasing the true bad apples that are willfully infringing the GDPR.
- guildenstern 9y agoWe (people who operate online services) are exposed to legal action already, but we aren’t worried about it because realistically there’s such little risk of being targeted. The same is true of the GDPR, the organisations responsible for ensuring GDPR compliance are going to have their hands full for years and years to come, by the time the little guys have anything to worry about the situation will be much better defined. I cannot see a scenario in which I’m going to be pursued because of accidental non-compliance with my revenueless service when there are so many large companies that can afford million dollar fines who can’t even store passwords properly. if you’re so risk averse that any minuscule chance of GDPR noncompliance precludes you from running an online service... aren’t you already not running anything because of existing legal risk?
- pdimitar 9y agoGDPR simply reminds me of the other possible legal venues small owners can be sued over. So you might be right on your final point. Can we just flat out assume the GDPR won't indeed be abused to scare away smaller players though? You are claiming they will be safe for years but what if bigger players want to make an example out of 5-10 smaller players and just report / sue them to hell and back? I know I am reaching but this possibility can't be dismissed just like that. Historically, bigger players have exhausted smaller competition with legal fees and effectively drove them out of market. We cannot in good conscience claim GDPR won't ever be used like that. I'll be happy to be proven wrong in several years time from now, but right now I am simply not sure if GDPR is gonna be used for or against the free market (competition). Not claiming either way, just saying the risk wouldn't be worth it for me for now.
- going_to_800 9y agoNot biggest players, but your competitors to make your life a hell. I already have competitors that are butthurt and spread shit about me since their clients come to me and they lose business. That's what I'm afraid of, not getting randomly picked by the regulators.
- latk 9y agoBut would another company even have standing to sue? The GDPR is about personal data of natural persons. Such data subjects can sue under Art. 79 if their rights are violated. The most another company could do would be to “incentivize” a natural person to get their rights violated by you and then sue.
- aantix 9y agoBlock all European IPs. It's just not worth the risk.
- pdimitar 9y agoI admit that I'd do that. Lowest friction solution. I don't want law enforcement agencies knocking on my door because I host a hobby project on a free / $5 tier VPS for years. My intent isn't malicious. I simply don't want to invest in more maintenance. Hence I'd block EU, yes.
- Sacho 9y agoDo you also block all US IPs to avoid patent infringement claims? What makes you think the GDPR is broader in scope than the patents the USPTO hands out? In the patents' case, there is even a direct financial incentive for companies to sue you, whereas in the GPDR the interest of the regulatory body is primarily compliance.
- lagadu 9y agoThat won't completely protect you, it would only greatly reduce your surface of exposure; the eu user could still reach you via a vpn or simply sign up while vising the US.
- chii 9y agoAsk if user is European, and if they answered yes, deny them service. If they lie, then you have plausible deniability to mistreat their data. Users of free services will just set their country to non-EU, and continue to consume the services. GDPR will gave achieved nothing in that case.
- acct1771 9y agoIf you have no presence in the EU, to what sort of "risk" do you refer?
- joering2 9y ago
- kodablah 9y ago> Small tech owners can't fight such litigations. I am kind of baffled how this point evades so many people in this thread. Even if they could fight, why would they want to? There are lots of us with tiny things on the internet where the burden of maintenance is only slightly below the enjoyment we get making it available. Increase that burden and the costs are negative and things get shuttered. Question, if I have a small thing and don't want to preemptively concern myself with GDPR, as a non-EU site operator can I tell an information requester "no"? Might I harm my ability as a person to travel to the EU? Ignoring the standard "if you do nothing wrong you have nothing to worry about" and "the GDPR is really easy to understand" arguments, and assuming I'm not wanting to do any real work, would it be wise for me to just add known EU subnets to my firewall?
- pdimitar 9y agoIn the spirit of my original comment I'd answer "yes" to your last question. If I wanted a legal career I'd pursue that -- but I don't. So I'll cut my loses. That doesn't mean I am a shady operator, it means I don't want to risk being sued for money I don't have and likely end up in jail; in EU you can't just declare bankruptcy and run free afterwards. Hobby or goodwill projects (==not turning a profit) just aren't worth that risk.
- jimktrains2 9y agoI thought the gdpr applied to all EU citizens, even if they're not in the EU. If so filtering IP addresses isn't enough.
- jkaplowitz 9y agoIt cares about the location where you're targeting your goods or services, the location where the data processor or controller is established, or the location where the data is processed. Not anyone's citizenship. Much reporting has been sloppy about this, but the more precise info is consistent.
- 9y ago
- kartan 9y ago> Small tech owners can't fight such litigations. Yes. This I think is a downside of the law. Some small owners are going to have a more difficult time. But this is true for any regulation like food safety regulations, construction regulations, etc. They hurt more a small restaurant than a big chain. But in the end, these regulations are there to protect the customers. Small restaurants have closed and will continue closing for not following food safety regulations. But what is the alternative? Is business creation the final goal of our society? Or there are things more important? In summary, small businesses are going to have to extend their insurances to also cover risks related to GDPR. But it's the price to pay for having safer data.
- pdimitar 9y agoI don't dispute the goal of GDPR -- I support it fully. My worry is that it could be abused by legal trolls. They are a fact of life.
- foxylad 9y agoBut legal trolls have an array of legislation to attack you with. GDPR is just the latest one.
- pdimitar 9y agoAgreed. GDPR simply made me aware of that once again. I still feel the trolls should have minimal amount of attack vectors to small businesses, though.
- bryanrasmussen 9y agoyes but the argument is that one hit from the gdpr can kill you and maybe even most likely will even if you're in reasonable health, and most other legislation you can survive a few hits if you're not already critical.
- DanBC 9y agoNo. The first hit from GDPR violation will be from the regulator, asking if you actually are in violation, and giving you advice about how to come back into regulation.
- cft 9y agoI have to make two points. 1. This regulation is specifically (deliberately?) anti small business. If your revenue is less than €20m their fine is up to €20m, i.e. can be 100% of your revenue, meaning bankruptcy. If your revenue is greater than €500m, your fine is capped at only 4% of your revenue, i.e. an acceptable fluctuation. It's worse than a regressive tax. 2. China also has many regulations. Instead if trying to extend their jurisdiction to foreign sites, they simply block them. I thought about this and I actually prefer the Chinese non-expansionist model: I would rather outsource due diligence to the Chinese government than hire expensive EU lawyers and then implement EU specific blocks. FYI we do not collect any data other than for spam and DDoS attack mitigation, but apparently if you have any third party code in your site like ads you have to subject all of that to this expensive audit. Well meaning regulation like this written by people who have never created anything pratical in their lives other than regulations illustrates why entrepreneurship in modern Europe is nearly impossible.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Cacti 9y ago> outsource due diligence to the Chinese government That is easily one of the more absurd statements I've seen this month. > Well meaning regulation like this written by people who have never created anything pratical in their lives And websites whose customers advertising agencies, and whose product is people, create something? Attempting to track and then monetize everything everyone does online is _creating_ something now?
- closeparen 9y agoFacilitating anything online is in GPDR scope, regardless of whether data monetization or advertising is involved.
- asadjb 9y ago> And websites whose customers advertising agencies, and whose product is people, create something? Attempting to track and then monetize everything everyone does online is _creating_ something now. This is snarky, and intentionally simplifies things down to a dumb level. Here's a list of things that "create something" while relying on an advertisement model for revenue: - Gmail - Facebook - YouTube - StackOverflow - Reddit (to some extent) - Yahoo - Miniclip - Neopets I can find a hundred other examples that are ad-revenue supported by create immense value. It's a difficult balance to strike, and while not perfect, this model has allowed us access to so many good services that would otherwise not exist. Saying that none of them "create something" is just wrong.
- mathattack 9y agoThis is why regulation favors incumbents. The rules don’t help any individual company, so they won’t self-regulate, but the cost becomes a barrier to competition and innovation.
- andrewcarter 9y agoI have a little birth control pill reminder iOS app I made like 7 years ago that I still maintain in the app store. I don't make really any money off of it but I keep up with it because it has a good amount of users. I don't THINK any of the GDPR stuff falls under anything the app does, but I sure as hell aren't taking any chances. I just removed it from any country that fell under "Europe" in the app store. I guess my point is I agree with what you're saying, and here's an example of a little hobby app that GDPR killed for EU countries. It's not worth my time, money, or risk to bother with it.
- actuator 9y agoEdit: I re-read it and it looks like it only applies if you are a business with physical presence in EU or if the user is accessing from EU GDPR applies to you if a EU citizen signs up from somewhere outside EU as well, but since you don't have any physical or online presence in EU I don't think they will do anything.
- dangrossman 9y agoGDPR applies only to people physically located in EU. Citizenship doesn't matter. Read Article 3, Territorial Scope.
- downandout 9y agoJust to clarify your point: it applies to users physically located in the EU. Fines assessed under it apply businesses that serve them anywhere in the world, which is what makes it so damned scary. The EU government has essentially declared itself the Emperor of the Internet.
- matthewmacleod 9y agoTransactions with EU users should be expected to comply with EU law. What’s unusual about that?
- rdiddly 9y agoThe law is not even in effect yet. The persecution you're talking about is imaginary. Those of us having trouble being so imaginative probably tend to prefer waiting for evidence.
- ILikeConemowk 9y agoLack of foresight is not a virtue, it is a bug.
- rdiddly 9y agoWasting time & energy planning for a scenario that never happens is over-design.
- ILikeConemowk 9y agoGood luck with that mindset. Besides, who said it will never happen? What can you be sure will "never happen" Can I use your crystal ball?
- salvar 9y agoYou're right. On that note, it's best to never leave your house. It's just not worth the risk. How can you be sure that debris won't fall out of the sky? Do you have a crystal ball?
- ILikeConemowk 9y agoI'm aware of the risks involved in going outside and I plan accordingly, that's why I have a life insurance. I wasn't the one who said that was a "scenario that never happenS"
- chii 9y agoWhat kind of insurance can you buy for GDPR non-compliance, where it costs you less than actually complying?
- rzwitserloot 9y agoProbably because, compared to the status of legal matters in the US, blaming _europe_ of all places for being legally murky is just mind boggling.
- eksemplar 9y agoFrom the description Streetlend didn’t violate the GDPR in concept though. Addresses are public record, available in public databases, and there is nothing stopping you from doing lending eBay. All it needed to do was clear it’s records every 6 months and let people delete their accounts. Except this isn’t really true. Streetlend made its money by selling your privacy data to advertisers through Amazon. So when you put up a power drill for lend, people would see power drills for sale at local shops, based on their online presence harvested through stuff like their Facebook account. The really ironic thing about that this is that streetlab imagined itself “ethical” when it’s entire business model was selling your data... The GDPR isn’t really that hostile to small business and it doesn’t require an understanding of law. You can hire a data protection officer at a legal firm for almost nothing, and as long as you follow their advice on how to pass audits, you’re really not in trouble. That being said, the GDPR is really hostile toward startups trying to make money the same way Facebook and Google does. You need to have a massive legal department to do that, and Streetlend obviously did not. But is that really so terrible? It may call for a new business model for the internet, and that may seem impossible right now. But do you remember when the EU outlawed environmentally shitty lightbuilbs and everyone said we were going dark because it was impossible to do anything else? Today 95% of lightbuilbs are LEDs because of that. Startups will find a way to make money that isn’t selling your data.
- tchock23 9y agoCould you share the name of a legal firm charging ‘almost nothing’ for a data protection officer? Because the ones I’m finding definitely cost more than ‘almost nothing.’
- _o_ 9y agoUnfortunately there is no more site to prove it, but I would imagine something like this. GDPR on its own shouldn't be a problem for Streetlend, there was something more, users data releated and how to make money off them.
- yellow_postit 9y agoThe massive legal team part is indeed the problem as it further entrenches Facebook and Google from competition in that space.
- ec109685 9y agoEncrypting all user data doesn’t get you out of the gdpr if you hold the key to decrypt the data.
- pdimitar 9y agoFair point, but I personally wouldn't ever do that. There are well-known solutions to the problem: the user's cookie after authentication is not persisted on the server and only an ID is used (the key is derived from the password, otherwise this wouldn't ever work). Then another part of the cookie serves as an ephemeral key that the backend uses to decrypt and serve the personal data back (through HTTPS). Again, that second part of the cookie is never persisted on the server. I am not asking anybody to take my word for it, just saying how my ethics and tech education tell me I should be doing things.
- megaman22 9y agoI am resisting a push into converting from an on-premise, installed product to a SAAS model for precisely these reasons. I don't want to be responsible for that liability, and I'm just the engineer doing the work. It's a minefield, compared to the way things were.
- e12e 9y agoThat seems backwards; with a data agreement between you and the saas - the saas takes on much of the liability for the day to day (eg: making sure data is actually deleted - from backups as well).
- ryandrake 9y agoThere were "legal matters" on the Internet before the GDPR. These scary rogue legal firms can already target you if they want, without the GDPR. Yet plenty of law abiding small Internet businesses existed yesterday and will continue to exist tomorrow. I don't currently run a business online, but if I were, honestly I'd be more worried about the usual headaches like accepting payments legally, dealing with spam/fraud/abuse, finding product/market fit, etc. GDPR would be somewhere around 500th on my list of "start-up things that give me crippling anxiety."
- JorgeGT 9y agoThis is why I don't get all the hysteria and all the "block all EU IPs!" comments of people in this thread. For years, there have been 28 different data protection laws in the EU that you could be sued with. Now there will be a harmonized one. So from getting sued 28 times with 28 different laws you have reduced your risk to being sued with just 1. Now, in order to have an online business in the EU you just need to comply with 1 data protection law instead of with 28. How is this bad? What I suspect is that many people were just not aware of the 28 previous data protection laws that they needed to comply with, at all, and are now realizing that these laws exist.
- pdimitar 9y agoI don't see how your points and mine conflict. They don't, IMO. GDPR simply made me aware that I am not willing to go the extra mile for hobby projects so I shut them down and never sold any info to anyone, nor have I served ads/trackers. Many commenters of my sub-thread here are making me look like a histeric and that's seriously annoying. It's all about deciding if a cost is worth it and I figured in my case it wasn't. Why make it more complex than that?
- jlangenauer 9y agoOr, to put it another way: a big group of tech people who have no interest in protecting the data of their customers, preferring to be able to cut corners and do as they please with information that is not theirs. There is nothing in the GDPR that allows for a person or lawyer to sue a company for GDPR non-compliance. All they can do is complain to the regulatory authority in their EU country, which has the sole power to issue fines. And if you're not taking care of my data, then I have no problem at all with you being fined.
- pdimitar 9y agoIs deliberately missing the point giving you pleasure? I stated exactly what I had in mind, the rest is your projection and fantasy. You say there is nothing in the GDPR that allows a person / lawyer to sue a company. I have no reason to doubt that. Okay. But laws aren't that clear and cut; there are overriding laws, parent laws, derivative laws... the spaghetti black hole is huge and everybody who isn't a hardcore specialist lawyer can't possibly hope to be 100% informed and protected. That was my original point and still is. How did you transition to the hint that I am (1) farming personal info, (2) not taking care of it, and (3) I deserve a fine.. guess that's one of the Universe's mysteries.
- blub 9y agoAfter more than a decade of privacy abuses from almost all companies, I am perfectly ok with the collateral damage to start-ups, apps and personal projects that this law will cause, as long as it stops the abuse. Society doesn't owe entrepreneurs a business model, but it does owe people a dignified life and some control over information that can be used to harm them.
- pdimitar 9y agoFinally somebody who makes a balanced commentary. I fully agree and that's why yesterday I deleted 7 hobby projects -- all their databases and hosted apps, cancelled VPS subscriptions and never made any backups. Never put ads, never put trackers, never sold anything to anyone. Hell, I just checked their VPS dashboard once a month, that was all. Since I don't want to deal with the legal baggage I am doing my part in NOT contributing to the rampaging privacy abuses and simply destroyed anything goodwill that I created in the past that might have collected any shred of personal data. Thus I am perfectly okay with my personal project being a collateral damage of the GDPR. I believe in the GDPR and want to see responsible private data usage.
- svennek 9y agoI paraphrase: what most posters here seem to miss is that most chemist cannot be bothered to read up on environmental rules. It should be my right to dump toxic waste wherever I want, because I am a chemist. Sorry, but society doesn't work like that. You are always responsible for your actions no matter if you earn a profit or not. And not bothering to read up is also not an excuse. Companies take risks. This is just another one, that has to be managed like all other.
- pdimitar 9y agoGood thing I am looking for your pardon then. Let's try that again: (1) I have a few hobby and free projects hosted on the net where people sign up and might fill up full names. Never made a penny out of them, never had any trackers or ads -- just a bunch of acquaintances used them, and maybe 50-100 strangers. (2) I don't want to deal with the GDPR. (3) I delete the entire database without backing it up. (4) I delete my hosted app and don't renew my VPS subscription. Zero damage done now and in the past because I never sold any data to anyone. What part of that gives you the hint I am irresponsible? Society might "not work like that" as you say and since I don't want to deal with extra legal baggage, I am simply doing my best not to contribute to the abusing privacy problem. I delete any and all traces of personal data my hobby apps gathered. Really, what's so unclear or tempting in my original comment that makes you people attack me?
- svennek 9y agoFirst of all, I wasn't attacking you, but your statement, that to me sounded like "who cares about the law, I am a programmer". If that wasn't what you meant, then I am sorry to have misunderstood you. Fact is, at we have a giant tragedy of the commons due to loose and fast play with peoples personal data. This is similar to what happens in third world countries where people play fast with working safety or environmental laws.. My point was, any data you collect has a risk of doing harm and we have historically grabbed everything in sight, just in case - as if there was no potential downsides to it. What happens when somebodys sideproject (which hasn't been updated for 18 months due to lack of interest) gets hacked and a gay persons sexual preference and home address is leaked and that person is killed by haters? (extreme example I know) I have no problem with you doing the above 4 steps, but I do think that we, programmers, have a collective responsibility to safeguard people against non-obvious (to the layman) dangers, the same way as any other industry. And the tone in this thread is hysterical from the "ooh the GDPR is devil incanated" group. Fact is that the "new" regulation aligns with what most europeans would have belived had been the law all along (and actually was, just mostly non-enforced). I also acknowledge that the US have vastly different ethical standards and that everyone is free to be exploited as much as they want.. Click-through EULAs are also not binding in Europe for example, I am interested to see what happens when a DPA takes an american company to court due to having given themselves unlimited consent on page 2712 in their EULA. If those companies withdraw from Europe, I welcome the collateral damages of some innocent but lazy projects.. Do you really think that a thought about what data you really need (and why), the need to actively safeguard the data (especially the sensitive) and a need to formalize those thoughts on paper is a unbearable burden? All the american scare-mongering about the fines are people that don't understand European law practice. And the whole affair of Facebook moving non-EU people away from the Irish juristiction to have them not under the GDPR shows, that it will probably work as intended. (Some people call it Lex Facebook already)
- chunkyslink 9y agoI'm baffled by the fact that people think you can be sued for non compliance. You get reported to a government authority that will address the issue. The point to protect users, not to prosecute companies for operating. However, GDPR would be enforced if you just ignored it. It really isnt such a big deal.
- CodesInChaos 9y agoFor my hobby projects I'm more worried about getting expensive letters from greedy lawyers telling me about some non compliance issue (Abmahnung) not about government authorities. Especially since you often have to sign agreements which include high fines for a second violation (Strafbewehrte Unterlassungserklärung). Considering the complexity of the regulation, reliably avoiding violations and regressions sounds difficult.
- z3t4 9y agoCan anyone give an example of a company that has been targeted by legal firm or an agency ? All I know about it patent trolls. So how would these legal firms make any money from the GDPR !?
- scaryclam 9y agoApart from selling services related to the GDPR, such as helping companies with complience or helping individuals report problems, they won't. It seems a lot of people haven't even read the cliff notes version but are happy to proclaim the sky is falling. The GDPR will be enforced only via the appropriate agencies in each country where it is law.
- DanBC 9y ago> The problem is what happens if a legal firm or an agency targets you. Even if you adhered to the spirit of the law, they can dig up evidence that you didn't obey the letter of the law (since GDPR is quite loose and ambiguous). And in that case the regulator would write you a letter asking you to fix it. At that point you have the choice to fix it, or to write back and explain why you can't fix it now. Or you can ignore the regulator, which may lead to a small fine.
- hywel 9y agoForm a limited company and run the site from that. If you're prepared to shut the site down anyway, then that remains the worst thing that can happen for non-compliance. There's no need to shut the thing down just in case someone sues you when that hasn't happened yet. On the other hand, there's a good reason to shutter your site because you don't have time to make it respectful of people's privacy. By all means, shut down your site because the GDPR makes you realise that! But that's not what OP is saying.
- coldtea 9y ago>Look, it's not hard to encrypt all personally identifiable information; there are ready-made frameworks that let you choose which DB columns you encrypt and how. You can generate a key for each user on creation and have their data encrypted with it. The problem is NOT that. The problem is what happens if a legal firm or an agency targets you. The problem is also not botching the encryption process -- and relying blindly on some "ready-made frameworks" is a sure-fire way to do that.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pdimitar 9y agoI'll immediately agree to that but in the spirit of the GDPR which allows you some screwups, isn't that still better than keeping non-encrypted personal data on a small VPS you have no idea if other people have no unlimited access to? I shut down my hobby projects because I didn't want to rework them. Deleted everything, never sold info to anyone, never served ads and had exactly zero external JS snippets on them. If I am to open a business, I'll however work a lot to be GDPR-compliant. I believe it was about damn time for something like that to emerge.
- aquadrop 9y agoYeah, that's what I was talking about couple of weeks ago here. I was afraid that GDPR will stifle innovation and it's just a beginning. GDPR is highly vague omnipresent regulation with huge strict fines. It's like infamous cookie law times a million. They could make it into a good law, my opinion on what should have been done: Keep good parts, such as: - Appoint official 'security' representative who're responsible for breach disclosures, promoting security practices etc, that person can be personally held responsible for shifty company behavior (though nothing draconian) like non-disclosing a breach, so they would be motivated to be on user side in the company. - Let users ability to download their own data - Let users clear way to tell company that they want to stop using their account (and related data gathering) - Mandate more open disclosure of what is done with data gathered from users And also: - Mandate easier ways to review EULA and changes to EULA (like each change should be available separately, describe what changed and why) - Create system of centralized disclosure of security vulnerabilities by third parties, with record showing request and response publicly after some time. Maybe also create some system of grants for third party penetration testing for larger players in the internet. - Split available data into categories, like 'non-sensitive data', 'sensitive data', 'highly sensitive data'. Medical records, financial records etc is highly sensitive and higher standards are applied. Email and name is non-sensitive data (so you could run a simple forum, or any other simple free service, where you only want email from a user, without being afraid). - Split companies into tiers, under 50 employees or 100000 users nothing applies; 51-1000 employees higher standard applies; over 1000 - full power applies. This also should be tied with previous point - for example, smallest tier company should still be responsible for some rules if they deal with highly sensitive data, and if it's largest tier company they should be following some rules even if they only deal with non-sensitive data. - More sensible fines. For example 1% or $100k, whichever is smaller for the first time, 2% or $1m second time etc. Designated security officer can also be held responsible in the same manner (like, % of salary and later being forbidden to work as a security officer). It can also be tied to tiers of companies. - Start applying law gradually, beginning with just applying it only for european countries. I believe that would keep benefits for users and won't create giant problems for the industry as a whole.
- BlackFly 9y agoWith one minor exception, you have just described GDPR. The exception being: there is no minimum for fines. So a small company could be fined absolutely nothing for an infringement if it was representative of the harm caused or they fixed the issue. Also. Security representatives--actually called data protection officers--are only necessary at large scale or highly sensitive operations. The law is being applied gradually. It is already in effect and has been for two years. The approaching deadline is when the penalty clauses will come into effect. How it will be applied remains to be seen, but has no bearing on the validity of the legislation itself.
- lagadu 9y ago> The problem is what happens if a legal firm or an agency targets you. Nothing. GDPR enforcement is carried out by each country's regulatory authority; they're the only ones who can sue, target or take action against you for non-conformity.
- tobltobs 9y agoI guess you never heard about the German "Abmahnung" industry.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pbreit 9y agoThat’s why I would think that no matter what you do you’re probably still technically exposed so not to worry.
- Rattled 9y agoAre many US based businesses considering limiting access to EU consumers to avoid GDPR? Reselling user data seems to be part of many business models, and I don't know if EU is such a huge market internationally, especially without UK. I support the goal of improving data privacy, and in general GDPR is seen positively by those I've talked to, but the EUs last attempt resulted in useless, intrusive cookie warnings all over the place.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> The problem is what happens if a legal firm or an agency targets you. Even if you adhered to the spirit of the law, they can dig up evidence that you didn't obey the letter of the law (since GDPR is quite loose and ambiguous). As I understand it, you will be able to appeal or somehow else address the European Data Protection Board, that will be tasked with ensuring the consistent application of the regulation: Coordination and Consistency Under the Directive, there has been a certain level of coordination in interpretation and enforcement. Apart from informal contacts among authorities, there has been a succession of non-binding opinions issued by the “Article 29 Data Protection Working Party,” an advisory committee comprised of representatives of the national supervisory authorities (commonly termed “data protection authorities” or DPAs), along with the European Data Protection Supervisor appointed by the European Commission. Under the Regulation, that group will become a more independent and powerful regulatory body called the European Data Protection Board, tasked with ensuring “the consistent application” of the GDPR. An entire chapter of the Regulation (Articles 55-63) is devoted to cooperation and consistency, with procedures for multiple DPAs to coordinate investigations and promulgate consistent decisions and policies reviewed by the Board and reported to the European Commission. One feature of coordination that should be helpful for multinationals is a provision for companies to work with a “lead supervisory authority” in the country where the company has its “central administration.” That authority will then coordinate with the authorities in other countries where the company operates, attempting to achieve consensus on issues that affect all of them. https://www.infolawgroup.com/2016/05/articles/gdpr/gdpr-getting-ready-for-the-new-eu-general-data-protection-regulation/ https://www.infolawgroup.com/2016/05/articles/gdpr/gdpr-gett...
- usgroup 9y ago... well, you set up a LTD precisely to limit liabilities in that catastrophic case scenario but you'd probably find that people "coming after you" will be proportionate to how much you have to come after ... I.e. if you're a guy with a side project that makes no money; you're unlikely to attract "parasitic lawyers". Further, in my opinion the GDPR is wholesome. You ought to implement it even if it didn't exist. If your business relies on playing fast and lose with user data then IMO it's not an honest business ... Further still, the worse punishment is 4%/20M; it's not the default intervention or anywhere near the only way that the GDPR will be enforced.
- hjnilsson 9y agoRegarding your first statement, GDPR does not apply to personal projects. Only to business to consumer interaction. You are at less risk (in fact, zero), if you don't have an LTD as you are outside the scope of the law.
- simion314 9y ago>he problem is what happens if a legal firm or an agency targets you. Even if you adhered to the spirit of the law, they can dig up evidence that you didn't obey the letter of the law (since GDPR is quite loose and ambiguous). >Small tech owners can't fight such litigations. I am kind of baffled how this point evades so many people in this thread. Isn't this the same with the other laws, like copyright,trademark, patents, software licenses? I could say the same about one of this other laws, like you may have a video of you doing something cool and a bit of copyrighted music could be heard in background then you coulg get sued by a big bad law firm, the difference is that in this case the regular citizens are protected and not the budget of big music publishers.
- pdimitar 9y agoTrue, GDPR simply adds one more lane from which you can be attacked. Never claimed otherwise, and you are correct.
- jakobegger 9y agoWhat’s the upside for a legal firm to target you? You’re not going to pay fines to them, right?
- themacguffinman 9y agoLegal firms acting on behalf of a competitor or spiteful customer?
- dbbk 9y agoI don't think this actually happens.
- fencepost 9y agoThe problem is what happens if a legal firm or an agency targets you. Even if you adhered to the spirit of the law, they can dig up evidence that you didn't obey the letter of the law (since GDPR is quite loose and ambiguous). They don't even need to dig up any possible violations - just the legal process alone is enough to kill any side project. Or, "You can beat the rap, but you can't beat the ride." For a small company or individual, even winning a GDPR case will be a Pyrrhic victory.
- pdimitar 9y agoYes, and people keep missing THAT point exactly. Guess they believe in the system more than I do. My country -- and the EU -- has been known to have cases where a big player makes a grizzly example out of a small player, in basically every business area.
- smoe 9y ago> [...] there is a big group of tech people that have no interest in dealing with legal matters more than the bare minimum, and overall deem them risky. Then maybe those people shouldn't be opening side businesses? Running a business implies having to deal with business matters which include legal. For example in Switzerland if I want to open a small cafe in the corner selling home made cheesecake, I'll have to first figure out what the exact regulations in my state are, obtain a permit for opening one, create a "Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points" concept and send it to the authorities, make somewhat sure I get accounting right, maybe getting a permit for infrastructure changes, etc. I'm not talking about GDPR especially because I don't know enough about it yet. And in general I am sceptical of laws and regulations that don't seem absolutely necessary. What I don't get is why anyone should care that some tech people running a business don't want do deal with legal like everyone else? What makes us so special?
- pdimitar 9y agoI don't run a side business and I don't collect personal data. I had 7 hobby projects that very few people used. After I read on the GDPR yesterday, I simply deleted all their databases and apps (without backing anything up) and didn't look back. I believe in the GDPR and I don't want to become a part of the problem. The lowest friction solution was to just delete stuff I don't deem at all important. If I am to open a business, I'll cross 100 rivers to be GDPR compliant. And you are correct -- us the techies aren't special, of course. I only asserted that for hobby projects or projects that are not turning a profit the extra effort is simply not worth it. Nothing more.
- merinowool 9y ago> You can generate a key for each user on creation and have their data encrypted with it. The problem is NOT that. This is still debatable, because what if in near future your encryption turns out to be weak and all the personal data become readable again? Things like this... This law was really not thought through.
- bagacrap 9y agoWhy would a small, unprofitable website be the target of an opportunistic legal team?
- pdimitar 9y agoSpite. I've seen big players (controlled by pissed off influential person) chase down small businesses in my country relentlessly, to the point that the father of a family had to serve in jail for 2 years because he couldn't afford the fines. The lawsuit lasted 3-4 years and the poor guy was called to court basically every month... It was awful to watch. Eventually some good souls gathered the fine money and bailed the poor man. And then the suers got pissed and tried to raise the fine, eventually had to pay for... I don't know the legalese for that, but basically they took it too far and the judge called them out on it and forced them to cover ALL legal expenses. My point however is that for ordinary people even the nerves and time lost in a lawsuit are too big a price to pay. We aren't machines, these things get to us.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoYou aren't willing, so you exit the market. Someone else will come along, who is willing, and fills the need while respecting people's privacy. Everyone wins. Considering one can be sued for just about anything, or accused of patent infringement for just about anything in tech, the fear of litigation isn't a compelling argument.
- EpicEng 9y agoOk, then don't comply and shut down, but I don't see what's ambiguous about the GDPR in this context. Also, they goal of the EU is not to fine the hell out of small businesses; it's compliance. Companies found to be out of compliance will be worked with and an attempt to conform to the spirit of the law shows good faith. This article sounds a lot like sour grapes and shows no real attempt to actually figure out what compliance would look like.
- pdimitar 9y agoOP of the top-level comment here. A lot of people here: please CHILL. You make me look like a histeric. Not what I had in mind. - I don't want to become a semi-lawyer or hire a lawyer until absolutely necessary. - I had 7 hobby projects where people could fill out full names if they wanted to. - I deleted all of them -- apps and database -- without backing them up. Never served ads or trackers, never had a 3rd party JS on any of them. Unless somebody had unfettered access to the VPS-es without me knowing it, I never leaked personal info. It's a very simple cost calculation: I don't even want to invest 2 hours in reading the GDPR in details nor do I want to rework the hobby projects to encrypt the personal data in the DBs, hence I refuse to be a part of the abusing privacy problem and delete anything that might have gathered any personal data. I believe in the GDPR and this was my way to at least not contribute to the problem. Seriously, what's so unclear? You can repeat to me that "knowing laws and protecting from bogus lawsuits is a fact of life" but it doesn't have to be before I have a business -- which I don't. So I still respectfully disagree that I have to learn legalese today. So seriously, don't get so worked up over a comment that expresses a sentiment that I want to become more law-aware only when absolutely necessary and not a minute before that. Geez.
- Dayshine 9y agoSo why not wait until a regulatory authority gets in touch raising concerns, and then delete? You don't want to hire a lawyer until absolutely necessary, but you're willing to delete everything way before absolutely necessary?
- pdimitar 9y agoSimple: I like coding and solving problems, not learning legalese. My hobby projects were inconsequential. Nobody cares about them much, including myself. I prefer tinkering, not becoming better versed in legalese. It's rather fascinating to me how I keep being misunderstood. I guess I am not stating things as clearly as I imagine.