23 ms·
Medicare will require hospitals to post prices online
- txcwpalpha 9y ago> Patients concerned about their potential out-of-pocket costs from a hospitalization would still be advised to consult with their insurer. Having a heart attack? Make sure you call your insurance company and ask about the latest rates before you call 911, folks!
- tantalor 9y ago> emergency rooms account for "2 percent of all health care spending." http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2013/oct/28/nick-gillespie/does-emergency-care-account-just-2-percent-all-hea/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2013/oct/...
- josefresco 9y agoAlso from your linked article: "Getting anything other than true emergency care in an emergency department tends to be an expensive, fragmented way to receive care and should be avoided if any other reasonable alternative is available," Wilensky said.
- mattmcknight 9y agoMost money is spent in non-emergency care. Just because something doesn't solve all problems doesn't mean it isn't an improvement. The next step is then to force the hospitals to charge all payers the same price.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- silveira 9y agoA delusional wishful thinking that a patient, while in pain and in need to care, will be shopping and browsing around to see prices, and that would drive prices down. Even if that was true, it requires that you could predict how much your treatment or visit would cost, and anyone who have actually used and paid bills in the health system in US knows how it goes.
- adamnemecek 9y agoIt depends on the patient and the procedure. It will keep them honest tho, like if the hospital charges 10x what the next one does, you can ask some questions.
- bkohlmann 9y agoWhile you are right about in the moment decision making, this is a welcome change. What will likely happen is that aggregators / bloggers / journalists will start comparing prices and write about the differences. People will see the articles. And in a moment of crisis, they'll potentially think about the ones they read about, remembering one hospital or another. And even if they don't, the mere fact of comparison articles (and likely outrage from normal people in the comments sections, etc), will create competitive pressure driving prices closer together. At that point, people won't need to search for the specific price for a hospital because all will likely be similar.
- TheBiv 9y agoI believe the theory is that by posting prices online hospitals will become generally regarded as being "expensive" or "inexpensive", which in turn could drive prices down.
- mikepurvis 9y agoIt opens the door to third party organizations to do the comparison upfront, and assign different hospitals an overall grade. No one's expecting you to shop around while you're waiting for an ambulance, but a) there are a lot of procedures where you do indeed have some time to think about it upfront (childbirth, most surgeries), having a sense that a particular hospital is overcharging allows social and political pressure to be put on them to normalize.
- rdl 9y agoThere are some facilities which already post basically accurate prices online: https://surgerycenterok.com/ https://surgerycenterok.com/ is a great example. If I needed some kind of elective or non-emergency procedure, they would be high on my list (along with medical tourism to foreign countries where procedures are also clearly priced, and even cheaper) I've recently been having pretty good luck going to medical providers and offering cash (I have Kaiser insurance now, which I basically treat as emergency/catastrophic only, since they never cover any providers I'd want to see, so I basically end up paying cash.). I was able to get a dermatologist to go from $600+ to $95 because cash.
- madengr 9y agoAs long as they assign a variance to that mean price. Even then it woukdn’t fit any known distribution.
- aaavl2821 9y agoI really like this push towards transparency but hopefully people who use the data / develop will make sure to understand the system and the data they're dealing with. Like list prices are often incredibly far removed from the actual dollars paid, and the actual amount paid is all dependent on insurer contracts I'd imagine hospitals hate this. Many of them are paranoid at what will happen if there is more transparency -- there's a union fighting Stanford hospital now and playing radio ads about high infection rates at Stanford. Other hospitals are worried about whether similar things could happen to them -- and hold their data tight to make sure no one has ammunition to do similar things. Hospitals in many cases market based on brand value rather than quality. In a closed world, hospitals can define quality any way they want. Everyone is #1 in something. If there's an objective standard for quality based on integrated data from hospitals nationwide, many brands will be tarnished. I'd be interested to see how hospitals respond to this push towards openness
- octorian 9y ago> Like list prices are often incredibly far removed from the actual dollars paid, and the actual amount paid is all dependent on insurer contracts Which means that anyone those insurer contracts don't cover, is getting royally screwed. Thus, healthcare is simply unaffordable to someone who doesn't have those insurers acting as a payment intermediary. This one of the dirty secrets of the whole US healthcare coverage problem that I never see politicians (or talking heads) on either side actually acknowledging.
- killjoywashere 9y ago> politicians (or talking heads) If you're serious about learning, stop listening to these people (seriously, it's a waste of your one precious life) and try taking a healthcare economics class or reading Paul Starr's Social Transformation of American Medicine.
- octorian 9y agoThe problem is that these people dominate the public conversation. We can't solve a problem if you have to read some special book or take some special class to even be able to correctly acknowledge it.
- BurningFrog 9y agoOne of the biggest problems with US health care is that it's usually impossible to find out what treatments will cost before having them. This makes "shopping around" and being an informed consumer near impossible. If this actually happens in a meaningful way, hospitals will have to be competitive on price, and I can easily see a 30% cost reduction across the industry just from that. ...which is why I'd be surprised if that actually happened. Such a big restructuring of such a politically powerful industry doesn't just happen in our system.
- txcwpalpha 9y agoThe article already states that these online prices will be meaningless to most people, as they are the 'list prices' that no insurance company or individual would actually end up paying. So it will still be nearly impossible to find out what a treatment will cost before having it.
- sigmar 9y ago>It may still prove to be confusing to consumers, since standard rates are like list prices and don't reflect what insurers and government programs pay. Does not mean "meaningless." And the purpose of shopping around is comparing between hospitals. List prices should be a good relative predictor for comparing cost.
- txcwpalpha 9y ago> And the purpose of shopping around is comparing between hospitals. List prices should be a good relative predictor for comparing cost. When is the last time you dealt with any healthcare bills? This is almost universally untrue. Hospital A's list price for an MRI might be $1000, but your insurance has a deal with them where you only pay $100 out of pocket. Meanwhile Hospital B's list price for the same MRI is $500, but your insurance doesn't have a deal with them, so your OOP cost is $500. This is very common, and in many cases is impossible to know if it will happen until after you have had the procedure and are billed.
- phkahler 9y agoNext step is to make them actually charge those prices to all patients/insurers. It's not appropriate for insurers to pay less because they made a deal with the hospital. From TFA: It may still prove to be confusing to consumers, since standard rates are like list prices and don't reflect what insurers and government programs pay. Just because your insurance doesn't cover something doesn't mean they should make more money. This is one of the root problems driving healthcare costs. No deals for government or insurance companies. Post prices. Standard procedures should end up with lower pricing due to competition.
- sharemywin 9y agoHow much of my money are you willing to spend to save your own life? Read an article that talked about insurance companies providing tools to consumers about pricing, turns out they don't use them because people are price conscience when it comes to their current healthcare needs. And my guess they're probably too price/time conscience when it comes to preventive care. Aka, they would need to be compensated to stop eating cheeseburgers.
- xena 9y agoCheeseburgers are cheaper than healthy eating
- shaki-dora 9y agoPeople are mocking this policy here, but it’s obviously better than nothing. A large number of hospital procedures are likely planned, and can therefore be subject to comparison shopping. Giving birth is an obvious one. But even for many fractures there is a day or two before the procedure, and you could transfer. Maybe more importantly, public price information allows independent research into price disparities, and public shaming of the worst offenders. That’s data only insurance companies currently have access to.
- txcwpalpha 9y agoI don't really think it is "better than nothing", though. If we start 'publicly shaming' hospitals for high prices, then that will encourage hospitals to aim for low prices. That of course sounds great on its face, but my concern is that this is going to encourage hospitals to achieve lower prices through cost cutting, (aka cutting corners, in the industry where corners need to be cut the least: healthcare). Trying to rein in healthcare costs is great, but I fear that trying to do it by encouraging focus on narrow metrics like these could do more harm than good. Also, these publicly-available prices will be almost meaningless to the average person, as they are just 'list prices' and won't match what insurance or any individual actually pays.
- jamroom 9y ago"cutting corners" is part of the overall profitability picture for a health organization (or any large corporation) so literally _anywhere_ that corners could be cut is already happening.
- tibbon 9y agoIsn't pressuring them to lower prices (at least a bit) what the insurance companies do themselves?
- root_axis 9y agoNot really. It is much more common and much easier from a business operations perspective to simply increase premiums or deny coverage, especially because a lack of competition means that consumers will have to pay the premiums no matter what. If a price hike causes the premiums to become unaffordable the insurance company actually benefits because they no longer have to endure the cost of providing benefits but they get to keep all the money that was paid before raising the rate to a level that the consumer could no longer afford. This is in contrast to healthcare providers which have a much better negotiating position because they're the ones actually providing the service that the consumer actually wants for the money that they're paying, so trying to get them to lower prices ends up being a much more difficult and risky negotiation.
- mey 9y agoRemoving any of the information asymmetry in health care is useful. Providers in clinics usually don't know what procedures costs, especially with various insurance negotiations. This empowers patients and additionally medical providers themselves. It is a real conversation (in non-emergent situations) that should be happening with patients and providers about what the patient can afford. If you do not like that this exposes publicly the capitalist nature of US health care, then I encourage you to support a universal/government health care option, rather than trying to prove this information isn't helpful.
- snuxoll 9y agoHonestly the biggest pain in the ass when it comes to trying to price healthcare comes outside office visits. Want to go in for a surgical procedure? You think it's going to cost $X but it ends up costing $X+Y because some complication caused the operation to run 10-15 minutes over the estimated time and now you have an extra unit of time for the anesthesiologist getting billed. Price transparency is great, but office visits are basically the only thing you can estimate well upfront (there's five CPT codes for the visit, 99211-99215 and it's easy to estimate which one will apply based on whether it's a new/existing patient and the level of history/examination you anticipate requiring). I will stand by my belief that the only way to "fix" healthcare in our country is going full single-payer so citizens don't have to worry about whether they can afford to get treated or not.
- arethuza 9y agoA few years back my son got his tonsils taken out at a private hospital in the UK (my employer at the time provided it) - after the operation the anesthesiologist and apologized and said that due to a billing mistake I'd have to pay an additional amount directly and handed me a bill. Having read horror stories about medical billing in the US I was prepared for a shock. However the bill was for something like £4.50... :-)
- sjg007 9y agoGood. They also need to improve the appeal processes for private insurance and crack down on improper denials.
- BurningFrog 9y agoHere is an article about one of the few US hospitals with a fixed public price list: http://time.com/4649914/why-the-doctor-takes-only-cash/ http://time.com/4649914/why-the-doctor-takes-only-cash/
- xivzgrev 9y agoFinally the first good news from the Trump administration.
- dirtybirdnj 9y agoI went to the emergency room with a horrid ear infection because no local urgent cares were open and after I called the phone # on my insurance card thats what they told me to do. The receptionist literally, and I am using this word correctly, LITERALLY laughed in my face when I asked how much the visit that had just ended would cost. For me it's not about "shopping around" before I go to a hospital. Its having a transparent and up front bill for what services were rendered before I leave. It's preventing that shock unbelievable bill that shows up in the mail three months later, and giving the patient a chance to dispute fraudulent or excessive costs while they are still in the building. Hospital billing needs to be open and transparent. It's the most manipulative and predatory industry on the planet. If only the goal was to help people, it seems like the companies that own hospitals only care about shareholders.
- poulsbohemian 9y agoI had a similar situation about 5 years ago. Even though the hospital had my insurance info, they sent a bill / demand letter for the full amount anyway. Of course insurance eventually paid for most of it, and I was finally reimbursed by the hospital about six months later. This was from an "award winning" hospital in Oregon. Scum suckers.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoDo you remember what the actual cost of the visit ended up being?
- jehlakj 9y agoI’ve had similar experiences when I went for a checkup for the first time with my own insurance. I’ve been so used to knowing the prices beforehand through my young and feeble life, but everything about my initial visits felt abnormal. I’m here to pay for a service, but why aren’t they telling me anything about price? I’m aware of my copay but what about the original price? Okay, I should probably get an x-ray. Why the hell aren’t you mentioning the costs? I mean, I don’t have to get it either. I always feel so helpless whenever I go as if my decisions are more or less made for me. Transparency will not only help me decide, but give me options that weren’t visible in the first place.
- maxxxxx 9y agoWe will have to see how this will be implemented but I like that they acknowledge that price transparency is a big problem.
- koolba 9y ago> Hospitals are required to disclose prices publicly, but the latest change would put that information online in machine-readable format that can be easily processed by computers. This is great news and step zero on the long road to transparency in the voodoo that is USA medical billing. What would be really awesome is if someone can get non-Medicare versions of these prices and somehow marry that with the co-pay / co-insurance of common insurance plans to give people an idea of what they'd be on the hook for. At the moment nothing short of going through with the medical service and then taking a time machine will get you the true answer. And even then they can retroactively change it!
- joombaga 9y agoThis is exactly what my company's solution does! We get prices from multiple sources, one of them being claims data (which is basically your time machine).
- koolba 9y agoWhat's your company? (Your HN profile is empty). Shameless self-promotion is encouraged in this type of reply so don't be shy!
- shmerl 9y agoGood! It should have been done a long time ago.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- willart4food 9y agoI like this. Last year I went to my dermatologist for a routine check up and they frooze 1 mole on my leg: $ 600 for the visit $ 600 for freezing the mole
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoHm my GP does this, for a regular office visit fee?
- gm-conspiracy 9y agoNow the real question, what incentive did your dermatologist have to not freeze the mole? Even if it was perfectly healthy, why not freeze it anyway?
- pg_bot 9y agoWow, that would cover 2 years worth membership at the clinic I run. We charge $49 / month for unlimited visits, freezing the mole would've been around 10 bucks. You likely could have gotten a plane ticket, flown to our clinic, gotten the procedure, and flown back for less money
- ihodes 9y agoI'm curious to learn more about your clinic. Mind sharing any information?
- pkaye 9y ago>Hospitals are required to disclose prices publicly, but the latest change would put that information online in machine-readable format that can be easily processed by computers. Apparently the hospitals have already been required to do this but now it will be online. Also this number will only give the upper bound of the cost since it is considerably negotiated down. What good does it do if they say mending a broken bone costs up to $20k when in reality it is somewhere between 0-$20k depending on insurance and other factors.
- technologia 9y agoThis would be a halfway decent way to fight back a hospital's insane chargemaster.
- VikingCoder 9y agoThis is a terrible idea. Which is better, a CT Scan for $1000 or one for $10,000? You probably guessed the cheaper one, right? Thinking "all CT Scans are the same," right? I happen to know that's not remotely true, but it's easy to think that saving money on a test would make sense, right? Okay, now which is better, open-heart surgery for $20,000 or $200,000? That's a lot harder to answer, isn't it? You need to know the outcomes of those procedures at that facility, compared to other facilities, to have any possible way to judge them.
- pas 9y agoEven some price transparency is better than none.
- dudul 9y agoOutcomes of procedures are already public information. This is not the case for prices.
- VikingCoder 9y agoOutcomes of procedures _at a specific location_ are already public? Do tell.
- dudul 9y agoI don't know why I'm being downvoted. Hospitals are ranked and they do have outcomes of procedures available. For example, when my wife and I were looking into IVF, hospitals and medical centers were ranked based on their success rate for various procedures. And on the contrary, prices were not easily available without first going through a few interviews. Now, outcome data is probably not available for every single procedure.
- ictoan 9y agoThis is free market working correctly. Transparency is important. You should have information about the price AND outcome. It is not mutually exclusive.
- amluto 9y agoI would like to see a stronger law: Hospitals and doctors must post their price list online. Hospitals and doctors must disclose to each patient before any non-emergency service how much that service will cost. The disclosed cost must be consistent with the price list and must not depend on what insurance is involved. Hospitals and doctors must not give any non-charitable discount to anyone that lowers the total amount that they charge below the listed price. (With the possible exception of Medicare.) Hospitals and doctors must not attempt to collect more than the listed and disclosed price from any patient for any service. In other words, if a doctor is willing to see a patient with some particular insurance plan for $100 (split between the insurer and patient however the insurer sees fit), then that doctor cannot bill a patient $300 for the same service becaues they have a different insurer. Yes, a law like this would thoroughly invalidate the entire way that insurance contracts work right now in the US.
- eldavido 9y agoInteresting that many states have laws mandating this for auto care. I'm hoping we reach consensus soon that healthcare isn't somehow "special". It's just an industry, with incumbent interests, fighting to earn as much profit as possible, just like any other industry.
- hoschicz 9y agoWhat do you mean by „auto care“?
- RightMillennial 9y agoIn the U.S., "auto care" means automobile (car) maintenance. In other words, car repair shops must list or quote you a price before service.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lolsal 9y agoHow would doctors and hospitals account for complications or non-standard 'things' that come up during treatment? I don't think it's reasonable to try to document every outcome or potential action taken. It's easy for me to think "setting a cast on a broken arm should cost $X.", but having had it done before, there can be complications - existing fractures, location of fracture, skin conditions, etc. I absolutely would love things to be transparent, but I think healthcare is more like fixing software bugs than delivering well-scoped features. It's very hard to estimate anything beyond the most basic, superficial issues. Just to be totally clear, I want prices posted online. I'm just worried there would be asterisks next to everything and then they would be useless. Perhaps that's an opportunity for differentiation in hospitals: "broken bone - cast set: $X - all inclusive".
- davidw 9y agoAnecdote: along with the public health care system in Italy, there's a parallel, private system if you want something a bit fancier, or a bit faster for non-urgent things. One of the things that made me laugh was when I went through that to see a local ear-nose-throat doctor. I was able to call and ask for prices on the phone. In other words, along with covering everyone via the public system, Italy's private system is a better functioning market than the US system.
- testfoobar 9y agoHospital billing is incredibly murky. 1 - I'd imagine the price they will post is similar to an airline's full fare, refundable ticket price. The price actually paid is quite different and related to the negotiated rates with your insurer and your deductible. 2 - Hospital billing is often separated from physician billing. Does price transparency extend to all physician groups? 3 - Patients care about total out of pocket expense. How much is it going to cost me? Hospitals can't know this because they are not privy to your health plan structure/details - they only know their negotiated rates. Your health plan doesn't know it, because it hasn't received the full details of your treatment.
- moistoreos 9y agoStill have to change consumers of health care to have a consumer mentality for health care. Whatever the age, you really should actually shop around for non-emergency medical procedures. This is one area you can really save money because a lot of places are severely overcharging for simple procedures. Call the facility, get a quote (they will probably have to do a bunch of work on their end), document quoted price (if I were to do this I would probably have the hospital email me a document), and don't pay more than the agreed upon price. Receiving non-emergency medical care should be like shopping for cars, pizza, iPads, houses, etc. So, yeah, start doing that. Be the change you want to see.
- ppeetteerr 9y agoWho wants to start the Uber for ambulances? It will have a list of prices for the nearest hospitals and drop you off where the costs are cheapest and the waiting times the shortest? (I'm a mobile/backend dev B) )
- dominotw 9y agoWaiting time depends on the type of emergency you have, its not a single number for everyone.
- zavi 9y agoStart it in San Francisco and Board of Supervisors will immediately shut it down.
- dragonwriter 9y agoAmbulance services are generally extremely tightly regulated, and often exclusive area contracts. You probably couldn't operate an ambulance company with the policy you describe in most places, and you certainly couldn't legally do an Uber-style middleman service with independent ambulances that used that policy. And, unlike taxi laws, the laws on operating thingd that pretend to be legally-mandated emergency vehicles are going to be vigorously enforced.
- ppeetteerr 9y agoI'm hearing a lot of reasons why it couldn't work. Uber broke all the laws yet here we are.
- jihoon796 9y agoI've worked in medical finance as a consultant, and a huge problem that I've seen is that although private insurance was originally intended to encourage competition, it has made prices much more complicated and opaque for the end consumer (patient). Generally speaking, each hospital/practice/clinical lab has to negotiate with individual insurance companies to get reimbursed at a given rate minus "contractual adjustments" - this negotiation process is highly inefficient, given that each payer may do things differently (a contract with BCBS of NC may be different than one with Florida Blue), and smaller providers simply don't have the bandwidth or resources to have any leverage in this process. The complexity of this ecosystem only hurts consumers and providers (and helps the payers, of course), and although many insurance entities call themselves "non-profit", I seriously question their motives. It's almost reminiscent of the era leading up to the financial crisis of 2008, where complex derivatives, mortgage-backed securities, and other overly sophisticated financial instruments made those that worked in the industry fantastically wealthy, while the common people were left holding the bag when the stock market finally plummeted. I hope we can find ways to simplify this system - the single payer system, for all of its flaws, seems like a step forward in the right direction.
- matz1 9y agoWhy hospital even need to negotiate with insurance company? Can't they just set the price they deem reasonable and then let the patient and insurance to work out the payment within themselves .
- djrogers 9y agoIt works that way for 'out of network' facilities and doctors, and there are higher deductibles and lower limits on payouts for those as the insurance copany has no fiscal control. The negotiations happen for 'in network' systems, and it's in the hospital's interests to be 'in network' for as many insurance companies as possible, as most people choose 'in network' care providers.
- jihoon796 9y agoYes, this is also true.
- OliverJones 9y agoMedicare reimbursement is generally fixed price based on diagnosis (DRG == diagnostic related groups) Table 5 here shows a "weight" . That's the number of units of reimbursement a hospital gets for each particular diagnosis / procedure / whatever. (LOS is length of stay) (CC is complications) (MCC is major complications) https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Medicare-Fee-for-Service-Payment/AcuteInpatientPPS/FY2018-IPPS-Final-Rule-Home-Page-Items/FY2018-IPPS-Final-Rule-Tables.html https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Medicare-Fee-for-Service-Paymen... Hospitals negotiate with CMS the number of dollars per unit of weight. Sometimes aggressively. It would be good to have that number of dollars posted publicly and explained. Does the hospital hate serving Medicare patients because they don't make enough?
- hackerews 9y agoThis would take effect in 2019 if passed.
- jadedhacker 9y agoUseless. Consumers don't care about how much something costs when it's life or death and they may not even know enough to understand what price they should be looking for. Medicare must have the power to negotiate prices for the benefit of the population full stop. Also, medical service must be free at the point of service for all US residents to ensure everyone gets essential care and preventative care. Here's the healthcare plan we should have: https://medicareforall.dsausa.org/ https://medicareforall.dsausa.org/
- conanbatt 9y agoMultiple the medicare spending for the amount of population it serves and rejoice in a 40% GDP spending on healthcare.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Multiple the medicare spending for the amount of population it serves and rejoice in a 40% GDP spending on healthcare. Don't forget to account for the fact that Medicare's reimbursement rates are not self-sufficient - they're implicitly subsidized by private insurers. So it's actually much higher than that.
- conanbatt 9y agoThat effect goes both ways: medicare gets patients that are old and have more expensive and chronic diseases, thus their spending per service might be very efficient. Which leans on which is hard to know without some rigorous analysis.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> That effect goes both ways: medicare gets patients that are old and have more expensive and chronic diseases, thus their spending per service might be very efficient. It doesn't really matter, if they're reimbursing below COGS (which they are). If the expected value of a set of numbers is negative, you can't make it positive by adding a bunch of other numbers which are also negative (even if they might be closer to zero, which in this case they oftentimes are not).
- CoffeeDregs 9y agoThis is great. Article in The Atlantic back in 2009: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/09/how-american-health-care-killed-my-father/307617/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/09/how-ame... My mother-in-law died of brain cancer over the course of about five days. We received a "Statement of Benefits". She received ~$130,000 of care. Medicare paid ~$30,000. That's bullshit. Per James Fallows' article, medical price transparency is CRITICAL. You can't improve something if you can't see it and can't measure it until after you experience it. I'm an anti-Trump (and anti-Republican) Republican but I have to admit that, with this Medicare transparency action, sometimes this administration takes surprisingly sensible actions.
- iooi 9y agoWere you responsible for that debt? Why did Medicare cover so little?
- CoffeeDregs 9y agoGreat question. We were not responsible for the difference. The "Statement of Benefits" is a very confusing US healthcare tradition in which you're told how much you should have paid before being told what you owe. In our case, there was a corresponding "Medicare discount" (or something; it's been 8 years) and the final bill was $0. The situation is terribly regressive: people with the least money and the least likely to be able to afford healthcare and are therefore most likely to suffer high hospital costs. People with the most money get healthcare "insurance" and so get the lowest prices.
- arca_vorago 9y agoI don't want just prices, I want to know actual costs and then the prices, and breakdown of what goes where.
- brettproctor 9y agoUnderstanding the root cause of how our healthcare system developed is both crucial and completely lacking from most of these discussions. It is a tale of federally mandated wage control and specialized tax breaks. A quick google will show many articles outlining how we got here. Why is car insurance not tied to employers? In general how much better does car insurance work than health? Are the prices not much more straightforward and is it easy to shop around? If you are treated poorly by your car insurance company, can you easily tell all your friends and change companies? This is the real problem here. Most folks have no choice and no skin in the game, which leads to all these crazy stories about zero pricing information and no ability to change companies. If the tax breaks simply got removed, and people had to actually pay directly for their insurance and could switch companies, the vast majority of these problems would go away.
- custos 9y agoCar insurance is not comparable to health insurance. It's apples to oranges. Car insurance reduces risk, by exchanging the cost of an unpredictable potentially costly event (an accident) for a regular much reduced cost event (monthly payment). The benefit is predictable expenses and budget. Health insurance only works this way for the healthy. For the chronically ill, it's flat out cost reduction to have it and a profit loss for the insurer. My insurance pays out more than I pay into it every year. I had one year it paid out ~$250k. Unless we stop mandating care for the sick unable to pay for it, healthcare is socialized; it's just a matter of how efficiently socialized it is. Insurance companies overcharge the healthy to make up for their losses with the chronically ill, and hospitals overcharge those who can pay to make up for their losses with those who can't. Really just need to cut out the middle men.
- 49bc 9y agoEven if it was just “this is the cash price for item X” this would be a huge benefit for he consumer.
- rb808 9y agoThe next interesting question. Say you needed some surgery, would you choose the cheapest one or the most expensive one?
- notadoc 9y agoSingapore does this. Their health care costs are significantly lower than the USA.
- enknamel 9y agoI never understood why doctors, hospitals, etc never do this. They know their prices but they never want to let you know until too late. Heck doctors have often told me they take my insurance then say "woops you gotta pay me cash!". Medical billing needs some serious fixing or consumer protections.
- notabee 9y agoCurrent U.S. healthcare: NIH syndrome writ large.
- bwb 9y agoThe big question is which set of prices IMO...
- wdn 9y agoThis is a step in the right direction. I hope they push all medical services and drugs to publilsh their prices. This way, customers can have the option to pay cash or go through insurance.
- smilbandit 9y agoWill hospitals decide to just not take medicare any longer?
- intrasight 9y agoGreat read on this topic https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/09/how-american-health-care-killed-my-father/307617/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/09/how-ame... And his book of course
- michaelmrose 9y agoHow about we take this a step further and require hospitals to have one price for each service to all comers. Then we can trivially pick a plan independently of backroom deals that are impossible to evaluate ahead of time and easily pick the provider that provides the combination of service and price.
- late2part 9y agoHotels are required in most jurisdictions to post their rack rate for hotel rooms. Look on the inside of your hotel room next time, you'll find the rack rate is usually 4X what you actually pay. You'll find they comply with this, just like California Prop 65. They'll continue to give discounts just like Rockefeller gave rebates and subsidies.
- SemiTom 9y agohow about taking it one step further and aggregate the database of all hospital prices so we can filter and compare. better yet, single payer system overall
- delinka 9y agoFeels like a step in the right direction. But we've already got geographic monopolies in many cases - you can't just decide to go ten more miles in an emergency because you know the prices are 15% lower. However, if a new hospital opens close-ish to an existing one, offers a temporary discount, then the two just keep an eye on each other's websites to maintain the status quo in pricing will offering "competition," now we have a duopoly. Capitalism will find a way to keep screwing consumers.
- doggydogs94 9y agoI wonder what will happen when an important hospital opts out of Medicare over this?
- zavi 9y agoIt's not going to happen, hospitals mostly get revenue from Medicare/Medicaid.
- throwaway84742 9y agoI’m in favor of this, and not just for Medicare. Medicare pricing is extremely low because doctors can’t turn down Medicare patients. Medicare pays like $8 for a physician visit, which is, quite obviously, not sustainable for the physician. I want to be able to comparison shop at the very least for routine stuff that’s not customized patient to patient: yearly physical, blood tests, chronic disease care, etc. Combined with ratings this should reduce the current extreme information imbalance and drive the prices down.
- King-Aaron 9y agoThis discussion makes me appreciate the healthcare system here in Australia much more.