20 ms·
My Sony "smart" TV has updated itself and tried to force me to use a new app
- nathanaldensr 9y agoThe meme of "if you're not paying, you are the product" is, of course, true, but it doesn't acknowledge the host of cases when you are the product even if you're paying. This guy basically paid to be spied on.
- kartickv 9y agoWhich is why this meme is a half-truth. Other examples include old-world companies like magazines and banks selling our data despite us paying for the service. Even in areas other than privacy, my bank mistreats me far worse than Internet companies like Google and Twitter. Not to mention that in a multi-sided ecosystem, Internet companies need to keep both users and advertisers happy, so even if you're not paying, your desires still factor into the decision. To be clear, I didn't say this meme is a lie, just that it's a half-truth. It makes sense to some extent.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agomy bank mistreats me far worse than Internet companies like Google and Twitter Oh boy is this true, I'm on my fourth bank for my UK business and they have all been appalling. I'm not very happy with the current one but have given up on the idea that any other might be better.
- devmunchies 9y agoMy bank (US Bank) had a Facebook script behind the login wall and was firing requests to Facebook while I was doing private banking.
- knuththetruth 9y agoYou should write it up in a blog post or something. Given the climate around Facebook right now, it’s not inconceivable that it could get enough attention that your bank stops doing this.
- sizzle 9y agoPlease write this up and share it on HN.
- josu 9y ago>"if you're not paying, you are the product" Read it again, you are falling in a logical fallacy. The phrase is only saying that "if you are not paying", it doesn't make any claims to what happens when you are paying.
- svckr 9y agoI'm fairly certain the smart features are what's subsidizing current TVs and making them relatively cheap. Last time I checked dumb TVs were reserved for the more high end part of the maker's lineup (if at all available). So, yes, you're still paying, but you get a price cut in exchange for being … productized?
- jmilloy 9y agoAnd in particular, I suspect this is why smart TVs are often cheaper or the same price as the equivalent non-smart (?) TV.
- babalulu 9y agoI bought a 32-inch dumb TV just a couple of weeks ago. It was only $77US, on clearance at Walmart from $129US. The brand is Element, which I'm unfamiliar with, but it works nicely and has absolutely no smart capabilities. So you can find dumb TVs on the low end these days if you look for them.
- na85 9y agoDoes it support 4k?
- EpicEng 9y agoThis one? https://www.walmart.com/ip/Element-ELEFW328-32-720p-60Hz-Class-LED-HDTV/33844084 https://www.walmart.com/ip/Element-ELEFW328-32-720p-60Hz-Cla... So, a small, 720p TV? In other words, a TV most people don't want? I fail to see how that's an alternative when I'm looking for a 60" 4K model, not to mention I have no idea what the quality of the device will be.
- y4mi 9y agoIve heard great things about swedx, never had one myself however. Theyre also not IPS/HDR. Also, its important to use the pixel policy 1, there are some dead pixels otherwise. http://swedx.se/index.php?cPath=133_149&language=en http://swedx.se/index.php?cPath=133_149&language=en
- remir 9y agoFirst day I used my Pixel 2 XL I saw ads in the Gmail app. I mean, this is not some $100 phone. I paid 1k for it and Google still showed me ads in Gmail.
- Tyr42 9y agoOn the other hand, if there was special code running in the Gmail app to detect if you're on a google phone and behave differently, would you also be annoyed?
- necubi 9y agoThe ads are there because you're using gmail the service, not because you're using gmail the app. If you use "gmail the app" with your own imap server or a paid google apps account, you will not see ads.
- iliketosleep 9y ago> This information is then used to market to you within the TV and offer you a "hot list"... but it is also used to "Detect, investigate and prevent fraudulent transactions and other illegal activities and protect the rights, safety and property of Samba and others" This app pushes ads and tries to protect everybody except the user!
- gcb0 9y agoto be honest, sony have a track record of doing this. bought a music CD or games? get a rootkit. if you still buy sony products, I can't be sory for you.
- rectang 9y ago> if you still buy sony products, I can't be sory for you. Such condescension towards those not in the know, even though they are likely allies or soon will be, is pernicious and self-defeating.
- appleflaxen 9y agoI read the condescension as being toward those who /are/ in the know, yet still buy Sony products.
- babygoat 9y agoIt's condescending to anyone who buys Sony products.
- nip 9y agoAny good tv recommendation, if not Sony?
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoNot Samsung. I've been reasonably happy with my Panasonic.
- gcb0 9y agopanasonic has a good middle ground on quality (hardly hear about bad panels, dead pixel, different from LG), new tech (only brand to have plasma and oled early on), and price.
- petepete 9y agoPanasonic Viera TVs used to have adverts in the EPG. It's an industry-wide shitshow http://gonedigital.net/wp-content/uploads/PanasonicEPG.jpg http://gonedigital.net/wp-content/uploads/PanasonicEPG.jpg
- paulie_a 9y agoThis sort of crap makes me think a manufacturer should brand a dumb tv, and simply market: "it's just a high end tv without all the crap we know you hate and dont use anyways, also the CIA can't hack it" https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/25/15421326/smart-tv-hacking-cia-samsung-weeping-angel-vulnerability https://www.theverge.com/2017/4/25/15421326/smart-tv-hacking...
- Waterluvian 9y agoI am quite angry that my PS4 is full of ads. I paid money for that box. What I want is a law that requires a product to clearly indicate if it has ads or not in the software, and it cannot change at any point in the product's life. So I know what the price tag actually is. Edit: I want to be clear. I am not against advertising or the freedom for a manufacturer to decide that advertising is their business model. What I want is to protect consumers who pay for a product that slowly devolves into an advertising box. I am also not expecting my rush-designed law to prevent ads or give consumers more options. All it would do is make it clear to consumers what they're paying for. Advertising is just another form of payment. Imagine if you bought a smart fridge and 3 years in it required a subscription to use the "smart" part of it. You would be furious.
- nol13 9y agoPretty much my only gripe with roku.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sz4kerto 9y agoThe money you paid for your PS4 barely covers manufacturing costs.
- falcolas 9y agoAnd that's our problem... how? Sony makes money off every video game sale; attempting to get more from ads is just greedy. And how they present the ads as another game a very dark pattern.
- chrischen 9y agoNetflix also tracks what you watch, most likely where as well (since the app is on so many devices).
- mr_toad 9y agoI doubt they sell it to third parties, and they don’t do third party advertising.
- madez 9y agoIf this happens under EU jurisdiction, then you can deny the update and legally demand that the TV continues working. The manufacturer may not impose new rules after the selling contract. Fuck this wild-west anarchistic behaviour of software companies. When we have legal protection, we can make use of it.
- solidangle 9y agoAlso have a Sony Smart TV, and I live in the EU. After updating the TV, it asked me whether I wanted to enable Samba, and I simply declined. Seems to be disabled now.
- jake_the_third 9y agoUnfortunetly, it seems that the TV will still contact Samba.tv's servers regardless: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16728720 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16728720 The only way to be sure with untrustworthy devices like this is not to connect them to the network at all (i.e. use a separate device you can trust instead), or better yet, buy a dumb monitor instead.
- simion314 9y agoI hope EU will push more laws, when you buy hardware like a smatphone,TV,PC all the extra crap on top should be opt-in not opt-out, I bought an ASUS cheap smartphone(new, unlocked no carrier contracts) and it has extra apps on top of the basic Android that I can only disable and not remove. At startup there should be a prompt with suggested apps that they want the user to install, if the user selects an app to install it(after reading the description) then pull that app from the store.
- rapnie 9y agoyou might like eelo.io and there are others in the works that are open-source and privacy-focused, but eelo looks promising :)
- username223 9y ago> Ideally you run a TV on a different VLAN. Are these the depths to which we have sunk? I remember when a television was a thing that showed moving images using a cathode ray tube. The switch to liquid crystal displays was a genuine technological improvement. Now we need to treat our televisions as hostile surveillance devices because "ad tech" runs the world? I can't wait until our robot taxis drive diabetics to Krispy Kreme, then to Bob's Dialysis Center.
- sparkling 9y agoThis is the problem with putting logic into the TV. Keep it Unix-y. Do one thing, but do it right. A TV should be just a panel, nothing more. A $50 player box does everything better than the built-in player hardware and software.
- tome 9y ago> A TV should be just a panel, nothing more. Don't we have such things, called "monitors"?
- squarefoot 9y agoYup, that would be the ideal solution, but their prices skyrocket as soon as one goes above the "normal" office/gamer panel sizes. They're also probably built using better parts and better quality control. Economies of scale do the rest.
- greenleafjacob 9y agoTVs are monitors that are large, for more distant viewing.
- raziel2p 9y agoI looked at monitors 35" and larger and the cheapest I could find are at least twice as expensive as the corresponding TVs. Maybe it's just a marketing thing but there are definitely differences which make monitors a hard sell to be used in place of TVs (e.g. in a living room, opposite to the sofa).
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoNot readily available in the sizes popularly used for TV/video viewing, as far as I can tell. Large-format monitors tend to be full of "digital signage" or touchscreen features now; some are even Android-based.
- tome 9y agoTo respond to all my respondents: perhaps we should all be using projectors for TV then :)
- natch 9y agoLooks like they have nepotism on the executive team, too. Sketchy.
- dapearce 9y agoFamily members co-founding a company isn't nepotism.
- natch 9y agoFamily members co-founding a company is a perfectly natural thing that sometimes happens, but that doesn't magically make it not nepotism, and a setup that over time will cause problems. It creates a company where anyone below knows that the opportunities for upward mobility are severely curtailed by the family interests that generally override company needs when push comes to shove.
- Adirael 9y agoSince there doesn't exist a good panel without Smart TV capabilities, what I do is just don't give them access to the network. Everything runs through an Android Box connected to an HDMI or a PS4 when I want to use Netflix (I never managed to make it work on the Android box)
- navaati 9y ago> Since there doesn't exist a good panel without Smart TV capabilities Have a look at the Dell P4317Q, decent 4k 43" screen, less than 1k€. I use it as a TV, very satisfied (and since it's got no tuner, I get to avoid the Irish TV tax (but IANAL) !) Only caveat is no HDMI 2.0, you can only get 4k@60hz via DisplayPort so not fully compatible with ChromeCast 4k for example.
- anonymousab 9y agoEventually they'll just ship with some sort of connectivity out of the box. If consumers are 'lucky' it will surface as something they can use. But the bare minimum of a persistent connection to load you ads and track your usage seems inevitable.
- nv-vn 9y agoAT&T does this on their Android phones pretty frequently. Missed my alarm the other day because they decided to push an update overnight and you need to input a password to boot into your phone after it restarts. I'm just waiting till the high profile lawsuit where someone can't call 9/11 because AT&T just forcibly turned their phone off.
- cletus 9y agoJust don’t plug your “smart” TV into the internet and all these problems go away. Seriously. Get a Roku or similar for any services you want.
- butterfi 9y agoI have a Samsung TV with built in apps and a suspicious privacy policy, so I plugged in a Roku and never use the built in apps.
- bilbo0s 9y agoI thought about this but I discovered that my Roku has the same things going on behind the scenes with respect to data "visibility", or, "sharing". What they need to do is just to make the panel with no network features. I ended up simply disconnecting the tv panel from the net work and using a small pc to get to netflix. Crude, but effective.
- mhb 9y agoRoku: Part I. Information Collection A. Information you provide Information you provide Roku through the Roku Services includes, for example, your name, email address, postal address, billing and shipping information, telephone number, product purchase information, credit card and other payment data, product registration information, and demographics. If you connect with Roku’s accounts on third party social networking sites, we may also collect information about your social networking accounts, for example, your name, user name, or handle. We also collect the personal information of other people, for example, if you provide email addresses of friends for referrals or postal addresses of recipients for gift purchases. We may also combine information you provide with data we collect automatically (as further described in Section I-B below) and with data we receive from third parties. We may also associate information you provide with information we collect about you from different devices, browsers and platforms. B. Information we collect automatically 1. Roku Site data We may automatically collect information related to your use of Roku Sites - for example, we collect your computer’s or mobile device’s operating system type and version, Internet Protocol (IP) address, mobile device ID, access times, browser type and language, and the websites you visited before coming to a Roku Site. We also use cookies and related technologies such as web beacons to better understand your needs, remember your preferences, and to provide targeted advertising. For more information on how we and others use cookies and related technologies on Roku Sites, please click here to review the Roku Cookies Policy. 2. Roku Device data We regularly and automatically collect information about your Roku Devices and your usage. The collected information includes, for example, the IP address associated with your Roku Devices, your device types and models, device identifiers (including RIDAs as described in Section II-B-2 below), the retailer to whom your Roku Device was shipped, various quality measures, error logs, software version numbers, Wi-Fi network name (SSID – service set identifier) and strength, and information about other devices connected to your Roku Device. We also collect usage data such as your search history (including letters you key in for searches, and utterances provided if you choose to use voice search (if available on your Roku Device)), search results, content and advertisements you select and view, including through use of automatic content recognition technology (ACR) (see “Smart TV Experience and ACR on Roku TVs” (Section I-B-4) and “Choices regarding Smart TV Experience and ACR on Roku TVs” (Section IV-E), below), and content settings and preferences, channels you add and view, including time and duration in the channels, and other usage statistics. https://docs.roku.com/doc/userprivacypolicy/en-us https://docs.roku.com/doc/userprivacypolicy/en-us
- gambiting 9y agoYep, I used to use the Netflix app on my Sony TV (bravia W8) but after an update couple months ago it stopped working completely, Netflix just closes when I try to play anything. I actually have completely changed my opinion on OTA updates over the last few years - I don't want any updates. I want the software my phone/TV/car shipped with and I don't want to to change for the sake of updating, it's universally more pain than it's worth.
- isoprophlex 9y agoThis is, sadly, nothing new. See [0], Samsung also did something like this in 2016. I was affected by this, I'm never getting a Samsung TV ever again. [0] http://adage.com/article/digital/samsung-smart-tv-update-forces-ads/307246/ http://adage.com/article/digital/samsung-smart-tv-update-for...
- paulie_a 9y agoI don't get why Samsung bothers too make great products that have shitty software. My refrigerator shouldn't need to reboot. Or at one point get into an endless reboot cycle. This "smart" but mediocre age needs to go away
- josephg 9y agoI've been looking at getting a new washing machine lately. One of the "hot new features" some new washing machines have is the ability to "download new washing programs via our app!". Really? The 40+ different pre-programmed wash cycle options aren't enough and you expect to think of new washing machine routines over the next year or two? Its like ... DLC but for washing my clothes. Who thinks this is a good idea? I wonder how much of that functionality will still work in 10-15 years when the machine is getting long in the tooth. I can't wait for botnets made up of old internet connected washing machines. You know its just a matter of time before some Russian teenager takes down github using your grandma's washing machine.
- kungtotte 9y agoYou think botnets don't already include all these smart devices? We recently bought a new fridge and freezer with that functionality but there's no way they are getting hooked up to any network.
- paulie_a 9y agoYou can apparently request the source code for many of those devices. Ive done it for my Samsung fridge and got a reasonable response. I scanned the code and don't find any egregious problems like hard coded passwords but I just assume the codebase is a complete shit show with flaws. I will not connect those devices to my wifi.
- djrogers 9y ago> Ideally you run a TV on a different VLAN. Why let it ‘run’ on your network or the internet at all? I’ve never connected my newest TV to my WiFi, and can’t ever foresee a reason to do so. All of the apps I want are running on a connected box I trust to maintain a degree of privacy that I’d never assume from Sony, Samsung, or the like. It’s not as if Netflix or Hulu actually force you to use the embedded TV apps.
- nickhalfasleep 9y agoI plug my "smart" TV into ethernet now and then to get firmware updates, then unplug it the rest of the time.
- Filligree 9y agoAre the updates needed? Was anything broken?
- baq 9y agoIf you ever read some av forums, you'll find that modern TVs are about as reliable as modern computers, i.e. it's amazing they even turn on when requested. Features are DOA for new lines and need multiple updates to be useful, sometimes they're completely disabled and only get enabled after a year, e.g. Dolby Vision on 2017s Sonys.
- roywiggins 9y agoMy parents' TV has an incredible anti-feature where, if the video gets dark enough, the whole screen dims temporarily. There's no firmware update for it so they've just lived with it for years.
- wvenable 9y agoWhy do you need firmware updates for a TV not connected?
- 9y ago
- makecheck 9y agoMy parents’ TV has various apps built in and one of them is Skype. They discontinued the Skype service so now every single time the TV turns on it displays a stupid error message about “a problem with an app” that can’t be uninstalled and that they never used. Smart TVs are full of stuff like this. They need to go.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoThat's why I went with Roku TV. They are the only platform with a consistent track record of supporting old hardware. You also don't suffer from the single vendor lock-in of Tizen or WebOS or the wild west of Android.
- scarface74 9y agoif you are going to get a smart TV, definitely get a Roku TV. While the interface for controlling the settings is much better than any other TV, the remote app is nice and the private listening is awesome, the hardware is slower than AppleTV 4K, and it doesn't handle fast forward and rewind as well. The right half of the home screen is used for ads and the remote buttons for quickly going to other channels isn't customizable and you are stuck with whatever provider paid Roku for placement. We have two Roku TVs and two other TVs with Roku sticks. We also have AppleTvs connected to each of the TVs - one 4K ATV and the rest 3rd Gen ATVs.
- Crespyl 9y agoThe ads are obnoxious and the way every "app"/service implements their own interface with quirky behavior (Does the "up" button show the timeline, pause, or take you back out to the episode/series selection screen?) is annoying. Fortunately it's possible to fix the ads at least by blocking doubleclick and the roku ad/tracking domain at the router level. Doing this leaves a blank "empty poster" graphic instead of an ad, but doesn't seem to break anything else. Updates, search, and content all continue to work fine.
- MrBuddyCasino 9y agoThe software in „smart“ TVs is awful. Always been, always will be. Don’t use it. You could try and find a dumb panel, but you could also simply not use it. Get an AppleTV or whatever, plug it in, problem solved.
- bsenftner 9y agoI just picked up a 55" TV, and the troubles I had explaining I did not want any "Smart" features was like explaining to morons that smoking is bad for you. The store had no commission on the sale, but the sales people, all of them, could not understand why I'd not want TV apps and Internet.
- dijit 9y agoSame story, but one more caveat: When I'm playing a game a nice "Youtube encountered an error and needs to be close [ok] [report]" dialog pops up in the dead center of the screen. Why is youtube running? Apparently the TV is an Android base, but I have no information on how to flash it because if I could turn it into something not Sony produced I'd be a lot happier. -- Another annoyance is that it /really/ wants me to use speech to text in everything, but the TV has (thankfully) no mic.... Why!?
- spacehome 9y agoYou think it has no mic.
- Merad 9y agoIs it even possible to buy a non-smart TV today (not counting PC monitors)? I bought my TV in 2015 and even then it seemed like most of the non-smart options were overpriced older models with worse image quality, etc.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoYou have to get commercial or hospitality versions made for hotels.
- Sharlin 9y agoAren’t hotel TVs pretty much all smart these days? Honestly, it even makes sense as you can use it as a media center (Spotify etc), movie ”channels” are easier to implement etc.
- Zigurd 9y agoThis is an example of a strategic bind: Google wants Android to be "cleaner," to better compete with Apple. This means no underhanded service modules or system extensions, and no intrusive or otherwise low quality privileged apps. Android phones are inexpensive because Google doesn't make money directly from licensing the OS. Barriers to entry are low, competition is fierce, and hardware differentiation is only possible at the high end (e.g. vertically integrated OEMs like Samsung). This means at the high end Samsung's product managers won't give up making Samsung phone differentiated through things like Bixby, which is a value-subtracted wart on Android, and at the low end, cheap OEMs won't stop taking payments from app makers who monetize by collecting user data. Google has the power to reject OEM products that violate whatever standards Google chooses to impose on OEMs, but, as Microsoft learned decades ago, standing between a low margin OEM and a few extra dollars per unit is a difficult position. Once a product ships, policing updates is even harder. If you are wondering "Why can't I get a 'clean' TV, phone, PC, etc?" This is why.
- gruez 9y ago>as Microsoft learned decades ago, standing between a low margin OEM and a few extra dollars per unit is a difficult position. Once a product ships, policing updates is even harder. What is this about? Afaik windows (desktop) and windows phone all get 5+ years of patches.
- mprev 9y agoPresumably, it’s about all the junk that OEMs install on Windows in exchange for a few cents or dollars per machine.
- diafygi 9y ago> From their own privacy policy: https://samba.tv/legal/privacy-policy/ https://samba.tv/legal/privacy-policy/ they track what you watch, when you watch it, your location, your interactions with other apps. And they share this with... well, everyone basically. I wonder how the GDPR will affect companies like Samba's business model. Also, isn't this effectively true of all internet connected TVs since they will never receive security patches and become part of the botnet of things?
- Sharlin 9y agoGDPR will hopefully make companies that do things like this really sweat. The EU doesn’t seem to be fucking around with that one.
- fipple 9y agoGDPR only increases engineering and compliance costs. It doesn’t have any consumer-side impact since to a first approximation, zero consumers take advantage of data privacy laws.
- notimetorelax 9y agoOne significant advantage that comes with GDPR is the fact that users will be able to opt-out from any tracking that is not required for the service to function.
- jacquesm 9y agoIt's much better than that, it is explicit and specific (as in with purpose) opt in and the defaults are to be 'off' (see section 4.11).
- IshKebab 9y agoThat's not true. GDPR means you have to have explicit, clear consent for many things. It can't be hidden behind "you agree to our updated terms and conditions, click (here) for details" type things. Also it much be easy to opt out.
- buro9 9y agoI'm the author and linking to my tweets is a bad idea because they auto-delete after 14 days. For future HN context, as the author I'm reproducing them here in full: My @Sony "smart" TV has updated itself and tried to force me to use a new app from https://samba.tv https://samba.tv and boy oh boy... this is worse than recent @facebook stuff. From their own privacy policy: https://samba.tv/legal/privacy-policy/ https://samba.tv/legal/privacy-policy/ … they track what you watch, when you watch it, your location, your interactions with other apps. And they share this with... well, everyone basically. This information is then used to market to you within the TV and offer you a "hot list"... but it is also used to "Detect, investigate and prevent fraudulent transactions and other illegal activities and protect the rights, safety and property of Samba and others" If you have a "Smart TV" from any brand and it's doing an update you will 100% want to disable Samba. Samba is not a feature for you, it is a snitch in your living room, snitching on everything you watch on your TV, it's a feature for corporations only. To disable Samba the soft way... don't agree to their T&Cs post OS upgrade. To disable Samba the hard way... use Android system settings to disable the app. This is a good time to say that if you own a "Smart TV" from any company you should run it on a different network than your NAS and other computers. And that all other devices best require passwords to connect to them. Ideally you run a TV on a different VLAN. And this is where I wish that dumb panels were all the rage, and that the only "smart" functionality was external to the display itself. But when @netflix and other content providers decline the use of their apps outside of integrated devices this is the hell we live in. I really wish that @Google provided a TV box that was the full Android TV, but that was vanilla Google with the ability to install @netflix, @BBCiPlayer, @mubi as apps. That I could just plug this into any display panel, including dumb displays. Perhaps @Google could even call it Pixel TV.
- buro9 9y agoHN replying to myself with some context outside of the tweets. I actually trust stock Android over Samsung, Sony, etc Android. Hence my "if we're going to have Android TV perhaps Google could supply it without the forced add-ons". I see this similar to installing Windows yourself rather than having "Windows with added vendor crap"... like if you know you want Windows, a stock one is better and same with Android. I'm now looking at purchasing the Nvidia Shield and disabling all network connectivity on my Sony TV. The Sony TV is a recent one, about a year old. A Bravia something or other. I have disabled the Samba app using the Android Apps system. One thing I didn't include in the tweets was Samba's patent list, because it's too deep a topic for Twitter. The patent numbers are on their site though... go take a look: https://samba.tv/legal/patents/ https://samba.tv/legal/patents/ Some of those are downright scary and have no positive application for privacy conscious users. Feel free to ask anything.
- kristianc 9y agoSlightly odd that the final tweet for the OP is a wish for Google to release a Pixel TV. I'm sure a Google TV wouldn't spy on you at all.
- andybak 9y agoI can see OPs point. I'm slightly less concerned about Google than some scrappy little upstart still trying the "growth at any cost" thing. I actually will probably trust Facebook again once they have been suitably thrashed over past deeds and have had time to reflect on what went wrong. Both companies will eventually become privacy conscious by necessity and have the resources (hopefully) to enforce it internally. If they don't then the next revelation or the one after that might be their death knell.
- kristianc 9y agoIt's ironic that "growth at any cost" is now being used as a stick to beat scrappy little upstarts with - when that is literally Facebook's phrase. What Facebook and Google lose in (pretty much entirely self-imposed, for now) regulations, they gain in the ability to index against all of your other activity, everywhere. The scrappy startup has only one data point on you, and has to work with others to make it useful (which, with GDPR will be a lot harder to do).
- squarefoot 9y ago"I really wish that @Google provided a TV box that was the full Android TV, but that was vanilla Google with the ability to install @netflix, @BBCiPlayer, @mubi as apps. That I could just plug this into any display panel, including dumb displays." He is basically asking to be spied in a different way, just like his cellphone does.
- jcousins 9y agoI was bamboozled by that comment. Out of the frying pan....
- lotyrin 9y agoWhile I'd love the option not to be spied on, If I don't have that option, I'd rather the spies be fewer and more competent. The doomsday scenario is if we have tons of little pop-up 3rd party data collectors that fail at infosec and produce datasets that become public knowledge via leaks and can be cross-referenced for all eternity.
- CyberDildonics 9y agoReliable internet basically turned tech companies into giant bait and switch factories. Things get swapped out from under you at will to force you to use certain apps, sign up for certain services, give over whatever data they want. Look at Microsoft switching out their terms of service for skype, xbox live, office, etc. Windows updates are more of the same. Cell phone apps are a prime target since they basically give a direct line to update whatever software a company wants on to your phone, now that you have invested in setting up and getting some particular software to work. All the solutions to problems get switched out to create more problems.
- exabrial 9y agoOn a similar note, Samsung updated a bunch of apps on my dad's s7 and pushed a bunch of notifications to him, trying to get him to join some Samsung rewards club and suspended use of his phone until he clicked next. He's 67 guys. The madness needs to stop.
- k3oni 9y agoWow, now that's all kinds of f'ed up. Not so crazy about the update but to suspend the use of the phone is just stupid when you talk about just some apps updates.
- exabrial 9y agoNow it's incredibly hard to get them to keep their software up to date. They refuse to install security updates for fear the rig will be pulled out from underneath them again.
- robotmay 9y agoI just got ahold of an S8 Edge and by god is it full of shite. I won't be buying any Samsung hardware, and I'll definitely recommend my friends/family don't; it might be the least user-friendly device I've ever used. The first 2 days you have to spend disabling so many things, or getting daft popups all over the place explaining things you don't care about.
- bookofjoe 9y ago"Crapware: Originally coined and reported by Marc Orchant on his ZDNet blog." https://lifehacker.com/5749098/the-computer-attacks-youve-never-heard-of https://lifehacker.com/5749098/the-computer-attacks-youve-ne...
- RaleyField 9y agoBuy Nokia if you need Android, you get only first-party shite that Google provides. And it receives updates.
- Mister_Snuggles 9y agoI would like to see a TV with the following attributes: 1. 8 Inputs, with at least four HDMI and one HDMI accessible from the front panel. The remaining inputs would have at least two composite inputs. There would be no cable input since most cable companies, around here anyway, require a set-top box anyway. 2. An optical audio output, for those who wish to hook up a proper audio system. Those who don’t would get ok-ish built in speakers. 3. An always-on power outlet or two, to make hooking up the obligatory set-top box, Apple TV, etc easier. It would also have two USB power outlets, which are also always on, which would make hooking up a Raspberry Pi, Chromecast, etc easier. This requirement is optional, but desirable. The remote on the TV would have a button for each input, a power button, volume controls, and a couple of buttons to support the on-screen settings menu (things like picture adjustments, activate/deactivate/rename inputs, etc). The TV would respond to HDMI CEC controls from attached devices, but would have the option to ignore these on particular inputs. In the end, the TV provides the appropriate infrastructure to hook up whatever devices meet my needs. It also doesn’t try to solve problems that TV manufacturers aren’t good at solving. Why does nobody make a TV like this? Assuming this was price-competitive with a regular TV, I’d buy two. EDIT: I found one that’s pretty close[0]. [0] https://www.costco.ca/Haier-49UG2500-49-in.-4K-LED-TV.product.100386052.html https://www.costco.ca/Haier-49UG2500-49-in.-4K-LED-TV.produc...
- xena 9y agoBecause this world is suffering.
- NelsonMinar 9y agoBecause there's almost no profit in selling a dumb screen. SmartTVs are all about the TV manufacturer trying to get a cut of subscription services.
- BoorishBears 9y agoThere is if you slap the term gamer on there and put a 200% markup on mediocre panels... so they’re coming soon: https://www.geforce.com/whats-new/articles/bfgd-big-format-gaming-display https://www.geforce.com/whats-new/articles/bfgd-big-format-g...
- kmeade 9y agoWe are recent "cord-cutters" with a brand new Sony 4K, Android-enabled TV. On our other TVs, we have a Roku and an Amazon Firestick. We use the builtin Sony apps because they were (essentially) free and are the only way we currently have to get 4K content. I noticed the Samba nonsense when I set up the TV and have declined to participate -- but guess what? The TV still regularly connects to the domain flingo.tv, which is Samba's old name. It also connects to other strange things, like playstation-related domains. (and what is ndmdhs.com?) I've set our WAN router to block samba/flingo and few other things, but my wife is (rightfully) concerned that I'll disrupt the Android update process, so I'm being careful. It would be useful for someone with the skill, time and tools to investigate what places these Internet TVs are contacting, aside from the actual video content providers. If someone is doing that, I'd love to hear what they find.
- corrigible 9y agoIf you could provide some packet captures from the TV, analysis is pretty straightforward...
- kmeade 9y agoMy WAN router only offers a short snapshot logging capability. I suppose I could look at using Wireshark or something, but I'm not too experienced in this area. If I decide to go "deep techie" on this, I'd probably pursue an alternative DNS approach. "Pi-hole" looks very interesting in this regard. I wish I hadn't just gotten rid of my old laptop. (smile)
- baq 9y agotcpdump is a cli program that can output a file that Wireshark can read. It's a matter of copying an invocation from somewhere and having room to store the dump (external storage recommended, it might be a lot of data).
- kmeade 9y agoThanks, I'll look into that. I would like to have a longer snapshot of what the Sony TV is doing. Something I forgot to mention in my original comment -- that darn TV is accessing the Internet even when it is (supposedly) turned off. It's hard not be cynical about this stuff.
- TheAceOfHearts 9y agoYou can't really buy a high quality TV anymore without having em try to shove extra garbage down your throat. I own an old Samsung TV, and it has terrible UX. Giving it a chance to connect to the internet was a horrible mistake. My TV is around +5 years old, and I don't see myself buying a new one any time soon. During the last 2 or so years I've drastically changed the kinds of media I consume. Now my primary sources of entertainment are a mix of books and audiobooks. Last year I think I read somewhere between 200 and 300 books. Books don't include any tracking bullshit. If you stick with digital you can at least buy DRM-free copies in a few online stores. But even cooler, we actually have tons of huge buildings all across the US, each with thousands of books, and you can grab any one you want and read it for free!
- pvaldes 9y ago> Books don't include any tracking bullshit. Most books aren't specially interesting. The history of the books that you borrow in the public library is registered with your library customer card, address and name. Some local libraries or universities will ask you to write your name in a card when you take the book and let the card in the shelf. Therefore anybody could read the names of the former five or ten people that borrow the book before, and how many days they have it. The complete history for some "person of interest" shouldn't be much complicated to obtain for authorities. Maybe anybody borrowing a lot of controversial texts in a short time and a small village would trigger some alerts. Who knows. Let suppose that this is a library specialized in history and the book title written in the public card is "mein kampf", for example.
- et-al 9y agoI am not your librarian, but the American Library Association (ALA) seems to respect readers' privacy. They pushed back on the Patriot Act: http://www.ala.org/advocacy/advleg/federallegislation/theusapatriotact http://www.ala.org/advocacy/advleg/federallegislation/theusa... And have guidelines for librarians when law enforcement comes knocking: http://www.ala.org/advocacy/privacy/lawenforcement http://www.ala.org/advocacy/privacy/lawenforcement Again, it will vary depending on your town and library.
- soared 9y agoIf you're curious what samba does with your data: https://platform.samba.tv/audiences/connected-tv-ads/ https://platform.samba.tv/audiences/connected-tv-ads/ I run two ctv ad camapigns partially using samba tv data.
- Keverw 9y agoI haven't used many smart tvs but I find the software to feel lower quality than a dedicated game console or box. Kinda feel like they are building in smart TV features just to say "me to". Plus some of the blu-ray players that came with Netflix and stuff aren't being updated anymore and then when the APIs are deprecated at some point. So then you have these boxes lose their originally functionality other than just playing disks. Seems like displays last longer than the software.
- noir_lord 9y agoMy "Smart" TV is a new 4K Samsung screen that I never connected to the WiFi connected to a Media PC running Xubuntu. I don't trust the security on any networked device I don't have the source code for (and I don't really trust the media PC hardware either since its intel, not a fan of their security policies).
- sunstone 9y agoRather than using the "smart" function of your TV you would be well advised to get a 'tiny form factor' computer (I use Zotac), perhaps running Ubuntu, so that you can get the 'smartness' under your own terms. Otherwise you may find that your smart TV is tracking everything you do and listening to everything you say! (ala 2001 A Space Odyssey; "I'm sorry Dave I can't do that.")
- remir 9y agoAnd this is what trouble me with the so-called "internet of things". No regulation, no standards, nobody cares. How long until you TV or microweave oven is part of a botnet?
- stjohnswarts 9y agoYet another reason not everything needs to be connected all the time. I don't need my fridge reminding me to get eggs or that the milk is out of date. Those things are readily apparent.
- ajkjk 9y agoMaybe, if you buy a product from a company which they are capable of later updating (read: breaking), they should receive your money in installments as long as the product still works, and if they upload a change that breaks it, you're in your rights to stop paying.
- hsivonen 9y agoIt's pretty sad that even a "premium brand" like Sony does this. Last year, Sony's privacy policy for their Digital Paper app (without which the Digital Paper device is useless) and Headphones Connect (not required for the headphones to function) claimed the content of the device the app was installed on as fair game for telemetry without opt out. That's not OK. The Headphones Connect privacy language seems to have been revised in January, but I'm still not installing the app. Digital Paper is marketed to legal and medical professionals!
- narrator 9y agoMy smart TV does not have my wifi password. Only my microphone-free last generation media player gets that privilege.
- samstave 9y agoYou should know that every single Vizio tv has been doing this for years. But it’s less nefarious than one may think and you can opt out. Source: helped build it.
- drefanzor 9y agoYou are blocked from following @buro9 and viewing @buro9's Tweets. Learn more Ha.
- jlebrech 9y agosomeone who deletes their tweets every 14 days also uses a blocklist, figures.
- social_quotient 9y agoMaybe over simplifying but could you filter the network traffic for the spying chatter and while letting it still get major updates? I’m assuming there would be a way to see what spy traffic is and then route the requests to a dead DNS host file. I’ll agree in advance you shouldn’t have to secure yourself from inside the home network like this but I also assume there will be more and more smart devices exfiltrating data that you didn’t really want.
- hypertexthero 9y agoHave boycotted Sony ever since their [rootkit DRM][1] in 2005. Seems things have not changed much at the company. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootk...
- acjohnson55 9y agoHaven't bought A Sony product since they killed Bleem!, the Playstation 1 emulator for PC. That rootkit really hammered it in though.
- Spearchucker 9y agoI have a smart TV and have simply never connected it to the Internet. I see no reason to. I watch movies and play games on Xbox, watch TV through my cable box. Terrestrial TV works just fine without an Internet connection. Is there anything else I should be doing? Am I missing something?
- baloki 9y agoLG TV’s have been doing this for years...
- baloki 9y agoSorry, should have added a source: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/11/20/lg_smart_tv_data_collection/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/11/20/lg_smart_tv_data_co...
- cachecade 9y agoOne of the few bright sides of Sony's smart TVs is that since they run android, its not a big deal to connect to the TV via adb and delete whichever apps you don't want to run. the xdc forums have a pretty good starting point on things to get rid of: https://forum.xda-developers.com/nexus-player/general/sony-android-tv-users-t3096901/page126 https://forum.xda-developers.com/nexus-player/general/sony-a...
- MisterTea 9y agoI own two dumb Sony TVs and a really old Westinghouse that I gave to my mother. 1080 tvs and high enough resolution for me. I consider 2k and above to be excessive and unneeded (I even think the smooth motion of today's TVs take away from the programming and turn those garbage dsp things off). I enjoy TV shows and I prefer to keep things simple. I prefer a dumb TV, in fact if be happy with a monitor. Just give me an TV with a few inputs and I'm happy. I prefer to buy a low cost media player, currently older fire sticks. That's all I'll ever want or need. Don't need apps on a TV. In fact, I think the idea is absurd.
- goofballisright 9y agoMisnomer of misnomers. It's not an upgrade if you can't roll it back.
- angel_j 9y agoI don't know why people want to buy smart TV when you can plug your computer, over which you have much more control, into a large, dumb, monitor. Opaque operating systems, terrible UIs, security and privacy implications galore. The experience is like going back in time w/r/t using computers and software to enhance your experience.
- ksec 9y agoHow much more crap until Apple think enough is enough. They will make an Apple TV Set purely for themselves. Why in 2018, we have "Smart TV" that requires so much settings and are not really anyway Smarter for most consumers. We then gives in so much privacy and information before we are allow to use it?
- johnflan 9y agoApple is not the solution here.
- giancarlostoro 9y agoI got a Smart LG TV with my LG G5 years ago (for 'free' with the purchase of my phone) and I don't give it Wi-Fi credentials. I bought a Mi Box Android TV from WalMart instead and hook that up to the internet. I rather my TV be as dumb as possible so I can replace the device I use to access Netflix without having to throw out my whole TV. It doesn't have Android TV it has some LG thing but regardless I rather keep my TV dumb altogether. I have no guarantee my TV wont spy on me through my wireless network tomorrow (if not today). I have no true guarantee that my TV wont become exploitable to some botnet either. I rather be able to take my Android TV device and unplug it and still be able to use my TV with a DVD player if it came down to my device being exploited somehow.
- acd 9y agoI want to run an open source operating system such as Debian/Ubuntu on my next TV. By using open source software I know what the TV does and other can verify what it does. There is a lot of usable streaming apps(Netflix through Chrome, Amazon Prime, Spotify). Also mention that there is Kodi. Please put open boot loader so one can load Open source software in TVs. Another great feature is that the TV will continue to get security updates and longer from a software perspective. Longer lasting TV will be better for the environment.
- eco 9y agoMy interest in smart TVs ended almost instantly after I bought my first. I went to adjust the volume and there was an advertisement below the volume slider. Not an ad for Panasonic. Just a regular old banner ad for some random company. I disabled that "feature" in the settings then just disconnected the TV from the network entirely after discovering how terrible all the apps were. I just use a Chromecast and Kodi on a NUC for everything now.
- ryandrake 9y agoIt’s funny sitting here on HN reading about this, with many HN readers outraged and disappointed that a company would do such anti-user stuff in their products. HN readers, quite a few of whom, are likely complicit software engineers at companies doing similar anti-user things. You ask when these practices are going to end? They will not end while we quietly implement them! You look for who to blame? As a profession we need to look in the mirror. These surveillance boxes masquerading as consumer electronics don’t build themselves.
- mr_toad 9y agoSoftware engineers aren’t all clones. There are probably more who don’t care about privacy than those who do.
- blitmap 9y agoIt's becoming almost necessary to have a wireless router that supports having a guest network where connected guests can't "talk to each other". The frustrating part is my Linksys has a captive portal rather than asking for password the traditional way, so I can't join some of my "smart" appliances to the guest network. This is somewhat irrelevant to the post, but I try to keep all the untrusted devices on a separate network. I don't want them talking to the devices I trust or learning from each other and becoming "smarter". It just stinks that it's getting harder to find dumb devices with a focused use - they all want to be tablets.
- ramphastidae 9y agoYou can easily buy a high quality dumb TV in 2018. I just did it last year. It took me ten minutes of research. I saved hundreds of dollars over and enjoy many more streaming features than the equivalent smart TV by hooking up an old laptop via HDMI. Here it is: https://www.walmart.com/ip/Samsung-43-class-fhd-1080p-led-tv-un43j5000/45161376 https://www.walmart.com/ip/Samsung-43-class-fhd-1080p-led-tv...
- nvahalik 9y agoWe bought a dumb TV on sale for $175. 50 inch, too!
- _audakel 9y ago> run it on a different network than your NAS and other computers. And that all other devices best require passwords to connect to them. Ideally you run a TV on a different VLAN. Very important. I used to have no password on any of my internal network devices, then changed to all the same pw. I need to put them all different, because threats seem more likely to come from internal "trusted" sources that we bring in
- nfoz 9y agoI have a 4K 55" "dumb" TV. You typically need to look for the "Business" line of products to find them. http://www.lg.com/us/business/commercial-display/displays-tvs/commercial/lg-55UX340C http://www.lg.com/us/business/commercial-display/displays-tv... The downsides are that it doesn't do HDR (that's typical for the pricepoint anyway, but I'm not sure they make their nicer lines as dumb-TVs "for business" if you wanted it). And it only has two HDMI inputs (which is fine for me, or I might get a separate splitter if I want to expand later). The upsides: the TV just works, works fast, and never gets in my way. The remote-control is simple. I'll avoid Smart TVs as long as I possibly can.
- wemdyjreichert 9y agoStill have a CRT tube because I don't want a smart TV. Panels can last for ~10 years; the "smart" brains won't.
- kwhitefoot 9y agoJust when you think it might be time to forgive Sony for the rootkit they do something that shows that as a corporation hey have not learned anything.
- rmstallman 9y agoWhen a device or system is described as "smart", read "spy". See stallman.org/articles/what-mary-had.html. I wouldn't allow anything "smart" in my home, and I urge you to do the same. As for Netflix, I refuse to let a company know what I watch, or tolerate DRM, or agree to a contract not to give, lend or share copies. See stallman.org/netflix.html.