16 ms·
Medium suspended our account and blocked access to all our published stories
- Shywim 9y agoI don't even understand why someone who has a hosting would want to write on medium when they can host their own blog, especially when in the case of liberapay and mastodon they say they are fighting for freedom but choose to wirte their posts in a closed, centralized service which also has user-hostile behavior.
- etattva 9y agobecause they can get access to audience which could take years to get on your blog
- domevent 9y agoThst only explains why they would syndicate to Medium, not host there.
- djsumdog 9y agoI get e-mails ever once in a while asking if I'd like to write for a medium blog. I always ask how much they're paying and never get a reply. I'm fine for writing in a spot I can get exposure, but you better pay me. Medium does pay a subset of their writers. I know when they started The Nib, they paid political cartoonists like Matt Bors. So they paid a small group to get others to contribute. They're pretty much the new Huffington Post.
- EGreg 9y agoHow exactly does that happen btw? What are all the discovery mechanisms? Once the network is saturated like the Web, what does it do to allow new blogs to be discovered, besides just a "new on X topic" section and stuff people can do anyway to share urls?
- forgotmypw 9y agoI rarely click medium.com links, or any of their associated domains, hackernoon.com, etc. The website sucks. It's crippled without JS, and squirmy and laggy when JS is enabled. Either way, it's very heavy on the network pipe. Medium is in business of driving traffic, which means the content is likely to be mediocre. It's content that is looking for an audience, as my comment's sibling states. Which means that it is probably not that compelling, otherwise the audience would find it. It's written by someone who can't be bothered to set up their own website without all of these mis-features, nor understands the importance of doing so. And for all of these reasons, the opinion of someone who publishes on Medium is worth a lot less to me. The same goes for businessinsider.com, wsj.com, patch.com, nymag.com and all those other shitty sites that make me regret visiting them the moment I arrive. There can't be anything relevant enough on there that I can't live without. Just a big waste of my time and network resources. I've blacklisted them in my hosts file, and haven't looked back.
- pmarreck 9y ago> It's crippled without JS It's an SPA. What did you expect? That's the new M.O., unless you're a 90's relic like myself, in which case I appreciate your point but times change.
- Zak 9y agoThere are some use cases for which SPAs are a huge leap forward, greatly improving the user experience. A lot of modern web applications don't and shouldn't behave like a collection of pages, after all. A blog is not one of these use cases; it is exactly a collection of pages.
- et-al 9y agoNot to mention, as a SPA, Medium is a total failure. Trying to read a string of comments on Medium results in a bunch of unnecessary clicks and page reloads. I guess it's upping their click count..
- 9y ago
- exotree 9y agoMedium offers the potential for an audience who will read your work. It’s dead simple to use. The “claps” economy at least offers a glimmer of hope you could be compensated for your work. And, for a lot of folks, it can offer a sense of community. And honestly, hosting your own blog, while cheap, is often an annoyance to maintain.
- JoshMnem 9y ago> Medium offers the potential for an audience who will read your work. If you write good content and are consistent, it isn't that difficult to drive traffic to your own blog. Blogging is easy with a good static site generator and netlify (free).
- markbnj 9y agoI've got access to GCP and AWS, and a private account at a VPS provider with a server I can put anything on, and I still publish technical articles on medium for the simple reason that I get far more readers than I do when writing on my own blog.
- mulmen 9y agoWhy not publish to your own site and syndicate to Medium?
- heedlessly2 9y agoIt's the difference between having your own website and having a twitter page. Medium already has a bunch of daily users and your future audience can discover you there. If you only have your own blog, how will people know you exist?
- djsumdog 9y agoAny official word from Medium? I want to know what their excuse will be.
- smg 9y agoA blanket statement like 'Medium is bad' does not have enough nuance. Medium is for profit centralized service. You are trading freedom for convenience and access to an audience. It is for you to decide if this tradeoff is profitable. For me, having Medium as the sole repository of my content does not seem like the right tradeoff. Maintaining a static site with a CDN costs less than 5$ a month. Having complete control over the content is far more valuable than the audience that Medium brings. Mirroring posts to Medium can still allow me to reach that audience.
- api 9y agoWhy do you even need a CDN? GitHub will host static sites for free and updating is a git push. S3 will as well for pennies a month unless your site is huge.
- sulam 9y ago“I fled Medium because they are a profit making enterprise that rando-bans people.” “Cool, where’d you go?” “GitHub pages.” “...”
- greyman 9y agoThere is some bandwidth limit, though, and with CDN your site could also get better response times, since they will serve content from a server with better proximity to visitors.
- daurnimator 9y agoIs there a practical limit for gh-pages though? I think you get flagged for manual review if you're high traffic; but as long as you're serving content I don't know of anyone being taken down (and I have heard about some great lengths gone to to keep things up). And you can put a CDN in front of gh-pages too! I have done that with cloudflare a couple of times for relatives that want to run a static site and super low cost.
- adventured 9y agoDoes GitHub not push its static content from a traditional CDN, or something effectively simulating a CDN (just a lot of servers spread across the globe)? I don't know offhand, it'd be surprising if they don't given the scale in question.
- GenYCubeJockey 9y agoHappy Medium user here for several years. Even have been paid >$5 USD for work hosted there. Yes, I have skin in the game, and yes I'm positioning myself as a semi-advocate. Today's better lesson: LibraPay is too cheap to fork over money for effective legit marketing, so they're going the GoldiBlox route and trying to pick a fight to make themselves look good and get press. I mean they can totally respond to this post with a list of how much they've spent in hard currency to market their brand versus the traffic they've gotten from throwing mud at Medium...
- djsumdog 9y agoDid you get paid directly by medium? I know they hired people for things like The Nib. I feel like they hired some people to get initial content, but then expected other people to contribute for free. It feels like Huffington Post all over again, except more accessible I guess.
- detaro 9y agoComplaining about an unfair (or at least perceived as such) account deletion is now "marketing"? And how convenient that you define at the same time how they can absolve themselves of that claim: by demonstrating how much money a non-profit project financed by donations has spent on paid advertising...
- 1over137 9y ago$5 USD?? Is that a typo?
- madez 9y agoThe Mastodon website works great without JS, unlike Twitter. Nice!
- Hedja 9y agoAlways publish on your own platform then syndicate it across all the relevant social media providers to get exposure. It's a huge pain, especially now that most platforms are closed and don't provide automation (APIs, RSS), but it's really the most flexible solution. It also makes syndicating to new providers a lot less painful since you'll have some standard raw form (e.g. Markdown) which you can create a manual or automated pipeline for. Considering Liberapay is using Mastodon, I expected them to already know what they're getting themselves into. Especially with Medium's thickening walls.
- detaro 9y agoMedium even has options to import copies of posts from your main site and an API for it, which they haven't gotten rid of yet.
- alanh 9y agoThey don’t have a reciprocal export function, however. :(
- alanh 9y agoStandard reminder that Markdown, while pleasant to author in, is perhaps one of the least standard formats ever (every implementation does things their own way; see Babelmark 2) and not a great archive format, largely as a result. (Markdown files don’t have version or flavor information embedded) I hear org-mode is a good alternative. In the mean time, consider storing a permanent .html version upon publication of markdown
- steindavidb 9y agoCommonmark is a wonderful and well defined markdown standard (ie the one GitHub uses)
- seandougall 9y agoCited in the spirit of good humor, but not irrelevant: https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/
- bmarquez 9y agoI never understood why people who can use self-hosted wordpress and domain names would decide to give up control and put content on Medium. The stories featured on the front page seem a bit of an ideological bubble (I doubt any conservative bloggers would get any traction there.) And the whole "log in to your email to log on" is IMO horrible design. I put Gmail in a separate browser to mitigate cookie tracking, having to log on to email then copy the login link to my main browser is much more annoying than using a password manager like every other site.
- philfrasty 9y agoThat is a bit like saying "I never understood why people who can self-host video put it on YouTube". Most times your content will never reach a significant audience (if this is your goal), platforms like Medium/YouTube/Flickr/500px make discovery easier.
- mattbierner 9y agoSlightly better discoverability and easier “subscriptions” are the main values of Medium for me. I find syndication ok at attracting readers to specific posts but not great at getting people to keep coming back (even with rss available).
- busterarm 9y agoIt's called syndication. You still own your stuff and still get the exposure. Very little risk.
- post_break 9y agoYou're going from a simple CMS to video hosting is like saying why ride a bicycle when you can build a lamborghini from scratch. Sure some people have the bank roll to try and launch a youtube, very few, but everyone can afford to spin up a wordpress or some other sort of CMS on a one click host.
- alanh 9y agoI expected the other side of this link to be a thinkpiece that maybe having one company host and track all of our blog reading activity isn't smart in a post-Cambridge Analytica world (or even a post-Snowden world, but whatever). It’s actually saying that maybe giving a company control over your own blog isn’t always so smart. True. For these reasons it seems dumb to me that Mastodon itself (not the author of this post on mastodon) blogs on Medium. Like a global warming activist jetting around a lot, it just shows one not putting their money where their mouth is.
- api 9y agoMedium is a magazine with unpaid writers.
- matiasz 9y agoMatthew Butterick made this argument years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9063177 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9063177
- scrollaway 9y agoHey everyone, if you're looking for a fantastic blog engine, I want to tell you about Ghost: https://ghost.org https://ghost.org I found Ghost while looking for a new blog engine for my company. My first instinct was to use Medium as well, but I ended up hitting a lot of issues because it was impossible for us to customize it (add custom javascript, charts, disable the lame "highlights", custom domain was not free, etc...). 1. Ghost is open source, developed by a foundation in the open. They make their revenue open, their issue tracker, their code, everything. 2. Ghost is self-hostable, as well as hosted on a paid plan. The paid plan is a little pricy (https://ghost.org/pricing/ https://ghost.org/pricing/) but I recommend it if this is for a company blog. 3. Ghost is beautiful out of the box. Here is the default theme: https://blog.ghost.org https://blog.ghost.org -- Here is a slightly customized theme: https://articles.hsreplay.net https://articles.hsreplay.net 4. Ghost has an excellent featureset. It's powered by Markdown and has a wonderful markdown editor in its admin/authorship interface. It also supports authors, editors, contributors, drafts, publishing schedules, tags, etc. Seriously, try it out. I'm not affiliated, just a huge fan. I want to see more people use and support these fantastic open source tools, rather than complain about Medium like there's no alternative.
- cknoxrun 9y agoWe use ghost as well, can't say enough good things about it. Digital Ocean also has a pre-configured droplet for it that makes installation / testing pretty seamless.
- iDemonix 9y agoI'm a big fan of Ghost and have just set it up for a friend on free tier AWS for his travel blog. DO droplets have gotten better/bigger lately, and with the one-click install it's a cinch. That said, if anyone's interested, I wrote a post on getting it running on a small VM which I'm currently rewriting for AWS free tier: https://www.danwalker.com/running-ghost-on-a-5-digital-ocean-vps/ https://www.danwalker.com/running-ghost-on-a-5-digital-ocean...
- steve_adams_86 9y agoI'll add my recommendation here too. You can get going with it over at digital ocean with one of their single click images, whatever you call them, and run it fine for $5-$10 per month. I recommend $10, but I believe it'll still install and run fine for low traffic sites on the cheapest tier. It's also really easy to install yourself. They've done a great job on it all around. If you have a blog, give it a shot. It's not a WordPress replacement if you use tons of plugins but it's great writing software. It's also really easy to theme.
- amriksohata 9y agoWhat do people use medium for? To duplicate their blog posts? Can you put any content on it? Even controversial topics?
- ssimpson 9y agoStatic site generator + static site hosting + JavaScript based comment system like disqus is a great combo. You can generate in a container off markdown using something like Hugo and host on S3. I’ve got free tier werker pulling my repo, building it, then deploying it to CloudFiles. All I do is commit the markdown changes to github.
- fyfy18 9y agoIf you are concerned about the privacy of your readers, using Disqus probably isn't such a good idea: https://replyable.com/2017/03/disqus-is-your-data-worth-trading-for-convenience/ https://replyable.com/2017/03/disqus-is-your-data-worth-trad...
- ssimpson 9y agoGood point. There are probably other like services. I don’t really get much traffic!
- gkya 9y agoThe best other service: a mailto: link. People do write e-mails on posts they like, sometimes. Also, 9 out of 10 comment threads under blog posts I've read are just plain stupid logorrhoea. Maybe a subreddit would work too?
- KajMagnus 9y agoWhat do you think about https://www.talkyard.io/blog-comments https://www.talkyard.io/blog-comments? I'm developing it and if you or the ancestors have any thoughts or feedback that'd be interesting to hear
- gkya 9y agoI personally prefer not having comments at all in personal blogs. Tho the sytem seems robust and comprehensive, would be useful for those who want to incorporate comments in blog posts or support pages. An immediate criticism is that the web page needs a bit of work. It was unusable in Firefox for android, with half the video off screen. Also, the video is kinda cryptic, some narration, written or spoken, would be a nice addition. That it's OSS is really compelling, I personally would be more likely to buy hosted service from you because it's so. But maybe that's not the general stance. Overall, kudos, this seems cool!
- pjc50 9y agoIs there any sign of an explanation as to why Liberapay was banned?
- RobGav 9y agoThis is why I use Publii https://getpublii.com https://getpublii.com It's open source, free static CMS with GUI and free themes. You can easily sync your website with Netlify, GitHub Pages, Google Cloud, S3 or SFTP.
- navjack27 9y ago2nding this. And if netlify stops being good, well, Publii has everything saved so I can just upload it someplace else. Having a gui on a static site generator is a must.
- remir 9y agoWow! I gotta say, this looks fantastic. Thanks for the link!
- indigodaddy 9y agoIs there a facility that Publii supports, to easily sync locally, before an edit/push (eg if you are using different client systems a lot), either with Google Drive or Git (preferably) ? I never saw this feature listed when looking at Publii, which kept me from trying it. Note, please don't say just sync down from the server before doing anything locally; I don't want that to be the point of record. I'd rather that be Git.
- ryanar 9y agoSet up publii for a non-technical client, it looked like everything the client needed, but a few stumbling blocks 1) Themes are too limited, there are <10 and the path to customization is not simple. This is a chicken and egg problem, if publii grows, more themes come into the marketplace, but only having a few themes limits growth. 2) Even though it has a pretty good GUI, it is still confusing for non-technical people, and I struggled a lot with it too, mostly because there aren't tooltips next to fields to explain them (e.g. what is the difference between a "title" and a "label" for a link?) I'll have to unfortunately move to something else for my client, and revisit publii at a later time.
- RobGav 9y ago
- rcthompson 9y agoReading further down the thread, it seems they were suspended for violation of Medium's policy on cryptocurrencies... despite the fact that they have never written about cryptocurrencies.
- minimaxir 9y agoMedium has a policy on cryptocurrency? Given the amount of problematic thought pieces submitted to HN from it (and the no-so-subtle advertisements for the author’s own crypto), you wouldn’t know it.
- rcthompson 9y agoHere's the post where they quote the message Medium sent them: https://mastodon.xyz/@Liberapay/99744414079487371 https://mastodon.xyz/@Liberapay/99744414079487371 And here's the policy page it links to: https://help.medium.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000646167 https://help.medium.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000646167
- minimaxir 9y agoAh, that policy page was added a week ago (the update date is visible on the mobile site). Even if that policy was violated, it’s a jerk move to ban for infractions prior to that date.
- erAck 9y agoJerks do jerk moves to move as jerks.
- SuperNinKenDo 9y agoProbably a pre-emptive move triggered by FOSTA and that other one that starts with S who's name I forgot.
- rcthompson 9y ago
- EGreg 9y agoI never understood why people trust their data, identity and brand to others to have ultimate power over. Whether it's facebook.com/yourbrand or twitter.com/blah or medium.com/pleasedonthurtme I realize that these days people may want something more than Wordpress, they want some social networking layer. So I did something about it. I opened a company and 7 years we worked on an open source platform to once and for all solve this stupid situation. Take a look and I'd be curious to get your feedback: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI
- isostatic 9y ago> I never understood why people trust their data, identity and brand to others to have ultimate power over. > https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=pZ1O_gmPneI No further comment
- ryandrake 9y agoIt's getting harder and harder for me to muster any sympathy for these "Company X suspended my account and now I can't do Y" sob stories. As long as it's not your server, running software you control, you are taking the risk that whoever is providing that service will go out of business, capriciously close your account, censor you, ban you, etc., whether or not you're paying for it. Moreover, if your business actually relies on this service and you haven't accounted for this risk or prepared a mitigation plan? WTF! How many examples of this happening do we need before we start acknowledging and taking the risk seriously, rather than crying about it after it happens? The sooner self-hosting comes back into fashion, the better.
- quotemstr 9y agoWhat happens when your DDoS-protection reverse proxy deems your words wrongthink and drops you, allowing anyone with $50 to flood your server? What happens when your registrar drops your account and steals your domain name so that you can't transfer it elsewhere? What happens when you get BGP blackholed? And what happens when all the modern-day puritans on Twitter approve of these actions? What happens when the oh-so-responsible Twitter crowd decides that the above actions are mandatory under some CS "code of ethics" they made up? What happens if they can back up their words with an industry blacklist? You're screwed. We have a massive society-wide problem with censorship and moving to small-scale private infrastructure won't help.
- zaarn 9y agoYou can always start to host on a Tor onion service, though that is admittedly the last straw.
- phkahler 9y agoIs there anywhere you can blog under a pseudonym?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JoshMnem 9y agoI wish people would stop using Medium, especially for programming blogs. The UI is terrible (footer bar, animated pop-ups, monoculture design, paywalls), and I don't like landing on Medium sites. Publishing on the Web is supposed to be decentralized. If you're going to write a tech blog use a static site generator like Metalsmith, Hugo, Hexo, Middleman, Jekyll, or Pelican, and deploy it for free on Netlify.com.
- kaushalmodi 9y agoIf someone is writing a programming blog AND using a static site generator like Hugo, etc., that also builds up the author's credibility as a programmer in my view. But that's just me.
- throwme_1980 9y agolol, never smoke without fire
- navjack27 9y agoI'm partial to using netlify and Publii for my blog.
- chx 9y agoNo one even considers that Medium might be right and we might be better off without Liberapay aka Gratipay aka Gittip. May I remind you of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7844457 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7844457
- rdiddly 9y agoTheory: 1) Medium has SESTA/FOSTA concerns. 2) Medium constructs a broad, but also shallow/naive, search for warning terms. 3) Since darkweb pornographers accept cryptocurrencies, all crypto-related terms are included in the search. 4) One of those terms is "decentralized," which is also a property of Mastodon. 5) Mastodon gets auto-banned.
- gkya 9y agoIt's liberapay that they've banned, not mastodon.
- epeus 9y agoIf you like the medium editing you and want it for your own site, have a look at quill.p3k.io
- bookofjoe 9y agoAm I the last TypePad user? I never see it mentioned anywhere, including this entire comment thread. Based on my blog traffic in recent years, it would appear that, like De Niro rants in "The Deer Hunter" — "I'm the only one here."
- Alex3917 9y agoI still use TypePad. I actually like it much more than Medium, much better typography imho.
- jdbiggs 9y agoHost your own. I trust medium like I trust Facebook - they're a walled garden and the walls are getting higher.
- xab9 9y agoI never liked medium, their comment UX is weird and annoying, the whole thing is just faceless, brandless and feels generic. Mabye I'm old, but I find shared hosting with one click deployment of wordpress a better choice, but heck, most of the blogs I end up reading nowdays are tech blogs written by bright people who for some reason will not 1. deploy an existing blog engine to a shared host 2. host a blog on a vps 3. write a rudimentary blog engine 4. write a static generator (how much time could that be? a day?) Yep, searching may be tricky, especially with rendered sites, but it's doable and I literally never used the search function on medium... but whatever. Maybe I'm barking up the wrong tree. If you really want to publish something and you're a lazy bum, just throw up a github repo, or a gist, it's still 100% more flexible than medium.
- Kenji 9y ago> (how much time could that be? a day?) You'd be surprised how much time you can sink in a high quality blog engine.
- user5994461 9y agowordpress offers free hosting for unlimited traffic. You don't need to set up anything. The smallest blog takes a long time to setup. I understand developers who don't want to run web services at work only to come home and run other web services.
- Deimorz 9y agoLooks like their account has been reinstated now: https://mastodon.xyz/@Liberapay/99745922397657868 https://mastodon.xyz/@Liberapay/99745922397657868
- jacquesm 9y agoServes you right for handing control over your content to another party. So, now that the account has been reinstated I figure you must be busy executing your migration plan? Or will you leave it like it was until the next time it suddenly disappears like this?
- lifeformed 9y agoCan someone provide any context? What were they writing about?
- ohtwenty 9y agoMentioned elsewhere in these comments but they got deleted for violating a no-cryptocurrency that medium added a week ago. also they never wrote about cryptocurrencies, they're a free alternative to things like patreon, and only accept payment directly through the bank (i've used them once)
- tomrod 9y agoI wish the creator of dadgum started a no-frills blog hosting business, a Medium competitor that loads in milliseconds due to text being the medium.
- baxtr 9y agoWe use Jekyll and it’s just awesome.
- busterarm 9y agoIt was funny to me seeing so many people recommend less robust, less tested static site generators than Jekyll.
- adarsh_thampy 9y agoI have no idea why businesses think that it's a good idea to let third-party sites control their primary website pages. I have written at length here about this issue >> https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/basecamp-moved-blog-medium-you-probably-shouldnt-adarsh-thampy/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/basecamp-moved-blog-medium-yo... The point is, everyone is moving to medium because they have great UX plus they already have an in0built audience. But what happens when they have to start making money? We all know what happened to Facebook pages.