15 ms·
California to Introduce 'Right to Repair' Bill
- remir 9y agoThis bill is a step in the right direction. The Earth has a limited amount of resources, so we should really start thinking about better resources management because otherwise, we're going to have serious problem in the future.
- pas 9y agoThat's not exactly a good way to look at it. The Earth is enormous, and we have access to plenty of green energy. Wind, solar, nuclear. And with enough energy every other problem is easy. Including waste processing. The problem is that too short product lifespans close off a lot of avenues for long term utility extraction from products. (Second hand markets, donated stuff.)
- remir 9y agoThe Earth may be enormous, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't be more careful about consuming it's resources.
- tyingq 9y ago”The legislation would require manufacturers of electronics...” Seems like there’s a pretty big loophole here in that it’s mandating just manufacturers, not retailers and resellers. There’s a fair amount of electronics on eBay and Amazon that are from US resellers of Chinese manufacturers. Those manufacturers often have no US presence, and so no compelling reason to care about any of this.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoResellers really aren't the problem. The problem is manufacturers who "lock-down" their products to prevent repairs using things like proprietary software and DRM. To make matters worse, Section 1201 of the DMCA makes it illegal to break DRM, no matter what the reason, effectively making it illegal to do repairs in many instances. The "grass-roots" movement for "right to repair" legislation was started in Nebraska by farmers who are sick of being unable to repair their tractors without the assistance and permission of John Deere Inc. John Deere tractors are currently rejecting usable parts because the owner of the tractor cannot tell the software to use the part.
- tyingq 9y agoRight. This is not a general loophole, but a loophole for products where the manufacturer has no US presence. Because of portals like Amazon and eBay, there's more of this than you might think.
- olivermarks 9y agoI'm a big supporter of this. I also feel 'right to support' is very important. Copyright law that mandates proprietary service and technical manuals and software should become public domain after x years. As an example, modern cars are virtually unserviceable by mechanics with no access to proprietary diagnostic software and equipment. If a company is out of business or their support staff are unfamiliar with old products, publish everything to help right to repair...
- ythn 9y agoIf only it were cost-effective to repair cheaper things. Our vacuum recently stopped working correctly. We only paid $100 for it. Paying someone to repair it costs around that much after parts and labor. So my options are to fix it myself or simply buy a brand new one...
- ryandrake 9y agoIt’s often just the labor that’s expensive (at least in the US). The parts to repair most home appliances and electronics tend to be reasonably priced and available all over the web (my favorite source is eBay—people disassemble old appliances and sell parts separately). The tricky part is often merely access to service documentation, which is what most “right to repair” laws seek to correct.
- Shivetya 9y agoThe only concern I have is, as long as companies can exclude portions of a product whose sole purpose is to protect the privacy of the user data. I am worried that law enforcement will use this to end run the current situation mostly with apple products that the secure enclave processor/parts cannot be altered without loss of data/etc. as far as repairing tablets and such, any design changes forcing easier to repair items will have costs baked into the next generation and do these laws limit how much replacement parts can cost? Because it can take awhile for a 3rd party to make working replacement parts. finally, who certifies such?
- Bizarro 9y agoI love the idea of "right to repair", but as usual, would require manufacturers of electronics to make diagnostic and repair information, as well as equipment or service parts, available to product owners and to independent repair shops. could have far-reaching negative consequences.
- ryandrake 9y agoSuch as...
- quadrangle 9y ago…far-reaching ~~negative~~ positive consequences. FTFY
- pkaye 9y agoI remember many years back California passed a law that restricted what equipment auto parts stores could loan out to owners to diagnose their car issues. Maybe they should lift that law also.
- nradov 9y agoThere is no such law in California.
- shmerl 9y agoCan states also locally repeal DMCA-1201?
- intrasight 9y agoI would think that the insurance/warranty industry would result in considerable self-regulation. Many people (myself included) purchase 3rd party warranties, and these warranty companies expect to be able to repair appliances. Those that couldn't be repaired I would assume would not be covered, and that signal would get out to the consumer, and then to the manufacturer.
- nopacience 9y agoCalifornia always a step ahead. I remember opening watches and other electronics at circa 199x. Even 10, 15 years ago most electronics used standard cables and standard screws and anyone was able to open, see whats inside and maybe replace 1 or 2 things. Now it seems the industry moved to a path of making things break fast and hard to replace anything. Resulting in expansive repairs that will push users to purchase a new item that is cheaper than replacing 1 part. Some companies even weld RAM or processor into the motherboard. The world has limited resources. In the last 60, 70 years after ww2 and industrial revolution, the population has grown a lot and making thing un-repairable will worsen world limited resources. Some day world will run out of required materials. Some companies create a specific cable that can only be used on their devices. So if one breaks, the owner cannot use his old one because it is incompatible with that new model. Standarization of cables would good to have also. Nice move california!
- ataturk 9y agoA step ahead? Didn't such a law already go down in flames in Idaho or someplace?
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoGiven that California "joins 17 other states who have introduced similar legislation, which includes: Washington, Massachusetts, Vermont, New York, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Missouri, North Carolina, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Jersey, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Virginia"... It seems they're not exactly a "step ahead", just trying to keep pace with Nebraska. ;)
- rexaliquid 9y agoNebraska: Good Life, Great Legislative Innovations.
- deadmetheny 9y agoNebraska is surprisingly up to date with its digital frontier laws, weirdly enough.
- pero 9y agoAs someone who doesn't live in California, will this bill (indirectly) make available to me the service manual for my Acer Travelmate? I've search high and low and absolutely can't get my hands on one.
- NegativeLatency 9y agoWhich model?
- pero 9y agoP645-MG, but any P645 will do really.
- maxxxxx 9y agothere is a good chance that you will benefit from this step. It's easier for the manufacturer to make the manual available globally than restricting access to only Californians. EDIT: Is it even possible to restrict access to people from a US state? Even if I wanted to do that I would have no idea how.
- NegativeLatency 9y agoOr for someone in CA to make it available outside CA
- justboxing 9y ago> “People shouldn’t be forced to ‘upgrade’ to the newest model every time a replaceable part on their smartphone or home appliance breaks,” said Mark Murray, Executive Director of Californians Against Waste. “These companies are profiting at the expense of our environment and our pocketbooks as we become a throw-away society that discards over 6 million tons of electronics every year.” This. Don't know when all this changed ( 80s ?) in the US, but even appliance repairs are sort of a thing in the past here. If a washing machine or microwave stops working people simply get a new one. I was quite amused to see an "Appliance Repair" van parked in my neighborhood in San Francisco the other day. I started chatting with the guy and turns out he was from Ukraine and told me that in the former Soviet Union countries, they never throw away any appliance if it stops working. They repair it. Same is the case in countries like India (where I was raised), china. Esp. in India, there are scores of Radio, TV, phone, appliance repair shops in every city and even in villages.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI've been using a Macbook Pro with an external keyboard for the past year. The builtin keyboard no longer works: 1234567890- qwyuiop asdghjkl; zxcvbnm,./ Notice no E, R, T, or F keys. First the R key went out, and I got around that by leaving "r" in my paste buffer and typing Command-V instead of r. But then the T key went out about a month later. Apple wants $600 for a logic board replacement. It's so annoying to lug an external keyboard everywhere I go. Tiny wireless keyboards just aren't as responsive. But it's less annoying than paying $600 on top of a $2k MBP.
- RankingMember 9y agoThat is delightfully stubborn of you. I wonder what really goes "wrong" with those logic boards. Could it be as simple as a bad solder joint needing to be reflowed?
- reaperducer 9y agoIf it's a Macbook with a removable battery, check it for swelling. I had a Macbook experience similar symptoms and it turned out to be pressure being exerted from the swollen battery. Twice.
- ihaveajob 9y agoIn 1980 Richard Stallman found out that he couldn't fix a laser printer they just installed at MIT. That [and other events](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Stallman#Events_leading_to_GNU https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_Stallman#Events_leadin...) led 4 years later to the birth of the GNU project. Maybe the tide is finally turning, at least in some aspects.
- sudojudo 9y agoReddit markup doesn't work on ycombinator. Use square brackets and a number to designate the link [0] then put the URL at the bottom of your comment. [0] https://www.reddit.com/r/StallmanWasRight/ https://www.reddit.com/r/StallmanWasRight/
- ythn 9y agoThat's just normal markdown... sometimes I wish HN had basic markdown support: italics, `code`, [link](http:// http://), etc. Edit: looks like italics works...
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> sometimes I wish HN had basic markdown support: italics, `code`, [link](http\://) I like seeing the URL (or at least the domain) before I click. Hovering over is annoying, particularly on mobile.
- maxerickson 9y agoIndentation also works. It's intended for code blocks. An indented block. Don't use it for quotes. People, especially on mobile, will complain.
- gknoy 9y agoI think it would be neat if HN were updated to support Markdown formatting, except that links could be auto-converted to a footnote-link as is the convention on this board.
- 9y ago
- samcampbell 9y agoHere's a relevant video in regards to farmers and their equipment that drove the impact of the ‘Right to Repair’ bill home for me. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F8JCh0owT4w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F8JCh0owT4w
- coaxial 9y agoOne of the many reason that I love my 2013 ThinkPad. The service manual is freely available, every single part is serviceable with a bit of know-how, and second hand spare parts are plentiful. It's also built like a tank and hard to break to begin with. You can pick one up for 200-300$ in very good condition.
- organsnyder 9y agoI just ordered a T480 to replace my aging T410. The T410 is still functional, but has been crashing as of late. I'm planning to repair it (I suspect RAM, HD, or CPU heat), but I decided it was time to upgrade to something faster and lighter. Over the time I've owned it, I've replaced the keyboard twice and the battery at least once, and I've upgraded hard drives (it now has 768GB of SSD) and RAM (maxed out at 8GB, IIRC). I hope I'll be able to maintain the 7-year refresh cycle with my T480; newer ThinkPads are less beefy, but they still have similar levels of maintainability, so I should be able to fix anything that breaks. I am very much looking forward to the screen upgrade—even the best screen available for the T410 was mediocre at best. I've heard good things about the WQHD IPS screen I'm getting on the T480 (not quite as good as a MBP, but leaps and bounds better than my T410).
- karmapolic 9y agofirst world problems. Really good move considering the amount of e-waste that is generated.
- malchow 9y agoUgh. Another bill whose largest effect, to be understood only 10 or more years from now, will be to make sure that very large companies stay very large and very small companies have a hard or impossible road to growth. -- Someone who likes repairability as much as the next guy.
- ng-user 9y agoCare to explain what exactly you mean by this?
- ChristianBundy 9y agoI can't speak for GP, but it looks like the usual "regulation hurts small business" argument, often used by stakeholders in large businesses.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoIt's amazing how this discrepancy always seems to pop up. The five corporations with the largest market cap in the United States say SESTA will hurt small businesses more than big ones. Those same companies tell us that net neutrality is important for protecting small businesses. And these giant corporations are investing millions of dollars to fight these changes. Whenever the largest corporate entities are talking about how bad something is for "small businesses", it really means it is bad for them.
- pas 9y agoDo you mean Google, Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft, ... are against certain regulations because it's cost them too much?
- maxxxxx 9y ago"Whenever the largest corporate entities are talking about how bad something is for "small businesses", it really means it is bad for them. " Yeah. "Small business" and "family farm" are nice words for the big guys to hide behind.
- bradleybuda 9y agoMore regulation making it harder to produce goods in California / sell goods to consumers. If you want to buy repairable goods, vote with your pocketbook - don't force your preferences on me.
- FilterSweep 9y ago> If you want to buy repairable goods, vote with your pocketbook - don't force your preferences on me. This only stands true in a competitive economy. We live in an oligopoly, where the highest tech choices are not repairable. The oligopolists will be able to lobby against the "Right to Repair." My point is there isn't much ability to have "preferences" (i.e.: nothing to vote our pocketbook on) in the first place.
- 111_1_111 9y ago> This only stands true in a competitive economy. I don't know what your evidence for this is. There is a ton of competition in the smartphone market. I can name nine different companies competing against eachother just off the top of my head: Apple, Samsung, Huawei, OnePlus, Google, Essential, LG, HTC, Motorola, and Nokia.
- tengbretson 9y agoAll this proves is that people are unwilling to make a value judgement. To most consumers, having the "highest tech choice" is more important than having a repairable device. To really put one's money where their mouth is with repairability, one would have to show that they value repairability even if it comes at the expense of other things they value.
- thomastjeffery 9y agoIt proves that corporations can create small monopolies (over repair of their products, etc.), and use their economic advantage for more economic advantage, leading to true monopolies. I literally cannot vote with my wallet when there is a monopoly. That is the problem here. This legislation is about preventing a company from claiming a monopoly over repair of the products they sell.
- eth1 9y agoi hope it passes, but i bet it won't. sigh.
- rayiner 9y agoThis is nuts. If people wanted to purchase repairable products, they'd do it. Clearly the market doesn't care, so all this will do is create needless litigation and artificially constrain product design.
- daze42 9y agoThis exactly. This will only cause prices to go up if extra work is required to produce products that adhere to this new regulation.
- nradov 9y agoThere is no extra work required. They just have to provide documentation and sell spare parts (which they already produce for themselves) to consumers and independent repair services. There is virtually zero extra cost and this will have to impact on prices.
- sambull 9y agoThe market feels the incentive to make you purchase more.
- pas 9y agoNo it's not. It's a rational response to avoid a race to the bottom (tragedy of the commons) problem.
- refurb 9y agoThe race is to the bottom is the exact reason it's cheaper to just buy new than repair.
- quadrangle 9y agoat the expense of externalizing all the costs of e-waste etc.
- rayiner 9y ago
- acomjean 9y agoWe have this in Massachusetts for cars (car diagnostic info can't be a car company secret): It was passed by referendum (Voters voted on the law, not legislators...Although when they saw it was going to pass they passed a similar law). Here is a summary from the referendum: [1] "A YES VOTE would enact the proposed law requiring motor vehicle manufacturers to allow vehicle owners and independent repair facilities in Massachusetts to have access to the same vehicle diagnostic and repair information made available to the manufacturers’ Massachusetts dealers and authorized repair facilities." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_Right_to_Repair_Initiative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_Right_to_Repair_...
- Bizarro 9y agoFrom what you quoted, that seems like a reasonable bill. It just levels the playing field for everybody. Not sure about this California bill though. The devil is always in the details.
- acomjean 9y agoDetails are important. But usually I find there is always a constituency that opposes things and claims doom if anything changes: In Mass especially because of cynical attitude and proximity to more free wheeling neigbor states (RI and NH are like the wild west of the Northeast). We're a small state but we have enough people that businesses want to be here. California is big enough that business will change to do business there. For cars, "california emissions" was on all the cars they sold here because car companies don't want the hassle of two kinds of vehicles. Also the legislators here will likely change things if they're dragging down the state (We hope...) we get a summary of ballot questions: here is the Con argument for the right to repair: "This measure could lead to the release of sensitive personal information, make vehicle hacking easier, and threaten safety and fuel efficiency innovation. Increased safety threats – including theft – are why law enforcement opposes the measure." [1] http://www.sec.state.ma.us/ele/ele12/ballot_questions_12/quest_1.htm http://www.sec.state.ma.us/ele/ele12/ballot_questions_12/que... We've had this law for a while and none of it seems to be a problem. Some other things I remember strong opposition to that now seem like non-issues: 1) Bottle deposits (Grocery stores won't exist!) 2) No smoking in restaurants and bars (They'll all go to NH or RI) 3) Cambridge bring your own bag ordinance (nobody will buy anything here again).
- DINKDINK 9y agoThe cost to bring any good to market is a combination of: (1) R&D (technical and non technical), (2) Manufacturing, (3) Sales (compensation to intermediaries bringing the product to marketing), (4) Regulatory and Compliance (5) Consumer labor (6) Externalities New product prices are: (1)(2)(3)(4) Repair-part costs are dominantly comprised of: (2)(3)(5) If (2)(3)(5)(6)_oldProduct > (1)(2)(3)(4)(6)_newProduct the market is telling you your time is better spent doing something else and properly recycling the equipment. If the state inflates (4) to get (2)(3)(5)(6)_oldProduct < (1)(2)(3)(4)(6)_newProduct to be true, all that's been achieved is bureaucracy has siphoned off value from R&D and less products are produced. If there are negative, socialized costs associated with consumption (externalities) there's a justified argument to allocate those costs on the people who are producing them (recycling tax at time of purchase). Product Management via regulation is not how you get a vibrant market of inexpensive products that people want.
- ksk 9y agoAt one point in history we had a "vibrant market of inexpensive products" by allowing child labor, slavery, and polluting the air. We're deciding that there are some things that are not acceptable. Thankfully, more and more people don't care about "vibrant markets" if it means a landfill of irrepairable electronics that gets dumped onto some poor country. In any case, regulating the right to repair opens up new service markets, new parts supply chains, and a large job market that is local and difficult to outsource.
- DINKDINK 9y agoAre you arguing that opposing regulations that require people to publish manuals online is equivalent to child slavery? If not I have no idea your point as I already discussed allocating externalities of pollution.
- ksk 9y agoI'm arguing that its good to 'leave money on the table' if that means doing something positive for the environment or people.
- ferongr 9y agoWhy not cars?
- celestialcheese 9y agoWe already have this for cars. It was passed in 2012 in Massachusetts and applied throughout the country. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_Right_to_Repair_Initiative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massachusetts_Right_to_Repair_...
- elihu 9y ago"Right to repair" sounds good, but I'd like to know more details. How much documentation are you required to give users? If a device relies on programmable hardware, is it really "repairable" if you don't have the source code? What if there's a security vulnerability in the software, how do you fix that? If the ICs can be replaced but the original manufacturer stopped selling them, what then? Do the electronic interfaces between all the components need to be documented? How do small device manufacturers stay in compliance? Do end-user repairs void the warranty if the user is just bad at soldering and screwed up a surface-mount part? If the original design of the product was defective in some way, do consumers have the right to fix defects, or only to do repairs that return them to the original condition they were in when delivered to them? I think it's possible to craft a good right-to-repair bill that strikes a reasonable balance between consumer protection and not being overly burdensome on manufacturers, but I can't tell if this bill does that. The description (like most descriptions of bills given to the public by their proponents) is long on all the anticipated positive side effects and short on details of how it's accomplished.
- chme 9y ago> What if there's a security vulnerability in the software, how do you fix that? I would really wish for the 'Right to Repair' to be strong enough so that producers of all those trash IOT devices, mobile phones etc. would be forced to provide a guaranteed maintenance period for at least 5 to 10 years or would have to release all the source code and documentation if they stop updating their software so that other companies or users can step in. As a side effect it might also be possible for the consumer to choose the software separately from the hardware. Because then not only the Hardware designing company would be the only one that can write Software for it. More competition and a level playing field would be good for the consumer and economy as a whole.
- snuxoll 9y ago> How much documentation are you required to give users? Ideally any diagnostic tools you have developed and schematics, the same things you should have available yourself as the OEM. Legislation like this isn't usually designed to make companies make walkthroughs for replacing a BGA component on a board, but to make resources available so customers can get their products repaired at a 3rd-party repair center for a lower cost (or optionally themselves if they are capable of performing the repair on their own with the documentation made available to them). > If a device relies on programmable hardware, is it really "repairable" if you don't have the source code? What if there's a security vulnerability in the software, how do you fix that? Provide pre-programmed IC's, everyone is happy. Requiring the source code for firmware to be available would have huge ramifications for the protection of proprietary IP, and while I would love for companies to release open-source firmware for components I realize forcing them to do so is a straight up no-go. The goal of repairing a device is to get it back to (or as close as feasible) the state it was originally delivered, anything else is modification. > If the ICs can be replaced but the original manufacturer stopped selling them, what then? Not much you can do here, if you as the OEM can't source replacement parts you say "tough luck" and maybe offer a replacement at a reduced cost if you're a nice guy. Unfortunately this does mean 3rd party shops have to turn away work, but such is life, you can can only control companies you source parts from so much. > Do the electronic interfaces between all the components need to be documented? Pinouts and the connections between components should be documented ideally, including any voltage and/or resistance on the line so they can be properly inspected with a multimeter. Knowing the electrical communication details between two chips does me no good, knowing it operates at a certain frequency might me useful though to verify with an oscilloscope. > How do small device manufacturers stay in compliance? The same way large ones do. Provide documentation for download, buy spare components and offer them for resale at a markup to cover your costs. > Do end-user repairs void the warranty if the user is just bad at soldering and screwed up a surface-mount part? Yes, this is already federal law under the Magnuson Moss Warranty Act, manufacturers cannot require they get repairs from certified vendors or even use certified replacement parts - but they can void the warranty if the unauthorized repair caused further damage. > If the original design of the product was defective in some way, do consumers have the right to fix defects, or only to do repairs that return them to the original condition they were in when delivered to them? The latter. I mean, as a consumer once you have the device you are free to do whatever the hell you want with the physical object itself - but if you start modifying it beyond the factory state you have no guarantee of support. Whether this bill implements these is unknown, I can't find the text anymore - but the above answers are reasonable responses to your questions that shouldn't impose more than a minimal burden on businesses.
- Osiris 9y agoMy big pet peeve is non user replaceable batteries in devices (phones, laptops). It's very well known that Lithium batteries wear out over time. That means that devices with built-in, glued-in batteries are guaranteed to become useless once the battery begins to fail. The battery in my Nexus 6P is about 18 months old and it currently only holds about 40% of it's original design capacity (known issue with the phone). Replacing the battery is a very delicate task due to the glue and placement of the battery and the need to replace the glass and LCD.
- sdabdoub 9y agoYou shouldn't need to replace the glass/LCD to replace the battery on the 6P. Once you get the back off (which is definitely not easy, the battery is exposed.
- ericabiz 9y agoIt’s not too difficult for an independent repair shop with the right tools. We charge $49 to replace a Nexus 6P battery and it takes about an hour. Call some local phone repair shops near you and get some quotes. If you happen to be in Austin or Houston, contact me :)
- ausjke 9y ago1. for many appliance, repair is way more expensive (including the hours you spent on calling and scheduling and waiting (forever) for a never-arrived or always-running-late service guy, I had to just throw it away but just buy a new one instead. is this a problem of the design(say, make it DIY fixable with replace-friendly modular design) or something else? 2. easy to document and repair hardware components, what about failure caused by software? is factory-reset the only way? just some random thoughts, lunch time here
- stevecalifornia 9y agoMy Nexus 6P I purchase 1.8 years ago failed, unable to boot into Recovery Mode. I called Google and they said it's a known issue and the one-year warranty expired so...good luck. Called Huwei, they said there is no option for repair. A known issue bricks a device that is less than two years old and I had to go get a replacement. What the fuck.
- confounded 9y agoDoes anyone know how this affects the DRM circumvention clauses in the DMCA[1]? Currently trying to figure out how your stuff works can carry a prison term if there’s DRM involved. [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-circumvention?wprov=sfti1 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-circumvention?wprov=sft...
- jerkstate 9y agoI will have to read the text of this bill before I make any judgements (I haven't found a link to it, I don't believe the bill has been introduced to the Assembly yet.) but I have a hard time understanding what they would legislate. Is it going to be availability of replacement parts? Assembly methods that make repairability easier? Documentation of signal protocols so that if Samsung decides to stop making the washing machine controller, I can make my own? I've personally repaired a number of home appliances over the past few years including a LCD TV, a clothes dryer, a remote light switch, a juice machine, an espresso maker, and a vacuum cleaner, and I've tried and failed to repair a coffee maker and an electric tea kettle. I've also evaluated a macbook air and a samsung galaxy phone for repair and found that the replacement parts were too expensive to justify. My perspective is that usually the replacement part is available but the parts cost plus the time/skill to diagnose multiplied by the potential success factor in repair makes replacement a better option in many cases. I don't have a whole lot of confidence that the government can solve this problem with legislation; any rule that would solve repairability issues with your electric tea kettle would make your phone bulkier, for example. So my guess is it's going to involve a lot of lobbying by different industries and ultimately end up toothless, misguided, and ineffective. Oh well. I guess I'll just keep on replacing fuses and repairing traces.
- monomyth 9y agointerestingly enough this bill does not yet exist: https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billSearchClient.xhtml?session_year=20172018&house=Both&author=Eggman&lawCode=All https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billSearchClient.xh...
- amelius 9y agoDoes this mean that the source code for web services should be free, so a user can repair it?
- Scoundreller 9y agoOn this note, be sure to take the cover off your garage door opener and slab lithium grease on the gears every 5 years. The gears are plastic and turn into snow once it dries out.
- lysp 9y agoIn Australia I believe around 2011 they made a change to similar law called the Australian Consumer Law (ACL). In case of a major issue with a product, you can: Repair, replace or refund. And it is the buyer's choice - not the company. In case of a minor issue: The company must provide a free repair within a reasonable amount of time. If they don't or can't, you can get it repaired elsewhere and pass on the cost, or get a replacement, refund or compensation for the drop in value. Also the best bit is it makes no reference to warranty time period. So a company cannot say "6 month, 12 month or 24 month warranty" - if they do, consumer law overrides that condition. The length of time is intentionally vague as "the time you'd expect it to last". If you purchase a 100" TV brand new for $300, because of the cheap price the warranty may be only a year or so. If you purchase a 50" TV for $4000, you'd "expect" it to last many years - and people have received full refunds for their TVs 5+ years after purchase when they have developed a major fault. This is great, because it forces manufacturers to bare the cost and not plan intentional obsolescence into their products to force you to upgrade when they break. It's therefore cheaper for manufacturers to build quality products that will last. Reference: https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/consumer-rights-guarantees/repair-replace-refund https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/consumer-rights-guarantees...
- LifeLiverTransp 9y agoThe most embarassing thing, if you really think about it is- all these repairers and tinkerers- they want to put work into a product- and you deny them, because of some shortsighted sense of property and a fear of loss of controll. Look for example at games pre-steam- these where gated-communitys, walled in plattforms and gardens. All those modders, where putting in work anyway. And instead of taking a percentage, and supplying a plattform - we shut them out. Cant wait for someone to offer a hardware-steam version for IOT devices and vehicles. Add a simple scripting language like Lua to that - and suddenly - one ecosystem to rule them all, thanks to all those tinkering customers, who basically send you free money. But hey- lawyers and small sighted software department CEOs will see that it does not come to that.
- mvkel 9y agoThe spirit of this sounds great on paper, but are we not recognizing the reality that technology innovation necessitates an inability to repair? It happened in the car world when emissions regulations hit the scene and vacuum hoses and check engine lights became the norm. Can’t imagine anyone repairing their own Tesla. If the answer is to make devices thicker so they can be more easily serviced, I couldn’t be more against.