8 ms·
Flying Taxis May Be Years Away, but the Groundwork Is Accelerating
- bobthepanda 9y agoTake all the bad road behavior you see with taxi and Uber drivers normally and stick them in the air. It's a good thing it hasn't caught on.
- flogic 9y agoI think they're planning for 100% automated. So hopefully, poor behavior should not be an issue.
- maxxxxx 9y agoThey will be fully automated and regulated.
- vadimberman 9y agoLike the drones?
- maxxxxx 9y agoI bet bigger drones will be automated and regulated tightly. It's one thing that cars crash all the time but when flying vehicles crash they fall on other people. If that happens a few times people will call for rules.
- barronlroth 9y agoShort-term these will be piloted by certified pilots, and quickly be automated.
- zhoujianfu 9y agoI think the chances “flying taxis” become a thing before fully autonomous cars is actually pretty high. It’s an easier technical problem I’d think, and the regulatory issues are probably about the same. But a flying, electric, quiet, self-flying drone taxi will mean no traffic issues, as-the-crow-flies travel, and higher top speeds. It may eventually mean the death of roads and the ability for people to live 100 miles from where they work, possibly solving a lot of housing issues in metropolitan areas. Also it’d be a better way to get around watery/mountainous areas, not to mention just a few helipads to clean off after snowstorms. It would also be super cool, jetsons-style!
- Treegarden 9y agoAs much as I wish for flying cars in the future, Elon said they would be too loud and dangerous to be feasible. You can watch what exactly he said on the ted interview, would be interested in an counter argument to his position. Edit: here is the exact video (1 min long): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Nz69M6khCs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Nz69M6khCs
- justAnotherNET 9y agoElon also joked about hubcaps falling off, when flying cars won’t have hubcaps
- Retric 9y agoNoise quickly becomes a non issue with altitude. But, yea you would probably notice someone next door taking off or landing. IMO and his major point the issue/risk is falling cars. NYC for example does not have many safe places to crash, or just have a hubcap fall off. Aircraft tend to mostly hit empty fields and mountains because that's what most of the US is covered with. Still, plenty of people have died sitting at home as an aircraft failed and making that 10,000x as bad seems like a significant issue.
- gambiting 9y agoNYC specifically knows exactly what it's like to have a lot of aerial taxi traffic, as helicopter shuttles were really popular there until the crash on the PanAm building and withdrawal of all permits for on-building helipads. The risks are far too great to allow flying machines in city centres.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoBy “withdrawal of all permits” does this mean for new helipads? Or were all on-building helipads in NYC prohibited to operate going forward?
- 9y ago
- wpietri 9y agoInterestingly, the iRobot founder and brilliant robot scientist Rodney Brooks puts flying cars and robot taxis in similar buckets as to wide availability: http://rodneybrooks.com/my-dated-predictions/ http://rodneybrooks.com/my-dated-predictions/
- nsnick 9y agoThe reasoning for that is kinda thin. "I am pretty sure that practical flying cars will need to be largely self driving while flying, so they sort of fit the category." Essentially, because self driving technology is a necessary precondition for flying cars, flying cars are at least as difficult as self driving vehicles. There really isn't any argument for why flying cars aren't much more difficult than self driving vehicles.
- tzakrajs 9y agoAt least there is little new construction in the air.
- elmar 9y ago> There really isn't any argument for why flying cars aren't much more difficult than self driving vehicles. On a software level Self-flying aircraft are much more simple than self-driving cars, there exist today technologies to have 100% safe self-flying vehicles similar to small electrical planes capable of 1 to 2 passengers, it's much more a regulation challenge.
- sokoloff 9y agoI don’t believe that resilience against mechanical failure is a solved problem for flying cars yet. Flying a plane when everything is working isn’t particularly hard. Diagnosing and coping with partial failures is hard.
- ppbutt 9y agoThey already exist in parts of the world like Saudi Arabia, no? (Can't read the article because I don't pay to view their site..)
- FabHK 9y agoDubai is planning a trial with Volocopter, but there is nothing in production yet AFAIK.
- matte_black 9y agoThey are not years away, they are only a few innovations away, mostly related to battery performance and more compact powerful engines. Then of course, regulation.
- loceng 9y agoUntil the noise generated by the motors is solved they will only ever be allowed for emergency vehicles.
- matte_black 9y agoThis is a solved problem that has mostly to do with propeller shape. By creating 3D simulations of airflow you can come up with very quiet designs. The reason it’s not done is because no one gives a damn. Planes and helicopters fly too high up and if you’re in one of these vehicles the sounds of the engine will be louder than the propellers anyway because they aren’t electric. The military however already has this tech.
- loceng 9y agoRelative quiet and actual quiet are different things - I don't believe the physics exists to displace the noise/vibrations generated; you can change the propeller shape and sizes, however that energy still needs to go somewhere, so you'll mostly just change where the energy's going and the frequencies and concentrations that are output. I'd love to be proven wrong.
- sonium 9y agoI think there is an interesting problem to solve here is one of mass production. To be cost competitive these vehicles need to be produced as scale. This is nothing that the traditional aircraft business has experience with, but car manufacturars have plenty. This reflects in the savety architecture of airplanes vs cars: Airplanes rely on redundancy, which makes manuacturing more expensive but. Cars on the other hand try not to break in the first place, which is ensured through exhaustive testing and monitoring of the production chain. I think the winner will be the one who brings these two worlds together.
- hexane360 9y ago>Airplanes rely on redundancy, which makes manuacturing more expensive but. Cars on the other hand try not to break in the first place, which is ensured through exhaustive testing and monitoring of the production chain. I don't agree with this. You're missing a variable: safety factor. Cars try to minimize safety factor to save money and weight, airplanes often have more regulations to prevent this. Cars definitely break more often then airplanes. Also, keep in mind that aircraft can rely on preventative maintenance by trained professionals. Cars really can't, meaning they have to simplify their components and assembly a lot.
- mtgx 9y agoI hope they won't become mainstream until they can be fully battery-powered. You don't want something like that to fly above you when it has only slightly better Q&A than a regular car (and probably far less than a plane).
- mbid 9y agoFinally. This will be great for the environment and especially the climate.
- nitwit005 9y agoThat seems unlikely. The energy cost of flying is always going to be higher. You do, after all, need to move upward.
- sokoloff 9y agoI fly a piston engine airplane that seats 6 and gets ~15 miles per gallon at over 200mph. If I slowed it down, I could probably get it to 20mpg. That’s pretty competitive with 6-pax cars, so the spread may not be as much as you’d first imagine.
- jra_samba 9y agoFlying cars/taxis will never be a widespread thing for the public (IMHO). The weight of a car is an excellent kinetic energy weapon. Fly over soft target, detonate something on-board to disable safety features and you have the poor-man(terrorist?)'s remote-kill drone. Makes driving trucks into crowded streets look positively medieval. The danger of this far outweighs any possible benefits. Flying cars will become a thing, but stay heavily regulated and a rich-person's toy.
- redspectre 9y agoIsn't it sad that we can't have an exciting new technology because the threat that some outsider will blow themselves up? Is there really nothing we can do about this, either now, or in the future?
- tdb7893 9y agoVery few people actually blow themselves up (terrorism is really really low on the list of the most common causes of death) so I doubt that it will be why we don't have flying cars.
- cmurf 9y agoMaybe. There's a strong correlation between military occupations and terrorism, in particular when the use of force is asymmetric. http://foreignpolicy.com/2010/10/18/its-the-occupation-stupid/ http://foreignpolicy.com/2010/10/18/its-the-occupation-stupi...
- agumonkey 9y agoI used to joke around that we passed the Minority Report point, which was the latest movie where computer UI felt something unatainable (and new gesture, recognition etc is mainstream). This would be the 5th element point.
- Panino 9y agoNext time you drive past a car accident, picture the cars not along the side of the road but in someone's house. That's where they will go when something goes wrong and they fall from the sky.
- tytytytytytytyt 9y agoAnd yet somehow we manage to constantly have people travel by plane.
- strong_silent_t 9y agoI think the ideal scenario for this tech is running a downtown core to airport shuttle: - a short trip allows battery needs to not be excessive - bypass traffic, you don't have to go all that fast to get a huge speedup, and remove the extra buffer time on traffic uncertainty - radically less infrastructure than roads or rails, reduces the cost of adding more pickup zones In cites with poor airport to downtown infrastructure you could probably start off as a high-end service and charge i.e. 5x than an airport limo.
- javiramos 9y agoYes, Manhattan-La Guardia
- zhoujianfu 9y agoAnd you could do the security check at the downtown station to offload some of that from the airport (while also handling the need to screen people before they get on the flying taxi.)
- aarmenante 9y agoDoesn’t a helicopter serve these needs? I think the problem is there isn’t a market for it yet. There is Blade in NYC and LA but it’s closer to 10x the price. I think the cost could be a lot lower if there was higher demand. I think there doesn’t need to be new tech to make this work. Helicopters are safe and reliable, but are out of reach financially for most. I don’t see how drones or multirotor would be able to compete on price for a very long time.
- prostoalex 9y agoIf the drone is autonomous and electric motor-driven, at least the human labor cost and fuel cost are taken out of equation.
- FabHK 9y agoWhy do you think electric drones have taken off as toys and for filming etc, when remote controlled helicopters have been available for ages? Because they have better properties for many use cases: much simpler mechanically, cheaper to operate, easier to control, etc. I’d also expect drones to be more reliable, but that remains to be seen.
- brudgers 9y agoIn the US Flying Taxis/cars would require require a massive change in FAA regulations. In 2015, there were 6,876 air carrier aircraft.[1] Roughly 1/50,000 people. Air carrier aircraft are the only aircraft authorized to carry passengers for hire. There are so few because getting an aircraft certified is hard. Not just for commercial use. Even private use. Most private planes in the US were built in the 20th century. And there were only 210,000 of them in 2015. Roughly 1/1500 people. Even among the commercial fleet, many air carrier aircraft are more than thirty years old because FAA certification is so difficult. To put it in automotive terms, much of what is flying in the US is analogous to a 1973 Dodge Dart or a 1985 F600. Aircraft in the US are like old cars in Cuba. The number of aircraft in the sky is limited by long standing policies against general ownership. The FAA licensing of drone pilots is part of a general stance of limiting access to private aviation that began long long before 9/11. Just compare the number of private aircraft to recreational boats. [1]: https://www.rita.dot.gov/bts/sites/rita.dot.gov.bts/files/publications/national_transportation_statistics/html/table_01_11.html https://www.rita.dot.gov/bts/sites/rita.dot.gov.bts/files/pu...
- oldcynic 9y agoWhich is why the skies are so safe. It's not about limiting access. FAA licencing is one of the more liberal aviation regimes across the world.
- brudgers 9y agoFAA regulations make the sky inaccessible to the general citizenry. The safety claim is analogous to a world in which the roads were restricted to commercial vehicles and sports car owners. Safety is primarily achieved by limiting access and hence use.
- closeparen 9y agoFlying is available to the general public through the private, recreational, and sport pilot licensing programs. The main barrier to obtaining one of these licenses is the fuel, aircraft rental, and instructor labor costs involved in practicing.
- cmurf 9y agoRight now all ATC clearances (routing, takeoff, landing) are done by AM radio. So how would a pilotless taxi do this? Drones don't, as currently UAS are physically separated into their own airspace, they also can't fly in instrument/zero visibility conditions. To share the same space requires either really agile and smart flying taxis that will always avoid legacy aircraft, regardless of conditions, a kind of "smart separation" of aircraft, or we need a new air traffic control system. Setting aside ATC's automation, even autonomous aircraft has all sorts of unsolved technical problems. The reality today is that the vast majority of flights are not automated at all when it comes to taxi, takeoff, and landings. Most flights use Visual Flight Rules. The landing capacity of airports when using Instrument Flight Rules is substantially less, and there are various technical reasons why not least of which is that there is only one kind of precision approach to landing system, and it requires ground systems, airborne system, and pilot competency and certification. So we need a separate system invented for autonomous systems to do this at scale, while also integrating into the existing VFR and IFR systems for legacy aircraft. Or someone comes up with a cheap enough retrofit of existing airplane cockpits that this can happen really fast, and just ban all the legacy aircraft from operating in autonmous only space (make it Class A, B and C space). That's sort of a joke because this would be very expensive. But maybe a hybrid pilot with augmented non-human secondary pilot could make this vaguely plausible. Add in both FAA and ICAO regulations (global regulations apply for obvious reasons), economics, politics, and it's just really complicated. So I have to laugh every time I read "technical problems all solved" and "this could happen in 5 to 10 years". That's something I've heard for 30 years...
- ph0rque 9y agoATC clearance API? There's a startup idea...
- prostoalex 9y ago> Right now all ATC clearances (routing, takeoff, landing) are done by AM radio. So how would a pilotless taxi do this? That is the status quo, but FAA has been trying to move to an automated system forever (they were testing ATD-1 in KMWH as of last year) https://www.aviationsystemsdivision.arc.nasa.gov/research/tactical/ATD1_FS-2015-09-01-ARC_Web.pdf https://www.aviationsystemsdivision.arc.nasa.gov/research/ta... Most likely they will have to set up special flight rules for unmanned taxis. It also helps that rotor-driven vehicles don't need the runways the way the airplanes do - any large parking lot next to the airport could be designated as UAS landing space.