18 ms·
Millions Are Hounded for Debt They Don’t Owe. One Victim Fought Back
- nevir 9y agoDitto taxes. I moved to California in 2014. In 2016, I got a letter saying I owed back taxes (state) for 2012 on an estimated income. Took quite some time to clean that one up :-/
- coding123 9y agoIf a single paid employee at the FTC was this vigilant, there might be no scamming in the US. Time to replace the agency.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoOr they're all busy working on other equally important issues. Or they actually are working on busting other scammers. Or any one of a billion things that are invisible to you as a "civilian".
- coding123 9y agoMake all loans signed by an private key, all payments toward the loan signed by a private key. If the signatures don't match then credit reporting agencies should not be allowed to use it. I did more in 1 minute of thought than the entire ftc just now.
- s73ver_ 9y agoYou posted a comment on a website. You have not done a single thing to implement that, nor a single thing to tackle the immense logistics of getting everyone, including people who might not have a computer, a private key, securing that key, or dealing with the fallout that happens when people's private keys inevitably get leaked.
- michaelmrose 9y agoWhy would a central agency even have everyone's private key? All they ought to have is a record of whom a given public part of the key pair belongs to. If you lose your private key or leak it you don't go to the government to get it back you just pay some money to have a second key issued and the original declared to be invalid. All debt assigned to the original public part of the key pair would be transferred to the new one unless you could show that it is fraudulent much like you would if your debit card number was stolen. Additionally the private key shouldn't ever be shared it should be stored on a physical device and proof of having the public key ought to be the only thing transmitted. Its true that there are logistical challenges involved but they are the boring and tedious kind. Work that nobody wants to do.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> Why would a central agency even have everyone's private key? Why would people store the majority of their cryptocurrency on an exchange? Besides, a leak can happen without a big centralized repository - a flaw in the software used to generate and locally store these keys could be exploited, or a flaw in the generation algorithm itself, or any of a number of things. > Its true that there are logistical challenges involved but they are the boring and tedious kind. Work that nobody wants to do. I think that was part of s73ver_'s point, and what coding123 completely glossed over.
- bhhaskin 9y agoWho issues the private keys? What happens if the keys are compromised? What happens to the debt if a key is lost? How do you migrate older debt to the new system? How would this solve the issue of proving the person you are talking to actually owes the debt? There are soooo many questions and things to figure out in such a big and complicated system. It's easy to criticize, especially when you aren't actually responsible for execution.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoNo, you just armchair quarterbacked a "why don't you just" solution.
- brndnmtthws 9y agoYou seem to be under the mistaken impression that the US government cares about ordinary people.
- wpietri 9y agoI would like to see your data for this. In 2012, the FTC put on their Robocall Summit. It was livestreamed, so I watched it. One thing I took from it was that there were many smart and dedicated people at the FTC, but that it was a hard problem. One thing they didn't say, but I suspect is true, is that the FTC is not well supported by Congress. Look at how hard it was to ban telemarketing in the first place. Look at how energetically the CFPB is being undermined. Dedicated people aren't enough. You need institutional support, including money, resources, and laws that actually let you put the criminals in jail.
- AmVess 9y agoFederal watchdog agencies and underfunded, understaffed, and overworked. The people need replacing are the nitwits that have long since been purchased by the companies they are supposed to be protecting us from.
- matte_black 9y agoReplace it with what exactly? It’s not like there’s a secret reserve of smart, dedicated people who know what they are doing.
- Terr_ 9y agoGenerally speaking an ineffective agency is the result of certain political blocs in Congress trying to limit it or cripple it... Either out of political philosophy or to satisfy some donors. That's why the IRS is underfunded despite basically being a revenue center. That's why the ATF is forced to do manual searches of paper files. If all one does is call to replace the agency, that just provides even more opportunity to the saboteurs in charge.
- nunez 9y agoThere is an awesome podcast episode of Planet Money on how vicious these debt collectors can be and why they are “allowed” to be that way. Listen to it here: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/08/354591198/episode-574-the-buffalo-talk-off https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2014/10/08/354591198/epis...
- vxNsr 9y agoThere's another one about how to fight these types of loans in court, I can't seem to find it now though.
- eagletusk 9y agoCould it be Ralph Nader on Small Claims Court? I successfully, based on this video took Verizon to court over an overcharge of just $12 and I won. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YjH4Us0n0QY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YjH4Us0n0QY
- vxNsr 9y agoWasn't that, but that's pretty informative as well. The gist was that some of these lenders will try to garnish your wages by filing a lawsuit alleging that you owe them the money. About 60% of the time the defendants don't show up to court and so there's a default judgment in favor of garnishment. Even if the defendant does show, they'll usually ask to settle out of court or try to claim it wasn't them. The one thing most people don't know is that if you just say "show me the proof" the case will be dismissed by the prosecution because they don't have any proof. You then quickly counter sue for them to remove it from your credit file and/or lost wages if you think you can prove they were filing frivolously.
- klenwell 9y agoI suspect you're thinking of this This American Life episode: https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/532/transcript https://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/532/...
- DoofusOfDeath 9y agoIt's frustrating that a private citizen had to do this all himself. It reminds me of the problem of robocall scammers. If the government really cared, the problem would be fixed.
- wpietri 9y agoDefinitely. John Rogers, who wrote Leverage, a whole TV series about vigilantes striking back against the crooked, makes some excellent points here: https://twitter.com/jonrog1/status/938450037276733440 https://twitter.com/jonrog1/status/938450037276733440
- sjg007 9y agoI think the robocallers started calling members of Congress which is why they got shut down.. Now they just need to be called by the your windows computer is infected guys.
- jimnotgym 9y agoPerhaps if we all called a congressman and claimed he owes us money...not condoning it...
- throwaway613834 9y agoWhen did robocalls get shut down? Was it recent?
- jerf 9y agoI think there are probably several times that could be said to be "the time robocalls were shut down". Currently, I'm living in one of the times they are not shut down. Apparently student loan refinancing is quite lucrative now. I neither know much about it nor (personally) care, since mine have been paid off for a while, but apparently every state in the union has someone who is desperate to let me know about their services. In the last couple of weeks they've started leaving voice mails instead of just ignoring them when I hang up. (I'd be slightly less frustrated at the amount of advertising targeting and surveillance done if "the system" (scare quoted because I know it's not really one thing) would figure out that, say, I don't need to hear about student loan refinancing.)
- pascalxus 9y agoCertainly, none of those people deserve to be taken advantage of like that. But, for those who are willing to pay 150$ interest on a two-week 500$ loan, they've got even bigger problems. In a world where money is everything, people must learn how to use it. Basic Personal finance should be taught k-12 as a primary subject, it's far more important than anything else you could possibly learn.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mrkurt 9y agoPredatory loans can't really be solved with education, at least not a simple "personal finance" course. People don't get loans like that because they're dumb, they get loans like that because they're stuck and desperate: https://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21663262-why-low-income-americans-often-have-pay-more-its-expensive-be-poor https://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21663262-why-lo...
- wyager 9y agoI hear this a lot, but everyone I know who had debt trouble did so because they made a dumb purchase (or 20) with debt, not because they had no other options. I have trouble believing the maximally charitable explanation.
- CocaKoala 9y agoNone of the people I know are in massive debt, therefore I have trouble believing that anybody is in massive debt. Does that sound like a reasonable assertion?
- craftyguy 9y agoUnderstanding personal finance would give people the tools to help avoid becoming stuck and desperate in the first place (obviously not in every case)
- bluetwo 9y agoAnd yet we are letting the president neuter the CFPB.
- username223 9y ago> If it’s just about me, I don’t particularly give a f---. You call my wife, and you call my grandparents? You just opened up a door that got really f---ing ugly, and now I’m going to make sure that I just ruin your life. This guy is a hero.
- rootlocus 9y agoActually, for a person who considers themselves a good Christian ("he takes pride in being a more responsible person than his parents—paying his bills on time, going to church on Sunday, and taking care of those close to him") that threat is kind of hypocritical. The truly correct outcome would have all the stolen money back to the victims (together with their wasted time and moral damage), and safeguards placed to make sure this never happens again. Ruining someone's life would serve no purpose in that direction. EDIT: Since people have trouble understanding my point: it's not justice (morally or legally) to ruin someone's life. This guy isn't a hero for making a threat. He's a hero for making a change which would actually help other people.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>safeguards placed to make sure this never happens again Safeguards are great but there should be a penalty for bypassing them, we need to take people who commit crimes like this and throw them in prison.
- rootlocus 9y agoIf they don't work, they're not actually safeguards.
- cgmg 9y agoHaha, what? Please explain how ruining someone's life, which he believes deserves to be ruined due to their taking advantage of the poor, is 'hypocritical'.
- revelation 9y agoObligatory patio11 link: http://www.kalzumeus.com/2017/09/09/identity-theft-credit-reports/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2017/09/09/identity-theft-credit-re...
- s73ver_ 9y agoGiven that the US Supreme Court made the obscene mistake of saying that 3rd party debt collectors don't fall under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, expect harassment like this to become more common.
- Aloha 9y agoCan you show a citation for this? last I looked into this, all debt collectors are abound to the FDCPA
- razwall 9y agohttp://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/henson-v-santander-consumer-usa-inc/ http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/cases/henson-v-santande... They were simply confirming the plain meaning of the FDCPA, which applies to people who collect debt that is owed to another person. Junk debt buyers buy their debt outright, so they're not collecting on someone else's behalf, so FDCPA doesn't apply. If people are upset about this, they should direct that toward Congress for not having amended the law.
- s73ver_ 9y agoI believe directing ire at the SCOTUS for being that bone headedly idiotic in that decision, especially in a political environment where they had to have known there would not be a legislative solution anytime soon is also warranted.
- s73ver_ 9y agoYou know, if we switched our law enforcement priorities from low level drug offenses to getting rid of these scumbags, our prisons might be just as full (appeasing the private prisons lobby), but at least they'd be full of people who actually have done wrong, and we'd be making life better for everyone else.
- wnevets 9y agoThis is what happens when you make debt collection a for profit endeavour.
- razwall 9y agoWhat other kind of endeavor could it possibly be?
- harrumph 9y ago>What other kind of endeavor could it possibly be? Debt collection begins its life as a cost of doing business for the lender or service provider. It could be forced by law to remain that way by disallowing the sale of original debt.
- razwall 9y agoFair enough, but it seems arbitrary and capricious to single out debt collection as the one and only business function that you're not allowed to outsource. Just like accounting, payroll, advertising, lawyering, etc., it requires a specialized body of skill and knowledge that many businesses would rather not have to develop in-house.
- dragonwriter 9y agoPreventing selling debt wouldn't prevent outsourcing of collections, I can pay someone to collect debt without selling them the debt. I can even make their fee contingent on their success in collection.
- harrumph 9y ago>I can pay someone to collect debt without selling them the debt. True. Legislation designed to reduce collections abuse could make contracting illegal or strictly limit outsourcing to companies with operational records that are free of abuse.
- 9y ago
- TallGuyShort 9y agoI've had multiple encounters with debt collection agencies that all ended up being for medical bills that were never processed correctly in the first place that I had never seen before. In every single case so far it's been a legitimate, state-licensed debt collector, they have not fulfilled the requirements set by law to prove the debt, and the have just used scare tactics and bureaucracy to avoid a fair confrontation. I've filed complaints with the state regulator, at which point token (but inadequate) documentation has been provided and my complaint "resolved". I have little sympathy for most cases in which people rack up debt and try to escape the consequences, but Good Lord, the other side of that equation is shady as Hell, even when done far more legitimately than this.
- finkin1 9y agoYou should contact a bankruptcy attorney. I used to work for one and he loved cases where debt collectors violate collection laws. Getting a settlement was almost always easy and he split it 50-50 with the client.
- TallGuyShort 9y agoThank you for the suggestion. I just dug up documentation of the most recent case and left a message with a local bankruptcy attorney :)
- TallGuyShort 9y agoAlas - it's been just over a year, and the statute of limitations is up. Next time.
- pc86 9y agoWow, even ambulance chasing personal injury attorneys only take 30-35%.
- jzl 9y agoYep, same here. I got hounded by a collector for a fee that was incorrectly applied to a paid-off medical bill from three years prior. The only way I was able to fend them off was by sending a copy of a statement that I managed to find in the back of a folder buried under hundreds of pages of miscellaneous medical stuff. Moral of the story? Keep all medical paperwork for at least seven years. I've always done this and once in a blue moon it saves a massive amount of headache. You have to assume these days that someone will try to make money off you for not having records.
- djtriptych 9y agoReminds me of the time Optimum continued charging me for SIX MONTHS after cancelling their ISP service. Couldn't get it resolved and ultimately got collections notices for the debt. I had to get the city (NYC) involved and threaten to sue before I got to someone who was willing to resolve it.
- logfromblammo 9y agoI think if you ever get to the point where you feel like you have to threaten to sue in order to get something fixed, you should probably just visit your local small claims clerk or civil lawsuits lawyer and actually do it. The other thing that might work is social media shaming. Calling ordinary customer service reps has become increasingly useless over the last 40 years.
- lostcolony 9y agoThis. Nothing like a lawsuit to get a company to actually respond; even if they win it, the cost of sending someone to address it is almost guaranteed to be more than if they just settled the issue.
- logfromblammo 9y agoBesides that, if you threaten to sue, you're just giving them time to construct a defense strategy instead of addressing the actual issue at hand. With the threat, the burden is still on you to take action. With an actual lawsuit, they must act within a certain interval, or you win by default.
- bitsnbytes 9y agoI had the same thing happen with Comcast. I filed a complaint with the FCC online for erroneous billing and the inability to cancel my account. Forwarded the FCC complaint in an email to comcast and within a day got a response .A few days later they acknowledged that I was erroneously billed 600 bucks and that they actually owed me 10 bucks. Good thing these people are now going to be our internet gatekeepers.
- solaxun 9y agoWow... that was a cathartic read. I wish I could meet Andrew, shake his hand, and buy him a beer or something.
- AceJohnny2 9y agoI, too, can enjoy a good revenge story, especially in the current climate of credit uncertainty after the Equifax breach. I expect this will become a much bigger problem.
- solaxun 9y agoIt's been a problem for a long time with which I've had first hand experience. Years ago when I was in college a collector called my parent's house after being rebuked by me and convinced them to pay off the "debt" by appealing to their parental instincts. The very next day they called back asking for more stating it wasn't "paid in full". This despite the fact that they had told my parents the "debt" would be satisfied upon the requested payment. It was literally an outright lie, no room for interpretation, no grey area. These people are the scum of the earth and I hate to say it, but all the misfortune the perpetrators suffered in the article is well deserved (in my candidly vengeful opinion). This may not be the soundest advice, but IMO once you've gone to collections, the credit damage is done, and it's not worth paying them off strictly for the risk that they may be scamming you. It's sad that that murky corny of the industry has been allowed to continue harassment of consumers relatively unabated. I see people in this thread getting down-voted for calling out the FTC and other agencies for lack of action, but they are dead on. If one man in his free time during the evenings can bring down a $1bn+ fraudulent operation, how can you possibly think the government is doing enough? Perhaps Andrew should be hired by the FBI.
- adamw2k 9y agoSeems like an opportunity to setup a one-man non-profit, crowdfund it, and have him spend the rest of his life working on something he clearly has a passion for. I imagine many netizens would chip in a few $...
- rootlocus 9y agoJohn Oliver covered predatory lending in an episode of Last Week Tonight https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PDylgzybWAw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PDylgzybWAw
- cavanasm 9y agoAnd bought a massive amount of student loan debt, which was immediately forgiven, giving his show the record for largest TV giveaway (taking the record from Oprah).
- rootlocus 9y agoThat's a different episode [0] but indeed pretty epic. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxUAntt1z2c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxUAntt1z2c
- donarb 9y agoIt was actually medical debt that at one point may have been worth $15M, but was bought for about $60,000, which is less than one half of one percent of that value. This was essentially worthless non-recoverable and out-of-statute debt. Out-of-statute debt is debt that collectors cannot legally sue for. Lots of symbolism, but no actual relief for debtors. http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2016/06/06/john_oliver_did_not_really_give_away_15_million_on_his_show.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2016/06/06/john_oliver_d...
- rootlocus 9y agoConsidering that people are still harassed for out-of-statue debt, and some even pay, there is actually some relief. Of course, not $15M relief that's certain.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoThey are also harassed for debt that never actually existed, so it might not be any relief at all.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoWhy won't the FTC pursue jail time? I think Andrew is right in not stopping, this guy perpetrated a huge fraud, just telling him to pay back money he'll never have isn't enough, he should be behind bars.
- nradov 9y agoThe FTC isn't a law enforcement agency and has no power to file criminal charges. However they do notify federal law enforcement when they find evidence of criminal activity.
- vxNsr 9y agoFeels like block-chain authentication could resolve parts of this.... If we required that all debt be digitally signed in a central ledger, either nationally or by state, and then all payment transactions were also recorded there, it'd be a lot harder to fake this stuff... first though we need someone in gov to understand bc tech. I know that most big banks and FI have a few devs working on some sorta blockchain ledger for internal transactions, and apparently the big exchanges are very seriously considering using them as well, so it shouldn't be too difficult to make the leap to loans. ugh, I know we hate just saying throw current fad at this problem, but I'd like to know more why people are against this idea. I know the idea isn't perfect and would require a lot of work shopping but the current model of lenders selling each other spreadsheets with just a $$$ amount and phone number simply isn't sustainable.
- shawabawa3 9y agoWhy blockchain? If you have a trusted entity (the government) you just need a public database.
- vxNsr 9y agoBecause that trusted entity kinda sucks at these things. Also it'll mollify the people who don't wanna cede all control to the government. Some central database controlled by the government doesn't solve the issue that all databases have, which is that you need to have absolute trust in the people who admin that db, the beauty of blockchains is that trust is no longer needed, as long as the there are a reasonably diverse number of entities involved no single person can make unilateral changes. Also this would mean that we could go from each lender and predator having all my personal info to just retaining my public key which can unlock more info with their private one, but means they are no longer selling my phone # and ssn because they don't need to store it. I truly believe that the power of blockchain tech isn't in $1200 btc but in powerful and secure logging.
- nradov 9y agoThat doesn't actually fix anything, it just replaces one problem with a set of worse problems. There's no good way to manage the private keys. Many borrowers will inevitably lose control of their keys, either accidentally or by hacking. Then what?
- bobo_legos 9y agoI've been dealing with this for years. Every once in a while I get a call from some random debt collector looking for a guy with my name who skipped out on his college loans. I've gotten letters threatening wage garnishment. One time they even called my Mom's cell phone saying they needed to serve me papers. The conversation ended when it got to S/Ns(which didn't match) and me demanding they never call again. Eventually the conversations got real quick when I'd stop them before they got to begin saying, "No I didn't live at XXX, No I didn't go to college at XXX, No I don't have XXX in student loans." Luckily I've never had to deal with the level of threats that this guy went through. It's been a while since I've gotten a call looking for this guy with my name. Maybe there's no one left who wants to try to collect this debt.
- sf_rob 9y agoI'm very surprised that they stopped bothering you. I got debt collector calls for years for someone who used to have my number. For a while I tried to get them to stop calling me by asking for the name of their collection agency (75% hang up) or by asking that they don't contact me in any form again (compliance with the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act). The latter works, but they are legally allowed to resell your debt so the next day I'd get a call from a different collections agency. You'll never get them all to stop calling you so it's easier to deal with the one that you know. Overall it's been an interesting experience. As someone who grew up middle class, had a scholarship, and lives frugally I would have otherwise not realized how predatory debt collectors are. Instead I've written my representatives many times asking that they create stronger consumer protections in this area. Edit: Oh, also they aren't legally allowed to share the collections detail of the individual, so I couldn't research his debts further without claiming to be him, which I actually considered but decided against.
- greedo 9y agoYeah, middle class isn't as much of a target since they push back more than the poor. I read a great quote from John Rogers on twitter that put it in perspective for me: "you're life's not good because you worked hard. Plenty of good people work hard & their life is still shit. Your life's good because you haven't been judged a sufficiently delicious morsel by someone higher on the economic food chain."
- greymeister 9y ago"He who fights with monsters should look to it that he himself does not become a monster. And if you gaze long into an abyss, the abyss also gazes into you."
- draw_down 9y agoI don’t think that was meant in reference to debt collectors.
- fridek 9y agoThis is more or less how spam was almost solved in 2006 by Blue Frog [1]. Instead of trying to fight the spam distribution, they fought people who buy spam by contacting them directly for every email sent to them by users. The resulting DDoS and shutdown of the service was sad but inevitable. Still makes me feel nostalgic for the brief moment of hope some human behaviour might get better as the internet evolves, and makes me wish some corporation which claims to be socially responsible picked it up, supported and defended it. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Frog https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Frog
- endorphone 9y agoIt is off-putting how this story starts with the sort of morally-loaded rhetoric used to denigrate the indebted. Rhetoric that only is applied to the lower class, it should be noted. He was offended at being labelled a "deadbeat" -- a term they use more than once -- and then a company wrote him a letter saying he never borrowed from them (despite the paragraph before saying he did, in fact, borrow from them [edit - my misreading on that. He doesn't know who he borrowed from]). Okay. This was a company/group trying to criminally defraud people. Even in the legitimate debt realm there are criminal tactics to attempt to recover debt, usually after it has been written off and gone through multiple hands. The whole debt industry is a scumbag, shady industry, preying on the vulnerable. The debt/credit industry has an enormous number of punishers, from credit scores that can prevent you from getting a job to court-ordered remedies. They don't need the lobsters repeating their nonsense.
- CocaKoala 9y ago> then a company wrote him a letter saying he never borrowed from them (despite the paragraph before saying he did, in fact, borrow from them). Okay. You misunderstood that paragraph. He got a payday loan from an online lender, and paid it back promptly. The online lender was not Vista, the company to which his alleged debt purported to be owed. *edited so I don't end a sentence with a preposition. I have no idea how by that slipped me.
- sls 9y agoN.B. ending an English sentence with a preposition is fine, c.f. https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/grammar/ending-sentences-with-prepositions https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/grammar/ending-sentences-w... - it's just aping Latin style
- jdmichal 9y agoI'm sure you didn't mean it, but your sentence could be interpreted that ending with a preposition is aping Latin. That particular tradition comes from English's Germanic roots. Latin languages typically have non-compound verbs which cover the same concepts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phrasal_verb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phrasal_verb
- imchillyb 9y agohttp://www.usdebtclock.org/ http://www.usdebtclock.org/ A country that owes 20+ TRILLION dollars in debt, and has a shortfall of cash, for the current year, in the hundreds of billions of dollars, should NEVER allow debt collection on its citizens. Until the country's leadership pays its debts, resolves its deficit, and starts anew with a clean slate, its citizens should receive the same debt protection the state enjoys. If the country won't pay its obligations, the citizens should have free reign to do the same. What's good for the state, is good for its citizens.
- LanceH 9y agoThe country is in debt, not default.
- mikeash 9y agoThe country pays its obligations. When was the last time the US government defaulted on its debt?
- glorkk 9y agoYou realize that national debt, corporate debt and personal debt don’t work the same right? Countries can go on paying only the interest on their debt forever. And how would the US finance this massive debt repayment? The only ways are to sell state assets, cut services and raise taxes. I’m not sure the population will be happy with these measures.
- kbenson 9y agoThere's a distinction between debt, and failure to pay. The whole point of the continuous debates we have over raising the debt ceiling is to make sure the U.S. government can continue to function and be able to pay its debts. If I borrowed $100 from you yesterday with the understanding I would pay it back in seven days, I'm in debt to you, but in good standing. If I borrowed it six months ago and it was due a week after that, I am not in good standing. Those situations are not equivalent. This is not to defend horrible collection practices or the debt collection industry in general. But making some odd claim about U.S. government debt being equivalent to this needs a lot more explanation if you want it to be taken seriously.
- nautilus12 9y agoJust curious, this guy is obviously not getting payed for his heroic effort. But is there anyway that we can (or should) incentivize this behavior, either for lawyers or for others? Im guessing lawyers dont make a career out of hunting these people down because it doesnt really pay because so many are small potatoes? Can a lawyer comment?
- ficklepickle 9y agoI say we crowd fund it and turn it into the feel good reality TV (internet?) hit of the year
- nautilus12 9y agoIs there a way technology can better be leveraged to verify debt? Would such a centralized system be dangerous? What about a decentralized one? It scares me that someone can put my name in a spreadsheet with 300 next to it and it can cause so many to be fooled
- WkndTriathlete 9y agoIt would be funny if the ultimate use of a blockchain was to validate debt and put debt scammers out of business instead of being used as a currency replacement.
- GFischer 9y agoWell, we have a national ID here in my country that significantly reduces the bizarreness that is the U.S. system of not being able to verify who actually owes a debt.... (not that we don't have annoying debt collectors, but not in this scale and with those errors). In my opinion, a national ID's benefits SIGNIFICANTLY outweigh their theoretical downsides (I mean, the NSA already exists). It makes my life easier (but I still end up developing systems for the U.S. and I have to assume they don't have IDs :P )
- RightMillennial 9y agoThis was a very compelling read. We need more poeple like Therrien to make a stand. The fact that this sort of injustice is allowed to thrive really makes my blood boil. It makes me wish I had become a lawyer or some other legal professional instead with the authority to prosecute these predators and scammers.
- balabaster 9y agoIf he managed all this on top of a full time job and maintaining family life, just for the love of setting a wrong right, imagine what he would have achieved if this had been his full time job. Someone needs to give this guy a job and pay him to do this. There aren't enough people in the world that will stand up and do the right thing instead of just paying it lip service. For that alone, this guy is a hero to me.
- wlll 9y agoI was thinking just this as I read the article. If I had the money I'd just pay this guy to chase these people down.
- kodablah 9y agoLikewise. Needs to be a crowd-funded fight-the-man where the patrons can vote on the cause and watch progress.
- jxramos 9y agoI'd chip into that pot just for the pure entertainment of it all.
- dkersten 9y agoMe too. Both for the entertainment and because I dislike debt collectors. In my experience, they're all lying pieces of shit.
- ficklepickle 9y agoI love it. Make it a platform and call it something hip like vicarious.ly I could totally get into that.
- jaredandrews 9y agoThe body count in this article is unreal.
- andrewl 9y agoDoes anybody know if this kind of thing is as common in other countries as it is in the US? Are there stronger controls in, say, Germany or France, or Norway and Denmark, that make abuse on this scale impossible? Or is the situation as bad in those countries as here?
- raarts 9y agoI'm from the Netherlands, in my fifties, but haven't heard of anything like this here. A quick Google of the Dutch internet also turned up nothing.
- inflagranti 9y agoThere are similar shady companies in Germany that try individual scams surrounding phantom bills, sometimes for phantom services, but it generally stops at that company and selling dept is not a thing. Most countries also don't have central credit scoring entities like Equifax which scare people into avoiding bad credit history and more likely to just pay.
- russellbeattie 9y agoBanks and other institutions are willing to sell debt to collection agencies for pennies on the dollar, but aren't willing to make those same concessions to the debtors themselves, regardless of circumstance. The whole system isn't just unfair, it's vindictive.
- nisse72 9y agoSolution: become a debt collector, and buy your own debt!
- jimnotgym 9y agoNot sure about the US but in the UK you should never pay over money to see where it goes. Paying a debt is an admission, and resets the clock on the time bar (6 years from last payment a debt is statute barred)
- silverbax88 9y agoI read that as well, and I'm pretty sure that's still the case in the US as well. You never pay "debts" unless you're sure it's legitimate. NEVER. And I say that as a person who has actually done some of the same things as the man in the article. Not to the lengths he has...but, yeah, I've spooked quite a few debt collectors. It's one of the few times in life you can unleash against all the wrongdoing in the world and aggressively berate/hound/harrass some scumbag who completely deserves it, and has no idea when they've crossed the wrong person.
- codedokode 9y agoIt is interesting that we live in a world where everything is recorded, companies and even mobile applications collect everything they can, NSA listens to every international call, but when it comes to catching real criminals, this system just doesn't work.
- johansch 9y agoSweden has this construct that you should probably just copy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enforcement_Authority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enforcement_Authority The US seems like it's stuck in the wild west ways of doing things.
- OrwellianChild 9y agoInteresting concept, though the Wikipedia article itself seems to indicate this system has its flaws: "In Sweden, even with the existence of the Enforcement Authority, it is still considered complicated, so most companies use debt collection companies for the process anyway, similar to in other countries."
- tolle 9y agoHuh? I mean, if you don't pay a bill, it'll usually go to a private company trying to collect it at first. But they simply send out another bill with an additional charge added. After a few attempts they will in turn hand it over to the Enforcement Authority. I've never heard of anyone using anything but the Enforcement Authority as a last resort to claim a debt.
- codazoda 9y agoI recently cancelled Met Life Car Insurance. My new insurance policy was paid in advance so my old one probably was too. Met Life sent me to collections for a $180 bill they say I owed after cancelling. My agent, a broker, cannot explain why I owe the $180 since I had likely paid in advance. I also can't prove that I don't owe because I'd have to go back through nearly 10 years of statements to balance everything out. I'm buying a house and can't have the debt show up on my credit so I pay the bill. Obviously I'm still a little pissed about it. This article is making me wonder if Met Life or my agent released my details to a similar company when I cancelled. As a side note, I wrote a letter to the president of Met Life insurance on another policy that they had failed to cancel. The president's office responded with a letter that said they corrected the date and that I had no balance. That letter came on the same day as another letter showing that it had been cancelled retroactively but that I owed a remainder of $25. Their letters were in conflict with each other.
- CGamesPlay 9y agoEvery time you write a check for a recurring service, in the memo field include "services through X", so you will always know that you were paying for services through a given date, and it won't matter if it's paid before or after the services are rendered. Similarly, every invoice you got from Met Life should also have a coverage date range on it. Shouldn't ever be ambiguous.
- buckminster 9y ago$150 interest on a $500 loan over two weeks does not annualize to 700%. It's closer to 92,000%!
- JBlue42 9y agoGreat story and something I had to help my parents deal with as well (though not to this extent). I personally think payday lending should be banned nationwide. The thing is, there are people that depend on that sort of resource or small loans so what is a better way to do this that doesn't lead to bad outcomes? There was all the hoopla over Muhummad Yunas and microloans back in the day and P2P lending now. I assume there will be some sort of blockchain P2P lending soon as well. Also, I used to watch Dirty Jobs every now and then and sometimes the environment or role would look pretty gross but I can't imagine having to be one of these people as a job. Swimming in real filth is probably better for the soul than swimming in this immoral filth.
- s73ver_ 9y agoPayday lending itself isn't the problem. It's the usury that's the problem. Unfortunately, that was deregulated, so states are unable to enforce their own anti-usury laws.
- JBlue42 9y agoI didn't know there had been regulations. It sounds like there might still be some in place but maybe they aren't adequate enough or as enforceable (or politically chosen not to enforce): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usury#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usury#United_States In the following country analysis, I was surprised to see Canada set a limit of 60%/yr, which seems incredibly high. Japan seems to have a decent policy.
- s73ver_ 9y agoWell, as it says, there's no national law. However, the law followed is not the law where the borrower resides, but the law where the lender is headquartered. Which is why so many of the payday lenders are headquartered in New Jersey and South Dakota; those states were willing to gut their consumer protection laws in order to lure jobs.
- JBlue42 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sailfast 9y agoIf you're in the US, file a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. They will at least try to get a point of contact for the business to respond to the complaint. In general, there are a number of good answers to questions and strategies here when responding to collectors: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/category-debt-collection/ https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/category-debt-colle...
- kevin_b_er 9y agoThe CFPB is being intentionally attacked by the Republican Party. I suspect we'll see it completely destroyed in the near future. It helped the common person too much against banks and false debt. As long as that party maintains any power, do not expect much anymore out of the government protecting you or your fellow citizens against abuse from false collectors. * http://money.cnn.com/2017/11/28/news/economy/cfpb-trump-mulvaney-economy-lending/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2017/11/28/news/economy/cfpb-trump-mulv...
- paul7986 9y agoIt's 2017 the solution to this problem is never answer a call from an unknown caller. Problem solved especially if this guy, his wife and other family members followed this mantra. A mantra Im sure all of us follow on Hacker News. I only pick up the phone from those in my phone book or have a call scheduled with someone new. I then add them to my contacts or make note of their number.
- osamet67 9y agoShameless plug: That's exactly why we started TrueAccord (www.trueaccord.com). 1. People in debt aren't "deadbeats" and deserve to be treated well 2. Using technology to make the process about financial health and treating people like regular customers makes a huge difference
- snowpanda 9y agoYou might want to remove Yelp from your featured clients, they aren't exactly known as a moral company.
- AElsinore77 9y agoIf you encounter a problem with agencies collecting on illegitimate debt, it may be reported to the credit bureaus, which can be a big deal for you (buying home, etc). The bureaus wont help you; I went through an 18-month ordeal figuring out how to clear these things, and heres what I suggest: -get up to speed on FDCPA rights -officially dispute the collection -pursue the original debtor, and get a resolution in writing. sue them in small claims to get a judgement in your favor if you need to. -send a copy of the resolution to the debt collector and the credit bureau dispute centers Hope this helps in case anyone is dealing with this kind of stuff.
- Animats 9y agoIt's quite possible to do more via lawsuits, especially in California. One guy got a judgment against Bank of America and showed up at a branch with sheriff's deputies and a moving van to seize property.[1] He was paid very quickly. I once had a business refuse to pay me after a small claims judgment. I paid the sheriff's office for a "till tap" and an "8 hour keeper".[2] That means a sheriff's deputy (usually two of them) goes to the business, shows the court order, and takes the money out of the cash register, arresting anyone who gets in the way. If there's not enough money on hand, the deputies stand behind the register and take in money during the business day until the judgment is paid. The fee for this is about $85, which gets added on to the judgment. It worked for me. [1] http://business.time.com/2011/06/06/homeowner-forecloses-on-bank-of-america-yes-you-heard-that-right/ http://business.time.com/2011/06/06/homeowner-forecloses-on-... [2] http://www.dca.ca.gov/publications/small_claims/collect.shtml http://www.dca.ca.gov/publications/small_claims/collect.shtm...
- blahshaw 9y agoFor a till tap, do deputies compel the business owners to open the till, or is there some kind of skeleton key that law enforcement use?
- kevinchen 9y agoI assume that's where "arresting anyone who gets in the way" comes in
- jklein11 9y agoI think it is the courts that have compelled the business owner to open the till. The deputies are just enforcing the court's judgement.
- gbacon 9y agoSkeleton keys are a plot device in children's cartoons.
- 0xb100d 9y ago
- tmnvix 9y agoIn Australia, the government has been issuing debt notices[1] to some of the poorest citizens (beneficiaries) without first confirming the debts actually exist. It's been called the 'Robodebt scandal' and it's been going on for a year now. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-03-03/centrelink-debt-controversy-what-is-robodebt/8317764 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-03-03/centrelink-debt-contro... [1] Not strictly speaking debt notices, but the gist is the same: "We think you owe this money. If you can't prove otherwise, we will issue a debt notice."
- emmelaich 9y agoThis is just one reason I'm wary of Basic Income. Currently there's almost no-one so poor that they can't be scammed or threatened out of what little they have. Basic Income could just enrich the predators.
- toadi 9y ago"Sometimes, Therrien would make a small payment on the fake debt" Can't do that in my country because that's admitting the debt was right. Also, debt collectors can't overreach like that here. Need to go to court to get your money back. Just bring the proof and normally everything should be OK. At least tha's what happend with me ;)
- vadimberman 9y agoThe guy is a f.n hero! I don't get it, why was he reluctant to go public?
- mcv 9y agoReading the many comments on this story, I've got to say that the whole debt and collection situation in the US looks like a complete mess. I almost never hear these kind of stories from European countries. I have seen companies mess up their administration, but rarely, and usually with some reason. Never does it result in thugs calling you and threatening you. The whole idea that debt gets repackaged and resold to multiple parties is bizarre.