29 ms·
Things Many People Find Too Obvious to Have Told You Already
- wtvanhest 9y agoWhatever this app is, it would be really helpful to not do the jagged edge thing on the top as it makes it completely unreadable for me. I use the top of windows to line up text and without that ability, I basically cannot read the words.
- wnoise 9y ago> CS programs have, in the main, not decided that the primary path to becoming a programmer should involve doing material actual programming. Well, that's because CS programs are designed to teach CS, not to be a vocational school for programmers.
- Cyberdog 9y agoAnd yet many job listings for programmers demand you have a CS degree…
- SadWebDeveloper 9y agoThat's because CS grads always want to be pair with their own and put heavy work on "planning" how to do things well rather than starting working on it.
- throwawayjava 9y agoBecause for many employers "ability to program" is a minimum requirement, not the full job description.
- alexbecker 9y agoFor far more employers, "ability to program" is something they have no idea how to filter for in a pile of resumes, but "CS degree" seems like it might be a usable proxy.
- BeetleB 9y ago>Because for many employers "ability to program" is a minimum requirement, not the full job description I think this was the author's point. You state it is a minimum requirement, implying a CS degree is a more challenging requirement. Yet it's not hard to find people with CS degrees who do not have the minimum requirement.
- hamstercat 9y agoMy first boss once told me that when he looks at hiring, having a CS degree means that you know how to find solution to problems. Being able to code can be learned on the job if needed. Most junior jobs in bigcos are usually code monkey type of work anyway.
- jasonlfunk 9y agoYes. I often explained that CS was more like a math degree than an engineering degree.
- lordnacho 9y agoAn engineering degree won't teach you how to do things, either. I have one. Grads aren't able to build bridges, silicon chips, airplanes, or whatever else engineers are supposed to do. (Ok, I built a radio in my first term. But it was a very simple one.) They just have some intellectual tools that are useful precursors to gaining such knowledge. You can liken CS to something like Chemistry. Is Chemistry about test tubes and HPLC devices? No. Will you learn how test tubes work when you do a chemistry degree? Probably. It just happens that the practical skill practiced by CS majors is coding. And coding has this unusually large applicability that wet lab work doesn't. Does that mean CS is about coding? No. But you'll probably learn more about coding doing CS than most other things.
- hugs 9y agoIronically, an engineering degree is also like a math degree.
- NTDF9 9y agoElectrical engineering surely is.
- auxym 9y agoMeh, at least my (mechanical engineering) degree wasn't. Sure, you learn some mathematical tools that can help you solve some very practical problems, but it stops about there. I was not taught anything close to creative mathematical thinking. I was never taught the fundamentals of things: the axioms and the theorems on which the tools we "learn" are based on. I can guarantee you no one in my graduating class could read a proof of even modest complexity, let alone write one. Granted, I did go to a school with a good reputation, but one of a very practical/applied program. Still, I'm pretty convinced that math and engineering are very, very different fields, even if all engineering programs include a handful of math classes.
- macintux 9y ago...yet that's not obvious to everyone, hence the inclusion.
- macintux 9y agoForgot I just had this argument a couple of months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15502022 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15502022
- allenz 9y agoIt's not about that fact. The author argues that programming schools should be vocational schools (while ostensibly presenting a list of objective facts).
- jack9 9y ago> The author argues that programming schools should be vocational schools I dont see where. The implication is that they are assumed to be contrary to reality. It's supposed to be a list of obvious facts.
- allenz 9y agoThe full tweet, from the link: "CS programs have, in the main, not decided that the primary path to becoming a programmer should involve doing material actual programming. There are some exceptions: Waterloo, for example. This is the point where I joke "That's an exhaustive list" but not sure that a joke." This reads to me that Patrick wishes that the joke were not true, which is corroborated by other comments of his, such as https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7761134#7762383 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7761134#7762383 The fact that you think that the article is in any way objective is why it is so dangerous. Ideology is like water. Patrick's assumptions and biases shape how he presents his "facts" and which facts are left out. It's not objective! What he is really doing is presenting a specific market-based worldview, which has certain insights and major deficiencies. Consider for example "There is no hidden reserve of smart people". It sounds like an actionable insight, but is it true? Is it even falsifiable? What does it mean? And what actions would it lead you to take? My answer: it reinforces the perspective that smart people are the only people worth considering, that there are few smart people, and (in context) that these people are mostly "generalists" and entrepreneurs. It values "intelligence", probably measured in terms of short-term ability to make money, and leaves out values and self-reflection. It leaves out the possibility that you can learn from anyone (c.f. the story of the $20 fan[1]). It leaves out the possibility that your hiring process could be discriminatory or unwelcoming. And so on. This, I argue, is a good demonstration of why programmers need liberal arts; technical decisions are never just technical decisions. We must remember to ask who wins, who loses, is that desirable, is that just? [1] http://cs.txstate.edu/~br02/cs1428/ShortStoryForEngineers.htm http://cs.txstate.edu/~br02/cs1428/ShortStoryForEngineers.ht...
- drewrv 9y agoI've been spending a lot of time lately wondering if people who treat colleges and universities as though their job is worker training are confused, or if I'm naive in believing colleges and universities exist to expand human knowledge through research and education. I suspect the answer is that our culture is confused, we want people who are smart and well rounded to also be useful. And the ugly side of it is, we want clear class divisions. One would never refer to law school or medical school as "vocational".
- rch 9y agoI've heard doctors speak of themselves as having a trade skill... albeit one that pays well.
- mrkurt 9y agoPeople aren't confused. Colleges do many things. They're also very expensive to attend, and the most immediate value they offer is to get people jobs
- codingdave 9y ago> One would never refer to law school or medical school as "vocational". Sure you would. They are 100% vocational schools. Their cost, acceptance rates, time commitment, and difficulty level may be higher than other vocational schools, but that doesn't change what they are -- 100% focused on giving you the knowledge and skills to do a specific job.
- Danihan 9y agoWell then where are all the "vocational" CS programs at universities?
- kingkawn 9y agoCoding Boot camps
- AnimalMuppet 9y ago
- jackmott 9y agowelp, we could really use some vocational schools.
- BeetleB 9y ago>Well, that's because CS programs are designed to teach CS, not to be a vocational school for programmers. And which is why they should be moved out of the College of Engineering and placed into the college that has mathematics. Curiously enough, the only school he mentions where he can reliably know their grads have programming experience actually does place CS under mathematics. I think being able to program basic tasks should be a requirement for all engineering programs. They all require a course in CS - mostly not because they want ME's to know CS, but they want them to be able to program basic things. Yet, many/most engineering grads are really poor at it. I feel for any given engineering degree program, we should make all seniors who have declared they will graduate that semester to take a basic exam on very basic concepts that all grads of that program should know (strong emphasis on the word "basic"). If it's acceptable for them not to know basic material in an introductory class, then remove the class from the curriculum! Example: I was in a top 5 school helping an grad student in CS do basic probability homework. We were disagreeing on the correct answer, so I suggested he write a simple program to simulate it and compare with his calculated answer. This is the simplest program possible: A for loop, and a random number generator. He had no idea how to do it. I'm not picking on him because he's a CS student. I think it's a valid question for people in all engineering programs that involve introductory programming courses. What's the point of making such a course a mandatory requirement if they can literally do nothing based on that knowledge? Similarly, an electrical engineer who does not know, say, Kirchoff's laws should not be allowed to graduate. Yes, I do think universities are for education, but if they cannot apply what they learned, they are not educated.
- khedoros1 9y agoI went to a polytechnic university (i.e. one with a "learn by doing" focus). Our engineering students definitely had to have some programming classes, but they were taught separately from the CS ones. Most engineering students considered them an annoying roadblock in the way of getting back to their "real" work, and I (a CS student) spent a fair amount of time tutoring friends. I'll have to ask some of them if they use any form of programming now, in their day jobs. I suspect I'd get a mix of answers. As for the CS students, lectures were often on the theory, and homework was usually focused on implementing demonstrations of the theory. A grad student who wasn't a decent programmer was either a cheater in undergrad, or didn't come from our school.
- tikhonj 9y agoTo be fair, they do a pretty bad job teaching CS too. Your average undergrad program is almost entirely learning about CS, not learning CS. A non-trivial of students get through a CS degree never doing anything novel in CS—a real shame because, unlike math, research-level CS problems are eminently accessible to undergrads. It doesn't even have to be "real" research: I just expect more than classes which have you regurgitate what you learned to pass. And yet that's all you need to get a CS degree. It's a bit like learning to write by filling in blanks.
- ninkendo 9y ago> classes which have you regurgitate what you learned to pass I think that's what school is, no? I'm not trying to be glib, I think this is just a reality of how education works in pretty much all subjects (typical US academia, YMMV etc.) Can you name a major that doesn't work this way?
- aeorgnoieang 9y agoI had to write real proofs (tho I didn't fail completely if it wasn't free of errors) for my U.S. math undergrad degree.
- dsp1234 9y agoDid those proofs have to be novel, or were the proofs of already known concepts?
- alphaalpha101 9y agoOf course they have to be novel! You aren't allowed to just copy them off someone else.
- vecter 9y agoI'm sure those proofs at the time were novel to the student but obviously not the professor who assigned the problem. That's how the student learns.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ken47 9y agoThere is a well known delineation between applied math and pure math. It seems that such a convention has yet to be established for CS.
- ynniv 9y agoSometimes* the best way to learn things is to do them, a lot. - Graduate of the North Avenue Trade School (* Most times)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- JepZ 9y agoI think there is a thin line here. For example I was taught I to programm Smalltalk. On the one hand that is not a commonly used programming language and on the other hand it teaches Object Oriented Programming like no other language. So yes, after that you can't start as a Senior Java Developer but I think you have a very good foundation to quickly pick up other Object Oriented languages. So you do not have to teach the latest hyped language to give students the ability to programm. Instead you can use clean languages to teach CS and let your students excercise them to show you that they understood what you taught them.
- ptr_void 9y agoYet not having a CS degree makes getting a programming job 10x more difficult.
- nitwit005 9y agoNot sure that's an accurate comparison. We make the English majors do a ton of writing, the art majors produce a lot of art, and no one seems to have any issue assigning a lists of problems to math majors as homework. I suspect there is just a cultural issue, where the CS faculty doesn't want to do that style of teaching. I had a professor hand out debugging assignments because that was part of the industry feedback they'd gotten, but only the one professor listened to the feedback.
- wvenable 9y agoDon't worry most CS programs aren't designed to teach CS either. They teach a random assortment of technical material that is neither terribly difficult nor terribly relevant.
- patientplatypus 9y agoUgh...I hear this sort of thing all the time and I find it sooo obnoxious. Look, the reason that all the students go to university is to make money. Like 90%+ of undergrads go there to make money so whether it "technically" should be a monastery of cloistered academics pondering the universe (based on some high minded notion of what learning "ought" to be for) is besides the point. University costs a shit ton of money and people (the vast majority) pay it so they can have a decent life. And the fact that universities are, on the whole, teaching skills that do not help their students accomplish this means either A) they are actively misleading their students B) university is a class indicator more than a place to learn (I can spend huge amounts of money so I'm probably not poor and black - which sucks for all sorts of reasons) or C) they don't understand that teaching academic CS, as opposed to programming, is not what industry demands (so they suck at what they're selling). These are the people who, quite literally, are billing themselves as the "smartest guys in the room". If that's the case they can well stop sucking at their bloody job!
- extra88 9y ago> the reason that all the students go to university is to make money. Like 90%+ of undergrads go there to make money Which is it, "all" or "90%?" I went to a private liberal arts college so maybe that automatically puts me and my classmates in the 10% but I did not think the overwhelming majority of us were there to make money. The fact that lots of students still major in subjects that can be very worthwhile and valuable but lack obvious paths to financial success (e.g. most of Humanities and a lot of Social Sciences) indicates "making money" is not why they're there. You think universities should basically be trade schools. They're not and they shouldn't be. Trade schools should be trade schools but the U.S. has a dearth of them and many that fit the description aren't good enough.
- bordercases 9y agoI really hope we see greater specialization of mid-line universities that don't know whether they want to be an academic school or a trade school. Programming-as-inquiry is extremely difficult due to the amount of effort and math required to produce novelty, and programming-as-trade is much less difficult in comparison as a lot of the systems you're composing together already have their principles worked out. You can work from the manual in the latter case, while you're defining the manual in the former. Meanwhile a university not knowing whether it wants to be a trade school or a research school has mixed incentives that results in an inconsistent quality of education. You get professors who don't know how to teach and teachers who don't know how to go in depth. By requiring both you've made your staffing requirements that much harder to fulfill if you don't want to trade off education quality. On that note how have bootcamps been doing lately?
- matt_morgan 9y agoReminder that patio11 might be saying all these things without trying to imply value. I.e., he's not necessarily saying any of these things are good and bad; the "obvious" part is just that they are true.
- closeparen 9y agoMy CS education turned out to be “coding in a few fundamental domains” and I was very happy with it. We implemented some fundamental algorithms and components across operating systems, networks, distributed consensus, compilers/interpreters, visualization, sensing and perception, databases, machine learning, etc. You were free to construct a degree out of proofs rather than source code if you wanted, but those of us who desired a more practical education could fill our days with systems programming.
- fsloth 9y agoI would claim there is a significant portion of population for whom empirical teaching of CS would be far more kind and efficient than going through the Djisktraist pure theory route. Even Djisktra began with writing actual programs until he grogged how to think about it and then moved to pure theory.
- Clubber 9y agoWhat's the point of learning CS if you can't write a complete program? What the hell else are you going to do with it? Try to think of yet another way to write a sort algorithm?
- lukego 9y agoNostalgia: I really love the 60s definition of CS at Stanford, which seems more inclusive of practical aspects than the theoretical bent of today: "I consider computer science to be the art and science of exploiting automatic digital computers, and of creating the technology necessary to understand their use. It deals with such related problems as the design of better machines using known components, the design and implementation of adequate software systems for communication between man and machine, and the design and analysis of methods of representing information by abstract symbols and of processes for manipulating these symbols. Computer science must also concern itself with such theoretical subjects supporting this technology as information theory, the logic of the finitely constructable, numerical mathematical analysis, and the psychology of problem solving. Naturally, these theoretical subjects are shared by computer science with such disciplines as philosophy, mathematics, and psychology." http://i.stanford.edu/pub/cstr/reports/cs/tr/65/26/CS-TR-65-26.pdf http://i.stanford.edu/pub/cstr/reports/cs/tr/65/26/CS-TR-65-...
- michaelbuckbee 9y agoSlightly off topic, but I didn't realize that this was a series of tweets (a thread) that was extracted and re-presented as a coherent essay. This explains the somewhat "weird" cadence. On topic: it makes a lot of sense.
- lexicality 9y agoOh, that explains why it's so weird. I thought it was some kind of extra-terse blog until I saw your comment.
- SadWebDeveloper 9y agoThe author needs to relax, it feels like he wrote this rant while under heavy ADHD medication.
- jimktrains2 9y agoWhy is it necessary to make comments like this. Is it simply to demean those who have mental health issues and were responsible/brave enough to get help? Why use this as you example? You have many others, even just saying "while on stims/speed".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wutbrodo 9y agoIt's extracted from a series of tweets, that might explain the weird rhythm. And surely there's a less dickish way to communicate this?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- imperialdrive 9y agoThe author is keeping it pretty real based on a majority of my experience. Doesn't have to be spot on, but it's real.
- drewrv 9y ago> Everyone in Silicon Valley uses equity, and not debt, to fuel their growth because debt is not available in sufficient quantities to poorly capitalized companies without a strong history of adequate cash flows to service debt. A corollary to this is that if you're fundraising and can get debt, you should take it over equity almost every time. Many founders are skeptical of debt because everyone takes equity, yet everyone takes equity because it's all they can get. At the very least, if you're seriously trying to decide between the two, remember that equity investors want at least a 10x return within about five years. Break out a calculator and look at what the interest rate on that would be (spoilers, it's higher than any lender would think to ask).
- vm 9y agoNo no no. Debt is not universally better. Debt can wipe out companies. It requires payments that equity does not. Miss one payment and you're in default. It's extremely risky for companies that are young and volatile. Debt vs. equity is always a case-by-case situation. Debt is cheaper but comes with strings attached. Equity is pricey but more flexible.
- simonbyrne 9y agoBut it isn't in your creditor's interest that you go bankrupt either.
- emsy 9y agoThis. Being able to get debt should, in general, be a good indicator that your company might actually be valuable.
- saas_co_de 9y agoNot really. The easiest way to get a loan is to start a fast food franchise or build houses. Banks don't do innovation.
- valuearb 9y ago
- macintux 9y agoTypos are distracting. I don't know whether "modal" programmers is intentional or a typo for "model".
- saryant 9y agoPretty sure he means "modal" as in mode average.
- macintux 9y agoEntirely possible, and I thought so too, but then I bumped into a typo later which made me question it. Dunno.
- Domenic_S 9y agoHe also used "which" improperly (instead of "that") like 7-8 times. Majorly distracting.
- taejo 9y agoIn real English, as native speakers and good writers use it, allows "which" as as "that" in restrictive relative clauses (although it no longer allows "that" -- only "which" -- in supplementary clauses). See http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/%7Emyl/languagelog/archives/001464.html http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/%7Emyl/languagelog/archives/001464... ("although there is a clear frequency difference between the dialect groups [British and American English], ... both that and which are grammatical in integrated relatives in both dialect groups"). The rule is one made up by grammar checkers and authors of pedantic pamphlets, and if it's distracting to you I suggest you go cold turkey and read fewer of those and more of just about anything else.
- Domenic_S 9y agoNope. https://www.grammarly.com/blog/which-vs-that/ https://www.grammarly.com/blog/which-vs-that/ http://www.quickanddirtytips.com/education/grammar/which-versus-that-0 http://www.quickanddirtytips.com/education/grammar/which-ver... http://www.kentlaw.edu/academics/lrw/grinker/LwtaThat_Versus_Which.htm http://www.kentlaw.edu/academics/lrw/grinker/LwtaThat_Versus...
- throwawayjava 9y ago> Significant advances shipped by the tech industry in the last 20 years include putting the majority of human knowledge in the hands of 40%++ of the world's population, available on-demand, for "coffee money" not "university money." Oh, I didn't realize tech invented the library card.
- msla 9y agoLibraries are not run with "Access to Information" as their main goal. They're run with service to patrons as their main goal. If you think I'm making a distinction without a difference, how many libraries have subscriptions to Playboy?
- throwawayjava 9y ago> how many libraries have subscriptions to Playboy? It might be a difference, but it's a difference for which the university comparison is a red herring. How many universities have a porn department?
- msla 9y agoUniversities can study porn under the heading of the humanities or social science. The fact they don't have an explicit "Department of Pornography" is both an accident of our culture and a reflection of the fact our "top-level categories" for academics are more abstract than that. My point is, libraries maintain a very curated collection, and choose their holdings and resources based on very restrictive criteria, including funding and shelf space, making them relatively poor at keeping broad and deep holdings. Until you give the library an Internet connection, which brings us back to the origin of this sub-thread.
- throwawayjava 9y agoI think we're both way off topic if jerf's description of the intended meaning of the quote is accurate. But I have yet to be in a university library that stocks back-issues of Playboy...
- ElijahLynn 9y agoI thought this was going to be a list about "life". I was actually pleasantly surprised it was about our industry! I would still like there to be a list like this about life though.
- notdonspaulding 9y agoI'll have a go. Here's a few that seem almost axiomatic to me but that I think might be somewhat less so to this crowd: - Words are important. Choose them carefully. Hear them carefully. - "Tolerating everyone but the intolerant" is no real tolerance at all. - Only being "free" to hold your views in private, is no real freedom at all. Freedoms of speech and association and religion must be public freedoms if they are to be meaningful in any real sense. - There's a continuum that exists between equality and freedom. Governments and society can more-or-less choose where they sit on the continuum, but can't move more towards one value without trading off some of the other. - Prices agreed to by individuals in a free market (read: without coercion) are a statement each individual is making about the value of the good or service being traded. What's a "fair wage" for mowing lawns? What's a "fair price" for a watermelon? How much is "too much" profit for a legal firm? Capitalism is nothing more than a recognition that built into humanity is a desire to trade what you have for what you want, and a declaration that the Free Market is the most economical (read: efficient) way for humans to fulfill that desire. Following on from the previous axiom, you can certainly declare a "fair price for watermelon", but you're removing the freedom of individuals to decide for themselves how they value the world around them. - Be highly skeptical of anyone handing out pitchforks. And learn to recognize when you're being handed one in a news article, youtube video, reddit comment, political ad, etc., etc. - When you feel like the world is full of people who aren't changing their values fast enough, remember Chesterton's Fence[0]. In the main, the world around you exists the way it does for a reason (or for a plethora of reasons), and if you don't understand that reason, you're less likely to understand what the right fix is. - Debt (of all kinds: student, mortgage, business) is a promise you're making about your future. The older, more formal term for a loan is a "promissory note". - Before you make any promise, consider your ability to predict and control the future. - Constraints are natural pressures, disadvantages, and discomforts that can be helpful in decision-making. Don't avoid painful situations. (I think those last three make a powerful argument for bootstrapping startups instead of chasing VC funding or debt.) - We will always have "bad" laws. There is no one set of guidelines which humanity will ever discover that will cleanly cover all use cases and will be agreed upon as being right by everyone. - Humans are moral creatures. Whenever anyone uses the word "should" or "ought" in a sentence, they're making a moral statement. Hawking may be a world leading physicist, but when he declared philosophy to be dead, there's a reason philosopher's all around the world shot milk out their noses[1]. - You can't legislate morality. But in a democracy, legislation is the lowest-common-denominator of the morality of the governed. This means that just because something is legal, doesn't mean it's moral. It also means that in a society which encourages diversity of values, you'll have less common ground upon which to legislate. - Don't act surprised when someone is ignorant of a fact or subject which you know. Help them understand it with humility. - Don't hesitate to disclose your ignorance of a subject to someone who can help you learn more about it. They may not want to point out your ignorance, and silently pretending you do understand it only keeps you from learning new things. - Corporations are people. Or more precisely, its impossible to separate out the corporate entity's values and behavior from its owners' values and behavior. - As much as possible, have your mind made up how you will handle pressure to compromise on your values before you're in a tenuous situation. - Don't worry about "missing out". FOMO is terrible justification for doing things you wouldn't otherwise do. Though this isn't an argument against spontaneity. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._K._Chesterton#Chesterton.27s_fence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G._K._Chesterton#Chesterton.27... [1]: https://www.quora.com/How-are-philosophers-reacting-to-Stephen-Hawkings-proclamation-that-philosophy-is-dead https://www.quora.com/How-are-philosophers-reacting-to-Steph...
- jpm_sd 9y ago>Companies find it incredibly hard to reliably staff positions with hard-working generalists who operate autonomously and have high risk tolerances. This is not the modal employee, including at places which are justifiably proud of the skill/diligence/etc of their employees. I'm not sure if he's saying these hard-working generalists are hard to find, or undesirable to employ?
- throwawayjava 9y agoI'm also confused. What's a "modal employee"?
- jpm_sd 9y agoI assumed that was in reference to the mode of a distribution - the most common type of employee?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- duderific 9y agoI believe it's a typo, should be "model" employee.
- maxerickson 9y agoNo, it's referring to the statistical mode, the most frequent occurrence in a set, "typical" would be a reasonable synonym there. It's a roundaboot way of saying those qualities rarely all come together.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Jemaclus 9y agoI concur with jpm_sd, he's referring to the most common employee (the "mode" of the set).
- msla 9y agoI do not doubt this: > Most open source software is written by programmers who are full-time employed by companies which directly consume the software, at the explicit or implicit blessing of their employers. It is not charity work, any more than they charitably file taxes. But I wonder how many important Open Source projects were started that way, by employees of companies which wanted to use those projects. Linux, for example, most certainly was not begun that way.
- chubot 9y agoYes, I think this sentence oversimplifies things. The conclusions should be divided between: 1) Most open source software written and released today 2) Most open source software you use The code in category #2 is much older on average. Most people here use bash every day, but as far as I can tell, there's about one person behind it, who doesn't get paid for it (Chet Ramey). And you're right that a lot of projects start free, and then get commercial contribution once they are valuable. Linux, git, hg, and Python all fit that profile. In the "non-company" category, I would put Linux, git, hg, gcc, Apache. A lot of people still use Apache. nginx was in this category too until very recently. SVN is interesting because it was started by a company (CollabNet), but I believe they diverged and the company no longer had much economic interest in it. Anyway, I guess what I'm saying is that the story is really complicated. It's not as simple as what's in that Tweet.
- msla 9y ago> And you're right that a lot of projects start free, and then get commercial contribution once they are valuable. Linux, git, hg, and Python all fit that profile. I think you used the wrong word here, or at least a misleading one: Linux, for example, is still free and Free for most reasonable definitions people have of those terms. (Anti-copyleft trolling is not reasonable.) Its development is funded, yes, but that funding doesn't give IBM, for example, special rights which a sufficiently determined individual hacker couldn't also have: Both have the ability to have an idea, code it, and get the code accepted, and IBM isn't immune to a Linus veto just because IBM's poured money into their team of kernel contributors. I rant, but it's an important distinction between Open Source and closed source. It also reminds me of an old joke: Back in the 1990s, Apple, bereft of Jobs and nearly dead against Microsoft, was moving towards IBM in terms of strategic partnerships. So, the joke went "Apple + IBM = IBM", as in, if you move too close to IBM, IBM engulfs you and you lose your identity. My point is, IBM can't engulf an Open Source project unless absolutely nobody outside IBM cares about it and all the repos outside of IBM's purview utterly stagnate. > In the "non-company" category, I would put Linux, git, hg, gcc, Apache. A lot of people still use Apache. nginx was in this category too until very recently. I don't know if you noticed, but you put Linux in two different categories. > SVN is interesting because it was started by a company (CollabNet), but I believe they diverged and the company no longer had much economic interest in it. That is interesting. > It's not as simple as what's in that Tweet. Things rarely are. :) Good post!
- bambax 9y ago> Your idea is not valuable, at all. All value is in the execution. This is oft repeated, but not always true. Take the Nazis (bear with me). The Nazis had the best execution ever. They almost drowned the whole British army, which had previously conquered the world. While fighting battles all over Europe and being one of the most bombarded country in history, they continued to produce tanks, planes, submarines, operate a bureaucracy until the very end, invent bombs and other systems that befuddled all other nations. Yet they lost the war. The reason they lost the war is, their idea was so bad, people everywhere were willing to die to make it fail. An excellent idea can survive a bad execution for some time. A terrible idea will ultimately fail, no matter the execution.
- jimktrains2 9y agoOr they lost the war because of bad execution. They had feifdom fights in the upper ranks and Hitler wasn't able to have anyone tell him he had bad ideas (e.g. war on two fronts and locking tanks in Paris instead of letting them be commanded as needed during d-day (which again came down to infighting)). Germany was also being worn thin on supplies. It's not as if they were in perfect shape minus allied bombings. Also, the Nazi ideals weren't terrible in the way a business idea was terrible. Many people bought into it.
- blacksqr 9y agoYou clearly need to re-read John Gill.
- jimktrains2 9y agoYou're going to have to flush out your meaning more. Are you implying Nazi Germany didn't make quite a few large mistakes that are often pointed to as how they lost momentum and failed to repel D-Day?
- mLuby 9y agoThat Nazis were extremely efficient is a myth, which makes sense if you think about how they organized their government/economy. [1][2] Though they were effective at killing large numbers of (defenseless) people… Also they didn't lose the war because of some flaw in their ideology, they lost due to manpower and industrial shortages (inflicted by Soviet and Allied militaries) that limited their ability to wage war. For more, I recommend watching the Hitler Channel (err History Channel). [3] [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/five-myths/five-myths-about-nazis/2017/10/20/f4463dea-b2b5-11e7-9e58-e6288544af98_story.html?utm_term=.8cb6fb1d390d https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/five-myths/five-myths... [2] http://www.bbc.com/travel/story/20170903-why-people-think-germans-are-so-efficient http://www.bbc.com/travel/story/20170903-why-people-think-ge... [3] https://www.history.com/topics/world-war-ii https://www.history.com/topics/world-war-ii
- tptacek 9y agoEspecially after reading the comments on this thread, I'm really not sure HN is a good venue for discussing tweet streams. I think if Patrick wanted to write something that would spark a discussion on HN, he'd have written a blog post.
- jstanley 9y agoI for one had no idea this was not a blog post.
- tptacek 9y agoThat's definitely a part of the problem.
- OrwellianChild 9y agoCan we change the link to this: https://twitter.com/patio11/status/936615043126370306 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/936615043126370306 (so folks understand this is a tweetstorm and not a post?)
- jstanley 9y agoI actually think this interface is a better way to read a tweetstorm, it could just do with prefixing the title with "A tweetstorm by patio11" to remove the confusion.
- mrkurt 9y agoAre you sure HN is a good venue for discussing anything?
- dwaltrip 9y agoThis should be titled "Condensed snippets of accumulated wisdom, focusing mostly on software and business, that I am fairly confident of and feel compelled to share with you". Many of these nuggets are not "obvious", for any conventional understanding of that word. That said, I enjoyed the post, and liked the concise format.
- gizmo 9y ago"obvious" is not a property of a statement itself, it indicates a relationship between a piece of knowledge and a larger knowledge base, where one thing immediately follows from other things that are already known. I don't think "obvious" in the conventional sense is a real category, because no two people would agree the same things are obvious.
- dwaltrip 9y agoAh, just like the good old "it is trivial to see that a -> b" from advanced mathematics.
- rcoveson 9y agoThey should hire you to come up with titles.
- sturmen 9y agoThis was mentioned by someone else, but in case you missed it: the "concise format" is a result of this being a 23-tweet tweet storm that the Threadreader has compiled into one page for us.
- darioush 9y agoThe format is really good. Tired of paying ~$5 for a 300 page self-help book, when a 2 page summary like this can do just as well.
- mitchdoogle 9y agoyou should consider buying The Great American Bathroom Book. Despite the kitschy title, it consists of rather good and concise summaries of novels as well as nonfiction books, including some popular self-help books. None are more than two pages.
- zbentley 9y ago> People underestimate how effective a generalist can be at things which are done by specialists. People underestimate how deep specialties can run. These are simultaneously true. This is really, really important. In my experience, this is not just unknown but actively ignored and disagreed with (either explicitly or effectively) by a large majority of people involved in software businesses. This hamstrings: companies, individuals' growth, and the advancement of the state of the art.
- shostack 9y agoThere's also often a messy transition period where a team goes from a bunch of generalists to more specialists. This can be extremely rocky for all involved as often generalists have lots of historic operational knowledge and strong opinions, but the new specialists come with external knowledge of best practices and how to scale. It is important that historic knowledge is respected for the context it provides, while outside knowledge is equally respected for the deeper context and data behind it. Unfortunately, this change often means generalists lose jobs in favor of specialists as a company grows if there isn't a good place for them, or if they don't rise to management. In fact, even early managers can be displaced by outside managers who come in with more management experience. And this is not inherently a bad thing for the company (while it may be for the employee getting bumped). The people that take a company from point A to point B are rarely the same people that take it from point B to point C.
- dsnuh 9y ago>often generalists have lots of historic operational knowledge and strong opinions *citation needed Edit: to be clear, in my experience the specialists that aren't also generalists on some level are the least productive on the team because they have trouble participating outside their knowledge domain. Maybe I have worked at the wrong places though...
- shostack 9y agoTo clarify, when a company is young, you have a lot of people wearing a lot of hats. They may in fact be quite good at wearing some of those hats. Likewise, having visibility and exposure to multiple domains aspects of the same company gives a perspective that is hard to have if you live in a super specialized silo. However specialists don't need to be generalists to be productive as long as they come in with the mindset that they are specialists, and therefore may not know everything. And that is especially important, as I highlighted, for respecting historical context of the company and its operations. There might be VERY good reasons for not doing something the way the rest of the industry does it (which is what the specialist might be inclined to do). However a good specialist should also be adept at factoring that into how they approach problems, and properly weigh the new information against their past experience to determine if in fact this is a special snowflake situation, or if their approach is still the right one. Conflict can often arise when if they push for the latter, so strong communication skills are key (and that is something that never really changes for any role at any stage of company growth).
- swamp40 9y ago> Your idea is not valuable, at all. All value is in the execution. Then why did Amazon patent the concept of a drone that will fly to your car and recharge it?
- TheSithMaster 9y agoBecause one day that idea could turn into a product that is valuable.
- _jomo 9y agoTo prevent others from executing it better than them.
- brucephillips 9y agoWithout the idea, there would be nothing to execute on.
- mortenjorck 9y agoIdeas are not valuable. A stable of patents backed up with a team of IP lawyers is.
- psyc 9y agoBecause patents are valuable. Specifically, blocking others from executing.
- valuearb 9y agoAnd because knowing patents are valuable, Amazon will freely file for far more than they need, and employees will be rewarded for coming up with them even if they are dumb. This specific patent is likely the second in spades.
- brucephillips 9y agoPatents first require an idea to be patented, so if patents are valuable, ideas are valuable.
- 9y ago
- legitster 9y agoThis one had me stop >The explosive growth of the tech sector keeps average age down and depresses average wages. Compared to industries which existed in materially the same form in 1970, we have a stupidly compressed experience spectrum: 5+ years rounds to "senior." This is not a joke. I agree that it compresses the experience spectrum, but has the opposite effect on wages. It's tough to find any industry that pays more for the amount of experience/education.
- saryant 9y agoI think he's arguing that the average wage in our industry is low simply because the workforce leans so young, so a disproportionate number of software engineers are still junior—and making junior wages—compared to other industries where the age curve is more spread out.
- legitster 9y agoAh. That makes more sense.
- wmeredith 9y ago> the average wage in our industry is low Is this a joke?
- saryant 9y agoThere are a lot of literalists in this thread. The average wage is dragged down because the age distribution leans so far to the left. That is, the average wage disguises the wages made by staff/principal engineers, which can be 3-5x the comp numbers commonly tossed around for SV engineers.
- CryoLogic 9y agoIt's probably true. There are more CS majors now than ever in the history of the US.
- khedoros1 9y agoThey aren't low compared to wages in other industries, but I've heard it repeated over and over that they're low compared to the value that software devs create.
- macawfish 9y ago> Companies find it incredibly hard to reliably staff positions with hard-working generalists who operate autonomously and have high risk tolerances. This is not the modal employee, including at places which are justifiably proud of the skill/diligence/etc of their employees. This one. Every job I see when I go looking is 40+ hrs a week, likely with plenty of idle time and projects I don't believe in. Part of this is regional... my area is packed full of marketing jobs that I'm actively uninterested in. Anyway, I'm starting to get the hang of selling myself to contract shops, and I think I've found some twinkles of hope. But today I was told straight up that my resume wasn't conventional enough, that it was too well-rounded. After quite a few messages back and forth, I'm not even sure if they even looked at my portfolio. They told me there was no money for me, because their funders were looking for someone more professional. So I took this as a sign that maybe this wasn't the job for me. No need to go barking up the wrong tree. In the game dev world, I'd probably be a "technical artist", but even that doesn't quite fit for me. I'm like a "fool of all trades, jack of some, maybe a master of one or two". But it's hard to find a job that motivates me and leaves me with adequate space/time/energy to keep myself sharp and alive. If anyone knows of funding for a guy that makes creative, reusable web components, let me know... edit: I just saw that vue.js is primarily funded by patreon. that's awesome!
- rhaps0dy 9y agoI think you framed your anecdotal evidence as supporting the OP's statement, but also that you misunderstood such statement; and you actually present evidence against it. If companies find it hard to reliably staff generalist positions, _and_ you're a generalist as you claim, then you would find it _easy_ to get a job.
- eightysixfour 9y agoI think the anecdote and OP’s statement support one another - companies have a hard time reliably staffing generalists and one of the reasons for that is that they are bad at identifying them and determining how to use them. Parent showed them a generalist skill set and they saw a lack of professionalism.
- claudiulodro 9y ago> The chief products of the tech industry are (in B2C) developing new habits among consumers This was a profound revelation I didn't realize until I read it just now. Facebook, Google, Amazon, etc. have all done so well by starting a habit for their users. ("Check Facebook daily to see what your friends are up to." "Google it whenever you need info." "Buy your stuff conveniently on Amazon when you don't want to go to the store.") I think this approach can work great for even non-tech industries. It definitely worked for Starbucks ("Gotta get my morning Starbucks"). I think lots of industries are ripe for "habit-ifying", and I'm going to pursue that further. Brilliant insight.
- eponeponepon 9y ago> I think lots of industries are ripe > for "habit-ifying", and I'm going > to pursue that further. Brilliant > insight. This is, of course, the same insight that the gambling and tobacco industries and cults thrive on. Not talking you down - just reminding you never to forget the moral angle.
- r00fus 9y agoIs it a moral issue if the habit a starts a virtuous cycle? Like my Apple Watch making me exercise more?
- ZenoArrow 9y agoYes, it can still be a moral issue (I'd prefer to use 'quality of life' rather than moral, as the term moral implies a certain level of judgement of the choices of others, and I'd rather be focused on making those judgements over my own choices). Use of technology can both help and hinder us. On the negative side, we can become dependent on it, and that dependency does not always enhance our lives. Even in the case of your Apple Watch making you exercise more, used in moderation you can get the benefits without too many downsides, but it can also become a device that distracts you from the world around you, disconnecting you from experiences that you could get by being more fully in the moment. To be clear, this isn't an issue solely limited to use of technology, but the more devices we have and use the more easily distracted we become. The ideal for companies is to have all our life's needs and wants fulfilled by companies. If they can do so by suggesting there's a hole you need to fill by buying their products, and you become unhappy if you don't have it, is this a healthy trend? What if you were generally happy before this marketing campaign started?
- stirner 9y agoI expected this to be an article about general life tips. Perhaps the title could use the suffix “About Startups”?
- quadrangle 9y agoI think it's about software / programming world and economics, not just startups. Still very niche, not stuff about life relevant to any non-tech person
- rytill 9y ago> Meta thought: you radically underestimate both a) how much you know that other people do not and b) the instrumental benefits to you of publishing it. Can someone explain b) to me? Is he saying that, assuming you fit into category a, by explicitly revealing your knowledge, your potential opportunities will expand more than you estimate?
- geoffreyhale 9y agoTLDR: Yes. You will benefit from sharing knowledge. > You radically underestimate (...) the instrumental benefits to you of publishing it (much you know that other people do not). (He is saying, at least, that) you will benefit (more than you estimate) from publishing things you know (that others don't).
- sah2ed 9y agoYes. For instance, if you consistently put out good pieces on your past experiences in the software industry as a PM, then your current experiences as a software business owner, you will gradually become widely known as the guy who gives advice about what you shouldn't be doing in your software career or software business. This was essentially how Joel Spolsky grew his audience through his blog -- turning his knowledge into published pieces. His blog audience combined with Jeffrey Atwood's blog audience were instrumental to getting StackOverflow off the ground. You never know, but having an existing audience can be an incredible enabler for getting your future ventures off the ground.
- md224 9y ago> Charge more. Charge more still. Go on. This might sound stupid, and maybe it's my inner hippie talking, but did this make anyone else slightly uncomfortable? I get that it's "good business", but something feels kinda gross about saying "extract as much money from other people as you possibly can." Like... shouldn't you just charge whatever you think something (a product, your time) is worth? I realize that "what something is worth" is often subjective, but charging more just because you can feels morally ambiguous to me at best. (Then again, if you're talking about extracting money from a corporation, that feels less gross. But of course my inner hippie would say that.)
- deathanatos 9y agoI interpreted that point very much together with the preceding point: > Technologists tend to severely underestimate the difficulty and expense of creating software, especially at companies which do not have fully staffed industry leading engineering teams ("because software is so easy there, amirite guys?") That, in my experience, is very true. Teams are staffed to "we can make it work, maybe" not "we can actually engineer something"; the second bullet, to me, says, "you need to charge more than you think you do, because you're underestimating the costs of doing it, in particular, of doing it well."
- runako 9y agoTaken with the rest of his comment, the meaning here is to ensure that you build a viable, sustainable business. The norm for techies is to underprice their offerings (based on underestimating the difficulty and expense of creating, selling, and supporting software). This leads to even "successful" companies closing because they weren't built to be financially sustainable. One way of making a company sustainable is to charge a sustainable price (which is typically "more" than initially apparent).
- mikeokner 9y agoThe problem (other than your inner hippie :P) is that it can be quite difficult to accurately value a software product. Most physical goods are valued based on the cost of materials/manufacturing. However software is an intangible good without those fixed costs. The closest thing is hosting. For B2B solutions, value is more tied to how much it would cost a customer to implement your solution instead of buying yours. But even a startup founder who's been an engineer for many years might not have a clear picture of how much the previous projects they worked on cost their employer. They only see their own hourly rate or salary (which already might be low) and don't see the total cost of development, the cost of infrastructure, personnel for ongoing support, etc. Engineers notoriously under-price startup offerings because they lack the broader perspective to accurately value their creations.
- philipov 9y agoWhich cartel is he referring to?
- monktastic1 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_Litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L... https://pando.com/2014/03/30/court-docs-google-hiked-wages-to-combat-hot-young-facebook-after-sheryl-sandberg-refused-to-join-hiring-cartel/ https://pando.com/2014/03/30/court-docs-google-hiked-wages-t...
- gthtjtkt 9y ago> The tech industry is fundamentally unserious about how it recruits, hires, and retains candidates. About which I have a lot more to say than could fit in a tweet, but, a good thing to know. Would love to read more about that. I'd be willing to bet most SMBs are terrible at hiring / retaining developers. My last company did literally nothing to help devs learn and grow (or to reward those who did so on their own), which created a department full of miserable, unmotivated people. The only reason most of them are still there is because they haven't found a new job but can't afford to leave. They're trapped, essentially.
- InclinedPlane 9y agoGenerally good stuff, some quibbles: > Your idea is not valuable, at all. All value is in the execution. Good advice in the main but not 100% accurate. Some ideas are novel and good. In fact, many are. But communicating even good ideas is difficult bordering on impossible, more so for truly novel and innovative ideas. Think about how often an adaptation of an excellent novel translates into an excellent movie. It's rare. But that doesn't mean that novels (or idea) are worthless. It means that execution is hard, it means that communicating ideas is hard. Even if you can spend years turning an excellent idea into a fully fleshed out idea (a novel) it will still be hard to execute it faithfully. And by the same token, most books are pretty mediocre, for example, just as most ideas are mediocre. Trite, repetitive, hackneyed, etc. That doesn't mean all ideas are valueless, just most of them, and it can be difficult to figure that out until you've gotten to execution. > There is no hidden reserve of smart people who know what they're doing, anywhere. This is also mostly true but a bit misleading. It's nice to think that everyone is just struggling along half-assing things the same way you are, and that's true. Mostly. But there are actually a lot of people who really do have their shit together, really do know what they're doing, and are just better at their jobs by a significant margin than most people. It's comforting to think that such people are an illusion, but they are out there, sometimes they aren't even doing glamorous work. The fact that they exist isn't really terribly important (if you're really lucky you might be able to hire them, but you probably won't be that lucky). What's more important, I think, is that there is no excuse not to try to do better, constantly. If you want to really have a competitive advantage don't worry about hiring the top 1%, rockstars, ninjas, or even necessarily the "10x" workers. Concentrate on fostering a culture of continuous improvement and collaboration. Learn about best practices. Apply them. Build policies, processes, and culture that support doing better. Study what works and what doesn't push towards an environment that fosters doing what works and abandons bad practices. Stop firefighting start doing root cause analysis. Do code reviews regularly, get better at it. Test your code, increase automated testing, increase the quality of testing. Keep moving the bar higher in terms of quality. Figure out how to accelerate development velocity. Move error detection closer to the point of checkin. Never give up raising the bar. Decent developers working as a team with a good process focused on continuous improvement will out-perform rockstars stomping on each other's toes all the time every day of the week, by orders of magnitude.
- hoodoof 9y ago> Your idea is not valuable, at all. All value is in the execution. Simply not true. Ask the Winklevoss twins.
- aeorgnoieang 9y agoThat's a near-perfect example of his point.
- deanjones 9y agoYou are aware, I assume, that the Winklevoss twins were awarded $65 million for "their" idea?
- deanjones 9y agoYes, it's evidently, demonstrably, the case that ideas have value, because this is enshrined the concept of intellectual property. Even in a world where IP didn't exist, his statement would be wrong, because there will always be people who can sell an idea, and the value of something is exactly what someone else will pay for it.
- chubot 9y agoThe hardest problem in B2C is distribution. The hardest problem in B2B is sales. AppAmaGooBookSoft are AppAmaGooBookSoft primarily because they have mortal locks on distribution. I agree with this, but I think it's interesting. Wasn't the Internet supposed to democratize distribution? All someone has to do is go to your website. And anybody can set up a website. So it seems like the Internet just shifted the goal posts for everyone? The winners are still as dominant as ever. But I guess it is true that you can have a break-out hit like Instagram or WhatsApp, and that wasn't possible pre-Internet. The time scales are compressed. But perversely, maybe because distribution is easier and software flows more freely, you have to be even better? You can't rely on "local inefficiencies"? You have to be globally the best.
- brucephillips 9y ago> AppAmaGooBookSoft are AppAmaGooBookSoft primarily because they have mortal locks on distribution. Well, first of all, this isn't true. Google and FB aren't so profitable because of a distribution monopoly. They're profitable due to network effects.
- chubot 9y agoYes I agree the original post oversimplified it.
- mrep 9y agonetwork effects: a phenomenon whereby a product or service gains additional value as more people use it. How does google search get better from more people using it?
- chubot 9y agoTo be brief, more data (generated by clicks and queries) leads to better ranking. Better ranking attracts more users. Starting a search engine from scratch without any user data is a big disadvantage. Basically, you're benefitting from other people who are searching for the same thing as you on the same search engine. (I'm sure that's not the only network effect, but it's one of them.)
- westoncb 9y agoAnyone want to take a crack at expanding this?: > The tech industry is fundamentally unserious about how it recruits, hires, and retains candidates.
- curtis 9y agoGiven the amount of money and resources that goes into recruiting and hiring, I find it hard to believe that the industry is not serious. On the other hand, the current approaches clearly don't work very well, and everybody knows it, but nobody seems to be interested in seriously thinking about what we need to do differently. (patio11 and tptacek are notable exceptions)
- wyclif 9y agoAline Lerner is interested: http://blog.alinelerner.com/ http://blog.alinelerner.com/
- stevenwoo 9y agoSo her best predictor of future job performance is number of typos on resume. That is my pet peeve when looking at resumes, but it really discriminates against people for whom English is not their native language. On the other hand, didn't have a lot of non native English speakers applying to the positions for which I was hiring back then.
- brucephillips 9y ago> Your idea is not valuable, at all. All value is in the execution. This is wrong, and I'm surprised it's repeated so often. Some ideas are better than others. If you doubt this, ask yourself if, when starting a company, you would choose a random idea or your best idea. Of course you would choose your best idea, which implies ideas have different value. EDIT: I'm happy to debate this point with anyone who would otherwise downvote me. Critical replies welcome.
- drittich 9y agoTo recast what you are saying to remain congruent with the original premise, one might say ideas can have different potential value.
- brucephillips 9y agoBy that rephrasing, execution also only has potential value, since the value is only realized in conjunction with a good idea. So if you want to keep any useful definition of "valuable", you have to concede that ideas can be valuable.
- im2nguyen 9y agoI don't think it necessarily means "all ideas are the same". You're right -- some ideas may be better than others, but until they're executed successfully, they're just ideas. ie: There were multiple ways that Google could have executed their goal of building a search engine (engineering, sales, etc). Even if you come up with a 'better' idea, it may not be successful/valuable if you execute it poorly and make the wrong decisions.
- brucephillips 9y agoExcept google's idea wasn't "search engine". Google's idea was "search engine that uses the PageRank algorithm". PageRank did not encompass all of the value of Google, but it did encompass much of it, and it was unequivocally part of the idea. What you're effectively saying is that ideas have no value without good execution, which is of course true, but this is very different than saying they have no value, because after all, execution has no value without a good idea.
- peterwwillis 9y ago> Most open source software is written by programmers who are full-time employed by companies which directly consume the software, at the explicit or implicit blessing of their employers. It is not charity work, any more than they charitably file taxes. There are perhaps 1000 OSS projects that make up the software you use on a daily basis. Many of these have core developers or maintainers who are hired by a company to write or maintain that software for them to consume. But there are literally millions more open source projects, almost entirely developed by hobbyists. Github alone has 24 million developers, with 67 million repos (25 million of which are public), and 1.5 million organizations, in 200 countries. The top languages used there are JS, Python, Java, Ruby, PHP, C++, CSS, C#, Go, and C. (Github, btw, is not the only repository of open source code) Most open source software is most definitely not written by one kind of dev. But there _is_ an underlying motivator behind almost all open source: "I need this code." As long as there is someone who needs it passionately enough to take it upon themselves to craft and produce it, without regard to commercial gain, it will stay alive. Open Source is basically woodworking, and our computers are the chisels and saws.
- gajomi 9y ago>The amount of money flowing through capitalism would astound you I really like this one. During my biology days, there was a fellow PhD student in the lab who had spent 15+ years in corporate IT before joining academia, and he always had great stories of the incredible amounts of cash we should expect to see flow around us should we embark on careers outside of academia (he was not wrong).
- brutus1213 9y agoNot sure I agree with these two: "Salaries in the tech industry are up a lot in the last few years, caused by: a tight labor market, collapse of a cartel organized against the interests of workers, increasing returns to scale at AppAmaGooBookSoft, and the like. Investor money does not pay most salaries." But the rest are pretty sage. As one would expect of patio11 :)
- bonestamp2 9y agoI like this format/premise a lot... it allows you the freedom to say things you find insightful without the risk of some know-it-all coming along and telling you it's obvious. We should do more of this -- nearly everything is going to seem obvious to someone else, but those people should just keep their mouth closed and keep looking for something they didn't know.
- bdcs 9y agoCan anyone expound on "collapse of a cartel organized against the interests of workers"?
- bdcs 9y agoAha! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_Litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- brucephillips 9y agoBTW, doesn't this app break Twitter's ToS by displaying tweets in a non-standard format? https://developer.twitter.com/en/developer-terms/display-requirements https://developer.twitter.com/en/developer-terms/display-req...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- otakucode 9y agoI don't believe companies want "hard-working generalists who operate autonomously and have high risk tolerances." I mean obviously, yes, they would claim to want that, but that sort of employee is fundamentally incompatible with modern business. Modern business is predicated upon the idea of employees being as replaceable and interchangeable as possible. It is a common idea presented in many management books that if an employee becomes important to the company, they should be fired immediately. The thinking is that if your company grows in reliance upon this person, they might one day ask for more money and when you fire them at that point the damage done will be worse so it is better to nip the problem in the bud and bite the bullet and get rid of them when you notice their importance and deal with the smaller amount of disruption. Any hard-working generalist who operates autonomously will, by necessity, be building systems which they have all of the domain knowledge about. And despite companies wishing to believe domain knowledge is not valuable, it has substantial operational and financial impact when lost. >The hardest problem in B2C is distribution. This confuses me. Distribution is trivially solved. Anyone can get a product to a customer for quite low cost anywhere in the world now. Is something else meant by "distribution" aside from 'getting things from point A to point B'? If I had a warehouse in my back yard and a customer wanting a product from it, I could ship it to the customer just as easily as Amazon could. Their advantage isn't in being able to distribute things. It's in aggregation and many other different things but not distribution. Distribution was the most valuable economic activity of the past century, but it's commoditized now. >Weak-form efficients market hypothesis is a good heuristic for evaluating the public markets The efficient market hypothesis says that profit is an error, an inefficiency which will rapidly go to zero as it will be stripped by underpriced competitors. This is not a good heuristic.
- brucephillips 9y ago> The efficient market hypothesis says that profit is an error No it doesn't. It's a pricing hypothesis. It says nothing about the presence or absence of profits.
- dllthomas 9y ago> Technical literacy in the broader population can be approximated with the Thanksgiving test: what sort of questions do you get at Thanksgiving? That's the ambient level of literacy. At my Thanksgiving table there's two professional programmers, a CS student, and a CS professor. While I'm doubtless an extreme example, my general point is that "your Thanksgiving table" is still a bubble. That said, sure, for many it will be closer to representative than friends/coworkers.
- jondubois 9y agoI agree with most points except this one: >> Most open source software is written by programmers who are full-time employed by companies which directly consume the software, at the explicit or implicit blessing of their employers. It is not charity work, any more than they charitably file taxes. Most open source projects don't go anywhere... They have about 3 stars on Github and nobody uses them. To say that open source is not charity work is quite unfair. The number of people who make money from their open source projects is tiny... Even among popular projects with thousands of stars. The real motivation behind most open source projects is a strong desire to learn and explore new ideas and to share these ideas with others. The financial stuff might come later but most of the time it doesn't come at all. Outside of the cryptocurrency space and big corporations, very few people who get into open source do so because they think it is a good way to make money... Because it's not. I believe very strongly that most open source projects are founded on altruism. The motivation might change over time but you cannot disregard the initial intent.
- jpatokal 9y agoOpen source projects are founded on self-interest, not altruism: "I can do this better than any existing solution"! On rare occasions this is true, and on even rarer occasions others agree and start contributing.
- astura 9y agoYou're making the mistake of assuming open source means "something you that's not your job." This is false. Most open source development is paid work. Many people "get into open source" by accepting a regular day job. https://www.techrepublic.com/article/for-50-percent-of-developers-open-source-is-a-9-to-5-job/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/for-50-percent-of-devel...
- jondubois 9y agoI've done open source work for 10 years. I'm pretty sure I know what open source means. You can have a look at GitHub; there are 25 million active repos on there; at least 99% of them are not sponsored by any company and nobody gets paid to work on them. People like the OP and yourself are spreading distorted ideas which harm open source and the software ecosystem as a whole. Putting open source projects on the same level as commercial software is not right. They are often completely different kinds of people behind them.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 9y agoI like the notions of specialists and generalists. Generalists tend to under-estimate specialists and vice-versa.
- justonepost 9y ago"Your idea is not valuable" ... no, maybe not some top level idea like "Social media, but more private." But, execution is just a bunch of smaller ideas.
- mitchdoogle 9y agoIt's not just about ideas. Coming up with ideas is easy. Turning an idea into a viable product involves a lot of work.
- Bromskloss 9y ago> Coming up with ideas is easy. I think that depends on how stringent criteria you put on the ideas. An idea that maybe, with a lot of work, would be successful might be easy to come up with. An idea that is very likely to succeed, with little work and no investments, might not be that easy to find.
- justonepost 9y agoMy god, that read like someone did way too much meth or weed or both at the same time. How in hell did this get upvoted.. it's like a huge collection of click bait, overly vauge, broad, and hyperbolic with zero signal density. ooohhhh I get it now, it's patio11. Ok, well, all is forgiven then. He's a nice guy.
- charlieflowers 9y ago> This is not the modal employee, Is this a misuse of the word "modal"? If not, could someone please explain this definition to me? From context, I'm guessing the author means "typical" perhaps?
- ktta 9y agoHe does mean typical, but I'm not sure if the definition is correct. Mode of a sequence is the unit occurring most number of times. So the modal employee is supposed to be the most frequently occurring one.
- Kluny 9y ago> Charge more. Charge more still. Go on. I find this advice unhelpful. In the past, when I was making $23/hour as a web developer, people would occasionally ask to hire me for freelance work. I've given various answers, from $30 to $100, and haven't had any takers yet. The only freelance work I've actually done so far was when I said, "what do you think it's worth?" and my friend said, "I dunno, 60?" It was for about an hour of work so I said yeah, but I had already done the work by that point anyway. $100/hour seems like the right amount to me, since my company was billing me out at $116. But no one else thinks so. I'm pretty sure there's more to it than just "charge more".
- seppin 9y agoyour company markets, has sales people, and manages every part of the transaction from signing the contract to developing the code. I don't know if all that is 77/hour, but it might be.
- csomar 9y agoThen you are not competitive enough or not marketing to the right people. You might think that there is a market for $15/h skilled developers, but there probably isn't. There is a huge market, however, for NewStartup CEOs looking for dev at $15/h. They'll keep running in circles until they find something on their budget, or they don't. But they'll not raise prices. Beware of those.
- ccmonnett 9y agoI think this piece of advice is extremely relevant for those selling B2B software/products which comes in bigger 'chunks' than your labor which can be sold by the hour. The gist is that while you (as the average B2B startup) can estimate how valuable your product is to your average customer, you will most likely vastly underestimate the cost of replacement for such a system. In other words, if your sales pitch goes well and they like the product but think to themselves "How much would it cost us to build this ourselves?" you will underestimate this cost from the outside. This is because the cost of replacement is a reasonably good proxy for a price ceiling and by being aware of it you can get a much higher average selling price.
- delhanty 9y ago>Your idea is not valuable, at all. All value is in the execution. You think you are an exception; you are not. You should not insist on an NDA to talk about it; nobody serious will engage in contract review over an idea, and this will mark you as clueless. John Carmack is unusually direct and asserts pretty much the same things a couple of weeks back. [1] >This will never, ever work. Nobody will build your game idea and give you money for it. If you go through the development process, you will find that the original idea is a very small fraction of the value. [1] https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/931653803199275008 https://twitter.com/ID_AA_Carmack/status/931653803199275008 Edit: typo s/in/is
- timthelion 9y agoI agree and disagree with this one. Of course, no one is going to pay money for your game idea, but there are ideas which require an NDA. Those ideas typically take years of development and a person with such an idea would be able to present hundreds of pages of alternate designs and their pros/cons. For example, if I have a design for a 3mm x 1mm mechanism that can actuate a rod by 2mm and I know what kind of power consumption said mechanism will have, that design might be expressible on a single piece of paper, and be worth millions of dollars.
- delhanty 9y ago>a person with such an idea would be able to present hundreds of pages of alternate designs Arguably, that's much more than just an idea - it's the idea plus the development of the idea, with most of the value being in the development bit.
- timthelion 9y agoTrue, but if I know that you have been working on the idea for 5 years, and that you have those hundreds of pages of alternate designs, then even just the end result may be valuable enough to me that you would want an NDA.
- 9y ago
- chx 9y ago> There is no hidden reserve of smart people who know what they're doing, anywhere. Not in government, not in science, not in tech, not at AppAmaGooBookSoft, nowhere. The world exists in the same glorious imperfection that it presents with. This is painfully true. I so often hoped someone will explain some Linux stuff to me but... strace it is :)
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoI think the main point of the quote is that nobody knows everything. There are pockets of knowledge, and there are specialists who know quite a bit about Linux. ;) You just need to find that person and not expect them to also know about something completely different like Windows or Asian-Pacific geopolitics.
- Joeri 9y agoIf you are attempting to hire for an engineering position, greater than 50% of people who apply for the job and whose resume you select as "facially plausible" will be entirely unable to program, at all. The search term for learning more about this is FizzBuzz. So true, and something that stumped me when I sat at the other side of a hiring table myself. I couldn't figure out why until it was pointed out to me that people who are good at their job are not looking for work, they already have a job. In fact, the really good people often don't apply for jobs at all, but instead they get convinced to switch employers. By contrast, the people who can't program are on the job market all the time. So, the job market is heavily skewed towards people not good enough to hire.
- FLUX-YOU 9y ago>By contrast, the people who can't program are on the job market all the time. So, the job market is heavily skewed towards people not good enough to hire. People should be allowed to leave the industry for some amount of time without being marked as damaged goods. In fact, based on how poorly technical interviews have evolved, I have no faith that a hiring manager wouldn't just blindly ignore all candidates with an employment gap on their record after reading posts similar to yours, and that really is a damn shame. It's not a humane practice.
- Joeri 9y agoI didn’t mean to imply employment gaps, just that people who can’t program do a lot more job interviews than people who can.
- lifeisstillgood 9y ago"""in B2B) taking a business process which exists in many places and markedly decreasing the total cost of people required to implement it.""" thus a big idea search should be on what are common processes. "reading english" seems to be the next big one
- megamindbrian2 9y agoThis is helpful for my Asperger's. I like the part about the coffee money. Thank you!
- nickthemagicman 9y agoYour idea is not valuable, at all. All value is in the execution. You think you are an exception; you are not. You should not insist on an NDA to talk about it; nobody serious will engage in contract review over an idea, and this will mark you as clueless. Love that so much.
- Singletoned 9y ago> Technical literacy in the broader population can be approximated with the Thanksgiving test: what sort of questions do you get at Thanksgiving? That's the ambient level of literacy. I didn't understand this one (perhaps due to not being American). Can someone explain it please?
- oconnor663 9y agoThanksgiving is a holiday where many people have a big family meal. If you have family members who you usually only see once a year, there's a good chance that day is Thanksgiving. So that's when a lot of people tend to field questions from people who 1) care about them enough to ask how their new job is going but 2) have no idea what they really do at work.
- aap_ 9y agoI thought they meant that they would ask you to fix their computer.
- purplezooey 9y ago"collapse of a cartel organized against the interests of workers" -- to what is this referring?
- dlandis 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_Litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...
- zaptheimpaler 9y agoAgreements not to negotiate past a certain amount and not compete too hard for talent, etc. amongst tech companies to reduce wages. Link: https://pando.com/2014/03/22/revealed-apple-and-googles-wage-fixing-cartel-involved-dozens-more-companies-over-one-million-employees/ https://pando.com/2014/03/22/revealed-apple-and-googles-wage...
- ThomPete 9y ago"Your idea is not valuable, at all." If execution is all that matters your idea isn't good enough. I don't care how many times people keep claiming that execution is all that matters, it's still wrong or it becomes tautological, like saying. The key to success is being successful. Good ideas are often shitty ideas until they are good. What makes them good isn't just execution but timing, luck and so many other factors. Failing to understand that is a bigger problem than the few people left who think the idea is everything.
- Joeri 9y agoI always understood it to mean that a good idea doesn’t sell unless you execute well on it, and also that an idea doesn’t need to be unique, it just needs to be executed better than the competitors.
- ThomPete 9y agoBut that is also not always the case. If you are first to market you don't need to be executing better than the competitors since they don't necessarily exist. It's way more complex and subtle than the "execution is all that matters" or the "my idea is secured in a password protected powerpoint" camp. I have helped over a 100 startups and at least in my experience, it's not more correct to say execution is all that matters than to say ideas are all that matter. Plenty of well-executed ideas don't ever go anywhere because the ideas were wrong, to begin with. In the context of this otherwise fine list by Patrick this is just particularly problematic because it's wrong in a non-obvious way but sounds right.
- solatic 9y ago> Plenty of well-executed ideas don't ever go anywhere because the ideas were wrong, to begin with. Or, to put it another way, the founders made an MVP from their initial (for argument's sake, poor) idea, and then couldn't find product-market fit before running out of (bootstrapped or VC-funded) runway. Your argument, then, is that some ideas and MVPs make it impossible to find product-market fit, no matter who the founders / executive team are, because there is no market or whatever other reason beyond the startup's control. And you would be correct if it wasn't possible for startups to pivot. But they do, sometimes multiple times, and sometimes successfully. Part of the reason why execution is everything is because good executives can take what the startup has learned about its product and its market, understand that the startup's current trajectory leads to bankruptcy, and make the necessary pivot which presents better odds at viability.
- garfieldnate 9y agoWhat is the anti-labor cartel he's talking about?
- greenyoda 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_Litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_L...