12 ms·
Why do we care more about benefit ‘scroungers’ than billions lost to the rich?
- j7ake 9y agoWhen the rich have significant influence over the media and politics, they are able to sway public opinion to focus on others rather than them
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoYes, much better to have poor people fighting each other than coming after them.
- mirimir 9y agoBasically, yes. So most of us have been conned. Or bought off with small change. Also, "scroungers" serve as object lessons, so they must be painted with fear and loathing.
- pjc50 9y agoIndeed. As I'm arguing downthread, a lot of this is driven by sensationalist media and TV reporting that tries to use the most extreme cases to smear everyone else. Very few people who aren't on benefits have an accurate idea of how the system works and how obstinate it is.
- toasterlovin 9y agoWasn't the lesson of Trump's election that the rich and powerful don't have significant influence over the media that people actually consume (social media) anymore?
- lightbyte 9y agoIs Trump not rich and powerful?
- toasterlovin 9y agoYes, Trump is rich (and powerful, now that he's president), but he doesn't control the media in the sense that the person I was responding to was referring to. I think they had someone like Jeff Bezos, who owns The Washington Post, in mind.
- lightbyte 9y agoHe might not control the media in the traditional sense, but we have to give him credit for how he manipulated it into giving him endless free coverage and exposure. He turned the lack of media control INTO the powerful position.
- jlebrech 9y agoWe don't plan to be poor, and all wish to be rich. When someone claims that extra £30 a week we feel it's our money because we can visualise it in our minds. When a rich person finds a way to not pay tax, it feels more like it's their money to begin with and it is taken from them, and we ourselves wouldn't like to lose out on millions.
- roryisok 9y agoI don't feel that way. I feel much more angry about rich people dodging taxes than relatively poor people cheating on benefits.
- finaliteration 9y agoEspecially given that benefit “cheating” isn’t nearly as widespread as people tend to think it is. The percentage of benefit payout errors (not just fraud but overpayments for other reasons including fraud) in the US is typically in the single digits, whereas public perception seems to be that anyone using any sort of welfare program is cheating and doesn’t deserve it.
- roryisok 9y ago> whereas public perception seems to be that anyone using any sort of welfare program is cheating and doesn’t deserve it. I think this is it. Even being on benefits in the first place is considered scrounging by some. I'd much rather see someone on minimum wage manage to get a free medical card than someone making £100k a year find a way to avoid paying tax on their holiday home. I find it hard to believe I'm in the minority.
- jlebrech 9y agothe system is also designed in such a way that the rich have legal loopholes whereas the poor have to break the law.
- vixen99 9y ago
- fredley 9y agoAs the article states, a lot of this is to do with the characterisation of the ultra-rich as 'hardworking', vs the characterisation of benefits claimants (legally or otherwise) as not. This narrative plays depressingly well with a lot of people in the UK, especially with those who are in the socioeconomic classes just above recipients of benefits.
- s_kilk 9y agoA lot of that barely-scraping-by class see themselves as aspirants to the middle and upper classes, which is equal parts laughable and understandable. The term generally applied to this phenomenon is "False Consciousness", as opposed to Class Consciousness. If they want to identify a parasite class in society, they should be looking up, not down.
- kunimu 9y agoThis is precisely true. The ideological currents within bourgeois economy and politics do so much to promote false consciousness. On the other hand, most people do not view themselves as ideological, but is that not the paradox? To accept ideology, it must first be presented as non-ideological. The reader of the bourgeois papers, the person who is apathetic to his society's material conditions, the voter, the buyer of Starbucks because for each cup they give a few pennys to some improvished farmers. Their ideology is in fact simple: that they live in a post-ideological world.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agodafuq are you talking about?
- mandelbrotwurst 9y agoI think the parent may be referring to some of the ideas of Slavoj Zizek. The class consciousness / false consciousness concept he is replying to is a Marxist theory.
- 9y ago
- neilwilson 9y agoBecause the billions aren't lost to the rich. They ain't spending it, so there is no real resource drain. It's just numbers in a bank account. Essentially the rich saving has the same economic effect as taxation. Hit them with remittance taxation and it will just sit there 'offshore' doing largely nothing other than making the rich feel rich, even though they can't spend it. The 'scroungers' however are draining real resources for nothing apparently in return. Not that they can provide anything because there aren't sufficient jobs for them. In other words they are not 'scroungers', they are just the 1 in 20 people who can't get a job under neo-liberalism because it requires about 5% permanently unemployed to control inflation. What we do get annoyed about are the 'idle rich'. Those who appear to get their money 'for nothing' the same as the 'scroungers' and then flaunt it by buying expensive stuff. There is no reduction in public service capability by the rich having vast sums of money 'offshore'. The government is never short of money - as they demonstrate everytime somebody they don't like needs bombing, or a set of new nuclear submarines need purchasing.
- pc86 9y ago> Those who appear to get their money 'for nothing' the same as the 'scroungers' and then flaunt it by buying expensive stuff. How someone got their money is irrelevant, but it's much better for the economy that they spend it, even on garbage, than let it sit in a brokerage account. Every person with a trust fund spending $400k on an Aston Martin is sustaining (not creating) jobs and distributing wealth to some degree.
- neilwilson 9y ago"but it's much better for the economy that they spend it," Generally it isn't - because that tilts the economy towards producing goods and services that are wanted rather than those that are needed. Trickle down has been shown over the last 30 years to be largely a myth. For example if you have public healthcare and private healthcare and there is a shortage of doctors then the wealthy "crowds out" the public healthcare system by purchasing private healthcare. Essentially they are using their wealth to jump the queue. Like the 'priority queue' at a theme park.
- ryandrake 9y agoFalse optimism? Old article, but probably still true today: 19% of Americans think they are among the top 1% of earners and 20% more think they will be one day [1]. When you introduce a plan that hurts "the rich": 39% of people think they're the target. 1: http://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-hope-over-self-interest.html http://www.nytimes.com/2003/01/12/opinion/the-triumph-of-hop...
- Frqy3 9y agoI think it is a combination of people expecting to move up financially over time, and wanting to keep as large a gap as possible between themselves and the next rung down on the financial ladder.
- blfr 9y agoThis isn't false optimism. It's a surprisingly accurate self-assessment. It turns out that 12 percent of the population will find themselves in the top 1 percent of the income distribution for at least one year. What’s more, 39 percent of Americans will spend a year in the top 5 percent of the income distribution, 56 percent will find themselves in the top 10 percent, and a whopping 73 percent will spend a year in the top 20 percent of the income distribution. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/from-rags-to-riches-to-rags.html https://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/20/opinion/sunday/from-rags-...
- yorwba 9y agoSo ... 39% think they'll be in the top 1%, when in reality that's the proportion who get to be in the top 5%. How is that an accurate self-assessment?
- yequalsx 9y agoH.L. Mencken once defined puritanism as the haunting fear that someone, somewhere is having fun. Based on my interactions with conservatives in the U.S. who are religious I've modified Mencken's quote: Religious conservatism is the haunting fear that someone, somewhere is getting something they don't deserve.
- mrguyorama 9y agoFor various definitions of "deserve" that depend on the person, the color of the sky, how they are feeling today etc etc
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoSo, in your country only the religious are greedy?
- yequalsx 9y agoNo. I think your logic may be off. If I say all A have property B this does not imply that no other type of object can have property B. For instance, it is true that all living men have cells that reproduce. But men aren’t the only living humans with this property. Also it’s clearly just meant to be a witty statement and not to be taken as a formal definition.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoIt was a question, not a conclusion; I think you'll find the flaw with your own logic, comprehension, or both. >"Based on my interactions with conservatives in the U.S. who are religious [...]" This strongly implies you only find the given characteristic, greed, amongst the religious subset of conservatives. I was thus enquiring so as to establish whether, for example, you found all those without religion to be devoid of greed. You strongly implied it was only non-religious conservatives who were immune to greed; do you care to comment on those who aren't conservative, do you find the same result. Of course my question was loaded: I expect your position to be based primarily on prejudice rather than science but would be happy to be corrected. FWIW I'm not religious, not conservative, not USAmerican, but am often greedy.
- archagon 9y agoFor some reason, people can't wrap their heads around the fact that every enterprise needs some degree of "shrinkage" to keep functioning effectively. Try to get those margins to zero and everything starts going haywire.
- indubitable 9y agoWithout expressing an opinion one way or the other, the reason is very simple to explain. Taxes are seen as taking something away from you. Benefits by contrast are something that somebody else is giving to you. Having less taken away from you is going to be seen as less of an issue than somebody else taking more from other people than they 'deserve.' There's plenty of lost nuance in this view, but if you try to empathize with people who feel this way - it's not hard.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoA lot of the people in the UK you hear complaining about benefits are pensioners, the pension budget dwarfs that for benefits, it's the largest part of our welfare state. They don't complain about that gift from the government. The reality is we have had a rather rabid right wing press for some time, this has led to some people having a distorted view on these things. There was a survey recently which asked people how much is lost to benefit fraud, the answer people gave was 25% when the reality is 0.7%. I don't know about the costs but I can imagine you couldn't get lower than that without spending more than the return. I try and empathise with their attitudes but I don't want it affecting policy.
- Boothroid 9y ago'gift from the government'?! These are people that have worked their whole lives from times when benefit scrounging was not a viable life plan. There's plenty of poverty in retirement. Also quite apart from fraud there are peversely generous incentives for people not to work, and thus we end up with the spectacle of multiple generations having never worked, and having no intention to do so.
- pjc50 9y agoIncentives not to work: a real problem. The only way out of that is methodical reform of the system; what Universal Credit could be if it wasn't a disaster being run by IDS. Multiple generations never having worked: very rare, this is a common piece of anti-benefit propaganda that's rarely rooted in fact. https://www.jrf.org.uk/report/are-cultures-worklessness-passed-down-generations https://www.jrf.org.uk/report/are-cultures-worklessness-pass...
- gadders 9y agoBecause in general the rich are a net gain to society.
- Boothroid 9y agoI don't care - we need to counter the cynicism at both ends of the scale. For example, it cannot be right that someone that pays into the system their whole lives can then be refused housing in favour of an able bodied person that has paid in nothing and caused their own homelessness by arriving in the UK without a job or means to support themselves. Needless to say the tax avoidance is also disgusting. There are some very strange situations in the UK at present - for example when a person would actually be worse off by going out to work, or when someone's (viable) career plan involves having a child in order to get a house and benefits. Given my political views I'm consoled by the fact that the level of welfare spending is unsustainable in the long term. The UK is already going deeper into the red every month, despite supposed austerity.
- pjc50 9y ago> able bodied person that has paid in nothing and caused their own homelessness by arriving in the UK without a job or means to support themselves Is this actually possible? People claim it happens a lot, but without being specific on what they mean. Note that most UK visas involve "no recourse to public funds" https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/public-funds--2/public-funds https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/public-funds--2/p... > the level of welfare spending is unsustainable in the long term Reducing this means either an expansion of employment in run-down areas like Blackpool, or reducing benefit levels and hoping that people die quietly. http://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/news-articles/1117/161117-austerity-deaths-england http://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/news-articles/1117/161117-austerit...
- Boothroid 9y agoBut if you come from the EU you do not need a visa, do you? >Reducing this means either an expansion of employment in run-down areas like Blackpool, or reducing benefit levels and hoping that people die quietly. Not reducing means that the country eventually goes bankrupt. And then there won't be any benefits for anyone at all, will there? To put it another way, if your principle holds true, why don't we just increase benefits until they are 100% of the economy?
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoTo me the biggest benefit of UBI is we might be able to get rid of this attitude. It's hard to criticise a benefit when you are a recipient of it yourself.
- neximo64 9y agoThis is precisely the reason I'm against UBI, I don't want to be involuntarily subject to it. I'd rather have the choice.
- pjc50 9y agoThe capacity of people to rationalise a literal free lunch as oppression never ceases to amaze me.
- ApolloFortyNine 9y agoAnd the capacity of people to call government hand outs 'free' never ceases to amaze me. The money is coming from somewhere. It may be free to you, but it's someone else's money.
- lovich 9y agoAnd with an actual free lunch the group handing it out is losing something. That doesn't change the fact that to you, it is free, and how is that a bad thing for you?
- mdemare 9y agoIn a world with a $10K yearly UBI, income taxes for many people will go up by a lot more than $10K.
- lovich 9y agoMaybe were talking past each other. I definitely see why someone wouldn't want to pay for the system but I took OPs comment as complaining about being given money which I cannot understand
- hasenj 9y agoThe other day I was listening to a clip from Jordan Peterson, and he said something that I found a bit surprising/shocking, but this articles seems to confirm it: people on the left who claim to side with the poor don't actually care about the poor, they just hate the rich. This article is basically just hating on the rich people. I think it's rather easy to understand what this author is puzzled by: people want to keep their money. If you've earned your money and you want to keep it, I can empathize with you. If you think you deserve to take other people's money, I can't empathize with you.
- pjc50 9y agoA little case study from Twitter today: https://twitter.com/imajsaclaimant/status/930515080130826240 https://twitter.com/imajsaclaimant/status/930515080130826240 Do you "empathize" with the person referred to as "PH" there? Why not?
- hasenj 9y agoFor every guy who legitimately could use some temporary help until he gets back on his feet, there are hundreds of free loaders. If you think about it actually more reason to hate on free loaders. They cause tragedies like this.
- DanBC 9y agoClearly not in the UK. For every freeloader there are hundreds who need a bit of temporary support. We know this from the number of people who are working and claiming benefit. (I think these now outnumber people not working and claiming benefit).
- hasenj 9y ago> We know this from the number of people who are working and claiming benefit. For how long do they claim benefits? This could actually be a bad sign.
- muzani 9y agoIt's a matter of principle. I think most people just have this plan of working hard until 65. They're deeply unhappy with this. They sacrifice joy, comfort, relationships, and family to live this dream of survival. They value others who suffer similarly. Benefit scroungers have some level of comfort without the hard work. I don't even tell people I live comfortably freelancing anymore because people have such a negative perception of it. I may work 20 hours a week at double the effort but all people see is that I'm being lazy for not doing a full 40 hour week. Whereas people have this perception of a rich person working weekends, waking up at 4 AM, getting divorced to make their company work. And so people empathize more with the corrupt rich.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- arethuza 9y agoIn the UK I don't think it's "people empathize more with the corrupt rich" - I think it's simply that most people aren't aware of the amounts of money lost to the Treasury by benefit fraud and tax evasion.
- valuearb 9y agoIn one case someone wants you to work harder so they can work less, in the other someone worked hard (or smart) and doesn't want to give up as much of what they earned to others so they can work less.
- eevilspock 9y agoMany people take issue with whether it was "earned" and how it was "earned" in the first place.
- arethuza 9y agoYes, I know what they both are - and I don't approve of either. However, looking at the simple finances of it (because that's what actually impacts public services) tax evasion is about 30 times bigger a problem than benefit fraud.
- contingencies 9y ago"The rich" have more education, political and media influence and resistance to accusations as advertisers, potential litigators, owners, etc. Many people are not critical thinkers and lap up media as gospel without a second thought.
- dnautics 9y agoI think this is a question everyone who is anti-austerity should ask themselves. It seems like every program labelled 'austerity' marginally cuts social services and benefits instead of actually cutting bloatware programmes (construction, military) that send money to the 1%. And then is declared (usually by the left) to be a failure of the concept of ending deficit spending.
- draw_down 9y agoBecause we hate the poor.
- loourr 9y agoBecause the rich are contributing and it's a question of the degree to which they're contributing. Scroungers are just taking and draining the system even if it's a "smaller" amount.
- endymi0n 9y agoI was going to downvote you, but actually — even though I completely disagree with the premise — it makes perfect sense as an explanation.
- goda90 9y agoThis raises the question of the importance of the consumer in our economy. Scroungers still spend money, and often spend most of the money they get, which puts money in the pockets of companies, which they then spend on payroll and other things. If the money they get is being put back into the system, then how is it draining?
- Merthurian 9y agoAlmost by definition, these people can't manage their resources as efficiently as the wealthy.
- myaso 9y agoThere is nothing to manage at least from the perspective of monetary assets, things would disappear too fast for you have a chance to 'manage' them; also it's the opposite, the poor are very efficient with the limited resources they have -- you kinda have to be wouldn't you? Lest you end up from just being poor to being a corpse. Below a certain breakpoint money only functions as a means of consumption. With what they are bringing in they will never be able to save enough to make any investments that will have a net positive in their lives and a negative shock will very quickly wipe out whatever progress they make. From their perspective it is actually logical to buy lottery tickets and gamble since the price of admission is low enough for them to afford; the calculus for them is shifted in a way that is different from your experiences. When you have an abundance of resources you are in a completely different position since you don't need to be concerned with survival anymore -- also you get many chances since your eggs won't end up in the same basket. It's not impossible but the chances that somebody who is poor can execute the process for a legitimate means of making money outside whatever formal arrangement they are in as opposed to brewing meth (which can be considered a 'side project' depending on your frame of mind) is unlikely given the context they find themselves in. The prior statements also hinge upon the unlikely event that someone can escape the cess pit of proletariat culture in the first place. It's structured to be this way, the range of choices somebody can make at the bottom of the socio economic ladder is much more restricted -- why do you think there are such stringent drug and prostitution laws in certain places? It's to reduce the actions that poor people can take outside the game that a relatively small group collectively decided we need to play -- when you reduce people's agency enough you can get them to do absolutely anything through a 'legit' channel: like taking a bullet to the head in some far off country, doing back breaking work in a kitchen, or something else that is equally unpleasant. A certain fraction of the population needs to be meat for the grinder to do it's job.
- hans_mueller 9y agothe scroungers are visible while the rich are rather abstract and invisible.
- adamwong246 9y agobecause we, mere thousandaires and paupers alike, live in a separate reality from the ultra-wealthy. The rich and poor-and-middle-class might as well be living on different planets. When a benefits cheater somehow gets free housing or spends foodstamps on lobster, we ordinary citizens can see that and relate to that. "That could have been my house or my dinner!" We can see the cheaters on the street and imagine ourselves in their place. We can relate. But when a faceless corporation we've never heard of hides umptillions in a place we've never heard of, somehow the impact is lost. Ask an average joe on the street the difference between a million, a billion and a trillion and you will be answered with shrugs. We don't see how that money flows from one holding company to another and we fail to connect that to the broader economy, and this illusion has been perpetuated by hidden class of venal, remorseless, well-educated and very smart mercenaries beholden by law and their shareholders to accumulate every last speck of capital. This state of affairs is not new in America- Kurt Vonnegut recognized the phenomenon 50 years ago https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/158414-america-is-the-wealthiest-nation-on-earth-but-its-people https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/158414-america-is-the-wealt...
- somethingabout 9y agoI've talked about tax avoidance to many people. I get the sense that most people don't understand it or the consequences. If you say "so and so company avoided paying 1 billion in taxes so all of us will have to pay it instead" that means nothing to them.
- HarryHirsch 9y agoMaybe it's a matter of staging and perception. Every quarter Social Services audit their books, and the local fishwrapper features the County Executive and the Sheriff grandstanding with their arrest record over overclaimed benefits. Now if you did like Mohammed-bin-Salman and paraded with the most brazen tax evaders payment morale at the top would increase quickly.
- georgeecollins 9y agoI think the answer is because you tend to compare yourself to people that are close to you in terms of attainment. So you don't compare yourself to the Queen of England or a malnourished farmer in Africa. A middle class person compares them self to the person who lost his job, and the person that is doing a bit better in their town or neighborhood. Focusing on the "scroungers" is a way to hate what you are afraid of becoming, or what you sacrifice to avoid.
- megamindbrian2 9y agoBecause if we were rich, we would try and avoid the government also? Can't blame them. Don't like it? Find yourself an angel investor.
- jokoon 9y agoBecause the rich are essential the functioning of society, while the poor are expendable. If the poor don't trust the government, even the poor will agree that the rich should pay less taxes. I really believe that's how things lead to anarchy.
- mseebach 9y agoThis seems to be the central data point of the article: > less than half (48%) thought that legal tax avoidance was “usually or always wrong”. > By contrast, more than 60% of Britons believe it is “usually or always wrong” for poorer people to use legal loopholes to claim more benefits I think there are two reasonably simple explanations here: First, I don't know what a legal loophole to claim more benefits is - either you qualify for a given payment, or you don't. Perhaps I'm not paying attention, but I don't recall having heard much debate on legal benefits loopholes, just regular fraud. There's a risk that some portion of respondents heard "fraud", even though the question was about legal loopholes. The other factor is that there is a significant moral difference between arrangements for paying less tax on money that you legitimately earned, and arrangements to receive more money that you didn't, but which are provided to you to help you become your situation is considered precarious. Yes, there are people (legally) receiving unreasonable amounts of income that they didn't "earn", in many cases from public budgets, directly or indirectly, through various kinds of cronyism. This, not which rate of tax is paid on such income, is unethical, basically a crime, but I believe that the way to deal with it, is in a first class way, not through the tax code.
- DanBC 9y ago> There's a risk that some portion of respondents heard "fraud", even though the question was about legal loopholes. Isn't that the point? People see tax avoidance but don't see it as fraud; people see legal benefit maximisation and see it as fraud. > First, I don't know what a legal loophole to claim more benefits is - either you qualify for a given payment, or you don't. A benefit claimant's benefit is paid by the secretary of state for the department for work and pensions. That person is obviously busy, so they employ decision makers who sit in benefit centres across the UK. There's no way to interact directly with a decision maker. You can only ever interact with them via forms and postal letters, and those letters and forms go through an intermediary. A decision maker looks at the details of the person's claim. They apply the various acts, statutes, statutory instruments, and case law to the person's claim. All that law is scattered across various places, and so decision makers have a couple of handy guide books. These are available online. https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/decision-makers-guide-staff-guide https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/decision-makers-gu... https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/advice-for-decision-making-staff-guide https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/advice-for-decisi... The advice for decision making is for: > DWP decision makers now use Advice for decision making (instead of the DMG) for decisions that involve: > Universal Credit > Personal Independence Payment contribution-based Jobseeker’s Allowance and contribution-based Employment and Support Allowance for people who are eligible for Universal Credit I think all the rest use the decision makers guide. Have a look at the guide. Have a look at the page numbers listed in each volume. The decision makers guide is 14,000 pages (fourteen thousand) long. And there's no index. It's impossible for ordinary people to work out if they're really entitled or not to a benefit. And the quality of decision making is, frankly, piss poor. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/oct/30/staggering-rise-pip-complaints-rot-system-disability-benefits https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/oct/30/stagge... here's a judge from a first tier appeal panel saying the decision making is terrible: https://sirhenrybrooke.me/2017/11/08/poor-decision-making-personal-independence-payments-pips-and-pip-appeals/ https://sirhenrybrooke.me/2017/11/08/poor-decision-making-pe... So, a legal benefit loophole might be a skilled benefits adviser who helps claimants make claims by helping them fill in the forms and gather evidence, and then helps them attend the independent medical assessments, and then helps them write the letter for mandatory reconsideration and then follow up with an appeal.
- mythrwy 9y agoHuman nature is such that we are in awe of tigers but disgusted by cockroaches.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mattlondon 9y agoI don't know enough about who-hasn't-paid-what or what the cuts to benefits are and what the impact of those are, but the article feels a bit like flame-bait to me by doing things like directly equating corporations not paying tax to people committing suicide. Surely if someone is fit for work (and so their benefits are cut), then they are fit for work even if we did have a benefits system overflowing with untold riches from Apple/Facebook/Alphabet? They'd still be fit to go to work regardless of tax revenue, surely? Perhaps there is something deeper and there is research between tax revenue and suicide due to being found fit for work, but they didn't cite any research - anyone seen any?
- mter 9y agoIt's because normal people see the money that we make as ours, then the government takes their cut. "Benefits" are our money redistributed to people who don't work. At no point do the people receiving benefits actually contribute to the system.
- russellbeattie 9y agoI'm surprised this wasn't flagged. Who is "we"?? God knows what the British think, but for years I've considered Republicanism as "a debilitating phobia that somewhere out there, someone is getting something they don't deserve, and it isn't you."
- DanBC 9y agoSome more, and recent, info: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-42012116 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-42012116 UK gov has been cutting disability benefit, but it turns out they've been underpaying by maybe 0.5 billion.