30 ms·
The Shock of Sweden's Housing Market Is Hitting the Country's Currency
- estomagordo 9y agoThe combination of removing the wealth tax and the introduction of a 30% rebate on all interest costs for individuals have really combined to clusterfuck the Swedish housing market. Now, the interest rebate seems politically impossible to touch, even long term and through minor transitioning. Home ownership is so important to the economy and affects so many voters, that the property owning class always must be looked after. People have been talking about the bubble bursting for years now, but it's only in the past year or so that the decline truly has been expected. Only a few weeks ago, there was an article in a major paper about a couple who quinnied about not being able to sell their house with the expected 1000% profit (over 30+ years). How ever would they manage, once they'd sold the house, bought an apartment, and didn't have the cool million SEK to splurge on whatever people in their 70s enjoy?
- pathy 9y agoThe interest rate deduction has been around longer than that. In 1990/1991 it was reduced to 30% from 50%. Low interest rates, the deduction, no wealth tax and a massively reduced property tax all contributed to this bubble though.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoWe got rid of mortgage interest relief in the UK so I wouldn't rule it out completely.
- soVeryTired 9y agoDoing so cratered the housing market in '89. Other countries watched and learned.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI think it was more to do with soaring interest rates. I remember it all rather well as I had just bought my first house.
- rsynnott 9y agoWe also got rid of it in Ireland when the housing market had just crashed. House prices are now rising alarmingly quickly again, regardless.
- pimmen 9y agoI absolutely hate speaking to Swedish people who invest all of their retirement savings in their home. It just breaks my heart to know that they are taking on a very high risk by putting all of their eggs into one, figurative basket when other types of investing are not only less risky but also often present more of a reward too. And, add the fact that investing in your house is one of the least helpful investments for creating new jobs and wealth for future generations. The people who had this idea have my pity but I won't refrain from using their story as a cautionary tale.
- robinwassen 9y agoHow do they "invest" in their home? Renovate it to the max, keep buying a more expensive one or paying off your loan?
- pimmen 9y agoThey buy more expensive homes than they need (or stay in the one that housed a family of four way after their kids have moved out) and pay off the mortgage. That's "saving" for retirement; they expect to get the money they've payed on their mortgage back when they sell it. Some practically only pay off the interest because we can do generous deductions off it and we have low demands of paying off the principal (or at least we used to have, now the Department of Finance is advising the government to require that banks make higher demands of paying back the principal) and why should I pay off the mortgage in full if the property prices always go up? At least that's the reasoning. I have nothing against paying off your loan, but seeing it as your one and only retirement investment is something I have serious problems with. You should live where you are most comfortable living, I don't want people speculating in their homes on a casual basis "knowing" it always pays off. If you're going to really invest in your home, renovate a floor and rent it out. That way, you're contributing to the economy, you're not just speculating you're value investing and you know what the revenue stream of your investment really is. I had the privilege of growing up in a wealthy household with 7 bedrooms and after me and my brother moved out my parents decided three rooms was enough and converted the house into three apartments, living in one and renting out the other two. Many of the neighboring families however don't like the idea since it means work, but they also don't want to move into something that won't grow as much over time. They're staying put even after the kids have moved out in hopes of cashing in right before retirement.
- mrec 9y agoThe relentlessly negative reporting here would be funny if it wasn't so pernicious. "risk ... backfire ... risks sinking ... worrying". And yet they're explicitly talking about a correction. Making something that isn't correct, correct. You might think that was a good thing. If you don't want a correction, stop pumping up bubbles. You can keep 'em inflated a long time, longer than many people can remain solvent, but if you shut out the younger generations then eventually the political calculation will change, and that change will not be in your favour. As Mark Blyth is fond of observing, the Hamptons are not a defensible position.
- matt4077 9y agoEntropically speaking, life on earth is also a bubble that will, at least over the really long term, correct.
- jackcosgrove 9y agoThe funny thing about the housing correction in the US was that prices dropped back to their historical trendline, as if the housing bubble had never happened. There wasn't even much overshoot.
- margorczynski 9y agoAre the regulations blocking the development? Considering the demand is so high wouldn't the supply follow by e.g. scaling vertically?
- pathy 9y agoLocal municipalities have veto rights to block development. There are also a bunch of rules, often overlapping, than may stop planning. All planning decisions can also be (and are) appealed for years. There is also a lack of cheap housing, most houses built today are unaffordable to most low/medium earners. This has become an even more acute problem with the recent influx of refugees. This has lead to overcrowding in poorer suburbs.
- ptaipale 9y agoSweden has rent controls, which has caused long queues to apartments (we're talking wait times of 20 years) as well as a significant grey/black market in second, third and even fourth hand contracts, because the regulated first contract is so valuable that people keep them and rent them onwards. It has also created situations where e.g. trade unions and other organisations (who own rental apartments) arrange nicely-located apartments to friendly politicians (and their relatives) ahead of the queue at very advantageous rents.
- mijamo 9y agoContrary to popular belief there is no housing shortage in Sweden. There is howere shortage of new cheap housing.
- mmrezaie 9y agoAs someone just bought an apartment in Stockholm two years ago I was shocked seeing that I made 50 or more percent on how much I paid for my apartment but when I checked the data there I saw not all the areas in Stockholm raised in the same time and rate. I think there were many areas got hyped and there are many old buildings which raised and if you check the data you will see the start of falling in prices is not happening everywhere. I would guess prices will continue falling for two or more years but to the point, before the scare and excitement started which raised the prices too high in a year, and then it will stabilize. There is a talk also to loosen the restriction on companies which renting apartments. I really do not think this is like US's 2008 era inflation.
- estomagordo 9y agoI mean, buyers aren't going to be able to loan money at 1.5% interest (1% effective) forever.
- alkonaut 9y agoThere are tons of things inflating house prices. The most important for Sweden are - Deduction of interest expenses from income tax. - Too long mortgages (100 years or more) means nominal prices are high which add to the risk - Historically big mortgages (90, 100 or even 110% of the cost could be financed - yes negativev down payments existed in the early 2000's). - Rent control of almost all flats, meaning no one will build places to rent, only to buy. - Extremely low interest rates as the central bank refuses to look at housing costs and interest rates when aiming for the inflation target. This is the recipe for disaster. Now, it's not ALL doom and gloom, a lot has actually improved. Down payments have been 15-25% for some time now, mortgages are no longer infinite, and banks are using max-multiple-of-household-income caps (typically 4-5x) to limit lending. I think the situation now is a bit brighter than it would have been if we had been hit by a big correction in 2008 (which we were not). Many would welcome a controlled price correction (say 10-15%), and it IS expected since all the above changes have yet NOT changed the prices downward, even though the pool of prospective buyers gets smaller and smaller the more restrictive lenders are. It would be very welcome to see the correction now that both domestic and global economy is decent, interest rates are low etc.
- selectodude 9y ago> Too long mortgages (100 years or more) means nominal prices are high which add to the risk That is absolutely bananas. Almost like a Chinese-style 99 year lease. Your kids might be dead by the time it's paid off, you'll never own it. Edit: apparently the AVERAGE mortgage term is 140 years! Just recently the Swedish government limited the maximum mortgage term to 105 years. That is some absolutely stupid policy.
- opportune 9y agoAs an American I am absolutely shocked anybody thought that was a good idea. If an average person making $50k/year finds it affordable to pay $1200/month on housing, they're just going to shop for a house that will yield that desired monthly payment. When interest rates are low, how is this not a recipe for runaway housing costs? What's worse is that this is actually a huge subsidy for landlords, unless their mortgage terms are limited to be much shorter. A landlord can afford the downpayment to finance many homes at low interest rates, whereas a poorer person may be able to make the payments on such a mortgage, but can't save up enough to afford a down payment.
- opportune 9y agoWhen will we learn that a "strong" housing market is not necessarily a good thing? High housing prices are great for those who already owned houses but terrible for everyone else (e.g. the entire generations born after prices became inflated). Not to mention people are greedy and will over leverage themselves when interest rates are good. No country should let the "landed gentry" hold them hostage over interest rates or tax policy so that their assets - many of which they do not even actually own - can appreciate.
- maxxxxx 9y agoTotally agree. It seems one of the factors that helped the US until the 90s was that housing was affordable so people could move around easily. A "strong" housing market seems to indicate that there are no productive places for investing and no wage growth so people need to gamble on houses to rise instead.
- expertentipp 9y ago> A "strong" housing market seems to indicate that there are no productive places for investing and no wage growth so people need to gamble on houses to rise instead. You've just summarized the situation in Prague, Czech Republic.
- jankotek 9y agoPrague has problem with supply, new flats are build slowly.
- Yizahi 9y agoSame in Ukraine
- novalis78 9y agoSame in Munich... QE money looking for a 'tangible' home
- contingencies 9y ago
- jacknews 9y agoWhile a drop in house prices might, in theory, negatively effect the economy in the short term as homeowners, in theory, have less disposable income, in the long term land prices/speculation (and when people talk about house prices, they really mean land prices) are a huge rentier suck on the economy, and should be taxed to the point that speculation or 'investment' in land itself (not the development of it) reaps zero gains. After all, why should anyone profit merely by owning land, when the value of that land really reflects other people's economic activity and development in the surrounding area.
- saiya-jin 9y ago> After all, why should anyone profit merely by owning land, when the value of that land really reflects other people's economic activity and development in the surrounding area. After all, why should anybody profit from merely owning a stock? Or vintage car/painting, whatever that can appreciate over time because of supply/demand. This is how people invest. I understand that being on the other side of equation might suck, but that't not the problem of equation.
- baursak 9y agoI don't get it. When prices are high, it's a housing crisis. When prices are going down, it's a housing crisis. It's almost as if news articles just need to be written regardless of the reason.
- spand 9y agoThere is a third option you know.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- adventured 9y agoThat's because those two market situations are the most concerning. Prices haven't just been high, they've been extremely high. You're not presenting all scenarios however, there's the vast in-between, aka healthy, that sits between bubble and falling.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoIt's because of how much money and emotion the average person is throwing into a house.
- dfhdfhfdh 9y agoMaybe housing shouldn't be a market system. Instead, housing should be free and landlords should be abolished.
- IdontRememberIt 9y agoA successful real estate agent once told me: the market price is driven by the threee "D"s: Death, Divorce, Debt.
- yxhuvud 9y agoI'd add a fourth, Delivery. As in new kids.
- soVeryTired 9y agoIf falling house prices are so problematic, then why do governments allow house prices to rise so sharply? If house price stability was explicitly a part of our central banks' mandate, we wouldn't have such ridiculously low interest rates, people wouldn't be borrowing vast multiples of their salary to buy a house, and we wouldn't have the sword of damocles hanging over us in the form of another property slump.
- staticelf 9y agoThe housing market in Sweden has been like borrowing money to buy stock and while everyone earns a profit, no one complains and it would be unpopular to make a change politically.
- EGreg 9y agoContrarian position: low inflation seems like a good problem to have. You can always increase inflation much more easily than decrease it -- such as printing more money and giving it to people or businesses to spend on things, which spurs the economy. What is interesting to me is that, even though it seems to take less Kronor now to buy something, somehow it slumped against the Euro so it takes even less Euro to buy that same thing? Yet the thing remained the same?
- bracobama 9y agoAs a foreigner here in Sweden I've heard about this mystical bubble which will burst sometime soon causing morgage rates to skyrocket. If I was going to buy something, say in North Stockholm, how long would you recommend waiting?
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoThat's the wrong way to look at it. If you wait for the bubble to pop, it may never happen. Or it could happen, but only after prices doubles, and the "crash" may only take the price back to where it is now. Buy now IF you can afford to hold onto the property through a crash. If you expect to need to sell this property in the next 2-5 years, do not buy it.
- styren 9y agoI recently sold my appartment in central Stockholm, I am reinvesting my money in stocks and renting for 1-2 years before hopefully entering a more healthy housing market. Of course it is all a gamble, but most people I talk to recommend waiting +1,5 years, if you can.
- zeeed 9y agoCouldn’t agree more. The current market situation here looks downright bizarre at times, I’m having trouble seeing how any substantial investment in this makes sense. Who did you talk to for advice in Stockholm?
- mrmekon 9y agoIf bubbles were predictable, they wouldn't be bubbles. Everyone claims they're in a housing bubble when prices rise for years on end. They often aren't. Even when they are, literally nobody knows when they will break, or by how much. Here's an article predicting the Stockholm "bubble" would pop in 2009: https://arbetet.se/2009/06/26/har-alla-glomt-90-talets-bostadsbubbla/ https://arbetet.se/2009/06/26/har-alla-glomt-90-talets-bosta... And here's one predicting it in 2003: https://www.svd.se/prispress-okar-risk-for-bostadsbubbla https://www.svd.se/prispress-okar-risk-for-bostadsbubbla And here's what it did: https://www.globalpropertyguide.com/template/assets/img/sweden-average-house-prices-4.gif https://www.globalpropertyguide.com/template/assets/img/swed... So, if you followed internet advice, you would have pulled out of the market 15 years ago and still be waiting.
- djohnston 9y agoDoes anyone have a good resource (book or site) that explains the interactions between central banks and the economies they influence? My macro-economic knowledge is lacking...
- bjourne 9y agoI wonder why this article is upvoted so highly. The article is not very interesting and almost devoid of real content.
- WilsonPhillips 9y agoCrytocurrencies and blockchain based solutions like Bitcoin have a built-in deflationary element from the start right? Could that be a way to counteract the deflationary tendencies of this market?
- jackcosgrove 9y agoDon't conflate cryptocurrencies with blockchains. Blockchains are merely a decentralized way to prove stake in something. Cryptocurrencies with a fixed supply like Bitcoin are deflationary, especially since mining costs increase over time. Cryptocurrencies need not have a fixed supply, and in fact a "currency" with a fixed supply is indeed not a currency but an asset. Currencies must slowly and predictably inflate to be useful, otherwise people don't spend today since the "currency" is worth more tomorrow. Currencies facilitate commerce and should grow in supply with the economy. They should not be a speculative tool to benefit first movers. tl;dr: inflation is necessary, deflation is bad, hyperinflation is the worst.
- jjawssd 9y agoWhat are the major tech hubs with the "weakest" housing markets? This would be an interesting list of options for techies that do not want to pay so much for land and housing.
- hsjoberg 9y agoAs a Swede owning an expensive apartment this sucks. Currently we only need to pay mortgage down to 75%, so a lot of young swedes will loose a great deal of money.
- jesusthatsgreat 9y agoIt's not just Sweden, it's almost everywhere (in the western world at least). It's almost entirely down to the effects of unprecedented quantitative easing over the past decade or so. When you print more money than you've ever printed before, it's only natural that the prices of things will rise as more people can afford to buy things. And even if more people can't afford to buy things, the money goes somewhere so it probably means the rich people get richer. And they'll go out and buy things they know poorer people will always need i.e. property. It all works well until property gets so expensive that the only people that can afford to buy it are other wealthy people. Eventually someone gets forced in to selling at a loss and the whole house of cards collapses as the wealthy who can afford to buy more property sit on the sidelines and wait / hope for a catastrophic collapse. Rinse, wash, repeat and yet we still question why the rich get richer... the only way to prevent property getting out of control is by regulating it so that it remains affordable and that speculators are discouraged from entering the market and encouraged to sell. But that won't happen either because most politicians own large amounts of property and they've a vested interest in seeing the price of property rise...
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoIt's less about printing money and more about falling long-term interest rates (and thus, discount rates). Fundamentally, a house is worth the net present value of its use value. Lower discount rates means that more of that value gets pulled forward into its present valuation. An equivalent way of thinking of it is that house prices are fixed by mortgages to rents - when mortgage payments are lower than rents, people buy houses and rent them out, pushing house prices up. Falling mortgage interest rates push mortgage payments lower at the same principle amount, which convinces people to buy and push up housing prices.
- alkonaut 9y agoIn Sweden though, pretty much no one rents a house. This may or may not be relevant to the above observation. It's also generally not allowed to buy flats to rent them out which limits speculation in that market.
- davidf18 9y agoHousing, just like any other input, is best for the economy when prices go down. The less money spent for housing, the more money that can be spent on other goods and services (the same is true of food, healthcare, fuel prices, ....). Much of the cost of rising housing is because of the increasing scarcity of land in desired locations (read major cities such as NYC, SF, Boston, London, Paris, ...) though "rent-seeking" which in this case is politically induced scarcity through zoning density restrictions, overuse of historic landmark status, and overregulation. The "rent-seeking" causes market inefficiencies or "market-failure." Healthy economies rely on wealth creation. Rent-seeking is a form of robbing Peter to pay Paul without creating wealth. Happily, the solution costs no money at all. It simply entails ridding the legislation that caused the rent-seeking, the artificial scarcity of land. For example, in Japan, the federal government overrides local laws that limit zoning densities. See Economists Edward Glaeser and Tim Harford (in his case, Greenbelting) for more details.
- fredgrott 9y agoits a signal that the capital markets are out of balance as far as other assets to invest in
- robinwassen 9y agoSome of my thoughts regarding the housing market, they come from both observing the market and from first hand experience by selling in Sept 2017. - A widespread mindset of people living in Stockholm has been that the housing prices will continue upwards because they have been doing so for 15+ years. A change to this mindset was starting to be noticed in the spring of 2017 and recently rapidly changed. 66% believed in rising prices in September 2017 compared to 43% in October[1]. - The time it takes to sell an apartment in Stockholm is up from ~3-4 days to weeks. - It was previously possible to earn $10k - $50k by flipping a newly produced apartment. This was done by commiting to buy the apartment when it is finished by paying a deposit and then sell it when you get the keys. This opportunity ceased to exist around the end of 2016. - Trusted sources such as Svensk Mäklarstatistik[2] and Valueguard[3] indicate that the fall in prices is around 3% - 5% this far. Untrusted sources[4] indicate that the fall is above 10%. Trusted sources uses formulas to give better stability to their indexes, but they also react slower than the untrusted sources due to that. I suspect that untrusted sources also use data points that are removed even though they failed to close the deal. - The difference between renting and cost of ownership is still huge, would estimate a 400% increase in interest rate would make the costs about even. - About 56 250 (24.96% of total) people aged 20 - 27 in Stockholm are still living with their parents even though they would like to move to their own place. In the central parts of the city this share is above 60%. [5] - Rising prices, difference between renting and cost of ownership and flipping of newly produced apartments has attracted a lot of people that invest/speculate in buying and renting out. They have probably not realized until now when the prices start to dip that they are sitting with a huge leverage on their investment/speculation and what risk that comes with. So they are probably the first ones to panic. - Production of new apartments has exploded in Sweden the last 2 years, most of these are quite expensive which might have saturated the higher end of the market. - The increase of prices has acted as jet fuel for different industries since a lot of people feel rich, increase their mortgage and consume the money. Companies that work with home makeover will be the first to get hit, but new car sales will also dip. With this said I cannot be other than uncertain about the direction of the market, there are still a lot of things that indicate that the prices will increase (cost of ownership vs rent, demand for housing, interest rate prognosis). But if the market keep going down I am quite certain that it will drag a lot of other stuff with it and become a self fulfilling prophecy. Edit: Sorry for a lot of typos and language that could be improved, just did a brain dump in a rush. [1] http://www.privataaffarer.se/bostad/seb-hushallens-boprisforvantningar-rasar-941969 http://www.privataaffarer.se/bostad/seb-hushallens-boprisfor... [2] https://www.maklarstatistik.se/omrade/riket/stockholms-lan/stockholm/ https://www.maklarstatistik.se/omrade/riket/stockholms-lan/s... [3] http://www.valueguard.se/stockholmbr http://www.valueguard.se/stockholmbr [4] https://husmask.se/kommun/stockholm/ https://husmask.se/kommun/stockholm/ [5] https://www.svd.se/en-tredjedel-av-stockholms-unga-tvingas-bo-kvar-hemma https://www.svd.se/en-tredjedel-av-stockholms-unga-tvingas-b...
- jesperlang 9y agoSome historical context: https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-tonEuOE0IXE/WfpBpIzy8rI/AAAAAAAAFBk/PvhThXo1MaYG_BtcN9BkBWgR4bmQC_SzgCLcBGAs/s1600/realaBostadspriser1952-2017k3.png https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-tonEuOE0IXE/WfpBpIzy8rI/AAAAAAAAF... The interesting lines are apartment prices (yellow/orange) and salary (green). Note that the small bump in the early 90s was the last economic crisis...
- breakyerself 9y agoIt's getting harder and harder to keep inflation on target. Universal income may become attractive from a monetary policy position at some point on top of the other reasons that have already been discussed.
- zzzzzzzza 9y agopersonally I like "quantitative easing for the people" - it doesn't provide guarantees like ubi, but it does a very similar thing, and, I think it would be a more powerful tool to combat inflation that the qe we know today, (which just swaps long term gov bonds for cash... two almost equivalent asset classes)
- acd 9y agoFractional reserve banking creating new debt of almost nothing. Hoping for a block chain future.