38 ms·
Paradise Papers: Dear Tim Cook
- ttul 9y agoTim Cook could be sued by Apple shareholders if he _didn’t_ pursue the most efficient organization for tax purposes. It’s actually his legal responsibility - not some evil thing he’s doing because he is a heartless capitalist. If you don’t like what Apple is doing, don’t blame Apple. Blame government, and use the power you do have to make change happen.
- cjsuk 9y agoI think we can bitch all we like and nothing will happen. International taxation is complicated and part of a multinational's business model revolves around exploiting that for shareholder gain. What this points to is that we need a new global trade and taxation agreement for handling this. But the policy makers don't want that because they benefit from it. Ergo, it'll always be like this. At best you can add additional sales tax for non-resident companies at the point of sale to kill their bottom line. But no one will do that because the government will be the target of the abuse from the consumer.
- k__ 9y agoAlso, they make it sound like Cook could do anything. If he would, the shareholders would simply replace him.
- cjsuk 9y agoExactly.
- LiamMcCalloway 9y agoCountries can unilaterally have taxes based on the share of total company profit generated in the country, rather than just profit in the country.
- thomasahle 9y agoThat doesn't prevent companies from moving all profit generation out of all countries but the lowest taxed.
- Maarten88 9y agoGood luck Apple selling iPhones in Jersey. They'll need to sell everyone hundreds of iPhone X's there to keep profits up.
- blowski 9y agoPeople said the same about slavery. Change _is_ possible, but it requires a lot of patience.
- JorgeGT 9y agoProblem is, it was not a lot of patience what ended slavery in the US, it was a lot of violence.
- exDM69 9y agoAnd I'm afraid that it'll be a lot of violence ending tax evasion/optimization/avoidance too. The globalization game has winners and losers and it's starting to look like the losers outnumber the winners. I'd like to see something done to the global economy system with peaceful means before someone resorts to violence.
- WillReplyfFood 9y agoYour tone is very negative, but such is the subject you state the truth. There is no incentive to build a tax world government. There seems to be a similar arrangement in the makings when it comes to trade agreements. If the EU showed one thing, its that you cant form a multinational entity by unifying trade laws alone.
- dx034 9y agoThis is why the EU thinks about introducing a revenue based tax for tech companies. Cheating on profits is easy, cheating on revenues is close to impossible.
- mindw0rk 9y agoThe point about Apple hiring best graduates who got their education mostly free of charge cause of all the tax payers really shift my mind about the whole tax-avoidance thing.
- nip 9y agoIt goes both ways, the hired graduates also benefit from this relationship: a salary used to live and buy goods, and incidentally pay taxes.
- mattmanser 9y agoTo be clear, the taxes paid by employees are their taxes, that they'd be paying if they worked for another company or set up their own business. Obviously there is some effect from Apple being an employer in increasing the overall employment rate, but there's a reason Apple needs local employees to hawk it's products. If they weren't employing and selling locally, some other company would be employing those people and taking Apple's market share.
- eref 9y agoAre there any statistics about how much of the value produced by professionals abroad actually flows back to the country of origin? Intuitively, I would say it is very little because why would you return once you live in much more privileged circumstances.
- greyman 9y ago> The point about Apple hiring best graduates who got their education mostly free of charge cause of all the tax payers really shift my mind about the whole tax-avoidance thing. Yes, that's true, but another angle is, that when the corporation profits are very high, let's say $40B yearly, then at 20% profit tax they should pay $5B. And that looks like a too high, government didn't spend nearly that much on providing stuff to Apple, per year (it's like $500K per one employee per year, if the company has 10K employes, for example).
- 9y ago
- jarym 9y ago"Such “tax optimization” – albeit legal – is only possible because specialized law firms such as Appleby devise complex company structures inaccessible to most other firms" Maybe governments should simplify their own tax rules. Then you wouldn't need specialised law firms and simpler tax systems are harder to bypass. To add, there is nothing 'moral' about tax - you have no choice but to pay what you're legally obligated to pay. Given the lack of choice in the matter, since when did it become a crime to do what you need to do to stay within the law?
- jlebrech 9y agoshould people who make enough money to hire an accountant be punished? because i'm sure they'll avoid/reduce some taxes?
- jarym 9y agoHiring an accountant should not be a crime. Especially not while tax laws are so horrendously archaic. However, look at countries that have flat-rate taxes [1]. They are much harder to skirt and the level compliance tends to be higher. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_tax
- speedplane 9y agoIf your accountant was structuring your finances so it appeared your income came from countries other than where you worked, then yes, he should probably be punished.
- jlebrech 9y agoif something isn't right but is legal, it should be made illegal. you cannot prosecute abuse prior to the change.
- speedplane 9y agoThe problem is that these companies through their lobbying power can influence governments and decide what is and isn't legal. If you define what is legal, you can legally do whatever you want.
- wjnc 9y agoDear Herr Krach, thank you for your letter. I think you misunderstand how business works. Apple is a profit seeking corporation. Profits we make, we hope to distribute to our shareholders. Paying taxes is an obligation with which we comply, both to the letter and in spirit. We meet such obligations, but not nilly-willy. Our shareholders would not look kindly upon executives who pay more taxes than necessary. Avoidance of taxes is not illegal. We even enlist the help of tax offices in many countries, like the Netherlands, Ireland and perhaps some countries internationally deemed 'tax havens'. We pay what through mutual understanding with tax offices worldwide is necessary. If you conclude that you find tax evasion a problem, this would be a political problem, not one of enterprise. No enterprise would knowingly pay to much and no construct of 'corporate social responsibility' could make paying too much alright. We should seek to minimize cost, and we do. Governments should fix tax evasion, not corporations. It's not my role to point out the obvious, but if you find the VAT customers pay on our products insufficient and were hoping on a larger slice of our 'foreign income': fix your tax code. Kind regards, TC ;)
- jarym 9y agoTax evasion IS illegal, tax avoidance is not. That's a legal point that's worth keeping in mind.
- wjnc 9y agoDarn, I mixed them up. Fixed it. Local news in the Netherlands is that our tax office gave Proctor and Gamble a few hundred million dollar tax windfall, by error. I don't look angrily upon P&G. They asked for a deal and got a super sweet one. It's the tax offices that mess this stuff up. One European tax office that coordinates these taxes and ruling could solve a lot. Then the mess would be, which country gains the taxes / profits and all hell in European government rightly ensues..
- jacquesm 9y agoYou also mis-spelled political.
- 9y ago
- jlebrech 9y agopeople avoid tax all the time, when VAT goes up do you buy that new TV or do you wait for the next budget. of if it's a laptop do you wait to buy it at duty free?
- steve19 9y ago"The iPhone not only changed the world, it did so faster than virtually any other technological innovation in history." This seems a little over the top.
- juj8 9y agoEveryone wants to be like John Oliver or Rush Limbaugh these days. There is no waiting for the EU lawmakers or the tax man to react.
- hiisukun 9y agoI have nothing against companies minimising their taxes in legal ways. I understand the various incentives at play, and it makes quite some sense - all parties concerned appear to be acting predictably. However: I do take issue with companies minimising their tax in ways that are not legal, but appear legal unless discovered. I haven't the time or knowledge of various countries' tax laws to discover which is the case in this round of leaks, and unfortunately it seems the above two views are conflated in all the articles on the subject I have so far read. It'd be great if this caused some illegally hidden/minimised/shuffled/moved profits to be taxed appropriately, but it is all too easy to covet the rich man's "hidden wealth" and proclaim his methods "cheating" without knowing whether they were simply the same as you claiming your dry cleaning. p.s. The adult in me suspects that is (as with most things) isn't a black and white issue; that the line between "legal tax minimisation" and "only legal so long as you don't find out about this part you have no way of finding out about" is both bent and blurry.
- mattmanser 9y agoIn the UK, for example, you have to register any tax avoidance scheme that you're using (as an individual at least). If the HMRC then look into that tax scheme and deem it against the rules, you pay the tax, but without penalty. As I understand it, if you don't register the scheme and you are found to be using the previously grey-area avoidance scheme, then you get done for tax evasion. That's how it's supposed to work at least, but companies seem to get sweetheart deals in these circumstances.
- daxelrod 9y agoI'm super curious about how this works in practice. What's the bar something has to meet before being reported? Do decisions made about how to do accounting count? How about decisions when filling out tax forms? (US example: itemizing deductions vs taking the standard deduction).
- mattmanser 9y agohttps://www.gov.uk/guidance/tax-avoidance-an-introduction https://www.gov.uk/guidance/tax-avoidance-an-introduction
- jbaudanza 9y agoIf we want the rich to pay more taxes, it would be simpler to just raise taxes on the rich individuals. Things get more complicated when you try to tax an abstraction (a corporation).
- adventured 9y agoEverybody else has already long since figured that out of course and are cutting their corporate income tax rates significantly, while half the political sphere in the US is still arguing about taxing corporations more. Meanwhile, in Sweden: 22% statutory corporate income tax rate; Finland: 20%; Denmark: 24.5%; Norway 27%. Those horrible socialists!
- Synaesthesia 9y agoBut you have to look at the effective rate after deductions, which are very significant in the US.
- thisisit 9y agoJohn Oliver did a piece on this last Sunday: https://youtu.be/8bl19RoR7lc https://youtu.be/8bl19RoR7lc
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- artur_makly 9y agoapparently that xtra $ isnt quiete reaching their IOS 11 team in constructive ways.
- wslh 9y agoELI5: why Wolfgang Krach needed the paradise papers to write this letter? Are paradise papers just an information leak that don't contribute to solving any problem? Except obviously when you can find plain corruption based on these papers.
- Tepix 9y agoPerhaps you missed these parts towards the end of this letter: "But what unsettles me the most is the way in which Apple instructed a law firm to obtain an “official assurance of tax exemption” from the government of a country." and "And what understanding of democracy are we supposed to discern from the question you had this law firm ask? The one about whether the country had a “credible opposition party” or “movement that may replace the current government?” Were you trying to ensure that you would be able to retain tax-free status even after elections or a change in government?"
- wslh 9y agoI don't find this strange when you are looking for a long term tax strategy and trying to reduce the involved risks. For example, when Intel invests in chip plants there are big discussions about tax privileges [1]. I know this is different because it doesn't involve a big R&D but it is natural to big company plans. [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-israel-intel-plant/israel-approves-intels-6-billion-investment-in-chip-plant-idUSKCN0HH1F720140922 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-israel-intel-plant/israel...
- almostarockstar 9y agoAs an Irish citizen, I feel embarrassed by the way we have dealt with Apple (and other behemoth corps). We simultaneously gave these organisations "free parking" and a "get out of jail free card". I don't blame Apple for taking advantage though. I would.
- adventured 9y agoThat free parking increased Ireland's economy by nearly six fold in a mere 25 years. It took Ireland from a second tier economy, to a first tier economic power ($300b in GDP with a mere 4.7m people). From sub $15,000 GDP per capita in 1993, to surpassing the US in GDP per capita at $62,000. You can tell it's the large foreign corporations causing it, because of the big gap between the growth in domestic income and the headline GDP figure. However those companies still employ a lot of people and pay taxes Ireland otherwise wouldn't have. Huge companies like: Mylan, Alkermes, Medtronic, Allergan, Johnson Controls, Accenture, Intel, Google, Apple, etc. would have likely not set up shop there if not for the tax policies. One can say, in response to that: fine, let them leave, we're better off -- except the Irish economy would get cut in half if you pushed them out by raising corporate taxes significantly, poverty would increase dramatically, unemployment would skyrocket.
- mtremsal 9y agoGDP per capita doesn't seem like the best metric to track the growth of "Ireland's Economy" if it doesn't translate into more jobs/taxes/etc. though. Would you happen to know whether these development incentives have actually befitted the Irish people?
- dx034 9y agoGo to Dublin and you'll see that these are not just postboxes. Most of those companies have a significant amount of employees in Ireland. They also pay taxes to the Irish state (albeit at a low rate) which is used to further develop the country. Not a fan of what the Irish government did but it clearly helped Ireland to become what they are now.
- 9y ago
- rootlocus 9y agoThis sounds similar to what Amazon are doing with their latest HQ: making states compete each other over what advantages Amazon would get if it opened its HQ there [1]. I'm terrified by the power big companies have over our government. [1] https://youtu.be/8bl19RoR7lc?t=2m52s https://youtu.be/8bl19RoR7lc?t=2m52s
- DoctorPenguin 9y agoThat really hurt to read. What I get from this article is: "I use apple products every day and now I feel bad for using them. But I won't stop anyways because who cares really. Please do anything to make your company less profitable so I can feel better again."
- martin_a 9y agoYou obviously misread it. Try again.
- juandazapata 9y agoRead again DoctorPenguin, you might understand the message this time.
- jitbit 9y agoWhile I do agree with the point that "govs should fix taxes, not corporations"... Still. It's a fact that (at least in the EU where I live) the majority of tax burden ends up on small companies - mom & pop shops, little bakeries etc. Who simply can't afford these global tax avoidance tricks (or can't use them because they're "local") Not that this is wrong or right, just a fact you can't argue with. I run a small software shop in the EU (4 ppl) I know what I'm talking about.
- pawelk 9y agoSo I live in Poland and it's not really a secret that small companies can and do optimize their taxes by registering in the UK (mostly self-employed professionals) or Czech Republic (small companies / family businesses). It's not like you can avoid taxes, but the difference for a self-employed programmer is non-trivial, like getting a 13th monthly salary every year. The Czech deal is done mostly for simpler tax code and better handling of car-related costs. I've seen many luxury cars on the roads with CZ license plates recently and I can guarantee it's not because a sudden influx of Czech tourists :) There are probably more schemes I am not aware of, but these two are popular enough that you get tons of adsense ads when looking for them (i.e. there are companies / accountants specializing in setting this up).
- jitbit 9y agoYes, I know the UK drill... But how do you hire someone in Poland being a UK company? I thought that's not possible
- pawelk 9y agoThere are many Poles employed in the UK, so there has to be a way. It may get tricky when these workers do not live in the UK, but on the other hand there are many foreign companies operating in Poland and hiring people here. As I said the UK setup is mostly used for self-employment, so when you need a team mate they are most likely incorporated as well (either in Poland or the UK), so you just sign a B2B contract.
- 9y ago
- styx31 9y agoWhat annoys me the most is that, as a small company, I can't evade from my country tax system. I pay the taxes. All of them, at full rate. But there are these big companies which can afford to create offshore companies/holding just to evade some tax system, and lower their tax rate. So, what? The tax rate of a country is now "artificial", because it will never be applied to all revenues from all companies, because the higher profiles will be able to evade a part of it. If governments want to reclaim more, they could raise up the tax rate, considering that the biggest players will only pay a fragment of it. But the small companies, the one that can only follow the rules? They are screwed. All companies should be considered equals regarding the tax system. It is simply not the case when such schemes are used. Edit: exactly the same point of view as jitbit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15651457 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15651457
- Gustomaximus 9y agoI feel the other solutions is obvious in that we need to align tax law to meet the global mobility of money, in the same way we aligned trading laws. Something like; 1) A group like the WTO/G12 get together and agree to minimum tax rate for any corporate/country/individual that wants to do business and or have access to these economies/nations. Any company/individual that earns income in lower tax rate countries is fine to do so but must tax equalise to the minimum or they can not do business or visit these countries. 2) Citizens of the above group of tax aligned countries must declare overseas assets and incomes and equalise tax payments if below a set minimum. Should undeclared assets/income be found the assets are forfeit and the person gets 1 year jail per $1mil. And anyone who provide information to create asset forfeit or additional tax owned gets 25% of that.
- ThrwyAct 9y agoThis, plus sanctions on tax havens.
- sschueller 9y agoSame goes for US individuals living abroad not having any business relations or even holdings in the US. Yet they are required to file and pay US taxes in addition to local taxes.
- snappyTertle 9y agoI don't get why people think paying more taxes is "moral". There are a lot of things the government spends on that I don't agree with...and I'm sure I'm not alone on this.
- simias 9y agoThat's what it's like being in a democracy and living in a society. Maybe you'd prefer to live in an anarcho-libertarian state but many people seem to enjoy benefits of a modern democratic society with all its safety nets. There are ways to work around that to a certain extent though, for instance you can donate to nonprofits for causes you care for and get a tax rebate. That effectively means that you decide where that share of the taxes gets invested personally. But beyond that there's not much you can do, you'll never have a government you 100% agree with on all subjects, at some point you have to accept to compromise and vote for the representatives that best represent your viewpoint and interests. Or leave I guess.
- draugadrotten 9y agoPeople usually feel (don't think) that it's moral for OTHERS to pay more taxes. They also feel (don't think) that's moral for themselves to pay less. It's called socialism.
- orwin 9y agoWell, i feel its moral for me to pay all my taxes, and even though i also give money to charity, i don't use this fact to reduce my taxes, because i feel a lot of people need this money way more than me. This is socialism.
- golergka 9y agoNo, this is either personal choice over your own property, (which is charity), or irrelevant - your feelings over taxes don't matter, you don't get to choose whether to pay the taxes or not. Socialism is forcing your choice on other people's property through the only organization that has monopoly on violence in today's society - government.
- nickpp 9y agoOn thing I wonder about all these proponents for Apple to voluntarily pay more taxes: do they themselves pay more taxes than strictly required of them? I mean do they not take advantage of that child exemption? Do they not deduce that mortgage? Those medical costs? That college tuition? Those business expenses? Do they decide to voluntarily add at least 1% to their income tax bracket? Do they practice what they preach?
- fastball 9y agoHonestly this point is so obvious but I hadn't thought of it myself.
- jaymzcampbell 9y agoThere is a world of difference in the moral intent of claiming tax credit that the government itself publicises in order to help the people in their society and the likes of "Double Irish" tax schemes. It saddens me that this argument is always rolled out. As a global population (not thinking about individual countries, however unrealistic) - it depresses me that people try to justify these blatant abuses of legislation.
- Marazan 9y agoAt the core of many of these tax avoidance schemes is wholly owned subsidiaries making intra-group loans that are treated differently in different tax jurisdictions. Imagne there is subsidiary X & Y in jurisdiction. In jurisdiction A the parent company declares those two subsidiaries should be considered a single entity, in jurisdiction C the parent company declares they should be considered separate. This allows intra-group loans between those two subsidiaries (and other subsidiaries outside jurisdiction C) to appear and disappear from the accounting as necessary for the purpose of tax avaoidance. Whilst the declared company structures are perfectly legal in jurisdiction A and C the fact that the parent company has declared different corporate structure for the same entities is deeply suspicious as an activity.
- lucozade 9y agoAs the "editor-in-chief of the Süddeutsche Zeitung, Germany’s leading daily", why not do something? I don't mean complain, that's already happening, I mean actually do something. For example, ban all Apple products from the paper. Lobby the German government to ban all Apple products until Apple pay a sufficient amount of tax. Use the paper's influence to get people to stop using Apple's services. That sort of something. If not, then why not? Is it possibly that you don't really care? It's just a fun story that helps circulation a bit. Or, maybe, that you don't believe that you'll get much support and having a campaign that fails is bad for circulation? Possibly it's because this would have a direct negative effect on you and yours and, well, we wouldn't want that. Personally, I'm fine if you don't do anything but complain as protecting your circulation and your convenience is a perfectly reasonable thing. But don't be surprised that nothing changes.
- dx034 9y ago> For example, ban all Apple products from the paper. Lobby the German government to ban all Apple products until Apple pay a sufficient amount of tax. Use the paper's influence to get people to stop using Apple's services. That sort of something. Not sure if they even issue company phones. But if, that's maybe 100 iphones. And how should they lobby a government to ban iPhones? As official phones they're not used anyway (for security reasons) and the state has no say in what people use privately. Boycotts almost never work.
- lucozade 9y ago> As official phones they're not used I mean lobby for the ban on the sale of Apple products in Germany. As in, make it illegal to sell Apple products. And if you really want to put the cat amongst the pigeons, make it illegal to buy them. > Boycotts almost never work They absolutely can if they're popular enough. And they can in Germany too. If you don't believe me, check out the Shell boycott. And that wasn't officially sanctioned. I think it's reasonable to expect that a 40% reduction in sales in a market as important as Germany would cause Apple to think seriously about its position. Now, I'm not suggesting for a second that a ban on Apple, or even a boycott, would occur let alone be successful. But that's kind of my point. No-one's going to call for it because it's just not important to anyone. It's posturing.
- jansho 9y agoGenuine question. Are there actual large, profitable companies which are tax responsible? I.e. companies that follow ethical accounting practices to minimise their tax and none of the dodgy off-shoring stuff
- Kale_Rogers 9y agoDo the right thing. Paying no taxes on generated revenues is obviously not the right thing. Pay taxes. Care about how these taxes are spent. Become an active part of the democracy that empowers a government. If you are not happy with a tax system, argue. If you feel not represented, vote with your feet and leave the country. Though don't play tricks. Don't pretend you are a proud part of a country that you betray.
- fgvqdc 9y agoI have a simple solution: Create a business which behaves and acts the same way as Appleby but for small enterprise of lets say 30k revenues a year only. You provide the service on a almost non profitable way to attract the vast majority of enterprises in this revenue sector. Ultimately, governments will see the effect of lost taxes and act accordingly.
- ainiriand 9y agoIt is funny to see that here in Dublin there are so many homeless people. Almost one in every street. This tax evasion is not the direct responsible but it is another symptom of this 2-speed society in which inequality separates citizens.
- hop 9y agoIn Mexico, people don’t finish their houses and leave rebar coming out the roof to pay less tax. In Vietnam, the houses are really thin because property taxes are based on width. For an American company selling things overseas, they’re going to setup in Ireland or wherever else because the laws make it advantageous. All these decisions are functions of the laws written, so if they want to complain and write open letters, it should be to lawmakers, not the heads of companies operating logically.
- jason_slack 9y ago> In Vietnam, the houses are really thin because property taxes are based on width. Really? Interesting. Can anyone explain how taxing the width of the house was established?
- yathern 9y agoIt's similar in many places in Europe, where you see houses laid out like this: http://c8.alamy.com/comp/F56ABW/old-and-narrow-houses-in-street-of-gdansk-poland-europe-beautiful-F56ABW.jpg http://c8.alamy.com/comp/F56ABW/old-and-narrow-houses-in-str... Your property size, and subsequent taxes were decided based on how much of the road you took up, ie the width of the house. This practice dates back surprisingly far (1500s?)
- jason_slack 9y agooh, that kind of "this". I was thinking the walls were thin. Width meaning taller and skinnier....lol
- yathern 9y agoHaha I was thinking the same thing - until I remembered some trivia I learned on a recent trip to Germany
- larrysalibra 9y agoWow! I always wondered why properties in Vietnam were so thin! Makes sense - give people incentives to build "thin" buildings and they'll build thin buildings!
- fauigerzigerk 9y agoI fear that Mr. Krach does not understand corporation tax. Comparing profits from sales in a particular country to corporation tax paid in that country by a foreign company makes absolutely no sense. Apple's tax avoidance schemes are in place to avoid US taxes, not German taxes or taxes elsewhere in the world outside the US. I think Mr. Krach is right that global corporations do not pay their fair share towards global infrastructure and education. But the reason for that is not tax avoidance. The reason is that corporation tax, as it is structured today, is unfit for porpose in a globalised economy. Corporation tax is based on the assumption that companies primarily use the public infrastructure of the country where they are incorporated. But for global corporations this assumption is incorrect. So Mr. Krach is barking up the wrong tree, unless his main concern is US tax take. He should call on politicians to change the way in which global corporations are taxed.
- improbable22 9y agoYes to this: "corporation tax, as it is structured today, is unfit for purpose in a globalised economy". Where Apple sold its computers is well-defined, you can count each one and tax it. Where their employees work is also well-defined, they have desks, and beds. Where they made their profits simply isn't well-defined. How much was due to the software (California), the marketing (let's say London), the assembly (China), the logistics (in between)? These question don't have sharp answers. Sure, Apple's accounting guys write down some numbers. But once you attempt to tax them, you discover that they have great freedom in what column they write those numbers in. I increasingly think the correct corporate profit tax rate is zero. Tax the goods they sell. Tax the salaries they pay. Tax the capital gains when shareholders sell, if you must. These things all involve actual people and take place in particular countries. The rest is an abstraction.
- philliphaydon 9y agoAs Long as tax’s remain high, they will be avoided. Raising taxes on the 1% or raising corporate taxes on businesses it only going to make the issue worse. America probably wouldn’t need such high tax if it didn’t have such a terrible government system.
- dennis_jeeves 9y agoGot to chuckle when articles like this appear. Essentially it means this: I paid my taxes, you haven't. Translated it means ( in my opinion): I got robbed, but you didn't get robbed, and I feel envious of you. Taxes are an extortion by the government and it is fair game that anyone should try and evade it legally or otherwise. Extortion cannot be justified even if some of the money is used to deliver useful services to the people who have to part with the money. Summary: people get the government that they deserve.
- soVeryTired 9y agoLet me guess. You're in favour of private healthcare, private security, private education, and no social safety net. In short, nothing to aid social mobility, and nothing to restrain powerful people who have gained the upper hand. You know, to some of us, that libertarian utopia sounds like a fucking nightmare.
- dennis_jeeves 9y ago>You know, to some of us, that libertarian utopia sounds like a fucking nightmare. Correct, nobody is obliged to help you. What a sense of entitlement! So your only option is go ahead ask your government to arm twist rich people into funding your healthcare etc. ( and the rich includes the ones that have both legitimately and illegitimately obtained wealth).
- ionised 9y ago> Correct, nobody is obliged to help you. What a sense of entitlement! Actually, they are. It's an innate instinctual behaviour inherent in all healthy human beings and we are social creatures that have succeeded through co-operation. If you have never felt the urge to help someone, prevent abuses and exploitation you might actually be a sociopath. In the wild, members of social species that don't conform to this become outcasts and eventually die off as they cannot contribute to the group. It's an evolutionary weakness. People like you try to wax philosophical about self-reliance and pulling yourself up by the bootstraps, but it's simple greed masquerading as some kind of stoicism and self-reliance. The simple fact is, neither you nor Apple nor anyone else in this vein has made their living without the benefits and support that a tax-paying society has afforded you. Considering especially that it is people like you that espouse this naive view of the world and your support for companies like this engaging in these socially-damaging practices, it is interesting that it also happens to be these very same 'captains of industry' that receive all manner of corporate welfare, bailouts and handouts. Privatise the profits, socialise the losses. Capitalism when you are winning, socialism when you are losing. It's interesting how that works isn't it? Almost like it isn't some kind of profound personal philosophy, but rather just simple greed.
- m_st 9y agoGreat letter that is part of a great movement right now. It's not just Apple, but they're an easy target and rightly so. It has to start somewhere. I'm confident they're doing their usual 'wait for a week' until we get a reply. And then I hope, just like with the ecological issues after the Greenpeace accusations, Apple will finally start doing the right thing and pay rather than trying to escape. - A happy Apple user
- bryananderson 9y agoIt is so, so important to our social contract that everyone plays by the same set of rules. Right now, I think that a lot of people (such as small business owners who will never employ an army of offshore tax lawyers) are realizing that this is not the case. Hopefully this disillusionment will be a vehicle for positive change, but the past and present provide abundant evidence that there are tyrants and charlatans aplenty waiting to capture the popular anger and turn it to their own purposes. It is in all of our interests - from the richest to the poorest - to keep this from happening. We need to return to the lesson of the Progressive Era. There is an alternative to chaos, and it is to build a society in which the average person can justifiably say that the system works for them, too, and not only for the wealthiest.
- fgjjgutjvnu 9y agoHow does it even work - how can they sell stuff for Billions in Germany and pay only 25 Millions in taxes? I think if the German government is unhappy about that, they should change their tax laws. There is of course also competition among countries to attract top companies. So just assuming all you'd have to do is tax some company and you'd rake in the billions is foolish. As for "democratic duty to pay taxes" - meh. I didn't vote for my government, and given the choice (and money), I'd probably prefer to give my money to other charities and projects than the government would. My government would use the money to fund gender studies, botched government projects that waste billions, and so on. In Germany it is actually legal and encouraged to pay as little taxes as possible (looking for "loopholes", as left wing media would call it).
- karl11 9y agoWhy do we expect Apple to be altruistic instead of expecting governments to have sensible tax policy?
- bsaul 9y agoi think pressure should also come from apple ( and google and amazon..) employees. They work for an objectively "bad behaving" company, they should tell their management that they're not ok with it.
- tareqak 9y agoIs there a sort of international tax agency (hopefully with the proverbial teeth) like there is the World Trade Organization [0] (WTO) for trade or Interpol [1] for policing? With my colloquial/urban-legend-style understanding of the fear of being audited for taxes in both Canada and the US, I would be mildly entertained if I ever heard that the "Global IRS" was auditing a multinational corporation. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WTO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WTO [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interpol
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- xapata 9y agoIncome tax is hard to collect. Sales tax is regressive. Solution: sales tax with lump-sum redistribution to make it progressive. Forget income tax.
- jrobn 9y agoApple and the like are just being “smart businessmen” as our current tax evading president once said. I never really minded paying taxes. Sure, I was upset sometimes when I learned how some of it is spent. After Trump said that, I made it my duty to pay as little taxes as possible to the federal gov’t. The US election taught me that a total morally banktrupt asshole can win the presidency of the United States and flaunt his disgraceful behavior, I might as else enjoy what he enjoys.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- stesch 9y ago70% downvotes on /r/apple, posted 17h ago.
- danra 9y agoA lot of the responses here are missing the point. It's not that Apple must behave morally with regards to taxes, and not just legally. It's that Apple claims to behave morally, and doesn't.
- stesch 9y agoDavid Mitchell on Tax Avoidance: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m2q-Csk-ktc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m2q-Csk-ktc Makes some good points.
- OJFord 9y agoWorking link in the UK: https://youtu.be/xc8epam4NyY https://youtu.be/xc8epam4NyY
- fredgrott 9y agohere is what the average American does not know...read? US collects $2.5 trillion in corp taxes...guess how much revenue is earned by US corps? $27Trillion...US corp effective tax rate tan is exactly 10%...contrasty that with China where the effective tax rate for corps counting corruption is at somewhat 45%... Somewhere there is something wrong with US corp claiming they need lower taxes when they cannot increase the number of those hired..at leas that was the former social contract they were operating under when getting those lobbyist tax breaks in the first place.
- qaq 9y agoI am a bit confused what does sales in a given jurisdiction have to do with amount of taxes payed on profits in that jurisdiction? Apple does same thing every german company in US is doing e.g. shifting money flows in such a way as to optimize profits.
- makapuf 9y agoI cannot count the number of times I've heard the word "Legal" in the news in the last few days. As in "everything we do is legal". What's implied is therefore ... I can do it. What I understand is : therefore... change the 'fing law. And make it very public who is blocking this change of laws. Any country such as isle of Man or Ireland can have its own laws. My country has a system where infrastructure is build from transactions. You don't want it, you cannot have access to its customers. simple on principle. Some laws can be bent to avoid it ? change them. Have issues changing them ? Please explain them clearly. Act on those & iterate.
- known 9y agoTax revenues, not profits on all listed companies
- known 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome
- Davidbrcz 9y agoWant to prevent this ? Use your ultimate weapon, your wallet. Start boycotting Apple products (all other companies that appeared in the leak such as Nike).
- lxchase 9y agoWould it be possible to create a "Tax evasion as a service" where one can buy shares, and said company will offshore the pool of money allowing individuals to get benefits of big corporate tax?
- qaq 9y agoOK could someone explain to me why people in US would be complaining about evil Apple or any other major US company ? It's not owned by some evil rich dude largest Apple shareholder is Vanguard second Blackrock and so on. It's owned by you it creates value for your pension I'd rather trust Tim Cook than Donald Trump with my pension $.
- dontreact 9y agoIs there anyone here who is enough of an expert to propose changes to the U.S. tax code that would actually get rid of all of the tricks that multinationals play to avoid taxes? Or knows of where to find such a thing. I have responded in subthreads to at least 3 people who think they are but curious if there is anyone out there with actual expertise on the topic. My sense is that it's easy to feel that the solution to the problem is simple (like this xkcd: https://xkcd.com/793/ https://xkcd.com/793/) when in fact it is tremendously complicated: perhaps even intractable. It may be that it there is a sort of Godelian way of always finding a loophole given the emergent complexity of the interactions between the tax codes of ~200 different countries, many of which are incentivized to have a lax tax code to promote local job growth.
- qaq 9y agoThere is significant trade imbalance between US and Germany as in Germany exports 2X more goods to US so if laws would be passed that make you pay taxes on profits proportional to sales in a given jurisdiction Germany would suffer greatly.
- boramalper 9y ago> "I guess the trouble was that we didn't have any self-admitted proletarians. Everyone was a temporarily embarrassed capitalist." > - John Steinbeck Reading some of the comments here which rationalize, justify, and even defend corporal behaviours such as Apple's nauseate me. How (and why) can you, YOU as a mere individual (or the owner of a small start-up if you'd like to think that way) who pays taxes for nearly every single transaction, can justify these kinds of "tax optimizations"? Speaking from experience, this is how things (countries, organisations, etc.) corrupt: when people start rationalising (and then justifying) the behaviour of those who are breaking the rules and sitting at the top. The corruption happens when ordinary people looks above and thinks that "I would probably do the same, why would one obey the rules where it can be evaded?". Since everyone except those at the very bottom is above some others, corruption spreads like a bushfire and everyone starts breaking the rules s/he can. It would be naive to think that only top 500 companies evading tax. Those at the scale of Apple break the rules at their own scale, and smaller ones break it at a smaller scale. Whilst, here I am in the UK, have to pay 10 GBP for a pack of 20 cigarettes because of the taxes.
- therealmarv 9y agoNo comment. - Best regards, Tim Cook
- rimliu 9y agoI wonder, does the author pay more taxes than he legally owes to.
- jokoon 9y agoI don't care about a lot of political subject, would it be inequality, welfare, immigration, racism, etc. But tax havens seem like a huge threat, and my favorite subject of opinion of all, and they are a big source of problem in how the economy is unfair and how any country's budget is unbalanced. Weirdly, libertarians will defend the existence of tax havens. I'm really happy to see that some political actors are finally advancing on that subject. Even in terms of geopolitics, it will be delicate, but I don't care, this is the largest abscess to burst, and it's crazy it's not a bigger issue and that it took such a long time. It's really time that this gets fixed.
- l8again 9y ago>> Did you want to make zero-tax status a precondition for establishing tax residency there? What gives you the right to do so? This is a pretty twisted way of publicly shaming someone for just asking. They have all the right to put whatever condition on any country they want. Any country has the right to not accept their conditions. If the intent of the author is to publicly shame Apple and paint them as being somehow culpable for the poor conditions of the said countries, then its not working. There are jobs that Apple bring to these countries that kick start their economies. Again, its not for nothing that countries _agree_ with their pre-conditions. The other argument presented here is that smaller companies don't get to play by these rules. Again, they can. Just that there is no incentive for a country to not tax smaller companies. Bottom line: Apple brings more to the countries than just its taxes, and that's why the countries are fine with their special tax status.
- mementomori 9y agoEven though I don't believe that articles like this would make the slightest bit of difference, I sincerely admire the sentiment of people who write them.
- monktastic1 9y agoIt seems like a lot of people here are looking for "the" root of the problem, as though there is one person or small group of people or laws that could fix the whole mess. The truth is that we are pretty much all complicit in small ways that add up, and that complicity generally takes the same form: I want a little more for myself, and have a convenient blind spot when it comes to ways in which systems and processes help bias things in my favor. Elsewhere it's been pointed out that there's no (non-arbitrary) way to distinguish a "tax loophole" from a "tax code." It's sort of an "I know it when I see it" thing. But how many of us have the courage to stand up and say "hey, this is unfair for others" vs "hey, this is unfair for me"? Until that happens, this kind of thing will continue in a variety of forms that may seem unrelated but profoundly aren't. But something inside us is scared of giving up any ground. So what's the solution? Well, meditation and psychedelics are showing tremendous promise in awakening the sort of "universal empathy" and profound sense of fundamental safety and security that can shift the balance. We can't get on that train fast enough.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fatjokes 9y ago> Apple bills itself as a transparent company. lolwut? Secretiveness is kind of their thing.
- bantunes 9y agoFor people talking about how the solution is to fix the tax code: the problem is not the tax code or the rates. Even if the tax rate was 2%, these people wouldn't pay it. I feel the problem is much deeper than that - the fact that Tim Cook, and others, do not see it as "fair" to pay for the use of public facilities and services. That they fail to grasp the notion that by helping a nation create better, more educated, healthier citizens will effectively improve their bottom line in the future. That levelling the playing field creates more customers for their businesses. Unfortunately you can't put that on a quarterly profit report, so let's just make more and more money and screw everything else. That's not success. That's a virus in economical form, slowly killing the host.
- bambax 9y ago> since 2010, Apple’s foreign-earned income has been taxed at a rate of between 1 and 7 percent. Mr. Cook, do you believe this comports with the “moral responsibility” you have advocated? No, he doesn't believe that. He also doesn't care about "moral responsibility". He's the CEO of a mega-corporation. He cares about world dominance, competition, and profits. It's completely useless to appeal to CEOs' moral sense; they probably don't have one and even if they do, they don't let it run their lives. > Such “tax optimization” – albeit legal... That's the whole problem. What would be useful would be to make laws that force corporations to pay proper taxes, and then ruthlessly enforce them. Shame can help a little, maybe, but laws first.
- justacat 9y agoAll I want is a world with a single flat tax, is that too much to ask?
- 0xbear 9y agoThe article is mis-addressed. If the goal is to change something and not just pointlessly grandstand, it should be addressed to the lawmakers who wrote the laws that make this legal. Nobody should be required to pay more taxes than the laws tell them to. Anything else is frivolous and arbitrary.
- speleding 9y ago> In Germany, Apple is estimated (you don’t publish the exact figures) to have generated revenues in the billions last year – of which it paid 25 million euros in taxes. I assume that Apple paid 20% German VAT on those billions, as well as paid taxes on the salaries of the Germans it employed, and probably several other taxes such as environmental tax on packaging. The article raises an important issue but it's disingenuous to focus just on the profit tax, which is a highly malleable number in the hands of an accomplished accountant. But since they do focus on profit tax, they should have made it clear why profit on a phone designed in the US and built in China should fall to Germany, and they fail to do that.
- angel_j 9y agoWhose torch are these media co's carrying? I'm not so quick to swallow a newspaper editor's moral indignation about taxes. Much ado about symptoms, not so much a cause. Our governments waste so much money, even Apple's lost taxes are a drop in the bucket. Should we all join in crying about that loss? We know 90% of it would go to military and corrupt, partisan, spending. I say spank the news media along with the government, for being partners in the inertia. At least Apple innovates.
- yalph 9y agoSo HN is full or libertarians I realize.
- nobodyorother 9y agoWhat is Apple's effective tax-rate, world-wide (for, e.g., 2016)? I've not seen this spelled out anywhere, yet.
- drraid0 9y agoHacker News Staff: can you please publish stats on how many of the comments on this thread are posted from Apple devices?
- m3kw9 9y agoThis guys seem to know nothing about economics. A company can be enticed with tax exemptions to setup shop there and in return help the count in many ways. The tip of the iceberg is employment, talent generation and the surrounding areas where the office is placed.
- m3kw9 9y agoThis paper seem to be made to stir stuff up amongst people who thinks this is a simple matter
- otakucode 9y agoThere is a question in that letter which I wonder if it is intended as a threat. I might just be misguided. But asking about the questions asked about 'credible opposition party' and 'movement that may replace the current government'... I think Tim Cook (and others in his tax bracket) might see such a question coming from a media outlet as a bit of a threat. The general public think of the rich as simply normal people with way more money and power. They have no concept of how differently they relate to the world, governments, etc. They've got no idea that once you get beyond a few million dollars, once you've surpassed whatever an individual would reasonably ever need... you start planning for your family. When you get to a billion? Then you start planning for your legacy. You don't think "what will make me some money this week" or "month" or "year". You think on the scale of centuries. And you fully intend your dynasty (for some reason all rich come to fetishize bloodlines and draw irrational conclusions about the superiority of their genetics, likely a psychological defense mechanism against a sort of survivors guilt born out of all their compatriots they've seen fall/destroyed) to outlast flimsy flash-in-the-pan happenings of history like the rise and fall of currencies or redrawing of national boundaries. When people talk about things like a large movement to automation, or things like Apple having a value greater than the GDP of nations, and things like that... they don't tend to follow through and consider things like... people have fought very, very large wars and killed many, many people over sums smaller. Those who think it isn't a game are only those expendable enough to be fodder for it.
- webXL 9y ago> Many of these institutions of higher education are entirely or partially funded with taxpayer money. This is a tell. I should have seen it coming. Another "you didn't build the ROADS!" guilt trip. As if a big part of the rationale behind all government-funded activities (wealth redistribution) was to promote the importance and preservation of the state, not what the citizens couldn't do for themselves. The same goes for the "freedom isn't free" bullshit. A "security" argument could have just as easily been substituted for the "education" argument. Citizens all around the world are paying double for this self-aggrandizing propaganda, some with a mountain of subsidized student loans, others with their lives. The fundamental goals of government (that I think that most people could get on board with) are to provide law and order, and if it has the resources, promote the general welfare. If the welfare is being promoted and increasing by other means, why do we need the state to continue that role? The pie is growing in the form of a piece of technology that is improving your life, and the private sector doing more, more efficiently. Just because the guy next door struck it rich in some risky investment or startup doesn't mean you were made worse off or will be made worse off. The sooner we can stop flirting with that flawed, quick-fix socialist thinking, the better off we'll all be.
- arshaanb 9y agoYou can’t blame the people taking advantage of the loops holes, you have to blame the countries which allow it, and then stop them, thus putting all business owners on a level playing field. They are driven by capitalism and money, they aren’t going to not do it for moral reasons.
- rajacombinator 9y agoY'all should hate the game not the players, c'mon. -50 Cent (ie. Pass bad laws/tolerate bad governments, get bad results.)
- ninjabeans 9y agoBy how much would the country's tax income increase, percentage wise, if all these companies started paying full tax?
- smilangalang 9y agoNot to be a jerk, but I do not agree that Apple makes outstanding products any longer. In particular the quality of UX has decline rapidly since jobs' decline. Have you looked at the stopwatch app for example? Where did the seconds go? Milliseconds? There are many many more things like this that have changed for the worse. And their hardware has always been sub par afaik.
- thisrod 9y agoAustralia taxes shareholders instead of companies. Companies pay tax on paper, but it gets refunded to their shareholders when they pay dividends, and those dividends are taxed like any other income. If other developed countries did the same, these problems might be easier to manage. Investors could still get bigger dividends from these transfer pricing rorts, but they would have to hand them back as income tax at home, and the rorts might stop being worthwhile.
- vfulco 9y agoThere are a sea of lawyers, accountants, investment bankers et al., using the best intelligence the marketplace has to offer, to move money around the world for corporations in a game of (don't) whack-a-mole. Until these guys get a kick in the teeth and some semblance of honor, the game will go on because it pays top tier compensation. Scoundrels.
- henvic 9y agoLet people protect their finance in peace. If I earn money by creating a good product that consumers love I have the right to do whatever I wish with this money. Socialism is evil. Let people be free to use their wealth for the benefit of society by producing more, donating, and so on. Why the hell would I want to give money to politicians to generate war and tragedy? It is a shame so many socialists try to destroy California and whatever is left of free-market in America.
- jon49 9y agoApple is, by US law, required to maximize their profits for its investors. I'm not religious, but I agree with the sentiment: "Thou shalt not covet." Rather than drag on Apple maybe we should be figuring out how everyone can lower their taxes.
- ech085 9y agoAt the end of the article "Apple bills itself as a transparent company." . This is news to me. The Apple is famously (infamously) secretive. Tim Cook is doing the job shareholders hired him for. Most boards would replace him if he made no effort to minimize taxes. It's the fault of the system that collects taxes, not Apple. If a system wants to govern and collect taxes it shouldn't rely on companies to donate more than they're legally obliged. Fix your laws, Germany, EU.
- importantbrian 9y agoI think the real issue is that taxing corporations is the wrong approach. Companies don't and really can't pay taxes. The burden of the tax always falls on some individual or group of individuals, not the company. When try and tax a company they can pass on the cost of that tax in one of 3 ways. They can pass it on to shareholders in the form of lower dividends. They can pass it on to customers in the form of higher prices, or they can pass it on to workers in the form of lower wages. Several CBO studies have show that it is workers who bear the primary burden of the tax. Which I think is probably the exact opposite outcome of what people who argue for corporate taxation want. However, it makes perfect sense why it is that way. The shareholders are never going to agree to pay the tax in the form of lower dividends. The company has limited ability to raise prices in many cases without losing customers, so the easiest way for them to pay the tax is to reduce the total wages that they pay out. Taxing corporations is nonsensical. Some individual is always going to end up paying the tax.