23 ms·
New Zealand to ban foreigners from buying existing houses
- dogruck 9y agoIs this fairly common? Once I casually shopped for houses in Bermuda -- but they had a similar rule.
- Cyph0n 9y agoThe UAE has a similar law in place, but with a twist: you can buy property in certain "free zones".
- lwhsiao 9y agoWhy not link directly to the full story [0]? [0] http://www.independent.co.uk/news/new-zealand-foreigners-buy-property-ban-coalition-talks-prime-minister-jacinda-arden-a8017261.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/new-zealand-foreigners-buy...
- dang 9y agoThanks! Url changed from http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/10/seems-will-ban-foreigners-buying-homes-new-zealand.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/10/see....
- mustntmumble 9y agoTitle is too broad. "We have agreed on banning the purchase of existing homes by foreign buyers," said Ms Ardern My point is that non-residents will still be able to build new houses. This policy brings New Zealand in line with Australia which already has a similar policy.
- xxgreg 9y agoAgreed. Funny that everyone is focusing on that point, which probably won't have much affect. I expect other policies such as below, will likely have more affect. Encouraging more housing at the lower end of the market seems like a good idea. Rather than pushing low income earners into the exurbs. "LABOUR WILL PARTNER WITH THE PRIVATE SECTOR TO BUILD 100,000 AFFORDABLE HOMES KiwiBuild will deliver 100,000 affordable houses over ten years for first home buyers. Half of these will be built in Auckland. That is a ten-fold increase in the number of affordable houses being built in Auckland each year, from 500 to 5,000." http://www.labour.org.nz/kiwibuild http://www.labour.org.nz/kiwibuild
- elyobo 9y agoThe main price driver is speculation, so I'm not confident that increasing supply in anything except for absolutely massive numbers (which 10k/year is not) would have much price impact.
- xxgreg 9y agoI think speculation is part of the equation, but not the only part. There is also lack of reasonably priced rentals and housing within a reasonable distance from transport infrastructure. Current build out is focused on the high end of the market, or green field sites in the middle of nowhere.
- skybrian 9y agoAlso, it appears that residents of New Zealand (who may be foreigners) can buy existing homes [1]. So apparently it would still work if you can move there and establish residency, but not for buying a second home while living elsewhere. Seems pretty sensible? [1] "The country’s proposed ban on foreign buyers, which would only apply to non-domiciles" https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/25/new-zealand-to-ban-foreign-buyers-existing-homes-jacinda-ardern https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/oct/25/new-zealand-to...
- raquo 9y agoNo, it seems toothless, with obvious loopholes. A sane housing market is way more important than allowing temporary residents to buy a home. They can rent until they either leave or become permanent residents. Just look at Vancouver where incomeless foreign students are buying supermansions.
- elyobo 9y agoYeah, if they're planning on allowing those with only temporary residence rights to continue to buy then the policy is useless.
- msie 9y agoIt doesn't matter who's buying supermansions. Most people aren't looking to buy supermansions.
- raquo 9y agoObviously they're buying other houses as well, and not only students but other foreigners as well. This example is just a good illustration of toothlessness. Also obvious is that increasing demand on one type of housing puts upwards pressure on the prices of other types of housing because they are (in part) substitute goods.
- soperj 9y agoeverything in vancouver is priced as a supermansion.
- dang 9y agoWe've added 'existing' above. Also changed the url from http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/10/seems-will-ban-foreigners-buying-homes-new-zealand.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/10/see....
- elyobo 9y agoAustralia's is toothless though, in that enforcement is minimal and so are the penalties. NZ's may be equally crap or it may be quite effective, but I haven't seen details on the above and so it's hard to compare the policies at this point. A policy like Thailand's, where those found to be buying against the rules have their property taken off them without compensation, would be ideal. The next step would be to require that those that do not meet the rules sell up, which should put a bit of supply into the market and achieve some meaningful price movement. Another good step would be to finally bring in a decent capital gains tax, ideally charged annually on paper profits at whatever your marginal tax rate is, and with no family home exemptions. Ironically taxing the family home would, in this case, actually make them more affordable by exerting further pressure to move speculators out of the market.
- charlesdm 9y ago> A policy like Thailand's, where those found to be buying against the rules have their property taken off them without compensation, would be ideal. You can't do that in an open, globally connected economy though. As great and beautiful as Thailand is, it is still for the most part a corrupt developing country. You want to hold Australia or NZ, which should be open for business and wants to attract global investment by better protecting investor rights, to a much higher standard.
- elyobo 9y agoI'm not proposing that we take on board the corruption, but of course you can have a law with appropriate penalties for violators of it in an open, globally connected country. We want people to invest; we don't want them to break our laws. Their rights (and the penalties that would apply to them) would be laid out under the law, so no problem at all.
- flukus 9y agoWe can't confiscate illegally obtained goods because we live in a open, globally connected economy?
- indemnity 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoWhy not simply introduce foreign ownership surtaxes instead of this ham-handed (and loopholed) approach? Wouldn't that be a win-win? Either you have more tax income, inflating housing prices cool off, and/or more vacancies for citizens. What's not to love?
- elyobo 9y agoIt's not really loopholed; those that actually live in NZ _should_ be able to buy property there (our voting laws are similar, those with permanent residency are also entitled to vote).
- rm_-rf_slash 9y agoPerhaps I should have clarified. Too much prime real estate in almost every country is purchased by wealthy foreigners who either sparsely live there or hold it for purposes of speculation. The result is chronic housing shortages and economy-ruining rents. In that case a hefty surtax is certainly justified.
- elyobo 9y agoI'm OK with that on principal if the "foreigner" is someone that has the right to permanently reside in NZ (basically the rules as for the right to vote - http://www.elections.org.nz/voters/enrol-check-or-update-now/who-can-and-cant-enrol http://www.elections.org.nz/voters/enrol-check-or-update-now...). It sounds like this policy would not achieve that, because it's claimed that the policy would only apply to "non-domiciles" which would presumably include temporary residents... so in that regard I would have to agree that it is loopholed :-/
- nugget 9y agoI saw an interesting proposal that called for hefty property tax surcharges that could be rebated against annual personal income taxes.
- elyobo 9y ago
- justicezyx 9y agoI like this approach. Try the obvious and simple approach first. If not working, revise. Instead of trying to balance between too many factors, slumping in decision making and consensus gathering, and in the process, all the smart people already exploited or even corrupted the system.
- elyobo 9y agoThe main obvious thing is to make property speculation neutral with regards to tax, rather than the tax avoidance hole that it currently is. Hopefully they'll address that too, but given that Adern has been quoted as saying they're not looking to push down prices in AUckland I'm not all that hopeful that they'll actually take the steps that need to be done.
- xupybd 9y agoThe tax loop hole in housing is something that needs to be addressed. If we have income tax we really need to tax all profit, including capital gains.
- elyobo 9y agoTOP's policies with regards to taxation were very interesting; no change in overall rate of taxation but broadening the tax base in such a way that would have significantly increased the tax on assets and decreased it on income. Too painful for the National base to take on and too radical for Labour to consider (even though it would significantly benefit their base) though.
- xupybd 9y agoI'm a New Zealander that was deeply concerned by the new government winning the election but this policy gives me hope.
- elyobo 9y agoI'm happy that National is out, but concerned about Winnie being in. This policy might be a good start, but so far looks like window dressing that's not going to achieve much.
- contingencies 9y agoWhy? It already cost foreigners NZD$30,000 in extra foreign buyer approval fees (no guarantee) which was a cash cow. This will kill that cash cow. The best thing about NZ has been immigration. This is just going to funnel money to large construction companies building apartments, and turn NZ in to an apartment farm.
- FooHentai 9y agoThat's not correct. >New Zealand’s overseas investment legislation only affects transactions that include sensitive New Zealand assets, including land that is considered sensitive. https://www.linz.govt.nz/regulatory/overseas-investment/find-out-if-you-need-consent-invest-new-zealand/answers-about-overseas-investment https://www.linz.govt.nz/regulatory/overseas-investment/find...
- contingencies 9y agoSensitive includes half the country, eg. anything naturalesque with "covenants", government proximity, foreshores, historical sites, etc. Source: Real estate expedition to NZ, 2015.
- FooHentai 9y agoDoesn't particularly include urban residential.
- 9y ago
- duncan_bayne 9y agoThis is the result of negotiations between a party called New Zealand First, led by notorious xenophobe[1] Winston Peters, and a socialist PM who has described capitalism as a "blatant failure"[2]. In fact, Peters has already confidently predicted an economic crisis post-election, and begun distancing himself from it[3]. My current bet is on the coalition collapsing, with new elections held in October 2018. A few of my NZ friends and family are placing similar bets; closest guess wins. I'm glad I left for Australia in 2007. [1] http://thewireless.co.nz/articles/winston-why-are-you-like-this http://thewireless.co.nz/articles/winston-why-are-you-like-t... [2] http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/world/jacinda-ardern-capitalism-has-failed-new-zealanders/news-story/d8dd86ac01419bcd6e8a1b7ebdbf03bc http://www.theaustralian.com.au/news/world/jacinda-ardern-ca... [3] https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/industries/98061685/Winston-Peters-played-it-down-but-economy-will-remain-strong-Infometrics-forecasts https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/industries/98061685/Winston...
- patrick-dd 9y agoWelp, Australia's coalition may collapse on Friday too!
- duncan_bayne 9y agoHuh. Funnily enough I don't follow Australian politics; I checked out of politics almost entirely after leaving NZ (where I was quite involved with the LibertariaNZ). Been doing a bit of reading about the last election in NZ, though, as you can probably tell :) It should be an entertaining coalition collapse. Apparently they have a 31-MP executive!??!?! https://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/2017/10/strengths_and_weaknesses_of_the_new_ministry.html https://www.kiwiblog.co.nz/2017/10/strengths_and_weaknesses_...
- elyobo 9y agoTo be fair, it was likely doomed whichever way Winnie went, because both outcomes would have still had Winnie in there.
- elyobo 9y ago
- ACow_Adonis 9y agoSpeaking as an Australian, , where we already have nominally similar policies, and keeping in mind the metro house price phenomenon is repeating in several places in the world in a similar fashion, there's just one small problem with these policies: There's limited evidence available that it's foreign buyers primarily responsible for our high house prices :/ The primary cause has always been local steady employment, low interest rates combined with liberal access to debt with households culturally disposed to pumping that into housing. It's very easy to blame this on Chinese money (which I'm sure is a common story in many parts of the world where house prices are taking off), but the far bigger cause had always been leveraging afforded by local households combined with a low interest rate environment.
- elyobo 9y agoAustralia's policy is weak with regards to enforcement and penalties; NZ's may or may not end up being more effective. Agreed that foreign speculation is at most only part of the problem and that the drivers you mention are a large part of it, but you missed out the other significant factor in the "cultural" inclination to invest in property, which is that the favourable taxation policies (CGT discount, negative gearing, family home CGT exemption) and benefit policies (family home exemption from pension means tests) drive money into property. In NZ's case it's even worse as there's close to no capital gains tax on any property speculation (no requirement to actually live in a property to claim it as an owner/occupier style non-investment property).
- dzhiurgis 9y ago> no requirement to actually live in a property to claim But how do you enforce it?
- elyobo 9y agoI wouldn't bother, because my preference is to tax capital gains on all property including family homes (and to apply this tax annually based on paper profits too). That said, occupancy requirements are reasonably common elsewhere (e.g. to claim first home buyer benefits in AU, to prove that it's your primary residence to avoid capital gains taxes in AU, to get owner/occupier interest rates in AU) so I assume that they have some means of enforcement, but haven't really looked.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoOne of the main problems with this policy is that it's addressing something that isn't actually a problem. The main driver of house pricing is land use and building regulation, unsurprisingly. If it's harder and / or more expensive to build housing, houses will cost more. http://pc.blogspot.com.au/2014/01/australasia-world-leader-in-excessive.html http://pc.blogspot.com.au/2014/01/australasia-world-leader-i...
- elyobo 9y agoThe main driver in AU and NZ is property speculation, driven by terrible tax and pension policies in combination cheap money.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoThat is certainly a driver, but I'm not convinced that it's the main one in Australasia. Certainly, it's not the main one worldwide.
- elyobo 9y agoI can't comment on the worldwide situation, but it's pretty clearly the main AU + NZ driver and it's one that's very easy to address; removing the tax perks would be fairer even if it had no effect on prices at all anyway, so it's a win win scenario. The only difficulty (and it's a biggie) is that actually doing something meaningful on housing affordability requires knocking down prices and that's political suicide, so nobody is willing to do it.
- colordrops 9y agoWish they did this in Los Angeles.
- thrden 9y agoit'd likely be found unconstitutional on the basis of discrimination against someone due to nationality.
- sxates 9y agoNot if it was equally applied to all nationalities.
- ng12 9y agoWhy? You have to have some legal residency to get a driver's license. Why not to buy a house?
- colordrops 9y agoThere is no constitutional law against discrimination based on nationality.
- LgWoodenBadger 9y agoWhat about the Fair Housing Act? "The prohibitions specifically cover discrimination because of race, color, national origin, religion, sex, disability and the presence of children."
- colordrops 9y agoNational origin is not the same as nationality. There are countless rights that citizens have that non-citizens do not.
- toomanybeersies 9y agoNational origin and nationality are different things.
- deleted 9y ago
- sparrish 9y agoThat will pair very poorly with their incentives to get foreign tech workers to move to New Zealand. http://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/Foreign-Expert-Workers-Wanted-for-Technology-Jobs-in-New-Zealand-New-Zealand-Visa-Expert-1001862237 http://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/Foreign-Exper...
- charlesdm 9y agoCan't this easily be avoided by purchasing through a New Zealand company? What stops NZ residents (or non-residents) holding RE through corporate entities from selling their shares and indirectly transferring ownership? Will be interesting to see how it's implemented.
- gorkish 9y agoNothing; this is what I was going to suggest. If you are the sort of person who is wealthy enough to cause housing prices to inflate to the point that it becomes a national crisis, I would be rather surprised to learn that you are NOT buying your real estate through a local shell company of some sort.
- PatientTrades 9y agoIt would be nice to see the West do something like this in the major cities like LA, NY, etc. Foreigners shouldn't be able to come in and buy competitive property when they don't play by the same financial rules as us. seems unfair
- vacri 9y agoWhat counts as 'foreign' to LA? An investor from SF? From outside CA? From the east coast?
- PatientTrades 9y agoForeign as in an individual whos permanent residence is not in the United States. i.e. A Russian millionaire buying a townhouse in LA
- tetromino_ 9y agoWhy oppose a Russian millionaire buying an LA townhouse, but not a Texan millionaire buying the same townhouse? After all, both millionaires earned their millions thanks to low taxes and lax regulations in their native land. Isn't it unfair for an LA native to compete against either of them? Why oppose a Russian millionaire buying an LA townhouse, but not a Russian millionaire buying a Degas painting? If LA residents deserve laws to help them buy a townhouse in a good neighborhood, don't they deserve laws to help them buy other luxuries? Why oppose a Russian millionaire buying an LA townhouse, but not a Russian tourist buying a ticket to Disneyland? Tickets to a venue of limited size are the most inelastic of goods. If you ban foreigners, won't that help lower demand for tickets (and therefore ticket prices) and reduce lines for native LA visitors?
- PatientTrades 9y agoYou are comparing apples and oranges. > Why oppose a Russian millionaire buying an LA townhouse, but not a Texan millionaire buying the same townhouse? A Texan resident is subject to the same federal financial rules and regulations when earning an income in the US as a LA resident. The Russian millionaire can earn millions in a different country under unknown rules. > Why oppose a Russian millionaire buying an LA townhouse, but not a Russian millionaire buying a Degas painting? Buying a Degas painting is a luxury, having a home for your family to live in is a necessity. > Why oppose a Russian millionaire buying an LA townhouse, but not a Russian tourist buying a ticket to Disneyland? Again buying a ticket to Disneyland is a luxury, not a necessity.
- muninn_ 9y agoWe need to implement this in the United States, and work to reduce the birth rate and number of immigrants into the country. Let's follow New Zealand's footsteps in this policy, and Canada's policy of letting in only skilled immigrants.
- msie 9y agoCanada closed down a foreign-worker program. Now I see help-wanted signs in all these stores and some stores are closing down or scaling back service. I don't think Canadians were clamouring to work at a Tim-Horton's, ski hill or farm.
- soperj 9y agomostly because the pay is shit, raise the prices and pay people more, or go out of business, and someone will replace you if the demand is there. That's how it's supposed to work.
- pascalxus 9y agoWhy not just allow more or denser housing to be built? You could take all that foreign cash and turn it into high paying jobs! I mean sure construction jobs aren't high paying, but with enough automation, those jobs could turn into high paying software jobs. Just get rid of all the building and zoning laws and allow companies to innovate as much as they want. Optionally, you could still ban foreigners from buying in places where things are already built out. It just seems such a shame, to see so much economic loss on both sides (both for purchasers and those who'd have benefited from more jobs or higher paying jobs). This is a disturbing pattern I've been seeing playing out in many countries: politicians and the sometimes the voters that elected them have insufficient economic education to make optimal decisions, leading to economic losses - the prime example being what happened in Venezuela.
- vacri 9y ago> Why not just allow more or denser housing to be built? Neither of those things are "existing housing". Foreign cash can still be used to build new housing.
- BronSteeDiam 9y agoConstruction jobs are already very high paying jobs in New Zealand and Australia, maybe even more than software.
- kjksf 9y agoAuckland is the largest city in New Zealand. 75% of Auckland is zoned for 1 or 2 story buildings (according to http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&objectid=11562709 http://www.nzherald.co.nz/business/news/article.cfm?c_id=3&o...). Of that 33% is the most restrictive single house ("The Single House zone currently covers around a third of residential Auckland and is very restrictive, allowing for only one dwelling on sections smaller than 600 square metres." according to http://www.stuff.co.nz/auckland/75219048/Aucklands-controversial-new-residential-zoning-maps-released http://www.stuff.co.nz/auckland/75219048/Aucklands-controver...). 5% is zoned for apartment buildings. Here's 97% of your house pricing problem. Not foreigners, not low interest rates, not land taxing policies. New Zealand has total population of ~2x Paris and land 1000x of Paris. This is Venezuela style of fixing problems: instead of addressing underlying economics (limited supply meeting increasing demand causing raising prices) by increasing supply, find a political scapegoat (all nations are xenophobic so outsiders are always a good target) to get people to vote for you and create ineffective rules. The real fix is politically unpopular. Unsurprisingly, Aucklanders are NIMBY with the best of them. The plan to upzone is "controversial" and anti-upzoning arguments are the same you see in SF and everywhere else where that comes up.
- elyobo 9y agoThis is definitely a major contributor and absolutely needs to be addressed, but it's not the only thing. Improving supply by permitting an increase in density has to be part of the solution, but without also fixing the tax incentives it's only a partial fix.
- marlokk 9y agois it xenophobic to prefer free-range beef too?
- microcolonel 9y agoApartments suck. Most people vastly prefer not to live near them or in them if they have the option. If they have 1000x the land (still remembering that a lot of that is grazing land), then what they need is transport, houses, shophouses, townhomes, and lowrises. If the land price is higher in the the middle of town, then so be it. At least the current residents aren't having the sky systematically parceled away by a corrupt bureaucracy for paltry favours. I'm not totally fond of the way NIMBYism ends up working, but the fact is that these people would otherwise have their land value degraded by amendments to local zoning. The rules for projects like this should at least include compensation for the decrease in assessed value of their property.
- andrewstuart 9y agoIn Australia this just gets gamed so existing houses are knocked down then rebuilt and sold as "new".
- csomar 9y agoI'm just wondering: Can't foreign money create a company in New Zealand, buy real estate with that company and then rent it out or just let it stay there. It says it is banning non-residents. But a New Zealand company owned by a foreigner is considered a resident entity, right?
- Untit1ed 9y agoProbably - the equivalent law in Australia has enough loopholes to make it largely pointless anyway... particularly sending one of your children to study then buying through them. It's a crowd-pleasing law, not an effective one.
- caf 9y agoI don't understand the concern with foreigners wanting to buy real estate. If a bunch of people want to import money from another jurisdiction and use it to buy something that is literally impossible for them to repatriate, more fool them! Let's take as much of their money as they'll offer.
- wtetzner 9y agoI think the problem is that it drives house prices up.
- derefr 9y agoThey don’t want to repatriate it; they want to get it out of their country as the first step of getting themselves out of their country. (Though, they want to stay as long as possible to squeeze as much dirty money out of their corrupt regime as they can before they do, which is why they aren’t just arriving alongside the money.)
- FooHentai 9y ago>use it to buy something that is literally impossible for them to repatriate The asset being fixed in place does not prevent capital outflows. Plus it depends on the purpose of the investment - If it's a means of just parking money, then the only real impact of the purchase is to deny the same purchase to a citizen of the country. That's not a massive issue unless you have a housing shortage (which NZ does, not aided by it's high level of immigration). If on the other hand a return is expected on that investment then you end up with a situation where house prices raise due (in part) to foreign investment, but people still need to live somewhere and so they rent those houses back from the foreign landlord. This absolutely leads to rent extracts which flow out of the country.
- aceon48 9y agoVancouver would like a word with you. Foreigners were buying homes sight unseen to park cash. Vancouver passed a foreign buyer luxury tax for those who arent living in their homes full time... and Lo and Behold! Sales decreased a ton and things have been cooling down.
- gorkish 9y agoI believe this is a much better solution to the problem, but I don't think it should have anything to do with whether or not a buyer is a foreigner.
- scott_karana 9y agoI agree. Speculative land purchasing by wealthy boomers at the expense of their (grand)children is just as bad and much more common.
- zach417 9y agoThis debate is simply that of liberalizing or controlling a nation's capital account. There are benefits to both. The benefit of liberalization (i.e. no limits on foreign investment) is that it can provide "a higher rate of return on people’s savings in industrial countries by increasing growth, employment opportunities, and living standards in developing countries." [1] The benefit of controlling (i.e. limit foreign investment) is that it can reduce market volatility and risk. "International investors are willing to lend to them in good times but tend to pull back in bad times, thereby amplifying swings in the domestic macroeconomy." [1] [1] - http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/basics/capital.htm http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/fandd/basics/capital.htm
- CodeSheikh 9y agoAs an immigrant New Yorker, I welcome this step and kudos to the local government of NZ for taking such initiative. For example on NYC foreign investors have ruined the prospect for an average hard working New Yorker couple to purchase a property at a reasonable price. Foreign investors (Chinese, Russians and Middle Easterns, nothing personally against all of these demographics) have been pouring in capital via greedy American established real estate management agencies. Often owners do not want to deal with the hassle of loan approval, waiting times etc and they mostly take the offer whoever pays the quickest cash. Same thing is happening in Vancouver and other major metropolitan cities across the nation and the world.
- rukittenme 9y agoOh bullshit. New York City is the poster-child of bad housing policy. It's amazing Tokyo can fit 38 million people into its city but New York City can't find room for 1/5 of that. You look at any major city and you'll see rent control and stabilization, restrictions on building and eviction, and a thousand other well intentioned policies that "help" the poor or "save" our "historic" neighborhoods. What a great job its doing...
- dreit1 9y agoYou can't compare Tokyo and New York. Tokyo has wayyyy more land area than New York. It's a build wide instead of build tall city. Source: Live in Tokyo
- mashpotatos 9y agoHave you accounted for mixed-use zoning?
- vorg 9y ago> Tokyo can fit 38 million people into its city but New York City can't find room for 1/5 of that You compared the populations of the greater Tokyo metropolitan area (38m) with the New York 5 boroughs city area (8.6m). You could also compare the Tokyo 23 wards city area (9.4m) with the New York tristate urban area (23.7m) and make the opposite argument.
- Lachy01 9y agoSomeone suggesting relaxing zoning restrictions is not inherently suggesting no restrictions. It doesn't mean "sky scrapers" at all to suggest zoning could be relaxed from single story. It certainly doesn't mean sky scrapers as far as the eye can see. Nor does it mean you should be able to build a toxic waste dumps. You can move the line without removing it, to suggest otherwise is irrational and weakens you argument IMHO.
- princetontiger 9y agoTell the Chinese to get the hell out of NZ. They don't have reciprocal laws. Glad to see this finally happen. Vancouver is a disaster. Glad to see right wing nationalist young leaders in the west. Poland, NZ, Austria, and many others.
- harmlessposter 9y agoGood, we need this in Canada and all California cities.
- thecodeboy 9y agoSubconscious racism?
- mercurial 9y agoAs a data point, here in Denmark, EU citizens need have been residing in the country for at least five years in order to buy. I don't know what the minimum time period is for non-EU citizens, but probably longer.
- Ice_cream_suit 9y agoHomosexuality was illegal in New Zealand until the "New Zealand Homosexual Law Reform Act 1986 " was passed in 1986. New Zealanders are lovely people. However, the country is rather provincial.
- jijji 9y agoHow would countries like the U.S. implement something similar to this?
- mastazi 9y agoAustralia has had a very similar rule (foreigners can only buy newly built property) and prices kept soaring. The problem in Australia (and I suspect in New Zealand as well) is that the offering is limited due to regulation.
- sgt 9y agoThe article isn't clear on the following; will this ban apply to all foreigners, including foreigners with permanent resident permits?
- alexasmyths 9y agoIt's an interesting proposition that has to be taken up. Globalism is having weird effects on certain urban communities. 'Free Trade' - when applied to our personal domiciles - causes crazy problems. At least for residential property - it should be taxed much more heavily, and possibly banned in some cases by foreigners.
- epx 9y agoPrice of real estate is insane everywhere. Here in Brazil there are not many foreigners buying houses but prices are completely unrelated to income since 2010. It has more to do with cheap money, lack of other investment opportunities (at least the perceived lack of) and the good old Ponzi scheme ("la vivienda nunca baja"). Government loves that because it is an easy way to swell up the economy (now we are paying the price for this kind of disingenuous measure) and also the payment of certain taxes like property and real estate transfer.
- dilemma 9y agoGreat. Too many Americans in NZ that buy homes as vehicles for speculation.
- bertil 9y agoI’m surprised that no one is considering taxing (highly) unoccupied flats. The issue is that foreign (I’m assuming that’s dog-whistle for Chinese) money is looking for investments but that those crowd out people who work there. By making renting meaningfully advantageous, you can keep the investment (and have modern, state of the art real estate) and housing for families.
- naasking 9y ago> I’m surprised that no one is considering taxing (highly) unoccupied flats. It's the logistics. How would you police it?
- bertil 9y agoDetection via water, gas or electricity consumption; postal mail to the address with a suggestion you might have to pay the higher rate; challenges of that letter lead to visits where you are expected to provide evidence of living (water, gas, electricity, internet bills). Similar things are being monitored rather effectively: TV fee in the UK, child welfare, cannabis cultivation. The point is not to be perfect but to tell people that they can’t own an asset with large externalities and not use it.
- naasking 9y ago> Detection via water, gas or electricity consumption So we punish people who might just be conservative environmentalists? These are all metrics that can be spoofed if the expected return is high, which it certainly seems to be in real estate.
- bertil 9y ago- Would we punish people who consume so little water, electricity or gas that they appear as not there? Of course not, but people who save enough to not product garbage are still quite rare; they still use water and electricity. Some people have their own well and solar array/windmill, those rarely live in a densely populated city where raising the level limit hits the local Nimbysm. Once again: that’s the first step for detection, city inspectors would most likely be happy to flag you for a medal if you actually save resources that aggressively. > These are all metrics that can be spoofed Indeed, but wasting water to save tax sounds quite egregious. Once again: finding a renter that pays you is financially far more beneficial. The point of the tax is to signal it’s not OK to sit on a property and speculate, not collect more tax.
- 1897235234 9y agoEvery single article about housing affordability on HN has the same comments. I don't know who actually writes these comments, but their solution is to just reduce the quality of life of people by increasing housing density. They think that somehow this idea has escaped everybody and they are geniuses for thinking of it. Everybody who doesn't want to smell other people's shit is called a "nimby", and infinite population growth is supposedly the only rational path forward. Are the people making these comments the same people that will happily live in this situation? Are they rich people that will never live in this environment, or are they young progressives who think they want to live in a high-rise and have sex with robots or whatever despite being 20 and not knowing anything? Or are they immigrants trying to get into a country?
- namlem 9y agoYes, I do support slightly reducing the quality of life for rich people so that poor people can afford rent. I see no problem with this.
- 1897235234 9y agoNo. New Zealand's most common form of housing (not "rich people") is a stand-alone house. The solution always proposed on HN is to increase density. To convert housing into apartments. Meaning the new standard in a decade will be apartments. You are decreasing the quality of life of the average person and not the quality of life of rich people, who live in a mansion with a giant yard.
- namlem 9y agoNot across the whole country, just in the area around Aukland's urban core. And I'm not convinced it actually decreases the quality of life of the average person. In fact, I'd wager that it increases it, by reducing cost of living.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 9y ago
- odammit 9y agoI don’t live in New Zealand, but I assume this is good for locals. Would love to hear your thoughts if you live there! I live in LA and I’d welcome it here - not for all “foreigners” but at least to block foreign investors in residential homes and condos (not the actual buildings but the units). I bought a home last year and I put in 36 offers all 5-15% above asking and was outbid by investors on all but one that I ass-backwarded into. I feel like this is something that would also be welcome in Barcelona with the issues they are having with investors buying up all the housing and renting it on AirBNB.
- zsoprano 9y agohope this gets to Australia at one stage.
- 0xADEADBEE 9y agoThe real reason this is happening is in fact much simpler than outlined in the comments: Kiwis quite simply don't have an asset class in which to invest sensibly that isn't property [1]. In America, I'd cheerfully put the majority of my income into an index fund tracking things like the S&P 500 but New Zealand tax laws heavily penalise this and incentivise property ownership by giving a pass on capital gain tax. The result? House prices are driven up artificially; a problem adroitly obscured by not appearing on an RPI index. The current political developments present an interesting situation; a Labour campaign pledge was to impose capital gain tax on personal property investment (already sanely capped for anyone considered a property developer). I don't see other asset classes being taxed differently to compensate, thus exacerbating the already dire talent drain the country is experiencing. Ironic, given the endemic NZ aspiration to 'get ahead'. It's certainly an interesting time to live here, but I'd prefer bubbles to confine themselves to the Bay Area! [1] https://www.fsc.org.nz/site/fsc/files/Releases/Releases%202014/FSC-Taxation%20and%20Savings%20Paper-Final.pdf https://www.fsc.org.nz/site/fsc/files/Releases/Releases%2020...