15 ms·
Why do sales people get commissions and engineers don't? Because the sales person knows exactly how much money they bring in and can claim "if I didn't make the
by phkahler 9y ago
Why do sales people get commissions and engineers don't? Because the sales person knows exactly how much money they bring in and can claim "if I didn't make the sale, that money would not be coming in" even though it's not always true it's a good story. An engineers actions are so far removed from revenue that they can't make a claim so directly. Also, if they did want to claim a portion of product revenue they could just as easily be fired and the revenue would still flow. Such is the delay between engineering work and revenue.
- Waterluvian 9y agoAlso personality. Good salespeople are... Good salespeople. They apply their craft when negotiating compensation. What am I going to do, make a single page app about why I should be paid more? ...actually that's not a bad idea.
- KekDemaga 9y agoI wonder if that's how Glassdoor was started.
- jbooth 9y agoAt the end of the day, a salesperson not making quota is going to be fired. The best salesperson in the world could maybe buy themselves an extra year, at best. But eventually, if they're so great, where are the numbers? And their next job search isn't gonna look so great. They can't solve a problem on a whiteboard to make up for the fact that their prior business was a bad fit for the market, or whatever. A salesperson who is making quota and running way over it into big bonuses is by definition earning their money. Sometimes people are in the right place at the right time, of course, but in general it's hard to say a sales person is overpaid unless they're completely useless and failing to earn their base pay.
- Waterluvian 9y agoBut a good salesperson who is making quota can also apply their craft to carving a larger piece of the pie for themselves. Just because they're doing well, it does not mean their compensation is an accurate proportion to their contribution to the whole. But don't get me wrong, I'm not saying we should try to quantify the efficacy of SW devs more. I had a PM do that once in the form of ticket quantification as a KPI. I had to expend a lot of political capital to opt out from that nightmare.
- protomyth 9y agoAgreed and to add: It is very much like a waitress / waiter. Lower base pay with commissions substituting for tips. The big difference is the Darwinian nature of the job. Bad food or service from the kitchen might decrease tips, but probably won’t get the waitstaff fired[1], but salespeople that don’t perform, regardless of the software or support, are going to be canned. I don’t begrudge high salespeople commissions because that means things are pretty good, just don’t let them run the company (see Steve Jobs ‘lost’ 1995 interview with Cringly). 1) until the restaurant goes under
- tiggybear 9y agoDo bad engineers not get fired?
- matwood 9y agoDefine bad. What metric do you use? Sales people have a single objective metric - sales.
- kbart 9y ago"What metric do you use?" The key difference between good and bad engineers is that good ones deliver the product/finishes the projects (add bonus points if on time) and bad ones don't. Quality makes much less business sense and is usually only important to the engineer himself and his peers than managers that pay his wage. That's especially true in current "move fast and break things" environment. I have seen a fair share of bad engineers (by this definition) fired, even though they had decent technical skills.
- vidarh 9y agoVery rarely, in my experience. The only dev I've worked directly with that was fired over job performance was first fired when he deleted the entire contents of the corporate IMAP server for a dozen or so people without having verified the most recent backups were up to date and working. We didn't lose enough for it to cause a lasting problem, but it was what finally demonstrated to the CEO that he was careless enough for us to fire. His code was atrocious, but we'd put up with that until the IMAP incident because getting the CEO to understand that his code was bad enough for him to actually be a net loss in performance for the team didn't work until we had to scramble to recover what we could of the corporate e-mail. Last I saw he was a senior developer somewhere more prestigious than the position he was fired from. Maybe he's improved. Or maybe he's just managing to stay above the threshold they'd fire him for. A lot of bad developers just learn to fly sufficiently under the radar and hunker down and accept that they probably won't get many raises until they move jobs and can point to X years of service in company Y, aided by lack of willingness at many companies to stick their neck out when it comes to giving bad references (a lot of places I've worked, HR policy has been clear that we were only allowed to confirm dates of employment).
- skookumchuck 9y agoCoffee is for closers!
- gbacon 9y agoGreat point. Compensation is a vector of which job security is a component. Sales: extreme volatility, excellent pay for the survivors. Engineering: medium to high volatility, strong pay. Education: near zero volatility, low pay.
- samstave 9y agoEhhh. Yap, in coarse we gotta db dat can handle dat shit. Look bro.. you gots an issues, we got da, uh, ting dat can service you! Dats watt we 'ere fer.. we do what's you needs. Now, I'm not gunna lie to ya, I love ya, why would I lie to ya... what I got 'ere fer ya t'day is da best deal yer gunna see in yer lifes! So whadda I gotta do ta get you behind this deal ofs a lifetime fer, say, twenty cores on da best DB on da freakin planet for a fraction of what da others would even dream of? You sign right now and I promise you I'll take dis deal all da way to the top and get the CEOs personal sign-off on dis deal so dat you get da best pricing you ever seen!! What say you? We gots a deal? C'mon, you have to only say yes and I'll get my guys all over dis and you will look like a freakkn rock star to your boss for savin da moneys! (Plus I'll be out dere in august and I'll take yous out fer a steak dinner, c'mon that will be our celebrations!!) /oracle
- dingo_bat 9y ago> single page app about why I should be paid more? Isn't that a resume?
- Waterluvian 9y agoMy resume doesn't have enough frameworks.
- Fordrus 9y agoWhen I was still in the humanities (German Literature Major), my program was making a MAJOR push for all graduates of the major to be able to articulate to others and interviewers the skillset they'd gained during their time at university, and I found it quite useful and helpful, even though I can't remember too much about the specifics. I even talked to one of my professors personally about the push, in which I mentioned how the humanities in general are not amazing at 'selling' their contribution to human progress (she enthusiastically agreed - this was a sign that some of us were 'getting it') - part of that deficiency shows is via the incredible antipathy the internet holds towards the Literature major who then becomes a starbucks barista. I don't always love salespeople, and I often chafe at the thought of having to emphasize my own efforts in an attempt to gain leverage with those of higher status than myself (a situation known to some as 'playing politics') - yet salesmanship is literally universal to the human condition (really want yammer more and explain what I mean by that, but it is time to shutdown for the day. :) )
- Waterluvian 9y agoI think I know what you're saying all too well, if I understand correctly. In my Master's program, my advisor had to keep asking me to stop saying, "we" any time I described efforts. I didn't even notice I was doing it, but very naturally I would say, "we applied X." "We then did Y" instead of "I", being the sole researcher. It's very hard for me to be so bold as to flatly say, "I designed and built this, and I feel responsible for why it has been such a success." The most I can get out these days is, "I am very proud to see that software still finds value among the other dev teams."
- MrQuincle 9y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/F.D.C._Willard https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/F.D.C._Willard used another strategy.
- Fordrus 9y agoI think we are understanding each other very well! Yes, learning to "sell ourselves" and highlight our own successes well enough to influence social structures when we need to is a hard problem, we're trained quite strongly and mostly correctly that "rooting one's own horn" is quite rude, and even in cases where it isn't actually rude or is expected, we STILL have to tread lightly! (For example, resumes and interviews are functionally places where we're given ORDERS to tout our achievements- yet there's still an invisible line you can cross that'll mark you as a braggart if you go overboard!) But on the other hand, people can only make decisions based on information that is actually available to them, and so the quiet industrious worker in he corner who rarely pipes up and silently gets the job done but does nothing to make certain his/her contribution is noticed is passed over, because the boss can't magically know that quiet worker is the excellent contributor they are without something imparting that info- good managers will try to understand who's truly contributing in ways like that but even very good managers are frequently subject to imperfect information! Anyway, I'm glad your advisor told you that, and I'm glad you shared that with me, yours is a succinct way of describing that, I'm almost tempted not to post this reply, as I'm uncertain it adds anything more of value than an emphatic "yes I agree!"
- greedy_buffer 9y agoDepending on who you are pitching, it might turn out something like http://getcoleman.com/ http://getcoleman.com/
- puranjay 9y agoThat page is glorious
- twic 9y agoOr http://noahstokes.com/ http://noahstokes.com/
- Waterluvian 9y agoThat's incredible.
- vidarh 9y agoMost engineers would do vastly better simply by negotiating at all when receiving an offer. I hardly ever experience engineers trying to negotiate when I hire people, yet when I've taken permanent jobs myself I have always negotiated and it has always yielded a higher offer (never once have I experienced anyone pulling an offer or refusing to raise the offer; sometimes they've not raised it enough for me to take it, though).
- ugh123 9y ago>An engineers actions are so far removed from revenue that they can't make a claim so directly. Really? I see it the other way around. How did the salesperson contribute to building the product? A well built technology solution can sell it self in many scenarios. If we didn't have sales people, we could still build a product and push it into the market. Of course all of this depends on the type of product, but still... I'm actually in favor of of commissions, and engineering bonuses for the same reasons from this article. But it cannot be said that engineers are so far removed from the revenue.
- parasubvert 9y agoI've been working in software for a long time, and other than inexpensive / simple consumer software or inexpensive departmental IT software, I've never seen products that sell themselves. Marketing at the very least is required, and for anything remotely complex, that's what sales is for. Sales does something nearly as important as building the software: they map a customer's opportunity or problem to a technical solution, and ensuring they're successful with it. Sales (and marketing, which is arguably the evolution of sales at scale) are the field forces in discovering and exploiting product/market fit. No feature list survives first contact with the customer. Sales creates customers, and thus create markets. You might have a great piece of software but if no one can explain it, no one will understand it, and it won't sell. This is the difference between software that costs $1k and $100k+. The price is reflective of the value it can provide and who is buying it. Now in very small companies, the engineers are also marketers and salespeople. But beyond (say) 50 people, the divide between engineering and customers gets wider unless you have very good communication between sales, marketing, product, and engineering. There's too much work for everyone to focus on everything.
- gaadd33 9y agoDidn't Atlassian grow to a pretty big size before they even started hiring a sales team?
- parasubvert 9y ago
- caf 9y agoThere's often a considerable delay between sales work and revenue, too. "Sales" are generally counted on the day the client signs the contract, but the company doesn't see the revenue until actual delivery. It's more likely to be because in sales, the individual can have a major effect on the numbers that their commission is calculated on, so (as the article describes) that attracts the strongest performers, because they know that they will be well-compensated. In positions where your personal performance doesn't have a direct and immediate effect on the numbers, the strongest performers won't be attracted to commissions. If you were part of a software development team would you want a significant part of your compensation to be at-risk based on this quarter's sales numbers? Probably not, because you know that you could bust your ass this quarter getting an important release out but still see your paycheck dive because that big potential lead backed out of signing.
- sidlls 9y agoCommission isn't the only mechanism of performance based compensation: bonuses and revenue and profit sharing (which commissions might be considered a subset of, I suppose) are also things. Equity (real equity, e.g. of a public company or profitable, stable company with a clear, real value) is another form. Besides that, it's certainly possible to measure at least in aggregate the impact on revenue non-sales team members have, e.g. by the value the products they work on create. It's obviously not as clear or direct as a sale.
- richdougherty 9y ago> the sales person knows exactly how much money they bring in I agree this is the key factor. Any job where a person can argue a clear, direct, measurable link between their work and profit is a job that can be paid based on financial results. Other jobs where you see this: financial traders, consultants with direct client contact. To take the other extreme, look at teachers. They have the potential to generate huge value based on how effectively they develop society's human capital. Unfortunately the effects of a single teacher are so noisy and indirect that it's basically impossible to measure their performance. The lack of firm data is why the debate about teacher compensation is so fraught.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Unfortunately the effects of a single teacher are so noisy and indirect that it's basically impossible to measure their performance. The lack of firm data is why the debate about teacher compensation is so fraught. The problem is not that it's hard to measure. The people is that teachers actually have very little ability to make a marginal impact on their students though their performance, except at the very tail ends of the distribution. In other words, structural factors that teachers can't directly control, like family support or district curriculum standards, have a much larger impact on student performance than teaching quality does. (Except, of course, for the exceptionally bad teachers, but that's better addressed by firing them than by adjusting the compensation strategy).
- camelite 9y agoThat's a myth. The real problem is that the average teacher (relative performance) is so far away from being close to maximally performant (as proved in studies which rigourously control teacher behaviour) that the impact of variation about that mean is swamped by environmental factors. People conclude that since swapping teachers doesn't make an appreciable difference, teacher performance can't make a difference. When in reality the problem is that teaching is uniformly bad (compared to maximal possible performance, which is very difficult. this is why the answer is not to look for better teachers but to look for better, uniformly implementable, curriculums)
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoThe fact that it’s easy to measure sales is part of it, but it’s really about creating the right incentives for the business to succeed. When you pay comissions the sales people will chase big sales for their own self interest — the more they sell, the more they make. Engineers are similarly incentived through stock options to design products and features that will help the company make more money.
- scarface74 9y agoAn engineers actions are so far removed from revenue that they can't make a claim so directly. Not always. I've worked for two companies that customize software for customers. I knew exactly what the company was charging for every hour I worked.
- erikb 9y agoIf you work as an engineer in a big company you often face decisions that will influence big time results. And you can make a big impact, by deciding which competitor for your time (manager, co-department, company's partner A or partner B) will get you to build the result they desire. I can guarantee you that even ina 600 ppl team there will only be a few engineeers who can really plan, push others, understand the technical problems, and communicate to all parties, so that a result can be achieved. These people will either work their 40 hours, tell everybody maybe, and then work on their side business the other 30 hours, or they spend 50-70 hours on your project and get the result you need to even start calling customers. It is also very accountable, because no technical results means no deals. Thus, the same logic as with sales people also applies for engineers. It's just that they are cheaper, because fewer of them know, and fewer people actually are smart enough to make them offers accordingly. In the end it's always how to make the biggest impact with the limited amount of money you have. And there's no natural reason that would stop engineers from being in key positions to your success.
- KGIII 9y agoWe gave bonuses and profit sharing. The now-parent company stopped that practice, I am told. I still own shares in the parent company, I should sell them.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- terryf 9y agoSales also has a different culture than development. Sales really is brutal and soul wrenching in a completely different way than software is (yeah, I've been on both sides, less on sales part). The measurability of money has two sides - one is that you can argue for a commission, the other is that it's very easy to point to numbers that say you didn't really sell anything this month. In sw dev, if you're mildly competent, you can coast for many months, if not years. So, essentially it comes down to different risk/reward profiles . Which of course selects for the right kind of people and the cycle feeds itself.
- tiggybear 9y agoSales can get a percent of the value they generate because they have more leverage than engineers. Plain and simple. They have direct relationships with customers and the value they bring in is easier to show. This line from the article was pretty gross to read, "Do your engineers like programming? Might they even do a little programming on the side sometimes for fun? Great. I guarantee your sales people never sell enterprise software for fun." Personally, I don't do that much programming for fun and a lot of the crap I have to do for work I would never do for my own projects. It reads as though they are aware that they can get away with paying engineers less because they like to create valuable things just because. So it's easier to trick them into giving up the valuable things they create for cheaper. Who cares why someone creates something? No businessman is entitled to someone else's creation because it was created for fun. I mean, if all these VCs and founders are sooooo passionate about their work, they should't need equity or much of salary, right? It's the same line of thinking, but of course it doesn't apply in those situations for...reasons.
- johannes1234321 9y agoFrom a company's perspective the nice thing there is that they can push some risk to the sales people. If they build a shotty product nobody wants the sales people earn less, while not being responsible ...
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoHow exactly is that a good thing for anyone in the company?
- blubb-fish 9y agoThey are also closer to management - having drinks with higher ups and important customers, going to events. They tend to be more fun to be around and in a better mood. I'm an engineer and I am really not happy about this industry habit. I think it is simply not fair.
- m-app 9y agoSales is also a rather short-term, target-oriented activity. If you would incentivise developers on those same short-term goals, this would have a negative impact on the quality and innovation of your product, since they'd also start chasing the quick wins. This is not to say that developers do not deserve a bonus when performing well, I just don't think it should be tied to Sales.
- rbcgerard 9y agoIn my experience it's all about where the sales target gets set with sales people, as it can be really hard to differentiate the "seat" from the person. I.e. An all star salesman at one company, given a different product/company might not be able to make their numbers. Hence the old saw that good salesman find easy products to sell...
- Eridrus 9y agoA coworker once suggested to our CTO that we should get bonuses as a % of the money we save by optimising our AWS costs. I was super on board with that plan at the time since I had been thinking about an unmaintained system and had figured out we could shave off a huge chunk of storage saving us 20k/month with no impact on functionality, and I got the change deployed. Instead of a bonus I got laid off a few months afterward.
- brianwawok 9y agoIs there a reverse incentive here? *IF we bloat AWS costs for 1 year, then at year end find a way to cut 50k.. bam, big bonus? Maybe if the adding to AWS cost team is a different team from the lowering cost team...
- wil421 9y agoSomething like this happens all the time in Corportate IT, I've been seeing it a a lot lately. It goes like this VP agrees to do these projects in 2018 at X amount. VP gets the highest possible cost for X. VP cuts projects and/or project budgets down to bare minimum. Now he can say he saved whatever amount and is a hero for saving so much let's give him a fat bonus.
- carlmr 9y agoExactly, you can always fool the metrics, but everyone who is paid by metrics is doing it.
- Eridrus 9y agoI'm not saying this is a good metric, just relaying an anecdote :)
- jasonkester 9y agoAs an engineer, the way you get paid for the value you create is by starting a company. In fact, that's the way you do it in pretty much every profession. The only difference between the guy who owns a successful Veterinary practice and the guy working as an underpaid veterinarian is that one of them went out and leased some office space.
- simonswords82 9y ago> The only difference between the guy who owns a successful Veterinary practice and the guy working as an underpaid veterinarian is that one of them went out and leased some office space. I understand the point you're attempting to make but the guy who owns the <type of business> has done much, much more than simply lease an office. Many business founders put their life savings on the line. Those who don't have that luxury ramp up thousands of dollars of personal debt. On top of that they work every waking hour. Time is a precious commodity and cannot be replaced, so risking so much of it to enjoy the slim chance of being a successful business owner is not something most people care to risk.
- jasonkester 9y agoThat's why it's so much better to be a developer than a veterinarian. I didn't have to buy an MRI machine to start doing my thing. I just had to register a domain name and sign up for a Stripe account. Incidentally, there's a lot of room to build a successful software business with an effort between zero and "work every waking hour"/"put [your] life savings on the line". I built the products I live off in the downtime between contract gigs, when the surf wasn't working and conditions weren't right for climbing. With two digit hosting expenses for the first several years. Definitely don't let fears like the ones you expressed above stop you from doing it.
- simonswords82 9y agoToo late I'm afraid, set this thing up 10 years ago and still going at it :) https://www.atlascode.com https://www.atlascode.com
- glynjackson 9y ago> "An engineers actions are so far removed from revenue that they can't make a claim so directly" This statement is simply not true in my experience as an engineer in the tech industry for over 15 years. Sell a bad product 'once', and the sales person 'ability' to sell it again will decrease. Sales people ultimately sell a project and its features, interpreted by engineers. You must incentivise an engineer to be creative, write better features and good code or you run the risk of having something that destroys a sales person reputation along with the companies revenue!
- wiz21c 9y agoThe money the sales person needs to live is probably the same as the engineer. Therefore, if sales people get commission, then their salary must be set lower than the engineer so that on average (that is, when the ratio between actual sales and missed sales is average), they earn the same thing as the engineer. (this in a context where the added value by the company is equally shared between the engineer and sales people)
- alien_at_work 9y agoI don't understand what you're saying here at all. Are you under the impression that money someone needs to live has something to do with compensation? Labor is a market like any other. A sales salary has nothing to do with how much a sales person needs to live but rather perceived value of a sales role. In my personal experience, sales people tended to have higher salaries along with strong commission. Maybe your comment is constrained by your idea that revenue is shared equally between engineers and sales people, but why would that be the case?
- wiz21c 9y agogood questions indeed. I was challenging the fact that, as you say : "Labor is a market like any other.". I don't think it is like that because behind each job there's a life. Moreover, on the fact that engineers and sales persons should have the same salaries, yep that's what I think. I don't see why sales works should be more compensated. I understand that the way it is compensated (bonus for sales) is the way it works, but in the end, I don't see why it should pay more than engineering (here I consider a context where the sales person and the engineer are both employees). The two roles are equally important to me, just different skills.
- alien_at_work 9y ago>I don't think it is like that because behind each job there's a life. Labor is a market. It's a shockingly inefficient one, but it's definately a market.
- craigvn 9y agoThis is pretty much spot on, they get a commission because it is easy to work out, and has the added bonus of an easy to calculate monetary incentive.
- matco11 9y agoGetting commissions does not necessarily mean getting paid more. Often people paid on commissions have smaller base salaries. Payments with commissions are a managerial tool to incentivize a certain behavior, the same way there are other structures to help organizations behave in a certain way. For example, you can incentivize people based on an easily measurable metric fully under their control (e.g. $ sales, customer support tickets solved, factory throughput, etc.), or choose to align everyone's behavior (e.g. Profits of xyz division of the company - hardly under a particular person's control). That's the same principle behind giving CEO and other senior executives incentives based on stock options: you want them to create value and get share price up, while leaving them maximum freedom on how to get there. Each approach has its pros and cons in terms of how easy it is to explain to employees, track the metrics, create a collaborative environment (or not), incentivize intra-company communications (or not), and the impact it has on workforce productivity (also, it depends on how you measure productivity...) In designing an incentive plan, one has to decide which one of these factors one wants to prioritize. Because of the salesperson role, and because of the type of mindset/profile these people predominantly have, it is easy/common to have their pay structure heavily based on commissions. Looking at things from the other side: if you ask a salesperson about compensation structures, possibly she would be wondering why engineers' or designers' pay is not linked to sales, so (instead of working on interesting and beautiful stuff) they would prioritize shipping features that help her sell... (as an example of not so beautiful designs that sell more think about the design of certain low cost airlines websites) ...Then again, possibly, the salesperson only knows what would help her sell more easily TODAY, and not what she is going to need in a year's time... you need an engineer not directly incentivized on current sales to think about that!
- dkersten 9y agoThe difference is that often sales commissions have no (or much higher) upper limit. That is, if you are skilled enough (and lucky enough, for sure, since there are certainly many factors outside of the salespersons control), then they can potentially make a large commission. On the other hand, a salaried engineer has a hard upper limit (their salary + any bonuses that may exist) which can only be raised through a promotion or renegotiation. A problem for me is that there's little incentive to work b tons what my contract stipulates and what my manager feels is acceptable productivity (and whatever I need to get bonuses, if I get bonuses at all), because I get the same compensation (in terms of money or time off or whatever -- I don't get to leave early if I finish my work early: I move on to the next task instead) no matter how hard I work or productive I am. So why would I wear myself down by working harder if I can be less stressed and work less hard for the exact same compensation? At least a commission-based role puts some of this into my hands. If I feel I can make more sales by working harder/longer/faster/smarter, I can get paid more.
- cafard 9y agoWell, yes and no. I have seen "sales" types get accounts handed to them, after which they are essentially collecting rent. If their protectors are sufficiently powerful, this can continue indefinitely.
- carlmr 9y agoAccount managers would be the ones mending the existing clients. They get less commission but they can coast a little more easily.
- Raphmedia 9y ago> An engineers actions are so far removed from revenue that they can't make a claim so directly. That's not true for everyone. I worked for an agency that did e-commerce integrations and developments and we had eyes on the client's budget and profits along with our agency's. We were not paid on commission either despite knowing the exact value of our work. To be honest, being so close to the money was demoralizing. It skews perspectives (or should I say it enlighten you?). Hard to stay motivated working for xx.xx/h salary salary when you know very well that you create yyyyyy.yy$/day in value.
- carlmr 9y agoYeah, in my last job I saw I was making the company over a million Euros a year, if you split the projects among the employees working on them. And I got an entry level salary. It was demoralizing, I switched to a bigger company that pays well. And it's so soul sucking that I yearn for my last job. Money isn't everything. Life is still unfair.
- matchagaucho 9y agoA great Salesperson can sell a mediocre MVP on the promise of future enhancements. This can help start-ups defer fund raising by bringing in operational cash. This can also bury start-ups by making promises that can't be kept.
- ChemicalWarfare 9y agoWhat about sales engineers though? I've never seen them get commissions even though in a vast majority of cases they are the ones doing the heavy lifting of convincing the client's tech team[s] to go with the product/solution the company is selling? A little less obvious case, but still - what if we're talking professional services type situation and the architect/engineer assigned to the customer does such a killer job the customer decides to spend more money on their services. Sales person's job at this point is minimal but they still get the commission but the tech person doesn't.
- pheldagryph 9y agoThere's lots of ways to compensate a cat! Not all sales compensation plans are commission-based (a percentage of the sale). Commission-based plans are much less common for sales engineers vs. salespeople, unless they are working with only a single salesperson. In general, sales engineer variable compensation plans are going to be based on some mix of sales numbers, with less variability and risk than the salesperson's plan. Ideally providing goal alignment with money, smoothing out the stresses, but also encouraging some level of independence for the sales engineers. A ward against salespeople who might be seduced by the Dark Side. The less obvious case you raise, a single engineer directly responsible for causing a customer to spend more money: structurally or ad-hoc, that person should probably be getting paid. Maybe the customer-facing people aren't engaging efficiently, and it's a sign of something a bit out of alignment with customer operations. Salespeople can provide big value in getting engineering attention to the right customers at the right time... but the best ones know it's a team sport. I know salespeople that give envelopes of cash to difference-makers, though that's exceptional.
- anonyxyz 9y agoIf you haven't seen sales engineers get commissions, then you're working for the wrong companies. Very common for sales engineers to have up to a third of their comp commission based.
- networkguy 9y agoI work for a Major ISV and I get a commission. How it works is there are various clip rates 0-80% 80-100% 100%+ On 0-80 I get a percentage of the deal, on 80-100% I get a percentage and there is a small multiplier and above 100% I get a larger percentage and a significantly improved multiplier. My quota is divided quarterly and yearly; the incentive is set out that if you overachieve on a couple quarters, I might exceed my "On Target Earnings" even though I didn't hit the yearly number. You are correct that the Sales Engineer does a lot of the heavy lifting; and in most cases we are the deal -- without us selling the technical, the deal usually doesn't get done. So should we get paid the same as the Account Executive? No Freakin Way. The purpose of the Account Exec isn't to close a deal; that's table stakes. The purpose of the Account Exec is to open doors and exceed quota, 100% quota attainment isn't a high-five moment as the expectation is 110%+. Take a good hard look at the sales people you know and look where they are and where they have been -- these people are hired for their contacts and usually once they have exhausted their contact list they are done and they move on to the next organization unless they are exceptional at developing new pipeline and new relationships. I've seen firms go through 2x Account Execs in a year because they weren't hitting the numbers fast enough; that wont happen with a Sales Engineer we get a lot of job stability and protection but we wont get a 30% commission.