13 ms·
Why has regional income convergence in the U.S. declined? Housing costs
- api 9y agoThe problem has been popularly summarized as "housing cannot be both affordable and a good investment." Of course that might be an oversimplification. Housing has been an investment class as long as it's existed and yet there hasn't been an affordability crisis like this since at least before WWII. What's different now?
- JBReefer 9y agoDramatic increases in lifespan have produced a home owning class that would normally have died years ago, locking up a large chunk of the housing stock. Also NIMBYs.
- s0rce 9y agoIt surprised me when I moved to the US from Canada how many elderly planned to stay in their homes. In Canada it felt like many people downsized to smaller condos, at least in the city.
- rpazyaquian 9y agoTo be fair, moving is a pain, you'd be giving up an investment you've held for decades, and you may have settled down into an area and not want to move around. Plus, maybe there just aren't many other options where you live. I'm not elderly, but that's a few reasons why they wouldn't downsize.
- JBReefer 9y agoThat's started to happen again in the US, but you have to remember that many US cities were fairly dangerous and neglected until about 20 years ago.
- surveilmebro 9y agoAnother factor that is present in some places (at least here in Seattle) is that certain regulations discourage condo construction relative to building rental units. Essentially, there is a stricter inspection process for any units that are to be sold. The law was well-intentioned, but has led to crazy things like 10-20k luxury apartment units being built per year with none of them available for purchase.
- klipt 9y agoIn California prop 13 freezes property tax assessments at time of purchase, so many elderly people are paying less property tax on their house than they would on a newly bought condo.
- jandrese 9y agoProp 13 will go down as one of the biggest blunders in legislative history IMHO. I get the complaint that people were being taxed out of their homes and that's not good, but in the end it just shifts the tax burden from the old to the young.
- pascalxus 9y agoAnd it's extremely Regressive. Out of 2 people who bought the same house, the guy who bought it 30 years ago, made 2 million dollars, but is taxed 10 times less!
- lostapathy 9y agoI've always wondered why this can't be subject to a constitutional challenge under equal protection. If the main reason somebody pays less taxes is that they bought the house before you were born, that feels like age discrimination.
- wbl 9y agoThey tried. It didn't work.
- lostapathy 9y agoTotal agreement here. Prop 13 is outright generational theft from younger people by older generations.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Prop 13 is outright generational theft from younger people by older generations. It's actually theft by corporate (or family chain) long-term property owners from everybody else; it doesn't favor individuals of particular ages (especially since the parent-child residence exception was adopted.)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jdavis703 9y agoNIMBYs are part of the problem, but there are also well-meaning (if poorly executed) safety and zoning regulations that drive up the cost. Rules like parking minimums, disability accommodations (i.e elevators) and minimum square footage requirements all contribute to increasing pricing. We have to decide as a society whether housing should be considered a luxury, and those who can't afford things like elevators and parking spots should be forced to live in a tent on the street or not.
- oconnore 9y agoI'm pretty sure that parking minimums, zoning, and minimum ft^2 are just thinly veiled NIMBY tactics, not a separate thing.
- jandrese 9y agoMost of those are well intentioned laws to fix actual problems, but the lawmakers didn't take into consideration that not all developments would have those problems. The parking thing is a good example. It basically just says you need to have a space for most people in the building to park so they don't fill up the street parking for the entire block all of the time. A very valuable rule for suburban development where most units will have at least one vehicle. Not so necessary for downtown units where most of the apartments won't own a vehicle. Or there are just cases where the developer is complaining about having to build parking, but if they had built the building as they wanted the parking would have been a total nightmare, not only for residents but also for everybody else in the neighborhood. In other words they're being forced to consider the actual cost of their actions instead of pushing them off on the community and pocketing the profits like in the good old days.
- sbov 9y agoIf you could designate a building "car free", and have all local street parking be permit parking, AND don't hand out permits to people living in "car free" buildings, it seems like it would fix the problem. But I don't know how practical it is to do this.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoMaybe its a soft-cap on commute times? People were fine driving 20 minutes instead of 10, 30 instead of 20 and so on if it meant they got to live in nice suburbs. But now staring down the barrel of an hour commute or more people aren't willing to continue moving further and further out. Purely speculation of course.
- jandrese 9y agoDoesn't that just further inflate the prices of homes in reasonable commute distance?
- tcbawo 9y agoWe have external money moving into US property. I wonder how much the Pacific Northwest's recent surge is due to Chinese investment moving on from Vancouver.
- sokoloff 9y agoHousing that you live in (aka "consume") has not been a particularly good investment, IMO. What confuses many people into thinking that it is is that you often end up holding it for a long period of time, paying down the mortgage and when you go to sell, you have a large gain, where you started with a very small downpayment. For most people, that gain is also tax-free, so it seems like a magic windfall. The problem is that over that long a period of time, inflation may have halved the purchasing power, meaning your gain is a paper one, you spent a lot of years fixing and maintaining the house, paying taxes and insurance, working on the yard, maybe did some remodeling, etc. If you'd instead invested in the stock market any surplus over renting, you often would have come out ahead. Most people would find a way for that surplus to turn into lattes, vacations, new cars, and large TVs rather than into shares of VTSAX, so for them, homeownership is a good idea, not because it's a better investment than equities, but because it's a better savings vehicle than nothing. I'm a homeowner and very happy about that fact for our family (for lifestyle reasons), but even in a steeply rising market (Cambridge, MA), my other investments have performed much, much better (even including the 2007/2008 crisis).
- rpazyaquian 9y agoWhat's your investment strategy? I recently started a Roth IRA and started maxing it out each year, but I don't know what else to do with my savings (that are extra over my ~6mo salary buffer + emergency fund, I mean). Dumping it all into something like VTSAX is something I've thought about for a while, but I'm not sure how well it works for long-term investment/"making my money work for me".
- sokoloff 9y agoThis is my go-to post on advice for US taxpayers: https://forum.mrmoneymustache.com/investor-alley/investment-order/msg1333153/#msg1333153 https://forum.mrmoneymustache.com/investor-alley/investment-... (I didn't write it, but I generally agree with it and I like that it's very concise, fairly approachable, and you can readily act on the advice.)
- avn2109 9y agoRead https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002QX44IS https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002QX44IS The sibling comment's Mr. MM recommendation is better than nothing but not as good as a real book IMHO.
- coliveira 9y agoThe difference now is that we have seen a big uptick on inequality in American. People that are well off not only drive up housing prices, they also use their political clout to avoid the construction of affordable housing in order to maintain the value of their homes. It is a double effect that makes a big difference. Also, Americans got used to the idea that their personal home is wealth, which is a misleading and dangerous idea.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- maxxxxx 9y agoHistorically hosuing has not been an investment where people could expect a BIG payout after ten years. It was a good, conservative investment but not a money maker as it is now.
- bradleyjg 9y ago> What's different now? Cash compensation for most percentiles has stagnated since the 80s. There's a lot of mooted reasons for that -- increasing fringe benefit costs, demographic changes, Cowen's technological plateau, decline of labor unions, etc., etc., etc. -- but the upshot is that we have a ratio where the numerator has continued its growth pattern but the denominator has not. Growth covers a multitude of sins.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- a2tech 9y agoWell no kidding. You don't need to be a genius to see that housing costs in big cities have outstripped wage growth by a large margin for many years. Housing costs outside of the big population centers have grown at a much more reasonable rate.
- grandalf 9y agoAfter decades of Federal policy to encourage investment in housing, the consequences are getting harder and harder to ignore, yet the blind faith in these sorts of paternalistic policies remains unabated. The many tax breaks and loopholes for real-estate investors resulted in overbuild in many parts of the country... these were the parts that were hit hardest in the crash of 2008. Not only was this a big misallocation of capital which robbed other industries of investment for decades, but the response to the crash was to prop up real-estate prices through other drastic measures. These massively inflated prices enriched many of the landlords in urban areas, greatly increasing their political clout and ability to push for regulations that protect their incomes and harm the public. Meanwhile, transit systems and roadways declined, further increasing the value of urban real-estate because of the great inefficiency of getting to and from a city if one lives outside of the city. So now, real-estate-fueled urban price inflation has altered mobility patterns creating further economic distortion. Software engineers in SF make high salaries but live a lower standard of living than those in other cities: https://www.codementor.io/blog/best-cities-software-engineer-earnings-271vpf599k https://www.codementor.io/blog/best-cities-software-engineer... Who is benefitting from all of this? The landlord class, builders, and construction companies. When you see a politician wearing a hard hat chances are that politician is helping enrich those interest groups at the expense of everyone else.
- wbl 9y agoBuilders don't profit because they don't have places to build legally.
- jandrese 9y agoIMHO the inflation of housing costs has many factors, but one of the ones that gets overlooked is the concentration of wealth near the top. Rich people need safe places to stash their money, and they end up buying real estate all over the country. This isn't just Americans either, US real estate is a popular investment all over the world. But when you are buying real estate as an investment where do you buy, not out in some no-name town in some flyover state. You buy in a place where the market is already hot and ride the wave. Thousands of millionaire investors piling into a market end up pricing out regular folks who just want a place to live. I'm frankly surprised that we have not seen more real estate bubbles pop over the years. It's clearly unsustainable, yet somehow the market keeps going. Ask your parents if they could afford to buy their home today, even with their best yearly income. Most of them will say no if they lived in the city for a couple of decades or more. I know so many who bought their house for $70k-$100k in the 70s and now see their neighbors sell for $1m-$1.5m. It's insane.
- nemo44x 9y agoInterest rates were also very high in the 70's and early 80's. If we could get housing interest rates up to 8% you'd see a large decline in housing prices. If it got up to 1970's and 1980's rates it would be around 17%. This would dramatically reduce the price of a typical house and become a darling market for people who have can pay in cash.
- icantdrive55 9y agoYea, but the 1% er's, and REIT's would just have more no brainer deals/units to add to the portfolio. Personally, I would like to see changes on whom can buy real estate. 1. Disavow all foreign ownership of residential/commercial land. (This I don't get at all.) 2. Get rid of REIT's 3. Put a cap on the member of units(homes, buildings) a entity can own. We might prevent another Trump dynasty? Personally, I don't like looking at a home as a investment.
- colechristensen 9y agoI'd assume it was forced by all of the initiatives of making the "American dream" of owning a home a reality for as many people as possible. Real estate shouldn't be an investment, it shouldn't raise in value, and it shouldn't be possible for a huge chunk of the population to fund the financial sector through mortgage interest. It's a tax on everyone designed to funnel wealth upwards towards a sector of capital owners that get paid for doing very little. Regulations and taxes should be arranged such that it is very expensive to own real property that isn't for your own personal or business use. If you want to act as a gatekeeper for real estate, at least a large chunk of the profit should go to the state for the benefit of the public. If it's expensive and not beneficial to own things so others have to pay you to use them, the market will shrink dramatically and more people will actually be able to own homes.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoIt always stuns me to hear so many people blaming NIMBY movements for housing prices while completely ignoring the effect that good job concentration has on the local housing markets. Housing is insanely expensive on the east and west coast because those are the only areas of the country seeing economic growth. If everyone is required to be in such a small area to even have an opportunity to get a good job, then of course it will be expensive to live there.
- asabjorn 9y agoThat is because we on the west coast have zoned most neighborhoods to single family housing, and that is a direct cause of our housing supply constraint and therefore our high housing cost. It would be trivial to replace a fraction of that housing with enough housing to meet demand if we rezoned.
- surveilmebro 9y agoIt is a direct cause, but not the only cause. The fact that virtually all job growth is in these cities is equally if not more to blame. As a Seattle resident who was priced out of a succession of neighborhoods through grad school, I can't help but wonder why we need so much growth. It's not like there's a shortage of employment opportunities.
- epistasis 9y agoThe NIMBY problem prevents the housing market from adapting to demand, it's entirety of the problem. Job growth and economic growth are not the problems. In places such as Texas with high economic growth housing is not a problem. It just so happens that NIMBYs have huge economic gains from restricting the market from supplying what people want.
- angersock 9y ago> because those are the only areas of the country seeing economic growth. [citation needed]
- 9y ago
- coliveira 9y agoThe dirty secret of the tech industry is that their leaders and investors are making a killing in Real Estate. VC owners and their billionaire friends have bought a lot of land and buildings in San Francisco, Seattle, and other cities, and are "forcing" their companies to move into these cities. This has the nice side effect of making another fortune for them. At the same time, tech workers need to pay essentially a large tax for living where the jobs are, and other types of workers cannot even live in these cities anymore.
- tmh79 9y agoYep, biggest example is marc andreesen himself. His wife a member of the Arrillaga family (old money real estate in the south bay, lots of buildings in stanford and palo alto parks & rec named after them), and they have more land wealth than tech wealth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Arrillaga https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Arrillaga > In the 1960s, Arrillaga and business partner Richard Peery bought California farmland and converted it into office space.[4] They became two of Silicon Valley's biggest commercial landlords with more than 12,000,000 square feet (1,100,000 m2). > His daughter Laura Arrillaga-Andreessen is married to Marc Andreessen, the successful entrepreneur
- adventured 9y agoNice try at slandering Andreessen. Marc Andreessen is worth a billion dollars at 46 years of age. John Arrillaga is worth $2.5 billion at ~81 years old. With Andreessen Horowitz now the preeminent VC firm in the US, it's extremely likely Marc Andreessen is going to far out pace Arillaga's real estate wealth via his investment returns in companies. Simply put, Marc Andreessen found a far more lucrative and faster way to make money than John Arillaga did. Andreessen's current position is worth more than a couple billion in real estate. The biggest companies on earth are all tech companies now. The most profitable companies on earth are all tech companies now. Andreessen has a seat at the center table of the greatest corporate wealth boom in world history (just MSFT+AMZN+GOOGL+FB+AAPL = $3 trillion). Further, Andreessen isn't necessarily entitled to that land wealth. For your premise to even be considered, we'd need to know more details about their marriage. How do you know Andreessen won't be richer - courtesy of his growing tech wealth - than John Arrillaga before John passes away? The money isn't in tech? Just ask Gates, Bezos, Zuckerberg, Ellison, Page, Brin, Powell Jobs, Ballmer, Allen, and Dell how that works. Now compare them to the dozen or so richest real estate tycoons in the US.
- bradleyjg 9y agoWe would have been much better off if politicians left housing alone and just cut checks to the people they are buying off with all the interventions into the housing market. Of course that would run into the problem that people love to push for giveaways from the government but want it to be slightly obfuscated so they can tell themselves stories about how they never got anything from anyone. Witness the uproar over "you didn't build that." Rent seeking is a fact of life, I can accept it. But the hypocrisy and self righteousness of some rent seekers just drives me bananas.
- Dirlewanger 9y agoI don't know shit about real estate, be it property taxes or zoning laws. From my dumb angle, I see it as metropolitan markets across the country going crazy because of the decade-long-or-so trend of people moving to cities. In simple terms, what are governments doing/not doing that is causing such ridiculous costs?
- wbl 9y agoBanning housing construction in "cities" through hight limits.
- francisofascii 9y agoIn retrospect, the problem is the US has had poor property tax policies. Property tax should be based on 1) the land square footage and 2) the value of the location. If a lot is double the space of normal lot, the tax should be at least 50% higher. If the price increases sharply, the taxes should as well. This way large lots sizes and price fluctuations would stay in check. The property taxes in SF, by the way, are way too low for the current value and square footage of the lots.
- epistasis 9y agoProp 13 has hugely restricted the ability of municipalities to tax land. Despite being sold as keeping the elderly in their home after retirement, that's a tiny subset of what was actually covered in the law. I agree that a more Georgist tax policy is in order, but fixing Prop 13 is pretty tough. It gets older residents really really riled up when changing Prop 13 is mentioned.
- s73ver 9y agoWith decent reason. There is no, and I really mean no reason why someone should be forced out of their house due to rising property taxes. That's just not what taxes should be used for. Really, it should have applied to one's primary residence, and that's it. Maybe the primary office of a small/medium business.
- guntars 9y agoI don't think people who rent have a right to complain about the housing market. If there's a toxic spill across the street, they can just pack up and move. They also can't complain about gentrification of "their neighborhood" since it's not really their neighborhood, they're just visitors.
- jahewson 9y agoYeah it's the investor's neighbourhood! Despite the fact that they live in a fancy part of town in some other city, or in China, or they're a corporation. Screw the people who actually live there. It's not like they are the neighbourhood. /s
- guntars 9y agoThere's no need for snarkasm. You don't have to be a Chinese investor to buy an apartment. I simply have no sympathy for people who rent long term: 1) They can take off any time. A new job? A market crash? No problem, just pack your stuff and leave. 2) Someone else is doing all the maintenance and dealing with building codes and paying all the taxes, etc. Because of the inherent risk in owning a home and the effort required to maintain it, it will always be cheaper to buy than rent. If someone likes their neighborhood, but isn't willing to commit and put in the work, they deserve what's coming for them.
- styrophone 9y ago>it will always be cheaper to buy than rent. That's decidedly untrue. In many markets you can make the case that conservative assumptions result in a cheaper buy option. However, the Bay Area in particular throws that calculus in reverse for many neighborhoods and property types. Your argument seems to rely on the premise that buying is monteraily cheaper in the long run as long as you're willing to put in nominal sweat equity and risk. And that labor buys you some sort of citizenship that money, for the same amount of tenure, does not. The Bay Area market does not reward that puritanical ethic.
- 9y ago
- joshe 9y agoIt is not a conspiracy or an inevitable consequence of growth. It is not because of the concentration of wealth (also a problem!). It is because there is not enough housing. There are many kinds of restrictions, some you probably agree with. Most of the restrictions are popular with liberals, conservatives, Democrats, and Republicans. Restrictions like: * must build parking per housing unit * zoning restrictions to limit density * long approval processes for construction * many blocks to construction approval even after complying with all the restrictions This is a bipartisan problem, it's really a culture problem. It's understandable, even on the micro scale. When you move into a place (and are done renovating it), you'd prefer that the neighborhood never change and that no one does any construction in it. There's a little tinge of atavistic fear of strangers too, even though people are moving in and out of neighborhoods all the time. In 1960, San Francisco population was 740,000. 50 years later in 2010 it's 808,235. The east bay and peninsula have been as reticent about housing. Despite wanting to live in SF and ending up in San Mateo once they get there they don't want anyone to build anything - no more density. Despite wanting to live in the mission/noe valley/haight and ending up in the less dense sunset once people get there they vote against more housing. The solution is more housing. Transit oriented development (denser zoning and no parking requirements near transit), allowing people to convert illegal inlaws to legal apartments, converting garages into apartments, and allowing people to add stories to their homes are all possible good moves. Maybe there are some of those you don't like, but each one we don't do is less housing and higher costs. And when you do vote for more housing you are getting: * cheaper housing * less climate change * less pollution * less homelessness (because homes) * less inequality (housing costs are a regressive expense) * a more prosperous city (you personally will have more money) * a more interesting city (you personally will have more interesting restaurants and things to do) You think that cute 4 story victorian in Noe looks cool? Maybe make it legal to build it anywhere in the city or bay area. The whole sunset and richmond are filed with 1 story single family homes. Even pretty dense mission/noe/haight have lots of individually low density properties. Regionally why not let people build 4 story houses with apartment flats anywhere along caltrain or bart? But does it work in practice? Check out Tokyo: https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3c60 https://www.ft.com/content/023562e2-54a6-11e6-befd-2fc0c26b3... (SF resident)
- 1024core 9y agoInflation of housing costs wouldn't be that big of a problem if we had cheap and fast public transportation. I live in the Bay Area, and I've seen families forced to move further and further from the area to afford a reasonable house and good education for their kids. The problem is, now they have to commute for hours, driving in sub-optimal conditions to get to their jobs. Imagine if BART charged a flat $1 fare? Or if the Caltrain ran every 15 minutes from 5AM to 1AM and charged $1/ride? Then living far away wouldn't be that bad. But we're getting squeezed from both sides here: sky high housing costs, and terrible commutes on gridlocked "highways".
- DrScump 9y agoOr if the Caltrain ran every 15 minutes from 5AM to 1AM and charged $1/ride? Then you'd have absolute gridlock at all unseparated crossings (e.g. Castro Street, Rengstorff, Menlo, Redwood City, etc. Those would have to be separated first.
- mojomark 9y agoThis article speaks to regional income convergence. However, national wages, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics data (1) for Usual Weekly Earnings (parsed by education level in particular) show clear divergence - along with a clear dissappearance of the middle class. Perhaps regional economies are simply settling down and catching up to the economy at large (I'm not implying that wage divergence is good or fair - it just seems to be what is happening based on BLS data). 1. https://www.bls.gov/news.release/wkyeng.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/wkyeng.nr0.htm