25 ms·
The Old Are Eating the Young
- ar0 9y agoNote that the article makes a crucial assumption: That all those unfounded future liabilities (most of which are pensions etc. I assume) of governments are fixed and cannot be changed. This isn't true, though: By changing the law, those unfounded liabilities can be erased at the stroke of a pen. What does this mean? That these staggeringly high numbers (if true) do not necessarily mean doom but "merely" that at some point people will find out that the pensions they have been promised won't be there when they reach retirement. (I.e. what the people in Greece are currently painfully experiencing will eventually hit others, too - one pension cut after the other until little is left.) This doesn't necessarily affect "future" generations, though: Those that will pay for it is the generation that lives through the cut, i.e. which has paid into the system before the cut but was due to receive money only after the cut. This can very well be a generation that is alive today. Edit: Just to clarify - the article conflates these financial liabilities with environmental damage. Just to avoid confusion: obviously, environmental degradation cannot be erased with the stroke of a pen, the above is only talking about the financial side of things.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Joe-Z 9y agoBeing born and working in a country with a strong social system, this is just another positive for my current lifestyle: Just earning enough to sustain myself and paying only minimal taxes so as not to waste anything on benefits I will never get back! Now I made myself sad...
- a_bonobo 9y agoIf everybody behaves like you then the above comment becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy...
- deusofnull 9y agoMaybe, but the blame for this situation can't only be placed on the young who see the system failures approaching. Maybe a system built to provide care to its creators is fatally flawed if it is largely dependent on the consent and participation of children and unborn people of the future? At which point I would like to point out that this world can likely provide for everyone were the economic ideology focused on sustainability and maintaining (at least) baseline human resource needs instead of demanding permanent growth, potmarked by boom-bust crises every 10-20 years.
- ruirr 9y agoI was also born in a country "with a strong social system". The so called social system is in shambles, and contributing to it is basically contributing to a ponzi scam.
- taejo 9y agoI think that's what grandparent is getting at. Better to make use of the social system by working little or not at all, now, while it's still paying out, than to contribute now and not get any pension later.
- usuallybaffled 9y agoHow can it have a strong social system with minimal taxes?
- kgwgk 9y agoI think his point is that he avoids paying high taxes by not earning much.
- danbolt 9y agoDo other people feel this way in regards to social benefits? At least in my line of work, earning more money has much higher value than earning less and having assistance.
- markvdb 9y agoAn example from Belgium. Imagine you're an employee and earning 38k€ a year including bonuses. Now you want to start a side activity as an independent contractor. You pay about 53.5% of taxes on this amount. On what is left after taxation, you pay 20.5% social contributions that you get literally nothing in return for. If you choose the cheapest "social contributions" provider. That means you get to keep about 36.96€ for every 100€ in pretax profit. Don't you think this steers people in different directions?
- ENGNR 9y agoWouldn't the equivalent contractor wage factor those costs in though, plus a risk premium for short term work ideally
- jpttsn 9y agoWhat makes you think it would?
- RugnirViking 9y ago
- Roritharr 9y agoI have to agree. I see this attitude in ever increasing numbers of German developers as our High-Tax System even openly admits to all the benefits you won't receive. The amount of taxes one has to pay compared to the security one is offered feels strongly out of whack for the 60-200k/yearly family salary bracket. There is braindrain, but also Stockholm Syndrome. I oftentimes see discussions between developers where ones that have left Germany's system get attacked behind their back for being so "irresponsible" and missing out on security systems here, while enjoying, after about two to three years of saving money elsewhere a lifestyle of financial security that is leagues above everything the german social security can offer. There are lots of reasons to stay in Germany, but social security and finances aren't ones if you are a talented developer that is just looking for a good life. It's a strange tension currently, I'm unsure where this will lead in the long run.
- tushartyagi 9y agoCan you please explain a little more? I always thought Germany (and Scandinavia) to be a strong economy where although you pay a lot of taxes, the returns are extremely well in terms of childcare, hospitalization, etc.
- ido 9y agoI assume they compare it to upper-tier high-tech hubs like Silicon Valley, Boston & Seattle - where a software developer can earn well into 6 figures (and double or more of what they'd earn in Germany). But I suspect this is mostly limited to those and very few other cases (e.g. top tier doctors).
- timr 9y agoYes, but for how long? And what happens after you're put to pasture? You can earn a lot more in the US when you're young (or at least, mid-career), but you'd better hope and pray that you never get sick, or laid off in late-middle age. I've never lived in Germany, so I don't know the problems with their system, but the US system is (currently) a "get yours while the getting is good" approach to life.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoIn the former USSR, people were still getting their promised 60 rubles per month pensions. It's just that inflation had eroded the value of each ruble to where the government had no problem paying such an amount. (Later, however, the government did increase many pension payments, from total penury level to grim survival level.)
- mseebach 9y agoThey're on to that one. All of the "interesting" liabilities are indexed to one (or more - in the UK three) inflation measures.
- J-dawg 9y agoAnd yet the pledge to link the student loan repayment threshold to average earnings was reversed almost immediately. https://www.theguardian.com/money/2016/nov/22/student-loans-fight-over-disgraceful-freeze-on-income-threshold https://www.theguardian.com/money/2016/nov/22/student-loans-...
- pjc50 9y agoPensioners have historically voted more than students and young people. If you don't participate in the process, you don't get fair treatment, unfortunately. This seems to have improved somewhat in the 2017 UK election.
- DanBC 9y agoOnly 57% of 18-19 year olds and 59% of 20-24 year olds voted. https://yougov.co.uk/news/2017/06/13/how-britain-voted-2017-general-election/ https://yougov.co.uk/news/2017/06/13/how-britain-voted-2017-...
- crdoconnor 9y agoIt's not like the consistent Tory voting pensioners were safe either. They tried to axe triple lock, the heating allowance and institute a new NHS tax this time around. The heavily indebted young only voted in droves this time around because for the first time there was actually a party that actually represented their interests. Both pensioners and students would be a lot more screwed right now if the left wing of the Labour party hadn't effected a successful takeover and shifted the overton window.
- gnicholas 9y agoIn some jurisdictions, pension guarantees have constitutional protections that may not be erasable by simply passing a bill [1]. While an amendment to the constitution (the CA state constitution, in the case cited) at issue would fix this problem, getting such an amendment passed would not be easy — at least not while many pension recipients are still alive and voting. Senior citizens generally turn out to vote more than other groups, and when their pensions are at risk you can bet they'll show up in force. 1: http://reason.com/blog/2016/11/30/california-supreme-court-will-determine http://reason.com/blog/2016/11/30/california-supreme-court-w...
- jk2323 9y ago"In some jurisdictions, pension guarantees have constitutional protections that may not be erasable by simply passing a bill." You would be surprised what bills can be passed. The 3rd Reich ("Nazi Germany") was supposed to last one thousand years by the way. It didn't. And in the end laws won't enable to circumvent the laws of nature (limited resources).
- pmontra 9y ago> Note that the article makes a crucial assumption: That all those unfounded future liabilities (most of which are pensions etc. I assume) of governments are fixed and cannot be changed. This isn't true, though: By changing the law, those unfounded liabilities can be erased at the stroke of a pen. Easier: default on the debt made by previous generations. No law required. If only one country defaults it's going to be hard for them, because the future lack of trust and the inevitable retaliations. If a large enough number of countries default, it's different. The problem is that if they default and start borrowing money again then it will be in vain. Some debt is inevitable (think mortgage to buy a house) but debt for everything is too much despite being convenient: get the money now instead of with next year's taxes and possibly get as much money as the larger country next door (a competitive advantage but be wary of interest rates.)
- nostromo 9y ago> Easier: default on the debt made by previous generations. Previous generations didn't leave us with much debt. Half of the debt is from post-2007. 85% or so came after 1990. Previous generations were actually good stewards compared to today.
- kingkawn 9y agoNot if they led us toward this
- anth1988 9y agoGee, who was in charge since the 1990s.
- throwaway2048 9y agoinflation distorts these numbers pretty massively. Especially when you consider something like "quantitative easing" to actually be causing massive inflation, but not visible to consumers in anything except housing, health care and education (all three are not tracked by typical inflation indicators either). The reason that traditional indicators are not being touched is that money is being sucked out of peoples pockets by the aforementioned three factors faster than printed money can inflate them.
- TuringNYC 9y ago"at some point people will find out that the pensions they have been promised won't be there when they reach retirement." One might argue this has already happened in the US, just subtly. Inflation (mostly ZIRP driven) has been very high, and is a hidden tax on those with fixed incomes. Perhaps headline inflation indicators are not high, but just look at the largest component of spending (rent) and you realize how difficult it must be to live on fixed pension payments. As a double whammy, seniors who tediously saved money hoping to earn interest income in their later years, find that income yield is near zero. This doesn't even consider the other major component of spending (healthcare)...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- notacoward 9y ago> Inflation (mostly ZIRP driven) has been very high Totally untrue. In 2013-2016 inflation was lower than at any time in the last half century. 2017 has been a bit higher, but still lower than all of 1967-1996. Sure, you can cherry-pick a particular commodity in a particular market to make it seem otherwise, but momentary or local fluctuations in supply and demand aren't really inflation. Inflation is a systemic phenomenon, and it's actually at historic lows. The fact that some people make life choices that subject them to rising costs doesn't really have anything to do with inflation. http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-inflation-rates/ http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-in...
- lotsofpulp 9y agoWhatever inflation is being measured should be linked to the choices people are making, otherwise what is the point of measuring it? You need to get higher education, at least bachelors if not masters level, in order to secure a decent income. The cost of this higher education increases at a ridiculous rate, and it's one of the biggest purchases a young person makes. Then you need to live near a city, the bigger the better. That's where all the jobs are and since work is much more fluid, you need to be where there are many employers. Also, you the advantages of networking capabilities in cities will give you a shot at going big. Living costs near large cities have also increased at a rapid pace, whether it be a home or rental. If you're going to have kids, you want them in the best schools, so you pay high property taxes or pay for private school. Best thing you can do to increase the odds of financial success for your kids is to make sure they go to school with other rich kids and have an wealthy network. Then you get start getting sick and need medical care. This is also one of life's huge, unavoidable expenses. There is absolutely no way inflation is low for you if you depend on certain medicines, just read the headlines, the price could skyrocket anytime if the patent holder chooses to.
- jk2323 9y ago"What does this mean? That these staggeringly high numbers (if true) do not necessarily mean doom but "merely" that at some point people will find out that the pensions they have been promised won't be there when they reach retirement." This is true. And since money, debt and energy are interlinked, it is very possible that there will be a cliff that we are approaching. Only two questions remain: 1. When? 2. How deep will we fall? "There is No Steady State Economy (except at a very basic level)" http://ourfiniteworld.com/2011/02/21/there-is-no-steady-state-economy-except-at-a-very-basic-level/ http://ourfiniteworld.com/2011/02/21/there-is-no-steady-stat... Limits to Growth–At our doorstep, but not recognized http://www.resilience.org/stories/2014-02-12/limits-to-growth-at-our-doorstep-but-not-recognized http://www.resilience.org/stories/2014-02-12/limits-to-growt... Wealth And Energy Consumption Are Inseparable http://www.declineoftheempire.com/2012/01/wealth-and-energy-consumption-are-inseparable.html http://www.declineoftheempire.com/2012/01/wealth-and-energy-... Galactic-Scale Energy http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/07/galactic-scale-energy/ http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/07/galactic-scale-e...
- _pmf_ 9y ago> That these staggeringly high numbers (if true) do not necessarily mean doom but "merely" that at some point people will find out that the pensions they have been promised won't be there when they reach retirement. (I.e. what the people in Greece are currently painfully experiencing will eventually hit others, too - one pension cut after the other until little is left.) Not only Greece; it's the same in Germany. People who have worked their whole life sometimes have a lower pension than they would receive if they would apply for welfare.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> By changing the law, those unfounded liabilities can be erased at the stroke of a pen. True. However, the problem is: doing that will land a government in a world of trouble. Firstly, the popular unrest. While in my country, it seems that most people under 30 don't believe the government pension scheme will survive to our retirement, people older than that do hope for their promised pension. After all, that's what they worked so hard and paid so many taxes for. Pull the rug out from under them, and my bet is you'll have riots in the streets[0]. Secondly, loss of trust. Kill off something as big as a pension scheme, and good luck in convincing next few generations to believe you if you want to reinstate it again. -- [0] - Related - many young people will join too. While I fully intend to support my mother in her old age, if the government decides to take away her retirement money, I'd be pissed personally too - after all, they'll be impacting my finances as well. Also related: that's why the loss of low-skill jobs by automation can't be ignored by people with high-skill jobs. Because after all, when your father, uncle, sister and closest friends will find themselves unemployed, who will they ask for help?
- Brakenshire 9y agoThis is one of the major reasons why the UK Conservatives just lost the election, they attempted to 1) Maintain the ratio of working life to retired life by increasing retirement age in proportion to increased life expectancy. Which meant increasing retirement age to 67 by something like 2050. 2) Reduce the triple lock of pensions - which means the state pension rises by a minimum of either 2.5%, the rate of inflation or average earnings growth, whichever is largest - to a double lock, which only includes the latter two elements. 3) Means test the payment of winter fuel allowance, which is a yearly payment of about £300 made to everyone above a certain age, so that it would not be received by wealthy pensioners. 4) Put in place what was effectively an inheritance tax for payment of social care (i.e. care homes and in-home care) after death, which is currently both criminally underfunded and also massively expensive. In combination, this is something like £15bn each year of extra spending now, rising to £50-70bn each year within the next 30 years. All of these measures were opposed by Labour, and their most enthusiastic supporters are the young.
- 9y ago
- coldtea 9y ago>What does this mean? That these staggeringly high numbers (if true) do not necessarily mean doom but "merely" that at some point people will find out that the pensions they have been promised won't be there when they reach retirement. That's enough doom. What other "doom" would there be?
- mseebach 9y ago> What other "doom" would there be? That what little you might have saved/your house is worthless because of inflation and/or punitive taxes. That the economy crashes so you can't take a job/stay on the labour market longer to make up, and your kids, if you have any, won't be able to help you because they have no jobs. That the heath service won't be there, so you risk adding sickness to poverty. Crime and civil unrest.
- crdoconnor 9y ago"Note that the article makes a crucial assumption: That all those unfounded future liabilities (most of which are pensions etc. I assume) of governments are fixed and cannot be changed. This isn't true, though: By changing the law, those unfounded liabilities can be erased at the stroke of a pen." Ultimately this becomes fight between funding the liabilities (taxing the rich once again) and eliminating the liabilities (screwing the poor pensioners). No politicians intent on slashing pensions would ever admit that it's a choice, though, just as they wouldn't admit that it was a choice to make the liabilities unfunded in the first place. That's why consent for these policies must be manufactured, which in turn is why this article exists - to foment intergenerational strife.
- Shivetya 9y agoTwo future obligations are important, the social security and medicare provisions but one is worse Many public employee pensions are in trouble is the idea of pension spiking and double dipping. pension spiking comes about by saving up sick and vacation time and cashing it out at retirement or taking on extra shifts. double dipping occurs where they retire from one qualified job and get into another though this has mostly been seen on the political side. You can end up for 100k retirees which is absurd on any level. the trouble facing reform is there no set outcome in courts. some courts have allowed government to reign in costs and others have forced it back on the taxpayers to make up. California law has been towards and reduction is one category has to be made up in another. Illinois just keeps digging the hole as their State Supreme court has basically stomped on all attempts to fix. The unions representing many government employees are very strong and politically active and if they cannot stop changes in court political intimidation will be the rule. the will simply work to unseat anyone who doesn't play ball. even the threat of reform by changes in party who runs the state brings out tens of millions of dollars and all sorts of shenanigans (look at Minnesota)
- usmeteora 9y agoyeh, I work in clean energy, and I'm all about it, which is why casual conflations or assumed relationships like this are irking, because all it does it add to the pile of things parties that still want to reject climate change get to point to show how many arguments are lacking in substance, this being one of them. I guess its true just about as much as any other correlation can be made with anyone who purchases anything. The more valid and underlying issue I thought would be focused on here is the baby boomers who have paid off their houses, have nice pensions waiting for them and refuse to retire after living 30+ years at the same job, while our generation has to re-educate ourselves 3-4 times over throughout our lifetimes (the first time in college being 500% more calibrated for inflation than baby boomers paid to go to college, many of who didnt need to go to get a good job) and change jobs every 7 on average years to stay relevant and avoid being too niche to niche ourselves out of career growth, which is the opposite approach of most baby boomers, relocate to follow our industries and/or navigate around jobs where we find out there is not career progress for the next 15 years because our superiors won't retire, or require a large amount of effort to navigate around their informaiton hoarding habits to maintain job security. This along with the fact that as our generation is laden with college debt and switching jobs to stay relevant, the few who can manage to pay off loans, afford to livei nc ities where the good jobs are and set aside money for buying a home, are competing with baby boomers for starter homes as baby boomers downsize after kids graduate from college, so now many jobs, even most engineering jobs outside of software have us held back from higher positions and catalyzing change due to baby boomers, and their cash offers make it impossible for promising young couples or individuals to mortage houses. The icing on top of the cake is the passive comments I hear from baby boomers about how we are narcissistic and lazy. I know these are human beings, and they aren ot to just be thrown out as soon as it bcomes inconvenient for society, but moreso than ever I experience a bigoted increase of hatred for our generation couples with a lack of acknowledgement for our hard work, increase in adaptability and refusal and resistance to wanting to grow in any way to even slightly accomodate our generation, and justifying it all under the broad stroke that we are all wasting our lives away taking selfies, and our retirement funds away on avocado toast and urbanoutfitters clothing, most of which is untrue and irrelevant to the group in our generation that works harder and longer hours and puts more time and money in our education to earn stagnant wages, and for those less educated our age who don't have jobs, they have top struggle with being their own brand and selling themselves or personalities in the service industry because there are no factory jobs to send young men of low education into, and I'm sure the baby boomer generation would be experiencing the same issues if factory jobs were not there en masse waiting for them as well.
- usmeteora 9y agoyeh, I work in clean energy, and I'm all about it, which is why casual conflations or assumed relationships like this are irking, because all it does it add to the pile of things parties that still want to reject climate change get to point to show how many arguments are lacking in substance, this being one of them. I guess its true just about as much as any other correlation can be made with anyone who purchases anything. The more valid and underlying issue I thought would be focused on here is the baby boomers who have paid off their houses, have nice pensions waiting for them and refuse to retire after living 30+ years at the same job, while our generation has to re-educate ourselves 3-4 times over throughout our lifetimes (the first time in college being 500% more calibrated for inflation than baby boomers paid to go to college, many of who didnt need to go to get a good job) and change jobs every 7 years to stay relevant, relocate to follow our industries and/or navigate around jobs where we find out there is not career progress for the next 15 years because our superiors won't retire, or require a large amount of effort to navigate around their information hoarding habits to maintain job security. This along with the fact that as our generation is laden with college debt and switching jobs to stay relevant, the few who can manage to pay off loans, afford to live in nice cities where the good jobs are and set aside money for buying a home, are competing with baby boomers for starter homes as baby boomers downsize after kids graduate from college, so now many jobs, even most engineering jobs outside of software have us held back from higher positions and catalyzing change due to baby boomers, and their cash offers make it impossible for promising young couples or individuals to mortage houses. The icing on top of the cake is the passive comments I hear from baby boomers about how we are narcissistic and lazy.
- collyw 9y agoIts avocado on toast that causing all their problems. That and iPhones.
- OliverJones 9y agoPension liabilities are, no doubt, big. But other unfunded large scale liabilities include loans, infrastructure maintenance costs, student loans, household debt, health care costs, etc. Basically all the stuff that turns into daily cash outlays in the Sim City game.
- mcv 9y ago> Those that will pay for it is the generation that lives through the cut, i.e. which has paid into the system before the cut but was due to receive money only after the cut. This can very well be a generation that is alive today. I suspect I'll retire after the cut, but I'm glad I got out of the pension funds before the cut. I have a kind of private pension fund for freelancers, which, if I understand correctly, is technically already my money, so it can't be looted to fund the retirement of someone who retires before I do. I am sad to see the solidarity of pension funds break down like this, and I feel a bit guilty that I'm leading the charge, but that solidarity has to go both ways. Expecting future generations to pay the entire bill for the greed and mismanagement of today, is not solidarity; that's exploitation.
- brazzy 9y ago> I have a kind of private pension fund for freelancers, which, if I understand correctly, is technically already my money, so it can't be looted to fund the retirement of someone who retires before I do. Wrong. The only difference is that your pension fund will not be "looted", it will have to cut its payouts because its investments don't yield the same returns as they did before. Inflation will do the rest. Private pension funds and investments are no more sustainable or "honest" than public pensions. The underlying problem is the same: the currently working population has to produce the goods and services for themselves as well as for pensioners. If they cannot produce enough of something, some people won't get that thing, and it doesn't matter what some numbers in accounts say.
- mcv 9y ago> The only difference is that your pension fund will not be "looted", it will have to cut its payouts because its investments don't yield the same returns as they did before. Inflation will do the rest. Only if the economy goes down and inflation goes up. At the moment, inflation is low and the economy is growing. My problem is not so much that I'm exposed to the whims of the economy, because that's unavoidable. My problem is when I need to pay extra so others don't have to feel the whims of the economy while I get to feel it double.
- InTempWeTrust 9y agoLets just vote on that. Nobody has the intention to build a anti-statistical wall. The youth would never escape the loving hug of the last generation.
- Qantourisc 9y agoI don't know who to blame here: the people for allowing this mismanaged of future problem, or the politicians doing the mismanagement. As I just said this morning: "The reason you have to work longer before you get to retire is because the state failed to save and put aside the money required. And they have known for years this was coming." Lets hope we do better on global warming or other catastrophes.
- papabrown 9y agoWho is to blame? Part of the original article is a lie (at least as how it pertains to the US). The social security system will eventually be unable to pay out at current rates. But notice how nobody worries about whether we'll still be able to spend 10x what everyone else spends on the military? A lot of this is about how we plan on spending our money. The current argument is framed as "if we don't change anything, this might happen" but the change everyone focuses on is the change in how much money goes towards satisfying the retirement savings. You notice nobody suggests buying less aircraft carriers or scaling back the military? Instead it's all about not reducing any other spending. Putting the spotlight on one particular form of spending and then declaring that if it can't pay for itself due to demographic changes, we should scare the shit out of everyone and privatize it and pour trillions of dollars into Wall Street.
- freeflight 9y ago>Instead it's all about not reducing any other spending. I'm even more amazed how many people think the welfare budget is supposed to stay fixed, not accounting for any growth in population at all, while military spending, going over budget, is considered the most normal thing in the world and leads to an increase in military budget.
- papabrown 9y agoI've always considered myself a fiscal conservative. Not the "let's cut all welfare" type of fiscal conservative but the kind who says, "Ok, we just found out that the Pentagon can't account for billions of dollars worth of equipment. Let's figure this out and try to use taxpayer money as efficiently as possible." I think if you cut all of the waste and abuse and held agencies to certain targets (i.e. 90% of taxpayer funds earmarked for education have to make it to the classroom level) you would free up enough money that you could actually create poverty programs that solved poverty. You could improve education without paying more for it. You could smooth out demographic shifts that challenge the social security system. The government is a big money sucking machine. It's not that we aren't paying enough taxes, it's that they're being spent irresponsibly.
- mathattack 9y agoHere's the thing... It is very hard to tell now if we've gotten our money's worth for the debt. Many things are much better today than 50 or 100 years ago. Longer lifespans, better health care, less pollution.... Was it worth the debt? Hard to say. Also - debt is just one person owing money to another. Yes someone today funded their consumption at someone else's expense. But guess what - someone tomorrow will get the dollar back to consume it. We can argue that as a country we will be paying for the consumption of others in the future, but is that so awful for the world's richest place? (And please note - this rant comes from someone who believes we should live within our means and balance the budget)
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoWe can't really "balance" the budget though, as there are just too many savings needs and the USA has become a debtor of last resort (which in turn is why the dollar is so strong and widely used). Money you need tomorrow can't really be saved under a mattress, someone has to "spend" it today, hopefully on something productive that will provide enough value tomorrow to pay it back. Saved money must produce growth, it has to be invested in someway, even if it is just invested in ultra safe but low interest government bonds and treasuries. If everyone lived within their means, but still needed to save money, we'd all be screwed. These are wild imbalances one sees in china, where the lack of a safety net and sky high housing prices means one must save much of their income, dragging down consumption and leading to easy money for SOEs, who then often spend it unproductively.
- pitaj 9y agoBy balancing the budget we wouldn't be getting rid of debt, we'd be stopping the growth of debt. Ideally, debt should grow at the rate of inflation, but there can be some large spending times and some low spending times. Debt shouldn't be larger than a significant portion of the economy.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoWe already have mechanisms to control debt accumulation: raise interest rates if we want to borrow more and lower interest rates if we want to borrow less. Interest rates have been rock bottom, negative if inflation is considered, and the US government has been practically paid to borrow via Treasuries. > Debt shouldn't be larger than a significant portion of the economy. Are you referring to just public debt? It really depends again on saving needs. It really isn't that simple. Debt in itself isn't bad, default on debt is bad. If you had to choose between debt and a depression, unless you are Hoover, you will choose debt.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- havetocharge 9y agoWhen I was young, I used to love articles like this. Now that I'm old, I think they are stupid.
- edejong 9y agoEmpty statement. Back up why you thought they were loveable and what makes them stupid now.
- mythrwy 9y agoThat statement doesn't need backing up. It is self contained, and speaks directly to the nature of human opinion.
- edejong 9y agoBut it doesn't add any depth to the discussion. I'm sure everyone has specific positions on how the article makes them feel. However, HN is about getting to know different standpoints which have a certain amount of profundity to it. Just saying: "I like this", or "I used to like this", doesn't give any substance.
- mythrwy 9y agoAs I understand the statement's intent, it has layers of depth and is concisely profound. It speaks directly to (IMOP) the root of the problem the article talks about.
- edejong 9y agoWell, I can think of a couple of reasons why the OP thought it is stupid now: - He understands the article is preaching to the choir. - He thinks the article does not take into account the total flow of capital. His better understanding of economics makes him understand this now. - The article does not cite any sources. - It (apparently) is a common theme that older plebians tend to vote more conservative. Perhaps he is referring to his changing political position. - Without dialogue, these articles are fundamentally empty. They do not help different actors come together. - The article is using various framing devices to make it appealing to a certain audience. The OP currently feels exalted from this pleading to the hoi polloi. - Due to the effects of filter bubbles and targeted psy-profiling, the OP has unknowingly narrowed his vision, causing him to label the article stupid. Which one is it? I'd like to know because I might be missing the point here. So, my point is: I can create many layers of depth by just using my imagination. But that doesn't add anything to the discussion. I could say I'm a post-post-modernist or a holistic a-structuralist, which might capture some depth and raise some questions, but it does not allow for any kind of true dialogue.
- shubb 9y agoA large part of this article discusses future liabilities, but makes no mention of growth. For instance, it says total UK liabilities are 1000 times gdp, but past gdp growth over the same duration those liabilities are amortised over is 3000%. Past performance would suggest this seeming over committed will simply be eclipsed. There is no guarantee gdp will keep going up, either globally or in particular countries, but it does indicate that, growth is the way out and we should places our bets there. As recent small state low tax economic policy has failed to deliver growth like we saw under bigger state higher tax policy, maybe we'd be richer if we reverted to that.
- bambax 9y agoGrowth is exactly like Jesus. Some people strongly believe it will return, despite strong evidence to the contrary. And we're all cargo-culting around it, changing laws, reducing taxes, opening borders to lure it in, like if growth was a wild animal afraid of fences. Meanwhile, old people live the good life of having revenue without doing anything productive. Good for them, but I'd resent them less if they didn't vote for Trump, May, Le Pen.
- shubb 9y agoNow that's a little pessimistic. Look at the graph: http://www.ukpublicspending.co.uk/spending_chart_1950_2010UKb_11s1li011lcn__UK_Gross_Domestic_Product http://www.ukpublicspending.co.uk/spending_chart_1950_2010UK... Exactly what would make the next decade special compared to the last 5? If lack of growth is unusual then expecting it to return would seem rational. Have faith brother!
- cjg 9y agoThis log version might be better: http://www.ukpublicspending.co.uk/spending_chart_1950_2010UKb_11c1lo011lcn__UK_Gross_Domestic_Product http://www.ukpublicspending.co.uk/spending_chart_1950_2010UK... You can see the S-shape in the curve. We hit peak growth in the 1970s and it has been slowing since.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoSome parents are generously allowing their children to live at home rent-free. Mine are not. They provided me with an education, but in fact that was a scholarship from the institution my dad works at, not their own generosity. Young people are better-educated, well-travelled, and more aware of the world than ever before. But old people control the Human Resources department. To protect themselves, they keep changing the rules to keep us out. HR demands years of continuous work experience, not only a degree. The result is that we settle for low-paying entry level jobs. We can't afford to have children. Instead of seeing this as a problem, I consider it a weapon in this war of generations. I'm denying my parents the joy of grandchildren. Pension funds take money from young people and pay it out to old people. I have no hope that the fund will still be around by the time I'm able to retire (and the retirement age is probably going to increase anyway). A similar thing can be said about insurance. Therefore I think that young people should boycott pension funds. The system is not working for us, so we should not pay into it. We must continue to pay taxes because of legal requirements, but all other financial services are biased towards an older generation. The worst part is the inequality that will come when the older generation finally pass on their inheritances. Some people will be very rich. My parents promised me that I will not receive any inheritance. So I will be poor. The instability and debt is likely to lead to a war. It wouldn't surprise me if the USA decides to fight China about the huge debt they owe the Chinese. And who will die in the war? Young people. We really need to see this through. (Anthem Part 2 - Blink 182)
- sien 9y agoThe US has a huge trick they can pull with debt. The US borrows in its own currency. Ultimately, if the US government debt burden becomes to large it can choose to print money to print itself out of debt. There are huge costs involved in pulling these sorts of tricks, but it's far cheaper than a nuclear confrontation with China. The Chinese are also well aware of this and don't just buy US treasuries for their own reserves.
- stephen_g 9y agoMost advanced economies are in a similar position - having their bonds denominated in their own currency and having a central bank that can never run out of that currency. The Eurozone are an exception, which is probably going to cause the currency to eventually collapse, but that's another story. There aren't really 'huge costs' to paying down debt with new money. People assume that it would cause problems, but when you look into the mechanics of how both central banks and commercial banks work, some things become clearer. The first thing to note is that the money supply is actually constantly expanding, even without the central bank creating money, because new money is also created when central banks issue loans (see [1] for an explanation from the Bank of England, central bank of the UK). So money creation by itself is not inherently inflationary. Inflation actually happens when aggregate demand over some period is greater than the amount of goods and services produced in that period. Money creation generally does add to aggregate demand, but so does all spending in general (i.e. increasing the velocity of money). So, if money creation is properly managed (to keep it from adding too much to aggregate demand), then it can be done without any inflationary consequences. But that only applies for a Government creating money to spend. Changing bonds ("debt") into central bank reserves is actually asset-neutral. The bond is an asset worth a certain amount that can already be bought and sold. Replacing it with central bank reserves makes it more liquid, but doesn't actually add new assets into the system. Of course, there's not much point to paying down bonds like that. Since the Government can't run out of its own currency, their bonds are basically meaningless. Since the gold standard was dropped, they exist mainly because the private sector likes having a zero-risk asset to invest in. What really needs to happen is to stop pretending that bonds and taxes actually finance Government spending, which hasn't been the case since 1971... 1. http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/quarterlybulletin/2014/qb14q1prereleasemoneycreation.pdf http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/quarte...
- chrismealy 9y agoSome days it's robots taking all the jobs, other days it's who's going to take care of all the old people. Come on people, just pick one. Unless you count hoarding canned food, you can't really save for the future. You can acquire claims on income in the future by buying stocks or bonds or whatever, but that income will have to be produced in the future, produced by young people working. Old people have always been taken care of by young people. The illusion of the financial system can't change that. There are relatively more older people now than there used to be, but on the whole that's a good problem to have, because people are living longer and have more control over their lives. The best way to deal with an aging population is to guarantee a decent standard of living for the young, so people don't have to wait until they're pensioners to enjoy income security.
- rayiner 9y agoAt least in the U.S., we can rationally worry about both things at the same time! Social Security is bankrolled by a tax on labor income. Robots, however, produce capital income. We could easily be in a position where millennials have limited employment because of automation but nonetheless carry the burden of supporting the baby boomers in retirement.
- averagewall 9y agoYou seem to be contradicting yourself. Unemployed but working to support old people? That's employment. Not all jobs have to be in factories. Why can't elder care be a booming industry that sucks up all the unskilled labor left behind by automation? The customers are the very people who can afford it the most.
- trelltron 9y agoYou don't understand the premise. The Parent is pointing out that taxation of working people is used to fund the care of others. Low (human) employment breaks that system. Having a large pool of potential workers is meaningless if there is no money to pay them for the work, or to pay for the other necessary elements that go into that kind of care.
- rayiner 9y agoI'm as salty about baby boomers as the next guy, but it's a bit ironic that millennials don't realize that they'll be screwing the next generation over even harder. We are in the position we are in now largely because baby boomers didn't have enough kids to support them in their retirement.[1] But millennials are having even fewer kids. When millennials in western countries can no longer work, who will take care of them? Can they count on an endless supply of young immigrants raised and educated on foreign taxpayers' dimes? [1] In the past, people had children so someone would be around to take care of them in retirement. Financialization of that process decouples the specific children from the specific retirees, but does not otherwise change the basic dynamic that there has to be a working generation to provide for the retired generation. You can't eat money in your 401k.
- flukus 9y agoNot really, the biggest problem with the baby boomers aging was the "boom" part, there were a disproportionate number of people in that generation. Gen Y may be having less kids, but there will be less of them to support in retirement and the next generation might even get cheaper housing as the population shrinks.
- nopinsight 9y agoBy the time millennials retire, around 2045 and later, robots and AI are likely advanced to the level that they could take care of the old and produce most necessities of life. The labor needs of that future world would likely look quite different from what most of us envision now.
- rayiner 9y ago2045 is about as far into the future as the first episode of "Seinfeld" is in the past. Unless a black swan event happens in AI development, the world will look pretty similar to how it does today.
- nopinsight 9y agoAs a counter anecdote, one can also say that just 10 years ago, no computer systems came close to human at facial recognition or scene recognition for still images. Today's AI systems can caption events in videos. [1] Researchers are also working on higher-level cognition tasks. We do not know for certain if there will be breakthroughs but there are many diverse tasks that seem within reach in the next 10-20 years. What are human capabilities that you believe AI/Robots in 2045 will still likely be lacking? [1] Dense-Captioning Events in Videos "...We introduce the task of dense-captioning events, which involves both detecting and describing events in a video. We propose a new model that is able to identify all events in a single pass of the video while simultaneously describing the detected events with natural language.... " https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.00754 https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.00754
- mythrwy 9y agoHome values appreciating out of proportion to salary increases are another way this is occurring. Discussed a couple of weeks ago. It's great someone who works as a bus driver bought a home 40 years ago and it's now worth a mint. For that person. For the young person wanting a home now it's a very bad situation.
- techsupporter 9y agoI read an interesting comment thread on a Seattle-oriented forum the other day: It was a thread about some landlord something or other--the topic isn't all that important, just that it brought up the classic landlord-versus-tenant debate--and someone made the comment that a sizable contingent of landlords in Seattle are one- or two-unit (usually standalone house or townhouse, but sometimes condominium or duplex) owners renting out places where the landlord previously lived. The point was that tenants should be more predisposed to give "landlords" as a group a break because many landlords aren't corporate real estate trusts. A person replied to take issue with that statement and made a what I thought was a good point. He or she pointed out that all of those houses that are being owned by a small-time landlord and subsequently leased out are houses that are out of the pool of available properties for people to own and, possibly, redevelop into more dense or different housing styles. Ownership and renting in this way contributes to the upward spiral of housing prices: a person has owned a house in an area for a while and then moves out. Instead of selling, that person rents out the house while, in all probability, having purchased another house in the same area. As the first house's mortgage is paid down by outside rent, the small-time landlord has even less incentive to sell because, hey, "free"[0] money. Lather, rinse, repeat for an entire metro area and it's just as good a contributor to tight owned housing availability as the specter of foreign investors swooping in or people moving from other regions of the United States. And it reduces the pool of houses that could be used for someone to buy[1] into a market. 0 - I know that being a landlord incurs costs and that not all landlords, especially small landlords, make money on the deal but many obviously do because to do otherwise would be financially foolish. 1 - There's a really good argument to be had about whether or not ownership of one's residence is a good thing for society at large. I happen to think that yes, it is, but that the pool of "culturally acceptable residences" must be expanded beyond "detached house with fenced yard, large driveway, and bountiful on-street parking directly in front of the structure." Point being, people want to have stability in where they live and there's a wide gulf between "5,000 square foot minimum lot size" and "downtown condominium high-rise" that is not being served in many metropolitan areas.
- AnthonyMouse 9y agoA promise from the government to pay you something in 30 years is inherently a promise to take the resources from your children, because there is nowhere else for it to come from. It doesn't help anything to have the government hold its own bonds; then your children inherit the debt instead of the unfunded program. It's the same number of dollars no matter what you call it. And you don't want governments holding other investment assets because the government choosing what to invest the money in would be the world's strongest corruption magnet. > Rather than reducing high borrowing levels, policy makers use financial engineering, such as quantitative easing and ultra-low or negative interest rates, to maintain them, hoping that a return to growth and just the right amount of inflation will lead to a recovery and allow the debt to be reduced. This is a misapprehension of the relationship between debt and inflation. Inflation is how you reduce the real value of the debt. It's effectively a tax on dollars, and it reduces the debt on both ends: If the government creates new money then it can spend that instead of borrowed money, and if the value of the dollar goes down then the value of each outstanding dollar of debt goes down. But none of that changes the problem with retirement benefits because, again, the government holding its own bonds is self-canceling. The only thing inflation might "help" there is to allow a reduction in real (inflation-adjusted) retirement payments without a nominal cut. If you want the same real benefits then you need to collect that number of real tax dollars, and if you won't or can't collect that number of tax dollars then you have to pay lower benefits.
- pmontra 9y ago> A promise from the government to pay you something in 30 years is inherently a promise to take the resources from your children, because there is nowhere else for it to come from. Not a big deal: those people helped their parents, their children will help them. It's fair and it's what happened for tens of thousand of years: people knew they must have children because without children they'll be pretty much without any support when old. However it works when the number of children is substantial. It can't work with 2 or 1 children per couple and that's where most of the western world is now.
- mjevans 9y agoYet increasing the population will also lead to either war, or the destruction of the environment to the point where none can survive.
- baybal2 9y agoPut your money into a full reserve bank, there quite a few around. I have an account with one of such. It also makes sense to open a "metal account" in some offshore bank abroad (remember, US was prohibiting its citizens from buying gold less than 50 years ago)
- lordnacho 9y agoWhat should have been done was to make some precautions for the inevitable. There was always a good chance at the start of the various welfare states in the last century that people would live longer. Why didn't they say "we'll pay pensions to the oldest X% of the population" or "we'll pay x% of GDP to the oldest people, according to living standards of the time"? Instead we have societies where people feel entitled to be pensioned at a specific age. And it's very hard to change that age, while at the same time they become a larger and larger voting block.
- dmoo 9y agoIreland raised the age at which people are entitled to a state pension. It's moving from 65 to 68. https://www2.deloitte.com/ie/en/pages/deloitte-private/articles/increasing-state-pension-age.html https://www2.deloitte.com/ie/en/pages/deloitte-private/artic...
- lordnacho 9y agoIs the proportion of people being taken care of higher or lower than when the system came into being? I get that a lot countries are aware of the issue, but moving a fixed age to another fixed age does what the article says: it kicks the can down the road.
- dmoo 9y agoYes, but the road has a stop sign.
- GrumpyNl 9y agoNot true, as long as we can keep the money printing machines working.
- kartan 9y agoShort term thinking pays off and has been favoured by evolution, so human beings have a strong bias to choose short term benefit over long term gains. Local maximums, or even cul-de-sac paths that are good in the short term but fatal in the long one, are chosen by short term gain maximization. To overcome this bias, we need better education of the general population - the ones that vote and choose our future - so they understand the situation. About pensions, it is ridiculous to compare "working people"/"pensioners". The correct comparative is "production capacity"/"pensioners needs". Comparing the output of an employee from 1970 with a 2050s one (the future they talk about) makes no sense. About climate change, and general environment protection, the article is spot on. We ripe the benefits while future generations pay the cost. That's the only reason we destroy so much to get so few, because we don't pay the cost.
- groby_b 9y agoI wonder if anybody ever has thought of a solution... why, we'd need massive growth (to increase the tax base), a reduced population, and the ability to completely eradicate some debts. As if you were removing the people who lent you money in the first place. You know what fits that description? A bit of war. And that's exactly where we're heading. (Middle East is not going to get better. Refugee numbers will become staggering as climate change destabilizes even more countries. Russia has its eyes on Ukraine and the Baltic states. Europe is militarizing to counter that. Pakistan/India is about the same as it ever was - so, precarious balance, with nukes on hair trigger. China would like nothing more than a Greater Asian Co-Prosperity Sphere. North Korea is about as bonkers as the US)
- perilunar 9y agoYeah, but we want to reduce the population old people, not young people. Maybe an intergenerational war.
- tremon 9y agoStrictly speaking, we want to reduce the ratio of nonproductive vs productive people. Culling the old is not the only way to do that, and certainly not the best. (edit: and we definitely need better language. "nonproductive" need not be synonymous with "having an income to support oneself", since there's still many productive activities that are not rewarded monetarily)
- thriftwy 9y agoEven productive old people can't bear children. Even non-productive young people can bear children. If you "cull" young people (by war) you make the problem worse by having even smaller working-age population later. Of course you can lose and have incoming invading horde which may solve the problem, FSVO "solve".
- polskibus 9y agoRent-seeking is getting stronger and stronger because money is getting cheaper and cheaper. Those with good credit lines get ahead of the poorer ones and force them to pay them rent. I wonder if a reset like 2007/2008 is coming.
- mjevans 9y agoIf there is a reset I hope it's actually effective at fully deflating the bubbles this time.
- zanny 9y agoI think this is much closer to the issue. It is not about solvency of the global economy as a whole - that is absurd, there is so much loose capital floating around in corporate coffers and the stock market and HN is just a testament to how relatively loony ideas can still get millions in rounds. The real issue is the dramatic wealth divide that has been growing worse over time, which bleeds into capital ownership by the rich as a means to extort rents from the poor. It doesn't matter what generation you are from - these debts exist not just to pay for past generations but to keep the current ones under foot of the wielders of the capital. Debt isn't just some evil force from the shadows, it is a business run for profit as the ultimate rent seeking, and is wholly intentional.
- skybrian 9y agoI'm skeptical of purely financial measures of this. It would be nice if we could distinguish between purely financial "savings" versus real-world actions that might actually make things better in the future. For example, there's such a thing as perishable resources. You can't "save up" labor; if people are unemployed now (and not doing something useful like going to school), that doesn't mean there will be more labor available in twenty years; it's just gone. Sunlight or wind power not used now is gone; it can't be saved for later. And even the things that can be saved often have storage or maintenance costs. Finance makes it seem like you can save for your retirement or pass on wealth to your children, and that's true for individuals but only to a limited degree for society as a whole; the labor you use in twenty or forty years will come from younger people who are working then. Call it a ponzi scheme if you like, but this is the only way it can work. On the other hand, natural resources are the opposite; oil or natural gas can be left in the ground as long as you like, and it's cheaper to leave it where it is than to do anything else with it. There are also long-term investments in people (education in particular) that could pay off later with a better educated workforce. Instead of deferring infrastructure maintenance, we could do it before it's needed, possibly freeing up future labor to do something else. Scientific research done now can come up with new techniques that will always be useful.
- Von_Jones 9y agoIs it any wonder this is happening when the central organising feature of our political, economic and personal lives is a huge ponzi scheme? This reality has destroyed the possibility of changing a system to benefit all. This ponzi scheme is the housing market: since the late 90s this has ceased to be a true market, and instead became a pyramid scheme in which value growth and price is based on the expectation that money will be sucked in from new investors, not derived from the utility of house-ownership or expectation for yield. This is the very definition of ponzi - and it governs so much of our lives. Why are the young and the old so segregated in their voting? It's because they are either the beneficiaries of or the 'bigger suckers' in this state-sponsored fraud - and can be mobilised accordingly. Until the housing market is dealt with, it will be impossible for politicians to create policies which 'grow the pie', increasing wealth for all, rather than simply carving it up - governing by robbing Peter to pay Paul. The only solution I can see if for the young to organise to boycott house purchase, but I am not yet sure how realistic this.
- metalliqaz 9y agoHousing is just now starting to emerge from a huge correction. Despite all the bullshit surrounding housing, it is still a functioning market. (meaning, prices are set by scarcity and demand) There are still inequalities there but it's not nearly as big an issue as the debt discussed in the article.
- TheCoelacanth 9y ago> prices are set by scarcity and demand Scarcity which is artificially limited by zoning and demand which is artificially inflated through near-zero interest rates.
- lpaone 9y agoI have a theory that may not be popular around here. I also probably have not thought this through and researched it enough, but I will throw it out there anyway. I would love to have it torn to shreds by someone who has studied economics or more likely this is something that has already been extensively researched. It seems to me that real sustained economic growth cannot happen without population growth, at least the way things work right now. Efficiencies gained through technological innovation and financial manipulation cannot sustain growth indefinitely, they just smooth out the bumps and with population growth help increase the rate of economic growth. And without economic growth, we are going to keep running into these issues and others brought up in the article. Look at Japan, no amount of economic/financial manipulation has really helped them. Their main economic issues stem from the fact that there are not enough young people. Aside from epidemics/catastrophes, there has almost always been sustained population growth through human history. It is in our nature to multiply and expand. I feel this is why so many people are fascinated with space and space colonization. The current demographic trends in western society is unprecedented and in my estimation, I do not think it will end well unless someone finds another solution, or these demographic trends are reversed. Feel free to rip apart my theory. I would love to hear what someone with a better understanding of this area has to say.
- ianai 9y agoI think we covered this in my Econ courses.
- flushandforget 9y agoWhen you have population growth (or non-native settlers), they prop up the old. It's a pyramid scheme.
- tu7001 9y agoApparently, we are too stupid to maintain civilization...
- ucontrol 9y agoWhile your comment may seem simplistic, as years pass and as I study human history in more depth, I'm afraid that I'm beginning to nurture that exact sentiment as of late. It seems that Western civilization was not an inevitability, but a lucky roll of dice (or unlucky, depending on who you ask). On average, we are not as intellectually capable as our civilizational accomplishments may indicate, quite the contrary. Seeing the missteps that we keep making, looking at our shortsightedness and our inability to act collectively towards long-term prosperity.. It's just depressing. What bothers me the most is the degree of such incompetence. It should't be so widespread.
- roflc0ptic 9y agoI know we don't on usually quote poetry on HN but there's some apropos Bad Religion - "I've got this one problem where I live forever // I've got just a short time to see." The human mind is not apparently built for thinking at the scales (sizes, time frames) at which humanity operates. The limited distribution of competence is an amoral phenomenon - as a first approximation, I like to think about it as a natural consequence of limited information transfer between generations. Should or shouldn't is beside the point.
- kaonashi 9y agoI liked this piece which touches on many of these issues: http://www.ianwelsh.net/the-basic-psychological-structure-of-our-society-does-not-work/ http://www.ianwelsh.net/the-basic-psychological-structure-of...
- Tepix 9y agoWhy are pension funds not changed (gradually) so that i get my own money back (+interest) instead of paying the pension for current retirees? It's blatantly obvious that not changing the system will lead to issues as the populace grows older.
- kuschku 9y agoThat’s how they worked originally. WWII killed that concept. Now in the past decades people switched to private pension funds, which do that, but that doesn’t fix the inherent issues with the system.
- JonCox 9y agoNom nom nom
- tempodox 9y agoThis effect isn't new. Before antiquity, Greece had lush forests. Then, they cut off all the trees to build ships so they could fight their wars and conquer the world. And Greece has been a desert ever since.
- OlivierKessler 9y agoTheory which is largely challenged today.
- tempodox 9y agoWhere would they have taken the wood for their ships from?
- OliverJones 9y agoHey, fellow older folks in the US! Wanna do your part to help deal with this problem? Wanna do it without all the trouble of getting organized? Use some of your wealth to pay off the education loans of a younger friend or colleague.
- freeflight 9y agoThis is especially bad in Germany where the introduction of the Euro pretty much split the earning population in two. Around 1990 the average retirement age in Germany was 60 years, retirees also got way more money (they still do) because back then people still earned proper wages and the retirement is based on prior income. Since the introduction of the Euro real wages in Germany have kept on stagnating while living costs kept rising and live expectancy also increased. This has lead to the absurd current situation where (old) retirees make up the bulk of the upper-income levels in Germany, while younger generations are not even sure they will be getting any retirement at all down the line, as German government keeps increasing the retirement age (67 years now, estimated target being at least 69 years) while decreasing the amount of retirement money people actually get. The worst part is that a lot of this is based on the naive assumption that life expectancy is gonna keep on increasing and people can stay "productive for longer", like we are all gonna be able to work till 70+ by 2030. But nobody answers the question that actually matters in that regard: Where and as what are all those people supposed to work? And why should any businesses hire a 60+-year-old guy vs hiring from a flood of overqualified, eager, and cheaper young folks?
- aramas 9y agoLooking at youth unemployment rate (44%, 38%, and 25% in Spain, Italy and France, respectively), you will find how serious this issue is. It's not only about young people's job skills.
- return0 9y agoThere's also the sociocultural aspect of it. Weak and economically dependent youth -> conservative values, avoidance of confrontation with parent generations. There is no such thing as the rebelious spirit past generation, and this is prominent in millenials.
- tomohawk 9y agoI had a conversation with a retired person. They were upset that they had to pay taxes to support schools. Yet, they expected me to pay for their retirement in a system that I'll likely never see a penny of. This retiree had an income well above the median, and was at the same time getting full social security benefits. Regardless of age, people will take and take if they're allowed. Unfortunately, we've built "safety nets" that enable this behavior.
- clarkmoody 9y agoThis is a fundamental problem of democracy: a voting minority uses the government to extract wealth from other portions of the population. Just look at the comments in this thread. Tons of "us" vs "them" when talking young vs old. We would not be divided without the government exacting the will of the voters on portions of the population for the benefit of others. Instead of uniting us, democracy divides us.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoAusterity NEVER works. It's small minded and looks solely at the debt instead of the investment. IF we get debt for a billion dollar highway system but that highway system helps the country make billions of dollars over the time of the loan. That is called an incredible investment. Greece, Kansas, Louisiana, etc have austerity governments and they are falling apart. Investment pays off dividends...whereas austerity kills.
- Scea91 9y agoGreece is not falling apart because of austerity government but but because of the ones before that which were the opposite.
- nickthemagicman 9y agoOk..given that's the case. There are lots of governments who run high debt levels and aren't in that quandry. The debt isn't the problem. It's misuse of the debt that's the problem. Even most companys run standard levels of debt every quarter, because borrowing is a very powerful tool IF USED CORRECTLY. So, there's a significant distinction there, the I feel less educated and less economically inclined people fail to grasp.... Debt can be a very positive tool if used correctly.
- Scea91 9y agoI actually agree. The problem is that it feels to me that governments use debt incorrectly far more often than companies. I believe that it is because the current political systems reward short-sighted populistic debt more than long term investments which are often unpopular. As a consequence, austerity is often the only option for countries that obtained lots of debt irresponsibly.
- mcv 9y agoA couple of years ago there was a discussion in Netherland about increasing the retirement age from 65 to 67 because babyboomers were about to retire and the working population that would pay for it would shrink. (Also because people live longer; increasing retirement age is not unreasonable in itself.) But because increasing retirement age just in front of people who were just about to retire would be too big a shock, it was decided to increase it slowly over a period of years. The end result is that all the babyboomers can still retire at or near 65, but it's the younger generations that have to keep working longer to pay for the boomers' retirement. In the mean time, the mortgage crisis has undermined pension funds, which in some cases meant everybody had to chip in extra so the babyboomers could retire the way they were originally promised. I have no idea where this is going, but I'm glad my retirement savings are actually my money rather than part of a fund that can be plundered or mismanaged by others. Dutch retirement funds are among the strongest in the world, but these past couple of years have seriously hurt people's trust in them. I'm all for solidarity, but the solidarity has been a bit one-sided lately.
- greedo 9y agoJust because it's "your money" now, doesn't mean it will stay that way permanently. In the US during the last decade, there's been talk of plundering 401k accounts...
- mcv 9y agoThat's exactly what I'm talking about. When it's my money, that plundering becomes theft. When it's not actually my money until it's paid out, I have less control over it and rules may be changed so it can be plundered. In the past I've heard plenty of stories about American companies looting retirement funds in ways that would absolutely be illegal in Netherland, so even if I'm part of a big fund, I'm probably better protected than an American. But even that protection might not be enough if I can be required to pay extra.
- ryan606 9y agoThe baby boom generation, as well as the "Greatest" generation before them, have saddled our future generations with huge liabilities. Sadly, not every younger Gen X'er, Gen Y'er, Millennial, or Gen Z'er realizes the magnitude of the debt left behind -- and more importantly that it reflects future tax increases or government services that won't be able to be provided. The only hope is that the current generations will have accumulated enough personal assets to pass along to their kids and grandkids to offset some of this deficit.
- jerianasmith 9y agoI don't think old are really eating the young. To me, this intergenerational conflict is exaggerated. As technology improves and so is human life span, we all have to face this when we become old.
- fithisux 9y agoThe article cites no scientific evidence (references), follows no scientific methods and can be regarded as biased. To strengthen my point, the articles compares 5.3 / retired in 1970 vs 1.6/retired in 2050 without taking into account automation or scientific / technological progress. The analysis is therefore unsound.
- kaonashi 9y agoMore like the rich are eating the poor.