16 ms·
Americans Hold Over $4.1T in Consumer Debt
- omilu 10y agoCombine low wages, increasing loan delinquency, and the probable start of trade wars with mexico and china and I can't see how this doesn't turn out to be like 2008 on steroids.
- jdavis703 10y agoNot sure why OP was being downvoted. I just bought a new truck, financed mostly with an auto loan. I couldn't remember or provide half the information required for the loan application and was told "don't worry about that." I still got approved. Another story, I recently changed rental apartments. My "credit report" was a page I printed out from a consumer credit reporting site, where I could've changed any data. My point being, all this loose validation seems very remiscnet of the easy money that was so common pre-Great Recession.
- holydude 10y agoCheap money is vital to the economy. I know that the market is different in the EU but look at what is happening in Germany and Greece. You would not want that.
- gillianlish 10y agomassive endemic fraud is not vital to the economy... although it is vital to destroying an economy.
- cylinder 10y agoVital to an unstable, bubble prone economy. Long-term sustainability is not enhanced by cheap money. What we want is clever money.
- stuart78 10y agoSame experience for me on a recent car purchase. Dealer didn't particularly want a down payment, which made me suspect that they are being comped on loan volume when financed through manufacturer, a choice I opted for because the % was 2 points lower than my bank.
- matwood 10y agoNot even in the same ball park as 2008. Auto loans are a lot easier to recover than a home loan. If you don't pay your auto loan they just come pick up the car. Then they get to resell the car again. This is completely different than a home loan in both value, and the process for the lender recover the collateral. Home loans right now are still very tight. I had to provide more documentation for a simple refi with the same bank, than I had to provide in 2011 when I purchased the home. When I asked why, they responded that regulations have continued to tighten since them. When dogs can get a 500k home loan and then sell the house a month later for 600k I might start believing we are back in 2008.
- gillianlish 10y agoalso "subprime financial products bundled together and resold as low-risk investments to massive institutions" combined with "moral hazard" of said institutions knowing they will be bailed out again by the taxpayers when the speculative bubble bursts. also Student Debt cannot be forgiven in bankruptcy so you essentially have an entire generation of indentured servants who will never actually own property outright.
- idiot_stick 10y ago>also Student Debt cannot be forgiven in bankruptcy so you essentially have an entire generation of indentured servants who will never actually own property outright. This is an issue, but can vanish with the stroke of a pen.
- vwcx 10y agoA pen being wielded by a man with no desire, or knowledge, or forethought, to do so.
- pm90 10y agoYou are forgetting that if large enough section of the population is wronged/backed into a corner, they are going to protest/rise/riot. It certainly seems to be heading that way...I would be seriously worried if I were one of these student loan companies that are giving loans to people with no prospect of getting paid back.
- twoodfin 10y agoStudent loans are now almost entirely held by the taxpayer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- IshKebab 10y agoDoes America really have low wages? Granted, the lack of a minimum wage is crazy, but the median household income is $56k. Compare that to £23k in the UK.
- tzakrajs 10y agoAre suggesting that the US does not have a minimum wage?
- maxxxxx 10y agoA lot of people don't have guaranteed retirement benefits, education is expensive and sickness can cost you a lot of money any time. When things go well you can live well in the US but things can go bad quickly.
- adventured 10y agoThat's also true in many other developed nations in regards to education, such as Canada, Japan and Britain, which have between moderately and very expensive education systems. Britain for example now has arguably the most expensive university costs: https://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/nov/24/uk-has-highest-undergraduate-tuition-fees-in-industrialised-world-survey-finds https://www.theguardian.com/education/2015/nov/24/uk-has-hig... "Britain has the world’s most expensive public university tuition fees, surpassing the average in US equivalent institutions. While student fees can be higher at many ivy league and other top colleges, the £9,000 annual charge for attending an English institution pushed the British average above the US’s public colleges for the first time, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development said." http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/62a1d4e0-9213-11e5-bd82-c1fb87bef7af.html http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/62a1d4e0-9213-11e5-bd82-c1fb8...
- grandalf 10y agoMore likely we'll see more forms of non-dischargable consumer debt. This is debt which is not discharged when someone declares bankruptcy. Every time you hear a politician advocating more student loans (rather than more affordable higher ed), one of the reasons they do this is because student loans are non-dischargeable. Think about someone who is 18 and takes on lots of debt. There would be very little reason not to declare bankruptcy, and just live off of wages for 5-7 years until the bankruptcy is cleared from his/her credit report. With the housing crisis, most debtors also owned some equity in the house, which was a massive incentive not to foreclose, yet many still did. But with consumer debt there is no downside. You can just choose not to pay it. The collections industry uses some marginally-illegal tactics to create personal embarrassment, but that's where it ends. With an auto loan the car can be repossessed, but you can pay your rent using a credit card or buy a new TV every few months and if you fail to pay back the debt nobody is going to force you to give up those items. As with education, once the money has been used nothing the creditor does can take away the item, which is why the debt had to be made non-dischargeable. I think we can look forward to a new class of non-dischargeable consumer debt which will initially be sold via lower interest rates, but will become the sort of debt that college campus credit card pushers will mainly be slinging. There is really no political opposition to this anymore, now that both parties are so strongly aligned with the finance industry. I'd also expect to see the credit report become something somewhat more like a "trust dossier" that would routinely be viewed by employers and other entities we all work with who do not typically view the data, and would include things like TSA precheck status, IRS timely filing information, immigration status, etc. There's a reason debtors prisons used to exist, which is that the human optimism that can get us through great hardship can also tend to lead many humans to be overly optimistic about their ability to repay debt. It takes a very firm hand to create compliant borrowers. In the US, the older generation views missing a credit card payment as a really big (and embarrassing) deal, but the younger generation does not care as much about this. The occupy movement was a backlash against the shackles of student debt, but was shut down relatively efficiently. The next iteration has fewer principled objectors but a lot more debt cynics who view consumer debt more as something to be exploited.
- dpweb 10y agoDefaulting isn't a big deal even to the banks. They can just price it into the product. What would be interesting though would be credit offerings, cards for instance, that are not dischargable, but with better terms or interest rates. My concern though is mandating classes of debt as non dischargable by law, banks wont necessarily pass the savings along to the customer, so the laws should allow certain types of debt to be dischargeable but subject to your agreement with the bank. So you get a non dischargeable card at 2 pts less than the normal one.
- adventured 10y agoLow wages? The US has among the highest wages on the planet. To go with nearly the highest GDP per capita and nearly the highest disposable income levels. The US has higher wages than: the UK, Germany, France, Sweden, the Netherlands, Finland, Austria, Belgium, Spain, Portugal, Japan, Taiwan, South Korea.
- tradersam 10y agoTrue, but considering with that high income no education assistance, medical insurance, or job-loss insurance, you can easily half the average income and then see actual disposable income.
- DenisM 10y agoOne man's debt is another man's financial asset.
- hack_edu 10y agoWith this attitude, you might as well just give all your money to the bankers now and just be done with it.
- 1001101 10y ago... and it's gone
- idiot_stick 10y ago>With this attitude, you might as well just give all your money to the bankers now and just be done with it. With what attitude? Having knowledge of accounting, and that the balance sheet has two sides? If anything, ignorance of finance is how you give your money to the bankers.
- mightybyte 10y ago> If anything, ignorance of finance is how you give your money to the bankers. I don't think it's quite that simple. It's probably some combination of a number of factors such as: * Inability to control one's spending * A consumer-driven culture where status is equated with material possessions * Availability of easy credit * Society not recognizing compulsive spending as an addiction
- gillianlish 10y agowhich is the taxpayers "troubled asset" which has to go into a "Relief program" which somehow translates into Socialism for the hyper-rich and indentured servitude for everyone else.
- throwaway2048 10y agowhen you default you lose your home, when they default they get a trillion dollar cheque from the government, and 10 million dollar performance bonus.
- to3m 10y agoSecured on wasting assets, the promise of future earnings, or nothing at all. What could possibly go wrong? (On the bright side this is far from the majority of debt.)
- idiot_stick 10y ago>What could possibly go wrong? Americans are the wealthiest people in the history of mankind. Fortunes ebb and flow, but there isn't much to worry about.
- bdcravens 10y agoDepends on your definition of wealth. Defined as "amount of time you could survive with no income", most Americans (including many in the HN crowd) aren't very wealthy at all.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoOnly if they insist on keeping their current (very high compared to most people in history) standard of living. A median American could survive at the standard of living of a medieval peasant indefinitely on their current assets.
- handojin 10y agoYes, but it would require one to possess a marked fondness for worms.
- purple-again 10y agoAmericans Hold Over $4.1 Trillion in Consumer Debt and Roughly $90.0 Trillion in Asset Wealth doesn't quite have the same ring to it.
- purple-again 10y agoLet's also keep in mind the population is still growing so just like the game of "Highest grossing movie of all time!" title you see every year, it's not surprising at all that total debt numbers are increasing. We need debt per capita to be alarmed.
- dpweb 10y agoThe debt is real, the wealth not necessarily. But a more telling measure would be debt per capita or debt vs liquid assets. The financial crisis showed us that 20 trillion can be erased relatively quickly. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/14/financial-crisis-cost-gao_n_2687553.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/02/14/financial-crisis-co...
- obstinate 10y agoThe debt is as "real" as the assets. All it would take to erase a good chunk of it is for people to stop paying or for significant inflation to occur, among many other possibilities. Edit: I'm not trying to suggest some kind of Fight Club-esque reorganization of society's financing structures. I'm just talking about the way that debt tends to get fractionally charged off when it goes to collections.
- mcguire 10y agoI wonder what the NCAV of the US is?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- coliveira 10y agoYou are conflating consumer debt, i.e., hold by consumers, with asset wealth, which is hold mostly by corporations and their owners. The first is usually carried by the poorest part of the population, since rich people have little need for consumer debt.
- slg 10y agoThe most dangerous problem with the housing crisis in 2008 was not the amount of debt. It was the feedback loop that was created by defaulting on that debt. Foreclosed homes naturally have a lower value than non-foreclosed homes. Homes are priced by looking at recent comparable home sales. If your neighbors to both your right and left have had their houses foreclosed on, the value of your home will go down. If the value of your home goes down too much, it becomes nearly impossible to refinance your mortgage (which was important due to all the crazy adjustable rate mortgages that were handed out in the preceding years). This leads to more and more foreclosures and worse and worse home values. That feedback loop does not exist with unsecured debt. If your neighbors to both your right and left can't pay their student loan, the value of your education will not go down.
- rlpb 10y ago> Homes are priced by looking at recent comparable home sales. If your neighbors to both your right and left have had their house foreclosed on, the value of your home will go down. Surely the lower valuation on your home is incorrectly low, though? Or is there some actual reason why buyers would want it less?
- slg 10y agoIt is a supply and demand problem. Your house is only worth what someone will pay for it. If the potential buyers have several cheaper foreclosed homes to buy instead of your home, the potential sale price of your home will go down
- coredog64 10y agoThe banks use "comps" to figure out the maximum loan value. Assuming the housing nearby as similar, their actual sale price provides the price signals markets crave.
- chrisabrams 10y agoComps have nothing to do with loan value. Your income, credit, and assets and debt decide what your max loan value is.
- mortehu 10y agoFor lots more data and charts, see New York Fed's quarterly report on household debt and credit: https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/interactives/householdcredit/data/pdf/HHDC_2016Q4.pdf https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/interactives/househo... Page 13 shows newly delinquent balances by loan type, and the trend doesn't seem too worrying. Page 11's "total balance by delinquency status" also seems to be heading in a good direction.
- mcguire 10y agoWhat happened to bankruptcies in 2006? They dropped significantly.
- NumberSix 10y agoThe United States has a total resident population (as of January 23, 2017) of 324,420,000 people (about 324 million). Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta... Thus, $4.1 trillion in consumer debt works out to $12,638 per person. The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in the United States was worth 18036.65 billion (about $18 trillion) US dollars in 2015. That is about $55,424 per person. Note that the "consumer debt" is divided into several categories. Student loans represent a long term investment and may be reasonably paid off over decades. Auto loans are typically paid off in 3-5 years. Ideally, credit card debt should be paid off immediately. It is difficult to evaluate credit card debt because credit cards have increasingly become the substitute for cash in the United States. How much of the debt is extremely short term and essentially represents what used to be cash transactions? What is "other" consumer debt -- payday loans? IOU's? The point is that $4.1 trillion in consumer debt in a nation with over 300 million people and a GDP over $18 trillion per year is neither unreasonable nor a crisis, particularly when that debt includes longer term items such as auto loans and student loans.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoOther consumer debt includes mortgages. I'm sure there were people making similar arguments about the health of the US economy before 2008. http://inflation.us/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/niareport84.jpg http://inflation.us/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/niareport84.j...
- mcguire 10y agoBoth of these statements are true.
- mathattack 10y agoYes. If anything, the bigger issue is national debt. It can be broken out into investments versus borrowing for transfer payments, but either way the #s come out much higher. And it's easier for consumers to walk away from debt in a bankruptcy than it is for a country.
- makecheck 10y agoThe trend is probably more important than the total. A single debt amount can be “OK” for one person but practically sink another person. The rate of bank-related expenditures should be measured instead. Add up all the ridiculous overdraft fees, the interest payments, changes in rates due to an ARM, etc. and one person’s financial picture could look quite a bit different than another for “the same debt” amount.
- helthanatos 10y agoHere's a few things that could ease student loan debt: make the interest rate less, use SS paid into while in college towards college, simplify all the federal student loans, etc. Seriously... I'm going to die before I get to use any SS...
- bbcbasic 10y agoDebt is money. Money is debt. You borrow money and it's fresh new money, expanding the money supply. If everyone pays back their debts, then (nearly) all of the money is gone. You don't have $1000 in your checking account. You have an IOU from the bank for $1000. You can then 'spend' the money by transferring the IOU to someone else. But it is never guaranteed transferable for something real. It relies on everyone else believing the $1000 has value, which they do, so you are OK.
- yuhong 10y agoMy favorite is government budget deficits. Take for example Medicare and drugs. Where does the money Medicare use to buy drugs comes from.
- bamboozled 10y agoHonest question here, does this actually matter anymore? Do economists see it as a positive, negative or neutral thing? When I hear about debt that big I wonder if $4.1T even a real thing. I mean is it a tangible number that actually represents something of real substance?
- cnnsucks 10y agoYes, it's real. Lenders have computers that sum lots of accounts; they're expected to do that and disclose how much they've lent. $4.1E12 isn't really that difficult to relate to. Just amortize it across the US population of 325 million. That's $12,612 per citizen. It's also about one year of Federal spending. It's a negative thing. Both individual debt load the and the rate of delinquency has been increasing, with student debt being the worst of these; if you can fog a glass you can make the Federal government send money to some school against your future earnings. There is probably no form of debt easier to assume in the US and upon this river of money floats a horde of careers, bonuses, pensions, endowments and gold plated benefits for The Great and The Good of academe, which makes questioning the value of it all a political third rail. What do economists think? They're watching the bubble grow and devising ever more contrived ways to pretend it's not a bubble.
- bamboozled 10y agoThank you for the response! I've actually been thinking about the implications of student debt for a while and it seems like a really terrible thing for a lot of reasons. I think it sucks people are forced into jobs they probably wouldn't otherwise do, just to pay off some debt. The only thing I'll say about your response is that, I frequently hear about "the bubble getting ready to burst", but it never seems to happen. Similar to radical increases in housing prices, they seem to just keep rising, contrary to economists predictions about a crash. It's a totally anecdotal observation, but it's the reason I asked the question in the first place.
- cnnsucks 10y ago>> forced There is no force involved; please maintain perspective. There are no debtors prisons filled with 20-something Berkeley graduates. Every penny of every student loan was voluntarily assumed by the debtors. The terms for much of this debt allow payments to be deferred based on income. The average amount of student debt being carried is typically less than the cost of a new car. We deal here with "first world problems." >> but it never seems to happen 2008? TARP? "Great Recession"? It clearly registers on every measure of economic activity I've seen. Rather hard to miss, really. You can have a look and the 07-08 collapse of property values over here if you missed it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_housing_bubble#/media/File:Median_and_Average_Sales_Prices_of_New_Homes_Sold_in_the_US_1963-2010_Monthly.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_housing_bubble#/...
- nashashmi 10y agoIMO, the biggest problem with so much debt is the amount of interest embedded in the agreement of it all. Let's say that the average interest rate is 4% and that none of the debt is double counted, e.g. one debt leading back to another debt at a different interest rate. The total interest revenue on the debt is $161 billion dollars. Where does that money come from?! It needs to pop up out of thin air, like someone needs to print it. If there is a question of why, I will explain. It is the same explanation I give to a banking specialist for my refusal to accept a savings account. Take a village of 100 people; the entire village has no money whatsoever, so they cannot trade or buy food or sell goods and services. A rich man lives on the top of a mountain and decides to lend a $100 to the entire village, which is $1/person, at an interest rate of 5%, and the entire debt is to be paid back in exactly 1 year. For the duration of that year, villagers are beginning to buy and sell, the economy is created and is moving healthily, villagers are working, products and services are being created, sold, and consumed. At the end of the year, $105 need to be paid back, but the entire amount of money in the entire village adds up to just a $100. Where does that $5 come from? Some villagers will have accumulated more than $1 and they will be able to pay back their debts and have some left over. But then also some villagers will have nothing. What do they lose? How do they fulfill their debts? The entire system relies on the introduction of additional money from somewhere. If so, then that entity loses money. This system is deeply toxic and works contrary to the one who borrows. And once all is added up, the net result is all money is removed from the system. Losers lose big. Winners hit net zero eventually.
- steveax 10y agoSee also: http://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2017/02/ny-fed-household-debt-increases.html http://www.calculatedriskblog.com/2017/02/ny-fed-household-d... (For some more analysis)
- dangerboysteve 10y agoThe number is 12+T when you factor in mortgage debt which should be factored in. http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-02-16/us-household-debt-rose-126-trillion-2016-biggest-jump-decade http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-02-16/us-household-debt-r...
- Garycooooper 10y agoIf you need to check on your partner’s sincerity,employee’s honesty,recover your email passwords,Social networks Institutional servers-keylogging -University grades changing / Admin(staff) Account hack -Access/Password Credit score increase Facebook, instagram, bbm,Skype, snapchat,zoosk, Various blogs, icloud, apple accounts etc Clearing of criminal records- Email accounts hack ( gmail,yahoomail,hotmail )Databases hack- Untraceable IP Change your school grades, *Gain access to bank accounts. Contact data Shaft via deepdatashaft@gmail.com9
- Garycooooper 10y agoI was able to raise my credit scores excellently with th help of Alpha tunnel they increased my credit score from poor credit and helped my nephew upgrade her school grade as well without any traces, His reliable and very good you will be grateful. Alphacredittunnel@cyberservices.com r he will definitely deliver.