25 ms·
Instacart is playing games with its workers’ pay
- hemantv 10y agoInstacart seems to be most overhyped company in delivery space.
- doctorpangloss 10y agoIs it possible to have a value-added services company that doesn't exploit its labor? Is your answer going to be self-driving cars? What about alternatives that don't fundamentally replace the labor? In my opinion, it is impossible to achieve venture capital goals and pay service labor commensurate to the value it delivers.
- pshposh 10y agoI think it's possible if the labor owns the company.
- doctorpangloss 10y agoSo then your answer is no, because then the venture owners don't own the company.
- pshposh 10y agoI didn't realize your comment exclusively pertained to venture owners. Even so a venture owner could sell the company to the employees and move on to their next big thing.
- doctorpangloss 10y agoYou're right that it's something a venture owner could do. But then, you'd be surprised at how many highly-compensated programmers never bother to exercise their options. The same ones who then go on Hacker News and complain about bad treatment of workers, and how if only they owned the companies.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI not only complain about how workers are treated, I'm also active in the political process to effect social change for workers. I've also exercised all of the options I've vested at the startup where I'm employed. Careful with them broad strokes Tex.
- pshposh 10y ago> But then, you'd be surprised at how many highly-compensated programmers never bother to exercise their options. The same ones who then go on Hacker News and complain about bad treatment of workers, and how if only they owned the companies. This reads like an oddly specific claim -- do you have examples?
- FussyZeus 10y agoIf the process is entirely automated and consistently deliverable? Sure. But then that's not really exploiting labor. For me, if I wouldn't be comfortable asking a neighbor who was less well off than me if they'd mind dropping off my laundry for $10 a month, I'm not going to do it via a shiny website.
- babesh 10y agoCostco and Trader Joe's workers supposedly get much more than minimum wage although not venture capital based. It isn't an economic law.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- wwalser 10y agoI think this argument takes a relatively small set of companies a generalizes their exploits across the larger economy. Isn't it the case that most service companies in the west do not exploit it's labor? The people involved in customizing your car configuration prior to it being delivered to the dealership are not, to my knowledge, exploited. Most laundromats in my area do bag service, those workers don't seem to be exploited. I feel sure that the list goes on. There are some common threads amongst companies that are exploiting their workers: 1. They are b2c companies. 2. Most seem to be venture backed. 3. The worker they employ are mostly unskilled. 4. The law doesn't seem view the current treatment of these employees as illegal in any way. #1 seems most significant to me, the price that a critical mass of consumers are willing to pay for the value that unskilled workers can provide seems to be too low to build a large business on the back of.
- doctorpangloss 10y ago> Price that a critical mass of consumers are willing to pay Sure, but Instacart is demolishing a very worker-popular tipping feature. That suggests that actually, there is a critical mass of consumers willing to pay more. The question is, why does it matter to Instacart so much that some consumers pay less than what they're willing to pay?
- wwalser 10y agoYour comment is 100% assumptions. > Sure, but Instacart is demolishing a very worker-popular tipping feature. That suggests that actually, there is a critical mass of consumers willing to pay more. Nothing about this article says that to me. Nothing. At least one worker has given this information to someone who tweeted the information whose tweet was picked up by recode. We don't know if tipping is "very worker-popular" we know that some workers asked the company to change it back and they half capitulated. I'm personally a fan of charging higher fees and paying all workers the same living wage. That's effectively what a static service charge does. > The question is, why does it matter to Instacart so much that some consumers pay less than what they're willing to pay? We also don't know that. Do you know what the average tip was on instacart before this change? So you know that a 10% static service fee is lower than the average tip before now? Do you know if brown workers were tipped less than white workers? Men more than women, the inverse? We don't have the information required in order to make the judgements that you've decided to make.
- tray5 10y agoProfit has to come from somewhere. You can't reimburse the workers the full value of their labour if you wish to make a profit. I'd say that counts as exploitation. Unfortunate, but thats the reality of capitalism.
- xapata 10y agoThe two inputs to production are capital and labor. You need to make profit by paying below market rate for capital (like a bank borrowing from the Fed) or by paying less than the value created by labor.
- emodendroket 10y agoSure, but there's some space between "full value of one's labor" and table scraps.
- tray5 10y agoOf course, but when the decision of where the workers pay is on that scale is taken out of the hands of the workers, it tends towards table scraps then full value.
- virmundi 10y agoIs value created by labor necessarily the only way to create value? Can labor by itself cost $10, I pay out $10, but when I combine that labor (a largely undirected force) with thought (scheduling, order placement, etc) I get a multiplier over the labor? It seems like it should be possible to do this. I pay for raw, undirected labor. It's like raw iron. When I use my skills for planning (speaking as the management for the company), I can pay full price for labor, but get synergistic effect not possible without thought? To keep with the iron reference, in the end I produce steel or even better a car. Seems like the labor to extract the iron met a multiplier of my metallurgic enhancements.
- thehardsphere 10y agoThe mistake here is the assumption that value comes from labor. Value is inherently subjective, depending on what the purchaser is willing to pay for, not due to intrinsic properties of whatever the good or service is. Suppose in your raw iron example, instead of making steel or a car, you make an inferior product because either you or the people who work for you are incompetent. Suppose you make the 1960 Chevrolet Corvair, a car so horrible that it inspires the book "Unsafe at Any Speed" by Ralph Nader. Even though nothing about the product or the labor used to produce it changes, your product loses value immediately because people don't want to buy a dangerous car. Your hypothetical multiplier turns negative overnight, even though your car is just as unsafe before the book as it was afterward. If the labor and your intelligence were the source of the labor, the value of the car should not change just because Ralph Nader says it's dangerous.
- spraak 10y agoIt's the same story as with other similarly modelled startups like Deliveroo and UberEATs (and maybe Uber itself), both of which have slashed their groundworker's pay significantly
- matt_wulfeck 10y ago> Instead of the tipping option appearing on the checkout page as it originally had, a default 10 percent “service fee” sat in its place. If I could take a guess, I'd say this is more related to the user experience. I hate tipping. I'd rather just attach a 10-20% fee instead of needlessly evaluating someone else's performance with every delivery. Or better yet, I'd rather just use a company that adequately pays its own employees instead of attempting to offload a portion of that cost on its customers.
- emodendroket 10y agoExcept the money goes in a different bucket than the tips did even though it's the same amount. And both the "service fee" and tip are adjustable.
- dawnerd 10y agoI feel like even if they paid their delivery people a reasonable wage they'd still expect tips. Ive had movers that made over 50/hour not including the cost of materials/truck/etc ask for a tip. I was all for Uber being tip free until drivers started driving for Lyft which does tips in-app, and now all the drivers expect it. I've always felt this way with Pizza. Most places charge a delivery fee. That itself should be the tip. If it costs more to deliver a pizza then work it into the price.
- mikeash 10y agoThe solution is to pay them better and forbid them from taking tips. Make it clear to customers that it's not even allowed, let alone expected. Unfortunately, I don't think tipping culture is going away any time soon.
- zachsnow 10y agoThere's a restaurant in my neighborhood that does this (no tips, built into the price) and I really appreciate it. It's so much "easier" that I'm more inclined to drop in.
- 10y ago
- tyre 10y agoThey have tens of thousands of customers, yet are worth multiple billions of dollars (valued at $2bn in 2015.) That's just incredible. Let's say they have 100k customers who each use the service every week. That's 5.2m orders per year. Let's say $100 per order, to be generous. At a 10% service fee, that's $50m for a two-year-old 40x revenue multiple. Before paying their contracted workforce. This does not make sense. EDIT What I'm really getting at is that these are optimistic numbers, in the wealthiest country in the world, that just elected a populist president (partially) due to economic insecurity. What is the market for +10% on groceries and basic necessities? EDIT2 It may be tens of thousands of contractors, not customers (thanks @trevyn!) This is confusing, since I'm not sure what verb to use for the end user on Instacart. ("I am _______ on Instacart" (consuming, shopping, grocing?)) Regardless, my number could be an order of magnitude off. I stand by the conclusion.
- hnarn 10y agoIt makes a lot of sense if you know how perverse financial markets are. The difference between those millions and those billions is the perceived potential of the company. All you need is some investment banker becoming convinced that noone wants to visit physical stores anymore, and suddenly money starts pouring into companies supporting that view of the future, almost regardless of whether they are actually profitable or are creating any real value.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thehardsphere 10y agoRight, so the question becomes "Why do enough people perceive the potential of Instacart to be billions when a back of the envelope calculation by a guy on Hacker News suggests that's not the case?" Presumably said investment bankers are capable of doing the same math as Hacker News readers, so why did they still fork the money over when they have many other crazy bets to choose from?
- MegaButts 10y ago
- lloydde 10y agoWhat problem was Instacart trying to solve here? I use Amazon Prime Now and Google Express, but don't really factor in the tip when I think how much Prime costs me. I don't make that many orders though, so maybe people feel it as an additional cost over time.
- wwalser 10y agoThe positive spin would be that it reduces friction involved in ordering and delivery payment. The original change didn't offer the ability to change the service fee. Under that model they offer one less decision point for their customers. The negative spin is that they wanted to capture some percentage of the tip money.
- username223 10y agoI'm poor enough to buy my own groceries, but if you're rich enough not to do that, then "tip"/pay your servants in cash.
- chipperyman573 10y agoIf you do that then only the driver gets the money, not the shopper. Plus, if the tip button worked as intended, why would it matter how you tip?
- username223 10y ago> why would it matter how you tip? Taxes. People are supposed to pay taxes on tips, but one of the things that lets people live on sub-minimum wages is not reporting tips. Tipping is BS, and I wish it would go away, but this is unfortunately how the US economy works.
- rdl 10y agoWow, that seems gratuitously dishonest -- especially misleading customers about what's a "tip" vs. a surcharge. Having an $x delivery fee (paid to the company) and then a tip as a separate item ($ or %) would be fine. Making the "delivery fee" into a "service charge" is itself dishonest; making it adjustable when it doesn't go to the user is pretty bad, too. I can't tell if this loses them more goodwill with customers or with delivery employees, but it seems like a bad decision either way.
- wwalser 10y agoHow is it dishonest? It's a fee for the service that one receives. You pay one amount for groceries and another for the service of those groceries being delivered. That's exactly what a service fee should be. Consumers should understand that services have a cost. Companies should charge consumers an amount that is commensurate with the cost that it takes to deliver that service (unless they operate in a non-competitive market in which case they are free to charge whatever their customers are willing to pay). If there are humans involved in providing that service, they should be paid a living wage. Tipping is the backward part of US consumer expectation. Not service fees.
- developer2 10y agoYou may have missed the part where the service fee is optional and can be removed, or replaced with a tip to the employee. The fact that the fee is optional, instantly makes it not a "fee". Service fees are not a discretionary addon that customers can choose to eliminate.
- NotSammyHagar 10y agoYes, you can set it to 0, but they are 100% trying to trick people into not tipping and giving instacart the money. At my neighborhood restaurant they eliminated tips and replaced it with a fixed service fee of 20% they give to the employees. It's common to call such things service fees and to think that goes to the end workers, instead of the corp. It's indefensible to say they didn't mean to trick people into thinking it was a tip for the delivery people.
- grandalf 10y agoI'm a customer of Instacart and a big fan of the service. It has saved me so many hours. The contract between a customer and Instacart is very simple: The customer picks out groceries and they show up at the door an hour or so later. Uber's decision to remove tipping was brilliant. Why impose additional uncertainty and friction into the work flow? Star ratings allow Uber to compensate top performers without creating an inconvenient friction point for users. Instacart's initial approach to tipping was to default it to 10% and force the user to change it. This was very bad UX. It not only takes extra time, but it was included during the checkout flow before you even know how good the service was. Star ratings (such as used by Uber) are way more powerful. People feel an archaic obligation to tip as is clear from the shaming tone of the linked article. But with ratings, customers have an incentive to be honest about the service, and the company gets to incentivize whatever qualities are most important to customer satisfaction. I've found that in restaurant tipping, most people are reluctant to tip below 10% even if the service was really bad. This creates a bad incentive. Most service problems in restaurants are due to waitstaff being over-stretched and not having time to stop by tables often enough, etc. If a waitperson realizes that adding another worker would reduce tables/tips by 30% (for example) he/she would have to make up for that via a higher tipping percentage for it to be worthwhile. Meanwhile, customers are tipping mostly out of obligation and the restaurant owner may not realize the extent of bad service that is going on, even though it slows through-put and gives customers an inferior value. Why we'd want to carry this sort of system over to a modern service like Instacart is beyond me. I have written to Instacart support/management suggesting that they create a financial incentive for shoppers to be available at peak times, even if that results in something more like surge pricing. On Superbowl Sunday all deliveries were taken by around noon, and I could really have used some more tortilla chips, beer, etc. Shoppers willing to work during those times should make enough money that they are willing to miss the game themselves, etc. I think that if Uber were competing in this space, there would be no tips and also no service fee (still not sure what it is, but it seems to be Instacart's way of charging a baseline tip for all orders). I think the most important thing during the growth phase for Instacart is to gain market share and to deliver a service level that creates a disincentive for stores like Whole Foods to start their own delivery service (or an incentive to white-label Instacart's). I think Instacart should be raising enough money that it can really think long term about its strategy. It's doing so many things right. The shopping experience and app experience are superb, the shoppers are conscientious and friendly. Uber was able to grow rapidly by subsidizing rides significantly. It seems Instacart wishes to avoid this. I very much like the free delivery subscription level, but the service fee is annoying, as are the price mark-ups at some stores. Getting this right is likely very difficult for companies that generally follow in Uber's wake but who have more challenging labor relations. I was quite disappointed to get a tip solicitation flyer like the one shown in the article. As an Instacart customer who just paid a service fee and an annual fee, I don't want an ugly reminder of Instacart's labor relations problems arriving along with my groceries.
- artursapek 10y agoThis sounds extremely scummy, and if the story really is as simple as this article tells it I don't understand how the CEO of this company can look at himself in the mirror. I think a great example of an app that lets me give positive feedback to service people is Uber. They let you get a ride ASAP with as little decision making as possible, and then you can rate it after you get where you're going and you have some down time. If they let me, I would probably leave a tip along with my good ratings. Everything else is invisible: I have no idea if there's a "service fee" included in the ride fare. They don't make me worry about it. They definitely don't make drivers have to hand out paper flyers in order to feed their family.
- et-al 10y ago> They definitely don't make drivers have to hand out paper flyers in order to feed their family. I don't know how Instacart works, but could it be that Lyft/Uber drivers have ratings they need to maintain, whereas Instacart delivery people don't? (Someone feel free to shine some light/correct me here.)
- ontoillogical 10y agoOne of the reasons I prefer to use Lyft is that they let you tip drivers.
- alehul 10y agoIs Instacart paying significantly lower via this new system (aside from the UX advantage like Uber)? Assuming they have a reasonable proportion of couriers:orders and the pay change here is substantial, this seems like it could backfire if many couriers stop delivering / delivering as often, given how easy it is to switch to GrubHub, DoorDash, Postmates, et cetera. Instacart apparently has a surge-like system called "busy pricing." It'll be interesting to see whether that'll now occur more or whether they can actually retain their couriers (assuming they don't have an excess).
- jnagro 10y agoit is still not clear to how the people actually doing the work get paid and how much of the order they make?
- MaxGabriel 10y agoI think Instacart's other justification for this is that multiple people are now involved in procuring your groceries. One person shops and another delivers. If you tip in cash, the shopper gets nothing. Can't speak to if this is their real motive, but does seem to be in line with other criticisms of tipping (e.g. waitresses making much more than kitchen staff).
- marcell 10y agoThis is a misdirection and Instacart knows it. In the old system, the shopper got half the tip. Source: I worked as an Instacart driver for fun.
- MaxGabriel 10y agoAh, sad to hear that
- l8again 10y agoBefore Instacart was on the scene, my brother and I thought of about a similar service. My brother in his college days used to be a pizza delivery driver, so he had the "real world" experience. Over the weekend, I quickly created a simple dropwizard java jar that would take in two variables - number of drivers, and number of orders. Everything else was randomized to be close to reality - such as delivery times, routes, etc. To be clear this was a bare bone, CLI application. I would run the service for 5 minutes, and collect the metrics. One thing was clear as mud, the more we scale up, the higher the loss. The thing was that my brother kept telling me that I am paying too less to my drivers, and that no one would work for me at that rate. Also, I will admit that my algorithm was a "simple Fed-ex" style hub-spoke model.
- tomcam 10y agoVery cool story. Love that you tried it, love that you're honest about it now.
- kovek 10y agoInteresting! You estimated the costs using a small program. Have you ever done this with other ideas? Is there some resources which teaches the best ways to do such estimates? I've done this before with an excel sheet for a specific business my friend was enthusiastic about. It turned out he would have been alright had he gotten a loan.
- marcosdumay 10y agoThere is a concept called "Monte Carlo Simulation" that can help on that. Pushing random numbers into a program can be as rigorous as you want. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monte_Carlo_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monte_Carlo_method
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dkarapetyan 10y agoWhy does startup after startup think they can make delivery a viable business? The numbers never work out.
- pcurve 10y agoI hear you. My favorite delivery + service start up is this. https://www.enjoy.com/ https://www.enjoy.com/ You should see which VC are backing this ridiculous idea. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Johnson_(businessman)#Enjoy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Johnson_(businessman)#Enjo... I have no idea how they would every make any money. With every order, they bleed cash.
- purple-again 10y agoHmmm...I'm confused. This is from their "How It Works" section on their website: "Yup, that’s right. The only thing you pay for is your new device. How is it possible? Well, we spend our money on training awesome Experts instead of on building stores. So, you get an amazing experience instead of just a device." That doesn't explain how it works at all. I'm guessing they have partnerships with the supplier so the customer pays the same price as retail and Enjoy gets a piece of the revenue. My understanding though is that these new hardware items usually have very thin margins. I would love to hear how they actually make money.
- mattm 10y agoAFAICT, you buy from their site so they are probably getting some kind of commission. But they only have 20 products in total that you can buy from their site. Plus they have someone spend up to an hour training you on the product. Their Experts page says all of them are full-time and not contractors and it looks like they have about 50 people listed there - https://www.enjoy.com/pages/meet-the-experts https://www.enjoy.com/pages/meet-the-experts I went through the first part of their checkout process and they suggest accessories to purchase with the item so maybe it's an upsell thing? Maybe the in-person "expert" is really just an incentivized sales person that you've invited into your home that will try to push other accessories that you "need" for the product you've purchased. I imagine the kind of people that would need this service would be people that are not technically adept and could probably be easily manipulated into purchasing things that they don't really need.
- neom 10y agoI can understand wanting predictability in your business model, but if your supply chain shakes when you add consistency, your business model probably doesn't work.
- nathanaldensr 10y agoWhen are we as a society going to tire of company executives feigning stupidity and ignorance when it comes to these very deliberate actions? All these executives--and likely all the developers, too--know exactly why these business model and app changes were made. The reasons given in the article are completely accurate. It can be boiled down to this: Money > People.
- aangjie 10y agoIt's called Hanlon's Dodge, built on the Hanlon's razor principle. it'll keep happening as long as there's a popular belief in Hanlon's razor.
- vinceguidry 10y agoI have been reading a lot about Russia and China recently, and I'm struck by just how much more realistic their citizenry is compared to America. I think it ultimately boils down to how real power operates in the countries. The average Russian or Chinese citizen is way less powerful than the average American citizen. If they have a grievance to make, whether it's against a local or national policy, Russians and Chinese have way way fewer options. Whereas Americans, if they feel aggrieved at the state of their world, can turn to any one of many many many political organizations that exist solely to collect and distribute that outrage and drive results. We may not be completely 100% satisfied with those results, but it's better than relying on the legal process. This network of civic participation has mostly replaced the usual role of electoral politics and Americans believe in their system, secure in the realization that if some bullshit is going down, outrage will be generated and justice will be served. The last election threw that whole system into critical disarray. It got yoked into the service of Donald Trump and the Republicans because liberal Americans trusted the system enough to stop looking to see how it was being used. Trump realized he could game the system to get elected and did exactly that. The critical insight here is that Americans are not stupid, and they are not ignorant, they just believe in the power of systems and institutions and want to just be able to rely on them to drive better results over time. We shift public attention gradually away from everything, and slowly onto the parts of the system that aren't working. In Russia and China, public arms of policy-making are non-existent. Citizens must therefore be extremely careful about picking their battles.
- c3534l 10y agoHow is this legal? They've been lying to customers in print about a service charge being a tip (as well as lying about the cost of the service to begin with by adding the charge to begin with) and basically stealing these people's tips.
- narsil 10y agoAs a sidenote, returning something bought via Instacart is a pain, as I learned. Target refused to accept a defective light-bulb without the original receipt, but did exchange it for store credit fortunately.
- muzz 10y agoYou were able to buy a light bulb on Instacart? I'm in Silicon Valley and it's just groceries here
- nashadelic 10y agoNot a US citizen but I find the whole tipping experience rather stressful and an additional item to worry about. I like it that Uber has it built into the service and there's only one thing to pay. I'd rather pay a flat increase on the menu and expect higher staff salaries than to have the delivery boy/waiter be at my mercy of tipping.
- hn_throwaway_99 10y agoNote there have been several articles about how some Uber drivers give lower ratings to riders who don't tip in cash.
- mrits 10y agoHow could anyone ever know this? Uber doesn't even have this data, since the tip is in cash.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoI've seen Uber drivers discuss this on forums. For some drivers, 'no tip' = 'no 5 star rating for the passenger'
- pshposh 10y agoWhat are the implications for a passenger with a poor star rating?
- mrits 10y agoI've never tipped in hundreds of Uber rides and I have like a 4.9 last I checked. Because I'm not a special snowflake I would think that most people have a good rating. But if you don't and there are options of who you can pick up, you gotta think that someone with a 4.5 would be picked up over a 3.5.
- 10y ago
- soheil 10y agoI don't understand the outrage, I like Amazon Fresh even more, next to the tipping box it specifically says in big letters tipping is neither required nor expected and defaults to zero. If the current laws regarding minimum wage are inadequate why not try to pass new laws instead of trying to read between the lines on why Instacart moved an input box and put it somewhere else? Why keep things murky? If it is against the law we have a justice system, I will not all of a sudden be reminded of greedy bankers on Wall Street being the reason that box was moved to a different screen. Do people benefit when things are less crystal clear? Why do we want them to stay that? Why should the tradition of tipping should still be alive in this country? What are we trying to prove? Who is benefiting? Do we enjoy this sadistic power imbalance every time we get a meal at a restaurant? Is it because it gives us control over livelihood of someone else? How is it any different that the Romans throwing Christians to the lions for their enjoyment? Let's create a society that we think is fair and just instead of trying to take things in our own hands. Engaging in social debate to win over your fellow citizens to see eye to eye with you on things like increasing the minimum wage would be a benefit not only to those at the bottom but also to the society as a whole if that's what you think is the right thing to do.
- developer2 10y agoSo Amazon Fresh has an optional tip. Instacart is adding a default 10% fee that goes into their pockets - it is not a tip. And they do not pass the 10% fee on to the employees in wages - it stays as part of their bottom line. Higher-ups realized just how much the tips are worth, are now stealing them by default behind a purposely confusing interface that their customers cannot understand, and pocketing the difference while affecting their employees' income. This is 100% nefarious. There is no reason to have both an optional service fee and a separate optional tip. It's one or the other; combining both options makes absolutely no sense.
- soheil 10y agoI understand it's not the most conventional way of doing it, but why it's someone "higher up" and that's a bad thing? Instacart is not Mother Teresa, its sole purpose is to make profit and I want it to do that as much as it possibly can. I want this service to exist so I don't have to feel like a chimp in a grocery store with a basket going from aisle to aisle in fact why do I even need to justify why I want it to exist? I am willing to give them my money for the services they provide, period. Again if someone thinks what they're doing is illegal or should be illegal one day then either take them to court or change the laws!
- rm999 10y agoWait a minute... wait. Those service fees I've been opting to pay haven't been going to the shoppers/drivers who are processing my order? On my last order I asked the shopper to specifically go out of her way to check on an out of stock item. I did this with the assumption that my 7 dollar service fee was going directly to her, and that she would therefore be happy to go out of her way. When the delivery person (I think the same as the shopper) came by and I smiled at her, I thought that was a "we're square", not a "sorry for not tipping you" smile. I'm livid. It's on instacart to pay fair wages with the delivery fees if they think it's a problem. Their misleading double fee system is unfair to both me and (more importantly) the people who are directly providing me with service. I'm sick of the uber-ish "on-demand" service culture abusing their non-employees under my dime. edit: funny thing is, I just watched the infamous episode of Kitchen Nightmares about Amy's Baking Company. In the episode, Gordon Ramsay becomes furious when he finds out that the customers' tips aren't going to the servers. He goes into the restaurant and asks the patrons if they would have tipped if they knew this and everyone agrees no. The owner meekly explains in a follow-up episode that he does this so he can pay the waiters a "fair fee". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amy's_Baking_Company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amy's_Baking_Company. This episode utterly destroyed Amy and her husband's company. Instacart, I love your service. It's changed the way I grocery shop and I planned on being a regular, high-value customer. Please don't make me question my decision on this.
- openmosix 10y agoI've learned this once talking to one of the shoppers. I never tipped again after that / I tip in cash for the good ones once they deliver at my door.
- gkop 10y agoThe shoppers do not deliver to your door FYI.
- Gargoyle 10y agoIt's varied over time. Sometimes I've talked to them on the phone as they shopped and it was indeed the same person that delivered to my door. Then for a while it wasn't, then it was again. From conversations with the shoppers, it also varies by store chain. Different chains have different deals with Instacart as to how the shoppers can perform their jobs, including if it's the same person delivering. My impression is that when they get what they want, Instacart has shoppers that stay in the store shopping and drivers that deliver.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- free2rhyme214 10y agoDoordash added a "service fee" awhile ago. How is this news?
- sebleon 10y agoPooling tips is quite common place in the restaurant industry, this isn't exactly a new way to f* over workers. While this move will reduce the pay for some shoppers, it will help many shoppers that earn less in tips for structural reasons. Ie. servicing low-income neighborhoods, racism & sexism from the tipper, etc
- etjossem 10y agoI agree with you, but while the tip pool is sacred (employers shouldn't touch it), a "service fee" is not. Describing it as a service fee allows Instacart to keep a portion of it rather than distributing it all back to employees on the ground.
- sebleon 10y agoAh right on - didn't realize Instacart would be taking a portion of it... and it looks like it would be taxed, effectively making every dollar into a $0.70 tip...
- robertcope 10y agoI'm unclear why I would tip my Instacart delivery person. I order A, B, and C; my expectation is that A, B, and C show up, because that is what I paid for. How can a particular delivery person do that "better" enough to deserve a tip?
- valkea 10y agoPick out better produce?
- joncalhoun 10y agoIt is hard to evaluate if the delivery person did the best they could with what the store had or just grabbed random produce. So now we are ripping drivers because the grocery store for a fresh produce delivery? I'm not saying the lack of tips doesn't hurt drivers, but I agree that I have no idea how I could determine when a tip is justified.
- gkop 10y agoFirst, note that for each of your Instacart orders, a shopper picks out the food, and a driver delivers it to you. Two people. To your point, I have noticed that Instacart users fall into two groups, those that care about specific replacements when an item is out of stock, and those that just want the shopper to use their best judgment. If you care about replacements, then you want your shopper to be responsive and well-mannered in working with you to resolve the shortfall.
- myrloc 10y agoAs a previous shopper who was intensely driven by high tips, I can guarantee this will have a big effect on the levels of motivation the shoppers will have. However, it's important to note that the tips while I worked varied immensely - and tended to be MUCH higher when completing order at Whole Foods, as opposed to HEB.
- misingnoglic 10y agoAre the tips determined after the user receives the order?
- jasonpeacock 10y agoI'm an avid Instacart user, and I refuse to pay the service fee, nor the tip. Companies need to pay the drivers fair wages, and charge the customers enough to do so. Don't push that responsibility to the customer. Also, the service fee is perfect example of a Dark Pattern[1]. The actual service fee option (which is pre-selected at 10%) is hidden below the fold in the iPad app (and iOS?) checkout widgets. You have to scroll to see it, but it's aligned just perfectly, and with a hidden scrollbar, to hide the additional options. If you're not looking closely at the final cart total you'll never notice the extra 10% charge. [1] https://darkpatterns.org/ https://darkpatterns.org/
- saretired 10y agoOf course you have the right not to tip, it's optional after all, but many people do choose to give tips, and then the question is whether part of the tip is being skimmed off by Instacart. Restaurants have paid large fines under the Fair Labor Standards Act for tip skimming; I have no idea if FLSA applies here, but if a consumer chooses to tip, s/he has a reasonable expectation that the money will be going to the person providing the service and not to the person's employer.
- grandalf 10y agoI'm glad I'm not the only one who doesn't tip and tries to avoid the service fee. The problem is that often most of the desirable delivery times disappear unless you've opted to pay the fee. I agree these are dark patterns. Better to just keep the transaction obvious and clean and leave out tip shaming of any kind.
- woogiewonka 10y agoTotally agree.
- timcederman 10y agoYeah, I'd prefer to not pay the service fee, or the tip, but realistically by not doing so you're screwing the delivery folks, who get deliberately underpaid by companies like Instacart. If there was an organized effort, and it was actually sending a message, then great, let's all do it! But really all you're doing is stiffing some poor underpaid delivery person.
- malz 10y agohttps://www.instacart.com/help/section/200761924#213895126 https://www.instacart.com/help/section/200761924#213895126 Why does Instacart use a service amount? Instacart is different than other delivery services because multiple shoppers may be involved in a single order. Some shoppers work in stores, for example, while others are involved in driving to deliver an order. The service amount is used to pay this entire set of shoppers. Furthermore, it helps to ensure that all shoppers are compensated fairly and competitively, and that shoppers are working collectively toward the common goal of providing an excellent experience for all customers throughout the entire order process. Should I still tip the shopper delivering my order? Additional tipping is optional. The entire amount you select goes directly to the shopper delivering your order. Why is there as service amount and a tip? The service amount is distinct from a tip. Instacart uses the service amount to provide higher guaranteed commissions to all shoppers on the platform. This will help us ensure that shoppers no longer rely on unpredictable tips for the majority of their compensation. Leaving a service amount is optional, and you may set the service amount to $0 in the checkout flow before you place your order. If you wish to include an additional tip for exceptional service performed specifically by the shopper who delivered your order, you may do so on our online platform, or in cash.
- ben174 10y agoThe way I read this is "the service fee is a way to give us more money, so we have more money to pay to everyone who works for us". So then why not just raise your prices and pay your employees more? If the service fee was split across everyone who participated in your individual transaction, I could understand. Otherwise this is just a way of them saying "a service fee is a way to tip the company, so we can maybe pay our employees more".
- timcederman 10y agoBecause their basic fee is just the delivery fee. They don't set the prices - the supermarkets do. The service fee is a consistent way for them to generate enough revenue to pay their shoppers and drivers, compared to the variability of user-provided tips before.
- tomcam 10y agoDespicable. That way of hiding the tip belongs in Wikipedia under Dark Patterns. I hope Instacart burns.
- popinman322 10y agoSo does this mean that if I have sensitive information and travel that I should just purchase computers in both inside and outside the US and never travel across the border with any electronics?
- xerophyte12932 10y agoThere is a very interesting Podcast on the tipping vs service fee debate on Freakonomics: http://freakonomics.com/podcast/danny-meyer/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/danny-meyer/ It shows how the "Hospitality Included" program removed tips from their restaurants. I guess its not always the idea, but also how you implement it. Instacart tried to do the same thing but appear to have totally botched it up
- Kiro 10y agoComing from a place where tipping is nonexistent this whole debate feels extremely ancient. I don't understand why a modern country won't just kill off tipping culture.
- nickez 10y agoThis is great for everyone! Hopefully they will get a higher salary and I guess the company will pay more in taxes and social benefits (or whatever it is called in English). I don't get how tipping can be legal, or do you actually pay taxes on tips in the US?
- TheCoelacanth 10y ago> do you actually pay taxes on tips in the US Yes, they are taxed the same as wages. For tips done via credit/debit card, that will even be reported and have taxes withheld by the employer. For cash tips, the recipient is supposed to report them on their own, though of course, it's fairly common not to report the full amount because it's hard for the government to track.
- khallil 10y agoSeems like they're learning a hard lesson on unit economics. We're somehow at a point where companies are burning cash to provide low service fees, and now they need to become profitable. When there's nothing left to optimize, the way to become profitable is to either pay drivers less or charge customers more, and customers are not down to pay more.
- xiaoma 10y agoIt's possible that pretty much any so-called "gig-economy" platform is inexorably pressed towards first wooing, then commoditizing and finally squeezing its workers.
- bkovacev 10y agoThis feels like communism. It does not matter how hard you work, you will all get paid the same. Why should someone that worked better be rewarded the same as someone who did not work so hard? Leave the things as they were initially. Let customer decide the performance part of the pay, you just take care of the base portion. Unless, all they really want is the 10% for themselves.
- mattbillenstein 10y agoI recently stopped using Instacart, there wasn't a single reason, but the sum of: 1. I'm paying 15-20% more for groceries just on line-item price. The prices Instacart shows vs what you see in store are sometimes a bit less, but more often not, 20% or more more. 2. Inconsistency between what's in Instacart's catalog and what's in the store. Making special requests isn't easy and they usually just go unfulfilled as it's up to the discretion of the shopper if they want to spend the extra time to find something special. 3. Safeway.com's online store got a little bit better -- and next day delivery is usually okay with me. 4. This service fee issue to top it off -- I just don't feel like paying 20% more for stuff, 10% for delivery, 10% for a service fee, then I'm compelled to add a tip? Poor UX IMHO if the solution is to manually change the service fee to 0% and tip 10%. 5. I had an incident last year that was sorta hilarious -- I had a shopper tell me Safeway was out of ice cream. Like, completely out of ice cream -- I went to their online store at the location the shopper was supposed to be and they list 400 different ice cream products. There is no way they were out of ice cream unless they had lost power for a day or something. It was just completely nonsensical and made me think they were maybe trying to fulfill my order out of their own warehouse because they had 90% of the stuff there -- and 90% in crunch time is maybe okay? That was maybe the first nail in the coffin.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- freyr 10y ago> I'm paying 15-20% more for groceries just on line-item price. In San Francisco at least, almost every store is listed as "Prices are same as in-store." Target and Whole Foods have "Everyday store prices," which means Instacart doesn't match sale prices. Costco and Cash&Carry are the only stores where Instacart prices are not matched. I'd expect they'd get called out right away if they weren't honoring this. But if you agree to a service fee and tip, you'll still end up paying 10%-20% more.
- mattbillenstein 10y agoYeah, they say that, but I challenge you to do the experiment I did -- put some stuff in your cart you use every week on instacart and safeway.com and compare the total.
- verytrivial 10y agoThis is not a fault of Instacart IMHO, but a symptom of the US's strange relationship with minimum wage laws.
- mack1001 10y agoPretty sure the day stores create their own delivery channel, instacart will be done. Easier to pay Krogers or Costco for quick delivery than a service like instacart.
- brownbat 10y agoInstacart wants to fix grocery shopping by eliminating the drive the store. Amazon wants to fix grocery shopping by eliminating checkout.[0] The friction with grocery shopping for me is in a completely different area, and also easily solvable. If I could go to a store that was basically a Kiva[1] fueled warehouse, enter an order on a tablet, and have it brought to my car (or order in the morning and do curbside pickup on my drive home from work), I would save the hassle of searching store shelves while playing demolition derby with a bunch of other carts. Walmart has toyed with free curbside pickup.[2] It should actually make groceries cheaper though. If they had a warehouse logistics backend, without customers wandering around through their inventory, they could do amazing things. With apologies to Clarence Saunders, yeah, basically I want to end self-service.[3] Customers were more efficient than the clerk for that job, so that model won. But robots are much more efficient than customers now, so I'm ready for the next revolution. [0] http://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-go-grocery-store-future-photos-video-2016-12 http://www.businessinsider.com/amazon-go-grocery-store-futur... [1] https://www.cnet.com/news/meet-amazons-busiest-employee-the-kiva-robot/ https://www.cnet.com/news/meet-amazons-busiest-employee-the-... [2] http://www.businessinsider.com/walmart-is-expanding-free-curbside-grocery-pick-up-2016-4 http://www.businessinsider.com/walmart-is-expanding-free-cur... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarence_Saunders_(grocer) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clarence_Saunders_(grocer)
- ghaff 10y agoIt doesn't use robots but Hannaford has a curbside pickup option. Anecdotally doesn't seem to be used much though and for me seems to satisfy a pretty narrow use case--people who can easily drive to the store but can't or don't want to wheel a shopping cart around.
- tharibo 10y agoAll big stores are doing it now in France (in large cities at least). It's called "<store>-drive" (like you would have a "Walmart-drive" in the USA). Some are doing it next to the shop, others try new warehouses at different locations (because one of the incentives is to avoid traffic too). It's far from perfect; but at least you don't have to walk the store for hours. Also, no tip culture in France, but workers seem to run against the clock, so I suppose they have incentives to deliver fast.
- krzrak 10y agoThe real WTF is tipping in advance for the service when you make an order.
- bluetidepro 10y agoYeah, this is one thing I will never understand when apps do this. Especially ones that FORCE a min % of tip when you make the order (most GrubHub/Seamless restaurants). Just call it a fee if you're going to force me to do it before I can even evaluate the service and tip accordingly, let alone if there is a min tip %. It's incredibly frustrating, and ironically makes me tip less than if I would if I could just tip after the fact. I don't want to risk an up-front tip, so I tend to stay on the lower end, but since the service of these places is usually pretty good, if I got to tip after, I would actually be tipping more. But they screw up just enough times that makes me not want to take that gamble. With Instacart specifically, this creates a confusing dilemma by giving me the option to tip before any service is done. Mainly because Instacart DOES allow me to modify the tip after the order is complete, which is good, but here is the dilemma... A) Do I not tip when placing the order (with intention of tipping when the order is complete and I can evaluate the service to give a fair tip), but also risk that the shopper knows I didn't tip when I placed the order thus thinks I won't tip at all making them not care as much and do a poor job because they think I'm cheap. B) Do I tip ahead of time when placing the order and risk that they think just because they already got the tip there isn't much I can do, so they could care less either way, and then I'm stuck paying a tip for service that wasn't up to par. Either way it's a lose-lose and a terrible experience. And I'm PRETTY sure the shopper doesn't seem the tip when they get the order so maybe that makes both A & B irrelevant, but it's not like the UX of the app tells me that so I'm stuck in this awkward dilemma during checkout making me hesitate my conversion. It's a terrible and very confusing flow/checkout/experience every time I use Instacart.
- inimino 10y agoThe author totally lost me at this point: "To get to the tip option, customers would have to click on a small arrow to the right of the service fee that doesn’t give any indication where it leads. Even if someone knew to click on that arrow (but honestly, why would they?)" Seriously?? Has this guy never seen a mobile app before? There is a line reading "Service (10%)" with an actual dollar figure and an arrow pointing to the right. Find me a mobile user who doesn't know what that arrow means. This whole article reads the same way, like the author is just trying to stir up outrage and get page views. Disclaimer: I have never used Instacart and have no connection with it. Not familiar with Recode either but I am less likely to read anything from them again.
- JoeAltmaier 10y ago'Service (10%)' doesn't scream 'Tip' to me. Why on earth not just say 'Tip'?
- criddell 10y agoBecause you would then assume that the tip is going to the person that served you. In this case, the service charge is essentially a tip to the Instacart company.
- wheaties 10y agoOnce upon a time I made a UI where there were several things. One of them was a gigantic text box with the title "Biography" and another a 2 character wide box with a title "years of experience." We had to change that to a drop down. Why? Read on... We got a lot of complaints. People couldn't see their resume in the "years of experience" box. Worse they kept getting error messages saying their resume was too long. It was restricted to 2 characters! These same people had glossed over the "biography" box. So, yes, your ability to reason about a UI and the requisite UX has nothing to do with how others will reason about it. You'll get to learn the hard way like I did.
- inimino 10y agoYes, thanks, but I am already quite familiar with the idea that users will break and misunderstand any UI in creative and unexpected ways. That's why we do testing of any new UI designs. That's totally unrelated to my point. My point is that the author writes as if something that is perfectly familiar to any mobile app user--and is literally the standard way to present a default option that can be changed--is something that has never been seen before. As I said, find me a mobile user who doesn't know what that arrow means in the screenshot in his article. He gave up all credibility with me at that point in the article. It may be that there's a story here, but either way this is just terrible journalism.
- tjpaudio 10y agoUgh tipping culture. Pay should be predictable and not guilted on the customer. If the predictable pay is too low people can try to find better work, but at least tension is removed from the time of transaction.
- TheOneTrueKyle 10y agoWhy the fuck do you keep talking about cultural norms? "Cultural norms" aren't homogeneous. This cultural norm bullshit you keep spouting is just a way to isolate people from your ideal world that exists in your head. Did you know that some people have different religions? Did you know that some people like macs more than PCs? My fucking intentions are to get some food. Why are you putting so much value into what is essentially a person who takes food (from a cook, you know, the person responsible for making your food and the actual star of the establishment) and transports it less than a 100 ft radius?
- harryh 10y agoCultural norms about tipping waiters in restaurants actually are homogeneous within the United States. In the very few cases where there are exceptions restaurants make sure to indicate this on menus.
- TheOneTrueKyle 10y agoYou live in a completely different world than I do yet insist on generalizing everything. You are quite fascinating. Let me ask you this then. Have you ever tipped the person who cooked your food?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- harryh 10y agoYou live in a part of the US where waiters don't typically receive tips from the vast majority of patrons?
- TheOneTrueKyle 10y agoOf course people do. It's more your reaction to it. Like you are financially invested in people who don't make food but people who bring food a couple feet to the left. So have you ever tipped a chef?